Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2018;94(2):192---199
www.jped.com.br
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
a
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Núcleo de Estudos em Saúde da Criança e do Adolescente (NESCA), Porto
Alegre, RS, Brazil
b
Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre (HCPA), Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
c
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Faculdade de Medicina, Pós-Graduação em Saúde da Criança e do
Adolescente, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
d
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Faculdade de Medicina, Departamento de Nutrição, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
e
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Faculdade de Medicina, Departamento de Pediatria, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
KEYWORDS Abstract
Validation studies; Objectives: To transculturally adapt and validate the Karitane Parenting Confidence Scale to
Confidence; the Brazilian Portuguese language and culture and verify the combination of the results with
Postpartum period; the maternal sociodemographic characteristics.
Mother---child Methodology: This is a validation and transcultural adaptation nestled in a longitudinal and
relations observational study in Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil, assessing mother-infant pairs from differ-
ent gestational and perinatal environments. The original authors authorized the translation
into Brazilian Portuguese, unified version creation, back-translation, analysis by specialists,
final version implementation, and acceptance. Cronbach’s alpha analysis was performed. The
Kruskal---Wallis test with post-hoc Dunn’s test was used to compare the study groups. Socioeco-
nomic and demographic characteristics, obtained through a questionnaire in the first 24-48 h of
the newborns’ life, were associated with maternal results by the Brazilian version of the scale,
using Spearman’s correlation and Mann---Whitney’s test.
Results: The sample consisted of 251 postpartum women, with the confidence maternal ques-
tionnaire being applied at 15 days postpartum. The median score of the mothers’ confidence
was 40.00 (37.00---43.00). The protocol obtained a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.717. There were sig-
nificant weak positive correlations between maternal confidence and age (p = 0.013, r = 0.157)
夽 Please cite this article as: Pereira LW, Bernardi JR, Matos S, Silva CH, Goldani MZ, Bosa VL. Cross-cultural adaptation and validation of
the Karitane Parenting Confidence Scale of maternal confidence assessment for use in Brazil. J Pediatr (Rio J). 2018;94:192---199.
∗ Corresponding author.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jped.2017.05.011
0021-7557/© 2017 Sociedade Brasileira de Pediatria. Published by Elsevier Editora Ltda. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND
license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Transcultural adaptation and validation of the KPCS 193
and between maternal confidence and schooling (p = 0.048, r = 0.125). Additionally, a significant
association was observed between maternal confidence and parity (p = 0.030).
Conclusion: The transcultural adaptation and validation of the confidence maternal question-
naire into Brazilian Portuguese language and culture showed good reliability for this sample.
The results of its use demonstrated that maternal confidence was associated with schooling,
age and parity.
© 2017 Sociedade Brasileira de Pediatria. Published by Elsevier Editora Ltda. This is an open
access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/
4.0/).
Introduction Brazil, there are still scarce tools available for this purpose.
The Breastfeeding Self-Efficacy Scale (BSES), a scale that
Maternal confidence is a very important characteristic for measures the woman’s confidence in her breastfeeding
adequate growth and development of infants. Its absence in potential,4 and the Postpartum Bonding Questionnaire
the beginning of the postnatal period can negatively influ- (PBQ), which aims to assess disturbances in the relationship
ence the mother’s ability to care for her child. Parental between parents and their children,5 comprise the national
confidence contributes to the child-mother relationship, to scenario of scales aimed at evaluating the relationship
the mother’s commitment and energy demanded in teach- between parents and their infants.
ing, playing with, and relating to her child, as well as in Thus, content validation allows the researcher to verify
many other aspects of child development.1 whether the scale and the questions that constitute it are
The feelings of maternal confidence and self-efficacy adequate predictors of the subject it is intended to assess.6
are determined by a number of different factors, includ- Moreover, when questionnaires validated in different lan-
ing contextual characteristics such as social support, infant guages are used, they allow reliable data collection and
behavior styles, and maternal mental alterations.2 Addi- facilitate the comparison and discussion of the results of
tionally, higher levels of maternal confidence have been several studies, including international ones.7
indicated as a protection factor against maternal depres- Considering this context, the use of a tool that can
sion, relationship difficulties, parental competence, stress, assess maternal confidence can be useful, contributing to
and child development impairment.3 the child’s healthy development. In this sense, the Karitane
Given this context, effective measures are required Parenting Confidence Scale (KPCS),8,9 designed to measure
to estimate the feeling of maternal confidence and, in parental self-efficacy in parents of children between 0 and
194 Pereira LW et al.
12 months of age, was shown to be a tool capable of per- After the translations were performed, the next stage
forming this evaluation. It is a protocol still little known was the creation of a unified version, in which profession-
and used in the Brazilian context, feasible for the addressed als from the protocol application area discussed the most
topic, and has proven use in its country of origin. appropriate questions and answers adapted to Brazilian Por-
Moreover, its use is recommended in the first year of the tuguese, the best context of sentences, as well as their
child’s life, when most of the doubts and difficulties arise for understanding in relation to the different levels of schooling
the parents, thus helping them to understand that moment. of the target audience. Thus, it was possible to include all of
Therefore, the aim of the present study was to transcultur- the questions to obtain a unified version that was adequate
ally adapt and validate this tool for the Brazilian Portuguese for the purposes of the questionnaire.
language and culture in puerperal women with different ges- The back-translation, which was the process of trans-
tational and perinatal conditions, allowing the evaluation of lating the unified version in Brazilian Portuguese back into
its applicability in different contexts, as well as verifying the English, was performed by a professional with a university
association of its results with maternal sociodemographic degree in languages, with an English idiom specialization,
characteristics. fluent in the Brazilian Portuguese idiom, with no knowledge
of the protocol purpose.
Methods For the final interpretation of the assembled ques-
tionnaire, after the Brazilian Portuguese versions and
back-translation into English, the next step was the anal-
This study consists in the validation and cross-cultural adap-
ysis by experts and original authors of the questionnaire.
tation of a protocol that was applied during a longitudinal
This step was carried out through a consensus consisting of
observational study entitled ‘‘Impact of Perinatal Different
different opinions of five experts in the area of the proto-
Intrauterine Environments on Child Growth and Develop-
col application, in which they discussed the understanding
ment in the First Six Months of Life’’ (IVAPSA), a thematic
of the questionnaire and its adequacy for the intended pur-
cohort of births whose main objective was to investigate the
pose. In parallel to this discussion, the unified version was
interactions between the maternal genotype during gesta-
sent by e-mail to the author of the original protocol (Dr.
tion (with the inclusion of women from different groups of
Rudi Črnčec), for evaluation of the translated version into
intrauterine and perinatal environments), the maternal and
Brazilian Portuguese, commentary on the final product, and
fetal genotype, and their influence on growth, behavior and
to obtain authorization for its use.
neurodevelopment in the newborn’s first six months of life.
Once the protocol was translated, unified, back-
The study protocol has been previously published.10 The
translated, discussed, and approved by all those involved
aim of this study was to validate the scale, evaluating its
in this process, the Brazilian version of the KPCS was finally
applicability in puerperal women with different gestational
applied by the researchers participating in the IVAPSA study
and perinatal in order to confirm its applicability in several
with the target audience to test its applicability.
contexts.
This aforementioned study selected a convenience sam-
Sample selection was carried out in three public hospitals
ple, in which puerperal women living in the city of Porto
of Porto Alegre: Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre (HCPA),
Alegre were included between 24 and 48 h after delivery.
Hospital Fêmina and Hospital Nossa Senhora da Conceição,
HIV/AIDS-positive women and mothers of newborns from
the last two belonging to the Grupo Hospitalar Conceição
twin pregnancies, premature infants with congenital dis-
(GHC). The project was approved by the Research Ethics
eases or those requiring hospital admission were excluded.
Committees of HCPA and GHC, in protocols 11-0097 and 11-
The mothers selected for the study were classified into
027, respectively.
five different groups, according to the conditions shown dur-
The KPCS protocol consists of 15 multiple-choice ques-
ing pregnancy: 1) diabetes mellitus (DM), 2) systemic arterial
tions with four possible answers that are scored as 0, 1, 2,
hypertension (SAH), 3) smokers, 4) idiopathic intrauterine
or 3; its total score range from 0 to 45, which is used to
growth restriction with small for gestational age infants
classify mothers as being confident or not about caring for
(IUGR/SGA), and 5) the control group. Participants prefer-
their children. Mothers with a total score ≥40 are classified
ably had only the clinical-obstetric conditions that were
as confident.8
characteristic of each of the different groups.
The validation process of the KPCS questionnaire, previ-
If there was overlap regarding more than one study group,
ously validated in its native language, started by contacting
preference was given to the primary gestational condition.
its original authors and obtaining their authorization. Subse-
This heterogeneity of the sample allowed an evaluation of
quently, transcultural translation and adaptation were per-
the protocol in puerperal women that developed different
formed in five stages: 1) translation, 2) creation of a unified
clinical and metabolic conditions during pregnancy. Maternal
version, 3) back-translation, 4) analysis by experts and orig-
socioeconomic and demographic information (age, level of
inal authors of the questionnaire, and 5) final version use.
schooling, income, marital status, and self-reported ethnic-
The first stage, translation into Brazilian Portuguese,
ity), as well as pre- and perinatal data (pregnancy planning,
consisted of two translations of the original tool, indepen-
previous pregnancy, and type of delivery) were obtained
dently performed by a professional with experience in the
through a structured questionnaire during the postpartum
questionnaire application area, fluent in the English lan-
(PP) interview between 24 and 48 h after delivery, and by
guage, and by a professional with a university degree in
reviewing hospital medical records. The final version of the
languages, specialized in the English idiom. As a result of the
KPCS scale (Appendix 1) was applied to the puerperal women
first stage, two different versions of the KPCS questionnaire
on the 15th day after delivery.
were obtained.
Transcultural adaptation and validation of the KPCS 195
The protocol validation procedure was complete when comprised the questionnaire were used and, in the end, a
the analyses of internal consistency of the translated ver- value of 0.717 was obtained, which classified the protocol
sion adapted to the Brazilian culture were performed. For as comprehensible and qualified for subsequent use in the
that purpose, some of the originally used analysis proce- Brazilian population. Cronbach’s alpha values per question
dures, previously described in the KPCS manual in its original are described in Table 3.
Australian version were followed.8 Thus, Cronbach’s alpha
coefficient, which is considered one of the main ques-
tionnaire reliability estimators, was used to evaluate the Discussion
internal consistency of the KPCS protocol. The variance scale
of this analysis ranges from 0 to 1, and 0.7 is the minimum This study demonstrated that the KPCS protocol is an appli-
acceptable value for considering a questionnaire as being cable tool for the measurement of maternal confidence
qualified for use.11,12 It is noteworthy that question num- level and adequate for use in the Brazilian Portuguese
ber 12 (‘‘Being a mother is very stressful for me’’), as it language, within the Brazilian cultural context. Maternal
showed in its response structure a format that was opposite confidence levels showed a weakly significant correlation
to the others in the scale, required reversing the answers to between maternal age and schooling and association with
perform the Cronbach alpha analysis, by attributing a higher parity. Corroborating these findings, a study carried out in
score to those with a more positive nature, thus making them Australia with a group of women in the first postnatal year,
equivalent to the other questions. voluntarily followed-up by a multiprofessional team in a pri-
For data presentation, the continuous variables were vate unit, used the KPCS scale and observed that multiparous
shown as median and interquartile range (P25---P75) and mothers were more confident in relation to their children, as
categorical variables as absolute and relative numbers, well as older mothers. These associations may reflect bet-
according to the results of the Shapiro---Wilk normality ter established social support among older mothers when
test. Statistical analyses to compare data from the sam- compared to their younger peers.13
ple groups included Spearman correlation, Kruskal---Wallis From a perspective of health integrality, the most rel-
test with Dunn’s post-hoc and Mann---Whitney’s test. Statis- evant aspects of care to the puerperal woman are the
tical analyses were performed using the SPSS software (SPSS inseparability of care for the mother and child, maternal
Inc. Released 2009. Statistics for Windows, Version 18.0. breastfeeding, family planning, and maternal and infant
Chicago, USA). The level of significance was set at 0.05 for morbidity and mortality.14 Thus, when the parental confi-
all analyses. dence, measured by other characteristics such as the
practice of breastfeeding is taken into account, a study car-
ried out in Feira de Santana, Bahia, Brazil, showed that the
Results children of multiparous mothers had higher chances of being
exclusively breastfed and an even higher prevalence of this
The study population consisted of 251 postpartum women at type of breastfeeding was observed in comparison to the
the time of the protocol use, on the 15th day postpartum. children of primiparous mothers.15 In another birth cohort
Table 1 describes the socioeconomic and demographic in Pelotas, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, which evaluated mater-
data of the general study sample and the distribution of nal nutrition and breastfeeding duration, the prevalence
intrauterine and perinatal environment groups. The median of breastfeeding was significantly higher as maternal age
family income (in Brazilian Reais) was 1.5 minimum wages increased, in addition to the fact that primiparous women
(R$ 1322.00 [1000.00---2000.00]), which is equivalent to breastfed for less time.16 Moreover, in 2011, Hernandez
approximately US$ 377.00 per month, and that median et al., in an analysis of trends in infant mortality rates and
maternal schooling was ten years of study. their risk factors in Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil,
Postpartum women who had a total score of 40 or more observed that the increase in maternal schooling was the
were considered confident (55.8% [n = 140]), while those who major impact factor for the decrease in infant mortality
had a total score of 39 or lower were classified as non- rates between 1996 and 2008.17 These results reinforce that
confident (44, 2% [n = 111]), according to the scoring system it is important for the mother to receive support and guid-
of the original protocol (data not shown in table). ance during the first weeks of the child’s life, decreasing
Table 2 shows data on the sample maternal confidence. feelings of insecurity and anxiety, benefiting the practice
The final median of the score was 40.00 (37.00---43.00). of breastfeeding for a longer period of time18 and, conse-
It should be noted that there was no statistically signifi- quently, providing better care for children’s health.
cant difference between the scale scores and the analyzed The process of translation and cross-cultural adaptation
intrauterine and perinatal environments groups (p = 0.575). of the KPCS protocol made it possible to adapt a tool and
When correlating maternal confidence with socioeconomic make it suitable for use in the Brazilian culture. According to
and demographic data, a weak correlation was observed the International Test Commission,19 when adapting tools, it
between confidence and maternal schooling (p = 0.048, is crucial to consider, in the new culture, the coherence of
r = 0.125) as well as between confidence and maternal age concepts and properties attained by the original version, as
(p = 0.013, r = 0.157). Moreover, a significant association was well as the adequacy of each item of the initial protocol in
observed between confidence and parity (p = 0.030), show- terms of potential representation of these questions in the
ing that mothers who had previous children had greater new target audience, considering semantic, linguistics, and
confidence. contextual equivalence between the versions.
The analysis of the protocol’s internal consistency was The validation stage fully consolidated the process,
carried out using Cronbach’s alpha. All the questions that allowing the assessment of whether the tool is, in fact,
196 Pereira LW et al.
Table 1 Maternal socioeconomic, demographic, and perinatal characteristics, IVAPSA, Porto Alegre, Brazil.
IVAPSA, impact of perinatal different intrauterine environments on child growth and development in the first six months of life; DM,
diabetes mellitus; SAH, systemic arterial hypertension; TB, tobacco; IUGR/SGA, idiopathic intrauterine growth restriction with small for
gestational age infant; CTL, control; P, percentile.
a The total n was lower for these variables due to lack of information and answers (does not know/did not answer).
Table 2 Analyses between maternal confidence and socioeconomic and demographic data, IVAPSA, Porto Alegre, Brazil.
capable of achieving its goal according to its original tar- achieved results refer to differences or similarities between
get audience. Especially in cross-cultural studies, the use of the several samples or whether they originate from transla-
tools that have only been translated does not ensure reli- tion errors.20
able results. That is because the mere translation of the In the validation of tools in different cultural and lin-
tool does not guarantee criteria for measuring whether the guistic contexts, some authors affirm that cross-cultural
Transcultural adaptation and validation of the KPCS 197
Table 3 Cronbach’s alpha values per question of the Kar- is noteworthy that when comparing these groups of the
itane Parenting Confidence Scale tool (KPCS), IVAPSA, Porto present study, the diverse conditions occurring during ges-
Alegre, Brazil. tation did not imply statistically significant differences in
relation to maternal confidence. Thus, the fact that the
Question Cronbach’s alpha sample included participants with different gestational con-
1. I am confident about feeding my 0.714 ditions allowed the assessment of how the scale behaves
baby in different health contexts, which differentiates the vali-
2. I can settle my baby 0.688 dation of the tool into Brazilian Portuguese from the original
3. I am confident about helping my 0.709 and Nepalese validations, increasing its applicability.
baby to establish a good sleep In addition to the aforementioned differences regarding
routine the translation and validation processes in the different con-
4. I know what to do when my baby 0.689 texts, it is also worth mentioning that the participants in
cries the present study were recruited from three different pub-
5. I understand what my baby is 0.678 lic hospitals in the same municipality. In the other KPCS
trying to tell me studies, participants were selected from a single hospital in
6. I can soothe my baby when he/she 0.683 the outpatient clinic and/or post-natal unit of the Maternity
is distressed Hospital of the Kathmandu Women’s Hospital in Nepal22 and
7. am confident about playing with 0.684 the Karitane Medical Clinic in Villawood, New South Wales,
my baby Australia.8
8. If my baby has a common cold or 0.699 The results found in the present study were not simi-
slight fever, I am confident about lar to those in other studies regarding internal consistency
handling this values, which showed a discrepancy from the original and
9. I feel sure that my partner will be 0.731 Nepalese scales when compared with the present validation
there for me when I need support for Brazilian Portuguese. This could be justified by the differ-
10. I am confident that my baby is 0.701 ences between the methods used in the comparison of these
doing well studies. Nonetheless, the results are within the required sta-
11. I can make decisions about the 0.691 tistical range for a classification to be considered reliable.
care of my baby Internal consistency values measured by Cronbach’s alpha
12. Being a mother/father is very 0.754 ≥0.7 are required for a new scale12 ; the exposed cross-
stressful for me cultural adaptation and validation presented in this study a
13. I feel I am doing a good job as 0.699 value of 0.717, while in Nepal it was 0.87 and in its original
mother version, 0.81.21,22 The association between maternal confi-
14. Other people think I am doing a 0.701 dence, schooling, age, and parity corroborates other results
good job as a mother already described in the literature. It has been shown that
15. I feel sure that people will be 0.713 a higher level of maternal education improves the quality of
there for me when I need support child care, while low socioeconomic and educational levels
are associated with worse child health status.23,24
IVAPSA, impact of perinatal different intrauterine environments Olafsen et al.25 recommend that the variable maternal
on child growth and development in the first six months of life. confidence be assessed as early as the neonatal period, since
the existence of low levels of parental confidence may rep-
studies allow not only verifying differences between indi- resent a vulnerability that must be addressed as soon as it
viduals and cultures, but also assessing the similarities and is identified. In the present study, as suggested in the litera-
common characteristics between them.20 Thus, the use of ture, the scale was applied on the 15th day postpartum, still
appropriate tools is crucial, as they can provide measure- in the neonatal period, when the parents are still adapting
ment equivalence, regardless of the context where they are to the newborn, and are sensitive to the new feelings that
used.21 are emerging.
The KPCS tool, previously validated in its native lan- Within the context involved in carrying out this study and
guage and place of origin, Australia, was also translated considering that the results corroborate the literature, it
and validated for use in the Nepalese population.22 Thus, is necessary to reinforce the importance of maternal confi-
it was possible to compare the procedures carried out by dence in the concept of motherhood. Given that low levels of
the researchers responsible for this task in Nepal and in the parental confidence may affect parent---infant interactions,
scale’s country of origin, as well as to compare the results the promotion of parental competence feelings becomes
found in the different contexts.8---22 very relevant. Thus, it is imperative to consider the clini-
The population studied in the original validation8,9 and in cal relevance of the maternal feeling of confidence, which
the cross-cultural adaptation and validation carried out in is crucial for the development of adaptive and rewarding
Nepal22 for the study performance consisted of puerperal fatherhood and motherhood.26
women without gestational, pre-, and postnatal adverse Among the limitations of the present study is the fact
events. Diversely, in the present study, in addition to the that the sample was selected by convenience, something
women in the control group, the authors also assessed that facilitates the researcher’s grasp of the volun-
postpartum women who developed several gestational and teer participant and meets the previously established
perinatal conditions distributed in groups, including women requirements, but results in a certain inefficiency when
with DM, SAH, smokers, and children with IUGR/SGA. It external generalizations and claims are made with statis-
198 Pereira LW et al.
Am I confident about feeding my baby? Can I make decisions about the care of my baby?
(0) No, hardly ever. (0) No, hardly ever.
(1) No, not very often. (1) No, not very often.
(2) Yes, some of the time. (2) Yes, some of the time.
(3) Yes, most of the time. (3) Yes, most of the time.
(88) Someone else feeds the baby Is being a mother very stressful for me?
Can I settle my baby? (0) No, hardly ever.
(0) No, hardly ever. (1) No, not very often.
(1) No, not very often. (2) Yes, some of the time.
(2) Yes, some of the time. (3) Yes, most of the time.
(3) Yes, most of the time.
Transcultural adaptation and validation of the KPCS 199