Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Marc Müller1
1
Haefely Test AG, Basel, Switzerland
*Email: mueller.marc@haefely.com
Abstract: The topic of this paper is the analysis of the fundamentals of the winding resistance measurement
and their application for the development of an optimized tool. The ultimate goal is to create a portable
device, which measures a complete transformer the fastest and easiest way possible. The influence of the
charging voltage and the measuring current on the measuring time has to be analyzed. Another important
issue is the stabilization time on low ohmic delta windings. Further, testing time can be reduced by
introducing a demagnetization feature, which eliminates the need of applying high voltage AC after a DC
resistance test. Finally, the implementation of the optimized tool is presented with its efficient connection
scheme and the multi-channel architecture.
+ R
connection and disconnection of the measuring
equipment are just some of the difficulties to deal
U DUT
with. - LM
The paper describes an integrated, mobile
instrument developed to speed up the stabilisation I
time when supplying DC to a transformer winding
by an intelligent magnetic-flux optimised charging.
With example diagrams of various transformers the Figure 1: Winding resistance measuring principle
charging and stabilisation effects are shown. using a DC power supply
After applying DC to a transformer, the core
remains magnetized. This can cause problems for The instrument consists of a programmable power
further measurements or reconnecting the supply, which is normally operated in constant
transformer to the grid. Thus, an integrated, low current mode. It is used to supply a user-defined
voltage demagnetization function to bring a power current into the DUT. Additionally, there is a
transformer into a defined, demagnetised state will voltage and current measurement unit. Thus, the
be shown. resistance is calculated according equation (1):
Typical problems arising when connecting a
measuring system to a power transformer have U U R + U LM U R dI
been solved. In particular these problems are time R= = = + LM ⋅ (1)
I I I dt
consumption and faulty connections, which have
been solved by a fully integrated connection set
2.2 Magnetizing inductivity LM
and a multiplexing circuit. Error possibilities in
setting up the measurement equipment have to be
Also, Equation 1 shows the main difference
faced and eliminated by offering state-of-the-art
between a normal and a winding resistance
graphical, self-explanatory user interfaces with
measurement. There is a large inductance in
online information about all related values and
series with the resistance of interest. This
conditions in an easy and well-arranged way.
inductance is typically in the range of L0 = 0.1H to
5000H. In figure 2, the current dependency of the current of the inductance, there is no relevant
magnetizing inductivity is depicted. difference anymore.
LM
Basically we can state the following rules:
L0 Æ The higher the supply voltage, the faster
the current can be charged or discharged.
dI U LM U I
= (3)
dt LM
UMax
For a given transformer, the rate of change of the ISet
measuring current depends only on the voltage
applied to the magnetizing inductivity LM. Current
charging and discharging time depends mainly on R·ISet
the maximally available supply voltage. Figure 3
compares two charging processes using a voltage 0s 10s 20s t
of either 50V or 100V.
Figure 4: Transient oscillation of a power supply in
I 100V 50V constant current mode with a high inductive load
+ Rb La
U DUT La + Lb + Lc
- τ= (9)
Lb Rc R a + Rb + R c
I
This leads to another problem for winding
Lc resistance measurement. When the delta winding
is on the low voltage side of a large generator
transformer, the winding resistance is typically very
Figure 6: Winding resistance measurement on a small (<10mΩ). According to equation (9), this
delta winding leads to a large time constant for the circulating
current to go to zero. Measurement stabilization
When we apply a voltage between terminals ‘a’ times from several minutes up to one hour can be
and ‘b’, a current starts to flow. This current splits observed on large transformers.
between the two depicted branches. One way to speed up this stabilization time is to
decrease the magnetizing inductivity of the
transformer. This can only be done by saturating
I (t ) = I b (t ) + I a (t ) (4) the transformer core. On low voltage windings of
large power transformers, the saturation current
During charging, the current distribution between can easily exceed 10A to 100A. Which is the
the two branches is dominated by the ratio of the reason why people often want to have high current
magnetizing inductances and not by the ratio of the (>50A) measuring devices.
resistances. During and directly after charging, the
current distribution is as follows (because the three
inductivities are not equal):
I b L a + Lc
= ≠ 2.0 (5)
Ia Lb
3 FLUX OPTIMIZED YN-DELTA METHOD 3.2 Experimental Results
N2
HV
I Sat = I Sat
LV
⋅ (10)
N1
1 2 1
4.1 Background
B=μ·(H+M)
+ΦR
ΔΦCheck+
M0
H=N·I
-IDemag
MDemag +IDemag
ΔΦCheck-
-ΦR
The invented demagnetization procedure consists This chapter deals with the problems arising when
of two sub procedures and requires only a low connecting a measuring system to a power
voltage power supply (<100V): transformer. Problems like time consumption and
faulty connections are discussed.
Analyzing the transformer: The hysteresis loop
of the transformer is calculated using a special The connectivity of a traditional high current
algorithm. The algorithm comprises the injection of winding resistance measurement device with two
a current IDemag to the transformer and the channels and one current supply is depicted in
measurement of the response of the transformer. figure 11.
+ +
U1
Multiplexer
Multiplexer
Signal
Power
- I1 -
N A B C N A B C + +
R1 R2 U2
DUT - -
HV LV I2
6 OPTIMIZED TOOL N A B C N A B C
HV DUT LV
The key to a portable and optimized winding
resistance measurement device is to reduce the
maximally needed supply current. Because a high Figure 13: Block Schematic of the Instrument
supply current results in larger and heavier power
supplies, connectors, cables and switching With this instrument a complete transformer can be
matrices. The switching matrix is needed to realize measured fully automatic. This includes all three
the multichannel concept of the device. phases on the high voltage side and low voltage
The two key elements necessary to reduce the side. Additionally, the device can cycle trough all
maximally needed measuring current have already taps automatically and correct all resistance values
been introduced: to a reference temperature without user
intervention. Figure 14 shows a comparison
- A power supply with a specially designed control between the measurement procedures of a three
loop for high inductive loads. phase transformer with a remote controlled tap
changer. The classical procedure requires
- A method to deal with the long stabilization times repetitive user interactions. The user has to write
when measuring a low ohmic delta winding (e.g. down measurement values, operate the tap
large generator transformers). changer and reconnect the measuring cables.
Using the optimized tool, user interaction is
This leads to an instrument which combines all the reduced to the initial connection and setup of the
features presented in this paper. Figure 13 shows device. This helps to reduce the overall testing
a block schematic of the proposed instrument. The time and does not allocate user resources during
system consists of two voltage and current the measurement.
controlled power supplies, which can be connected
in any configuration to the DUT. This is realized
using a power relay matrix. Additionally there are
two voltage measurement units, which can be
connected in any configuration to the DUT. This is
realized using a small signal relay matrix. Further
there is also a tap changer control circuit and a
temperature measurement unit.
Events
Classical procedure
Optimized procedure
Time
5 CONCLUSIONS