Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.3233/JAD-180095
IOS Press
Abstract.
Background: The Philippines is experiencing rapid demographic aging and with it, the dementia epidemic. Prevalence of
dementia and associated risk factors have not been studied in the Philippines.
Objectives: The study aimed to provide a reliable estimate of dementia prevalence and identify associated risk factors in the
Filipino population.
Methods: 1460 participants 60 years and older were randomly selected from the Marikina City’s senior registry. A multi-
disciplinary team (nurse, psychologist, and neurologist) administered a comprehensive assessment to the study population:
health history, neurological examination, Geriatric Depression Scale, Neuropsychiatric Inventory, Disability Assessment for
Dementia, Alzheimer’s Disease 8, and Clinical Dementia Rating Scale. The neurologist analyzed all clinical data to diagnose
dementia based on the DSM-IV criteria, Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) on the NINCDS-ADRDA criteria, vascular dementia
(VaD) on the Hachinski Ischemic Scale, cognitive impairment no dementia (CIND) on a CDR score of 0.5 and not fulfill-
ing DSM-IV criteria for dementia. Risk factors were correlated with dementia prevalence using multivariate binary logistic
regression.
Results: 1460 persons were randomly selected. 1367 agreed to participate and underwent all assessments. The response rate
was 93.6%. Dementia prevalence was found to be 10.6% (95% CI 9.0 to 12.4) with the breakdown 85.5% AD, 11.7% VaD,
and 2.7% other dementias. In this population, 82.0% of men and 70.4% of women had at least one cardiovascular risk factor
(hypertension, diabetes, dyslipidemia, smoking), which was associated with VaD prevalence but not AD.
Conclusion: The prevalence of dementia, CIND, and cardiovascular risk factors are high in the Philippines.
ISSN 1387-2877/18/$35.00 © 2018 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved
1066 J. Dominguez et al. / Dementia Prevalence in the Philippines
by population in the world with its 4.4 billion people MATERIALS AND METHODS
making up 60% of the world population today (7.3
billion in 2015) [2]. The number of people aged 60 Study design and sample size
years and older in Asia is increasing rapidly, projected
to increase from 507 million in 2015 to 1.2 billion in The Marikina Memory and Aging Project was
2050, a 250% increase [2]. In 1915, 56% of the world a large population-based longitudinal study of
population aged ≥60 years resides in Asia. In 2050, dementia epidemiology among community dwelling
this proportion will increase to 62% [2]. As a result, Filipinos. This project is part of the St. Luke’s
Asia is becoming one of the oldest regions in the Institute for Neurosciences database on aging and
world, while many of its countries are not economi- dementia. To establish the cohort, a random sam-
cally prepared to cope with the political, economic, ple of individuals older than 60 years old was drawn
and social consequences of population ageing. from the senior citizen registry of Marikina City,
As the incidence of dementia increases exponen- proportionally representing the percentages of senior
tially after the age of 65 years old, nations in the world citizens residing in all 16 barangays (villages). Based
is facing a global epidemic of dementia, with low and on the estimated prevalence of 5% for South East
middle-income countries (LMIC) sharing the largest Asia from World Alzheimer Report 2009 [11], the
proportion, i.e., 65%. Currently, Asia has the largest minimum sample size required to achieve a max-
share, about half of the worldwide prevalent and inci- imum error of ± 1.5 and a confidence interval of
dent cases of dementia [3], while the majority of its 95% was 811 participants. Adding an estimated
nations (about two-thirds) are LMIC, where access to 20% non-response rate and loss to follow-up, the
social protection, services, support and care for peo- sample size yielded a total of 1,440 participants.
ple with dementia are very limited [3]. Like many Subsequently, a random sample of 1,460 partici-
other LMIC, the Philippines has been undergoing an pants ≥60 years old were selected from the senior
epidemiological transition caused by lifestyles and registry in the city of Marikina, which registered
behaviors associated with industrial and economic 17,790 senior citizens (4% of the total population
development, such as increases in high fat and sugar in Marikina).
diets, sedentary lifestyles, and tobacco use, leading to Two community health workers provided by the
dramatic increase in the prevalence of obesity, hyper- city government visited the selected individuals at
tension, diabetes, and hypercholesterolemia over the home and coordinated their visit to the commu-
last three decades [4–10]. These are well-established nity research site accompanied by an informant. An
risk factors for dementia that have not been ade- informant was defined as the person who knew the
quately addressed in the country. Because of the high participant well, such as a relative, a friend, a neigh-
prevalence of these specific risk factors, the Filipino bor, or a caregiver.
population can be considered a high-risk population
for developing dementia. However, dementia is not Evaluation procedures
recognized as a major public health problem in the
Philippines. As the extent of dementia epidemic has The evaluation was carried out by a multidisci-
not been estimated in the Philippines and research plinary team comprised of a nurse, a psychologist,
onto dementia is in general lacking, it is of paramount and a neurologist. Both the selected participant and an
important to provide knowledge about disease burden informant participated in the assessments. The Uni-
in order to raise awareness and inform policy makers fied Data Set Version 1.2 of the National Alzheimer’s
about the necessity of social and health care reform in Coordinating Council [12] was used but we excluded
dementia care. Knowledge about the attributable risks neuroimaging due to high costs and Unified Parkin-
of major risk factors to specific dementia subtypes is son’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) due to length of
key to develop intervention programs to address the time of administration. Some activities in the Func-
dementia epidemic in the Filipino population. tional Assessment Questionnaire were not applicable
With the working hypothesis that the prevalence hence was replaced by the Disability Assessment in
of dementia is high in the Philippines, we aimed to Dementia [13].
conduct the first population-based study to provide a
reliable estimate of dementia prevalence and associ- Nurse
ated risk factors in Filipino population 60 years and Demographic data and heath history: The nurse
older. obtained informed consent and interviewed both
J. Dominguez et al. / Dementia Prevalence in the Philippines 1067
demographic and clinical characteristics. Chi-square The characteristics of the study sample were
test was used to determine whether there was a signif- described in Table 1. The gender distribution was
icant association between categorical variables, while 29.5% male and 70.5% female. Age distribution was
Fisher’s exact test was employed when the expected equal between the two genders. The mean numbers
observation was less than five. Independent t-test was of school years attended for both men and women
used to determine if there was a statistically signif- was at 8.61 ± 3.97 but women had significantly less
icant difference between the means in two groups. education than men. The prevalence of cardiovascu-
Significance level was set at p ≤ 0.05. Risk factors lar risk factors is alarmingly high, with 80% of men
were correlated with dementia prevalence using mul- and 71% of women having at least one cardiovascu-
tivariate binary logistic regression. lar risk factor (smoking, alcohol abuse, hypertension,
diabetes, and dyslipidemia). Women had a slightly
Ethics higher prevalence of hypertension, dyslipidemia, and
depression than men, whereas the prevalence of
The study was approved by the St. Luke’s Institu- smoking and alcohol abuse was much higher in men
tional Ethics Review Committee. than in women (Table 1). It was striking that half of
the men in the study population smoked and abused
alcohol (Table 1).
RESULTS In all, 145 participants were diagnosed with
dementia, yielding a crude prevalence of 10.6% (95%
Data collection started in March 2011 and ended in CI 9.1 to 12.4). The age-standardized prevalence
February 2012. The flowchart of study participants is of dementia was 14.2%. Based on the proportion
illustrated in Fig. 1. Only 5.1% of the selected random of citizens 60 years and older which is 6.8% and
sample refused to participate. Another 1.2% dropped the total population estimate of 100.98 million in
out and did not complete the assessments. Therefore, 2015 [23, 24], it is estimated that 726,864 people
the number of participants included for analysis was in the Philippines are currently living with dementia.
1367 persons or 93.6% of the original sample (Fig. 1). The breakdown of dementia subtypes were 85.5%
Fig. 1. Flow chart of study participants. CIND, Cognitive impairment no dementia; AD, Alzheimer’s disease; VaD, vascular dementia.
J. Dominguez et al. / Dementia Prevalence in the Philippines 1069
Table 1
Characteristics of the study sample
Variables Male (n = 403) Female (n = 964) p∗∗
Age (M ± SD) 69.6 ± 6.5 70.1 ± 6.9 0.24
Education (M ± SD) 9.4 ± 3.8 8.3 ± 4.0 <0.0001
Risks Factors Present n (%) Absent n (%) Present n (%) Absent n (%) p∗
Cardiovascular riskδ (n = 1,347) 327 (82.0) 72 (18.0) 667 (71.0) 281 (29.0) <0.0001
Hypertension (n = 1,280) 194 (52.4) 176 (47.6) 539 (59.2) 371 (40.8) 0.03
Diabetes (n = 1,243) 61 (17.0) 298 (83.0) 168 (19.0) 716 (81.0) 0.41
Dyslipidemia (n = 1,062) 78 (25.7) 225 (74.3) 294 (38.7) 465 (61.3) <0.0001
Smoking history (n = 1,345) 217 (54.7) 180 (45.3) 92 (9.7) 856 (90.3) <0.0001
Alcohol abuse (n = 1,303) 163 (42.2) 223 (57.8) 74 (8.1) 843 (91.9) <0.0001
TBIδδ (n = 1,347) 10 (2.5) 389 (97.5) 20 (2.1) 928 (97.9) 0.65
Depression history (n = 1,347) 135 (33.8) 264 (66.2) 420 (44.3) 528 (55.7) <0.0001
Depression active in 2 years (n = 1,298) 120 (31.1) 266 (68.9) 390 (42.8) 522 (57.2) <0.0001
Depression episodes 2 years prior (n = 1,279) 89 (23.3) 293 (76.7) 278 (31.0) 619 (69.0) 0.01
∗ Obtained using Chi-square tests; ∗∗ Obtained using T-tests for independent samples; δ Cardiovascular risk includes presence of at least one
of following cases hypertension, diabetes, dyslipidemia, smoking history; δδ TBI means traumatic brain injury which may include TBI with
brief or extended loss of consciousness and TBI with chronic deficits or dysfunctions.
AD, 11.7% VaD, and 2.7% other dementias (Fig. 1). The association between demographics and health
The prevalence of CIND was 23.2% (317 cases). Age- factors and dementia prevalence was shown in
specific dementia prevalence was shown in Fig. 2, Table 3. Age was significantly associated with
demonstrating that it increased steeply with age. dementia risk and AD but not with VaD. Gender
There was no significant difference between gender- was not associated with dementia risk. Education was
specific prevalence for men and women in the overall significantly associated with reduced risk for demen-
prevalence, being 11.7% and 10.2%, respectively tia. Depression, alcohol abuse and dyslipidemia were
(z = –0.819, two-tailed p = 0.41). However, the risk of significantly associated only with VaD (Table 3).
dementia for men increased much steeper with age. Sensitivity analysis for separate gender showed that
At younger age, few men than women were affected age was consistently associated with dementia and
with dementia, but the reverse held true at the higher AD (p < 0.0001) but not for VaD in both men and
end of age spectrum (Table 2). women. Dyslipidemia was associated with increased
1070 J. Dominguez et al. / Dementia Prevalence in the Philippines
Table 2
Age and gender specific dementia prevalence
Groups Both Sexes Male Female 2-tailed p
Age Groups Dementia n (%) Total Dementia n (%) Total Dementia n (%) Total
60–69 years old 41 (5.9) 694 8 (3.8) 213 33 (6.9) 481 0.01
70–79 years old 75 (13.6) 550 29 (18.0) 161 46 (11.8) 389 0.05
≥80 years old 29 (23.6) 123 10 (34.5) 29 19 (20.2) 94 0.11
Total 145 (10.6) 1367 47 (11.7) 403 98 (10.2) 964 0.41
Table 3
Multivariate analysis of factors associated with dementia prevalence
Variables Dementia (n = 145) AD (n = 124) VaD (n = 17)
Exp () p-value 95% CI Exp () p-value 95% CI Exp () p-value 95% CI
Age <0.0001 <0.0001 0.58
Age (≥80 years old) 7.84 <0.0001 (3.78–16.25) 9.24 <0.0001 (4.23–20.18) 2.04 0.57 (0.18–23.58)
Age (70–79 years old) 3.50 <0.0001 (2.03–6.02) 4.03 <0.0001 (2.12–7.35) 2.10 0.31 (0.50–8.86)
Sex (Female) 0.65 0.17 (0.35–1.20) 0.67 0.24 (0.35–1.30) 0.54 0.53 (0.08–3.74)
Education 0.94 0.05 (0.88–1.00) 0.95 0.14 (0.89–1.02) 0.92 0.37 (0.76–1.11)
Smoking History 0.87 0.68 (0.46–1.65) 1.07 0.84 (0.55–2.09) 0.27 0.23 (0.03–2.33)
Alcohol Abuse 1.83 0.07 (0.95–3.51) 1.41 0.34 (0.69–2.87) 16.30 0.01 (1.95–136.44)
Dyslipidemia 1.44 0.16 (0.86–2.41) 1.09 0.76 (0.62–1.92) 26.37 0.01 (2.73–254.40)
Hypertension 1.23 0.42 (0.75–2.01) 1.08 0.78 (0.64–1.81) 3.86 0.22 (0.44–33.71)
Diabetes 1.08 0.82 (0.58–1.99) 1.21 0.56 (0.63–2.32) 0.44 0.36 (0.08–2.52)
Depression 2 years active 0.77 0.44 (0.40–1.49) 0.87 0.70 (0.44–1.74) 0.44 0.39 (0.06–2.95)
Depression episodes 2 years prior 1.87 0.08 (0.92–3.79) 1.47 0.32 (0.69–3.13) 13.46 0.01 (1.73–104.90)
Traumatic Brain Injury 0.48 0.51 (0.05–4.28) 0.57 0.62 (0.06–5.08)
Notes: Selection procedure is Backward LR: Stepwise Algorithm; VaD, vascular dementia; AD, Alzheimer’s disease.
risk for dementia, AD, and VaD in men (p = 0.05). through to 2050. The prevalence of dementia is
For women, depression was associated with increased projected to increase by 236% from 2015 to 2050
VaDrisk (p = 0. 02) but not for dementia and AD. for South East Asia, according to World Alzheimer
Report 2015 [3].
The prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors was
DISCUSSION alarmingly high. Hypertension was present in half
of the study population, double of the global age-
This is the first population-based study in the standardized prevalence of hypertension and the
country to provide reliable estimate of dementia current estimate for Filipino adult population over
prevalence and CIND. Prevalence of dementia in 20 years old [25, 26]. While mean blood pressure has
the Philippines was found to be high, with a crude decreased in many parts of the world, it is increasing
prevalence of 10.6% (95% CI 9.1 to 12.4). The age- in South East Asia, with low-income and middle-
standardized prevalence of dementia was 14.2%, the income countries sharing the largest burden in the
double of the updated estimate for South East Asia in global increase of hypertension prevalence [25]. The
2015 of 7.6% [3]. There was no gender-based dif- high rate of smoking among men (about half) in
ference in dementia prevalence between men and the study population is striking, reflecting the cur-
women. Prevalence of dementia has been found to rent shift in smoking from high-income countries
be higher in women than men in some countries but to low-income countries [4]. Furthermore, the high
not in all [3]. prevalence of alcohol abuse among men (about half)
The prevalence of CIND was also high at 23.2%. is of great concern and needs to be addressed.
A longitudinal follow-up of the cohort to determine The prevalence of diabetes in this study population
dementia incidence and attributable risk factors to was also the double of the global age-standardized
dementia incidence has subsequently been conducted prevalence of diabetes and triple of estimated for Fil-
and data is being analyzed. Together with data from ipino adults [4, 26]. Dyslipidemia prevalence in this
this study, we will be able to compute a projection for population was also almost the double of the esti-
the increase of dementia prevalence in the Philippines mate for Filipino adults older than 20 years old [26].
J. Dominguez et al. / Dementia Prevalence in the Philippines 1071
It is known that population mean cholesterol levels in clinical trials to delay progression of cerebrovas-
have been steadily increasing in South East Asia [4]. cular disease and potentially cognitive decline in the
The reason for the high prevalence of cardiovascular Philippines and Asia. The prevalence of CIND was
risk factors found in the study sample compared to also found to be considerable in this study popu-
the national estimates is most likely due to age, as lation. Since this is a population at high risk for
older persons have higher prevalence of chronic dis- developing dementia [22], they are target for pre-
eases, including cardiovascular diseases. There were ventive interventions. In order to precisely assess
differences in the risk factor profiles for men and the efficacy of preventive interventions on which
women, with women having higher prevalence of type of CIND, it is crucial to define whether AD,
dyslipidemia and hypertension, whereas about half VaD particularly subcortical SVD or mixed pathol-
the men abused alcohol and smoked. These differ- ogy is present by neuroimaging at baseline [32, 33].
ential risk factor profiles could partly explain the Subjects with high SVD burden at baseline may ben-
findings that the risk of dementia increased much efit most from the intensive vascular management
steeper with age among men than women (Fig. 2, program [34].
Table 2), although the overall prevalence was the Certainly, dementia is already a major public health
essentially the same for the two genders. Cardiovas- problem and will be increasingly so in the years to
cular risk factors were associated with VaD but not come. Therefore, it is critical to provide policy mak-
with AD and dementia. Despite the high prevalence ers with the reliable estimate of the disease burden
of cardiovascular risk factors, the proportion of VaD to raise awareness and advocate for the develop-
in this population (11.7%) was not as high as reported ment of health care and social strategies to address
in Asia [27], where the proportions of VaD vary from this rapidly growing dementia epidemic, including
20–50% of all dementia cases. However, the propor- adequately addressing the high prevalence of car-
tion of VaD has been found to be age-dependent in diovascular risk factors. Cardiovascular diseases are
Japan, being lower (8-9%) in the age group older than currently the leading cause of death in the Philip-
65 years old and higher (16%) in the age group 64 pines and stroke is the second [30]. At the moment,
years and younger [28]. Furthermore, cardiovascu- dementia diagnosis and management in the non-acute
lar risk factors were only associated with increased settings is not covered by PhilHealth, the national
VaD risk and not with AD in this study population. health insurance program to provide universal health-
The possible explanations could be the high preva- care coverage for key health issues. The patients and
lence of stroke and high mortality rate associated with their families are basically alone in their struggles.
stroke in the Philippines [29, 30]. Due to limited ser- They pay for the costs of care out of their pockets,
vices and resources, medical care for stroke patients if they can afford. Older individuals with dementia
including acute intervention, rehabilitation, and pre- are usually not prioritized in the face of limited fam-
ventive strategies addressing hypertension, diabetes, ily resources. The Philippines is experiencing high
and dyslipidemia remains inadequate [29]. There- growth rate in the past years. Therefore, it is impor-
fore, stroke in older individuals is likely a fatal event. tant to channel this economic gain into social and
This could also explain that age was not associated health care reforms to address the major public health
with increased risk for VaD in this study popula- problems in the country, including dementia and its
tion. Furthermore, due to the lack of neuroimaging, major modifiable risk factors, i.e. cardiovascular risk
patients with cerebral small vessel disease(SVD) factors and diseases.
could be misclassified as AD, and a large proportion
of mixed AD and VaD could also be missed in this
study. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This is a cross-sectional study therefore the
association found cannot firmly establish a causal This study was supported by grants from the
relationship. Furthermore, neuroimaging and other Philippine Council for Health Research and Develop-
investigations could not be carried out to precisely ment of the Department of Science and Technology
ascertain the dementia subtypes. With the high preva- (FP09011) and St. Luke’s Medical Center (09-010),
lence of cardiovascular risk factors, it is highly likely and with the cooperation of the Office of Senior Cit-
that there is a high proportion of cerebral SVD, a izens Affairs of Marikina City, Philippines.
highly prevalent finding among older Asians [31]. Authors’ disclosures available online (https://
SVD markers could be a potential target for treatment www.j-alz.com/manuscript-disclosures/18-0095r1).
1072 J. Dominguez et al. / Dementia Prevalence in the Philippines
[31] Hilal S, Mok V, Youn YC, Wong A, Ikram MK, Chen CL [33] Heiss WD, Rosenberg GA, Thiel A, Berlot R, de RJ (2016)
(2017) Prevalence, risk factors and consequences of cere- Neuroimaging in vascular cognitive impairment: A state-
bral small vessel diseases: Data from three Asian countries. of-the-art review. BMC Med 14, 174.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 88, 669-674. [34] van Dalen JW, Moll van Charante EP, Caan MWA, Scheltens
[32] Wallin A, Kapaki E, Boban M, Engelborghs S, Her- P, Majoie CBLM, Nederveen AJ, van Gool WA, Richard E
mann DM, Huisa B, Jonsson M, Kramberger MG, Lossi (2017) Effect of long-term vascular care on progression of
L, Malojcic B, Mehrabian S, Merighi A, Mukaetova- cerebrovascular lesions: Magnetic resonance imaging sub-
Ladinska EB, Paraskevas GP, Popescu BO, Ravid R, study of the PreDIVA Trial (Prevention of Dementia by
Traykov L, Tsivgoulis G, Weinstein G, Korczyn A, Intensive Vascular Care). Stroke 48, 1842-1848.
Bjerke M, Rosenberg G (2017) Biochemical markers
in vascular cognitive impairment associated with sub-
cortical small vessel disease - A consensus report.
BMC Neurol 17, 102.