Bef

oreHonDi
rect
orofTownPl
anni
ng

Mahar
asht
raSt
ate,
Pune

Appealu/
s47ofMRTPAct1966
AppealNo

1)MrRav
iki
ranVasantGor
e
Fl
atNo2,
BldgNo1
Radhey
aHer
it
ageCHS,
Pal
aspe,
Tal
.Panv
el
Di
stRai
gad410206

2)Mr
.RameshNamdeoDeor
ukhakar
407,
Bwi
ng,
Shakunt
alaPar
adi
se
LodhaHeav
en,
Dombi
vl
iEast
Tal
Kal
yan,
DistThane421204 .
..
..
..Appel
l
ant
s

Ver
sus

1)TheCommi
ssi
oner
,
Panv
elMuni
cipal
Cor
por
ati
on,
Panv
el,
DistRai
gad410206

2)TheAsstDi
rect
orofTownPl
anni
ng,
Panv
elMuni
cipal
Cor
por
ati
on,
Panv
el,
Dist
.Rai
gad410206 .
..
.Respondent
s

Theappel
l
ant
smosthumbl
ymaket
heappel
l
ateaut
hor
it
ynot
ice

asf
oll
ows-

1
1)Thi
sappeali
sbei
ngpr
esent
edbef
oret
heappel
l
ateaut
hor
it
y

asperpr
ovi
sionsofsect
ion47oft
heMRTPAct1966

2)Theappeali
spr
otest
ingamendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
e

i
ssued by t
he r
espndent
s on 20/
04/
2021 wi
th no.

PMC/
TP/
PANVEL/
21/
A/2/
3/21-
21/
13011/
930/
2021

3)Theamendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eisi
ssuedt
oMrSuni
l

D.Waniand MrShar
ad Y.Nagr
e Thr
ough P.
O.A.
H.Sai
nat
h

Ent
erpr
ises,Shopno3,KanakSar
ovar
,NearPr
antOf
fi
cePanv
el

al
l
owi
ngconst
ruct
iononFi
nalPl
otno22/
3(Or
igi
nalPl
otno

21/
A/2/
3)atPanv
el

4)The const
ruct
ion on sai
d pl
oti
s compl
eted bef
oret
his

amendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eisi
ssuedont
hebasi
sof

pr
evi
ouscommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eissuedbyPanv
elMuni
ci
pal

Cor
por
ati
on.

5)I
tist
o be not
ed t
hatt
he bui
l
derhas done i
l
legaland

unaut
hor
ized const
ruct
ion f
ar bef
ore t
he amended

commencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eisi
ssued v
iol
ati
ng t
he t
erms and

condi
ti
onsi
npr
evi
ouscommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
e

6)TheMuni
cipalCor
por
ati
onhasi
ssuedshow causenot
ices

and not
ices t
o demol
ish t
he i
ll
egalconst
ruct
ion whi
ch ar
e

di
shonor
ed by t
he r
ecei
ver
s of amended commencement

cer
ti
fi
cat
e.

2
7)I
tis al
so t
o be not
iced t
hatt
he concer
ned war
d of
fi
cer
s

i
ntent
ional
l
ydel
ayedandav
oideddemol
i
tionoft
hesai
dil
l
egal

const
ruct
ionoft
hebui
l
der
,wai
ti
ngf
ort
hebui
l
der
stosubmi
t

appl
i
cat
ionf
oramendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
ement
ioned

abov
e.

8)Theamendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eisi
ssuednegl
ect
ing

v
ari
ouscr
imi
nalandci
vi
lcompl
aint
spendi
ngbef
oreHonCour
t

andPol
i
cest
ati
onr
aisi
ngdi
sput
eov
ert
heowner
shi
poft
hel
and

onwhi
cht
heconst
ruct
ioni
sdone.

9)The sai
d amended commencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eisi
ssued

negl
ect
ing t
hef
act
sthatt
hebui
l
derhasal
readyv
iol
ated t
he

pr
ovi
sionsofMRTPactandhascommi
tt
edanof
fencef
orwhi
ch

t
heconst
it
uti
oni
sli
abl
etobedef
inedi
l
legalandunaut
hor
ised.I

t
hisway
,thecor
por
ati
onhast
ri
edt
osav
ethebui
l
derandhi
s

of
fencet
obepuni
shed

10)As t
he sai
d of
fence i
s commi
tt
ed bef
orei
ssuance of

amendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
e,t
hecor
por
ati
onshoul
dnot

i
ssuet
hecer
ti
fi
cat
eascl
ear
lyexpl
ainedi
njudgmentofHon.Hi
gh

cour
tofBombayi
nthemat
terofAsi
anDev
elopmentCor
por
ati
on

VsKav
itaCHSMumbai
andot
her
sin2011

3
11) The cor
por
ati
on has negl
ect
ed t
he f
act t
hat i
f such

cer
ti
fi
cat
es ar
eissued byt
hem t
othe const
ruct
ion whi
ch i
s

al
readyi
ndi
sput
e,i
twi
l
lhar
mthei
nter
estoft
heappel
l
antand

f
urt
herf
utur
ebuy
ersoft
heconst
ruct
ionast
hedi
sput
erel
atedt
o

t
heowner
shi
poft
hel
andi
syett
obesol
vedi
nthecour
t.

I
nthi
ssi
tuat
ion,t
heappel
lant
srequestHonAppel
lat
e

Aut
hor
it
yto-
-

1)Al
l
ow t
heappel
l
ant
stobepr
esentper
sonal
l
ytoexpl
aint
hei
r

concer
nswi
thext
raev
idencesandar
gument
s

2)Or
derst
ayont
heamendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eti
l
lthi
s

appeal
isdi
sposed

3)Or
derdepar
tment
alenqui
ryandr
epor
tfr
om t
hecor
por
ati
on

aboutnegl
i
gencei
ndemol
i
tionoft
hei
l
legalconst
ruct
iont
ofi
nd

outt
he f
act
s and ci
rcumst
ances i
nthi
s mat
terand or
der

demol
i
tionoft
hei
l
legal
const
ruct
ionont
hel
and

4)Cancelt
heamendedcommencementcer
ti
fi
cat
eassoonas

possi
bleasi
t'
svi
olat
ingt
heMRTPActandsav
ingof
fencesoft
he

r
ecei
ver
soft
hecer
ti
fi
cat
e.

4
  Appr
opr
iat
efeeagai
nstt
hisappeali
sdeposi
tedi
nfor
m of

t
hecour
tfeest
ampswi
tht
hisdocument

 Noappeal
ispendi
ngi
nanycour
tofl
awi
nthi
sregar
d.

 Anyf
urt
herexpl
anat
ions/
evi
dences ar
erequest
ed t
o be

al
l
owed t
o submi
tinf
utur
eto pr
ove appel
l
ant
sthei
r

concer
nsanddemands

Si
gnat
ures

Appel
l
ant1

(
MrRav
iki
ranVasantGor
e)

Appel
l
ant2

(
MrRameshNamdeoDeor
ukhakar
)

Dat
e:-

Pl
ace:
-