Professional Documents
Culture Documents
third-party cookie.
Your complete guide to a world
without third-party cookies.
1
Technology does not need vast troves of
personal data, stitched together across
dozens of websites and apps, in order to
succeed. Advertising existed and thrived
for decades without it. And we’re here
today because the path of least resistance
is rarely the path of wisdom."
Tim Cook
Apple CEO
2021 CPDP Conference keynote
2
Table of contents
Executive summary 5
PA RT ON E
Getting real about third-party cookies 8
The personalization and privacy paradox 9
The customer identity crisis 10
Partner perspective: Sheri Bachstein, IBM 12
PA RT T W O
Confronting acquisition challenges
in a cookieless world 14
Diminished scale 15
The limitations of “walled gardens” 16
Partner perspective: Brad Herndon,
Accenture Interactive 20
PA RT T HREE
Planning for success without the
third-party cookie 22
Earn authentication to build
authentic relationships 22
Share the data wealth through partnerships 26
3
Put your campaigns in context 28
Develop a strategy for lifetime value 32
Partner perspective: Katie Li, Merkle 33
PA RT F O U R
Putting it all together—your step-by-step
guide to a cookieless strategy 35
Seven steps to thriving without
third-party cookies 35
Partner perspective: Joe Obringer, Capgemini 42
Adobe can help 44
Sources 45
Executive summary
By early 2022, all major web browsers will have phased out
third-party tracking cookies to respect the growing call for
customer data privacy. For most marketers, this paradigm
shift presents enormous challenges as they reimagine their
strategies for customer acquisition.
5
Introduction
Once upon a time, more than two decades ago, there was
a world without third-party tracking cookies—those handy
pieces of code added to web browsers that retain user data to
offer personalized web experiences. Browsing the internet was
the same for everyone, whether you were a college student
in Abu Dhabi or a retiree in Zürich. And data privacy concerns
were almost nonexistent—for the average web user, at least.
6
that use caches to create “supercookies.” Apple followed suit in
2020 by disabling third-party cookies in Safari and announcing
discontinued support for its IDFA (Identifier for Advertisers)
in iOS 14. The final nail in the coffin: Google announced in
2020 that it would block all third-party cookies in Chrome
by the end of 2022, and that that it will not create alternative
identifiers to track individuals as they browse across the web,
nor will it use them in its products.
Types of cookies—how they’re created, how they’re used, and how they differ.
8
Third-party data makes up a huge portion of data spending
for many businesses—and well over half of U.S. budgets, per
eMarketer. And despite existing policies against third-party cookies
in browsers such as Safari and Mozilla, year-over-year spending
on third-party data has increased, according to IAB. If you look at
marketing as an investment—your company’s money in exchange
for customers’ attention—then some diversification is badly
needed. Over-reliance on one marketing tactic can be just as
dangerous as investing in only one company’s stock—and third-
party cookies are like a stock whose fundamentals aren’t sound.
9
Still, consumers don’t want to let go of personalization. Despite
their privacy concerns, 80 percent of customers expect a tailored
experience on the web, according to
McKinsey. And they’re looking
What consumers say to you to resolve that paradox
about personalization. for them.
The customer
identity crisis.
Given that effective and ethical
personalization is the gold standard
80% are more likely to
make a purchase from in digital marketing, it’s surprising
a brand that provides
how much marketers still rely on
personalized experiences.
third-party cookies, which are
ineffective at gathering data across
unique devices and in individual
web browsers.
10
measurement in two years the same way we look at a tricked-out
1992 Dell today—antiquated and inefficient."
11
Partner perspective.
Sheri Bachstein
Global Head of Watson Advertising and
The Weather Company
Sheri Bachstein of IBM discusses how the cookieless future will transform the
advertising industry—and why AI will be at the center of that transformation.
12
platform sees 350 million consumers every month. I don’t need
to collect identifiers from all of them in order to deliver to my
marketing team or our partner brands.
1. Being consumer-minded
2. Building long-term sustainable solutions
3. Sharing tech across the entire open web
13
PA RT T W O
Confronting acquisition
challenges in a cookieless world.
For all the shortcomings of third-party cookies, the marketing
industry doesn’t have a perfect answer for how to acquire
customers without them. Third-party data may be a blunt
instrument, but it’s easy to obtain, affordable, and vast in quantity.
14
Unfortunately, it's not as simple as that. First-party data presents
several considerable hurdles to customer acquisition.
Diminished scale.
First-party data can be hard to obtain. Unlike third-party data, you
have to “earn” it—there isn’t a shortcut that money can buy. All
types of companies, whether they're high authentication or low, will
need to solve the puzzle of how to gain more first-party data in a
cookieless future.
What steps are you taking to address the impact of third-party cookie deprecation?
Building a
customer data
platform (CDP)
First-party
data strategies
Building out a
private ID graph
Moving to
contextual
targeting
strategies
Getting a data
clean room
Number of
respondents (n) = 259
Source: Epsilon
15
Third-party data—even when pseudonymous—has always
worked reasonably well for customer acquisition because of its
sheer volume. It’s the digital equivalent of handing out flyers in a
neighborhood that meets your general demographic requirements.
You develop audience awareness, capture some interest, and
convert a certain number of people into customers.
These conversions don’t cost you too much money, but you run
the risk of annoying some people—and wasting budget on people
who weren’t a good fit to begin with. It isn’t perfect, but it gets the
job done.
First-party data, on the other hand, comes from the customers you
already have—not the ones you want to convert. As you gather
first-party data, you’ll be able to serve your existing customers
better than ever—but it won’t help you acquire any new ones.
16
allow other businesses to use that data for targeted advertising on
their platforms. Think Facebook, Google, and Amazon—closed-loop
ecosystems that will command even more digital marketing power
once cookies vanish. These kinds of companies are often called
“walled gardens.”
17
There’s a lot to learn from this people-based approach when
it comes to encouraging authentication as a way to navigate a
cookieless world—which we’ll discuss more in part three. But when
it comes to relying on walled gardens for customer acquisition,
there are some things to consider:
18
homework—especially when
they don’t allow you to double-
check their work.
19
Partner perspective.
Brad Herndon
Managing Director, Personalization, Data
and Analytics Practice Lead, North America
20
motivations so you can create a unique value exchange that puts
the customer first.
21
PA RT THREE
22
In a cookieless world, authentication can no longer be an
afterthought—especially if you want to steer clear of walled gardens.
Authentication—the basics.
High-authentication Low-authentication
Authentication
industries industries
23
Instead of another ID, marketers
need a system that can stitch Strategies for consumer-
together all the right pieces of packaged goods and other
data—such as a customer’s low-authentication industries.
email address or phone “If there's a good relationship and
number—and apply them a good return of value for being
across channels. This is one part of your program, there's quite
great reason to make sure often a wealth of information that
you’re on top of your could be shared by a consumer
authentication strategy. with a retailer,” says Michael
25
transactional—it should be a positive and natural part of the
overall customer experience.
Second-party data can help you expand your reach and increase
customer acquisition because the data is shared among a network
of companies, allowing each one to advertise across the others. It
has many of the benefits of third-party data, but at a smaller scale.
Private partnerships.
26
Data co-ops.
Walled gardens.
For most companies, working with a data co-op is the best and
safest option to reach customers at scale. Gary Walter at Ad Age
offers five best practices for finding and maintaining the ideal
data partnerships:
27
• Source good data the right way. Every partner needs to source
data ethically and ensure its quality to maintain customer trust
across the co-op.
• Keep your data fresh. Data doesn’t last forever. Be sure you and
your partners agree on how to update, cleanse, and reconcile
your data.
• Include all the right types of data. To get what you need out of
the partnership, specify what data mix you require—as well as
what types of data you can offer.
28
Fortunately, two fresh approaches to contextual targeting can
improve your results:
29
For advertisers with large customer databases,
availing themselves of the opportunity to match
their own data to the unique rich data sets owned by
publishers is a safe, effective bet in a market with a
growing scarcity of quality audience intelligence."
Seb Joseph
Author
Digiday
30
To do this, marketers need two things:
31
Develop a strategy for lifetime value.
Meaningful relationships with customers drive business growth,
and technology has made it possible to build those relationships
at scale through personalization and high-touch customer
experiences. Still, success has always been measured by the value
you offer your customers—and that won’t change in a
cookieless world.
The hard truth of the new paradigm is that you may not be able to
reach the same number of customers you could before. The third-
party cookie was primarily about quantity. The new reality shifts
the focus back to value—but the value you offer over a lifetime of
engagement with dedicated customers, not the value you offer to as
many customers as you can acquire.
32
Partner perspective.
Katie Li
Audience Management Director
Katie Li of Merkle discusses ways brands can adopt new data strategies and
technologies to deepen relationships with customers.
Then you need to look at the new technology that can help. If
you’re still using a DMP, it might be time to consider migrating to
a CDP, which is custom-built to handle identity challenges. DMPs
and CDPs share a lot of similarities, so you can use the learnings,
principles, and governance developed for DMPs to kick-start
your CDP.
33
several months old, are you really giving your customers the best
possible experience?
In the past, with DMPs and third-party cookies, the trend was to get
as many people as possible inside the door. But for a business to
be successful in the long run, you need to sustain and nurture each
relationship. There are lots of positives here because we’re moving
past the anonymous crowd into relationships with individuals.
There are a few ways to make this work in practice. The first
thing you need is some form of value exchange. You can’t expect
customers to give you their data for no reason. There are tons of
ways to do this—coupons, rebates, discounts, and so on. Another
way I’ve seen businesses do this is through gaming. You can gamify
your loyalty program, for example, to draw people further into your
brand’s ecosystem.
Regardless of how you get your first-party data, the important thing
is what you do with that data afterwards. It’s all about how you
nurture the relationship and deepen it over time.
34
PA RT F O UR
1 2 3
4 5 6 7
35
Step 1: Assess where you are.
36
Step 2: Streamline to a single domain.
Action items:
Get visibility into behavior with customer profiles and gain insights
with analytics.
Store your data safely outside the browser to avoid losing important
profile information.
When customer data lives in silos, you have only a partial view of
your audience and can’t offer the best possible experiences. Without
37
third-party data to cast an ultra-wide net for acquisition, treating
your existing customers with care is extra important.
Action items:
Action items:
38
Step 5: Use contextual targeting.
Action items:
39
gardens, such as Facebook and Amazon, you can keep (and run
analytics on) your own data.
Action items:
Action items:
40
While nobody knows just what the cookieless future has in store,
following these guidelines will put you in a good position to
gain and retain customers without third-party data. Revisit your
marketing strategy regularly to make sure you’re keeping up with
the latest tools, technologies, and best practices. And remember
that when you put your customers first—no matter what type of
data they have to offer—you’ll always be on the right path.
41
Partner perspective.
Joe Obringer
Director of Search and Media
42
used to help them find products more easily or provide them with
discounts or special offers.
43
Adobe can help.
Our four pillars of cookieless customer acquisition:
Expand your
Pave the path to Activate your first- audience, acquire
Get smart with
authentication party data with new customers,
Customer Journey
with real-time Customer Journey and get true
Analytics
personalization Management insights with bias-
free advertising
Get the full picture Personalize the Put your first-party Connect with
of how customers customer journey data to work with customers
move through your in real time. By cohesive, real-time, outside your own
sales funnel across responding to customer-led domains—even
every channel— every data signal experiences. within walled
online and off. in milliseconds, With tools such gardens—via
With all your data Adobe Target as Journey second-party
stitched together helps you create Orchestration, data partnerships.
in one place, unique paths that you have the Deliver targeted
you’ll gain entirely lead customers scale, speed, and experiences
new metrics and toward a deeper intelligence to and set up ad
dimensions that relationship with automate unique suppression for
automatically your business—on journeys across all existing customers;
populate their terms. owned channels. use look-alike
into Analysis Offer value faster, modeling to reach
Workspace, where reduce attrition, new audiences.
you can gain and increase Get unbiased
incredible insights lifetime value performance
into your customer by providing analysis via
journeys. customers with the Attribution AI to
best experience in understand your
every moment. impact across
every channel
and segment.
Adobe products
44
Sources
Ben Jacobson, “No Need to Mourn the Death of the Third-Party Cookie,” The Next Web, 2021.
Blake Morgan, “50 Stats Showing the Power of Personalization,” Forbes, 2020.
Brian Boland, “Facebook Exec: Cookies Don't Cut it Anymore for Online Ad Measurement,” Ad Age,
2014.
“Consumer Privacy Survey: The Growing Imperative of Getting Data Privacy Right,” Cisco, 2019.
Emily Stewart, “Why Every Website Wants You to Accept its Cookies,” Vox, 2019.
Erik Lindecrantz, Madeleine Tjon Pian Gi, and Stefano Zerb, “Personalizing the Customer
Experience: Driving Differentiation in Retail,” McKinsey, 2020.
Gary Walter, “The Rise of Second-Party Data and How to Maximize the Value of Partnership Data,”
Ad Age, 2019.
Madison Crane, “Third-Party Cookies May Not be the Only Threat to Marketers,” eHealthcare
Solutions, 2020.
Nicole Perrin, “Identity 2020: Changes to Cookies, Ad IDs, and Regulations Take Aim at Tracking,”
eMarketer, 2020.
Owen Ray, “Tracking Cookies are Dead: What Marketers Can Do About It,” Invoca, 2021.
45
Sources
Ross Benes, “Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies,” eMarketer, 2018.
Seb Joseph, “In the Absence of Third-Party Cookies, Publishers are Building Walled Gardens of Their
Own,” Digiday, 2020.
Tim Cook, “A Path to Empowering User Choice and Boosting User Trust in Advertising,” CPDP
Conference Keynote, 2021.