Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Article
Accepted 05 Feb 2016, Available online 11 Feb 2016, Vol.6, No.1 (Feb 2016)
Abstract
Corrosion tests of carbon steel metal in 5% H2SO4 solution at different operating conditions were performed for
ranges of temperature (30 to 60 o C) and rotational velocity (0 to 600 rpm) using both weight loss method and
electrochemical polarization technique (Tafel extrapolation). The results revealed different trends of carbon steel
against the experimental parameters. The corrosion rate was found to increase considerably with increasing
temperature for the majority of results. However, increasing rotational velocity clearly enhanced the corrosion rate
for carbon steel. The corrosion potential shows sharp decrease with time in first few minutes and then increase
reaching an asymptotic value beyond that. In weight loss experiments, increasing temperature shifted the Ecorr to
more positive at stationary condition. Increasing velocity from 0 to 400 rpm shifted the Ecorr to more negative at 40
°C. Then trended to positive with increasing velocity to 600 rpm. In polarization experiments, Ecorr shifted to more
positive with increasing temperature from 30 to 40 °C and small change when increasing the temperature from 40 to
60 °C. Increasing velocities shifted the corrosion potential to more positive.
an increase of the oxygen supply. Corrosion potentials curves under different conditions of a rotational
were shafted toward the cathodic values and the velocity of 0, 400, and 600 rpm, and temperatures 30,
magnitude of the impedance was rose with flow 40, 50 and 60 ºC.
velocities. The chemical composition for carbon steel 0.62%V,
Ajeel et. al., 2012 studies the corrosion behavior of 0.00% Cr, 0.22% Mn, 98.71% Fe, 0.08% Cu, and 0.08%
low carbon steel in different concentrations of H2SO4 Mo. The specimen was hole from the center in a very
and HCL solutions. Weight loss method was used for small area can be negligible for purpose installing into
estimation the corrosion rate in the current study. The the solution by screw.
results show that the corrosion rate increases with Fig.1 shows the experimental apparatus which was
increasing acid concentration from (1 to 5) M. for both composed of stirrer to obtain different velocity, digital
types of acid used. The corrosion rate of low carbon voltmeter to measure the potential, digital ammeter to
steel in acid environments indicates that the measure the current, water bath having temperatures
hydrochloric acid solution was more corrosive media range of 10-95°C to obtain different solution
than that of sulfuric acid solution under the same temperatures, power supply to provide a constant
conditions. Oguike, 2014 has been studied the effect of applied voltage between the electrodes, variable
hydrochloric acid concentration on stainless steel resistance (rheostat) (0-106 ohm) to control the
(Fe6956) at temperature range 303 - 333 ± 1 K using current flow. Before each experiment the specimen
weight loss, thermometric and electrochemical (working electrode) was abraded with glass emery
polarization techniques. The corrosion rate of the paper of grade numbers; 120, 180, 220, 400 and 2000
stainless steel was found to be dependent on both respectively, washed continuously with brushing by
temperature variation and acid concentration. He was plastic brush in running tap water, followed by distilled
found appreciable corrosion resistance of the tested water, dried with a clean tissue, followed by ethanol for
Fe6956 coupons at 0.5 M HCl in all the tests, whose 30 second dried with clean tissue, and then dried by
resistance was undermined with increase in both using electrical oven to temperature of about 110 ºC
temperature and acid concentration. The corrosion for 10 minute [Mahato et al, 1980]. The specimen then
rate was found to increase with increasing was stored in the desiccator over high activity silica gel
temperature and acid concentration. until use.
To control the corrosion, good understanding of the
effect of operating conditions on the corrosion
behavior is required. Therefore, this work aims to
study free corrosion behavior of carbon steel metal in
sulfuric acid in ranges of temperatures and agitation
speed. Two different technique will be used to measure
the corrosion rate that are: weight loss and
electrochemical polarization.
2. Experimental work
Experimental work was carried out to determine the 1-calomel electrode (reference electrode), 2-working electrode
(specimen), 3-motor, 4-stirrer, 5-thermometer, 6-voltmeter, 7-water
corrosion rate of carbon steel (2×4cm2 coupon bath, 8-ammeter, 9-resistance box, 10-power supply, 11-graphit
specimen) under flow conditions at a rotational electrode
velocity range of 0 to 600 rpm, temperature 30, 40, 50
and 60 ºC, in 5% (wt/v) sulfuric acid solution using Fig.1 Experimental apparatus
weight loss and electrochemical polarization methods.
Then the specimen was weighted to the 4th decimal of
The experimental work is divided into three parts
gram (w1) by using digital balance and dimensions by
using ruler to the 2nd decimal of millimeter before use.
1- Weight loss in order to determine the average
After that one face of the rectangular coupon was
corrosion rates under a rotational velocity of 0,
exposed to corrosion environment for 1 h immersion
400, and 600 rpm, and temperatures 30, 40, 50
in acid solutions, while the other face was completely
and 60 ºC, which was performed to assess
insulated by insulating tape.
corrosion rate of Carbon steel specimen in a
At the end of weight loss experiment, the specimen
solution of 5% wt/v H2SO4.
was washed by tap water with brushing to remove the
2- Measurement of corrosion potential as a function
corrosion products that formed on the outside surface,
of time against saturated calomel electrode (SCE)
washed with distilled water, dried with clean tissue,
for all weight loss experiments.
rinsed in ethanol and dried by using electrical oven to a
3- Electrochemical polarization investigations in 5%
temperature about 110 ºC for 10 minute. Then the
H2SO4 solution to determine corrosion rate, specimen was kept in the desiccator to cool and then
i.e., corrosion current density using Tafel extrapolation weighted (w2). So that the corrosion rate can be
method based on anodic and cathodic polarization determined using:
278| International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, Vol.6, No.1 (Feb 2016)
Samar S. Hussein et al Corrosion of carbon steel in flowing Sulfuric acid
Previous studies [Alwash et al, 1987; Turkee, 2009; The Ecorr at 40 ºC is higher than that at 30 ºC and 50 ºC.
Hasan and Sadek, 2013] showed that the corrosion rate This behavior of corrosion rates indicates that the
in acidic solutions increases as the flow increases. combined effect of O2 solubility and molecular
Also, according to the experimental results in Table 1, diffusivity is highest at 60 ºC followed by 40 ºC and 50
it is possible to say that the measured cathodic ºC and 30 ºC i.e. at 60 ºC and 40 ºC the effect of these
currents (O2 reduction and H+ reduction) is affected by two parameters on the corrosion rate is maximum.
flow and that can be associated to the H+ diffusing These result agreement with literatures [Azambuja et.
through the corrosion products layer, where they are al, 2003; Hasan and Sadeq, 2013].
reduced to H2 gas. For that reason, the H+ reduction is Fig. 4 also reveal that initially the OCP has unstable
flow dependent [Ross et al, 1966; Poulson, 1993]. trend with temperature, while the asymptotic values of
OCP shifts to more noble values with increasing
temperature. This shift can be ascribed to the
formation and growth of a Fe2O3 film on the corroding
surface.
Fig. 7 shows the Ecorr versus velocity for carbon steel Table 2 shows that the values of corrosion potential
metal at constant temperature (40 °C). It can be seen (Ecorr) where slightly changed while the values of
the Ecorr shifts to more negative with increasing corrosion current densities (icorr) of carbon steel were
velocity from 0 to 400 rpm. Then small trend to increased with increasing in solution temperature.
positive with increasing velocity to 600 rpm. Thus, it
may be attributed this behaviour to an improvement of 0.2
the passivation by an increase of the oxygen supply 0.1
0 CS, T=40C
[Ochoa et al, 2005; Musa et al, 2011]. -0.1 u=0 rpm
-0.2
-0.3 u=400 rpm
E, V vs SCE
-0.5 u=600 rpm
-0.4
-0.5
-0.51 -0.6
T=40 C -0.7
Ecorr, V vs SCE
-0.52 -0.8
CS -0.9
-0.53 -1
-1.1
-0.54 -1.2
-0.55 0.1 1 10 100
i, mA/cm2
-0.56
0 200 400 600 Fig.9 Anodic and cathodic polarization curves of
u, rpm
Carbon steel at constant temperature and change
agitation velocity
Fig.7 Variation of Ecorr with velocity at isothermal
T=40 °C for 1 h immersion time (weight loss method) Fig. 9 shows the corrosion potential shift to more
positive with increasing velocity due to the increased
3.2 Polarization method
O2 transport to the surface. This agrees with previous
Polarization technique was also used to evaluate the findings [Foroulis, 1979; Mahato et al, 1980; Silverman,
corrosion rate of carbon steel in 0.52 M H2SO4 solution. 1984; Hasan, 2003; Hasan et al, 2011].
Plots of cathodic and anodic polarization curves were
used to determine corrosion currents density (icorr), Table 2 Polarization parameters for carbon steel with
corrosion potential (Ecorr), anodic Tafel slope (βa) and different temperature and velocity in 0.52 M H2SO4
cathodic Tafel slope (βc) as shown in Table 2. solution
T u βa βc Ecorr icorr
0.7 °C rpm V.cm2/mA V.cm2/mA V mA/cm2
0.5 CS, u= 0 rpm 30 static 0.2867 -0.2679 -0.545 1.2
0.3 T=30C static 0.2679 -0.4040 -0.522 4
0.1 T=40C 400 0.2493 -0.7265 -0.520 6
40
600 0.4663 -0.9657 -0.515 7
E, V vs SCE
-0.1 T=50C
T=60C 50 static 0.7535 -0.7535 -0.520 7
-0.3
60 static 1.1917 -1.4281 -0.518 14
-0.5
-0.7
-0.9 16
-1.1 14
-1.3 u= 0 rpm
12
1 10 100 CS
icorr, mA/cm2
i, mA/cm2 10
8
Fig.8 Anodic and cathodic polarization curves of
6
carbon steel in stationary condition at different
temperature 4
2
It is seen from the fig. 8 that the polarization curves are 0
shifted to the high current density region as the 20 30 40 50 60 70
T, C
temperature of H2SO4 solution is increased, indicating
the increase in the corrosion rate with the increase Fig.10 Variation of icorr with temperature at u=0 rpm,
temperature of H2SO4 solution as shown in Table 2. by polarization
281| International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, Vol.6, No.1 (Feb 2016)
Samar S. Hussein et al Corrosion of carbon steel in flowing Sulfuric acid
Ecorr, V vs SCE
to the metal surface by decreasing the viscosity and -0.515
enhancing the corrosion rate. The results for Icorr is
-0.52
comparable with weight loss method.
Fig.11 shows the Ecorr shifts to more positive with -0.525
increasing temperature from 30 to 40 °C and small -0.53
change when increase temperature from 40 to 60 °C,
-0.535
due to increase oxygen supply on the surface metal
with increase temperature. -0.54
0 200 400 600
u, rpm
-0.46 Fig.13 Variation of Ecorr with velocity at isothermal
u= 0 rpm T=40 ºC, by polarization
-0.48
-0.5 CS
Ecorr, V vs SCE
Conclusions
-0.52
-0.54 1) The corrosion rate was found to increase
considerably with increasing temperature for the
-0.56 majority of results. However, increasing rotational
-0.58 velocity clearly enhanced the corrosion rate for
-0.6 carbon steel.
20 30 40 50 60 70 2) The corrosion potential shows sharp decrease with
T, C time in first few minutes and then increase
reaching an asymptotic value beyond that.
Fig.11 Variation of Ecorr with temperature at u=0 rpm, 3) In weight loss experiments, increasing
by polarization temperature shifts the Ecorr to more positive at
stationary condition. Increasing velocity from 0 to
Fig. 12 and 13 shows the effect of velocity on icorr and 400 rpm shifts the Ecorr to more negative with at
40 °C. Then small trend to positive with increasing
Ecorr at isothermal temperature (T=40 °C), it is clear
velocity to 600 rpm.
that increasing the rotational velocity leads to an 4) The polarization curves are shifted to the high
increase in the exchange current density. The increase current density region as the temperature and
in the icorr is due to the increase in the transport of velocities of H2SO4 solution is increased, indicating
oxygen towards the metal surface [Foroulis, 1979]. In the increase in the corrosion rate with the increase
fig. 13, the increment in Ecorr with velocity is due to temperature and velocity.
increase in oxygen transport to the metal surface and 5) In polarization experiments, Ecorr shifts to more
positive with increasing temperature from 30 to
when the system is free from oxygen, velocity has no
40 °C and small change when increase
effect on corrosion potential (Ecorr) [Ross et al, 1966]. temperature from 40 to 60 °C. Increasing velocities
shifts the corrosion potential to more positive.
8
T=40 C References
7
6 CS Revie R.W. and H. H. Uhlig, (2008), Corrosion and Corrosion
icorr, mA/cm2
Transfer, Journal of Tech. & Eng., no.72, vol. 5, pp. 993- Alwash S.H., V. Ashworth, M. Shirkhanzadeh, and G.E
1007. Thompson, (1987), an Investigation of the Reduction of
Ciubotariu A. C., L. Benea, and P. L. Bonora, (2010), Corrosion Oxygen at a Rotating Disk Electrode with Heat Transfer
studies of carbon steel X60 by electrochemical methods, Facilities”, Corrosion Science, vol. 27, pp. 1301-1311.
Journal of Optoelectronics and Advanced Materials, no.5, Turkee H. M., (2009), Investigation of the Performance of
vol.12, pp. 1170 – 1175. Some Corrosion Inhibitors in Aerated Acid Solutions” M.Sc.
Musa A. Y., A. A. H. Kadhum, A. B. Mohamad, M. S. Takriff, S. K. Thesis Dept. of Chem. Eng., University of AL-Nahrain,
Kamarudin, and A. R. Daud, (2011), Determination of Mild
Baghdad.
Steel Corrosion Rate under Turbulent Flow in Highly
Ross, T. K., Wood, G. C., and Mahmud, I., (1966), The Anodic
Acidic Solution, journal of applied science, no. 13, vol. 11,
pp.2464-2466. behaviour of Iron-Carbon Alloys in Moving Acid Media, J.
Ajeel S. A., Waadulah H. M., Sultan D. A., (2012), Effects of Electrochem. Soc., vol. 113, pp. 334-345.
H2SO4 and HCL Concentration on the Corrosion Resistance Poulson B., (1993), Advances in Understanding
of Protected Low Carbon Steel, AL Rafdain Engineering Hydrodynamic Effect on Corrosion, Corrosion Science,
Journal, no.6, vol. 20, pp.70-76. No.1- 4, vol.35, pp.655-665.
Oguike, R. S., (2014), Corrosion Studies on Stainless Steel Azambuja D. S., Emilse M. A. Martinia, Iduvirges L. Müllerb,
(FE6956) in Hydrochloric Acid Solution, Advances in (2003), Corrosion Behaviour of Iron and AISI 304 Stainless
Materials Physics and Chemistry, vol. 4, pp. 153-163. Steel in Tungstate Aqueous Solutions Containing Chloride,
Mahato B. K., Cha C. Y., Shemlit W., (1980), Corrosion Science, J. Braz. Chem. Soc., Vol. 14, No. 4, 570-576.
Vol. 20, pp. 421-441. L. Cifuentes, (1987), Anti-corrosion, November.
Foroulis, Z. A., (1979), The Influence of Velocity and Hassan B. O., Abdul Kader H. D., and Abdul-Jabbar M. F.,
Dissolved Oxygen on the Initial Corrosion Behavior of Iron (2011), Experimental Study on Carbon Steel Corrosion and
in High Purity Water, Corrosion, vol. 35, pp. 340-344.
its Inhibition Using Sodium Benzoate Under Different
Scheers P.V., (1992), The Effects of Flow Velocity and PH on
the Corrosion Rate of Mild Steel in a Synthetic Mine Water, Operating Conditions, Iraqi Journal of Chemical and
J. S. Afr. Inst. Min. Metall., no. 10, vol. 92, pp. 275-281. Petroleum Engineering, Vol.12, No.3, pp.11-24 .
Shreir L.L., R.A. Jarman, G.T. Burstein, (2000), Corrosion Ochoa, N., F. Moran, N. Pebere and B. Tribollet, (2005),
Metal / Environment Reactions” third edition, Influence of flow on the corrosion inhibition of carbon
Butterworth-Heinemann Volume I, Great Britain. steel by fatty amines in association with
Slaiman Q. J. M., and Hasan B. O., (2010), Study on Corrosion phosphonocarboxylic acid salts, Corros. Sci., 47, pp. 593-
Rate of Carbon Steel Pipe under Turbulent Flow 604.
Conditions, The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Silverman D.C., (1984), Corrosion NACE, No. 5, Vol. 40, P. 220.
vol. 88, pp. 1114- 1120. Hasan, B. O., (2003), Heat, Mass, and Momentum Analogies to
Hasan B. O. & Sadeq S. A. (2013), Corrosion Behavior of Estimate Corrosion Rates under Turbulent Flow
Carbon Steel in Oxygenated Sodium Sulphate Solution Conditions, Ph. D. Thesis Dept. of Chem. Eng., University of
under Different Operating Conditions, Advanced Chemical AL-Nahrain University, Baghdad.
Engineering Research Vol. 2, Iss. 3. Pp.61-71.
283| International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, Vol.6, No.1 (Feb 2016)