Professional Documents
Culture Documents
by TIMOTHY W. FONG, MD
ADDRESS CORRESPONDENCE TO: Timothy W. Fong, MD, 760 Westwood Ave., Room C8-887, Los Angeles, CA 90024
Phone: (310) 825-1479; Fax: (310) 825-0301; E-mail: tfong@mednet.ucla.edu
C
Sexuality in the United States
has never been more socially
acceptable. Sex has become part of
acceptability and availability of sexual
mainstream culture as reflected rewards. For some...this increase in
through the explicit coverage of
sexual behaviors in the media, availability has uncovered an inability to control
movies, newspapers, and
magazines. In many ways, sexual sexual impulses resulting in continued
expression has become a form of
accepted entertainment similar to
engagement in these behaviors despite the
gambling, attending sporting
events, or watching movies.
creation of negative consequences—otherwise
Internet pornography has become a known as sexual addiction.
billion-dollar industry, stretching
the limits of the imagination.
Digital media offers portability, inability to control sexual impulses yields 164,104). Funding agencies,
access, and visually explicit resulting in continued engagement such as the National Institutes of
depictions of sexual acts in high- in these behaviors despite the Health (NIH), and pharmaceutical
definition that leave nothing to the creation of negative companies have not supported
imagination. Sales and rental of consequences—otherwise known research into the etiology and
adult movies through DVDs and as sexual addiction. This term has mechanisms of compulsive sexual
pay-per-view services allow access been used synonymously with behavior and, as a result,
to sex anywhere and at any time. others, such as compulsive sexual evidenced-based treatments are
The adult entertainment industry behaviors, hypersexuality, and limited. Despite the paucity of
generates close to $4 billion per excessive sexual desire disorder.1 It research, a significant number of
year and its acceptability in society can take many forms, and although patients with sexual addictions do
is reflected in the mainstreaming of it may seem obvious to diagnose, present for treatment. This is
its products into traditional retail standardized criteria have yet to be evidenced by the number of
stores and the portrayal of its developed. Furthermore, debate is treatment centers dedicated to the
actors and actresses as role models ongoing about where this treatment of sexual addictions in
and celebrities. Strip clubs have behavioral pattern fits into the both residential and intensive
evolved from backroom cabarets American Psychiatric outpatient settings. Mental health
into large multimillion dollar Association’s Diagnostic and professionals in any setting are
nightclubs and are present in Statistical Manual (DSM-IV), and likely to encounter patients with
virtually every state in the US. how it should be classified and this hidden addiction and require
Inside them, the degree of physical conceptualized.2 Is it an addictive better tools to diagnose and
contact has also increased, as disorder, an impulse-control manage them. This article will
compared to a generation ago, to disorder, or a variant of obsessive review the terminology, the
the point where the boundaries of compulsive disorders? Does it epidemiology, and the existing
what constitutes sexual intercourse merit enough empirical evidence to treatments that are currently
are blurred. Escort services, stand alone as a separate disorder? available for compulsive sexual
massage parlors, and street Finally, what are the boundaries behaviors.
prostitution continue to be and limits that distinguish disease
available in every major city in the patterns, at-risk behaviors, and DEFINING COMPULSIVE SEXUAL
US. Strengthening their presence socially appropriate expression? BEHAVIORS
and availability is the internet, Compulsive sexual behavior has The DSM-IV currently does not
which has created an information not yet received extensive list compulsive sexual behavior as a
portal for these services through attention from researchers and separate disorder with formal
online dating services, classified clinicians. To date, there have been criteria. There are 12 listed sexual
ads, and discussion boards for very few formalized studies of disorders and they are divided into
those in pursuit of sexual compulsive sexual behaviors. As an disorders of sexual dysfunction,
gratification. example, a keyword search on paraphilias, and gender identity
Together, these cultural changes PubMed, as of October, 2006, for disorder.3 Among these disorders,
have increased the acceptability “sexual addiction” yielded 518 there is no mention of repetitive,
and availability of sexual rewards. articles, while “compulsive sexual continued sexual behaviors that
For some, though, this increase in behavior” yielded 264 (in cause clinical distress and
availability has uncovered an comparison, “substance abuse” impairment. In fact, the only place
52 Psychiatry 2006 [ N O V E M B E R ]
where compulsive sexual behaviors primary conditions are treated, the IV: Exhibitionism, voyeurism,
might be included is within the sexual behaviors return to pedophilia, sexual masochism,
context of sexual disorder, not normalcy in terms of frequency and sexual sadism, transvestic
otherwise specified (NOS) or as intensity. fetishism, fetishism, and
part of a manic episode. In other frotterurism.3 There are many
words, hypersexuality, sexual CLINICAL FEATURES other forms of paraphilias that are
addiction, or compulsive sexual Compulsive sexual behaviors can not listed in DSM-IV (e.g.,
behaviors are terms that are not present in a variety of forms and gerontophilia, necrophilia,
found within the DSM-IV. degrees of severity, much like that zoophilia) that exist but have not
Some of the reasons for why of substance use disorders, mood been yet recognized as clinical
there is a lack of formalized criteria disorders, or impulse-control disorders. A key clinical feature in
include the lack of research as well disorders. Often, it may not be the diagnosing a paraphilic sexual
as an agreed-upon terminology. primary reason for seeking behavior is that it must be
This is due, in part, to the treatment and the symptoms are distressing and cause significant
heterogeneous presentation of not revealed unless inquired about. impairment in one’s life, with the
compulsive sexual behaviors.4 For Despite the lack of formalized exception of pedophilia and
instance, some patients present criteria, there are common clinical fetishism. In other words, with the
with clinical features that resemble features that are typically seen in noted exceptions, engagement in
an addictive disorder—i.e., compulsive sexual behaviors. these behaviors leads to sexual
continued engagement in the One of the fundamental gratification but does not cause
behavior despite physical or hallmarks of compulsive sexual distress or impairment and do not
psychological consequences, a loss behavior is continued engagement represent clinical disorders.7 Thus,
of control, and a preoccupation in sexual activities despite the frequency, amount of time spent,
with the behavior. Others will negative consequences created by and amount of money spent are not
demonstrate elements of an these activities. This is the same necessarily reliable indicators of
impulse control disorder, namely phenomenon seen in substance use the presence of a compulsive
reporting irresistible urges and and impulse control disorders. sexual disorder. Paraphilias begin
impulses, both physically and Psychologically, sexual behaviors in late adolescence and peak in the
mentally, to act out sexually serve to escape emotional or mid-20s.8 Commonly, paraphilias do
without regard to the physical pain or are a way of not occur in isolation; as the
consequences. Finally, there are dealing with life stressors.6 The expected course is characterized
patients who demonstrate sexual irony is that the sexual behaviors by multiple paraphilic and non-
obsessions and compulsions to act becomes the primary way of coping paraphilic behaviors.6
out sexually in a way that and handling problems that, in Non-paraphilic behaviors
resembles obsessive compulsive turn, creates a cycle of more represent engagement in
disorders. They do so to quell problems and increasing commonly available sexual
anxiety and to minimize fears of desperation, shame, and practices, such as attending strip
harm. For these patients, the preoccupation. clubs, compulsive masturbation,
thoughts and urges to act out Compulsive sexual behavior can paying for sex through prostitution,
sexually are ego-dystonic, whereas be divided into paraphilic and non- excessive use of pornography, and
other types of patients describe paraphilic subtypes. Paraphilic repeated engagement in
ego-syntonic feelings about their behaviors refer to behaviors that extramarital affairs. The onset,
sexual behaviors. are considered to be outside of the clinical course, and male
One important feature to note is conventional range of sexual predominance are fairly similar to
that hypersexuality is not behaviors. These include the eight paraphilic disorders.9 Various
necessarily symbolic or diagnostic paraphilias recognized in the DSM- epidemiological studies estimate
of compulsive sexual behaviors.
Libido and sexual drive can be seen
here are 12 listed sexual disorders and they
T
as similar to other biological drives,
such as sleep and appetite. States
of hypersexuality induced by are divided into disorders of sexual
substances of abuse, mania,
medications (e.g., dopamine
dysfunction, paraphilias, and gender identity
agonists), or even other medical
conditions (e.g., frontal-lobe
disorder.3 Among these disorders, there is no
tumors) can induce episodes of mention of repetitive, continued sexual behaviors
impulsive and excessive sexual
behaviors.5 However, once those that cause clinical distress and impairment.
[NOVEMBER] Psychiatry 2006 53
that close to six percent of the compulsive sexual disorder exists what a satisfying sexual
general population meet criteria based on physical examination relationship should be. At the same
but there are no national or large alone. time, the deception, secrecy, and
datasets to confirm this.8 Because Consequences of compulsive violations of trust that occur with
of the variety of activities possible, sexual behaviors can vary with compulsive sexual behaviors may
non-paraphilic compulsive sexual some being similar to that seen in shatter intimacy and personal
behavior can present in a number other addictive disorders while connections. The result is a warped
of ways. This has the potential to others are unique. Medically, view of intimacy that often leads to
confuse and cloud clinicians. In patients are at a higher risk for separation and divorce and, in turn,
addition, a clinician that screens sexually transmitted diseases puts any future healthy relationship
only for some but not all of the (STDs) and for physical injuries in doubt.
potentially problematic sexual due to repetitive sexual practices. Finally, the shame and guilt that
behaviors is likely to miss Human immunodeficiency virus those with compulsive sexual
behaviors experience is different
from those with other addictive
ne of the reasons why reliable
O
disorders. There are no substances
epidemiological data are lacking is the of abuse to explain seemingly
irrational behaviors. The stigma of
inconsistency in defining criteria for not being able to control sexual
impulses carries with it a
compulsive sexual behaviors, lack of funding, and connotation of depravity and moral
selfishness. Stigmatization in the
the lack of researchers committed to media and criminalization of
“sexual offenders” creates an
documenting the extent of this problem. atmosphere that does not promote
treatment and prevention. As a
important clinical information. (HIV), Hepatitis B and C, syphilis, result, access to care and seeking
Thus, asking about both paraphilic and gonorrhea are particularly care, even when one recognizes
and non-paraphilic behaviors is concerning consequences.13,14 that sexual behaviors are out of
critical in screening. In addition, it Virtually unknown is the control, is a decision faced with
is important to assess the percentage of those individuals barriers and limitations.
consequences as well as the nature with STDs who meet criteria for
of the behavior. A person who compulsive sexual disorders. EPIDEMIOLOGY
spends $1000 per week on strip Another significant consequence There have been no national
clubs may at first glance appear to is the loss of time and productivity. studies documenting the past-year
meet criteria, but if there are no It is not uncommon for patients to or lifetime prevalence of
notable adverse consequences in spend large amounts of time compulsive sexual behaviors in the
his or her life, then the disorder viewing pornography or cruising general population. Regional and
may not be present. (also called mongering) for sexual local surveys suggest that
Identifying a compulsive sexual gratification. Financial losses can approximately five percent of the
disorder is a challenge because of mount quickly, and patients can general population may meet
its sensitive and personal nature. accumulate several thousands of criteria for a compulsive sexual
Unless patients present specifically dollars of debt in a short amount of disorder (using criteria that are
for treatment of this disorder, they time. In addition, there is a long list similar to substance use
are not likely to discuss it.10 Much of legal consequences, including disorders).7 Further replication of
like other impulse control arrest for solicitation and engaging these data is needed but if true,
disorders, the physical and in paraphilic acts that are illegal. these rates represent a significant
psychological signs of compulsive One look at recent news headlines percentage of the general
sexual behaviors are often subtle or will likely reveal several stories population and would be higher
hidden. Even signs of excessive focusing on illegal sexual activities than the rates for schizophrenia,
sexual behaviors (such as physical or behaviors that jeopardize bipolar disorder, and pathological
injury to the genital area) or the someone’s livelihood or wellbeing. gambling. One of the reasons why
presence of sexually transmitted The psychological consequences reliable epidemiological data are
diseases does not necessarily are numerous. Effects on the family lacking is the inconsistency in
indicate compulsive sexual activity. and interpersonal relationships can defining criteria for compulsive
Their presence does signal the be profound. Compulsive sexual sexual behaviors, lack of funding,
need to screen for those behaviors behaviors can establish unhealthy and the lack of researchers
but one cannot assume a and unrealistic expectations of committed to documenting the
54 Psychiatry 2006 [ N O V E M B E R ]
extent of this problem. Most of frontal lobe lesion, tumors, and in functioning. Testosterone levels
what is known about the those with neurological conditions have been correlated to sexual
epidemiological nature of this that involve temporal lobes and functioning but curiously, levels do
disorder comes from clinical midbrain areas such as seizure not necessarily correlate to libido
treatment programs that focus on disorders, Huntington’s disease, and sexual desires.24 The
sexual addictions. Men appear to and dementia.17–19 Frontal lobe implication of these hormones in
outnumber women with compulsive damage may trigger the expression compulsive sexual behaviors is
sexual behaviors.7 Comorbidities of disinhibited behaviors, which critical to understand. It may be
include substance use disorders could partially explain the that regions of reward and pleasure
and co-occurring impulse control increased sexual activity along with are modulated by these hormones
disorders, and there is an decreased control.20 Still, more through facilitating or enhancing
association with histories of sexual investigation is needed to the response to sex and the desire
abuse.15,16 Other significant understand the specifics for sex.
epidemiological data is simply not aberrances because there are
known, such as the rate of certainly those individuals with CLINICAL ASSESSMENT
compulsive sexual behaviors among frontal lobe injuries that do not MEASURES
prosecuted sex offenders or the experience the emergence of There are existing screening
rate among those who work within compulsive sexual behaviors. instruments, which are only as
the adult entertainment industry. Neurotransmitter studies in valid as the responder’s honesty
compulsive sexual behaviors have and integrity. Although this is true
ETIOLOGY focused on the monoamines, of all psychiatric screening
As with impulse control and namely serotonin, dopamine, and instruments, revealing sexual
substance use disorders, no single norepinephrine.21 Again, research in practices is probably the most
biological cause has yet been clinical populations is scant. Normal humbling because of its private
identified to explain the origins and sexual functioning involves all of nature. Questions about time spent
maintenance of compulsive sexual these monoamines as evidenced by on sexual activities and impact of
behaviors. Neuroscience research, selective serotonin reuptake functioning are important clinically,
which would be an excellent inhibitor (SSRI)-induced sexual but also rely on self-report. Patrick
approach to understand basic brain dysfunction and the increased Carnes, one of the pioneers in the
differences between those with and sexuality observed among those on field of compulsive sexual behavior
without compulsive sexual stimulants. Cases of hypersexual research, developed the Sexual
behaviors, has rarely been applied behavior have also been shown to Addiction Screening Test, which is
to this population. In particular, be induced by medications for a 25-item, self-report symptom
neuroimaging studies in patients Parkinson’s disease, implicating checklist that can be used to
with compulsive sexual behaviors dopamine systems in compulsive identify those at risk to develop
would be interesting to compare sexual behaviors.22,23 What remains compulsive sexual behaviors.11 The
with those involved in substance unclear is understanding how these Sexual Addiction Screening Test
has also been modified for women
here are existing screening instruments,
T
and for internet sexual behaviors.
Kafka has suggested a behavioral
which are only as valid as the responder’s screening test (i.e., Total Sexual
Outlet) in which a total of seven
honesty and integrity. Although this is true sexual orgasms per week,
regardless of how they are
of all psychiatric screening instruments, revealing achieved, could represent at-risk
behavior and requires further
sexual practices is probably the most humbling clinical exploration.12
because of its private nature. TREATMENT: PSYCHOSOCIAL
Various types of psychosocial
abuse and other behavioral perturbations in neurochemical treatments are available for
addictions. To date though, most of functions differentiate compulsive individuals suffering from
the neuroimaging work has been sexual behaviors from those with compulsive sexual behaviors. The
done with nonclinical populations hypersexuality alone without a most widely available and
and has examined the biology of negative life impact. accessible are Sexual Addicts
sexual arousal in healthy subjects. In addition to neurotransmitters, Anonymous, Sex and Love Addicts
Hypersexual behaviors have the sex hormones are obviously a Anonymous, and Sexaholics
been reported in patients with critical component to sexual Anonymous.25 All three are modeled
56 Psychiatry 2006 [ N O V E M B E R ]
REFERENCES
linicians can enhance the identification
C
1. Carnes P, Schneider JP.
and treatment of these disorders by Recognition and management of
addictive sexual disorders: Guide
implementing formal screening for the primary care clinician.
Lippincotts Prim Care Pract
practices, becoming familiar with the warning 2000;4:302–18.
2. Stein DJ, Black DW, Shapira NA,
signs, and knowing which types of patients et al. Hypersexual disorder and
preoccupation with internet
are vulnerable. pornography. Am J Psychiatry
2001;158:1590–4.
3. American Psychiatric Association.
with the behavior. In an open-label of non-paraphilic compulsive sexual Diagnostic and Statistical
trial of naltrexone with adolescent behaviors. However, case reports Manual of Mental Disorders,
sexual offenders, 15 out of 21 and open label studies suggest Fourth Edition. Washington, DC:
patients noted reductions in sexual these may be effective treatments.13 American Psychiatric Association,
impulses and arousal.30 There have Of importance to note, this 1994.
also been studies examining the treatment approach is temporary. 4. Gold SN, Heffner CL. Sexual
efficacy of intramuscular naltrexone Once the medications are stopped, addiction: Many conceptions,
in this clinical population. testosterone levels will return to minimal data. Clin Psychol Rev
Mood stabilizers, such as valproic normal levels. This treatment 1998;18:367–81.
acid and lithium, appear promising approach has not been utilized in 5. Weintraub D, Potenza MN.
in the treatment of patients with the non-paraphilic sexual Impulse control disorders in
bipolar disorder and compulsive behaviors. Parkinson's disease. Curr Neurol
sexual behaviors.31,32 Whether this Neurosci Rep 2006;6:302–6.
class of medications has an CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE 6. Kafka MP, Prentky RA.
independent effect on reducing DIRECTIONS Compulsive sexual behavior
compulsive sexual behaviors in We have much to learn about characteristics. Am J Psychiatry
patients without comorbid bipolar compulsive sexual behaviors, 1997;154:1632.
disorder remains to be seen. Other particularly their neurobiological 7. Coleman E, Raymond N, McBean
medications, such as topiramate roots, psychological risk factors, A. Assessment and treatment of
and nefazadone, have also been and the impact of societal values on compulsive sexual behavior.
tried, but further replication is their emergence. For now, Minn Med 2003;86:42–7.
needed to determine their compulsive sexual behaviors are 8. Black DW, Kehrberg LL,
effectiveness.33,34 the extreme end of a wide range of Flumerfelt DL, et al.
In the treatment of paraphilic sexual experience. These behaviors Characteristics of 36 subjects
compulsive sexual behaviors, some can present in a variety of manners reporting compulsive sexual
pharmacotherapy strategies have and undoubtedly have many behavior. Am J Psychiatry
focused on altering or attenuating different subtypes, severities, and 1997;154:243–9.
sexual hormone function.35 Anti- clinical courses. Clinicians can 9. Allen A. Hollander E, Stein DJ
androgens, such as enhance the identification and (eds). Clinical Manual of
medroxyprogesterone acetate treatment of these disorders by Impulse-Control Disorders.
(300–500mg per week, implementing formal screening Arlington, VA: American
intramuscularly) or cyproterone practices, becoming familiar with Psychiatric Publishing, Inc.; 2006.
acetate (300–600mg per week, the warning signs, and knowing 10. Schneider JP. How to recognize
intramuscularly), lower serum which types of patients are the signs of sexual addiction.
testosterone levels and diminish vulnerable. In time, research will Asking the right questions may
sexual drive and desire.24,35 On a begin to uncover the different uncover serious problems.
more drastic level, surgical subtypes of compulsive sexual Postgrad Med 1991;90:171–4,
intervention (castration) has been behaviors as well as determine 177–82.
shown to reduce recidivism in which treatment and prevention 11. Carnes P. Sexual addiction
sexual offenders by theoretically practices work the best. Currently, screening test. Tenn Nurse
lowering testosterone levels to since there are no guidelines from 1991;54:29.
reduce urges and cravings. There which clinicians can work, we are 12. Kafka M. Hypersexual desire in
are no known double-blind, left to review the work of those males: An operational definition
randomized studies of anti- who specialize in the treatment of and clinical implications for males
androgenic agents in the treatment compulsive sexual behaviors. with paraphilias and paraphilia-