You are on page 1of 6

“Despite the willingness of businesses to become green, most executives do not believe their

companies are doing a good job nor even know how to implement green business practices
into their strategy and daily company practices. This is specifically where OD can have
a major influence.”

Green Organization Development

By Bauback Yeganeh A shift is taking place. Organizations Christensen, David Cooperrider, Peter
and Ante Glavas across the globe are awakening to the Drucker, Charles Handy, Stuart Hart,
reality that green business practices Philip Kotler, Henry Mintzberg, Michael
can provide competitive advantages Porter, CK Prahalad, Rosabeth Moss
while simultaneously producing world Kanter, and Peter Senge.
benefit. As larger organizations begin The business sector is increasingly
integrating such practices into their called upon to be one of the key drivers
strategic agendas, tens of thousands of of the green movement. In 2000, UN
supply chain organizations will need Secretary General Kofi Annan addressed
to adjust how they do business. Many business leaders at the World Economic
organizations, with a desire to “go green”, Forum by calling for a global compact
lack the know-how to materialize desired between business, government, non-profit
change without external help. In addition, organizations, and the UN: “Let us choose
since this type of external help is rather to unite the power of markets with the
new, there are few places to turn for it. strength of universal ideals. Let us choose
Given the values, tools, and skills that to reconcile the creative forces of private
competent OD scholar/practitioners entrepreneurship with the needs of the
have acquired, we believe they are poised disadvantaged and the requirements of
to help organizations succeed in Green future generations.”
OD initiatives. This would not only help Without the help of business,
organizations, employees and the Earth, governments and non-profit organizations,
but it will help grow the field of OD. we cannot create a healthy planet and
In this article we discuss ways to further society. Business leaders are increasingly
develop Green Organization Development. recognizing the importance of their
involvement. In a study conducted by
Update on Going Green McKinsey of 4,238 business executives
in 116 countries, 84% believed that
Green business is practically everywhere business should contribute to the public
around us. Magazine covers from Time to good; however, only 3% believe that their
Vanity Fair are focusing on going green. companies are currently doing a good job
Movies such as “An Inconvenient Truth” (McKinsey, 2006).
are hitting Hollywood. Companies such Despite the willingness of businesses
as Wal-Mart and General Electric are to become green, most executives do not
transforming their business practices believe their companies are doing a good
into green ones. Perhaps most striking of job nor even know how to implement
all is the list of prominent management green business practices into their strategy
and strategy experts that have focused on and daily company practices. This is
helping organizations bring about world specifically where OD can have a major
benefit including Warren Bennis, Clayton influence. There is a huge need and gap

6 OD PRACTITIONER  Vol. 40 No. 2  2008


to fill. On the one hand, business leaders (Glavas, 2008). Numerous terms states that for an activity to be considered
want their companies to go green, while such as sustainability, corporate social OD it must:
on the other they lack the process skills to responsibility, corporate citizenship, ethics, 1. Involve a change in the system that is
create sustainable, green companies. and sustainable development all exist with the focus of the effort.
definitions often overlapping; and even 2. It must have the intent of improving
What Do You Mean, Green? within the scope of each term, there is no the system.
consensus as to the definition. We feel 3. It must have the intent of building the
We like the word “green” because it has two comfortable using the label “Green OD” capacity of the system to change in
connotations, the environment, and the and we welcome your feedback on it as an the future by involving people in the
color of US Dollars. Because Green OD is adequate term. process (not dictate change).
about helping organizations nurture the
environment while increasing economic The Changing World of These criteria are unique to organization
value, the term seems fitting. It is also Organization Development development and in our experiences
important to note that the green movement contribute to the successes that competent
is about the whole environment, not just A new shift is emerging in organizations OD practitioners achieve.
nature. This includes poverty levels, health, from the trade-off illusion of green The field of organization development
peace, housing, and all the other factors OR profit, to seeing green business as is currently defining itself in relation
that contribute to the well being of society. an opportunity. Numerous methods to globalization. The World OD
By “green” we mean: benefiting our society exist for adding business value while Alliance created a responsible progress
doctrine, “calling on the field to provide
Without the help of business, governments and non-profit governments, non-governmental
organizations, corporations, and other
organizations, we cannot create a healthy planet and society. stakeholders with support to jointly
Business leaders are increasingly recognizing the importance optimize the four elements for global
success: economic development,
of their involvement. In a study conducted by McKinsey of technological innovation, cultural diversity,
4,238 business executives in 116 countries, 84% believed that and ecological sustainability” (Worley
& McCloskey, to be published). It was
business should contribute to the public good; however, only influenced by the triple bottom line, which
3% believe that their companies are currently doing a good job. focuses on economic, social, and ecological
value. Developing green organization
and environment while also adding value also contributing to society and/or development practices will help grow OD
to the organization. Such a definition the environment. These include but toward this responsible progress doctrine.
makes a clear distinction between many are not limited to: energy efficiency,
of the other concepts in the field of using renewable and cheaper energy, Green OD
business and society that assume there is innovations based upon green principles,
a “trade-off” between creating business increased quality of the product design, Consider This: OD Consultants have
value, and contributing to our society and increased brand image, increased always had to work to introduce
environment. employee engagement through aligning humanistic values into organizations.
While some use the term organizational and employee values, and Often after new values are adopted,
“sustainability” to describe the above improved company reputation. the bottom line benefit is revealed. We
definition, we chose not to for several In order to capitalize on any of the are poised to do the same with Green
reasons. First, in the field of OD, previously mentioned methods, it is OD values.
sustainability describes lasting change. necessary to perform a host of OD practices
While Green OD is about sustainable such as strategic planning (including large By “Green OD” we are referring to OD
change, sustainability alone is not Green scale design), leadership development, work that focuses on organizations seeking
OD. This is where things get confusing. strategy implementation, culture change, to change core practices so that they benefit
In the green world, sustainability in and team building. As a result, one of the our society and environment while also
organizations means going green in a hottest trends today is sorely in need of OD adding value to the organization. Implicit
core and lasting way. In many circles, the expertise. in the term Green OD is sustainability
two terms have become synonymous. A As readers of this journal know, there from the environmental side, meaning
literature review of the field of business are many definitions to describe our field. nature preservation and societal good;
and society found a lack of clarity and When thinking about OD we use Chris and the business value side, meaning
agreement of terms related to sustainability Worley’s (2002) suggested criteria. He reputation, stock prices, and viability.

Green Organization Development 7


Effective Green OD requires trust, Inquiry, the delegates developed world- CEOs or V.P.s) were valued for their
learning, empowerment, buy-in, and changing initiatives such as a $10 trillion ideas
relational capacity. The OD approach to commitment by the leading financial
organization change seems aligned with institutions to invest in only that which “I would like to commend you more
these requirements. If green business is to provides for a sustainable and green particularly for your innovative
be aligned with the goals of organizations, future. The event was successful for several methodology of ‘appreciative inquiry’
and every organization has its own unique reasons. First, it created a participative and to thank you for introducing it to
goals, then Green OD approaches must be environment that tapped into the whole the United Nations. Without this, it
unique to every organization as well. OD system. Rather than a series of speeches would have been very difficult, perhaps
already focuses on customized approaches being delivered, the participants—who all even impossible, to constructively engage
to change and is well suited to be of service. were extraordinary in their own right— so many leaders of business, civil society
It is important to note that when were able to fully contribute. Next, the and government”—U.N. Secretary
pursuing green goals, many people event utilized a strengths-based approach, General Kofi A. Annan, July 21, 2004
traditionally involved such as Corporate building on the best that exists. In that
Social Responsibility (CSR) officers, way, endless debates of the problems of There are many other cases in which
Environmental Health and Safety (EHS) the world and those to blame were avoided we have seen Green OD succeed in
employees, and others with similar and collective action was mobilized in businesses. For example, throughout
responsibilities seldom follow Worley’s one day. The day was focused on visions Brazil, businesses have come together
three OD criteria mentioned earlier. for the future, solutions, and what can be to learn from their experiences of green
Their approaches tend to be focused on done to scale-up Global Compact member innovations. In the U.S., Fairmount
endeavors that are on the periphery of the commitments. This is not to suggest Minerals received the award for #1
core business rather than a part of a core that AI is the only way to accomplish Corporate Citizen in 2007 by the U.S.
change process. Green activities that only Green OD. However as part of the BAWB Chamber of Commerce for the Small and
scratch the tip of the surface may include consulting team to the UN, we offer a first Medium Sized Business category, and
creating a code of ethics, brochures, hand account of one successful approach. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters was #1
philanthropic activities, internal awareness Some of the reasons we believe AI was a on the Business Ethics list for the last two
campaigns, and recycling programs. successful methodology at the UN Global years (the first ever to receive back-to-back
These activities, while important, are not Compact Leaders Summit include: awards).
enough to meet the green challenge. In »» we only had one day to work
fact, sometimes they can have a negative »» there were many stakeholders with Again, a commonality to their successes,
effect on employees by increasing their unique interests and ideas and a theme that continues to emerge, was
workloads without seeing true results. It »» the problems were vast and complex that these organizations brought the whole
is insufficient for organizations to simply »» all participants (most of whom were system in the room—from dock workers
add green-oriented peripheral activities to
the already demanding workloads of busy Figure 1: G
 reen Organizational Practices at Varying Levels
employees. For green practices to work, of Organizational Culture
they must be a part of the core change
strategy of an organization. This is where 1. A
 rtifacts—At a high level, organizational artifacts that may suggest an organization
OD can have tremendous effects. is focusing on green initiatives include posters and other signage, internal
In Figure 1, we use Schein’s levels of communications, providing recyclable products and bins, green commercials,
organizational culture to better understand identity branding (green washing). Other artifacts may include donating proceeds
varying degrees of commitment to green to charities or doing other sorts of green promotional work.
organizational practices. 2. N
 orms—One layer below the surface norms represent unwritten rules about
behavior. Certain expectations about green practices may be in place for services
Inspiring Examples of and product design, decision making, energy use, recycling and more.
Green OD at Work
3. Values—The next level of depth in an organization focuses on what ought to be.
At Case Western Reserve University, Here if the value of green work is different than the value of the core business,
The Center for Business as an Agent artifacts and norms that are designed to build momentum, will fail to do so.
of World Benefit (BAWB), chaired by 4. Basic Assumptions—The core of the organization. For green practices to really
David Cooperrider, was called by Kofi work they have to be linked to currently existing basic assumptions about creating
Annan to facilitate the first ever meeting business value. When basic assumptions are focused on green practices then
of 400+ leaders from all sectors at the productivity and profit are always linked to improving the environment and society.
United Nations. Using Appreciative

8 OD PRACTITIONER  Vol. 40 No. 2  2008


to owners to suppliers to activists who Figure 2 illustrates some differences General Electric has invested $1 billion
opposed the company. They then worked between traditional forms of Sustainability in this area, working with the value
with the whole system to scale up that Consulting and the emerging practice of chain through cutting-edge technology.
which works in order to achieve a shared Green OD Consulting. 2. Energy Efficiency—DuPont has saved
$3 billion from reducing carbon
The solutions that lead to energy efficiency rarely come from emissions, showing how a chemicals
company can go from being harmful
expert consultants alone because they lack covert knowledge to the environment to one that is
of the client system. On the other hand, the client system increasingly becoming a green
company. The solutions that lead to
may have difficulty creating solutions alone due to employees energy efficiency rarely come from
getting stuck in silos, daily routines, and not thinking on a expert consultants alone because they
lack covert knowledge of the client
systems level about potential solutions. system. On the other hand, the client
system may have difficulty creating
vision and move into action. Propositions for Flourishing solutions alone due to employees
Wal-Mart has also used OD to bring Green OD Practices: getting stuck in silos, daily routines,
together employees and stakeholders and not thinking on a systems level
to examine how their 300 billion dollar Despite inspiring examples, the Green OD about potential solutions. Therein lays
revenue generating operation can make field is still young and OD practitioners the opportunity for Green OD.
core shifts to green practices (Gunther, need to co-learn in order to practice. 3. Product Design—Numerous examples
2007). Other such initiatives currently exist in Bottom-of-the-Pyramid
under way include Dairy Management Inc. Identify existing green business approaches where a new product is
and 60,000 farmers to integrate green core opportunities and use OD to scale up needed that serves the needs of those in
practices into the dairy industry; together Examples highlighted in the previous poverty while also generating profit. For
with AESE, facilitating the process of section underpin the power of OD to example, the Jaipur Foot was developed
3,000 associations becoming associations bring about whole system, large scale as a response to the lack of prosthetics
of world benefit; and bringing together change. However, Green OD can be used to in India due to cost. The new prosthetic
the US energy sector to transform the facilitate any process that generates value that was developed costs hundreds
business model of how energy is produced, for the business. Examples of areas where of times less, can be produced in 30
distributed, and consumed. Green OD is being and can be used: minutes with far fewer resources,
Other OD methods such as scenario 1. Value Chain—Typically companies creates job opportunities for villagers
planning, U-process, World Café, and have approached the value chain and producing them, looks more like a
Open Space Technology, have been used more often the supply chain from leg than competing products, and has
successfully to develop companies, sectors, a purely cost-cutting and logistics much better mobility, allowing a level
communities, and even countries focused efficiency approach. However, when a of mobilization that cannot be attained
on green business practices. For example, “green lens” is used, there is enormous with the typical prosthetic from the
Peter Senge, Otto Scharmer, and Adam potential for the value chain to West.
Kahane are working with food value chains collaborate and produce goods that are 4. Employees—OD practitioners have
to alleviate worldwide hunger. of value to the consumer and the earth. often focused on vision-building
processes for companies. When
Figure 2: T raditional Sustainability Consulting vs. Green OD Consulting combined with green practices, there
is potential for Green OD initiatives to
Traditional Sustainability Consulting—examples include providing suggestions for increase employee engagement. For
green initiatives, ecological footprint analyses, sustainability reports, policy and/or
example, a division at Parker-Hannifin
operational change suggestions, and recommendations for improving environmental
impact.
found ways to shift its products so
that it addresses what it identified as
Green OD Consulting—examples include creating learning environments in which the top 10 problems in society. It is no
organization members develop green core business practices together, build relational surprise that the division had the most
capacity, reduce silos, enhance collaboration, help build shared vision and empower
empowered employees in the company.
the system to develop customized solutions based on cutting edge green technology.
5. Markets—As markets in the West
Preparation may include benchmarking green innovations and/or bringing in experts
to teach the latest developments in green technology, but the core innovations are become more saturated, there is an
produced and driven internally. increase in business opportunities
to address the world’s most pressing

Green Organization Development 9


problems. Countless examples exist of »» Check out http://worldbenefit.case. going green rather than solely outsourcing
companies that provide water filtering, edu/inquiry/features.cfm for stories knowledge. Happily this is an argument
energy to off-grid locations, health about businesses that have succeeded that requires little effort in our OD
insurance for HIV infected populations in green practices community.
etc… Muhammad Yunus won the
Nobel Prize in 2006 for his innovative Going Green as an OD Tool— Learn Strategic Planning Processes
micro-financing initiatives, the majority Large Learning Conversations and Implementation
of which provided means for small Creating a reason to convene in organiza­ This is a new area in which our field can
business creation to women suffering tions can be a challenge. OD practitioners innovate. From what we have gathered thus
disproportionate levels of poverty. always hear the needs to think out-of- far, it is crucial to use strategic planning
Perhaps Peter Drucker put it best when the-box and to work in cross-disciplinary processes that generate knowledge and
he said that every single issue of our arrangements. Large-scale participatory buy-in throughout the system. However,
time is a business opportunity.
This is what OD folks are good at! Help clients drive metrics
We realize that many of the highlighted
examples above focus on large, and create conversational spaces so that the organization
multinationals, some of which have been is collaborating from within. Use OD interventions where
questioned as to their overall intent.
The point of this article is not to put any necessary to continue helping the organization toward its goals.
one company on a pedestal. We find it Like most OD endeavors, this will look different in every system
interesting however to observe that some
of the companies most known for being that is attempting change. Some client systems will need more
profit-driven are adopting green business leadership coaching while others may need more teambuilding.
practices as a means of creating and
maintaining competitive advantage. As a rule, communicate, communicate, communicate internally!
In addition, break-through green
change is happening in small and events, in which many organization Green OD goes beyond repeating the same
medium sized companies such as representatives from various areas meet, popular techniques that we have used in
Fairmount Minerals which was previously learn, and plan together about green the past. It is about really customizing the
mentioned. Packaging companies such transformation provides a practical interventions we use to meet the unique
as Weatherchem are seeking ways to way of meeting these needs. It can also needs of the system for this specific type of
create disclosures using fewer resources increase relational and learning capacities, change. Prior to strategic planning retreats,
that are more Earth-friendly. RLE is a decrease silos, and create social contagion help clients analyze where they think their
lighting manufacturer that also consults of breakthrough thinking, resulting in strengths are throughout the organization.
with companies, helping them become positive actions that may have otherwise For example, if an organization is
more energy efficient while selling their not occurred. strong in engineering and marketing,
own products at the same time; and potential leaders could emerge from these
Nutrimental Foods in Brazil tapped into Expertise is Crucial— Departments to help champion the change.
the whole system to completely change its Not Just OD Expertise It is useful for organizations to engage
effect on the country. Teaching OD practices is important. in large scale planning processes where
It is also crucial to help organizations the entire organization is represented,
Uplift Green Organization Change create a sustained pattern of learning and from operations folks to administrative
Success Stories innovation. This can be accomplished assistants, to upper level management. To
People learn from stories. Copycat by creating learning labs for internal create a strategy around green business,
criminals acquire narratives from the news folks to grow green expertise within make sure to include examples of green
because examples of crime abound. OD their domains of work. Growing their business innovations that have succeeded
practitioners need to provide an abundance green expertise by creating learning labs in other organizations. Once a green
of resources to feed potential copycat social (case studies, learning conversations, strategy has been created, implementation
entrepreneurs throughout organizations. site visits, expert lectures, assignments), will be the key factor for whether or not
»» Encourage your client to share and enables an organization to build upon its successful change occurs. This is what OD
spread successful examples of other expertise rather than become continuously folks are good at! Help clients drive metrics
organizations going green. dependant on expertise from outside the and create conversational spaces so that the
»» Create facilitated conversations about system. It makes plain business sense to organization is collaborating from within.
case studies grow the capacity of the organization when Use OD interventions where necessary to

10 OD PRACTITIONER  Vol. 40 No. 2  2008


Bauback Yeganeh, PhD, is
President of B.Y. Consulting. He
has focused on individual and
continue helping the organization toward References
its goals. Like most OD endeavors, this organizational flourishing in
will look different in every system that is Drucker, P.F. (1984). The new meaning The Americas, Europe and Asia
attempting change. Some client systems of corporate social responsibility. with clients including the United
will need more leadership coaching while California Management Review, 26, Nations, the World Bank, United
others may need more teambuilding. 53-63. Way, and leading private sector
As a rule, communicate, communicate, Glavas, A., & Piderit, S.K. (2008). How
organizations. In addition to
communicate internally! does doing good matter: Corporate
citizenship behaviors and their writing and consulting, Bauback
Document and Share the Changes consequences within businesses. currently lectures at American
We are all pioneers of this work! Document Manuscript submitted for publication. University (AU/NTL). He received
what you learn and help others by sharing Gunther, M. (2007, April 2). Green is good. his PhD in organizational behavior
both experiences of success and failure. Fortune, 155, pp. 42-50. from Case Western Reserve
This may occur through conversations, McKinsey. (2006, January).The McKinsey
University where he consulted to
presentations, and publishing. global survey of business executives:
Business and society [Electronic global inquiry communities at The
Conclusion version]. McKinsey Quarterly. Center for Business as an Agent
Worley, C. G. (2002). Is OD Still Relevant? of World Benefit and researched
There is one more point we would like to Consulting Today. mindfulness and experiential
make in closing. We have seen Green OD Worley, C., and A. McKloskey. (in learning. Bauback received his MS
serve the parallel purpose of reinvigorating press). “A Positive Vision of OD’s
in organization development from
the hearts of OD folks and reenergizing Future,” in M. Brazzel and B. Jones
their commitment to OD work. This effect (eds.) Understanding the Essence of AU/NTL. He is an NTL Member,
is going to increase exponentially in the Organization Development (New York: guitarist, and music producer.
years to come. We don’t know about you, Wiley). Bauback can be reached at
but we do not get particularly excited about by@byconsulting.org.
work that solely increases profit margins
for businesses; the notion of increasing Ante Glavas, MA, is the Executive
profit margins by helping the society and Director of The Center for Business
environment is far more compelling. The as an Agent of World Benefit. He is
world is rapidly changing and as a result
also an organizational consultant
so is the field of OD. By developing Green
OD we are helping organizations commit who has worked with nearly 100
to real changes that unite corporate and companies around the world.
Earthly flourishing. Ante’s prior accomplishments
include leading the development
of a graduate business school in
Croatia, establishing a leadership
institute, and creating and
presiding over an organic food
company. His numerous awards
for contributions to society
include the Medal of Honor from
the President of Croatia. Ante is
in the dissertation phase of his
Ph.D. in organizational behavior at
Case Western Reserve University,
where he also lectures. He can be
reached at ante.glavas@case.edu.

Copyright © 2008 by the Organization Development Network, Inc. All rights reserved.

Green Organization Development 11

You might also like