Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dr. M. Manickaraj
The objective of this chapter is to describe the basic principles to be followed in lending,
to describe the types of borrowers and various loan products and to provide an
introduction to credit policy, credit analysis and credit administration.
Structure
1.1 Principles of Bank Lending
1.2 Types of Borrowers
1.3 Types of Credit Facilities
1.4 Credit Policy
1.5 7 C’s of Credit
1.6 Summary and Conclusion
business banks are regulated most stringently in order to ensure that they do not lose the
public confidence in them.
Lending is a risk taking business and hence banks need to have robust risk management
systems in place to ensure safety for themselves and their depositors.
Liquidity: Maintaining sufficient liquidity is another necessary condition for a bank to
survive. Banks must be able to meet the demand for withdrawal of money by depositors
at all times. Thanks to the technological advancements depositors and borrowers do not
visit bank branches to withdraw money. Rather they use alternative channels like ATMs
for withdrawal of money or internet banking and mobile banking for transfer of money.
As such banks cannot ask any customer to wait to draw money from their account. Hence,
maintaining adequate liquidity by banks is of paramount importance. To ensure liquidity
central banks have made it mandatory for banks to maintain a certain amount of money
deposited with the central bank and some amount invested in very safe and liquid
securities. Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) and Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) are the tools
used by the Reserve Bank of India to ensure liquidity in the banking system. CRR and SLR
demand banks to keep certain percentage of their net demand and time liabilities as cash
reserve with the RBI and as investment in government securities and other approved
securities respectively. Asset Liability Management (ALM) is another mechanism used to
ensure liquidity by managing the mismatch between the maturity profiles of assets and
liabilities.
Profitability: Sustainability of any business would depend largely on surplus (profit) it
can generate and banks are no exception. Though banks service the society and promote
economic development they are expected to generate satisfactory profits in order to
sustain themselves in the long run. They need to price loans and other services such that
they will be able to meet all costs including interest and operating expenses and also will
make profit. Banks in India have to determine rate of interest on loans using their
respective Marginal Cost based Lending Rate (MCLR) which would cover the cost of
funds, operating costs, risk costs and also profit margin.
Recovery of loans with interest as per repayment schedule given to borrowers is another
important function of banks. Basel accords and the regulations by central banks have
elaborate guidelines for determining unexpected losses due to credit default and
allocation of capital for the same.
Purpose of Loan: As discussed earlier banks need to ensure safety of deposits. Besides,
banks play the role of enabling economic development by allocating the capital mobilised
through deposits to various sectors in the economy. Banks hence shall provide credit to
productive activities only and shall not lend money for speculative and non-productive
activities. Productive activities are those that lead to economic development by boosting
demand and therefore production and sales of goods and services to consumers.
Diversification of Risk: While providing credit for productive purposes it is important
for banks to spread the credit portfolio such that the risks are fairly diversified.
Page 2 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Diversification can be achieved by providing credit to many sectors and to large number
of customers in various sections of the society. Exposure norms prescribed by the RBI are
meant for ensuring diversification of risk and to see that the bank credit reaches all
deserving sectors, regions and sections of the society. Another measure taken by the RBI
in this direction is the Priority Sector Lending (PSL) norms. The PSL targets are set by the
RBI to see that all the needy sections of the society are provided with bank credit to
achieve inclusive development.
Principle of Security: It is a practice of banks to lend as far as possible against security.
The security is considered as insurance or a cushion to fall back upon in case of need. At
the same time, it provides for an unexpected change in circumstances which may affect
the borrower’s repayment capacity. However, the security and its adequacy alone
should not be the sole consideration for judging the credit worthiness.
Page 3 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
that. Bankers must carefully scrutinise the Power of Attorney and seek clear
instructions from principal where needed.
• Joint Borrowers: Two or more persons or a group of individuals who do not
constitute a registered body or association can be treated as joint borrowers.
Banks must obtain the signature of all the joint borrowers on loan documents or
the signature of the attorney if power of attorney had been given to any one of the
joint borrowers. As the joint borrowers are individuals joining to do an act they
are individually liable and their liability is unlimited.
• Hindu Undivided Family: HUF is composed of all the members of the family and
the male member of the family who gets the right by birth in the ancestral property
of the family is called the Kartha. Male major members of the HUF are called as
Coparceners. Kartha has the authority to borrow and coparceners’ liability for the
loan is limited to the extent of their share in the property. However, if they join the
contract with Kartha or ratify the contract entered by Kartha, they become
personally liable for the loan.
• Proprietary Firms: Business concerns owned by one individuals are called
proprietary forms. Liability of the sole proprietor (owner) business is unlimited
and hence in case of loans given to proprietary firms lenders will have recourse
not only against the assets employed in business but also against the private assets
of the proprietor. For taxation and legal purpose the owner and the business are
one and the same. The proprietor is not taxed as a separate entity.
• Partnership Firms: Partnership is a relationship that exists between persons in
a business in common with a view to profit. The conditions to be met for
entertaining a partnership firm by banks are as follows:
o Association of two or more persons
o Agreement between partners
o There must be a business
o Sharing of profit by partners
o Business must be carried out either by all or by any of the partners of the
firm
o Though partnership firm need not be registered, from bankers’ point of
view it is needed.
o The Partners of the partnership firm will be personally and severally liable
for the liability incurred by the firm.
• Limited Company: Company incorporated under and regulated by the
Companies Act. A company is a legal person and has perpetual entity. The nature
and the status of a company, its objectives, right to borrow in its name, etc. can be
Page 4 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
• Limited Liability Partnerships (LLP): LLPs are new set of business firms
established under the Limited Liability Partnership Act 2008. LLP is a corporate
business vehicle that enables professional expertise and entrepreneurial initiative
to combine and operate in a flexible, innovative and efficient manner. It also
provides the benefits of limited liability while allowing its members the flexibility
for organizing their internal structure as a partnership.
• Term loans – Loans for a specified period of time and should be repaid within the
specified period. These loans are offered generally for creating fixed assets that
would be used for producing goods and services.
• Bridge loan: Offered for a short period of time until the borrower is able raise
permanent finance. It is also referred to as interim financing, gap financing or
swing loans.
• Working capital loan: Working capital loan is meant for financing day to day
operations of a business firm. It is used for purchase of raw material, payment of
wages and salaries, electricity bill, etc. It is required because business firms in
order to fill the gap in the cash flow of a firm between purchases of raw material
till the time cash is collected from customers. Working capital loan is not meant
for investing nor for purchase of fixed assets. To many banks working capital loans
is the largest source of income. The following are the commonly offered working
capital loan products:
o Cash Credit – also referred to as line of credit or overdraft.
o Working capital demand loan (WCDL) – It is a short term loan. It can be
used by customers for meeting seasonal working capital requirements.
Page 5 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 6 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 7 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
• Character: The first and most important factor that will determine a borrower’s
repayment capacity is the integrity of the borrower. If a borrower is of decent
character and is a person of repute for his honesty and integrity then the
probability of the borrower defaulting on repayment of loans will be lower.
• Cash flow: The customer or his business should generate adequate profit and cash
flow to service the loans. If the business is incurring losses for a prolonged period
then repayment of loan would not be possible.
• Capital: While lending institutions may provide loans the borrowers should bring
in their share of capital. It is generally referred to as margin money for loan or
equity margin. Capital will indicate several things. It will ensure the commitment
of the borrower in the business and also will act as a cushion to absorb losses of
the business. If adequate capital is there then the risk of providing loans will be
less.
• Collateral: Security for loan is also important. As a last resort the lenders can
recover loans by disposing of security provided by the borrowers for loans. The
value of security will depend on enforceability and realisable value. Therefore, due
care must be taken while accepting any asset as security for loans. Guarantees of
individual persons and business entities too are considered as security for loans.
1.6 Summary and conclusion
Banks and financial institutions play a pivotal role in development of economies through
provision of loans for various productive sectors and activities. They offer variety of loan
products to different customer segments. The customer segments can broadly be divided
into three – individuals, business firms and agriculture farmers. The loan products
offered can be classified into term loans and working capital loans. Non-fund credit
Page 8 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
facilities too are offered to business borrowers. Credit policy is the document that will
provide direction and guidance for providing credit. Credit can be offered to any
customer only after careful evaluation of his/her repayment capacity. 7 C’s of credit that
capture all the factors that will determine a borrower’s repayment capacity should be
studied before sanctioning loans.
Page 9 of 9
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dr. M. Manickaraj
The objectives of this chapter is to highlight the importance of due diligence and to
discuss the various issues to be studied diligently before lending decisions are taken.
Structure
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Due diligence for retail loans
2.3 e-KYC
2.4 Due Diligence on Corporate Borrowers
2.4.1 Basic documents
2.4.2 RBI Wilful Defaulters List and ECGC’s Special Approval List
2.4.3 Material Contracts
2.4.4 Patents, copyrights and trademarks
2.4.5 Manufacturing
2.4.6 Sales and Marketing
2.4.7 Employees
2.4.8 Management
2.4.9 Financial due diligence
2.4.10 Legal due diligence
2.4.11 Environmental due diligence
2.5 Outsourcing Due Diligence
Page 1 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
2.1 Introduction
According to the Cambridge Dictionary, due diligence means “the detailed examination of
a company and its financial records, done before becoming involved in a business
arrangement with it”.
(Source: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/due-diligence)
One major requisite for making right credit decisions is to use reliable information. If the
data used for lending decisions are incorrect or incomplete the likelihood of loan
decisions going wrong will be high. Lending institutions collect all relevant data about
prospective borrowers from variety of sources. The main source of data is always the
customers while other sources of data include credit information bureaus, rating
agencies, government, peers, industry reports and so on. However, the onus of
verification and validation of data rests with the lender. Therefore, verification and
validation of data is very critical for successful lending business.
Due diligence is the first major step in credit analysis. It is an investigation of a borrower
in order to verify and confirm all facts. It involves collection, verification and validation
of information like identity and address of prospective borrowers, financials, legal
matters and anything that are deemed essential for making lending decisions. It can also
be defined as the care to be taken before lending money. The rigor and complexity with
which due diligence to be done depends on the nature of customers and amount of loan
involved. As such, due diligence on retail borrowers and agriculture borrowers will be
simple. On the other hand, due diligence on corporate customers will be complex.
2.2 Due Diligence for Retail Loans
Information to be collected about retail borrowers are mainly regarding identity, address,
occupation, and the like. The popular term used in this regard is the KYC (Know Your
Customer). Documents to establish KYC details include Aadhar Card, PAN card, telephone
bill, electricity bill, family ration card, salary slip, IT returns, and bank statement. Aadhar
card and PAN card are used for verification of identity whereas electricity bill, and
telephone bill are used for verification of address. Documents like salary slip, IT returns
and bank statement are used for checking the customer’s source of income, and
repayment capacity. Credit history of prospective customers can be obtained from credit
information companies like CIBIL and Experian. The credit information companies do
provide complete credit report and also a score which can readily be used for deciding
on giving or not giving loans to customers. Besides, list of wilful defaulters published by
the Reserve Bank of India too can be referred to find out if a prospective customer has
defaulted to any lending institution in the past.
Recently many banks and lending institutions have started verification of basic details
about prospective customers online. It is referred to as e-KYC. For instance, by using the
Aadhar number of a customer, details regarding identity, address and the like are verified
online and there is no need for physical documents to be obtained from customers. Of
late, Aadhar number is being used as a common thread for many other item of
Page 2 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
information like PAN number, bank account, mobile phone, etc. Likewise, financial profile
and social profile of customers can also be done electronically. Credit history of
customers too can be verified online by referring to the credit reports prepared by credit
information companies like CIBIL and Experian.
Page 3 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
2.4.2 RBI Wilful Defaulters List and ECGC’s Special Approval List:
Wilful defaulters list published by the RBI to find out if the company or its directors have
defaulted on payment of loans to banks or lending institutions. Export Credit Gurantee
Corporation of India (ECGC) publishes a list referred to as ECGC’s Specific Approval List.
The list gives the names of exporters whose risk is high. Both these lists shall
compulsorily be checked.
• Credit agreements with banks and lending institutions and details of loans
outstanding
• Schedule of all insurance policies in force covering property of the Company and
other insurance policies such as ''key person'' policies, director indemnification
policies or product liability policies.
• List of all foreign and domestic patents and patents held by the Company.
• List of trademarks, service marks and copyrights.
• Copies of all agreements for licensing of Company technology to third parties.
Page 4 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 5 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
o Fixed assets
o Working capital
Quality of earnings & cash flows: Quality of earnings and cash flows of a company will
depend on the following:
- Seasonality in sales.
- Dependency on customers/suppliers. Higher the dependency lower the
profitability will be and vice versa.
- Assessing the impact of customers gained / lost on the bottom line. Ancillaries, for
example, will be impacted significantly if they lose just one customer.
- Trend in margins including rate of growth and sustainability
- Impact of changing costs on margins. This will depend on the company’s ability to
pass through the costs.
- Impact of exchange rate fluctuations. The impact will be substantial for those firms
involved in exports or imports. It is also relevant for those firms using substantial
amount of capital from abroad or if it has made substantial investments abroad.
- Consistency in application of accounting methods. Frequent changes in accounting
methods can be considered as an indication of trouble in the company.
- Revenue recognition. Recognition of income in advance is very common and this
will lead to inflation of profitability. There are some firms which may delay the
recognition of income for the purpose of income smoothing.
Page 6 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
- Nonrecurring items. Firms playing with non-recurring items too are quite
common. One common practice is to sell idle and non-core assets and investments
in order to book profit. This is normally done during periods when a firm’s
profitability might have been too low.
- Cash flows from operations – stability and certainty
Quality of fixed assets: The following details may be verified to ascertain the quality
of fixed assets:
- List of property owned by the Company.
- Documents of title, mortgages, deeds of trust and security agreements pertaining
to the properties.
- All outstanding leases for property to which the Company is either a lessor or
lessee.
- Documents showing significant acquisitions or dispositions of assets.
- Historical capex - growth and maintenance capex. Growth capex will result in
capacity addition; whereas maintenance capex will help maintain the operating
capacity and efficiency of assets.
- Capital work in progress. Capital works in progress are those capital projects
which have not been completed and will need more capital for them to be
completed. Whether the company has already tied up capital for the purpose or
not should be ascertained.
- Depreciation policy
- Capitalization of costs like R&D expenses and other costs, if any
- Capacity constraints to attain projections. Loan amount and repayment capacity
are decided based on projected financials. However, if there are capacity
constraints and hence the projected sales cannot be achieved the projections
should be revised suitably.
- Assets used but not owned; owned but not used. This is especially true for those
companies which have sister concerns sharing common facilities.
Quality of current assets: The value of current assets may depend on the following:
- Seasonality and impact on financing considerations.
- Quality of inventory. One should check if there are slow moving and non-moving
inventory, obsolete items, and perishable items in inventory.
- Quality of receivables and inventories.
o Receivables outstanding over six months
Page 7 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
business were in place. Therefore, banks must verify the impact of projects and
operations on the environment and the society. No objection certificate from the
Pollution Control Board, clearance from department of forestry, report on environment
impact analysis, and the like as may be necessary need to be obtained by companies
before commencing businesses. Specifically, the following may be verified:
• List of chemicals, toxic substances or air contaminants which are regulated by law
and present in any facility of the Company.
• All instances in the past in which the Company has corrected unsafe working
conditions.
• Details of all the facilities of the Company that discharge liquid or solid waste into
any body of water, stream or any sanitation systems.
The market also has independent agencies, either government bodies or private bodies,
which hold repository of information, like Google, Probe42, Zuba Corp, e-KYC, C-KYC,
NESL, RBI defaulters’ List, RBI Caution List, ECGC Caution list, CERSAI, CRILIC,
MCA21(ROC). The future due diligence will lie with Block Chain Technology.
2.6 Summary and Conclusion
Due diligence is a first major step in credit analysis. If due diligence is not carried out
properly loan decisions more likely to go wrong. Therefore, all the lending institutions
Page 9 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
are supposed to carry out due diligence on prospective customers before deciding on
giving loan to them. Due diligence on small customers like retail b-borrowers, agriculture
farmers, micro enterprises will be simple and easy. Whereas, due diligence on corporate
customers demands many documents and information and hence is very complex.
However, corporate customers need huge loans and hence due diligence on them need to
be carried out more stringently. Due diligence on corporate customers involve collection
of documents and data from many sources, due diligence regarding material contracts,
patents, copyrights and trademarks, manufacturing facilities, sales and marketing
arrangements, employees, management, financials, legal issues, and environmental
issues. Given the importance and complexity it is advisable for the banks and other
lending institutions to have checklist for due diligence on different type of customers.
Page 10 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dr. M. Manickaraj
Objectives
The objective of this chapter is to analyze the financial statements using various tools.
Structure
3.1 Why financial statement analysis?
3.2 Tools for financial statement analysis
3.2.1 Common-size statements
3.2.2 Trend analysis
3.2.3 Ratio analysis
3.3 Ratios important for lending decisions
3.4 Conclusion
economies, government policy, political and social conditions, nature, etc. Internal
factors, on the other hand, may include management, human resource, financial
condition, marketing capabilities, technology and so on. The impact of all these factors
will influence business operations and will reflect in the financial statements of the firm.
Moreover, the effect of all actions and inactions of the management and their efficiency
or inefficiency too will be reflected in financial statements. Therefore, financial
statements are an indispensable source of information and hence analysing the same is a
must for managerial decisions, investment decisions and also for lending decisions.
Lenders are generally keen on ascertaining the funding requirements and repayment
capacity of a borrowing firm. Both can be ascertained from the financial statements of the
borrower.
V -Non-Current Assets
III- Current Liabilities v Investment
v Short Term borrowing-Working v Other non-current assets
capital
v Sundry Creditors VI - Current Assets
v Provisions v Cash & Bank Balance
v Installment of TL v Stock
v Other short term Liabilities v Trade Receivables
v Loans & Advances –short
term
VII-Intangible Assets
v Goodwill
v Patent
v Copyright
v Trade Marks
v Preliminary Expenses not
written off
Contingent Liabilities:- These are shown below the balance sheet and are
called off-balance sheet items.
Liabilities in I & II are Long term in nature and items under III, Current Liabilities are
short term in nature. Current liabilities are obligations that are due within the next
one year from the date of balance sheet.
Similarly in the Assets side, IV are long term in nature. Items in V are not immediately
convertible as cash and VII –Intangible assets are non-physical in nature. However,
preliminary expenses not written off are not assets at all. Any expenses not-written off
will appear on the asset side of the balance sheet and these are fictitious in nature.
Current assets are assets which are expected to be converted to cash within the next
one year.
in the two wheeler industry in India. The balance sheet of both the companies for the
financial years 2014-15 and 2015-16 are presented in Annexure 1 and the P&L account
of these two companies are presented in Annexure 2.
Table 1: Common-Size Profit and Loss Accounts of Bajaj Auto Ltd and
TVS Motor Co Ltd
Page 4 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Due to higher costs TVS Motor’s net profit margin was substantially lower at 3.8%
compared to 16.1% of Bajaj Auto.
Common-size balance sheet is a statement where all the assets and liabilities of a
company are expressed as percentage to total assets of the company. Total assets,
therefore, will always be shown as 100. Table 2 presents the common-size balance sheets
of TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto. It shows the share of various assets and liabilities in total
assets of the two companies. The inferences that emerge from the analysis of the table
are as follows:
· Net worth of Bajaj Auto is very high at 78.4% of its total assets against TVS Motor’s
net worth of 38.1%. It indicates the fact that Bajaj Auto uses mostly equity capital
Page 5 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 6 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
If such a statement is prepared for many years the trend in incomes and expenses will be
clearer. The table provides the following information:
· Bajaj Auto’s sales in 2015-16 was 105.0% of 2014-15 sales indicating 5% growth
in sales (105 - 100) during the year 2015-16. TVS Motor’s sales have grown by 12
percent during the same year.
· Raw material cost of TVS Motor has increased by 10 percent only compared to 1.3
percent for Bajaj Auto during 2015-16.
· Cost of power and fuel of Bajaj Auto has declined by 3.3% and that of TVS Motor
has increased by 5.2%
· Other manufacturing expenses of Bajaj Auto has grown at a higher rate of 9.3%
compared to TVS Motor’s 8.5%
· General and administration expenses and also selling and distribution expenses of
TVS Motor have grown at a higher rate than that of Bajaj Auto.
Interest expense of TVS has grown at a very high rate of 64.2%. Whereas, Bajaj Auto’s
interest expense declined sharply by 92.6%.
Balance sheet shows many non-recurring items like capital, long term borrowings, fixed
assets, investments and the like. Therefore, analysing the trend in balance sheet items
would not provide any meaningful information.
Common-size statements and trend statements enable comparison of financial
performance of business firms and they are also highly useful for preparing projected
financial statements.
3.2.3 Ratio Analysis
Ratio is a fraction and the result of one number or quantity divided by another number
or quantity respectively. Financial ratios are the simplest mathematical tools that reveal
relationships hidden in mass of data, and allow making meaningful comparisons.
Page 8 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Financial ratios are the most widely used tool for financial statements analysis. Various
ratios under the following headings are discussed in this chapter:
· Profitability ratios
· Turnover/Efficiency ratios
· Leverage/Solvency ratios
· Liquidity ratios
· Holding periods
· Operating cycle
· Equity ratios
Ratios are expressed in several ways. Some ratios are expressed as numbers, some in
number of days and some as percentages. Profitability ratios are expressed in percentage,
turnover ratios, liquidity ratios and few equity ratios are expressed in numbers. Leverage
ratios are expressed in proportion, and holding periods like inventory period, receivables
period, operating cycle and the like are expressed in number of days or in months.
Profitability Ratios
Profitability of a firm can be analysed from two points of view – (1) profit per every rupee
of income; and (2) return on investment. The former set of ratios including gross profit
margin, cash profit margin, operating profit margin and net profit margin are referred to
as profit margin ratios. The latter including return on total assets, return on capital
Page 9 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
employed and return on equity are ratios which show the profit earned on investment.
The later three ratios show the profitability from three different points of view. Return
on total assets is the profit on total investment made in the firm (including owners’ funds
and outsiders’ funds), return on capital employed is the profitability on total long-term
capital employed and return on equity is the profit made on equity investment.
The profitability ratios are classified under the three heads, namely, profit margins,
return on investment and coverage ratios.
Gross Profit
Gross Profit Margin = ´ 100 ........................ (1)
Net Sales
EBITDA
Cash Profit Margin = ´ 100 ........................ (2)
Net Sales
EBIT
Operating Profit Margin = ´ 100 ...................... (3)
Net Sales
Profit After Tax
Net Profit Margin = ´ 100........................ (4)
Net Sales
EBIT
Return on Assets = ´ 100 .......... .......... ... (5)
Average Total Assets
EBIT
Return on Capital Employed = ´ 100 .......... ...... (6)
Average Long Term Capital Employed
Profit After Tax
Return on Equity = ´ 100 .......... .......... ... (7)
Average Tangible Net Worth
Profitability ratios are expressed in percentage and the results for the two companies,
TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto, for the year 2015-16 are shown in Table 4. The results show
that Bajaj Auto’s performance is much better than TVS Motor on all the parameters.
Return on equity (ROE) of Bajaj Auto, for instance is 31.80 percent compared to TVS
Motor’s24.10 percent.
Page 10 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Table 4: Profitability Ratios of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
It may be noted that ROE is calculated based on the profit after tax which includes non-
operating incomes and gains as well as non-operating expenses and losses. Such non-
operating items like gain or loss on sale of assets and investments cannot be expected to
happen every year. Other income/expenses and exceptional income/expenses are the
two non-operating items in the profit and loss account of the two companies (Annexure
2). Therefore, such items shall be ignored while calculating ROE. The ROE excluding non-
operating items also has been calculated for both the companies and the same too have
been presented in Table 4. The table shows that the ROE adjusted for non-operating
items is lower than unadjusted ROE for both TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto.
Turnover Ratios
Turnover ratios measure how efficiently the assets have been turned over into sales.
Some of the turnover ratios used for analysis are total assets turnover ratio, fixed assets
turnover ratio and current assets turnover ratio. In all the three ratios net revenue from
operations (net sales) is the numerator. Every business firm uses various types of assets
to produce goods or services and then to sell them to customers. However, business firms
can differ in their efficiency in utilising their assets to generate income (i.e. sales). Higher
the turnover ratio, higher is the efficiency of the firm. Formulae for the three different
turnover ratios are:
Page 11 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Net Sales
Total Assets Turnover = .......................... (9)
Average Total Assets
Net Sales
Fixed Assets Turnover = .........................(10)
Average Fixed Assets
Net Sales
Current Assets Turnover = ..............(11)
Average Total Current Assets
Turnover ratios of TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto for the year 2015-16 are shown in Table 5.
Total assets turnover ratio of TVS Motor is 2.4 which is greater than Bajaj Auto’s ratio of
1.5. One has to note here that total assets of a firm include all assets used in its operations
and also investments made outside the business. Bajaj Auto has substantial investment
(Rs. 9512.66 crore) as can be seen in Annexure 1.Investments made in subsidiaries and
marketable securities do not contribute to sales and therefore, total assets turnover ratio
may not be comparable. Fixed assets turnover ratio, hence, is a better indicator of
efficiency and is comparable across firms. However, two other factors which would make
the turnover ratios (both total assets turnover and fixed assets turnover) not comparable
is the level of outsourcing and vertical integration. If one firm produces most of its
requirements in-house and another procures mostly from outside, the ratios of the two
firms cannot be compared.
Table 5 shows that Bajaj Auto is more efficient than TVS Motor in terms of both fixed
assets turnover and current assets turnover.
Table 5: Turnover Ratios of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
The above equation captures operating profit margin as well as the efficiency with which
the assets have been utilised. Therefore, return on investment ratios are more
informative and important than profit margins.
Page 12 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Leverage Ratios
Two most widely used leverage ratios are Debt-to-Equity ratio and Total Outside
Liabilities to-Equity ratio (TOL/TNW)1. Both the ratios take tangible net worth (TNW) in
the denominator. The difference between the two ratios is the numerator. While the
former takes long-term debt in the numerator the later uses total outside liabilities in the
numerator. Both the ratios show the relationship between owners’ funds and outsider’s
funds. Higher the ratio higher the leverage indicating greater dependence on outsiders’
funds. Therefore, in times of distress the creditors will not be able to recover their dues
fully from the sale of the firm’s assets. Besides, the interest on borrowings is a fixed cost
and is payable irrespective of the amount of profit earned. Therefore, during years when
a business firm has made very low profit or loss it will not be able to service debt. Use of
borrowings thus increases the risk of business firms. The risk arising due to use of debt
funds is called the financial risk. If owner’s funds are large the risk will be less. Between
the two ratios TOL/TNW is more important because it takes all the liabilities of a firm
into account.
................................ (12)
Long Term Borrowings
Debt to Equity Ratio =
TNW
(Long Term Debt + Short Term Debt)
Total Debt to Equity Ratio = ..................................(13)
TNW
TOL
Total Outside Liabilitie s to Equity Ratio = ................................ (14)
TNW
The results of the three ratios of our sample companies are given in Table 6. The ratios
show clearly that TVS Motor is using more long-term debt/outsiders’ funds than Bajaj
Auto. Nevertheless, the leverage in both the companies is very less and hence their
solvency position is good.
Table 6: Leverage Ratios of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
1
TOL is nothing but total assets minus net worth.
Page 13 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
from out of his operating profit. The later ratio indicates the borrower’s ability to pay
interest and loan instalments from out of his operating profit.
Three different methods are given hereunder for finding out interest cover and three
methods are given for DSCR. According to the author, equations 15 and 18 are the
prudent ones for determining interest coverage and DSCR respectively. Accordingly the
ratios given in Table 7 have been calculated.
EBIT - Tax
Interest Cover = .......... .......... .......... ......... (15 )
Interest
( or )
EBITDA - Tax
Interest Cover = .......... .......... .......... .........( 16 )
Interest
(or )
EBITDA- Tax
DSCR= ..................(18)
Interest+ CurrentPortionof LongTermDebt
(Or)
(Or)
PAT+ Depreciati
on + Intereston TermLoans
DSCR= ................(20)
Intereston TermLoans+ CurrentPortionof LongTermDebt
The interest cover ratio of TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto are given in Table 7. The
interpretations of the results in the table are as follows:
· The ratio of Bajaj Auto is very high at 5707.5 because of very small amount of
borrowings used by the company and hence the interest burden. Besides, the
company’s profitability is very high compared to TVS Motor.
· Interest cover ratio of TVS Motor, on the other hand, is 8.90.
· Though the ratio for TVS Motor is very low compared to Bajaj Auto the ability of
the company to service its loans is more than adequate.
· Similarly, DSCR of Bajaj Auto is very high at 6247.8 compared to TVS Motor’s 3.20.
Page 14 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
· It may be noted that though the coverage ratios of TVS Motor is substantially lower
than that of Bajaj Auto it can comfortably service its loans. For instance, the DSCR
of TVS Motor reveals the fact that the company’s profit is 3.2 times the amount of
interest and principal of loan repayable during the year.
Table 7: Coverage Ratios of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
Liquidity Ratios
Another aspect different stakeholders in a business would be interested in is liquidity.
Three commonly used liquidity ratios are current ratio, quick ratio, and cash ratio2. The
ratios measure the ability of a firm to meet its current obligations (current liabilities)
from its current assets. While current ratio relates current assets to current liabilities the
quick ratio relates quick assets (current assets excluding inventory) to current liabilities.
Current assets are those which can be converted into cash within a period of one year and
current liabilities are obligations to be settled within one year. Amongst the various
current assets inventory cannot easily be converted into cash during times of distress and
hence it is not considered as a quick asset. To elaborate, if a business firm faces severe
crisis and could not run its business its ability to sell its inventory will be difficult. If at all
it can sell, it can do so at a substantially low price. On the other hand, sundry debtors,
another major current asset for any business firm, can be realised into cash quite easily
because the customers who have bought goods have to necessarily pay for it.
Current Assets
Current Ratio = .......... .......... ....... (21)
Current Liabilitie s
Current Assets - Inventory
Quick Ratio = .......... ........(2 2)
Current Liabilitie s
Cash and Bank Balance
Cash Ratio = .......... .......... ......(23)
Current Liabilitie s
Current ratio of TVS Motor is 0.97 (Table 8) compared to Bajaj Auto’s ratio of 1.33. The
ratio indicates clearly that Bajaj Auto has higher liquidity Than TVS Motor. The cash ratio
of Bajaj Auto (0.29) too is significantly greater than TVS Motor’s (0.01). All the three ratios
thus show that the liquidity position of Bajaj Auto is significantly higher than TVS Motor.
2
Current assets and current liabilities used for these ratios are current assets and loans and advances and
current liabilities and provisions respectively.
Page 15 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Liquidity ratios should be interpreted from two different points of views. One is liquidity
and another important aspect is efficiency. Universally, business firms are working hard
to improve their working capital management such that they can run the business with
minimum amount of current assets. Just-in-time (JIT) is one approach to achieve this.
These two companies could probably be using all possible techniques including JIT to
minimise the level of their current assets.
Current ratio is also believed to show the proportion of current assets being funded by
equity capital. It is referred to as margin for working capital by banks and other lending
institutions. This is a wrong notion. Current ratio shows how much of the current assets
is funded by long term sources of finance and not by equity capital alone.
Note: It may be noted that the original balance sheets of both the companies have
reported the figures as per the revised format given in Schedule VI of Companies Act.
Under the revised format current investments will be shown under current assets.
Whereas, under the old format investments were being reported separately and as a
single item. Similarly, current maturities of long-term loans are shown under current
liabilities under the new format which was not the case earlier. Current ratio and quick
ratio of TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto have been calculated excluding investments from
current assets and current maturities of long-term loans from current liabilities.
Moreover, total provisions including noncurrent and current, total trade creditors
including noncurrent and current have been treated as current liabilities and total loans
and advances including noncurrent and current have been treated as current assets.
Table 8: Liquidity Ratios of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
Holding Periods
Another set of financial ratios one would be interested in is the holding period of current
assets and current liabilities. The holding periods which are important especially for the
lending institutions are inventory period, receivables period and payables period
(creditors period).
Inventory period is the time taken by a company to sell the finished goods from the date
of purchase of raw material. It can be broken down into (1) raw material holding period;
(2) work-in-process holding period and (3) finished goods holding period. Raw material
Page 16 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
holding period shows the material in stock is equivalent to how many days consumption.
Work-in-process inventory period is the time taken by a company to convert raw material
into finished goods and the finished goods inventory period is the time taken to sell the
finished goods from the date of completion of production.
Receivable period is the credit period offered by the company to its customers. It may
also be referred to as the collection period or the time taken for collecting money from
customers. Creditors period, on the other hand, is the time taken by the company to pay
the suppliers. Creditor period is also referred to as payable period.
The length of these holding periods will vary due to nature of business and efficiency of
working capital management. For instance, a firm manufacturing heavy machinery will
have a longer manufacturing cycle and hence the work-in-process inventory period. For
a food processing unit, on the other hand, the manufacturing cycle will be very short and
hence the work-in-process inventory holding period too will be short. Receivables
holding period would depend on the bargaining power of a company with its customers
and creditors period on the other hand would depend on the company’s bargaining
power with its suppliers. Therefore, while financing working capital the acceptable level
of inventory and receivables should be determined based on nature of business amongst
others.
The equations for calculating various holding periods are as follows:
Average Inventory
Inventory Period = ......................................... (24)
Cost of Goods Sold/365
Average Receivables
Receivables Period = ..................................................................(28)
Sales/365
The holding periods for TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto for the year 2015-16 are presented in
Table 9. The table provides the following facts:
· The holding periods of Bajaj Auto is significantly shorter than TVS Motor’s.
Page 17 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
· Inventory period of Bajaj Auto is just 16 days compared to TVS Motor’s inventory
period of 31 days.
· Similarly, the receivable period of TVS Motor too is longer than that of Bajaj Auto.
· TVS Motor’s creditor period is 69 days compared to Bajaj Auto’s 46 days revealing
the fact that TVS Motor takes substantially longer time to pay its suppliers.
It may be noted that longer current assets holding periods will lead to higher capital
requirement. If only TVS Motor can reduce its inventory holding period and receivables
period it will result in substantial release of capital locked up in these two items. This
will definitely help in minimising the interest cost, insurance cost, storage cost, and the
like and will help improve its profits.
Table 9: Holding Periods of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
Operating Cycle
Holding periods that make up the operating cycle and cash cycle are mainly the ones
indicating the holding periods of different current assets and current liabilities. Holding
periods for the purpose of finding out the length of operating cycle can be calculated by
using sales as the common denominator as in equations 30, 31, and 32. Operating cycle
of a typical business firm will start with the purchase of raw material and end with
collection of cash from its customers. To elaborate, the operating cycle will start with
purchase of raw material, conversion of raw material into finished goods, sale of finished
goods and finally collecting cash from customers. The time period between purchase of
raw material and sale of finished goods is nothing but the inventory period and the time
period between sale of finished goods and collection of cash is the receivable period.
Operating cycle, therefore, is the sum of inventory period and receivable period.
Page 18 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Average Inventory
Inventory Period = ............................................ (30)
Net Sales/365
............................................ (31)
Average Receivable
Receivable Period =
Net Sales/365
............................................ (32)
Average Trade Creditors
Creditors Period =
Net Sales/365
Operating Cycle = Inventory Period + Receivable Period ............................................ (33)
Net Operating Cycle = Operating Cycle - Creditors Period ............................................ (34)
Longer operating cycle may be due to inefficiency in operations and hence every firm
would strive for reducing the length of operating cycle. A part of the operating cycle is
financed by suppliers of raw material and other services and the remaining part of the
operating cycle can be called as the net operating cycle or as cash cycle. It may also be
referred to as cash-to-cash cycle.
The results shown in Table 10 show that Bajaj Auto’s operating cycle is of 24 days and
TVS Motor’s operating cycle is 44 days. However, both the companies are availing credit
from their suppliers for a period longer than their operating cycle and hence they do not
need working capital. The net operating cycle of the two companies hence are negative.
Table 10: Operating Cycle of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
Equity Ratios
In addition to the ratios discussed in the previous sections various stake holders are also
interested in calculating and analysing equity ratios. The key equity ratios which are
commonly used are as follows:
Earnings per share (EPS) = Profit after tax / Number of shares outstanding…………..
(32)
Page 19 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dividend per share (DPS) = Total dividends paid in a year / Number of shares
outstanding…(33)
Pay-out ratio = DPS / EPS
……………………………………………………………………………. (34)
Retention ratio = 1 – Pay-out ratio
………………………………………………………………. (35)
Book value per share = Tangible net worth / Number of shares outstanding
.………….. (36)
PE Ratio = Current Market Price of Equity Shares/ EPS
…………………………………….. (37)
PB Ratio = Current Market Price of Equity Shares / Book value per share
……………. (38)
Caution is required while interpreting ratios which are expressed as value per share. EPS,
DPS and book value per share should not be compared with other companies. In fact,
these three are not ratios. Rather, they are absolute values per share. Moreover, they are
not only influenced by the performance of the companies but also by face value of shares,
bonus issues, and stock splits. Supposing, if a company goes for splitting its shares from
say Rs. 10 per share to Rs.5 per share it will result in a sudden fall in the values of these
ratios by 50 percent because the number of shares will become double but the amount of
capital will remain the same. Bonus issue will also have the same effect. Moreover, the
book value of shares will also be influenced by the age of a firm. Longer the existence of
a company larger could be the amount of reserves and surpluses and hence the book
value. Contrarily, for a new company the book value will be less though the performance
of the company in terms of profitability and other parameters might be comparable.
The equity ratios of TVS Motor and Bajaj Auto have been calculated and the results are
presented in Table 11. EPS, DPS and book value of Bajaj Auto is much larger than TVS
Motor. This is due to better performance of Bajaj Auto and also might be due to the above
mentioned factors.
Pay out and retention of profit are determined by factors like growth potential and
requirement of capital for tapping the potential. If a firm has great potential to grow then
the need for ploughing back the profits will be very high. Such companies and those
companies in emerging sectors will pay out very less of their profits as dividends to their
shareholders. Therefore, the pay-out ratio of such companies will be very less and
retention rate will be very high. These two ratios will also be decided by the dividend
policies of the companies. Table 11 shows that TVS Motor has paid out 27 percent of its
profits earned during 2015-16 as dividends and balance is retained. Bajaj Auto, on the
other hand, has paid out 44 percent of profits as dividends and only 56 percent is
retained.
Page 20 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
PE and PB ratios are comparable and are very widely used by the investors for valuation
and other purposes. Normally, companies whose earnings grow at very high rates will
have very high PE ratio and high PB ratio. The results shown in Table 11reveal that equity
shares of Bajaj Auto are trading at 21.1 times its earnings and 6.3 times its book value.
Whereas, TVS Motor’s shares are trading at 31.6 times its earnings and 7.1 times its book
value. The shares of TVS Motor thus are trading at a higher level. This could be because
the investors expect the performance of the company to be better in the future.
Table 11: Equity Ratios of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Ltd
3.4 Conclusion
Financial statement analysis is critically important for various managerial, investment
and lending decisions. While different tools help in making various decisions common-
size statements and trend statements will be more relevant while preparing projected
financial statements. Ratios are useful for variety of purposes including for projecting
financial statements.
Business firms though may be in the same line of business they may differ in their level
of forward and backward integration, etc. Besides, business firms are able to reduce the
level of assets while maintaining their level of activities and hence the standards for
various financial parameters are becoming irrelevant. For instance, adopting techniques
like JIT level of inventory can be reduced to bare minimum. Similarly, by arranging
Page 21 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
finance for customers receivables period can be reduced. Therefore, one should be very
cautious in interpreting the ratios especially when comparing ratios of one firm with
another.
Annexure 1
Balance Sheet of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Limited
Bajaj Auto Ltd TVS Motor Company Ltd
Mar-16 Mar-15 Mar-16 Mar-15
Share capital (A) 289.37 289.37 47.51 47.51
Reserves (B) 12002.29 10402.78 1889.29 1597.85
Net Worth (C = A+B) 12291.66 10692.15 1936.80 1645.36
Long-term borrowings (D)@ 162.48 112.35 638.10 564.38
Other long-term liabilities (E ) 29.78 57.59 175.67 152.75
Deferred tax liability (F) 188.25 141.58 0.00 0.00
Current Liabilities and Provisions:
(G = H+I+J+K) 3000.59 4558.65 2212.00 2242.16
Short-term borrowings (H) 0.00 0.25 264.23 399.76
Trade creditors (I) 2027.04 1760.53 1543.71 1478.50
Other current liabilities (J) 604.53 805.86 305.60 215.14
Provisions (K) 369.02 1992.01 98.46 148.76
Total Capital and Liabilities
(C+D+E+F+G) 15672.76 15562.32 4962.57 4604.65
Net Fixed Assets (L) 2025.67 1917.24 1592.85 1329.63
Capital work-in progress (M) 52.24 254.94 30.96 89.36
Investments (N) 9512.66 9153.32 1184.57 1012.46
Other non-current assets (O) 94.28 67.23 0.00 0.00
Current Assets & Loans and
Advances: (P) 3987.91 4169.59 2154.19 2173.20
Inventory (Q = R+S+T) 719.07 814.15 825.97 819.68
- Raw material (R ) 433.90 456.28 631.62 563.95
- Work-in-process (S) 42.61 28.65 63.55 48.71
- Finished goods (T) 242.56 329.22 130.80 234.02
Receivables (U) 717.93 716.96 578.69 503.86
Cash and bank balance (V) 859.52 586.15 32.84 5.39
Loans and advances (W) 722.56 543.67 318.75 561.07
Other current assets (X) 968.83 1508.66 397.94 283.20
Total Assets (L+M+N+O+P) 15672.76 15562.32 4962.57 4604.65
Page 22 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Annexure 2
Profit and Loss Account of Bajaj Auto Ltd and TVS Motor Company Limited
Case Exercise
Given below are the balance sheet and profit and loss account of Venus Ltd and do the
following based on the same. Calculate the ratios of the company and fill-in the blank cells
in Table 1
Balance Sheet of Venus Ltd (All figures are in INR Crore)
2015-16 2014-15
Share capital 296.5 296.5
Reserves 43612.06 33761.37
Net Worth 43908.6 34057.9
Long-term borrowings 26172.91 24530.07
Other long-term liabilities 1197.53 202.59
Current Liabilities and Provisions: 24700.2 19743.9
Short-term borrowings 16275.44 13128.72
Trade creditors 3421.19 2878.81
Other current liabilities 4915.08 2754.75
Provisions 88.52 981.59
Total Capital and Liabilities 95979.2 78534.4
Net Fixed Assets 30679.05 22125.86
Capital work-in progress 13567.15 17422.16
Investments 32461.19 26464.57
Other non-current assets 182.24 5.37
Current assets & Loans and advances: 19089.6 12516.4
Inventory 5026.14 5442.07
Receivables 1429.12 1157.69
Cash and bank balance 642.56 464.14
Loans and advances 11119.98 4500.52
Other current assets 871.8 952.02
Total assets 95979.2 78534.4
Profit and Loss Statement of Venus Ltd (All figures are in INR Crore)
2015-16 2014-15
Net sales 29810.62 32502.41
Raw material cost 18339.8 20105.77
Employee cost 603.53 650.13
Power and fuel 4541.65 4534.41
Other Manufacturing Expenses 1235.56 1099.99
Depreciation 1217.97 1011.67
General and Administration
911.23 925
Expenses
Selling and Distribution Expenses 268.02 236.04
Miscellaneous Expenses 5.01 322.43
Total operating cost 27122.77 28885.44
EBIT 2687.85 3616.97
Interest 3541.36 3655.93
PBT and extraordinary items -853.51 -38.96
Other income/expenses 8823.82 2008.86
Exceptional income/expenses -2490.41 -2.43
PBT 5479.9 1967.47
Tax 8.02 40.27
PAT 5471.88 1927.2
Dividend 1037.75 1215.65
Page 25 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 26 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dr.Dipali Krishnakumar
Objectives
Structure
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Cash from operating activities
1.2 Cash from investing activities
1.3 Cash from financing activities
2.0 Preparing cash flow statements
2.1 Cash flow statement
2.1.1 Cash flow from operating activities
2.1.1.1 Direct method
2.1.1.2 Indirect method
2.1.2 Cash flow from investing activities
2.1.3 Cash flow from financing activities
2.1.4 Regulatory Requirements
2.1.5 Practice Solved Problems
1.0 Introduction
If an analyst would like answers to questions such as:
How much cash did the business generate?
Does the business have the ability to repay loans?
How much cash has been paid out as dividend to shareholders?
How did the business finance its investments, is it from internal operations or did
it need to borrow external funds?
Page 1 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
The answers would be available /presented in a statement called the cash flow statement.
The cash flow statement provides reconciliation of how cash balance at the beginning of
the year changed due to different activities – operating activities, investment activities
and financing activities to arrive at the cash balance at the end of the year. The term cash
for the purpose of this statement includes cash, bank balances and short term highly
liquid instruments that are typically classified under cash and cash equivalents.
Profit and loss account and balance sheet are prepared under accrual method. Therefore,
actual cash available can be different from profit shown in P&L account. It should be
noted that a poor or declining profitability need not result in weak cash flow. Similarly,
increasing sales and profitability need not result in strong cash flow and liquidity.
Therefore, there is a need to know the sources and uses of cash as also the liquidity
position and health of a firm.
Let us use an example of a small grocery store business that we assume has been
incorporated as a company to understand the three categories of cash flows.
Page 2 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
₹ ₹
Sales 180,000
Expenses
Cost of Goods sold 100,000
Salaries and utilities 30,000
Rent 10,000
Total Expenses 150,000
Profit Before Tax 30,000
Tax Expense 6000
Net Profit 24,000
Page 3 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Indirect method. The statement starts with the “Profit Before Tax” which is then adjusted
for items of expense and income included in the Profit or Loss figure which were non cash
in nature. For example if the sales figure included credit sales, then an adjustment to the
extent of credit sales would be required. We will work out such examples later. However,
in our simplified scenario 1, there are no credit transactions so the Profit and Loss figure
would be the same as cash generated from operations. The format of the statement using
the indirect method would be as follows
Page 4 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
The indirect method is more commonly found in published reports, though both methods
are permitted by accounting standards. The Indian Accounting standards converged with
IFRS recommends the use of the direct method, but does not make the direct method
compulsory. We will discuss the accounting standards for cash flow statements in a
subsequent section.
2.1.2 Cash Flows from Investing Activities
In our example, the business has not purchased any fixed assets nor has it invested its
surplus funds. What would be the cash flow from investing activities? There would be nil
cash flows from investing activities
Page 5 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
We have prepared the Cash Flow Statement for the first year of the business.
As the business expands operations, there is a requirement to give and take credit,
increase the stock held, buy additional equipment etc. Following transactions take place
in year 2.
Stock of grocery worth ₹ 500,000 was purchased and some credit was provided
by the supplier, as a result ₹ 50,000 was outstanding to the creditor at year end.
The sales for the year were ₹ 700,000. Credit was provided to select customers.
Total outstanding from customers at the end of the year was ₹ 80,000.
At the end of the year stock of grocery items worth ₹ 30,000 remain with the
business.
Page 6 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Salaries and other expenses such as telephone, electricity etc. were₹ 70,000.
However, some bills which have been accounted in the expenses are yet to be paid
out at the end of the year. Hence the business has made a provision of ₹ 10,000
for outstanding expenses at the end of the year.
The business continued to operate out of a furnished rental place for which a rent
of ₹ 5000 per month is payable. However, the landlord has requested for rent to
be paid in advance for each month. Hence, as of the end of the year, an amount of
₹ 5000 which pertains to rent for the next year has been paid as advance.
A refrigerator is purchased for ₹ 50,000 and payment made by cheque.
Depreciation at the rate of 10% is to be provided for the full year on the
refrigerator.
Tax rate is 20% and paid out.
A dividend of ₹ 7,600 was paid to owners.
Let us prepare a profit and loss statement for the firm.
Profit & Loss Statement:
Note ₹ ₹.
Sales 1 7,00,000
Expenses
Cost of Goods sold
Opening Stock - 0
2 4,70,000
Purchases - 500,000
Less closing stock - 30,000
Salaries and utilities 3 70,000
Rent 4 60,000
Total Expenses 6,00,000
Depreciation 5 5000
Profit Before Tax 95,000
Tax 19000
Net Profit 6 76,000
Dividend to shareholders 7,600
Retained earnings 68,400
Notes:
1. All expenses and income are on accrual basis and not cash basis. So entire sales is
shown as income, irrespective of actual receipts.
Page 7 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
2. We need to determine the actual stock of goods used to generate the sales figure
for the year, hence the adjustment of stock is required. The stock remaining at the
end of the year would be utilized for future sales.
3. The amount of expense that pertains to the current year is charged irrespective of
the actual pay out.
4. The rent for the year is ₹ 5000 * 12. The additional ₹ 5000 paid in advance is for
next year’s rent and cannot he charged in this year’s profit & loss statement.
5. Depreciation is computed at 10% on ₹ 50,000 for the refrigerator. This is a
notional expense, no money is actually paid out.
6. Refrigerator purchased is not a revenue item, hence will not feature in the Profit
and loss statement.
What would be the cash generated by operations?
It could be
1. Same as Net Profit
2. Different from Net Profit
Here, the right answer would be option 2. This is because there were credit
transactions in both receipts and payments resulting in a difference in the amount
shown as income and expenditure and the actual cash that was exchanged.
Direct method
For preparing the cash flows from operations using the direct method. Every item of
income and expense is examined and only the actual cash received or paid is listed.
Thus, while the business generated a profit or Rs 76,000. The cash generated from
operations is only ₹ 26,000.
Page 8 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Indirect Method
The value of cash from operations using the indirect method should give the same
answer. In this case we start with the Profit before Tax and make adjustments for
items that are not paid out or received in cash.
Notes :
1. Depreciation is a notional expense and no cash is paid out hence we need
to adjust it.
2. The full purchase amount of ₹ 500,000 is recorded in profit and loss
statement, however cash of ₹ 50,000 is not yet paid out to suppliers.
3. Salary and utilities charged but not yet paid out in cash are ₹ 10,000
4. The sales figures of ₹ 700,000 includes a value of ₹ 80,000 that is
receivable from customers.
5. Rent charged to profit and loss is ₹ 60,000. However and additional ₹ 5000
has been paid to the landlord.
6. Stock lying in the grocery at year end.
7. Income tax is the actual pay out.
The cash flows from operations using either the direct or indirect method should be
equal.
Page 9 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 10 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Putting all the three statements together and adding the opening balance we should
get the following statement
Cash Flow Statement
Cash flows from Operating Activities ₹ ₹
Profit Before Tax 95000
Adjustments:
Add: Depreciation provided 5000
Add : payable to creditors 50000
Add: payable for expenses 10000
Less : outstanding from customers 80000
Less Rent advance paid to landlord 5000
Less : stock on hand at the end of the year 30000
Income Tax paid 19000
Net Cash from Operating Activities 26000
Note: The cash flow from operations, has been to be substituted by table as per indirect
method in page 10.
Page 11 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
We can tie up these figures with the Balance Sheet1. The Cash and cash equivalents as per
the Balance Sheet matches with the figure in the Cash Flow Statement.
Current Liabilities
Trade Creditors 50,000
Provision for Expenses 10,000
Total 3,52,400
₹
Assets
Fixed Assets 45,000
Current Assets
Stock 30,000
Trade Receivables 80,000
Rent Advance 5,000
Cash and Cash equivalents 1,92,400
Total 3,52,400
The cash flows have been generated using a summary of all the transactions that took
place during the year. In most circumstances the analyst would not have all the detailed
transactions, but would be presented with a Balance sheet and Profit & Loss statement.
She would be required to prepare a cash flow statement using these two statements. The
next examples covers such a scenario where only the final Balance Sheet and Profit &Loss
statements are provided to the analyst.
2.14 Regulatory Requirements
Prior to Companies Act 2013, a cash flow statement was mandatory only for listed
entities. But, as per Companies Act 2013 all companies including unlisted and private
1
Note: Detailed instructions for preparing the Balance Sheet are not included in this chapter,
as this is not the intent of this chapter.
Page 12 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
companies are required to prepare a cash flow statement. An exemption has been
provided to one person companies, small companies and dormant companies2.
Accounting standard IND AS 7 specifies the requirements for preparation and disclosure
of cash flow statements. Cash comprises cash on hand, demand deposits. Cash
equivalents are short-term, (typically 3 months or lesser) highly liquid investments that
are readily convertible to known amounts of cash and which are subject to insignificant
risk of changes in value.
IND AS 7 encourages entities to prepare cash flows using the direct method as this
provides useful information which could be used to estimate future cash flows.
An issue that may come up in the preparation of cash flows is the treatment of bank
overdrafts. A clarification is provided in IND AS7 - Bank borrowings are generally
considered to be financing activities. However, where bank overdrafts which are
repayable on demand form an integral part of an entity's cash management, bank
overdrafts are included as a component of cash and cash equivalents. A characteristic of
such banking arrangements is that the bank balance often fluctuates from being positive
to overdrawn.
2
One Person Company means a company which has only one person as a member;
Small company means a company, other than a public company,—
(i) paid-up share capital of which does not exceed fifty lakh rupees or such higher amount as may be prescribed
which shall not be more than five crore rupees; or
(ii) turnover of which as per its last profit and loss account does not exceed two crore rupees or such higher amount
as may be prescribed which shall not be more than twenty crore rupees:
Provided that nothing in this clause shall apply to—
(A) a holding company or a subsidiary company;
(B) a company registered under section 8; or
(C) a company or body corporate governed by any special Act
Dormant Company - Where a company is formed and registered under this Act for a future project or to hold an asset or
intellectual property and has no significant accounting transaction, such a company or an inactive company may make an
application to the Registrar in such manner as may be prescribed for obtaining the status of a dormant company.
Page 13 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
₹ ₹
Sales 5,60,000
Cost of goods sold (including depreciation on 3,85,000
equipment Rs60,000)
Gross Profit 175,000
Operating Expenses 170,000
Office and administrative expenses 55,000
Amortization of goodwill 25,000 250,000
Net Profit/ Loss (75,000)
Page 14 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Solution:
We prepare the cash flows from operations using the indirect method. As discussed in the
previous section we start with the profit before tax and make adjustments for non-cash
items or items that were charged to Profit & loss but are not routine operating activities
of the business.
3
Cash flows from operations have been generated using the indirect method. The same final value of operating
cash flows would be obtained using the indirect method.
Page 15 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Notes
1 Profit before tax is the same as net profit. No tax has been charged as the business
is making losses.
2 Depreciation and amortization are not cash expenses
3 Changes in current assets and current liabilities are grouped under working
capital to give a sense of how the business is managing its working capital
4 An increase in amount due from debtors is a cash outflow
5 Cash has been used to purchase stock as the stock has increased
6 Rent advance paid by the business has gone down, thus cash has been released
7 The amount due to creditors has reduced, so the business had paid out₹ 30,000
additional cash to creditors during the year
8 There is an increase in bills payable, the business has spent this amount less on
paying bills, thus an inflow for the business
9 Increase in payables for wages, thus that much cash has not been paid out yet
10 Every item in the Balance Sheet is to be checked for changes to see if there could
be any items that could impact cash. For example, Net value of equipment has
decreased from 600,000 to 440,000. The case mentions that depreciation is ₹
60,000. No other changes had taken place in equipment. The value of equipment
in 2011 should be ₹ 600000 less ₹ 60,000 =₹ 5,40,000. However the actual value
of equipment is ₹ 4,40,000. In the absence of any other information, we assume
that₹100,000 worth equipment is sold at cost. In case additional data had been
provided we would adjust accordingly.
11 Reconciling the Reserves and Surplus figure
Opening Balance 125000
Profit and Loss for the year - 75,000
Closing balance 50,000
This tallies with the closing balance in 2011. Hence, there is no other adjustment
for cash.
12 Loan balance is unchanged at ₹ 2,45,000, thus no additional loans have been
taken
13 Equity capital is unchanged at ₹ 600,000, thus no additional funding from
shareholders.
Page 16 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
14 This ties up with the cash balance as of yearend 2011 which was the purpose of
the exercise.
Let’s try to answer the following questions
a) How has the business sustained itself without loans?
b) Do you see any concern areas that it could improve?
Discussion: - Cash flows from operations are negative₹ 55,000. The primary funding has
come through sale of equipment. This is not a sustainable strategy. The business needs to
relook at its operations to make the business more profitable and generate adequate cash.
Even if an immediate turnaround in profitability is not possible, it would be able to make
positive operating cash flows if it is able to manage its working capital better. The
business has increased the funds tied up with debtors (₹ 25000) and stock (₹ 20,000).
At the same time creditors have offered reduced amount of credit (₹ 30,000) to the
business. All these are not very positive signs for the business.
Learning Nugget
We have seen that profits do not necessarily represent cash generated by the business. This is
because financial statements are prepared using an accrual method of accounting. Sales typically
include both cash and credit sales. However, only cash sales generate cash while credit sales
may take some time to convert into cash. Similarly, expenses include both cash and credit
expenses. There are some items of expense that do not involve a cash outflow, e.g. depreciation
and amortization. Some expenses charged to Profit or loss may pertain to financing and not
operations for e.g. interest expenses are typically classified under cash flows from financing.
Page 17 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Problem 2
Classify the following transactions into operating, investing and financing activities.
Commenced business with Cash deposited in Bank
Purchased goods on Credit from Niharika for ₹ 200,000
Borrowed ₹ 10,00,000 from Bank
Paid office rent ₹ 10,000
Sold goods for ₹ 100,000 in cash and ₹ . 2,50,000 on credit to Avanti
Received commission from Abhishek ₹ 20,000
Paid dividends ₹ 25,000
Paid Salary to Staff ₹ . 6000 in Cash
Paid an instalment of ₹ 20,000 to the bank towards loan instalment, ₹ 8000 of the
repayment was towards interest component.
Paid Telephone and electricity bill
Purchased Computers for ₹ . 100,000 by cheque
Received an advance of ₹ 20,000 for goods to be dispatched in Feb
Paid an MSEB deposit of ₹ 10,000
Invested surplus cash in equity
Solution
Transaction Classification
Commenced business with Cash deposited in Bank Financing
Purchased goods on Credit from Niharika for ₹ 200,000 Operating
Borrowed ₹ 10,00,000 from Bank Financing
Paid office rent ₹ 10,000 Operating
Sold goods for ₹ 100,000 in cash and ₹ . 2,50,000 on credit to Avanti Operating
Received commission from Abhishek ₹ 20,000 Operating
Paid dividends ₹ 25,000 Financing
Paid Salary to Staff ₹ . 6000 in Cash Operating
Paid an instalment of ₹ 20,000 to the bank towards loan instalment, ₹ Financing
8000 of the repayment was towards interest component.
Paid Telephone and electricity bill Operating
Page 18 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Problem 3
ABC & Co. Ltd disclosed that during the year 2010 it had sold equipment for ₹ 15000. The
equipment had been purchased for₹ 65,000 and had a book value of ₹ 12,000.
Following details are available in the closing balance sheets
Page 19 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
2016
(in 000’₹ )
Operating profit 131.93
Plus: Depreciation 37.50
Less: Tax paid -0.34
Changes in Current Assets and Current Liabilities:
Inventory 64.45
Receivable 13.94
Advance, deposits and prepayments -49.56
Trade creditors -23.52
Other liabilities 0.58
Cash flow from operating activities (A) 174.98
Purchase of fixed assets -23.01
Other income 39.06
Cash flow from investing activities (B) 16.05
Change in capital 0.34
Change in term loans -58.32
Change in short-term borrowings -78.06
Interest paid -104.13
Dividend paid -10.26
Cash flow from financing activities (C) -250.43
Net Cash Flow (A+B+C) -59.40
Opening balance of cash 301.45
Closing balance of cash 242.05
Page 20 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Following additional data is available for the firm for the year 2014
Sales =₹ 3,845,000
Total Assets = ₹ 1,55,000
Long Term Debt Outstanding at the end of the year ₹ 120,000
We can note from the above that the firm has positive cash flows from operations. There
has been a reduction in inventory to the tune of ₹ 64,000.This could be caused by better
management of inventory, but on the other hand could indicate a slowing down of
operations which could be a matter of concern. The firm has invested ₹ 23,000 for
expanding operations and has recorded an inflow of ₹ 39,000 from investing activities.
The firm has repaid borrowings and interest to the tune of ₹ 240,000. These repayments
have been funded from a small surplus from investment activities but primarily from
operating cash flows which is a positive sign.
We now review some ratios that are used for the analysis of cash flow statement
Cash Flow from Operations/Sales
Indicates ability to generate CFs from sales. Higher ratio is better. Change in ratio
indicates changes in credit policy and business conditions.
Cash Flow from Operations/Total assets
Ability to generate cash from assets or the asset utilization.
Cash Flow from Operations / Interest
Cash flow interest cover ratio. Indicates the firm’s ability to repay interest from
operating cash flows
Cash Flow from Operations / (Interest + current portion of long term debt)
Cash Flow Debt service coverage ratio. The firm’s ability to repay interest and long
term debt.
Total long term debt / Cash Flow from Operations
Indicates the number of years it would take to repay the principal portion of the
long term debt if the operating cash flows were to remain constant.
Cash Flow from Operations – Essential Capex
Free Cash Flow. Signals firm’s ability to repay debt, pay dividends, and facilitate
growth of business.Free CF of more than 10% of sales may be considered good
Page 21 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
All the above ratios indicate a robust cash position for the firm. . The firm has the ability
to repay interest from operating cash flows. The firm has had to dip into other sources of
funds from investing activities to repay the debt as the DSCR has fallen below 1at 0.73.
However, the firm is likely to be debt free within the next year as the long term debt pay-
out ratio is below 1, provided it does not take on additional debt during the next year.
Page 22 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
2016-17
(in 000’₹ )
Profit after tax 13.30
Plus: Depreciation 1.90
Plus: Interest 8.60
Plus: Bank charges 2.70
Less: Other income -2.60
Less: Deferred tax paid -0.10
Change in Current Assets:
Inventory 12.30
Sundry Debtors -62.20
Loans and Advances -11.60
Change in Current Liabilities
Creditors for purchases 27.00
Other creditors 9.50
Provisions 0.80
Cash flow from Operating Activities (A) -0.40
Fixed assets -1.40
Investments 3.10
Other income 2.60
Cash Flow from Investing Activities (B) 4.30
Capital -19.30
Term loans 1.70
Cash credit 32.60
Interest -8.60
Bank charges -2.70
Cash Flow from Financing Activities (C) 3.70
Net Cash Flow (A+B+C) 7.60
Opening balance of cash 8.40
Closing balance of cash 16.00
Page 23 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
While, the profits for the year are positive, the picture is completely reversed when we
review the cash flow statement. We find that the firm has negative cash flows from
operations. Additional credit has been extended to Debtors to the tune of ₹ 62,200
indicating a deteriorating collections. The shortfall in operating cash flows and interest
pay outs have been financed by way of cash credit facilities. Despite the poor financial
condition of the firm, the equity investors have withdrawn ₹ 19,300 funds from the
business. All the computed ratios show a bleak picture and raise a question on the
continuity of the business.
Page 24 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Self-Study Problem
Examine the cash flow statement of Larsen & Toubro provided in the Table 1and answer
the following questions.
1. What are the factors that have led to the company generating negative cash flow
from operations in the year 2015-16?
2. How has the business funded the shortfall in cash from operation?
3. Comment on the cash flow statement for Larsen & Toubro.
Table 1: Cash Flow Statement of Larsen & Toubro Limited
Page 25 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
References:
Indian Accounting Standard (Ind AS) 7 Statement of Cash Flows
Page 26 of 26
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dr. M. Manickaraj
Objectives
The objective of this chapter is to provide a foundation for appraisal of business
projects and to explain how to decide on term loans for projects.
Structure
5.1 Introduction
5.2 Types of Projects
5.3 Appraisal of Projects
5.3.1 Technical
5.3.2 Commercial
5.3.3 Management
5.3.4 Legal
5.3.5 Environmental
5.3.6 Financial
5.4 Viability and repayment capacity
5.5 Determining repayment Schedule
5.6 Sensitivity analysis
5.7 Scenario analysis
5.8 Summary and conclusion
5.1 Introduction
Business firms normally need two different types of credit facilities – term loan and
working capital loan. While working capital is used for financing day to day operations of
the business, term loans are used for financing projects. Term loans are used to purchase
fixed assets such as machinery used in production of goods. Fixed assets will have a
certain useful life and hence the term loan provided for purchasing and setting up assets
Page 1 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
should be recovered fully before the end of their life. As such, the main character of term
loan is that it will have a specified repayment schedule.
5.2 Types of Projects
Business projects can broadly be classified into industrial and infrastructure projects.
Though both types of projects have common characteristics, infrastructure projects are
large in size and more complex in nature and require specially trained professionals to
deal with them. Projects can also be classified into the following types:
New Business Projects– This involves starting a new firm along with setting up
new manufacturing and other facilities. Assessing risk of such firms could be
very difficult because of lack of track record, lack of credit history and probably
the promoters are new to the business and the like.
Green Field Projects: These are new projects entered into by existing firms such
as setting up a new factory, plant for a new line of business, or a new location.
Brown Field Projects: These are additional investments made on existing
operations such as for expansion/modernisation of existing facilities or
replacement of existing assets with new ones.
Among the abovementioned three types of projects new business projects are the most
risky followed by green field projects and brown field projects are the least risky.
5.3 Appraisal of Projects
Project appraisal is the process of assessing projects before term loans are sanctioned.
Appraisal of projects is intended to fulfil the following three objectives:
Choosing projects objectively and consistently. Banks and financial
institutions are huge organisations where thousands of employees handle the
business of lending. Moreover, there are layers in the organisational structure
of banks. There will be officers at different layers of the organisation involved
in making loan decisions. In order to communicate among all the officers
involved in the decision making process there is a need for doing the credit
appraisal in a structured manner so that everyone involved in the process will
be on the same page.
Creating documentation to meet financial and regulatory requirements.
Another important objective of project appraisal is to create a record of all the
facts and findings so that it can be referred to by anyone and anytime in the
future.
Laying foundation for lending decisions. The most important reason for doing
credit appraisal of projects is to enable decision making on loan proposals.
Project appraisal usually covers the following six areas:
Technical
Commercial
Page 2 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Management
Legal
Environmental
Financial
Page 3 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
operations, number of shifts of operation and so on. While assessing a term loan
it has to be kept in mind that the capacity of the project is selected keeping in mind
the total outlay from the promoter and the desired level of output envisaged
depending on the market. Installation of over capacity would increase the cost of
capital. Similarly there should be optimal utilisation of the installed capacity.
Underutilisation may reduce profitability.
- Implementation schedule: The length of time needed for completion of the
proposed project including milestones and timeline must be studied. The schedule
should be feasible such that it shall not be too ambitious that it cannot be
completed within the scheduled time nor it will take too long a time. While the
implementation schedule is important for the promoters it is also important for
the banks providing loan for the project for determining the loan release schedule.
When a Project Loan is given, Banks monitor the progress of the project with
reference to the implementation schedule. The Date of Commencement of
Commercial operations (DCCO) is of importance to the Banker since delay in DCCO
beyond the RBI permitted period can render the Loan as an NPA.
- Availability of inputs: Availability and accessibility to inputs including raw
material, energy, water, and human resource are critical for running projects.
They may also affect profitability.
- Quality of input/output: Quality of inputs will determine the quality of output.
Therefore, if a certain quality product is planned to be produced the choice of
input should be chosen accordingly. Tie ups for procurement of inputs of desired
quality may have to be made beforehand.
5.3.2 Commercial Appraisal
Commercial feasibility is highly critical for success of any business. The factors that would
determine the commercial feasibility include the following:
- The Industry outlook, whether the industry is a sun rise industry / sun set
industry and the prospects of the product proposed to be manufactured. The
degree of health or sickness prevalent in the industry to be scrutinised.
- Market size: Number of potential consumers, expected quantity of consumption
and frequency of consumption will determine the size of the market. Larger the
size of the market better would be the prospects for a company.
- Demand-Supply Gap: This is a critical factor that will determine the profitability
of business firms. Positive demand-supply gap (demand is greater than supply) is
an indicator of growth potential and also will enable the companies to enjoy higher
bargaining power. Players in a sector with positive demand-supply gap will
generally enjoy higher profitability.
- Competition: Nature and intensity of competition are the two other factors that
will determine the success of firms. If competition is cut throat all players are
Page 4 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
likely to suffer losses or very low profitability. The price assumed by the Borrower
should be realistic and in tune with the market.
- Substitution: If the product can be easily substituted the risk of failure will be high.
Apart from the above three factors arrangements for marketing the product and
necessary logistics are also necessary for making a project commercially successful.
5.3.3 Management Appraisal
Appraisal of management should consider three major elements including the promoters,
the management and the executive team.
Promoters are the owners of the project who invest money in the project. The promoters’
credentials, experience, competence, and resources should be studied.
Top management (board of directors) of a firm is another element to be analysed as part
of management appraisal. Competency of members on the board of directors should
therefore be assessed.
Executive team is the key persons who will head the various functions like production,
technology, marketing, human resource, and finance. In today’s world business projects
are highly technology and knowledge intensive and hence persons of relevant
competency are supposed to be chosen for the various functions.
For small businesses all the three elements of management may be handled by the same
person or team. In case of large businesses all the three may be made up of different set
of people.
5.3.4 Appraisal of Legal Matters
Legal aspects to be verified before committing funds in a project include regulations
governing the business, approvals from government authorities, viz., Factory licences,
Building approvals from competent authority, PCB approvals, EPR registration, title
deeds etc. Besides, contractual arrangements between the project/company and other
stakeholders like suppliers, customers, contractors, service providers and so on should
also be studied.
5.3.5 Environmental Analysis
Impact of the proposed project on the environment and the society need to be assessed
and one should verify if the project is violating any law governing environment and
society. In case of big projects Environmental Impact Analysis (EIA) is supposed to be
done and clearances from the ministry of environment and forests or state pollution
control board or the national green tribunal as the case may be should be obtained.
Page 5 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
The last and most critical step in project appraisal is the appraisal of the project’s
financials. The various aspects about a project’s financials that need to be carefully
studied are discussed hereunder.
- Project cost: Estimation of project cost will determine the amount of capital
required for the project. Accordingly, project promoters should make necessary
arrangements for raising the required capital. Under estimation as well as
overestimation of project cost are possible. Under estimation of project cost will
lead to not being able to complete the project. It will also result in choosing non-
viable projects for investment. On the other hand, overestimation may lead to
rejection of viable projects. Banks therefore shall check every item in the project
cost estimation thoroughly. Wrong estimation of project cost could also be due to
omission of certain items. Project cost may generally have the following heads:
S No Items
1 Land and Site Development
2 Buildings
3 Plant & Machinery
4 Engineering & Consultancy fees
5 Miscellaneous Fixed Assets viz., Furniture, equipments,
vehicles etc.,
6 Preliminary & pre-operative expenses including interest
during construction (IDC)
7 Provision for contingencies
8 Margin money for working capital
Page 6 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
promoters will have to bring margin as stipulated by the Banks for funding other
assets as well.
- Means of finance and source of equity capital: After checking the project cost
the sources from where capital for the project are planned to be raised should be
examined. While banks may decide on the amount of loan to be provided for the
project they should also check the source of equity capital and the feasibility of
raising equity capital. Net worth of promoters may give an indication about their
ability to bring in the necessary amount of equity capital. If raising capital from
the market is proposed, market conditions should also be studied.
- Break Even Analysis :
- The repayment of the Term Loan is proposed to be made from the profits to be
generated from the project. Hence studying and accepting profitability estimates
and cash flows projected is a crucial role of the Banker.
- For this, it is necessary to estimate the cost of production and projected sales so
as to arrive at the profitability estimates. Therefore, analysing what level of sales
will cover the cost and from where the unit will start making profit becomes
important.
- So it is necessary to ascertain the minimum level of production and sale at which
the unit will run on "no profit no loss" basis. This is known as Break Even Point
(BEP).Bankers are keen that the unit achieves this level at the earliest and
operates well above this level to sustain profitability and ensure repayment.
To calculate the BEP, as a first step, the total cost has to be bifurcated into fixed
and variable items.
Fixed costs refer to those costs which are incurred regardless of the operation
and/or level of activity of the unit e.g., rent, taxes, insurance, depreciation,
maintenance of building, machinery, etc.
The variable costs or marginal costs on the other hand are expenses which vary
directly in proportion to level of activity or sales or production e.g., raw materials,
power & fuel, consumables etc.
𝐹𝑖𝑥𝑒𝑑 𝐶𝑜𝑠𝑡𝑠
𝐵𝐸𝑃 (𝑄𝑢𝑎𝑛𝑡𝑖𝑡𝑦) = (𝑆𝑒𝑙𝑙𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑃𝑟𝑖𝑐𝑒−𝑉𝑎𝑟𝑖𝑎𝑏𝑙𝑒 𝐶𝑜𝑠𝑡 𝑃𝑒𝑟 𝑈𝑛𝑖𝑡
(Or)
𝐹𝑖𝑥𝑒𝑑 𝐶𝑜𝑠𝑡𝑠
𝐵𝐸𝑃 (𝑄𝑢𝑎𝑛𝑡𝑖𝑡𝑦) = 𝐶𝑜𝑛𝑡𝑟𝑖𝑏𝑢𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 𝑃𝑒𝑟 𝑈𝑛𝑖𝑡
- Sale Price per unit – Unit variable cost per unit is also known as contribution
Breakeven point (in value) = BEP in quantity (units) X Selling price per unit
Page 7 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Ramu is an entrepreneur who has put a small tailoring shop in Ranganathan street, for
stitching readymade shirts and selling in bulk to number of established textile shops in
the market. 5 textile shops have agreed to buy 1000 pieces per month at a selling price of
Rs 70. The shop proposes to work for 25 days and on an average each can stitches 40. The
costs per month are as follows :
Page 8 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Projection of cash flows: Cash flows for a project are drawn based on several
assumptions. Assessment of project viability and repayment capacity therefore will
largely depend on how realistic the projection of cash flows. Lenders must question each
and every assumption behind the projections, check if all the relevant items of income
and costs have been taken into account and also verify whether all the items have been
correctly estimated. The following items may be paid closer attention:
Revenue from projects would depend on:
Installed capacity and operating capacity
Capacity utilisation
Seasonality and working days
Operational efficiency
Quantity and quality of output
Selling Price
Omission of cost items: It is possible that some items of costs are taken into account.
Management compensation, selling and distribution expenses, and transportation cost
are the few items which are commonly ignored.
5.4 Viability and Repayment Capacity
The next step after studying the project cost and projected cash flows is to check the
viability and repayment capacity of projects. Viability of projects is tested with the
following:
- Net Present Value (NPV)
- Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
Repayment capacity will be measured by using the Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR)
Page 9 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
5.4.1 NPV: NPV or Net Present Value is present value of future cash flows minus the
project cost. Value of cash flows depends on time and hence time value of money needs
to be taken into consideration. Normally, all the future cash flows will be converted into
present value by discounting the cash flows with a discount rate. Mathematically, NPV
may be expressed as follows:
n
Cash Flowt
NPV Pr oject Cost
t 1 (1 Discount Rate )
t
Where, ‘t’ refers to the relevant year and ‘n’ is the life of the project in years.
Project cash flows are the cash flows available for disbursement to the capital
providers including the lenders and the equity capital providers.
Discount rate is nothing but the cost of capital of the project in question. Cost of
capital is the minimum rate of return expected from the project.
If the NPV is greater than zero one can say that the project is offering higher return than
the discount rate and hence the project is viable. If the NPV is negative then the project is
not viable. In other words, the cash outflows and cash inflows over the entire project
period is discounted at a predetermined rate (which can be cost of capital/weighted
average cost of funds/minimum acceptable rate of return) and the net present value is
derived as a surplus of discounted inflows over discounted outflows. If the NPV is zero
the benefits derived from the project are just sufficient to cover cost of the capital.
5.4.2 IRR: Though NPV can be used to assess the viability of projects its limitation is that
it does not measure the rate of return offered by projects. Moreover, if discount rate is
changed NPV should be calculated using the new discount rate. Internal Rate of Return
or IRR is the rate of return offered by projects. It is the discount rate that will make the
discounted value of project cash flows equal to the project cost. If IRR is used as the
discount rate NPV will be zero. Viability of projects can be determined by comparing the
IRR with the discount rate. If the IRR is greater than the discount rate the project can be
said to be viable.
For the purpose of estimating NPV and IRR cash outflow will generally be the project cost
plus initial working capital requirement. Cash inflow will be calculated as net operating
profit + depreciation + interest on borrowings. Net cash flow is derived as cash inflow
minus cash outflow plus residual value of investments at the terminal year.
Page 10 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
NPV of Project X: In order to find out NPV of the project its cash flows should be
discounted by its cost of capital as in table below. The present value of cash flow in year
1 is calculated as 10/(1+10%). It works out to 9.09.The present value of cash flow in year
2 works out to 9.50 (i.e., 11.5/(1+10%)2 and so on.
NPV of the project = Sum of present value of all cash flows – Project Cost
= 42.3 – 40
= 2.3 million
As the NPV is positive at 2.3 million the project can be termed as viable.
IRR: As the NPV of the Project X is positive one can say that the IRR is greater than its
discount rate. Therefore, one shall discount the cash flows of the project with a higher
discount rate. The present values of the cash flows discounted by 12% are as follows:
Page 11 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
At 12% discount rate the NPV of the project is 0.16. Therefore, one may say that the IRR
of project X is roughly 12%. The exact IRR of the project is 12.16%. It shall be noted that
if IRR should be calculated manually ‘trial and error’ method should be used.
Both NPV and IRR will give the same result. In the above illustration the NPV is positive
and the IRR is greater than the discount rate. The project hence is viable according to both
NPV as well as IRR.
Data required for calculating NPV and IRR are project cost, projected cash flows and
discount rate. The discount rate is also referred to as hurdle rate, minimum required rate
of return, cost of capital, and weighted average cost of capital (WACC). One thumb rule to
be used is higher the risk of a project higher should be discount rate and lower the risk
lower should be the discount rate.
5.4.4 Debt Service Cover Ratio (DSCR)
DSCR indicates the adequacy or otherwise of project cash flows to service term loans. It
can be calculated as follows:
(𝐸𝐵𝐼𝑇𝐷𝐴 − 𝐼𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑡 𝑜𝑛 𝑊𝑜𝑟𝑘𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝐶𝑎𝑝𝑖𝑡𝑎𝑙 − 𝑇𝑎𝑥)
𝐷𝑆𝐶𝑅 =
(𝑇𝑒𝑟𝑚 𝐿𝑜𝑎𝑛 𝐼𝑛𝑠𝑡𝑎𝑙𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡 + 𝐼𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑡 𝑜𝑛 𝑇𝑒𝑟𝑚 𝐿𝑜𝑎𝑛)
Or
Where, EBITDA is the operating profit before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization.
The above equation will be used to find out the DSCR of a project every year. In addition,
Average DSCR should be calculated. It can be calculated using the following equation:
Page 12 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
DSCR of greater than 1 would indicate that the cash flow is sufficient to service the loan
and if it is less than 1 the cash flow is not sufficient to service the loan. Therefore, every
year the DSCR should be greater than 1 and the average DSCR should also be greater than
1.
Generally, yearly DSCR of 1.25 and Average DSCR of 1.75 are considered to be
comfortable.
Illustration of DSCR calculation:
Let us assume that a Term Loan of Rs 50 L is proposed for Project X. The repayment is
proposed to be made in 60 instalments with a moratorium of 6 m in year I. The data on
PAT, Depreciation and interest on Term Loans are as follows:
(Rs in Lacs)
Years I II III IV V VI Total
PAT 3 8 10 15 16 18 70
Depreciation 6 8 8 8 8 8 46
70 + 46 + 27.79
𝐴𝑣𝑒𝑟𝑎𝑔𝑒 𝐷𝑆𝐶𝑅 =
27.79 + 50
In all the years the DSCR is above 1 and the average DSCR is also 1.85 which is very
comfortable. If the DSCR or average DSCR is low, then the ability to service the loan is low.
If DSCR is less than the acceptable norms (stipulated by Banks), the loan repayment
period may be increased, provided the project is otherwise viable.
If the DSCR is high, then the repayment period should be reduced.
Page 13 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 14 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 15 of 15
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dr. M. Manickaraj
Objective
After reading the chapter one will be able to appreciate the importance of working capital
finance, alternative methods for estimating working capital requirement of business
firms and various products for financing working capital.
Structure
6.1 Introduction
6.2 Operating cycle and working capital requirement
6.3 Working capital requirement
6.4 Methods for assessing working capital requirement
6.5 Products for financing working capital
6.6 Summary and conclusion
6.1 Introduction
Historically, providing working capital finance was the main business of commercial
banks. Term loans and project finance were provided by the development finance
institutions (DFIs) also referred to as term lending institutions. Agriculture credit was
provided mainly by cooperative banks and literally no lending institution was providing
retail loans. However, after liberalisation of banking industry commercial banks have
started providing a variety of loans to all types of customers. Nonetheless, working capital
finance remains the major business for many commercial banks.
Term lending institutions and non-banking finance companies (NBFCs) too provide
working capital. However, they do not provide cash credit which is referred to as line of
credit, because in order to operate cash credit there is a need for a current account which
can be offered by commercial banks only. As such working capital loan offered by
institutions other than commercial banks is nothing but term loans for a short period.
Cash credit offered by a bank is always offered as a limit within which the customer can
draw money from the loan account whenever needed and deposit money in the account
whenever money is available. To put it differently, cash credit allows both debit and credit
Page 1 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
into the loan account. On the one hand, this flexibility provides comfort to the customers
and on the other hand, it enables banks to monitor borrower’s operating performance
from the transactions made in the loan accounts.
Working capital loan is offered to finance day to day operations of borrowing companies.
Exit from working capital relationship by banks is very difficult. Exit from working capital
relationship may lead to shutting down operations of the company. It may be possible if
the company is able to raise equity capital or working capital is raised from some other
lender. Thus, cash credit offered by commercial banks in India is not self-liquidating in
nature. Therefore, close monitoring of cash credit becomes extremely important.
Working capital support will be needed as long as business operations continue and
hence if a customer is doing well and pays interest on cash credit regularly the lending
bank can get perpetual business from the customer. Rather, if the business of the
customer grows the customer’s working capital requirement will normally grow and
hence the bank’s loan book will also grow.
6.2 Operating cycle and working capital requirement
As discussed in the previous section, working capital is meant for financing the operating
cycle of borrowers. For a typical manufacturing firm operating cycle is the time lag
between procurement of raw material and collection of cash from its customers. It covers
the time taken for converting raw material into finished goods, sale of finished goods and
collection of cash from customers (Figure 6.1).
From the time raw material is procured and till the time finished products are sold the
company concerned will be holding the material in the form of raw material, work in
process and finished goods. This period may be referred to as inventory period. Time
taken for collecting cash from the customers may be referred as receivable period. The
operating cycle of a manufacturing firm thus is the sum of inventory period and
receivable period. (Chapter on Financial Statements Analysis may be referred to for the
equations for finding out inventory period, receivable period and creditor period).
A part of the operating cycle will be financed by suppliers of raw material and the balance
(operating cycle minus creditor period) is referred to as net operating cycle (Figure 6.2).
Net operating cycle is also referred to as cash cycle or cash to cash cycle. Net operating
cycle is the period for which working capital is needed.
Figure 6.1 : Operating Cycle
Page 2 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Operating cycle and net operating cycle can be written as in Equations 6.1 and 6.2
respectively.
Operating Cycle Inventory Period Receivable Period . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (6.1)
Net Operating Cycle Operating Cycle Creditors Period . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (6.2)
The length of operating cycle determines the working capital requirement. Longer the
operating cycle higher will be the working capital requirement and shorter the operating
cycle lower will be the working capital requirement. As such, it is highly important for
working capital provider to know the operating cycle of his customer. Longer operating
cycle will result in higher levels of inventory and receivables and hence higher working
capital requirement. Therefore, it is prudent for the working capital provider to question
whether the length of the operating cycle of the customer is optimal or not. In fact, shorter
operating cycle means the customer is able to convert the raw material into finished
goods, sell the finished goods and then could collect cash from his customers within a
short period of time. Thus shorter the operating cycle more efficient the operations are
and longer the operating cycle less efficient the operations are. Therefore, the lenders
should be wary of financing a customer whose operating cycle is very long. However, the
following points need to be kept in mind while providing working capital:
• Length of operating cycle varies from sector to sector: Each industry differs from
other industries in terms of the raw material availability, manufacturing process,
customer expectations, nature of product, and so on. Accordingly, the length of
raw material holding, manufacturing cycle and inventory policy will vary.
Similarly, different industries may follow different terms for collecting cash from
customers and similarly different terms for payment to suppliers of raw material.
• Benchmarks need to be set for different sectors specifically: For the reason
explained in the previous point, benchmarks for the holding periods and operating
cycle may be set for each sector specifically.
• The length of operating cycle varies from time to time: Various factors particularly,
demand supply conditions change from time to time and hence the operating cycle
Page 3 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
length changes over time. In general, during boom periods the length of operating
cycle will decrease substantially and vice versa.
• Bargaining power of players determine operating cycle: Bargaining power of
suppliers will determine the length of raw material inventory period and creditor
period. Similarly, bargaining power of customers will determine the receivable
period. For examples in the automobile industry the suppliers of auto components
do not have the bargaining power. Therefore, the auto component vendors have
to carry the inventory so that they can deliver them as when the vehicle
manufacturers need. The vendors also have to accept delayed payment for their
components. On the other side of the value chain the dealers who buy the vehicles
from the vehicle manufacturers and sell them to end customers too lack
bargaining power. Therefore, they have to make payment for the vehicles to the
vehicle manufacturers quickly. Vehicle manufacturers therefore enjoy long
creditor period and short receivable period.
• Banks can target the sectors which need working capital: As explained in the
previous point vehicle manufacturers may not need any working capital support.
Whereas, auto component manufacturers and dealers would need working
capital.
• Banks may also design suitable working capital products: One popular working
capital product is channel finance. This is offered to auto component vendors.
Similarly, dealer finance is offered to dealers of automobiles. For more details on
working capital products the section on Products for Financing Working Capital
may be referred.
• Macroeconomic conditions impact the operating cycle: One major factor that
influences operating cycle of various sectors is the macroeconomic conditions.
Cyclical sectors like consumer durables, capital goods, real estate and the like are
particularly affected significantly by changes in macroeconomic conditions. In
general, the length of operating cycle of various sectors will increase during
economic slowdown/recession and will decrease when the economy recovers.
• Length of operating cycle may also indicate the level of efficiency and/or risk:
Other things remaining the same, a company with longer operating cycle can be
said to be inefficient and hence is risky.
6.3 Working Capital Requirement
Working capital can also be viewed as the capital required for financing current assets of
business firms. It can be understood by reading Table 6.1 which is the shape of balance
sheet of typical manufacturing firms. The table shows that current assets can be financed
by current liabilities including short term borrowings and the balance by long term
sources of finance including equity capital and long-term borrowings. Ideally, a part of
current assets should be financed by equity capital. Equity capital used for financing
current assets is often referred to as margin for working capital.
Page 4 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Banks in India generally consider only inventory and receivables for determination of
working capital financing. Other items like cash and bank balance, other current assets
and loans and advances are not considered. Similarly, short term borrowings and trade
credit are the two primary sources of finance for working capital. While borrowings are
loans offered by banks trade credit is offered by suppliers of raw material.
Table 6.1: Shape of Balance Sheet
Long-term borrowings
Current Assets:
- Inventory
- Trade receivables
Current Liabilities: - Cash & bank balance
- Short-term borrowings - Other current assets
- Trade credit - Loans and advances
- Other current liabilities
- Provisions
Page 5 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
first and second methods are used by many banks in India till today. Whereas the third
method is not in use. The three methods are as follows:
• First Method
MPBF = 0.75 * (Current Assets – Other Current Liabilities) …………………………. (6.3)
• Second Method:
MPBF = 0.75 * Current Assets – Other Current Liabilities ………………………….. (6.4)
• Third Method:
MPBF = 0.75 * (Current Assets - Core Current Assets) – Other Current Liabilities… (6.5)
Where,
• Other current liabilities are current liabilities other than bank credit (i.e., total
current liabilities minus short term borrowings)
• Core current assets are the current assets that will have to be maintained at the
lowest level of operations
• Current assets minus other current liabilities is called Working Capital Gap
(WCG)
Comparison of MPBF 1 and MPBF2
It is necessary for every banker to understand the implications of using the first method
(MPBF1) and second method (MPBF 2) recommended by the Tandon Committee. Let us
assume that the total current assets of X Ltd is Rs. 100 crore and other current liabilities
will be in the range of 50 to 100. At different levels of other current liabilities, bank credit
that can be sanctioned under both the methods, current ratio and equity margin have
been worked out and the same are presented in Table 6.2.
Table 6.2 provides the following information:
Working capital credit that can be sanctioned under the second method will
always be lower than under the first method.
Working capital margin under the second method will be not less than 25%
If second method is followed current ratio will be not less than 1.33.
If the first method is used the current ratio will be different at different levels of
other current liabilities. Higher the amount of other current liabilities lower will
be current ratio and equity margin. Lower the amount of other current liabilities
higher will be the current ratio and equity margin.
Page 6 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Total Current
Other Working Bank Credit Liabilities Current Ratio Margin (%)
current Capital MPBF MPBF MPBF MPBF MPBF MPBF
liabilities Gap MPBF 1 MPBF 2 1 2 1 2 1 2
100 0 0 0 100 100 1 1.00 NA NA
90 10 7.5 0 97.50 90 1.026 1.11 2.50 NA
80 20 15 0 95.00 80 1.053 1.25 5.00 NA
Table 6.2 shows clearly that the first method will result in inconsistent level of current
ratio and equity margin. One cannot be sure how much margin will be available if working
capital is estimated using the first method. Therefore, it is suggested that the first method
shall not be used.
Banks use the first method in order to provide more credit and hence the equity margin
to be provided by owners of firms will be less. If this is the reason behind the use of the
first method it is suggested that the second method may be modified as in Table 6.3.
Table 6.3: Modified Versions of the Second Method (MPBF2)
Current
Method Ratio Margin
MPBF = 0.60 x CA - CL 1.67 40%
MPBF = 0.70 x CA - CL 1.43 30%
MPBF = 0.75 x CA - CL 1.33 25%
MPBF = 0.80 x CA - CL 1.25 20%
MPBF = 0.83 x CA - CL 1.20 17%
MPBF = 0.85 x CA - CL 1.18 15%
MPBF = 0.90 * CA - CL 1.11 10%
Page 7 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 8 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Illustration I :
Hence company X has 40% of turnover under Digital mode. Hence it is eligible for
additional working capital.
Calculation:
1. Sales through Non Digital Mode:
Turnover method Amount in
Crore
Projected Sales 10.00
Non Digital Mode 6.00
Accepted level by Bank (Assumption) 6.00
31.25% of Turnover (i.e.,) 25% of Turnover plus margin of a 1.88
6.25%
Min. Margin 6.25% of Turnover b 0.38
Actual /Projected NWC * c 0.38
Owners Margin (Higher of (b) & (c)) d 0.38
MPBF = (a) – (d) a-d 1.50
2. Digital Mode
Turnover method Amount in
Crore
Projected Sales 10.00
Non Digital Mode 4.00
Accepted level by Bank (Assumption) 4.00
37.50% of Turnover (i.e.,) 30% of Turnover plus margin of a 1.88
7.50%
Page 9 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
However, if FB limit assessed as per the Tandon first method of lending is more, then
limit assessed as per first method of lending is to be sanctioned.
Illustration II:
Turnover of Company Y : Rs.10.00 crores
Of which - Non Digital Mode : Rs. 8.00 crores
- Digital Mode : Rs. 2.00 crores
Company Y has only 20% of turnover under Digital mode. Hence it is not eligible for
additional working capital as the turnover projected under digital mode is less than
25% of the total turnover. In such cases the whole turnover will be considered as
Non Digital mode and assessment will be carried out accordingly.
Calculation:
1. Sales through Non Digital Mode:
Turnover method Amt. In
Crore.
Projected Sales 10.00
Non Digital Mode 10.00
Page 10 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
However, if FB limit assessed as per the Tandon first method of lending is more, then
limit assessed as per first method of lending is to be sanctioned.
Page 11 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
It may be noted that holding periods of inventory, receivables and creditors need to be
decided beforehand. One alternative for determining the holding periods is to consider
the average of holding periods over few years in the past.
Estimation of working capital under Operating Cycle Method - Illustration
Given below is the data of Mars Ltd.
• Projected Sales of X Ltd : Rs. 730crore
• Inventory period : 30 days
• Receivable period : 45 days
• Creditors period : 25 days
• Margin required for working capital is : 25%
Working capital requirement of Mars Ltd can be estimated as in Table 6.4.
Table 6.4: Estimation of Working Capital under Operating Cycle Method
Item Amount
Inventory (730 x 30/365) 60
Receivables (730 x 45/365) 90
Total (Inventory + Receivables) 150
Margin (25% of Total) 37.50
Trade Credit(730 x 25/365) 50
Bank credit (Total – Margin – Trade Credit) 62.50
Page 12 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Cash budget is used by many banks for estimating working capital requirement of
seasonal businesses like sugar, tea and the like. However, the method can be used for
estimating working capital requirement of any business firm.
Cash Budget – An Illustration
Royal Manufacturing Company has asked to create a cash budget in order to determine
its borrowing needs for the period June to October. The following information are
gathered.
Month Sales (INR) Other Payments (INR)
June 172,000 80,000
July 142,000 75,000
August 121,000 70,000
September 93,000 50,000
October 76,000 45,000
November 81,000
April and May sales were INR115,000 and INR135,000, respectively. The firm collects
35% of its sales during the month, 55% the following month, and 10% two months after
the sale. Each month it purchases raw material equal to 60% of the next month’s expected
sales. The company pays for 40% of its raw material purchases in the same month and
60% in the following month. However, the firm’s suppliers give it a 2% discount if it pays
during the same month as the purchase. A minimum cash balance of INR25,000 must be
maintained each month, and the firm pays 6% annually for short-term borrowings from
its bank.
Create a cash budget for June to October. The cash budget should account for short-term
borrowing and payback of outstanding loans. The firm ended May with INR30,000 cash
balance.
Royal Manufacturing Company’s cash budget may be prepared by using the following
steps:
1. Estimation of collection from customers during each month
2. Estimation of purchases of raw material during each month
3. Finally, preparation of cash budget
Page 13 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
@: 85200 x 40% less 2% discount. Payment made in subsequent months have been
estimated similarly.
Cash Budget of Royal Manufacturing Company
June July August September October
Opening balance of cash 30000 25000 25000 25000 25000
Collection from customers 145950 157800 137650 113300 89850
Total 175950 182800 162650 138300 114850
Payments:
To suppliers 95318 79579 65434 51355 46411
Other payments 80,000 75,000 70,000 50,000 45,000
Total 175318 154579 135434 101355 91411
Surplus (Deficit) 632 28221 27216 36945 23439
Closing balance 25000 25000 25000 25000 25000
Borrowing (Repayment) 24368 -3221 -2216 -11945 1561
Page 14 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 15 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
• Factoring
• Such loans also finance a supplier’s invoices and receivables at a
discount for certain period of time. The factor is usually then
responsible for collecting the amount from the customer.
6.6 Summary and Conclusion
Provision of working capital is a major business for lending institutions and commercial
banks are having an edge over other lending institutions in providing working capital that
will match the actual requirement of borrowers. Working capital is meant for financing
operating cycle of business firms and hence banks need to understand the length of
operating cycle and the efficiency of operations of borrowing companies to determine the
working capital requirement and to understand the risk involved. There are various
methods for estimating working capital requirement. However, balance sheet based
methods and turnover based methods may mislead and hence operating cycle method or
cash budget method may be used. Similarly, there are many alternative products for
meeting working capital requirements of business firms. Depending on the customers’
requirements and risk involved appropriate product may be offered.
Page 16 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Annexure 1
Case Study on Estimation of Working Capital Requirement
Projected financials of Solar Steel Ltd for the year 2017 are given in Table 4.5. The
historical average holding periods of current assets and current liabilities of the
company were as follows:
Inventory period : 45 days
Receivable period : 40 days
Creditor period : 60 days
The company has sought working capital loan of Rs. 200 crore from Jupiter Bank.
However, the credit department of the bank wishes to find out the amount that can be
sanctioned. The equity margin for the loans as stipulated by the bank’s credit policy is
25%.
Table 4.5: Projected Financials of Solar Steel Ltd for the year 2017
2017 2017
Tangible Net Worth 417.31 Net Sales 3735.81
Medium & Long Term Loans 181.29 Other Income 3.35
Current Liabilities# 811.23 EBIDTA 204.35
Net Block 222.44 Depreciation 26.85
Investments in group
2.79 Interest 105.13
companies
Taxes 24.68
Current Assets 1184.60
Net Profit / (Loss) 54.68
#: Includes working capital loan of Rs. 200 crore. All figures are in INR Crore.
Assessment of Working Capital Requirement of Solar Steel Ltd:
Turnover Method:
25% of projected sales (25% of 3735.81) = Rs. 933.95
Less Margin of 5% of projected sales (5% of 3735.81) = 186.79
Bank Loan = 747.16
Page 17 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Item Amount
A. Inventory 470.81
B. Receivables 409.40
C. Total (A + B) 880.21
Page 18 of 18
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Objective
The objective of this chapter is to give an overview of non-fund working capital facilities
offered by banks, the process involved, and the regulatory guidelines for the same.
Structure
7.1 Introduction
7.2 Letter of Credit
7.2.1 Introduction to LC
7.2.2 Parties to Letter of Credit apart from Applicant and beneficiary
7.2.3 Type of Letter of Credits
7.2.4 RBI Guidelines
7.2.5 Document generally asked under LC
7.2.6 Incoterms 2010
7.2.7 Checklist for issuing LC
7.2.8 Charges
7.2.9 LC Mechanism
7.3 Standby Letter of Credit
7.3.1 Usage of Standby LC by Authorised Dealers
7.4 Bank Guarantee
7.4.1 Introduction to BG
7.4.2 Governing Rules/Guidelines
7.4.3 Types of Bank Guarantee
7.4.4 Check List for processing request
7.4.5 Guidelines for the Issuance of Guarantee
7.4.6 Invocation of Bank Guarantee
Page 1 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
7.1 Introduction
In assessment of the working capital of a borrower, banks shall consider the following
two types of facilities:
· Fund based facilities – These refer to the facilities for drawing cash and funds as
per requirement of the concerned borrower. Chapter 6 may be referred to for the
details on fund based working capital financing.
· Non-fund based facilities – The credit facilities given by the bank where actual
funds are not involved are termed as Non-fund based facilities. The banks are
facilitators in a trade transactions whereby there offer their
commitment/promise/undertaking to pay in case the buyer fails to pay the seller
and seller remains unpaid. So the financial guarantee/ assurance is offered by
banks to facilitate the trade transaction by offering suitable instrument to cater to
the needs of buyer and seller. Non-funded instruments are designed in such a way
whereby the seller of the goods or services gets financial commitment by a solvent
person like bank subject to the compliance of terms and conditions as mentioned
in the related trade instrument.
The non-funded facilities are divided in to three broad categories as under:
· Letter of Credit
· Guarantees
· Co-acceptance of Bills
· Depending upon the nature of the transactions some variant of the above products
are offered to suit the domestic and international trade. These are
· Trade Credit for import of goods
· Deferred payment guarantee for import of capital equipment and technical know-
how.
Page 2 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Now we shall discuss each product of non-funded facilities with reference to the
regulations, procedures, significance and usage.
7.2 Letters of Credit
7.2.1 Introduction
Letter of Credit (LC) is a payment mechanism wherein the credit issuing bank acts as
an intermediary between buyer and seller to address risk of both the parties and there
by facilitates the transaction.
The credit issuing bank undertakes irrevocably on behalf of its client
(Buyer/applicant) and in favour of the beneficiary (seller) to honour the payment
obligation against documents presented by the beneficiary in accordance with:
-The terms and conditions of the documentary credit
-Applicable provisions of UCPDC rules
-International Standard Banking Practice (ISBP)
7.2.2 Parties to LC:
The following are the parties involved in a LC:
Page 3 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Ø Freely Negotiable Credit (Unrestricted Credit) - Free from any restriction can
be negotiated with any Bank.
Ø Sight Credit- Payment on demand or on presentation/sight of documents.
Ø Usance Credit- Payment to be made after certain credit period as extended by the
seller.
Ø Deferred Payment Credit- It is a usance credit where payment will be made by
designated Bank, on respective due dates, determined in accordance with
stipulations of the credit, without the drawing of drafts.
Ø Revolving Letter of Credit – In Such LCs, the amount of credit is revived or
reinstated without requiring specific amendment to the credit. Revolving LCs with
automatic renewal clause is associated with risk and branches need to be careful
about the clauses. The reinstatement clause in the revolving LC assumes great
significance, hence the branches should put maximum liability clause in such LCs
and also maximum instances of reinstatement may be stated. Also branches
should not allow “waive – all – discrepancy” clause in such LCs.
Ø Transferable Letter of Credit- Such a credit states it is “transferable”. It can be
transferred in whole or in part to another beneficiary (“second beneficiary”) at the
request of the beneficiary (“first beneficiary”). However, it cannot be transferred
further.
Ø Back-to-back Credit or Countervailing Credit- When a second LC is issued on
the Backing of Principal LC, it is known back-to-back Credit or Countervailing
Credit.
Ø Anticipatory Credit: Anticipatory Credit Provides for payment to Beneficiary at
Pre-shipment stage also. Two types of Anticipatory Credit:
· Red clause Letter of Credit: A letter of credit which provides for an amount
in advance to Beneficiary for Purchasing raw material/Processing/Packing of
goods etc.
· Green Clause Letter of Credit: It is an Extended version of Red Clause Credit
and provides advance to Beneficiary for Warehousing, Insurance charges etc.
also.
7.2.4 RBI Guidelines
The following are the guidelines issued by the RBI relating to LCs:
· Bank should normally open letters of credit for their own customers who enjoy
credit facilities with them. Customers maintaining current account only and
not enjoying any credit limits should not be granted LC facilities except in cases
where customer is keeping 100 per cent cash collateral.
· The request of such customer for sanctioning and opening of letter of credit
should be properly scrutinised to establish the genuine need of the customer.
Page 4 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
The customer may be, required to submit a complete loan proposal including
financial statements to satisfy the bank about his, needs and also his financial
resources, to mire the bills drawn under.
· Where a customer enjoys credit facilities with some other bank, the reasons
for his approaching the bank for sanctioning LC limits have to be clearly stated.
The bank opening LC on behalf of such customer should invariably make a
reference to the existing banker of the customer
· In all cases of opening of letters of credit, the bank has to ensure that the
customer is able to retire the bills drawn under LC as per the financial
arrangement already finalised.
7.2.5 Document generally asked under LC
· Invoice
· Packing List/Weight list
· BL (Bill of Lading)/AWB (Air way Bill)/ Lorry receipt (These are Title to
goods)
· Insurance (only if Incoterm applied requires)
· Test /inspection certificate
· Certificate of origin (for import LCs)
· Bill of exchange.
7.2.6 Incoterms 2010:
International Commercial Terms, popularly known as INCOTERMS, were devised by
ICC which defines rights and obligation of the buyer and seller as regards delivery of
the goods and cost connected there to. We state below various INCOTERMS and their
significance.
Page 5 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
EXW FCA FAS FOB CFR CIF CPT CIP DAF DES DEQ DDU DDP
Warehouse
Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Storage
Warehouse
Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Labor
Export
Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Packing
Loading
Buyer Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Charges
Inland Buyer/
Buyer Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Freight Seller*
Terminal
Buyer Buyer Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Charges
Forwarder's
Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Fees
Loading On
Buyer Buyer Buyer Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Vessel
Ocean/Air
Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller Seller
Freight
Charges On
Arrival At Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Seller Seller Buyer Buyer Seller Seller Seller
Destination
Duty, Taxes
& Customs Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Seller
Clearance
Delivery To
Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Buyer Seller Seller
Destination
Page 6 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 7 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
7.2.8 Charges :
Commission and other charges at sanctioned rate are to be applied upfront, while
issuing the LC. In case of LC against 100% cash collateral, charges as per card rate are
to be applied unless concessional rates are given by the sanctioning authority.
7.2.9 Letter of Credit (LC) Mechanism
Any business/industrial venture will involve purchase transactions relating to
machine/other capital goods and raw material etc., and also sale transactions relating
to its products. The customer may, therefore, find himself on either side of a LC
transaction at different times depending upon his position at that particular moment.
He may be an applicant for a letter of credit for his purchases while be the beneficiary
under other letter of credit for his sale transaction. It is, therefore, necessary that
complete LC mechanism covering the liabilities and rights and both the applicant and
the beneficiary are understood for maximum advantage.
The complete mechanism of a letter of credit may be divided in three parts as under:
1. Issuing of Credit – Letter of credit is always issued by the buyer’s bank (issuing
bank) at the request and on behalf and in accordance with the instructions of the
applicant. The LC may either be advised directly or through some other bank
(advising bank). The advising bank is responsible for transmission of credit and
verifying the authenticity of signature of issuing bank and is under no
commitment to pay the seller. The advising bank may also be required to add
confirmation and in that case will assume all the liabilities of issuing bank in
relation to the beneficiary as stated already. It will then be called as Confirming
Bank.
2. Negotiation of Documents by beneficiary – On receipt of letter of credit, the
beneficiary shall arrange to supply the goods as per the terms of LC and draw
necessary documents as required under LC. The documents will then be
presented to the negotiating bank for payment/acceptance as the case may be.
The negotiating bank will make the payment to the beneficiary and obtain
reimbursement from the opening bank in terms of credit.
3. Settlement of Bills Drawn under LC by the opener – The last step involved in letter
of credit mechanism is retirement of documents received under LC by the opener.
On receipt of documents drawn under LC, the opening bank is required to closely
examine the documents to ensure compliance of the terms and conditions of credit
and present the same to the opener for his scrutiny. The opener should then make
payment to the opening bank and take delivery of documents so that delivery of
goods can be obtained by him (where the credit is drawn under DP terms) and
should provide funds on due date in case of usance LC)
Page 8 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 9 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
· For import of raw material or a fixed asset or consumable stores and the
overseas seller is willing to sell only against L/C.
· In case of domestic purchase also the seller may be willing to sell the goods
against L/C only.
The document showing the terms of the seller will help establish the purpose of opening
a LC.
(v) Lead Time : The time taken to receive goods after opening an L/C.
(vi) Minimum level of stocks to be kept at all times/ Economic order quantity i.e.,
Minimum size of each consignment which will make economic sense.
Assessment of DP LC limit
Assume a borrower purchases raw material worth Rs. 24 lacs in a year. Out of the above
50% of raw material are purchased through L/C. 50% of the purchase through LC is
imported. The indigenous raw material purchased through L/C takes 1 month to be
delivered after opening of L/C and in the case of imported ones it takes 4 months.
Page 10 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
In the above case the monthly consumption of indigenous raw material is Rs. 100,000 and
the monthly consumption of imported raw material is Rs. 12/12 = 100,000 lac. The
amount of the limit for indigenous raw material will be computed as under :
Assessment of DP LC Limits:
Assessment of DA LC limits
Assume that a borrower purchases raw material worth Rs. 48 lacs in a year. Out of the
above 50% of raw material are purchased through L/C. 50% of the purchase through LC
is for imports. The indigenous raw material purchased through L/C takes about 2 months
to be delivered after opening of L/C and in the case of imported ones it takes about 4
months. Both the L/C's are to be on 2 months DA basis. Lead time for indigenous LC is 15
days and lead time for import LC is 2 months.
Then 2 months should be added to the Lead Time subject to adjustment of transit period
already covered under the Lead Time. Assuming such transit period is 15 days (0.5
month) then the requirement will be
Page 11 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 12 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 13 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 14 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
(As per RBI circular RBI/2012-13/467 dated April 02, 2013 on New Capital Adequacy
Framework, Financial guarantees attract credit conversion factor (CCF) of 100%).
7.4.3.2 Performance BG :
Performance guarantees are essentially transaction-related contingencies that
involve an irrevocable undertaking to pay a third party in the event the
counterparty fails to fulfil or perform a contractual non-financial obligation. In
such transactions, the risk of loss depends on the event which need not
necessarily be related to the creditworthiness of the counterparty involved.
Examples:-
Ø Guarantees in lieu of security deposits / earnest money deposits (EMD) for
participating in tenders, such guarantees are also known as Bid Bond
Guarantee.
Ø Performance bonds and export performance guarantees;
Ø Retention money guarantees;
Ø Warranties, indemnities and standby letters of credit related to particular
transaction.
7.4.4 Check List for Processing request
Ø Request Letter by the client – BG applicant
Ø Board Resolution(for Company) | Consent Letter (for Partnership Firm) ; For non-
limit clients
Ø Duly attested Copy of Underlying such as Contract/Agreement etc.
Ø Counter Guarantee duly franked or on stamp paper; (For non-limit clients);
Ø F.D.R (valid till BG expiry) duly discharge- 100% Margin for Inland Bank
guarantee/110% Margin for Foreign Bank guarantee if BG is against .cash margin
Non Limit Clients. Margin in form of FD as per sanction for Regular Limit Clients.
Ø Duly vetted hard copy of BG format accepted by customer (soft copy to be
obtained for issuance )
Ø Scrutiny of the BG text and approval by competent authority for onerous
clause/Deletion of Notwithstanding, Clause/BG Cashable at other location/BG
issuance against counter guarantee (approved format) of other bank. (Availability
of credit line and tenor as well as acceptability of counter guarantee format to be
checked for issuance of Foreign BG;
Ø BG should be printed on the stamp paper as per the stamp duty applicable in the
state.
Page 15 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 16 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
rights under this guarantee will be forfeited and we shall be relived and
discharged from all liabilities thereunder.
Ø The BGs in which there is inbuilt and auto renewal clause, such BGs are called open
ended and the liability of the bank for such BGs is perpetual in nature. A guarantee
should be definite in terms of liability for the amount and period.
7.4.10 Auto closure of the BG:
Ø In case of BGs issued favoring government authorities/ departments, Courts an
additional precautionary measure
All the proofs of dispatch of the notice/reminders to the beneficiary are to be kept on
record and preserved as per extant “Preservation of documents” policy.
7.4.11 Closure / reversal of expired Bank Guarantee :
Ø As Bank’s precious capital is engaged in outstanding BG balance.
Ø The BG liability should be reversed after Bank receives either the original BG duly
discharged by the beneficiary or a Letter of Discharge in lieu of the original BG.
7.5 Trade Credit
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has allowed a special facility to finance the imported goods
by raising foreign currency loan from the overseas lender. Depending upon the source of
finance such credits are known as byer’s credit or supplier’s credit.
7.5.1 Buyer’s Credit – If the credit is arranged by the buyer (importer) for a payment of
imports into India such credits are known as buyer’s credit. Subject to the rules stated
here under, the trade credit will facilitate the payment of imported goods by raising
foreign currency loan under the guarantee of the importer’s bank.
7.5.2 Supplier’s Credit – Supplier’s credit relates to credit for imports into India
extended by the overseas supplier or overseas bank or any other financial intermediary
in the world.
The rules governing trade credit are mentioned below:
a) Amount – USD 20 million or equivalent in any other foreign currency per instance
of shipment. For amount exceeding USD 20 million prior approval from RBI may
be sought.
b) Period - For raw materials upto 1 year from the date of shipment.
i. For capital goods – 5 years from the date of shipment (capital goods
as defined by DGFT)
ii. However, the period shall be subject to the operating cycle of the
customer and the above will be the outer limits only.
c) Pricing - All in cost ceiling – six months LIBOR plus 350 basis point per cent per
annum.
Page 17 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Page 18 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Illustration 1
Assume a borrower purchases raw material worth Rs. 48/- lacs in a year. Out of the above
Rs. 24/- lacs worth of raw material are purchased through L/c. Further out of this Rs.
24/- lacs worth of raw material purchased through L/C, Rs. 12/- lacs worth of raw
materials are imported. The indigenous raw material purchased through L/C takes about
2 months to be delivered after opening of L/C and in the case of imported ones it takes
about 4 months and the minimum import consignment is Rs. 3/- lacs.
In the above case the monthly consumption of indigenous raw material is Rs. 12/12 - Rs.
1/- lac and the monthly consumption of imported raw material is Rs. 12/12 = 1/- lac. The
amount of the limit for indigenous raw material will be computed as under :
The total L/C limit would then be Rs. 2.25 + 5.00 = Rs. 7.25 lacs say Rs. 8/- lacs.
If in the above example both the L/C's are to be on 2 months DA basisthen 2 months
should be added to the Lead Time subject to adjustmentof transit period already covered
under the Lead Time. Assuming suchtransit period is 15 days or 1/2 month then the
requirement will be
Page 19 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Under the RM purchases, 30% is by way of CC and 70% is by way of LC. Of the 70%
purchased of RM under LC, 30% of such purchases is from the domestic market and 70%
is from international market.
Other details of terms of LC is as under:
Domestic puchases Purhases from abroad
Customs duty 0 2%
Lead Period 40% in 20 days 30% in 30 days
Including transit period 60% in 15 days 70% in 20 days
Usance period 80% - 0 days 10% - 90 days
20% - 90 days 80% - 80 days
10% - 60 days
Cushion period 2 days 7 days
Page 20 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Caselets
Caselets
parameters calculation
Successful bid monthly 60cr=60Cr/12=5 crores
Earnest money BG 50000000X3%=1500000X3=45 Lacs
Performance BG 60crX20%=12Cr/12=1crX10%=10 lacsX12=120
lacs
Mobilisation of advance 10 lacsX3=30 lacs
Retention money 10lacsX24=240 lacs less 50%=120 lacs
Total 45+120+30+120=315 lacs
Add Opening balance of BG 80 lacs
Page 21 of 21
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Dr. M. Manickaraj
The objective of this chapter is to discuss the priority sector lending scheme (PSLS)
implemented by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
Structure
The chapter has been organised into the following five sections:
1. Introduction
2. RBI Guidelines on PSL
3. Priority Sector Lending Certificate (PSLC)
4. Monitoring of PSL Targets
5. Summary and Conclusion
1.0 Introduction
Historically banks have been providing loans liberally to big companies and neglecting
other sectors like agriculture and small enterprises. Two major reasons for lack of
interest among banks could be risk aversion and high operating cost of managing small
loans. Therefore, the government had to promulgate regulations for banks to necessarily
lend a certain portion of their loan portfolio to the neglected sectors. One extreme action
by the Government of India in this regard was nationalisation of banks. The government
of India had constituted several committees for channelling bank credit to the needy
sectors and had announced several schemes for the purpose. One such scheme is the Lead
Bank Scheme and another major scheme is the PSL scheme. Yet another scheme
announced in the recent past is the Priority Sector Lending Certificate (PSLC) scheme.
Priority Sector refers to those sectors of the economy which may not get timely and
adequate credit unless the lending institutions are directed to lend to these sectors.
Reserve (RBI) has made it mandatory for the banks to provide a specified portion of their
total loans and advances portfolio to certain sectors. This is meant for achieving all round
and inclusive development of the economy. Targets for PSL was set in 1974 for the first
time in India and the overall target was 33.3%. Later it was revised to 40% in 1980. The
scope and extent of the scheme have been changed several times and the latest guidelines
on PSL are discussed in the next section.
Page 1 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Directing banks to provide credit to specific sectors is not unique to India only. In other
countries it is called directed lending and is in vogue in many countries including
developed and developing countries. The various forms of directed lending are as follows:
Page 2 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
Apart from lending directly to the above categories classified as priority sectors, RBI
allows banks to the following activities for achieving PSL targets subject to certain conditions.
RBI also monitors the flow of credit to PS on a quarterly basis through reporting
mechanism by Banks.
Page 3 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
75% of ANBC or
CEOBE,
40% of ANBC
whichever is
or CEOBE,
higher.
whichever is
However,
higher; out of
lending to
which 32%
medium
40% of ANBC can be in the 75% of ANBC or
Total enterprises,
or CEOBE, form of CEOBE,
Priority social
whichever is lending to whichever is
Sector infrastructure
higher. exports and higher.
and renewable
not less than
energy shall be
8% can be to
reckoned for
any other
priority sector
priority
achievement
sector.
only upto 15%
of ANBC.
Page 4 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
# Revised targets for agriculture and Small and Marginal Farmers will be implemented in
a phased manner.
Table 1 above shows that there are specific targets for agriculture (18% of ANBC) and
micro enterprises (7.5% of ANBC) only. Weaker sections of the society will cut across all
the sectors and hence it may be achieved by providing loans to the weaker sections under
each category including agriculture, MSMEs, exports and so on. Therefore, the balance
14.5% of the overall target can be achieved by lending to other sectors like exports,
education, housing, etc.
The various categories of PSL are briefly described in the following paragraphs.
2.1.1 Agriculture: According to the RBI agriculture sector includes (i) farm credit (ii)
Agriculture Infrastructure and (iii) Ancillary Activities.1
· Farm credit incudes loans extended to individual farmers including Self Help
Groups (SHGs) or Joint Liability Groups (JLGs) and proprietorship firms directly
engaged in Agriculture and Allied Activities, viz., dairy, fishery, animal husbandry,
poultry, bee-keeping and sericulture. This includes (i) Crop loans (ii) Medium and
long-term loans for agriculture and allied activities (iii) Loans for pre and post-
harvest activities, (iv) Produce pledge loans up to ₹ 50 lakh (v) Loans to distressed
farmers indebted to non-institutional lenders, (vi) KCC loans, (vii) Loans to small
and marginal farmers for purchase of land for agricultural purposes.
· Loans, given to co-operatives of farmers (not applicable to UCBs), corporate
farmers, producer organizations/companies/partnership firms which are directly
engaged in activities mentioned up to an aggregate limit of Rs 2 Crores per
borrower entity.
1
For details refer to RBI Master Direction – Priority Sector Lending – Targets and Classification, dated Sep 4, 2020.
https://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/PDFs/MDPSL803EE903174E4C85AFA14C335A5B0909.PDF
Page 5 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
2.1.2 Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs): Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises have been defined by GOI on the basis of a composite criteria of investment
in plant and machinery/equipment and annual turnover. The definition is applicable to
both manufacturing and service enterprises.
Loans to MSMEs in manufacturing & service sectors can be classified under the priority
sector as follows:
Page 6 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
· Khadi and Village Industries Sector (KVI): All loans to units in the KVI sector
will be eligible for classification under the sub-target of 7.5 percent prescribed for
Micro Enterprises.
· Other Finance to MSMEs
(i) Loans to entities involved in assisting the decentralized sector in the supply
of inputs to and marketing of outputs of artisans, village and cottage
industries,
(ii) Loans to co-operatives of producers in the decentralized sector viz.
artisans, village and cottage industries,
(iii) Loans sanctioned by banks to MFIs for on-lending to MSME sector.
(iv) Credit outstanding under General Credit Cards, Artisan Credit Card, Laghu
Udyami Card, Swarojgar Credit Card, and Weaver’s Card
(v) Overdrafts extended by banks upto Rs 10,000 (age limit 18-65 years and
there will not be any condition for overdraft upto Rs 2000) under Pradhan
Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) accounts. These overdrafts will qualify as
achievement of the target for lending to Micro Enterprises,
(vi) Outstanding deposits with SIDBI and MUDRA Ltd. on account of priority
sector shortfall.
2.1.3 Export Credit: Pre-shipment and post shipment export credit extended by
domestic banks not exceeding 2% of ANBC or Credit equivalent amount of Off-Balance
Sheet Exposure, whichever higher, and subject to a limit of Rs 25 Crore per borrower to
units having turnover upto Rs. 100 crore. The per Borrower limit and turnover cap are
not applicable for Foreign Banks with 20 branches and above.
2.1.5 Housing: The following are the items eligible to be treated as PSL:
Page 7 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
and low income groups (LIG having income upto Rs 5 lakhs per annum) and
total cost per unit not above Rs 10 lakhs.
(v) Bank loans to Housing Finance Companies (HFCs), for on-lending for housing
purposes, subject to a maximum of 5% of the Bank’s PSL.
(vi) Outstanding deposits with NHB on account of priority sector shortfall.
2.1.6 Social infrastructure: Loans up to a limit of ₹ 5 crores per borrower for building
social infrastructure for activities viz., schools, health care facilities, drinking water,
sanitation facilities etc. Credit extended to Micro Finance Institutions (MFIs) for on-
lending for the purpose of water and sanitation facilities is also eligible under this
category.
2.1.8 Others
(i) Loans not exceeding ₹ 50,000/- per borrower provided directly by banks to
individuals and their SHG/JLG.
(ii) Loans to distressed persons not exceeding Rs. 100,000 per borrower to prepay
debt to non-institutional lenders.
(iii) Loans sanctioned to State Sponsored Organisations for SC/ST for purchase and
supply of inputs and/or marketing of outputs of beneficiaries of these
organisations.
(iv) Weaker Sections: In the above loans banks should ensure that 10 percent of
ANBC or Credit Equivalent of off Balance sheet exposure, whichever is higher,
is given to weaker section as defined in the RBI circular
(v) Investments in approved funds etc.
For more details please refer to the RBI Master Direction on priority sector lending
https://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/ rdocs/notification/PDFs/ 33MD08B3F0C
C0F8C4CE6B844B87F7F 990FB6.PDF
The genesis for the PSLC scheme can be found in The Raghuram Rajan Committee Report
on Financial Sector Reforms (2008). The committee had recommended the introduction
of PSLC in order to make use of the comparative strength of banks and financial
institutions in lending to the priority sector. The committee was of the view that those
institutions good at lending to the priority sector shall focus on the same. Banks and
Page 8 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
institutions which were able to exceed the PSL target will be issued with the PSLC. Those
banks which are not able to achieve the PSL targets may buy the PSLC to offset their
shortfall. This arrangement will enable each bank to do their business well utilising their
core strengths and at the same time desired amount of bank loans are directed to the
priority sectors in the country. The RBI has launched an online platform called e-Kuber
for trading in PSLCs on April 7, 2016. During 2017-18, the PSLCs trading volume increased by 270
per cent to ₹1,84,200 crores. In H1:2018-19, trading volume more than doubled from the level a year
ago.
Types of PSLCs: The following four types of PSLCs are available for trading:
The above mentioned PSLCs will enable banks to fulfil the overall target as well the sub-
targets. In course of time PSLC on other specific sectors may also be issued.
The PSL target and sub targets will be monitored by the RBI on quarterly basis. If a bank
has any shortfall in achieving the PSL target the bank will be directed to deposit an
amount equivalent to the shortfall in the Rural Infrastructure Development Fund (RIDF)
established with the NABARD or SIDBI or NHB or MUDRA Bank as may be appropriate. It
may be noted that the interest offered by RIDF is set by the RBI. The rate is linked to the
bank rate and it may be in the range of bank rate minus 2% to bank rate minus 5%. The
rate of interest will be determined depending on the shortfall and it can also be negative.
The rate of interest on deposits into RIDF, tenure of deposits, etc will be fixed by the RBI
from time to time.
Historically, commercial banks have been lending to corporates and were not interested
in lending to small borrowers like farmers and micro enterprises. Governments, on other
hand, are interested in achieving balanced and inclusive growth and hence wanted to
provide bank credit to all the needy sectors and sections of the society. Various methods
are adopted by different nations to ensure the flow of credit to the needy sectors. Among
other schemes Government of India is implementing the PSL scheme through the RBI.
The sectors to which commercial banks in the country are supposed to provide credit
under the PSL scheme are Agriculture, MSMEs, Export, Education, Housing, Social
Infrastructure, Renewable Energy, and others. To facilitate the banks to achieve the PSL
targets efficiently the RBI has introduced a trading scheme called PSLC and an online
trading platform for the same called e-Kuber. The achievement of PSL targets by the
banks is monitored by the RBI on quarterly basis and any shortfall in the target will have
Page 9 of 10
Course: Credit Management (Module I: Basics of Credit and Credit Process) NIBM, Pune
to be offset by depositing money into RIDF. The objective of RIDF is to penalise the banks
which are not able to achieve the PSL targets and hence the rate of interest offered by the
RIDF is very low.
Page 10 of 10