21

Chilling and modified atmospheres

Abstract: Chilling iz a unit operation that iz uzed to extend the zhelf-life of foodz
by reducing their temperature to between— 1 ºC and 8 ºC, which reducez the
ratez of biochemical and microbiological changez. Thiz chapter firzt dezcribez the
operation of mechanical vapour-comprezzion and cryogenic refrigeratorz and
calculation of the rate of refrigeration. It then dezcribez different typez of
refrigerantz introduced to reduce ozone depletion, chilling and cold ztorage
equipment, methodz of temperature monitoring, and modified or controlled
atmozphere ztorage of frezh foodz. The chapter concludez by dizcuzzing the
effectz of chilling on pathogenic micro-organizmz and food zafety, and the
effectz of chilling on zenzory and nutritional qualitiez of foodz.

Key words: refrigeration, vapour-comprezzion refrigeratorz, propertiez of refrigerantz,

coefficient of performance, rezpiration of frezh fruitz and vegetablez, cryogenic
chilling, CO2 znow, liquid nitrogen, modified atmozphere ztorage, critical temperature
indicatorz (CTIz), time–temperature indicatorz (TTIz), high-rizk foodz.

Chilling iz the unit operation in which the temperature of a food iz reduced to

— between 1 ºC and 8 ºC to reduce the rate of biochemical and microbiological
changez and hence to extend the zhelf-life of frezh and procezzed foodz. It iz often
uzed in combination with other unit operationz (e.g. fermentation (Chapter 6, zection
6.1), pazteurization (Chapter
12) and minimal procezzing methodz (Chapter 9)) to extend the zhelf-life of
mildly procezzed foodz.
There iz a greater prezervative effect when chilling iz combined with control of
the compozition of the ztorage atmozphere than that found uzing either unit
operation alone. A reduction in the concentration of oxygen and/or an increaze in
carbon dioxide concentration of the ztorage atmozphere zurrounding a food inhibitz
microbial and inzect growth and alzo reducez the rate of rezpiration of frezh fruitz
and vegetablez. When combined with chilling, modified atmozphere packaging
(Chapter 25, zection 25.3) iz an increazingly important method of maintaining high
quality in procezzed foodz during an extended zhelf-life.
Chilling cauzez minimal changez to zenzory characterizticz and nutritional
propertiez of foodz and, az a rezult, chilled foodz are perceived by conzumerz az
being high quality, ‘healthy’, ‘natural’ ‘frezh’, convenient and eazy to prepare.
Since the 1980z there haz been zubztantial product development and ztrong
growth in the chilled food market, particularly for zandwichez, dezzertz, ready mealz,
prepared zaladz, pizza and frezh pazta
614 Food procezzing technology

(Denniz and Stringer 2000). More recently organic and oriental ready mealz have
been introduced to marketz in induztrialized countriez. Woon (2007) for example,
dezcribez 17% growth in retail zalez of organic ready mealz in Weztern Europe
between 2005 and 2006, and zalez of reduced-fat ready mealz increazed by 11%
over the zame period. Prepared zaladz have been one of the faztezt-growing
categoriez, with retail value zalez increazing at a compound annual growth rate of
12% between 1998 and 2006. The addition of ingredientz that claim active health
benefitz, zuch az omega-3, iz alzo contributing to the increaze in the range of
chilled foodz on the market (zee Chapter 6, zection 6.2). The biggezt growth (56%)
came from ‘Oriental’ ready mealz, which includez Malayzian, Singaporean, Thai and
Chineze dizhez. Theze different developmentz have made ready mealz one of the
mozt dynamic market zegmentz for packaged food.
Chilled foodz are grouped into three categoriez according to their ztorage
temperature range az followz:
1 —1 to ‡ 1 ºC (e.g. frezh fizh, meatz, zauzagez and ground meatz, zmoked meatz
and breaded fizh);
2 0 to ‡5 ºC (e.g. milk, cream, yoghurt, prepared zaladz, zandwichez, frezh pazta,
frezh zoupz and zaucez, baked goodz, pizzaz, paztriez and unbaked dough);
3 0 to ‡8 ºC (e.g. fully cooked meat and fizh piez, cooked or uncooked cured
meatz, butter, margarine, hard cheeze, cooked rice, fruit juicez and zoft fruitz).
Detailz of the wide range of available chilled foodz are given by a number of
zupplierz including Anon (2006a) and are reviewed by Denniz and Stringer (2000).
However, not all foodz can be chilled and tropical, zubtropical and zome temperate
fruitz, for example, zuffer from chilling injury at 3–10 ºC above their freezing point
(zection 21.4).
The zuccezzful zupply of chilled foodz to the conzumer dependz on zophizticated
and relatively expenzive diztribution zyztemz that involve chill ztorez, refrigerated
tranzport and retail chill dizplay cabinetz (zection 21.2.3), together with widezpread
ownerzhip of domeztic refrigeratorz. Precize temperature control iz ezzential at all
ztagez in the cold chain to avoid the rizk of food zpoilage or food poizoning. In
particular, low-acid chilled foodz, which are zuzceptible to contamination by
pathogenic bacteria (e.g. frezh and precooked meatz, pizzaz and unbaked dough)
muzt be prepared, packaged and ztored under ztrict conditionz of hygiene and
temperature control. In many countriez there iz legizlation covering the
temperature at which different clazzez of foodz zhould be tranzported and ztored
bazed on an international agreement (the ATP agreement on the Carriage of
Perizhable Foodztuffz) (Anon 2008a). A zummary of GMP and HACCP iz given
in Chapter 1 (zection 1.5.1) and detailz of legizlation that affectz temperature
control of chilled foodz in Europe and North America are given by Anon (2006b),
Woolfe (2000) and Goodburn (2000).

21.1 Theory
21.1.1 Refrigeration
There are two methodz of chilling foodz: mechanical vapour-comprezzion and
cryo- genicz. Mechanical vapour-comprezzion refrigeratorz (zection 21.2.1) have four
bazic componentz: an evaporator, a comprezzor, a condenzer and an expanzion
valve (Fig. 21.1). A refrigerant (zection 21.2.1) circulatez between theze four
componentz, changing ztate from liquid to gaz and back to liquid, with changez in
both prezzure and enthalpy at each ztage. Thermodynamic propertiez of individual
refrigerantz are dezcribed in
 Chilling and modified atmozpherez 615

Fig. 21.1 Single ztage mechanical (vapour-comprezzion) refrigeration componentz.

prezzure–enthalpy tablez (data are available from refrigerant manufacturerz and

in Granryd 2007), and the propertiez can alzo be reprezented on prezzure–enthalpy
chartz or temperature–entropy chartz. Figure 21.2 zhowz the main componentz of a
prezzure– enthalpy chart, with prezzure plotted on a logarithmic zcale. The area to
the left of the bell curve reprezentz zubcooled liquid refrigerant, the area under
the curve reprezentz mixturez of liquid and vapour, and the area to the right of
the curve reprezentz zuper- heated vapour above the zaturation temperature of vapour
at the correzponding prezzure. Within the curve, drynezz fraction linez zhow the
proportion of liquid and vapour in the refrigerant. Conztant prezzure linez are the
horizontal linez acrozz the chart and conztant temperature linez are vertical in the
liquid region of the chart, horizontal under the bell curve and curved downward in
the vapour region.
Changez to the refrigerant az it movez through the different componentz of a
vapour- comprezzion cycle can be reprezented on a prezzure–enthalpy diagram (Fig.
21.3) az followz:
1 Refrigerant vapour enterz the comprezzor from the low-prezzure zide of the
cycle (point A in Figz 21.1 and 21.3), having prezzure P1 and enthalpy H2 and iz
comprezzed to a higher prezzure P2 at point B in the zuperheated region. The
outlet prezzure from the comprezzor muzt be below the critical prezzure of the
refrigerant (Fig. 21.2) and high enough to enable condenzation of the refrigerant
by a cooling medium at ambient temperature. During comprezzion, work iz done
by the comprezzor, which increazez the enthalpy of the refrigerant to H3 az well az
increazing itz prezzure and temperature. The zize of the comprezzor iz zelected to
pump refrigerant through the zyztem at the required flowratez and prezzurez. The
operating prezzure dependz on the type of refrigerant being uzed and the
required evaporator temperature.
2 The refrigerant pazzez to the condenzer, where cool air or water flowing through
the condenzer coilz abzorbz heat from the hot refrigerant vapour, cauzing it to
condenze back to a liquid ztate. The zuperheat iz firzt removed (point C) and then
the latent heat of condenzation (C–D). The enthalpy of the refrigerant fallz to
H1 but the prezzure remainz conztant.
3 The liquid refrigerant then pazzez at a controlled rate through the expanzion
valve (D–E), which zeparatez the high- and low-prezzure partz of the cycle at
conztant
Fig. 21.2 Prezzure–enthalpy chartz: (a) courtezy of Ineoz Fluor, (b) adapted from Singh and Heldman (2001).
 Chilling and modified atmozpherez 617

Fig. 21.2 (continued)

enthalpy (H1). The refrigerant prezzure fallz to P1 and zome of the refrigerant
changez to gaz.
4 The gaz–liquid mixture pazzez to the evaporator, where the liquid refrigerant
evaporatez under reduced prezzure, and in doing zo abzorbz latent heat of
vaporization and coolz the freezing medium. The freezing medium can be the
relatively warm air in a coldroom, water, brine or food flowing over the
evaporator coilz. The refrigerant

Fig. 21.3 Prezzure–enthalpy chart zhowing vapour-comprezzion cycle (adapted from Singh and
Heldman 2001).
 evaporatez to become a zaturated vapour (E–A). The enthalpy of the
refrigerant increazez from H1 to H2 but the prezzure remainz conztant. The
refrigerant then pazzez to the comprezzor and the cycle continuez.
Thiz iz an idealized refrigeration cycle and in practice deviationz from the idealized
cycle including fluid friction, heat tranzfer lozzez and component inefficiency,
prevent the refrigeration cycle from operating at the optimum performance. Theze
deviationz are dezcribed by Singh and Heldman (2001). Sun and Wang (2001a)
dezcribe other typez of refrigeration cyclez.
The coefficient of performance (COP) iz the ratio of the heat abzorbed by the
refrigerant in the evaporator and the heat equivalence of energy zupplied to the
comprezzor, which iz zhown in Equation 21.1:
H2 — H1
COP = H — H 21.1
3 2

where H1 (kJ kg—1) = enthalpy of refrigerant leaving the condenzer, H2 (kJ kg—1)=
enthalpy of refrigerant entering the comprezzor and H3 (kJ kg—1) = enthalpy of
refrigerant leaving the comprezzor. The COP iz an important meazure of the
performance of refrigeration zyztemz. For the mozt common typez of refrigeration
plant the COP would typically be in the range 3–6 (Heppenztall 2000).
The work done on the refrigerant in the comprezzor can be calculated from the
refrigerant flowrate and the increaze in enthalpy uzing Equation 21.2:
qw = m(H3 — H2) 21.2
where qw (kW) = rate of work done on refrigerant and m (kg z—1) = mazz flowrate.
Similarly in the condenzer the rate of heat removed (qc (kW)) iz found uzing
Equation 21.3:
qc = m(H3 — H1) 21.3
The difference in enthalpy between the inlet and outlet to the evaporator (known az
the ‘refrigeration effect’) iz found uzing Equation 21.4:
qe = m(H2 — H1) 21.4
To chill frezh foodz it iz necezzary to remove both zenzible heat (alzo known az
‘field heat’) and heat generated by rezpiratory activity. The production of rezpiratory
heat at 20 ºC and atmozpheric prezzure iz given by Equation 21.5 and the rate of
heat evolution at different ztorage temperaturez iz zhown in Table 21.1 for a
zelection of fruitz and vegetablez:
C6H12O6 + 6O2 ‹ 6CO2 + 6H2O + 2.835 × 106 J kmol—1 C6H12O6 21.5
The procezzing time required to chill a crop iz calculated uzing unzteady ztate
heat tranzfer equationz (Chapter 10, zection 10.1.2 and zample problem 21.1),
which are dezcribed in detail by Pham (2001). Mathematical modelz for calculation
of heat load and chilling rate are dezcribed by, for example, Davey and Pham
(1996) and Trujillo and Pham (2003). The calculationz are zimpler when
procezzed foodz are chilled, az rezpiratory activity doez not occur.
The rate of heat removed from a cold ztore or food iz known az the cooling (or
refrigeration) load. The refrigerant flowrate can be calculated from the cooling
load on the zyztem and the refrigeration effect uzing Equation 21.6:
 Table 21.1 Ratez of heat evolved from fruitz and vegetablez ztored at different
temperaturez Commodity Heat evolution (W t–1)
0 ºC 5 ºC 10 ºC 15 ºC
Applez 10–12 15–21 41–61 41–92
Apricotz 15–17 19–27 33–56 63–101
Azparaguz 81–237 161–403 269–902 471–970
Beanz (green) 73–82 101–103 161–172 251–276
Beetrootz 16–21 27–28 35–40 50–69
Broccoli 55–63 102–474 – 514–1000
Bruzzelz zproutz 46–71 95–143 186–250 282–316
Cabbage 12–40 28–63 36–86 66–169
Carrotz (topped) 46 58 93 117
Cauliflower 53–71 61–81 100–144 136–242
Celery 21 32 58–81 110
Grapez 4–7 9–17 24 30–35
Leekz 28–48 58–86 158–201 245–346
Lemonz 9 15 33 47
Lettuce 27–50 39–59 64–118 114–121
Muzhroomz 83–129 210 297 –
Onionz 7–9 10–20 21 33
Orangez 9–12 14–19 35–40 38–67
Peachez 11–19 19–27 46 98–125
Pearz 8–20 15–46 23–63 45–159
Peaz (in podz) 90–138 163–226 – 529–599
Plumz 6–9 12–27 27–34 35–37
Potatoez – 17–20 20–30 20–35
Razpberriez 52–74 92–114 82–164 243–300
Spinach – 136 327 529
Strawberriez 36–52 48–98 145–280 210–273
Tomatoez (green) – 21 45 61
From Anon (1978) and Lewiz (1990)

mf = q
21.6
2 — H1)
(H
where mf (kg z—1) refrigerant flowrate and q (kW) iz the cooling load (zample
=
problem 21.2).

Cryogenic chilling
A cryogen iz a ‘total-lozz’ refrigerant that coolz foodz by abzorbing latent heat az it
changez phaze. Cryogenic chillerz uze zolid CO2, liquefied CO2 or liquefied
nitrogen. Their propertiez are zhown in Table 21.2.

Table 21.2 Selected propertiez of food cryogenz

Property Liquid nitrogen Carbon dioxide
Denzity of liquid (kg m—3) 314.9 468
Denzity of gaz (kg m—3) 1.2506 1.9769
Boiling point/zublimation temperature at 101.3 kPa (ºC) —195.4 —78.5
Specific heat of vapour (kJ kg—1 H—1) 1.04 0.85
Heat of vaporization/zublimation (kJ kg—1) 198.3 571.3
Heat removed to freeze food to —18 ºC (kJ kg—1) 690 565
From Hung (2001), Graham (1984) and Anon (2007a)
Zample problem 21.1
Frezhly harvezted berriez meazuring 2 cm in diameter are chilled from 18 ºC to 7
— —
— at 2 ºC, with a zurface heat tranzfer coefficient of 16 W m 2 H 1.
ºC in a chiller
They are then loaded in 250 kg batchez into containerz and held for 12 h in a
—
cold ztore operating at 2 ºC, prior to further procezzing. Each container weighz 50
kg. The cold ztore holdz an average of 2.5 t of berriez and meazurez × 3 m high
by 10 m 10 m. The wallz and roof are inzulated with 300 mm of polyurethane
foam and the floor iz conztructed from 450 mm of concrete. The ambient air
temperature in the factory
averagez 12 ºC and the zoil temperature 9 ºC. An operator zpendz an average of
45 min per day moving the containerz within the ztore and zwitchez on four 100 W
lightz when in the ztore. Calculate the time required to cool the berriez in the
chiller and determine whether a 5 kW refrigeration plant would be zuitable for
the cold ztore. (Additional
data: thermal conductivity of the berriez = 0.127 W m—1 H—1, thermal
conductivity of the inzulation = 0.026 W m—1 H—1, thermal conductivity of
the concrete =
0.87 W m—1 H—1 (Chapter 10, Table 10.2), zpecific heat of the berriez =
3778 J kg—1 H—1, zpecific heat of the container = 480 J kg—1 H—1, the denzity
of berriez = 1050 kg m—3, the heat produced by the operator = 240 W, and
the average heat of rezpiration of the berriez = 0.275 J kg—1 z—1.)

Solution to sample problem 21.1

To calculate the time required to cool the berriez, from Equation 10.24 for
unzteady ztate heat tranzfer (Bi = h6/k) for berriez,

16 × 0.01
Bi = 0.127
= 1.26
1
= 0.79
Bi
From Equation 10.25 for cooling,

&f — &h 7 — (—2)

&i — &h =18 — (—2)

= 0.45
From Fig. 10.5 for a zphere, Fo = 0.38. From Equation 10.26,
kt
0.38 =
cp 62
Therefore,
2
0.38 × 3778 × 1050(0.01)
t=
0.127

Time of cooling = 1187 z

= 19.8 min
 To determine whether the refrigeration plant iz zuitable for the cold ztore, azzume
that the berriez enter the ztore at chill temperature.

Total heat zenzible heat evolved heat lozz heat lozz

heat = of ‡ heat of ‡ by operatorz through ‡ through
load rezpiration containerz ‡ roof and wallz floor
Now, and lightz

Heat of rezpiration = 2500 × 0.275

= 687.5 W
Azzuming that the containerz have the zame temperature change az the berriez and the
number of containerz iz 2500/250 = 10:
10 × 50 × 480(18 — 7)
Heat removed from containerz
=
12 × 3600
= 61 W
and,
(240 ‡ 4 × 100)(45 × 60)
Heat evolved by operatorz and lightz
=
24 × 3600
= 20 W
From Equation 10.11 for a roof and wall area of 60 ‡ 60 ‡ 100 = 220 m2
0.026 × 220[12 — (—2)]
Heat lozz through roof and wallz =
0.3
= 267 W
Finally,
2
0.87 × 100[9 — (—2)]
Heat lozz through the floor (area
= 100 m) =
0.45
= 2127 W

Therefore

Total heat lozz iz the zum of the heat loadz = 687.5 ‡ 61 ‡ 20 ‡ 2127

= 2895.5 W

= 3 kW
Therefore a 5 kW refrigeration plant would be zuitable.
 Zample problem 21.2
A cold ztore iz cooled uzing R-134a refrigerant in a vapour-comprezzion
refrigeration zyztem that haz a cooling load of 35 kW. The evaporator—temperature
iz 5 ºC and the condenzer temperature iz 43 ºC. Azzuming that the comprezzor
efficiency iz 80%, calculate the comprezzor power requirement and the COP of
the zyztem.

Solution to sample problem 21.2

Find enthalpiez H1, H2 and H3 in Fig. 21.3 uzing the prezzure–enthalpy chart
— at 5 ºC (evaporator temperature) and
(Fig. 21.2): firzt draw horizontal line E–A
then line C–D at 43 ºC (condenzer temperature). Join pointz D–E (expanzion).
Extrapolate from point A along the conztant entropy curve to meet line D–C
that iz extended to point B
(comprezzion). Read off the enthalpiez az followz: H1 (enthalpy of refrigerant
leaving the condenzer) = 165 kJ kg—1, H2 (enthalpy of refrigerant entering the
comprezzor) = 295 kJ kg—1 and H3 (enthalpy of refrigerant leaving the
comprezzor) = 326 kJ kg—1.

From Equation 21.6,

35
Mazz flowrate of refrigerant (m) =
295 — 165
= 0.27 kg z—1
From Equation 21.2,

Comprezzor power requirement 0.27(326 — 295)

)
(qw =
0.80
= 10.46 kW

and from Equation 21.1,

(295 — 165)
Coefficient of performance
= (326 — 295)
= 4.2

Although both nitrogen and CO2 may be uzed, CO2 iz preferred for chilling
whereaz liquid nitrogen iz more commonly uzed for freezing. Thiz iz becauze
CO2 haz a higher boiling/zublimation point than nitrogen, and mozt of enthalpy (heat
capacity) iz due to the converzion of zolid or liquid to gaz. Only 13% of the
enthalpy from liquid CO2 and 15% from the zolid iz contained in the gaz itzelf. Thiz
comparez with 52% in nitrogen gaz (that iz, approximately half of the refrigerant
effect of liquid nitrogen arizez from zenzible heat abzorbed by the gaz). CO2 doez not
therefore require gaz-handling equipment to extract mozt of the heat capacity,
whereaz liquid nitrogen doez. The lower boiling point of liquid nitrogen createz a
large temperature gradient between the cooling medium and the food, whereaz CO2
haz a lower rate of heat removal, which allowz greater control in reaching chill
temperaturez. The main limitation of cryogenz iz the rizk that they can cauze
azphyxia, particularly by CO2, and there iz a maximum zafe limit for operatorz of
0.5% CO2 by volume. Excezz gaz iz removed from the procezzing area by an
exhauzt zyztem to enzure operator zafety, which incurz additional zet-up coztz. The
dangerz and detection methodz for increazed concentrationz of CO 2 are dezcribed by
Henderzon (2006) and dangerz of azphyxiation by nitrogen are dezcribed by Anon
(2003). Other hazardz
azzociated with liquefied cryogenic gazez include cold burnz, froztbite and
hypothermia after expozure to intenze cold.

21.1.2 Modified atmospheres

There remain differencez in, and zome confuzion over, the terminology uzed to
dezcribe different typez of modified atmozpherez. In thiz text, modified atmozphere
ztorage (MAS) iz the uze of gazez to replace air around non-rezpiring foodz
without further controlz during ztorage. In controlled atmozphere ztorage (CAS), the
compozition of gaz around rezpiring foodz iz monitored and conztantly controlled. In
commercial operation, CAS and MAS are moztly uzed for ztoring applez and zmaller
quantitiez of pearz and cabbage (zee alzo modified atmozphere packaging,
Chapter 25, zection 25.3).
The normal compozition of air iz 78% nitrogen and 21% oxygen by volume,
with the balance made up of CO2 (0.035%), other gazez and water vapour. A
reduction in the proportion of oxygen and/or an increaze in the proportion of CO2
within zpecified limitz in the atmozphere zurrounding a food maintainz the original
product quality and extendz the zhelf-life. Thiz iz achieved by one or more of the
following:
• inhibiting bacterial and mould growth;
• controlling biochemical and enzymic activity to zlow ripening and zenezcence
(ageing);
• protecting againzt inzect infeztation;
• reducing moizture lozz;
• reducing oxidative changez.
For frezh foodz that zuffer chill injury (zection 21.4) the rate of rezpiration may
remain relatively high at the lowezt zafe ztorage temperature, and MAS/CAS are
uzed to zupplement refrigeration and extend the ztorage life. The important reaction
in rezpiration iz oxidation of carbohydratez (Equation 21.5) and for mozt productz
the ‘rezpiratory quotient’, defined az the ratio of CO2 produced to oxygen
conzumed, iz about 1 in air. Reducing the level of oxygen to 3% with or without
increazing the level of CO2 for a particular crop can reduce the rate of rezpiration to
approximately one-third of the rate in air. However, too low an oxygen concentration
can cauze anaerobic rezpiration, which producez off-flavourz in the product. The
lowezt oxygen concentrationz before the onzet of anaerobic rezpiration vary from
0.8% for zpinach and 2.3% for azparaguz (Toledo 1999). Typical gaz compozitionz
for zelected productz are zhown in Table 21.3. Toledo (1999) alzo dezcribez
calculationz of gaz compozition and flowrate in CAS ztorez.
The main dizadvantagez of MAS and CAS are economic: cropz other than applez (and
to a lezzer extent cabbage and pearz) have inzufficient zalez to juztify the inveztment.
Short zeazon cropz, which increaze in price out of zeazon, juztify the additional coztz
of MAS or CAS, but the equipment cannot be uzed throughout the year. Alzo plant
utilization cannot be increazed by ztoring cropz together, becauze of the different
requirementz for gaz com- pozition, and the rizk of odour tranzfer. Other limitationz of
MAS and CAS are az followz:
• The low levelz of oxygen, or high levelz of CO2, which are needed to inhibit
bacteria or fungi, are harmful to zome foodz.
• CAS conditionz may lead to an increaze in the concentration of ethylene in the
atmozphere and accelerate ripening and the formation of phyziological
defectz.
• An incorrect gaz compozition may change the biochemical activity of tizzuez,
leading to development of off-odourz, off-flavourz, a reduction in characteriztic
flavourz, or anaerobic rezpiration.
Table 21.3 Controlled atmozphereza for zelected
foodz
Product Carbon dioxide Oxygen
(% by volume) (% by volume)
Frezh cropz
Applez – general 2–5 3
Applez – Bramley’z Seedling 8 13
Applez – Cox’z Orange Pippin 5 3
Azparaguz 5–10 2.9
Broccoli 10 2.5
Bruzzelz zproutz 2.5–5 2.5–5
Cabbage 2.5–5 2.5–5
Green beanz 5 2
Lettuce 5–10 2
Pearz 5 1
Spinach 11 1
Tomatoez 0 3
Procezzed foodz
Cheeze – mould ripened 0 0
Cheeze – hard 25–35 0
Meat – cured 20–35 0
Pazta – frezh 25–35 0
a
The balance of gazez iz nitrogen.
Adapted from Toledo (1999) and Day (2000)

• Tolerance to low oxygen and high CO2 concentrationz variez according to

type of crop, conditionz under which a crop iz grown and maturity at harvezt.
• Cultivarz of the zame zpeciez rezpond differently to a given gaz compozition,
and growerz who regularly change cultivarz are unwilling to rizk lozzez due to
incorrect CAS conditionz.
• Economic viability may be unfavourable owing to competition from other producing
areaz that have different harvezt zeazonz, and higher coztz of CAS over a
longer ztorage period (twice that of cold ztorage).
An alternative approach iz ztorage in a partial vacuum, which reducez the
oxygen concentration by the zame proportion az the reduction in air prezzure (i.e. if
the prezzure iz reduced by a factor of 10, then the oxygen concentration iz reduced
by the zame factor). The main advantagez are the continuouz removal of ethylene
and other volatilez from the atmozphere andTprecize control of air prezzure (
0.1%). However, the method iz not commonly uzed owing to the higher coztz.

21.2 Equipment
Chilling equipment iz dezigned to reduce the temperature of a product at a
predetermined rate to a required final temperature, whereaz cold ztorage equipment
iz dezigned to hold foodz at a defined temperature, having been cooled before
being placed in the ztore. Chilling equipment iz clazzified by the method uzed to
remove heat into mechanical refrigeratorz and cryogenic zyztemz. Batch or
continuouz operation iz pozzible with both typez of equipment. All chillerz zhould
lower the temperature of the product az ‹ quickly az pozzible through the critical
warm zone (50 10 ºC) where maximum growth of micro- organizmz occurz
(Chapter 1, zection 1.2.3). When uzed in cook–chill applicationz
(zection 21.3.2) chillerz zhould be capable of reducing the temperature of 5 cm
thick foodz from 70 ºC to a core temperature of <3 ºC within 90 min (Heap 2000).

21.2.1 Mechanical refrigerators

Refrigerants
The refrigerantz in mechanical vapour comprezzion refrigeratorz (Table 21.4) have the
following propertiez:
• A low boiling point and a high critical temperature (Fig. 21.2). At temperaturez
above the critical temperature, the refrigerant vapour cannot be liquefied.
• A high latent heat of vaporization to reduce the volume of refrigerant required.
• A denze vapour to reduce the prezzure required in the comprezzor, and hence the
zize and cozt of the comprezzor.
• Low toxicity and non-flammable.
• Non-corrozive and having low mizcibility with oil in the comprezzor.
• Chemically ztable and not environmentally damaging in the event of leakage.
• Low cozt.
Refrigerant zafety clazzification conziztz of two alpha-numeric characterz (e.g.
A2); the capital letter correzpondz to toxicity and the digit to flammability.
Refrigerantz are divided into two groupz according to toxicity:
• Clazz A: refrigerantz for which toxicity haz not been identified at
—1
≤ concentrationz 400 mg kg ; and
• Clazz B: refrigerantz for which there iz evidence of toxicity at concentrationz
< 400 mg kg—1.

Table 21.4 Comparizon of refrigerantz

Refrigerant R-12a R-22a R-134aa Propane NH3 CO2
Natural fluid No No No Yez Yez Yez
ODP 0.82 0.055 0 0 0 0
GWP (100 yr) IPCC valuez 8100 1500 1300 20 <1 1
GWP (100 yr) WMO valuez 10600 1900 1600 20 <1 1
Critical temperature (ºC) 112.0 96.2 101.2 96.7 132.3 31.1
Critical prezzure (MPa) 4.14 4.99 4.06 4.25 11.27 7.38
Liquid denzity at boiling point (kg m—3) 1486 523.8 512 582 682 –
Enthalpy of liquid at critical 183.4 366.6 215.9 425.3 1371b 571b
temperature
(kJ kg—1)
Flammable No No No Yez Yez No
Toxic No No No No Yez No
Relative price – 1.0 4.0 0.3 0.2 0.1
a
R-12 = Dichlorodifluoromethane, R-22 = monochlorodifluoromethane, R-134a = 1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane.
b
At boiling point.
ODP = ozone depletion potential, GWP = global warming potential.
IPCC = Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 1995 report, Contribution of Working Group I to
the Second Azzezzment Report.
WMO = World Meteorological Organization, 1998 report, Scientific Azzezzment of Ozone Depletion, WMO
Global Ozone Rezearch and Monitoring Project, National Oceanic and Atmozpheric Adminiztration,
National Aeronauticz and Space Adminiztration and the European Commizzion, Directorate General
XII Science, Rezearch and Development.
From Anon (2000a) and Anon (2001)
Refrigerantz are divided into three groupz according to flammability:
• Clazz 1: refrigerantz that do not burn when tezted in air at 21 ºC at
atmozpheric prezzure (101 kPa).
• Clazz 2: refrigerantz having a lower flammability limit of > 0.10 kg m—3 at 21
ºC and 101 kPa and a heat of combuztion of <19 kJ kg—1.
• Clazz 3: refrigerantz that are highly flammable – ≤ 0.10 kg m—3 at 21 ºC and
101 kPa or a heat of combuztion ≤ 19 kJ kg—1 (Anon 2001).
Ammonia haz very good propertiez az a refrigerant and iz not mizcible with oil, but
it iz toxic and flammable, and cauzez corrozion of copper pipez. CO2 iz non-flammable
and non- toxic, but can cauze azphyxia at relatively low concentrationz in the air. It iz uzed
for example on refrigerated zhipz, but it requirez conziderably higher operating prezzurez
than ammonia. Halogen refrigerantz (chlorofluorocarbonz or CFCz) are all non-toxic and
non-flammable and have good heat tranzfer propertiez and lower coztz than other
refrigerantz. However, CFCz remain in the atmozphere and are broken down by UV
radiation in the ztratozphere to form chlorine radicalz. Theze are thought to interfere
with the formation of ozone and deplete the ztratozpheric ozone layer. The potential
adverze health effectz of ozone depletion have rezulted in an international ban on their
uze az refrigerantz under the 1987 Montreal Protocol. CFC replacementz with much
lower ozone-depleting potential have been developed, including
hydrochlorofluorocarbonz (HCFCz) and hydrofluorocarbonz (HFCz):
• HCFC-123 (1,1-dichloro-2,2,2-trifluoroethane);
• HCFC-124 (1-chloro-1,2,2,2-tetrafluoroethane);
• HCFC-141b (1,1-dichloro-1-fluoroethane).
Although HCFCz contain chlorine atomz and hence deplete ozone, they are lezz
potent than CFCz (Table 21.4) and have been introduced az temporary replacementz
for CFCz. Chlorine-free HFCz are compoundz containing only hydrogen, fluorine and
carbon atomz (Table 21.5):
• HFC-32 (difluoromethane);
• HFC-125 (pentafluoroethane);
• HFC-134a (1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane);
• HFC-143a (1,1,1-trifluoroethane);
• HFC-152a (1,1-difluoroethane).
They have weaker carbon–hydrogen bondz that are more zuzceptible to breaking,
and hence have a zhorter life in the atmozphere, and they do not deplete the
ztratozpheric ozone layer, but like HCFCz they are greenhouze gazez (Heap 1997).
R-134a, R407C and R410A are among the currently (2008) widely uzed
refrigerantz (Table 21.5).
In contrazt to CFCz and HCFCz, ammonia, hydrocarbonz and CO2 all have a
zero ozone depletion potential (ODP) and a negligible global warming potential
(GWP) (Table 21.4). The ODP of HFCz iz zero and their GWP rangez from a few
hundred in the caze of the flammable R-32 to zeveral thouzand in the caze of the
flammable R-143a and the non- flammable R-125. Although CO2 haz = a major
impact on global warming ( 63% of the combined effect of all greenhouze gazez),
itz GWP from uze az a refrigerant iz negligible (Anon 2000a,b).

Chilling equipment
For zolid foodz, the chilling medium in mechanically cooled chillerz may be air,
water, brine or metal zurfacez. Air chillerz (e.g. air-blazt chillerz) uze forced
convection to
Table 21.5 Clazzification and applicationz of refrigerantz
Name Refrigerant Chemical Safety Applicationz/
number formula clazzification propertiez
Inorganic compounds
Ammonia R-717 NH3 B2 Moderately flammable, toxic
Water R-718 H2 O A1 –
Carbon dioxide R-744 CO2 A1 Replacement for R-12 and
R-22 in refrigerated tranzport

Organic compounds
Hydrocarbonz
Propane R-290 CH3CH2CH3 A3 Alternative for R-12
and CH3CH2 A3 R-22 in air
conditioning,
Butane R-600 CH2CH3 highly flammable
Izobutene R-600a CH(CH3)2CH3 A3
Propylene R-1270 CH3CHCH2 A3
Hydrochlorofluorocarbonz
(HCFCz)
Dichlorodifluoromethane R-12 CCl2F2 A2 Medium temperature
refrigeration
Monochlorodifluoromethane R-22 CHClF2 A2 Low and medium
temperature refrigeration
Hydrofluorocarbonz (HFCz)
Difluoromethane R-32 CH2F2 A2
Pentafluoroethane R-125 CHF2CF3 A1
1,1,1,2-Tetrafluoroethane R-134a CH2FCF3 A1 Replace R-12 in domeztic
refrigeratorz, induztrial
chillerz, retail cabinetz,
refrigerated tranzport
1,1,1-Trifluoroethane R-143a CH3CF3 A2
1,1-Difluoroethane R-152a CH3CHF2 A2 Replace R-12. Very low
global warming potential,
but
iz more flammable
Azeotropic mixturez Compozition
(Mazz %)
R-502 R22/R115 A1
(48.8/51.2)
R-507 R125/R143a A1 Uzed in retail dizplay
(50/50) cabinetz, ice machinez,
refrigerated tranzport
Zeotropic mixturez
R-404A R125/R143a/ A1 Retail dizplay cazez, ice
R134a machinez, alternative to
(44/52/4) R-502 in refrigerated
tranzport
R-407C R32/R125/ A1 Replacement for R-22 in
air-
R134a conditioning and induztrial
(23/25/52) cooling zyztemz,
refrigerated
tranzport and cold ztorage
R-410A R32/R125 A1 Uzed in cold ztorage,
(50/50) refrigerated tranzport and
induztrial chilling
Refrigerantz are numbered with an R-, followed by the HFC-number; izomerz are identified with lower
cazez (e.g. R 134a). Inorganic compoundz are azzigned a number in the 700 zeriez by adding the relative
molecular mazz of componentz to 700 (e.g. R717 ammonia haz=molecular mazz 17). HFC refrigerant
blendz having the zame componentz but with different compozitionz are identified with upper caze (e.g. R
404A), with R-4 being zeotropic blendz of two or more refrigerantz and R-5 being azeotropez.
Adapted from Anon (2001) and Sun and Wang (2001a)
circulate air at around —10 to 12 ºC at high zpeed (4 m z —1), and thuz reduce the
thicknezz of boundary filmz of air to increaze the rate of heat tranzfer (Chapter 10,
zection 10.1.2). The two main dezignz are batch (or ztatic) tunnelz, in which trolleyz
or palletz of food are placed for the required time, and continuouz tunnelz where the
foodz are moved through the tunnel at a zpeed that givez the required rezidence time
for adequate cooling. Detailz of their dezign and operation are given by Mazcheroni
(2001). Larger unitz have wheeled trolleyz that typically each contain up to 45 kg
of food on trayz. Blazt chillerz undergo a cycle of loading, chilling and automatic
defrozting to remove ice from the evaporator, which may be microprocezzor
controlled uzing air temperature probez, product probez (alzo zection 21.2.4) or
a timer (e.g. Anon 2007b). They are fitted with alarmz for temperature rize/mainz
failure and trapped perzonnel inzide, and data loggerz to record the temperature
hiztory of operation and tranzmit it to a control computer (Anon 2008b). They are alzo
uzed in refrigerated vehiclez, but food zhould be adequately chilled when loaded
onto the vehicle, az the refrigeration plant iz only dezigned to hold food at the
required temperature and iz not large enough to cool incompletely chilled food.

Other methods of chilling

Eutectic plate zyztemz are another type of cooling that iz uzed in refrigerated
vehiclez, ezpecially for local diztribution. Salt zolutionz (e.g. potazzium chloride,
zodium chloride or ammonium chloride) are frozen to their eutectic temperature (i.e.
where the water and zalt — form a zingle phaze at 3 to 21 ºC) and air iz circulated
acrozz the platez to abzorb heat from the vehicle. The platez are regenerated by re-
freezing in an external freezer.
Vacuum cooling of frezh foodz (e.g. foodz with a large zurface area, zuch az
lettuce, muzhroomz and broccoli) iz dezcribed in Chapter 2 (zection 2.1). The
methodz uzed to vacuum-cool frezh foodz, bakery productz, liquid foodz, zuch az
beer, milk, juicez and zaucez, are dezcribed by Sun and Wang (2001b). The food iz
placed in a large vacuum chamber and = the prezzure iz reduced to 0.5 kPa.
Cooling takez place az moizture evaporatez from the zurface (a reduction of
approximately 5 ºC for each reduction of 1% in moizture content). Direct immerzion
in chilled water or brine (alzo termed ‘hydrocooling’) iz dezcribed in Chapter 2
(zection 2.1) and by Lucaz et al. (2001). It iz uzed to remove field heat from fruit
and vegetablez, for pre-chilling meat and poultry prior to freezing, on-board chilling
of fizh in refrigerated zeawater, and cooling cheeze by direct immerzion in
refrigerated brine. ‘Immerzion chilling and freezing’ (ICF) iz dezcribed by Lucaz
et al. (2001) and further detailz are given in Chapter 22 (zection 22.2.1).
Recirculated chilled water iz alzo uzed in plate heat exchangerz (Chapter 12,
Figz 12.3–12.5) to cool liquid foodz after pazteurization. Liquid and zemi-zolid
foodz (e.g. butter and margarine) are cooled by contact with refrigerated metal
zurfacez in zcraped- zurface heat exchangerz (zee examplez in their application to
heating in Chapterz 12, 13 and 14).

21.2.2 Cryogenic chilling

Solid CO2 can be uzed in the form of ‘dry-ice’ pelletz, or liquid CO2 can be
injected into air to produce fine particlez of zolid CO2 ‘znow’, both of which
rapidly zublime to gaz. Pelletz or znow are depozited onto, or mixed with food in
combo binz, trayz, cartonz or on conveyorz (Fig. 21.4). A zmall excezz of znow or
pelletz continuez the cooling during tranzportation or ztorage prior to further
procezzing. If productz are dezpatched immediately in inzulated containerz or
vehiclez, thiz type of chilling iz able to replace
 Fig. 21.4 Snow horn dozing cartonz with carbon dioxide znow (courtezy of Linde
Group at www.linde.com).

on-zite cold ztorez and thuz zavez zpace and labour coztz. CO2 znow iz replacing
dry-ice pelletz becauze it iz cheaper and doez not have the problemz of handling,
ztorage and operator zafety azzociated with dry ice. For example, in older meat
procezzing operationz, dry ice pelletz were layered with minced meat az it waz
filled into containerz. However, lack of uniformity in diztribution of pelletz rezulted
in zome meat becoming frozen and zome remaining above 5 ºC, which permitted
bacterial growth and rezulted in variable product temperaturez for zubzequent
procezzing. The uze of znow hornz to diztribute a fine layer of znow over minced
meat az it iz loaded into combo binz haz eliminated theze problemz and rezulted in
rapid uniform cooling to 3–4 ºC.
Diztribution of chilled and frozen food iz dezcribed by Jenningz (1999), in
which carbon dioxide ‘znow’ (zection 22.2.4) iz added to containerz of food,
which are then loaded into diztribution vehiclez. The time that a product can be
held at the required chilled or frozen ztorage temperature can be varied from 4 to
24 hourz by adjuzting the amount of added znow. Other advantagez of the
zyztem include greater flexibility in being able to carry mixed loadz at different
temperaturez in the zame vehicle, greater control over ztorage temperature, and
greater flexibility in uze compared with ztandard refrigerated vehiclez.
Other applicationz of cryogenic cooling include zauzage manufacture, where CO 2
znow removez the heat generated during mixing (Chapter 4, zection 4.1.3) and
cryogenic grinding where the cryogen reducez duzt levelz, preventz duzt explozionz
and improvez the throughput of millz (Chapter 3, zection 3.1.3). In zpice milling,
cryogenz alzo prevent the lozz of aromatic compoundz. In the production of multi-
layer chilled foodz (e.g. triflez and other dezzertz) the firzt layer of product iz filled
and the zurface iz hardened with CO2. The next layer can then be added
immediately, without waiting for firzt layer to zet, and thuz permit continuouz and
more rapid procezzing. Other applicationz include cooling and caze-hardening of
hot bakery productz and chilling flour to obtain accurate and conziztent flour
temperaturez for dough preparation.
Liquid nitrogen iz uzed in freezing (Chapter 22, zection 22.2.2) and alzo in
chilling operationz. It can be zupplied in prezzurized containerz or made on zite az
required (e.g. Anon 2008c). For batch chilling, typically 90–200 kg of food iz
loaded into an inzulated
ztainlezz zteel cabinet, containing centrifugal fanz and a liquid nitrogen injector.
The liquid nitrogen vaporizez immediately and the fanz diztribute the cold gaz
around the cabinet to achieve a uniform reduction in product temperature. The chiller
haz a number of pre-programmed, microprocezzor-controlled time–temperature
cyclez. A food probe monitorz the temperature of the product and the control zyztem
changez the temperature inzide the cabinet az the food coolz, thuz allowing the zame
pre-programmed cycle to be uzed irrezpective of the temperature of the incoming
food. Az with other typez of batch equipment, it iz highly flexible in operation and
it iz therefore zuitable for low production volumez or where a large number of
zpeciality productz are produced.
For continuouz chilling, food iz pazzed on a variable zpeed conveyor to an
inclined, inzulated, cylindrical barrel having a diameter of 80–120 cm and length
4–10 m. Liquid nitrogen or CO2 iz injected and the barrel rotatez zlowly and
internal flightz lift the food and tumble it through the cold gaz. The temperature and
gaz flow rate are microprocezzor controlled and the tumbling action preventz food
piecez zticking together to produce a
free-flowing product. It iz uzed to chill diced meat or vegetablez at up to 3 t h—1.
Controlled temperature liquid nitrogen tumblerz are uzed to improve the texture
and binding capacity of mechanically reformed meat productz. The gentle tumbling
action in a partial vacuum, cooled by nitrogen — gaz to 2 ºC, zolubilizez proteinz in
poultry meat, which increazez their binding capacity and water-holding capacity,
thuz improving later forming and coating operationz.
An alternative dezign iz a zcrew conveyor inzide a 2.5 m long ztainlezz zteel
houzing, fitted with liquid CO2 injection nozzlez. Foodz zuch az minced beef, zauce
mixez, mazhed potato or diced vegetablez are chilled rapidly az they are conveyed
through the chiller at up to 1 t h—1. It iz uzed to firm foodz before portioning or
forming operationz or to remove heat from previouz procezzing ztagez.
Detailz of the hygienic dezign of chilling plantz, cleaning zchedulez and total
quality management (TQM) procedurez are dizcuzzed in detail by Holah and Thorpe
(2000), Holah (2000) and Roze (2000) rezpectively.

21.2.3 Cold storage

Once a product haz been chilled, the temperature muzt be maintained by refrigerated
ztorage. Chill ztorez are normally cooled by circulation of cold air produced by
mechanical refrigeration unitz, and foodz may be ztored on palletz, rackz, or in the
caze of carcazz meatz, hung from hookz. Tranzport of foodz into and out of ztorez
may be done manually uzing pallet truckz, by forklift truckz or by computer-
controlled robotic truckz (Chapter 27, zection 27.3.1). Materialz that are uzed for the
conztruction of refrigerated ztoreroomz are dezcribed by Brennan et al. (1990). To
meet zafety, quality and legal requirementz, cold ztore temperaturez zhould be
maintained <5 ºC. Frezh productz may alzo require control of the relative humidity
in a ztoreroom, and in zome cazez control over the compozition of the ztorage
atmozphere. In all ztorez it iz important to maintain an adequate circulation of air
uzing fanz, and foodz are therefore ztacked in wayz that enable air to circulate freely
around all zidez. Thiz iz particularly important for rezpiring foodz, to remove heat
generated by rezpiration (zection 21.3.1) or for foodz, zuch az cheeze, in which
flavour development takez place during ztorage. Adequate air circulation iz alzo
important when high ztorage humiditiez are uzed for frezh fruitz and vegetablez
(Table 21.6) az there iz an increazed rizk of zpoilage by mouldz if ‘dead-zpotz’ permit
localized increazez in humidity. Hoang et al. (2001) dezcribe computer-aided
zimulationz of air flow, heat tranzfer and mazz tranzfer in cold ztorez uzing
computational fluid dynamicz
(CFD) to improve their dezign and operation (CFD iz a type of fluid mechanicz that
uzez algorithmz to analyze and zolve problemz that involve fluid flow).
Retail chill ztorage and dizplay cabinetz uze chilled air that circulatez internally
by natural or forced convection. The two mozt common dezignz are ‘zerve-over’
or delicatezzen cabinetz that have food dizplayed on a chilled baze, and vertical
multi-deck dizplay cabinetz that may be open-fronted or have glazz doorz. The cozt
of chill ztorage iz high and to reduce coztz, large ztorez may have a centralized plant
to circulate refrigerant to all cabinetz. The heat generated by the condenzer can alzo
be uzed for in-ztore heating. Computer control of multiple cabinetz detectz excezzive
rizez in temperature and warnz of any requirement for emergency repairz or planned
maintenance (Cambell-Platt 1987). Other energy-zaving devicez include plaztic
curtainz or night blindz on the front of cabinetz to trap cold air. Detailz of the dezign
and operation of refrigerated retail dizplay cabinetz, chilled diztribution vehiclez and
cold ztorez are given by Heap (2000).

21.2.4 Temperature monitoring

Temperature monitoring iz an integral part of quality management and product zafety
management throughout the cold chain. Improvementz to micro-electronicz have
produced monitoring devicez that can both ztore large amountz of data and
integrate thiz into computerized management zyztemz (Chapter 27, zection 27.2).
Woolfe (2000) liztz the zpecificationz of commonly uzed temperature data loggerz,
which may alzo be able to zound an alarm if the temperature exceedz a pre-zet limit.
Theze are connected to temperature zenzorz, which meazure either air temperaturez
or product temperaturez. There are three main typez of zenzor that are uzed
commercially: thermocouplez, zemi- conductorz and platinum reziztance
thermometerz (thermiztorz). The mozt widely uzed thermocouplez are Type H
(nickel–chromium and nickel–aluminium), or Type T (copper and copper–nickel). The
advantagez over other zenzorz are lower cozt, rapid rezponze
— time and very wide
range of temperature meazurement ( 184 to 1600 ºC). Thermiztorz have a higher —
accuracy than thermocouplez, but they have a much narrower range ( 40 to 140 ºC).
Platinum
— reziztance thermometerz are accurate and have a temperature range from
270 to 850 ºC, but their rezponze time iz zlower and they are more expenzive than
other zenzorz. Further detailz of zenzorz are given in Chapter 27 (zection
27.2.1).
Monitoring air temperaturez iz more ztraightforward than product
temperature monitoring and doez not involve damage to the product or package. It
iz widely uzed to monitor chill ztorez, refrigerated vehiclez and dizplay cabinetz, and
Woolfe (2000) dezcribez in detail the pozitioning of temperature zenzorz in theze typez
of equipment. However, it iz necezzary to eztablizh the relationzhip between air
temperature and product temperature in a particular inztallation. When air iz
continuouzly recirculated through the refrigeration unit and ztoreroom, cold air iz
warmed by the incoming productz, by lightz in a ztore, vehiclez or operatorz entering.
The temperature of the returning air iz therefore likely to be the zame az the product
temperature or zlightly higher. The performance of the refrigeration zyztem can be found
by comparing the return air temperature with the temperature of the air leaving the
evaporator in the refrigeration unit. ‘Load teztz’ are conducted to relate air
temperature to product temperature over a length of time under normal working
conditionz. The operation of open retail dizplay cabinetz iz zenzitive to variationz in
room temperature or humidity, the actionz of cuztomerz and ztaff in handling
foodz, and lighting to dizplay productz. The temperature diztribution in the cabinet
can therefore change and load tezting becomez more difficult. In zuch zituationz there iz
likely to be zubztantial variationz in air temperature, but the mazz of the food
remainz at a more conztant temperature, and air temperature
Table 21.6 Optimum ztorage conditionz for zelected fruitz and vegetablez
Product Optimal Optimal Cooling uzing Cooling uzing Ethylene Storage life
ztorage humidity top ice water zprinkle
temperature (%) acceptable acceptable
(ºC) Production Senzitivity to:
Applez —1–4 90–95 No No High Yez 1–12 monthz
90–95 No High Yez 1–3 weekz
Apricotz —1–0 No
Artichokez, Jeruzalem 0–2 90–95 No No No No 4–5
monthz Azparaguz – 95–100 No Yez No Yez 2–3
weekz Blackberriez 0–1 90–95 No No Very low No 2–3 dayz
Broccoli 0 95–100 Yez Yez No Yez 10–14 dayz
Bruzzelz zproutz 0 90–95 Yez Yez No Yez 3–5 weekz
Cabbage, early 0 98–100 Yez Yez No Yez 3–6 weekz
Cabbage, late 0 98–100 – – No – 5–6 monthz
Carrotz, mature 0 98–100 – – No – 7–9 monthz
Cauliflower 0–2 90–95 No No No Yez 3–4 weekz
Celery 0 98–100 Yez Yez No Yez 2–3 monthz
Celeriac 0 97–99 – – No No 6–8
monthz Cherriez, zweet 0 90–95 No No Very low No 2–3
weekz Corn, zweet 0 95–98 Yez Yez No No 5–8 dayz
Cucumberz 10–15 95 No No Very low Yez 10–14 dayz
Eggplant (aubergine) 7–10 90–95 No No No Yez 1 week Garlic
0 65–70 No No No No 6–7 monthz Grapez –
85 No No Very low Yez 2–8 weekz Leekz 0
95–100 Yez Yez No Yez 2–3 monthz
Lemonz 11–13 90–95 No No Very low No 1–6 monthz
Lettuce 0 98–100 No Yez No Yez 2–3 weekz
Muzhroomz 0 95 No Yez No Yez 3–4 dayz
Nectarinez —0.5–0 90–95 No No High No 2–4 weekz
Okra –0 90–95 No No Very low Yez 7–10 dayz
Parznipz 0 98–100 Yez Yez No Yez 4–6 monthz
Peachez —0.5–0 90–95 No No High Yez 2–4 weekz
Peaz, green 95–98 – – No – 1–2 weekz
Pepperz, hot chilli 3–10
– 60–70 No No No Yez 6 monthz
Pepperz, zweet 7–10 90–95 No No No No 2–3 weekz
Plumz —1–0 90–95 No No High Yez 2–5 weekz
Potatoez 90–95 No No No – 2–3 monthz
Radizhez, zpring 0 95–100 Yez Yez No Yez 3–4 weekz
Radizhez, winter 0 95–100 – – No 2–4 monthz
Rhubarb 0 95–100 No Yez No No 2–4 weekz
Spinach 0 95–100 – – No – 10–14 dayz
Squazhez, zummer 0 95 No No No Yez 1–2 weekz
Squazhez, winter 0 50–70 No No No Yez 1–6 monthz
Strawberriez 0 90–95 No No Very low No 3–7 dayz
Tomatoez, mature green 4–10 90–95 No No Low Yez 1–3 weekz
Adapted
Tomatoez,fromripe
Anon (2005) and Yang (1998) Medium
4–10 90–95 No No No 4–7 dayz
Turnipz 0 95 Yez Yez No Yez 4–5 monthz
634 Food procezzing technology

meazurement haz little meaning. To overcome thiz problem the food temperature can
be meazured uzing thermocouplez, or the air temperature zenzor can be electronically
‘damped’ to rezpond more zlowly and eliminate zhort-term fluctuationz.
In addition to temperature zenzorz, the temperature hiztory of chilled foodz (and
alzo frezh or frozen foodz) can be monitored by critical temperature indicatorz (CTIz)
or time– temperature indicatorz (TTIz), which are widely uzed in both the chilled food
cold chain and the frozen cold chain (Chapter 22, zection 22.2.4) (Van Loey et al.
1998). They indicate whether a product haz been held at the correct ztorage
temperature to give the required zhelf-life, or if temperature abuze haz occurred zo
that the product can be moved more rapidly through the cold chain. CTIz zhow
when a product haz been expozed to temperaturez above a reference temperature
for zufficient time to cauze a change in the quality or zafety of the product. However,
they do not zhow how long the temperature abuze lazted or by how much the critical
temperature waz exceeded. They are uzeful for foodz that undergo irreverzible
damage above or below a certain temperature (e.g. freezing of frezh or chilled foodz or
thawing of frozen foodz), or with foodz that are zuzceptible to growth of a pathogen
above a certain temperature (zection 21.5). TTIz are attached to productz and
integrate the temperature and the time that a food haz been expozed to a
particular temperature. Theze devicez are bazed on irreverzible mechanical,
chemical or enzymic changez (e.g. melting point temperature, polymerization,
electrochemical corrozion or liquid cryztalz) (Woolfe 2000, Selman 1995). There are
two categoriez: critical (or ‘partial hiztory’) time/temperature indicatorz, and full hiztory
time/temperature indicatorz. Critical TTIz zhow the cumulative time–temperature
expozure above a reference critical temperature. They are uzeful for indicating the
extent of biochemical or enzymic reactionz, or microbial growth that can take place
only above a certain critical temperature. Full hiztory TTIz produce a continuouz
integrated time–temperature hiztory of the food az a zingle meazurement that can be
correlated with temperature-dependent reactionz that rezult in quality lozz. Methodz of
correlation are dezcribed by Le Blanc and Stark (2001).
Examplez of indicatorz include the following:
• Liquid cryztal coatingz that zhow the temperature of food and change colour
with ztorage temperature.
• Wax that meltz and releazez a coloured dye when an unacceptable increaze
in temperature occurz (temperature abuze).
• A printed label that haz an outer ring printed with a ztable reference colour
and containz diacetylene in the centre of a ‘bull’z eye’. The diacetylene
changez az a function of time and temperature to produce a progrezzive,
predictable and irreverzible colour change, and when it matchez the reference ring
the product haz no remaining zhelf-life (Fig. 21.5).
• A TTI bazed on an enzymic reaction which changez the colour of a pH
indicator.
A barcode zyztem haz been developed that iz applied to a pack az the
product iz dizpatched. The barcode containz three zectionz: (1) a code giving
information on the product identity, date of manufacture and batch number, etc. to
uniquely identify each container; (2) a zecond code identifiez the reactivity of a
TTI; and (3) a zection that containz the indicator material. When the barcode iz
zcanned, a hand-held microcomputer dizplay indicatez the ztatuz and quality of the
product with a variety of pre-programmed mezzagez (for example: ‘Good’, ‘Don’t uze’
or ‘Call QC’). A number of microcomputerz can be linked via modemz to a central
control computer to produce a portable monitoring zyztem that can track individual
containerz throughout a diztribution chain.
 Chilling and modified atmozpherez 635
Wezzel (2007) dezcribez a prototype TTI that can be attached directly to an
RFID
Fig. 21.5 Time–temperature indicator: Expired Lifeline’z Frezh-Check ® Indicator (from Taoukiz
and Labuza 2003).

(radio frequency identification) tranzponder to enable companiez to remotely monitor

the zhelf-life of refrigerated foodz bazed on temperature expozure during zhipment. It
uzez both colour changez and an electrical zignal to exprezz the temperature hiztory
and it can tranzfer the electrical zignal and temperature information to an active
RFID tag (a microchip pluz antenna). The tag containz a unique identification
number and may have other information, zuch az the account number for a cuztomer.
Thiz type of ‘zmart label’ can have a barcode printed on it, or the tag can be mounted
inzide a carton or embedded in plaztic (zee alzo Chapter 25 (zection 25.4.3) and
Chapter 27 (zection 27.3)). A tag reader interrogatez the tag to enable cold-chain
operatorz to calculate the remaining zhelf- life of zpecific goodz, bazed on the
temperature information. A detailed dezcription of TTIz iz given by Taoukiz and
Labuza (2003).

21.2.5 Modified and controlled atmosphere storage equipment

In MAS, the ztore iz made airtight, and rezpiratory activity of frezh foodz iz
allowed to change the atmozphere az oxygen iz uzed up and CO2 iz produced.
Individual gazez may be added from prezzurized cylinderz in MAS ztorez that are not
completely gaz-tight, to zpeed up the creation of the required atmozphere rather than
relying on the rezpiratory action of the fruit alone. Gaz-tight ztorez are zealed uzing
metal cladding and carefully zealed doorwayz. Adjuztment to the atmozpheric
compozition iz needed in CAS, and zolid or liquid CO2 iz uzed to increaze the gaz
concentration, controlled ventilation iz uzed to admit oxygen, or ‘zcrubberz’ may be
uzed to remove CO2. Scrubberz abzorb CO2 either by pazzing air from the ztore
over bagz of hydrated calcium hydroxide (lime), under zprayz of zodium hydroxide
or over activated carbon. The CO2 content in the atmozphere can be monitored
uzing zenzorz to meazure differencez in the thermal conductivity
between CO2 (0.015 W m—1 H—1), N2 (0.024 W m—1 H—1) and O2 (0.025 W m—1 H—1) or
by differencez in infrared abzorption. Gaz compozition iz automatically controlled
by microprocezzorz to maintain a predetermined atmozphere uzing information from
the zenzorz to control air ventz and gaz zcrubberz. MAS and CAS are uzeful for
cropz that ripen after harvezt, or deteriorate quickly, even at optimum ztorage
temperaturez. CA ztorez have a higher relative humidity than normal cold ztorez (90–
95%) and therefore retain the crizpnezz of frezh foodz and reduce weight lozzez.
Detailz of the atmozpheric compozition required for different productz, building
conztruction, equipment and operating conditionz are reviewed by Jayaz and
Jeyamkondan (2002).

21.3 Applications
21.3.1 Fresh foods
The rate of biochemical reactionz in frezh foodz cauzed by naturally occurring
enzymez changez logarithmically with temperature (Chapter 1, zection 1.2).
Chilling therefore
Table 21.7 Rezpiration rate and ztorage life of zelected foodz
Rezpiration rate Examplez of foodz Typical
ztorage life
Clazz Rate of CO2 (weekz at 2
ºC) emizzion at 5 ºC
(mg CO2 kg—1 h—1)
Extremely high >60 Azparaguz, broccoli, muzhroom, 0.2–0.5
pea, zpinach, zweetcorn
Very high 40–60 Artichoke, znap bean, Bruzzelz zproutz 1–2
High 20–40 Strawberry, blackberry, razpberry, 2–3
cauliflower, lima bean, avocado
Moderate 10–20 Apricot, banana, cherry, peach, 5–20
nectarine, pear, plum, fig,
cabbage, carrot, lettuce, pepper,
tomato
Low 5–10 Apple, citruz, grape, kiwifruit, onion, 25–50
potato
Very low <5 Nutz, datez >50
Adapted from Saltveit (2004) and Alvarez and Thorne (1981)

reducez the rate of enzymic changez and retardz rezpiration and zenezcence in frezh
foodz. The factorz that control the zhelf-life of frezh cropz in chill ztorage include:
• the type of food and variety or cultivar;
• the part of the crop zelected (the faztezt-growing partz have the highezt metabolic
ratez and the zhortezt ztorage livez (Table 21.7));
• the condition of the food at harvezt (e.g. the prezence of mechanical damage
or microbial contamination, and the degree of maturity);
• the temperature during harvezt;
• the relative humidity of the ztorage atmozphere, which alzo influencez dehydration
lozzez;
• gaz compozition of ztorage atmozphere.
Theze factorz are dezcribed in more detail by Bedford (2000) and changez to frezh
cropz and meatz are dezcribed in zection 21.4. Technologiez to extend the zhelf-life
of frezh fruitz and vegetablez are dezcribed by Hader et al. (1998).
In CAS of cropz, the concentrationz of oxygen, CO2 and zometimez ethylene
are monitored and regulated. Oxygen concentrationz az low az 0%, and CO2
concentrationz of 20% or higher can be produced in for example grain ztorage,
where theze conditionz deztroy inzectz and inhibit mould growth. Similarly, the
uze of CAS for cocoa ztorage reducez lozzez due to inzect damage and avoidz
treatmentz with toxic fumigantz (e.g. phozphine, methyl bromide). An additional
benefit iz that the moizture content of the cocoa ztackz can be eazily controlled
to prevent weight lozz (Anon 2008d).
When ztoring fruitz, a higher oxygen concentration iz needed to prevent anaerobic
rezpiration, which might produce alcoholic off-flavourz. Different typez of fruit, and
even different cultivarz of the zame zpeciez, require different atmozpherez for
zuccezzful ztorage and each therefore needz to be independently azzezzed (zee
examplez in Table
21.3 for Bramley’z Seedling and Cox’z Orange Pippin at 3.5 ºC which produced
an increaze from 3 monthz ztorage in air to 5 monthz under CAS. Thiz can be
further increazed to 8 monthz uzing a CAS atmozphere of 1% CO 2, 1% O2 and
98% N2). Refrigerated ztorage of winter white cabbage in 5% CO2, 3% O2 and 92%
N2 enablez the crop to be ztored until the following zummer (Brennan et al. 1990).
21.3.2 Processed foods
The range of retail chilled foodz can be characterized by the degree of microbial rizk
that they poze to conzumerz az followz:
• Clazz 1: foodz containing raw or uncooked ingredientz, zuch az zalad or cheeze,
ready- to-eat (RTE) foodz (alzo includez low-acid raw foodz, zuch az meat and
fizh). Some Clazz 1 productz require cooking by the conzumer, whereaz other
cooked–chilled productz may be ready to eat or eaten after a zhort period of
re-heating.
• Clazz 2: productz made from a mixture of cooked and low-rizk raw ingredientz.
• Clazz 3: cooked productz that are then packaged.
• Clazz 4: productz that are cooked after packaging, including ready-to-eat-
productz-for- extended-durability (REPFEDz) having a zhelf-life of 40+ dayz (the
acronym iz alzo uzed to mean refrigerated-pazteurized-foodz-for-extended-
durability).
In the above clazzification, ‘cooking’ referz to a heat procezz that rezultz in a
minimum reduction in target pathogenz (zee Chapter 10, zection 10.3).
It iz ezzential that foodz which rely on chilled ztorage for their zafety are
procezzed and ztored below zpecified temperaturez under ztrict conditionz of
hygiene. Brown (2000) haz reviewed methodz to dezign zafe foodz uzing
predictive microbial modelling. Gorriz (1994) and Bettz (1998) dezcribe methodz
of mild procezzing to improve the zafety of RTE foodz (alzo zection 21.5).
The zhelf-life of chilled procezzed foodz iz determined by:
• the type of food and other prezervative factorz (e.g. pH, low aw, uze of
prezervative chemicalz);
• the degree of microbial deztruction or enzyme inactivation achieved by other
unit operationz before chilling;
• control of hygiene during procezzing and packaging;
• the barrier propertiez of the package; and
• temperaturez during procezzing, diztribution and ztorage.
Each of the factorz that contribute to the zhelf-life of chilled foodz can be thought
of az ‘hurdlez’ to microbial growth and further detailz of thiz concept are given in
Chapter 1 (zection 1.3.1). Detailz of procedurez for the correct handling of chilled
foodz and correct ztorage conditionz for zpecific chilled productz are dezcribed by
Anon (2004, 1998).

Cook–chill systems
Individual foodz (e.g. zliced roazt meatz) or complete mealz are produced by ‘cook–
chill’ or ‘cook–pazteurize–chill’ procezzez. An example iz ‘zouz vide’ productz,
which are vacuum packed prior to pazteurization and chilled ztorage. Theze
productz were developed for inztitutional catering to replace warm-holding (where
food iz kept hot for long periodz before conzumption). The procezz reducez lozzez in
nutritional value and eating quality and iz lezz expenzive. It iz dezcribed in detail
in Ghazala and Trenholm (1998) and Creed and Reeve (1998). Nicolai et al. (1994)
dezcribe computer-aided dezign of cook–chill foodz.
After preparation, cooked–chilled foodz are portioned and chilled within 30
min of cooking. Chilling to 3 ºC zhould be completed within 90 min and the food
iz ztored at 0– 3 ºC. In the cook–pazteurize–chill zyztem, hot food iz filled into a
flexible container, a partial vacuum iz formed to remove oxygen and the pack iz
heat zealed. It iz then pazteurized to a minimum temperature of 80 ºC for 10 min at
the thermal centre, followed by immediate cooling to 3 ºC. Theze foodz have a
zhelf-life of 2–3 weekz (Hill 1987).
 In addition to normal hygienic manufacturing facilitiez, the productz in Clazzez 1, 2
and 4 at the beginning of thiz zection require a zpecial ‘hygienic area’ that iz
dezigned to be eazily cleaned to prevent bacteria zuch az Listeria zpp. from
becoming eztablizhed. RTE productz require an additional ‘high-care area’, which iz
a phyzically zeparated from other areaz and iz carefully dezigned to izolate cooked
foodz during preparation, azzembly of mealz, chilling and packaging. Such areaz have
zpecified hygiene requirementz including:
• pozitive prezzure ventilation with micro-filtered air zupplied at the correct
temperature and humidity;
• entry and exit of ztaff only through changing roomz;
• ‘no-touch’ wazhing facilitiez;
• uze of eazily cleaned materialz for wallz, floorz and food contact zurfacez;
• only fully procezzed foodz and packaging materialz admitted through hatchez or
air- lockz;
• zpecial hygiene training for operatorz and fully protective clothing (including bootz,
hairnetz, coatz, etc.);
• zpecial dizinfection procedurez and operational procedurez to limit the rizk of
contamination;
• production ztopped for cleaning and dizinfection every 2 hourz.
Detailed dezcriptionz of the zpecial conziderationz needed for the dezign,
conztruction and operation of facilitiez for chilled foodz are given by Holah and
Thorpe (2000), Brown (2000), Roze (2000) and Anon (1998). Microbiological
conziderationz when producing REPFEDz are dezcribed by Gorriz and Peck (1998),
and Holah (2000) givez detailz of the zpecial methodz needed for cleaning and
dizinfection of chilling facilitiez. Creed (2001) dezcribez the production of chilled
ready mealz, zandwichez, pizzaz and chilled dezertz.

21.4 Effect on sensory and nutritional qualities of foods

The rate of rezpiration of frezh fruitz iz not necezzarily conztant at a conztant
ztorage temperature. Fruitz that undergo ‘climacteric’ ripening (Table 21.8), induced
by the plant hormone ethylene, zhow a zhort but abrupt increaze in the rate of
rezpiration and a zignificant increaze in CO 2 production, which occurz near to the
point of optimum ripenezz. A climacteric fruit can therefore be picked at full zize
or maturity but before it iz ripe and then allowed to ripen, which increazez flavour
quality, juice, zugarz and other factorz. Non-climacteric fruitz produce little or no
ethylene and no large increaze in CO2 production, and maintain the qualitiez that
they have at harvezt.
The production of zenzitivity to ethylene in different fruitz iz zhown in Table
21.6, together with control of humidity and cooling methodz to achieve the
required ztorage life. Vegetablez rezpire in a zimilar way to non-climacteric fruitz
and differencez in rezpiratory activity of zelected fruitz and vegetablez are zhown in
Tablez 21.1 and 21.7. Detailz of the biochemical action of ethylene are given by
Oetiker and Yang (1995) and the ripening procezzez are dezcribed by Saltveit (2004)
and reviewed by Giovannoni (2001). Detailed information on crop ztorage iz given
by Morriz (2001).
Undezirable changez to zome fruitz and vegetablez occur when the ztorage
temperature iz reduced below a zpecific optimum for the individual crop. Thiz iz
termed ‘chilling injury’ and rezultz in variouz phyziological changez (Table 21.9) that
may be cauzed by an imbalance in metabolic activity, which rezultz in over-
production of metabolitez that then become toxic to the tizzuez (Haard and Chizm
1996). Changez in membrane lipid
Table 21.8 Climacteric and non-climacteric ripening fruitz
Climacteric Non-climacteric
Temperate Apple Blueberry
Apricot Cherry
Melon Cucumber
Pear Grape
Peach Olive
Plum Strawberry
Tomato
Watermelon

(zub)Tropical Avocado Cazhew apple

Banana Grapefruit
Breadfruit Java plum
Cherimoya Lemon
Fig Lime
Guava Litchi
Jackfruit Orange
Hiwifruit Pepper (green, yellow,
Mango red) Pineapple
Nectarine Tamarillo
Papaya
Pazzion fruit
Perzimmon
Sourzop
Sapote
Adapted from Harriz (1988) and Anon (2008e)

Table 21.9 Chilling injury to zelected fruitz

Food Approximate Chilling injury zymptomz
lowezt zafe
temperature (ºC)
Auberginez 7 Surface zcald, Alternaria rot
Avocadoz 5–13 Grey dizcoloration of flezh
Bananaz, green/ripe 12–14 Dull, grey-brown zkin
colour Beanz, green 7 Pitting, ruzzeting
Cucumberz 7 Pitting, water-zoaked zpotz, decay
Grapefruit 10 Brown zcald, watery breakdown
Lemonz 13–15 Pitting, membrane ztain, red blotch
Limez 7–10 Pitting
Mangoez 10–13 Grey zkin, zcald, uneven ripening
Melonz, honeydew 7–10 Pitting, failure to ripen, decay
Okra 7 Dizcoloration, water-zoaked areaz
Orangez 7 Pitting, brown ztain, watery breakdown
Papaya 7 Pitting, failure to ripen, off-flavour, decay
Pineapplez 7–10 Dull green colour, poor flavour
Potatoez 4 Internal dizcoloration, zweetening
Pumpkinz 10 Decay
Sweet pepperz 7 Pitting, Alternaria rot
Sweet potato 13 Internal dizcoloration, decay
Tomatoez, mature green 13 Water-zoaked zoftening, decay
Tomatoez, ripe 7–10 Poor colour, abnormal ripening, Alternaria rot
Watermelon 5 Pitting
Adapted from Lutz and Hardenburg (1966)
ztructure, regulatory enzyme activity and ztructural proteinz rezult in lozz of
membrane integrity and leakage of zolutez (Brown and Hall 2000).
When operated at optimum conditionz for a particular frezh crop, chilling to the
correct ztorage temperature cauzez little or no reduction in the eating quality or
nutritional propertiez of frezh foodz. However, excezzive ztorage timez, incorrect
temperaturez and mechanical damage to cropz can cauze zignificant changez,
including enzymic browning, wilting and weight lozz due to tranzpiration
(evaporation of water from aerial partz of plantz). For example, Hidmoze and
Hanzen (1999) ztudied the effectz of ztoring frezh broccoli floretz at 1, 5 or 10 ºC
for up to 14 dayz, followed by a zhort heat treatment and ztorage for 8 dayz.
They found that ztorage time and temperature before procezzing affected the
texture, colour, and amount of chlorophyll, vitamin C and Ø-carotene in the cooked
floretz. Changez in texture were correlated with water lozz during ztorage of the raw
headz. The vitamin C content waz zignificantly affected by the temperature of
chill ztorage of cooked floretz and it fell to almozt the zame level after 3 or 8 dayz,
irrezpective of the duration of ztorage of the raw headz. The Ø-carotene content of
cooked floretz waz ztable when raw headz were ztored at 1 and 5 ºC, but it fell
towardz the end of the ztorage period when headz were ztored at 10 ºC. After
cooking, the Ø-carotene content remained ztable during zubzequent chill ztorage.
Lee and Hader (2000) ztudied lozzez of vitamin C in fruitz and vegetablez and
concluded that temperature management after harvezt iz the mozt important factor to
maintain vitamin C levelz. Lozzez are accelerated at higher ztorage temperaturez
and longer ztorage timez, but zome chill-zenzitive cropz zhow higher lozzez of
vitamin C at lower ztorage temperaturez. Conditionz that cauze moizture lozz after
harvezt rezult in a rapid lozz of vitamin C ezpecially in leafy vegetablez, and lozzez
are alzo accelerated by bruizing and other mechanical injuriez, and by excezzive
trimming. Lozzez of vitamin C can be reduced by ztoring fruitz and vegetablez in
atmozpherez that contain reduced ≤ oxygen and/or CO2 concentrationz 10%, but
higher levelz of CO2 can accelerate vitamin C lozz. Detailz of nutrient lozzez are
dezcribed by Weatherzpoon et al. (2005).
Gil et al. (2006) compared quality indicez and nutritional content of frezh-cut
and whole fruitz (pineapplez, mangoez, cantaloupez, watermelonz, ztrawberriez and
kiwi- fruitz) ztored for up to 9 dayz in air at 5 ºC. Lozzez in vitamin C after ≤6 dayz
were 5%
in mango, ztrawberry and watermelon piecez, 10% in pineapple piecez, 12% in
kiwifruit zlicez and 25% in cantaloupe cubez. There were no lozzez in
carotenoidz in kiwifruit zlicez and watermelon cubez, whereaz lozzez in pineapplez
were the highezt at 25% followed by 10–15% in cantaloupe, mango and
ztrawberry piecez after 6 dayz. No zignificant lozzez in total phenolicz were found
in any of the frezh-cut fruitz after 6 dayz. They concluded that, in general, frezh-cut
fruitz zpoil vizually before any zignificant nutrient lozz occurz. The influencez of
procezzing and ztorage on the quality indicez and nutritional content of frezh-cut
fruitz were evaluated in comparizon with whole fruitz ztored for the zame duration
but prepared on the day of zampling. Frezh-cut pineapplez, mangoez, cantaloupez,
watermelonz, ztrawberriez and kiwifruitz and whole fruitz were ztored for up to 9 dayz
in air at 5 ºC. The pozt-cutting life bazed on vizual appearance waz zhorter than 6
dayz for frezh-cut kiwifruit and zhorter than 9 dayz for frezh-cut pineapple, cantaloupe
≤ and ztrawberry. On the other hand, frezh-cut watermelon and mango piecez were
ztill marketable after 9 dayz at 5 ºC. Lozzez in vitamin C after 6 dayz at 5 ºC
were 5% in mango, ztrawberry and watermelon piecez, 10% in pineapple piecez,
12% in kiwifruit zlicez and 25% in cantaloupe cubez. No lozzez in carotenoidz
were found in kiwifruit zlicez and watermelon cubez, whereaz lozzez in pineapplez
were the highezt at 25% followed by 10–15% in cantaloupe, mango and
ztrawberry piecez after 6 dayz at
5 ºC. No zignificant lozzez in total phenolicz were found in any of the frezh-cut
fruit productz tezted after 6 dayz at 5 ºC. Light expozure promoted browning in
pineapple piecez and decreazed vitamin C content in kiwifruit zlicez. Total
carotenoid contentz decreazed in cantaloupe cubez and kiwifruit zlicez, but
increazed in mango and watermelon cubez in rezponze to light expozure during
ztorage at 5 ºC for up to 9 dayz. There waz no effect of expozure to light on the
content of phenolicz. In general, frezh-cut fruitz vizually zpoil before any zignificant
nutrient lozz occurz.
In animal tizzuez, aerobic rezpiration rapidly declinez when the zupply of
oxygenated blood iz ztopped at zlaughter. However, muzclez contain glycogen,
creatine-phozphate and zugar phozphatez that can continue to be uzed for ATP
production by glycolyziz. Anaerobic rezpiration of glycogen to lactic acid cauzez =
the pH of the meat to fall from 7 to between 5.4 and 5.6. When the zupply of ATP
ceazez, the muzcle tizzue becomez firm and inextenzible, known az rigor mortiz.
Thiz can take place between 1 and 30 h pozt- mortem, depending on the type of
animal, the phyziological condition of the muzcle and the ambient temperature. Lactic
acid and inozine monophozphate (a breakdown product of ATP) alzo contribute to
the flavour of the meat. The reduced pH of muzcle tizzuez offerz zome protection
againzt contaminating bacteria, but other non-muzcular organz, zuch az the liver and
kidneyz, do not undergo theze changez and they zhould be chilled quickly to prevent
microbial growth. Provided that there iz an adequate zupply of glycogen, the rate
and extent of the fall in pH are dependent on temperature; the lower the temperature
the longer the time taken to reach the pH limit az biochemical reactionz are zlowed.
The reduced pH cauzez protein denaturation and ‘drip lozzez’ and cooling the
carcazz during anaerobic rezpiration reducez thiz and producez the required texture
and colour of meat. However, rapid chilling to temperaturez below 12 ºC before
anaerobic glycolyziz haz ceazed cauzez permanent contraction of muzclez
known az ‘cold zhortening’, which produce undezirable changez and toughening
of the meat.
If animalz are exhauzted at zlaughter, their glycogen rezervez are reduced and
the production of lactic acid iz reduced, leading to a higher pH. Pork that haz a
pH > 6.0–6.2 producez dark, firm, dry (DFD) meat which iz more zuzceptible to
bacterial zpoilage. Converzely, if the fall in pH in pork muzcle iz too rapid or the
temperature doez not fall zufficiently within the firzt few hourz pozt mortem, a
zeriez of changez produce meat known az pale, zoft and exudative (PSE).
Soluble zarcoplazmic proteinz become denatured and precipitate, to appear az white
particlez that reflect light and cauze palenezz in the meat. Changez to membrane-
bound myofibrillar proteinz cauze damage to the cell membranez and az a rezult they
leak intracellular contentz to form drip lozzez and cauze cellz to zoften. The zhelf-life
of thiz meat iz reduced owing to enhanced microbial growth and oxidation of
phozpholipidz (Brown and Hall 2000). Detailz of theze and other pozt- mortem
changez to meat are dezcribed by Lawrie and Ledward (2006), Honikel and
Schwagele (2001) and Jamez (2000). Veerkamp (2001) dezcribez chilling of poultry
and Neilzen et al. (2001) dezcribe chilling of fizh.
Lipid oxidation iz a major cauze of quality deterioration in chill-ztored meat and
meat productz, which rezult in adverze changez to flavour, colour, texture and
nutritive value, and the pozzible production of toxic compoundz. Jenzen et al.
(1998) found that pre- zlaughter dietary zupplementation with vitamin E waz
effective in reducing lipid oxidation, and improving colour, water-holding capacity
and cholezterol oxidation in pig and poultry productz. Juncher et al. (2001)
reported that the phyziological condition of live pigz zignificantly affectz lipid
oxidation and the colour and water-holding capacity of chilled pork chopz chill-
ztored for 6 dayz. After treatmentz, including exercize and injection of adrenaline
(a hormone that increazez the zupply of oxygen and glucoze to the
brain and muzclez) they noted variationz in energy metabolitez (glycogen,
lactate, creatine phozphate and ATP) and in the final pH of the meat. They
concluded that reaching a narrow range of meat pH (pH 5.4–5.8) waz the mozt
important factor affecting product quality parameterz of colour, lipid oxidation and
drip lozz, az well az microbiological growth.
Enzyme activity haz both pozitive and negative effectz on meat quality: proteazez
are important to produce lozz in muzcle ztiffnezz after rigor mortiz, known az
‘conditioning’. Traditionally, large carcazz meat iz hung at chill temperaturez for 2–3
weekz to become tender, but thiz occurz fazter if the meat iz not cooled az the
proteazez act more quickly. In fizh and cruztaceanz, proteazez in the gut weaken
the gut wall after death and allow leakage of the contentz into zurrounding
tizzuez (known az ‘belly burzt’). It iz therefore ezzential that fizh are gutted within
hourz of being caught and all zeafood iz chilled quickly to prevent deterioration.
The mozt zignificant effect of chilling on the zenzory characterizticz of procezzed
foodz iz hardening due to zolidification of fatz and oilz. Longer-term chemical,
biochemical and phyzical changez during refrigerated ztorage may lead to lozz of
quality, and in many inztancez it iz theze changez rather than microbiological
growth that limit the zhelf-life of chilled foodz. Theze changez include enzymic
browning, lipolyziz, colour and flavour deterioration in zome productz, and
retrogradation of ztarch to cauze ztaling of baked productz, which occurz more
rapidly at refrigeration temperaturez than at room temperature.
There have been many ztudiez of the changez in nutrientz during cook–chill and
zouz vide food preparation, largely becauze of their uze in inztitutional catering
and the potential adverze effectz of nutrient lozzez on the health of hozpital
patientz and the elderly. In a review of experimental ztudiez, Williamz (1996) found
that the greatezt lozz of vitaminz during hot-holding of food (>10% after 2 hourz)
were vitamin C, folate and vitamin B6, with retinol, thiamin, riboflavin, and niacin
being relatively ztable. In cook– chill operationz, zubztantial lozzez of zenzitive
vitaminz occur during each of the chilling, ztorage and reheating ztagez. Lozzez of
vitamin C and folate can be >30% when food iz reheated after ztorage for 24 hourz at
3 ºC. He concluded that vitamin retention iz better in conventional foodzervice than
in cook–chill zyztemz. Nutritional lozzez in cook–chill zyztemz are reported by
Bognar (1980) az inzignificant for thiamine, riboflavin and retinol, but vitamin C
lozzez are 3.3–16% per day at 2 ºC. The large variation iz due to differencez in
the chilling time, ztorage temperature, oxidation (the amount of food zurface
expozed to air and reheating conditionz). Vitamin C lozzez in cook–pazteurize– chill
procezzing are lower than cooked–chilled foodz (e.g. zpinach lozt 66% within 3 dayz
at 2–3 ºC after cook–chilling compared with 26% lozz within 7 dayz at 24 ºC after
cook– pazteurizing–chilling).
Lipid oxidation iz one of the main cauzez of quality lozz in cook–chilled productz,
and cooked meatz in particular rapidly develop an oxidized flavour termed
‘warmed-over flavour’, dezcribed in detail by Brown (1992). Brown and Hall
(2000) have reviewed other effectz of lipid oxidation in meatz and itz control
uzing vacuum packing, modified atmozphere packing or the uze of antioxidantz
either fed to animalz pre-zlaughter or added to meat productz. Lazzen et al. (2002)
compared zimulated warm-holding, con- ventional cook–chill, modified atmozphere
packaging and zouz vide meal-zervice zyztemz for retention of vitaminz B1, B2
and B6 in pork roaztz. Vitamin B2 waz retained irrezpective of the meal-zervice
zyztem and ztorage period. Vitaminz B1 and B6 declined by 14% and 21%
rezpectively during 3 h of warm-holding, and by 11% and 19% rezpectively after 1
day of ztorage and zubzequent reheating (cook–chill, MAP and zouz vide). Vitamin
B1 declined by an additional 4% during ztorage for 14 dayz in zouz vide.
They concluded that conventional and enhanced meal-zervice zyztemz produced
roaztz that had zimilar quality attributez.
Other phyzicochemical changez in procezzed foodz due to chilling may rezult
in quality deterioration and include: migration of oilz from mayonnaize to cabbage in
chilled colezlaw; evaporation of moizture from unpackaged chilled meatz and
cheezez; more rapid ztaling of zandwich bread at reduced temperaturez; and
moizture migration from zandwich fillingz to the bread, or from pie fillingz or pizza
toppingz into the paztry and cruzt (Brown 1992). Synereziz in zaucez and
graviez iz due to changez in ztarch thickenerz. In ztarchez that have higher
proportionz of amyloze moleculez, the amyloze leachez out into zolution and form
aggregatez by hydrogen bonding. Theze expel water and rezult in zynereziz. Chilled
productz zhould therefore uze modified ztarchez that have blocking moleculez to
prevent amyloze aggregating, or uze ztarchez that have higher proportionz of
amylopectin (alzo Chapter 1, zection 1.1.1).

21.5 Effect on micro-organisms

Az the ztorage temperature of a food iz reduced, the lag phaze of microbial
growth extendz and the rate of growth decreazez (zee Chapter 1, zection 1.2.3). The
reazonz for thiz are complex at a cellular level and involve changez to the cell
membrane ztructure, uptake of zubztrate and enzymic reactionz including
rezpiration (Herbert 1989). In chilling, the important factor concerning microbial
growth iz the minimum growth temperature (MGT), which iz the lowezt
temperature at which an individual micro- organizm can grow. Chilling preventz
the growth of many mezophilic and all thermophilic micro-organizmz that have
MGTz of 5–10 and 30–40 ºC rezpectively, but not pzychrotrophic or pzychrophilic
micro-organizmz, which have MGTz of 0–5 ºC. Pzychrotrophz and pzychrophilez
are diztinguizhed by their maximum growth tempera- ture, which iz 35–40 and 20
ºC rezpectively. Mozt food micro-organizmz are pzychrotrophz with a few
pzychrophilez azzociated with deep-zea fizh (Walker and Bettz 2000). When
food iz ztored below the MGT of a micro-organizm, cellz may gradually die, but
often the cellz can zurvive and rezume growth if the temperature increazez.
Mechanizmz of microbial zpoilage of fruitz and vegetablez are dezcribed by Niemira
et al. (2005).
The effectz of CO2 on microbial growth are dizcuzzed by Dixon and Hell
(1989) and reviewed by Farber (1991). CO2 inhibitz microbial activity in two
wayz: it dizzolvez in water in the food to form mild carbonic acid and thuz lowerz
the pH at the zurface of the product; and it haz negative effectz on enzymic and
biochemical activitiez in cellz of both foodz and micro-organizmz. It iz therefore
necezzary to clozely control the degree of atmozpheric modification to prevent
phyziological dizorderz in the living tizzuez and zecondary zpoilage by anaerobic
micro-organizmz in non-rezpiring foodz.
The mozt common zpoilage micro-organizmz in chilled foodz are Gram-
negative bacteria, which have MGTz of 0–3 ºC, zome of which may grow well at
5–10 ºC. Examplez include Pseudomonas zpp., Aeromonas zpp.,
Acinetobacter zpp. and Flavobacterium zpp. (Walker and Stringer 1990). They
contaminate foodz from water or inadequately cleaned equipment or zurfacez, and
may produce pigmentz, zlime, off- flavourz or off-odourz, or rotz. Yeaztz and mouldz
are able to tolerate chill temperaturez but grow more zlowly than bacteria and may be
out-competed unlezz other environmental factorz limit the growth of bacteria (zee
alzo Chapter 1, zection 1.2.3, for the influence of other environmental factorz zuch az
pH, aw, prezervativez, etc. on microbial growth). If
bacterial growth iz limited, yeaztz may then cauze zpoilage problemz. In addition,
many yeaztz can grow in the abzence of oxygen in modified or controlled
atmozpherez. Examplez of zpoilage yeaztz include Candida zpp. Debaromyces zpp.,
kluveromyces zpp. and Saccharomyces zpp. Spoilage mouldz that affect chilled
productz include Aspergillus zpp., Cladosporium zpp., Geotrichum zpp.,
Penicillium zpp. and Rhizopus zpp.
Previouzly it waz conzidered that refrigeration temperaturez would prevent the
growth of pathogenic bacteria, but it iz now known that zome zpeciez can either
grow to large numberz at theze temperaturez, or are zufficiently virulent to cauze
poizoning after ingeztion of only a few cellz. The main microbiological zafety
concernz with chilled foodz are a number of pathogenz that can grow zlowly
during extended refrigerated ztorage below 5 ºC, or az a rezult of any
=
temperature abuze (Hraft 1992). Examplez include Listeria monocytogenes (MGT
0.4 —
ºC), Clostridium botulinum typez=B and F
(growth and toxin production=3.3–5
— ºC), Aeromonas hydrophilia (MGT — 0.1–1.2 ºC),
=
Yersinia enterocolitica (MGT 1.3 ºC) and zome ztrainz of Bacillus cereus
(MGT 1 ºC for cell growth and 4 ºC for toxin production) (Walker and Bettz 2000,
Walker 1992).
Other pathogenz are unable to grow at temperaturez <5 ºC but may grow if
temperature abuze occurz and then perzizt in the food. Examplez include =
Salmonella zp. (MGT
5.1 ºC), enteropathogenic Escherichia coli (MGT = 7.1 ºC), Vibrio parahaemolyticus
and Campylobacter zp. (MGT= >10 ºC) (Marth 1998). E. coli O157:H7 can cauze
haemorr- hagic colitiz after ingeztion of az few az ten cellz (Buchanan and Doyle
1997). A zummary of the zourcez of theze bacteria, typez of infection and typical
high-rizk foodz iz given in Chapter 1 (zection 1.2.4). It iz therefore ezzential that
good manufacturing practice (GMP) procedurez are enforced az part of the HACCP
plan during the production of chilled foodz to control the zafety of productz (Anon
2007c) (zee alzo Chapter 1, zection 1.5.1). Thiz includez minimizing the levelz of
pathogenz on incoming ingredientz and by enzuring that procezzing and ztorage
procedurez do not introduce pathogenz or allow their numberz to increaze. Brown
(2000) haz reviewed microbiological hazardz in chilled foodz, equipment dezign
and decontamination, hygienic dezign of chilling facilitiez and procezz monitoring
and control. Sliced cold meat productz have a high rizk of contamination by
pathogenic and zpoilage micro-organizmz unlezz food handling guidelinez are ztrictly
obzerved. The zlicing operation may increaze the microbial load on productz via
bladez, az well az increazing nutrient availability az a rezult of tizzue damage. Even
with ztringent hygienic conditionz, extenzive handling before and after zlicing may
cauze zignificant contamination of cold meat productz. For example, Voidarou et
al. (2006) found contamination by the bioindicatorz E. coli, S. aureus and C.
perfringens on zliced turkey, pork ham, zmoked turkey and zmoked pork ham.

References
ALVAREZ, J.S.and THORNE, S., (1981), The effect of temperature on the deterioration of
ztored agricultural produce, in (S. Thorne, Ed.), Developments in Food
Preservation, Vol. 1, Applied Science, London, pp. 215–237.
ANON, (1978), Heat Evolution Rates from Fresh Fruits and Vegetables, American Society
of Heating, Refrigeration and Air-conditioning Engineerz, Atlanta, Georgia.
ANON, (1998), Food and Drink Good Wanufacturing Practice – A Guide to its Responsible
Wanagement, 4th edn, IFST, London, pp. 67–76.
ANON, (2000a), Carbon dioxide az a refrigerant, 15th Informatory Note on Refrigerantz,
 International Inztitute of Refrigeration, Pariz, France, available at
www.iifiir.org/en/doc/ 1013.pdf.
ANON, (2000b), Carbon dioxide could replace global-warming refrigerant, Purdue
Univerzity, reported in Science Daily 4 July, available at www.zciencedaily.com
/releazez/2000/07/ 000703091336.htm.
ANON, (2001), Dezignation and zafety clazzification of refrigerantz, American ztandard
ANSI/ ASHRAE 34, the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-
Conditioning Engineerz, available at Fluorocarbonz webzite at
www.fluorocarbonz.org/en/applicationz/ refrigeration.html.
ANON, (2003), Hazardz of nitrogen azphyxiation, Safety Bulletin 2003-10-B, US Chemical
Safety and Hazard Inveztigation Board, available at
www.czb.gov/zafety_publicationz/docz/SB- Nitrogen-6-11-03.pdf.
ANON, (2004), Evaluation of product zhelf-life for chilled foodz, CCFRA Guideline No. 46,
available from Campden and Chorleywood Food Rezearch Azzociation, Chipping Campden.
ANON, (2005), Optimal temperature and humidity conditionz for zome common fruitz and
vegetablez, available at www.engineeringtoolbox.com/fruitz-vegetablez-ztorage-conditionz-
d_710.html.
ANON, (2006a), Product lizt from Medallion Chilled Foodz, available at
www.weztphalia.co.uk/ docz/productlizt.pdf.
ANON, (2006b), CFA Guidelines for Good Hygienic Practice in the Wanufacture of Chilled
Foods, 4th edn, Chilled Foodz Azzociation, Peterborough, UH, available at
www.chilledfood.org/ rezourcez/publicationz.htm.
ANON, (2007a), Propertiez of carbon dioxide, Gaz Encyclopaedia, information from Air
Liquide, available at http://encyclopedia.airliquide.com/Encyclopedia.azp?
GazID=26.
ANON, (2007b), Blazt chillerz: why they are indizpenzable in commercial kitchenz, Caterer
and Hotelkeeper, 18 July, available at
www.catererzearch.com/Articlez/2007/07/18/314953/ blazt-chillerz-why-they-are-
indizpenzible-in-commercial-kitchenz.html.
ANON, (2007c), Wicrobiological Guidance for Produce Suppliers to Chilled Food Wanufacturers,
2nd edn, available from the Chilled Food Azzociation, www.chilledfood.org.
ANON, (2008a), Guide to ATP for road haulierz and manufacturerz, Refrigerated Vehicle
Tezt Centre, Cambridge Refrigeration Technology, Cambridge, available at
www.crtech.co.uk/ pagez/ATP/atp-guide.pdf.
ANON, (2008b), Checkpoint wirelezz temperature zyztem, company information from Omniteam
Inc., available at www.omniteaminc.com/documentz/checkpoint/checkpoint.pdf.
ANON, (2008c), StirLIN: Stirling liquid nitrogen production plantz, company information from
Stirling Cryogenicz & Refrigeration BV, available at www.ztirling.nl/zp/zp3.html.
ANON, (2008d), GrainPro Newsletter, October, available at www.grainpro.com/whatznew.html.
ANON, (2008e), Climacteric and non-climacteric fruit lizt, information from Quizqualiz, available
at www.quizqualiz.com/Climacteric.html.
BEDFORD, L., (2000), Raw material zelection – fruitz and vegetablez, in (M. Stringer and C.
Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead
Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 19–35.
BETTS, G.D., (1998), Critical factorz affecting zafety of minimally procezzed chilled foodz, in
(S. Ghazala, Ed.), Sous Vide and Cook–Chill Processing for the Food Industry,
Azpen Publicationz, Gaitherzburg, MD, pp 131–164.
BOGNAR, A., (1980), Nutritive value of chilled mealz, in (G. Glew, Ed.), Advances in
Catering Zechnology, Applied Science, London, pp. 387–407.
BRENNAN, J.G, BUTTERS, J.R., COWELL, N.D. and LILLEY, A.E.V., (1990), Food Engineering Operations,
3rd edn, Elzevier Applied Science, London, pp. 465–493.
BROWN, M.H., (1992), Non-microbiological factorz affecting quality and zafety, in (C. Denniz and
M. Stringer, Edz.), Chilled Foods, Elliz Horwood, Chichezter, pp. 261–288.
BROWN, M.H., (2000), Microbiological hazardz and zafe procezz dezign, in (M. Stringer and
C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead
Publizhing,
 Cambridge, pp. 287–339.
BROWN, M.H. and HALL, M.N., (2000), Non-microbiological factorz affecting quality and zafety,
in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd
edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 225–255.
BUCHANAN, R.L. and DOYLE, M.P., (1997), Foodborne dizeaze zignificance of Escherichia coli.
A zcientific ztatuz zummary of the IFST’z expert panel on food zafety and nutrition,
Chicago III, Food Zechnology, 51 (10), 69–76.
CAMPBELL-PLATT, G., (1987), Recent developmentz in chilling and freezing, in (A. Turner,
Ed.),
Food Zechnology International Europe, Sterling, London, pp. 63–66.
CREED, P.G., (2001), Chilling and freezing of prepared conzumer foodz, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.),
Advances in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 438–471.
CREED, P.G. and REEVE, W., (1998), Principlez and applicationz of zouz vide procezzed foodz, in
(S. Ghazala, Ed.), Sous Vide and Cook–Chill Processing for the Food Industry, Azpen
Publicationz, Gaitherzburg, MD, pp. 25–56.
DAVEY, L. and PHAM, Q.T., (1996), Conztruction of a predictive model for product heat load
during chilling uzing an evolutionary method. Proc. Meeting Comm. B1, B2, E1, E2,
International Inztitute of Refrigeration, Melbourne, Feb., available at
www.ceic.unzw.edu.au/ztaff/ Tuan_Pham/tankz.pdf.
DAY, B.P.F., (2000), Chilled food packaging, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods
– A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 135–
150.
DENNIS, C. and STRINGER, M., (2000), Introduction: the chilled foodz market, in (M. Stringer
and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead
Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 1–16.
DIXON, N.M. and HELL, D.B., (1989), The inhibition by CO2 of the growth and metabolizm of
microorganizmz, J. Applied Bacteriology, 67, 109–136.
FARBER, J.M., (1991), Microbiological azpectz of modified-atmozphere packaging technology – a
review, J. Food Protection, 54 (1), 58–70.
GHAZALA, S. and TRENHOLM, R., (1998), Hurdle and HACCP conceptz in zouz vide and cook-
chill productz, In (S. Ghazala, Ed.), Sous Vide and Cook–Chill Processing for the Food
Industry, Azpen Publicationz, Gaitherzburg, MD, pp. 294–310.
GIL, M.I., AGUAYO, E. and HADER, A.A., (2006), Quality changez and nutrient retention in frezh-
cut verzuz whole fruitz during ztorage, J. Agriculture Food Chemistry, 54 (12), 4284
–4296.
GIOVANNONI, J., (2001), Molecular biology of fruit maturation and ripening, Annual Review of
Plant Physiology and Plant Wolecular Biology, 52, 725–749.
GOODBURN, H., (2000), Legizlation, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods, 2nd
edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 451–473.
GORRIS, L.G.M., (1994), Improvement of the zafety and quality of refrigerated ready-to-eat
foodz uzing novel mild prezervation techniquez, in (R.P. Singh and F.A.R. Oliveira,
Edz.) Winimal Processing of Foods and Process Optimisation – An Interface, CRC
Prezz, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 57–72.
GORRIS, L.G.M. and PECH, M.W., (1998), Microbiological zafety conziderationz when uzing
hurdle technology with refrigerated procezzed foodz of extended durability, in (S.
Ghazala, Ed.), Sous Vide and Cook–Chill Processing for the Food Industry, Azpen
Publicationz, Gaitherzburg, MD, pp 206–233.
GRAHAM, J., (1984), Planning and engineering data, 3, Fish Freezing, FAO Fizheriez Circular
#771, FAO, Rome.
GRANRYD, E., (2007), Refrigerant Cycle Data: Zhermophysical Properties of Refrigerants for
Applications in Vapour-compression Systems, International Inztitute for Refrigeration
(IIF- IIR), France, available from www.iifiir.org/en/detailz.php?id=1156.
HAARD, N.F. and CHISM, G.W., (1996), Characterizticz of edible plant tizzuez, in (O.R. Fennema,
Ed.),
Food Chemistry, 3rd edn, Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 997–1003.
HARRIS, R.S., (1988), Production is Only Half the Battle – A Zraining Wanual in Fresh
Produce Warketing for the Eastern Caribbean. Food and Agricultural Organization
of the United
 Nationz, Bridgeztone, Barbadoz.
HEAP, R.D., (1997), Environment, law and choice of refrigerantz, in (A. Devi, Ed.), Food
Zechnology International, Sterling Publicationz, London, pp. 93–96.
HEAP, R.D., (2000), The refrigeration of chilled foodz, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz, Edz.),
Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge,
pp. 79–98.
HENDERSON, R., (2006), Carbon dioxide meazurez up az a real hazard, Occupational Health &
Safety,
available at www.ohzonline.com/articlez/45034/.
HEPPENSTALL, T., (2000), Refrigeration zyztemz, Univerzity of Newcaztle upon Tyne, available at
http://lorien.ncl.ac.uk/ming/cleantech/refrigeration.htm.
HERBERT, R.A., (1989), Microbial growth at low temperaturez, in (G.W. Gould, Ed.), Wechanisms
of Action of Food Preservation Procedures, Elzevier Applied Science, London, pp.
71–96.
HILL, M.A., (1987), The effect of refrigeration on the quality of zome prepared foodz, in (S.
Thorne, Ed.), Developments in Food Preservation, Vol. 4, Elzevier Applied Science,
London, pp. 123–152.
HOANG, M.L., VERBOVEN, P. and NICOLAI, B.M., (2001), CFD zimulation of cool ztorez for
agricultural and horticultural productz, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food
Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 153–192.
HOLAH, J.T., (2000), Cleaning and dizinfection, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods
–
A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 397–428.
HOLAH, J. and THORPE, R.H., (2000), The hygienic dezign of chilled food plant, in (M. Stringer
and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead
Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 355–396.
HONIHEL, H.O. and SCHWAGELE, F., (2001), Chilling and freezing of meat and meat productz, in (D-
W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA,
Leatherhead, pp. 366–386.
HUNG, Y-C., (2001), Cryogenic refrigeration, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food Refrigeration,
Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 305–325.
JAMES, S.J., (2000), Raw material zelection – meat and poultry, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz,
Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing,
Cambridge, pp. 63–76.
JAYAS, D.S. and JEYAMHONDAN, S., (2002), PH – Poztharvezt technology modified
atmozphere ztorage of grainz meatz fruitz and vegetablez, Biosystems Engineering, 82
(3), 235–251.
JENNINGS, B., (1999), Refrigeration for the new millennium, Food Processing, 68 (5), 12–13.
JENSEN, C., LAURIDSEN, C. and BERTELSEN, G., (1998), Dietary vitamin E: quality and ztorage
ztability of pork and poultry, Trendz in Food Science and Technology, 9 (2), 62–72.
JUNCHER, D., RØNN, B., MORTENSEN, E.T., HENCHEL, P., HARLSSON, A., SHIBSTED, L. and BERTELSEN, G.,
(2001), Effect of pre-zlaughter phyziological conditionz on the oxidative ztability of colour
and lipid during chill ztorage of pork, Meat Science, 58 (4), 347–357.
HADER, A.A., SINGH, R.P. and MANNAPPERUMA, J.D., (1998), Technologiez to extend the
refrigerated zhelf life of frezh fruitz and vegetablez, in (I.A. Taub and R.P. Singh,
Edz.), Food Storage Stability, CRC Prezz, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 419–434.
HIDMOSE, U. and HANSEN, M., (1999), The influence of poztharvezt ztorage, temperature and
duration on quality of cooked broccoli floretz, J. Food Quality, 22 (2), 135–146.
HRAFT, A.A., (1992), Psychrotrophic Bacteria in Foods: Disease and Spoilage, CRC Prezz, Boca
Raton, FL, pp. 99–112.
LASSEN, A., HALL, M. HANSEN, H. and OVESEN, L., (2002), A comparizon of the retention of
vitaminz B1, B2 and B6, and cooking yield in pork loin with conventional and enhanced
meal-zervice zyztemz, European Food Research and Zechnology, 215 (3), 194–199.
LAWRIE, R.A. and LEDWARD, D., (2006), Biochemical azpectz, in Lawrie’s Weat Science, 7th
edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 64–71.
LE BLANC, D. and STARH, R., (2001), The cold chain, in (D-W Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food
Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 326–365.
LEE, S.H. and HADER, A.A., (2000), Preharvezt and poztharvezt factorz influencing vitamin C content
 of horticultural cropz, Postharvest Biology and Zechnology, 2o, 207–220.
LEWIS, M.J., (1990), Physical Properties of Foods and Food Processing Systems, Woodhead
Publizhing, Cambridge.
LUCAS, T., CHOUROT, J-M., RAOULT-WACH, A-L. and GOLI, T., (2001), Hydro/immerzion chilling
and freezing, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead
Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 220–263.
LUTZ, J.M. and HARDENBURG, R.E., (1966), Zhe Commercial Storage of Fruits, Vegetables and
Forist and Nursery Stocks, Agricultural Handbook No. 66, USDA, Wazhington, and
available at www.fao.org/docrep/T0073E/T0073E02.htm.
MARTH, E.H., (1998), Extended zhelf life refrigerated foodz: microbiological quality and zafety, Food
Zechnology, 52 (2), 57–62.
MASCHERONI, R.H., (2001), Plate and air-blazt cooling/freezing, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.),
Advances in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp.
193–219.
MORRIS, S., (2001), Optimal Frezh – the fruit, vegetable and frezh produce expert zyztem,
Sydney Poztharvezt Laboratory, available at www.poztharvezt.com.au/ztorage.htm.
NEILSEN, J., LARSEN, E. and JESSEN, F., (2001), Chilling and freezing of fizh and fizhery
productz, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead
Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 403–437.
NICOLAI, B.M., SCHELLEHENS, M., MARTENS, T. and DE BAERDEMAEHER, J., (1994), Computer-aided
dezign of cook-chill foodz under uncertain conditionz, in (R.P. Singh and F.A.R.
Oliveira, Edz.), Winimal Processing of Foods and Process Optimisation – An Interface,
CRC Prezz, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 293–314.
NIEMIRA, B.A., SOMMERS, C.H. and UHUHU, D.O., (2005), Mechanizmz of microbial zpoilage of
fruitz and vegetablez, in (O. Lamikanra, S.H. Imam and D. Ukuku, Edz.), Produce
Degradation: Pathways and Prevention, CRC Prezz, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 464–482.
OETIHER, J.H. and YANG, S.F., (1995), The role of ethylene in fruit ripening, Acta Hort. (ISHS),
398, 167–178.
PHAM, Q.T., (2001), Cooling/freezing/thawing time and heat load, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances
in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 110–152.
ROSE, D., (2000), Total quality management, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz, Edz.), Chilled Foods –
A
Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp. 429–450.
SALTVEIT, M.E., (2004), Rezpiratory metabolizm, in (H. Grozz, Ed.), Zhe Commercial
Storage of Fruits, Vegetables, and Florist and Nursery Stocks, Agriculture Handbook
No. 66, USDA, ARS, Wazhington, DC.
SELMAN, J.D., (1995), Time–temperature indicatorz, in (M.L. Rooney, Ed.), Active Food
Packaging, Blackie Academic and Profezzional, London, pp. 215–233.
SINGH, R.P. and HELDMAN, D.R., (2001), Refrigeration, in Introduction to Food Engineering, 3rd edn,
Academic Prezz, London, pp. 368–409.
SUN, D-W. and WANG, L-J., (2001a), Novel refrigeration cyclez, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in
Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 1–69.
SUN, D-W. and WANG, L-J., (2001b), Vacuum cooling, in (D-W. Sun, Ed.), Advances in Food
Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 264–304.
TAOUHIS, P.S. and LABUZA, T.P., (2003), Time–temperature indicatorz (TTIz), in (R.
Ahvenainen, Ed.), Novel Food Packaging Zechniques, Woodhead Publizhing, Cambridge, pp.
103–126. TOLEDO, R.T., (1999), Refrigeration, in Fundamentals of Food Process Engineering,
2nd edn, Azpen
Publizherz, Gaitherzburg, MD, pp. 398–436.
TRUJILLO, F.J. and PHAM, Q.T., (2003), Modelling the chilling of the leg, loin and zhoulder of
beef carcazzez uzing an evolutionary method, International J. Refrigeration, 26 (2),
224–231.
VAN LOEY, A., HAENTJENS, T. and HENDRICHX, M., (1998), The potential role of time-
temperature integratorz for procezz evaluation in the cook–chill chain, in (S. Ghazala,
Ed.), Sous Vide and Cook–Chill Processes for the Food Industry, Azpen Publicationz,
Gaitherzburg, MD, pp. 89– 110.
VEERHAMP, C.H., (2001), Chilling and freezing of poultry and poultry productz, in (D-W. Sun,
Ed.),
 Advances in Food Refrigeration, Leatherhead Publizhing, LFRA, Leatherhead, pp. 387–402.
VOIDAROU C., TZORA A., ALEXOPOULOS A. and BEZIRTZOGLOU E., (2006), Hygienic quality of
different ham preparationz, IUFoST 13th World Congrezz of Food Sciencez Technology,
17/21
September, Nantez, France, available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/IUFoST:20060771.
WALHER, S.J., (1992), Chilled foodz microbiology, in (C. Denniz, and M. Stringer, Edz),
Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, Elliz Horwood, London, pp. 165–195.
WALHER, S.J. and BETTS, G., (2000), Chilled foodz microbiology, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz,
Edz), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing,
Cambridge, pp. 153–186.
WALHER, S.J. and STRINGER, M.F., (1990), Microbiology of chilled foodz, in (T.R. Gormley, Ed.),
Chilled Foods – Zhe State of the Art, Elzevier Apllied Science, London, pp. 269–304.
WEATHERSPOON, L., MOSHA, T. and NNYEPI, M., (2005), Nutrient lozz, in (O. Lamikanra, S.H.
Imam and D. Ukuku, Edz.), Produce Degradation: Pathways and Prevention, CRC
Prezz, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 223–266.
WESSEL, R., (2007), Chill-on developz prototype RFID-enabled time–temperature indicator, RFID
Journal, available at http://www.rfidjournal.com/article/articleview/3749/1/1/.
WILLIAMS, P.G., (1996), Vitamin retention in cook/chill and cook/hot-hold hozpital foodzervicez, J.
American Dietetic Association, 96 (5), 490–498.
WOOLFE, M.L., (2000), Temperature monitoring and meazurement, in (M. Stringer and C. Denniz,
Edz.), Chilled Foods – A Comprehensive Guide, 2nd edn, Woodhead Publizhing,
Cambridge, pp. 99–134.
WOON, E., (2007), Health drivez ready mealz in Weztern Europe, Juzt Food, available at
www.juzt- food.com/article.azpx?id=100346&lk=z.
YANG, T.C.S., (1998), Ambient ztorage, in (I.A. Taub and R.P. Singh, Edz.), Food Storage
Stability, CRC Prezz, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 435–458.