Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Objective: To examine the effect of -cyclodextrin piroxicam treatment for priming of the uterus on the
pregnancy outcome of IVF– embryo transfer (ET) programs.
Design: Prospective, randomized, double-blinded placebo-controlled clinical study.
Setting: Large urban medical center.
Patient(s): One hundred eighty-eight consecutive cycles of fresh IVF–ET and 78 cycles of frozen–thawed ET.
The patients underwent IVF because of tubal, male infertility, unexplained, or endometriosis factors. They
were randomly divided into treatment and control groups.
Intervention(s): In the treatment group, 94 cycles in fresh ET and 39 cycles in frozen–thawed ET the patients
received an oral dose of 10 mg of piroxicam. In the control group, the same number cycles corresponding to
the treatment group were treated with placebo. Both groups started piroxicam or placebo treatment 1–2 hours
before ET. Patients and staff were blinded to the treatment.
Main Outcome Measure(s): Implantation rate (IR) and pregnancy rate (PR).
Result(s): Piroxicam increased significantly IR (18.7%) and PR (46.8%) compared to the control group (8.6%
and 27.6%, respectively) in fresh cycles. With the exception of an unexplained factor, patients with the tubal,
male infertility, or endometriosis factor had significantly higher PR in the treatment group compared to the
control group. The beneficial effect of piroxicam was found in patients less than 40 years old, but was not
found in patients more than 40 years. In frozen–thawed cycles, there were statistically significant differences
between the treatment group and the control group in IR (9.4% vs. 2.3%) and PR (25.6% vs. 7.7%),
respectively.
Conclusion(s): Our study showed that piroxicam increases IR and PR after IVF–ET in both fresh and
frozen–thawed ET cycles. The beneficial effect seems to be more remarkable in patients less than 40 years old
with tubal, male infertility, or endometriosis factors. These results suggest that piroxicam treatment before ET
is very effective in the priming of a uterus suitable for embryo implantation. This is the first study to
investigate the possible consequence of piroxicam for improving the PR after IVF–ET. (Fertil Steril威 2004;
82:816 –20. ©2004 by American Society for Reproductive Medicine.)
Key Words: -Cyclodextrin piroxicam, pregnancy outcome, uterine contractility
Received April 17, 2003; During the past 20 years numerous studies Practical limitations in the evaluation and
revised and accepted have been made to improve the implantation improvement of uterine receptivity may be in-
February 17, 2004. process. Most of their attempts have been fluenced by several factors. First, no one factor
Reprint requests: Bo Sun
Joo, Ph.D., Center for
focused on the induction and selection of the was considered to play a critical determining
Reproductive Medicine and best quality embryos and the improvement of role in the establishment of uterus receptivity
Infertility, Good Moon-Hwa uterus receptivity. Several developments in for implantation because the events of implan-
Hospital, 899-8 Bum-il
Dong, Busan 601-062, controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH), tation are regulated by a complex morpholog-
Korea (FAX: 82-51-630- fertilization, and embryo culture techniques ical and biochemical change of the endome-
0750; E-mail: bosunjoo@ have contributed to the improvement of the trium (1). Thus all of these factors should be
hotmail.com).
quality of embryos available for ET. In con- investigated simultaneously to clearly assess
0015-0282/04/$30.00 trast, little development has increased the the receptivity status of the endometrium. Sec-
doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2004.
02.140 uterus receptivity. ond, tissue sampling for the direct assessment
816
of markers of uterine receptivity is inherently impossible in Follicular development was assessed by transvaginal ul-
the actual ET cycles. trasonography. When at least two dominant follicles were 18
mm or larger, the serum E2 level was measured and 10,000
Recently many researchers have focused on noninvasive
IU of hCG (IVF-C, LG Inc.) was administered.
prognostic factors of uterine receptivity with the advent of
high resolution ultrasound probes, which permitted the direct Oocyte retrieval by transvaginal ultrasonographic guid-
visualization of the uterine contractile activity (2, 3). The ance was performed approximately 36 hours after the hCG
uterus has typically three patterns of contractility throughout administration. Follicular aspirates were transferred into
the menstrual cycle that influence embryo implantation (4 – 60-mm tissue culture dishes (Falcon 3002; Becton Dickin-
7). Uterine contraction at the time of ET alters pregnancy son, Lincoln Park, NJ). Oocyte– cumulus cell complexes
rates (PRs) after IVF (8). These results suggest that uterine were isolated under a dissecting microscope (SZH, Olym-
contractility can be an important factor in determining en- pus, Tokyo, Japan). The maturity and quality of each oo-
dometrial receptivity as well as an alternative noninvasive cyte– cumulus cell complex was graded under inverted phase
prognostic factor (9). In this respect, treatment of adjuvants, contrast microscope (Olympus IX 70, Olympus) by spread-
such as uterine relaxants, should be considered to prime of a ing each oocyte– cumulus cell complex on one line of the
uterus suitable for embryo implantation. surface of 60-mm culture dishes. Oocytes with first polar
body and extensive cumulus cells were regarded as mature.
Prostaglandin, which is synthesized from arachidonic
acid by cyclooxygenase (COX), stimulates uterine contrac- Four or five oocytes were placed into each organ culture
tion. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) block dish (Falcon 3037; Becton Dickinson) containing 0.9 mL of
the action of COX and inhibit the production of prostaglan- glucose-free mHTF medium supplemented with 10% follic-
din (10). This result indicates that NSAIDs may cause the ular fluid (FF). Highly motile spermatozoa were collected by
reduction of uterine contractility. To date, no reports have a discontinuous three-layered percoll gradient (100%–90%–
evaluated NSAIDs with the purpose of improving a preg- 50%) and suspended in glucose-containing HTF medium
nancy outcome after IVF–ET. Piroxicam is the most effec- with 10% FF. Then they were inseminated 4 –12 hours after
tive of all NSAIDs in the clinical relief of dysmenorrhea oocyte retrieval, depending on the oocyte maturity.
(10). The aim of this study was to examine the effect of Fertilization was confirmed 16 –20 hours after insemina-
piroxicam treatment for the priming of the uterus on the tion by visualization of two pronuclei. Fertilized oocytes
pregnancy outcome in IVF–ET programs. were transferred to fresh mHTF medium with 20% FF, and
then cultured for 24 hours or more, followed by co-culture
with autologous cumulus cells in glucose-containing HTF
MATERIALS AND METHODS with 20% FF. After co-culture, embryos were graded based
This study was performed on 188 consecutive cycles of fresh on the size of the blastomere and the presence of fragmen-
IVF–ET and 78 cycles of frozen–thawed ET from March tation, using Bolton’s definition (11), just before ET. The ET
1998 to February 2000 at the Center for Reproductive Med- was performed with Embryon transfer catheter (Rocket med-
icine of Good Moon-Hwa Hospital. The study included ical, Waterford, United Kingdom) 3 days after oocyte recov-
women who underwent IVF because of tubal, male infertil- ery in fresh cycles and 3 days after ovulation in frozen–
ity, unexplained, or endometriosis factor. Written informed thawed cycles.
consent was obtained from all patients. This study was Piroxicam Treatment
approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Human The 188 fresh IVF–ET cycles and 78 frozen–thawed ET
Investigation Committee of Good Moon-Hwa Hospital. cycles were randomly divided into treatment and control
groups. In the fresh ET cycles, the treatment group (94
Controlled Ovarian Hyperstimulation and cycles) received an oral dose of 10 mg of piroxicam (Brexin;
IVF Procedures Kolon Inc., Daejeon, Korea), and the control group (94
Controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH) was per- cycles) received a placebo. In the frozen–thawed ET cycles,
formed by a long standard protocol with GnRH agonist 39 cycles received 10 mg of piroxicam orally (treatment
(GnRH-a; Lucrin, Johannesburg Abbott, France), hMG group) and 39 cycles were treated with placebo (control
(IVF-M; LG Inc., Iksan, Korea), and highly purified FSH group). Both groups started piroxicam or placebo treatment
(hpFSH; Follimon, LG Inc.). In brief, GnRH-a was given 1–2 hours before ET. Patients and staff were blinded to the
daily at a dose of 1 mg until a serum E2 level was obtained treatment.
to assess whether adequate suppression had been achieved.
When ovarian suppression was observed by serum E2 and Statistical Analysis
FSH levels on the third day of the menstrual cycle, GnRH-a All data were presented as mean ⫾ SD. Statistical anal-
was given daily at a dose of 0.5 mg in the morning and one ysis was carried out using the unpaired Student’s t-test and
or two ampules of 75 IU of hMG and hpFSH were given IM 2-test. A P value ⬍.05 was considered statistically signif-
in the evening, depending on the follicular development. icant.
Patient characteristics in the control and piroxicam Comparison of pregnancy rates according to the infertility
treatment groups. causes.
Control Piroxicam treatment Infertility causes Control Piroxicam treatment
TABLE 4
TABLE 2
Comparison of pregnancy rate with the age of patients.
IVF–ET outcomes in the control and piroxicam treatment
groups. Age Control Piroxicam treatment
818 Moon et al. Piroxicam increases pregnancy rate of IVF Vol. 82, No. 4, October 2004
Uterine contractility follows three characteristic pat-
TABLE 5 terns according to the phase of the menstrual cycle. Uter-
Pregnancy outcomes in frozen–thawed ET cycles.
ine contractility during the early follicular phase (menses,
antegrade: fundus-to-cervix) increases progressively to a
Piroxicam maximum activity at midcycle (retrograde: cervix-to-fun-
Control treatment dus), and declines gradually throughout the luteal phase
No. of cases 39 39 (quiescence) (4, 25–27). Dyskinetic alterations in this
No. of embryos transferred 4.0 ⫾ 2.3 3.7 ⫾ 1.8 process may be responsible for infertility, especially with
No. of grade A embryoa 2.7 ⫾ 0.5 2.8 ⫾ 0.2 endometriosis (28, 29). The uterine contraction amplitude
Implantation rate 2.3% 9.4%b is three times higher in women with endometriosis than in
Clinical pregnancy rate 7.7% (3 cases) 25.6% (10 cases)b
women without endometriosis (30). The finding that en-
a
Grade A embryo is the best quality embryo with even sized blastomere and dometriosis is intimately associated with dyskinetic alter-
no fragmentation.
b ation on uterine contractility is looked at in our present
P⬍.05 (vs. control group).
study, which shows that the PR in women with endome-
Moon. Piroxicam increases pregnancy rate of IVF. Fertil Steril 2004.
triosis who had the piroxicam treatment increased about
twice as much as in control women. We hypothesize that
(10 mg) of piroxicam during the preimplantation period. Our this increased PR may be a result of the normalization of
present study does not show any increase in spontaneous uterine contractility by piroxicam treatment.
abortion as well as malformation after piroxicam treatment However, our present study did not show the significant
compared to the control group in IVF–ET. improvement of PR by piroxicam treatment in the patient
The cause for this beneficial effect of piroxicam may be group with an unexplained infertility factor. One explanation
postulated in two aspects. First, piroxicam treatment may re- of this unexpected finding is an unknown factor of unex-
duce uterine contractility. IJland et al. (5) found that concep- plained infertility may surpass the calming effect of piroxi-
tional cycles had less endometrial wavelike activity compared cam on the uterine contractility. Therefore, further study to
with nonconception cycles in spontaneous cycles. High fre- seek the effect of NSAIDs on the uterine contractility and PR
quency contractions of uterus at the time of ET are associated is necessary. Also, in the present study, the beneficial effect
with poorer implantation (8) and poorer IVF–ET outcome (14). of piroxicam was not expressed in older women, notably
These results mean that uterine contractility influences embryo patients more than 40 years. This result implies that the
implantation. calming effect of piroxicam does not seem to overcome the
Uterine contractility is stimulated by prostaglandins (PGs) age-related fertility declines.
synthesized by COX (10). The NSAIDs block the action of In conclusion, this study is the first to investigate the
COX and inhibit the production of PGs (15), probably resulting possible consequence of piroxicam to improve the preg-
in the decrease of uterine contractility. In this respect, the one nancy outcome of IVF–ET, and shows that the treatment
time oral treatment with piroxicam on the day of ET seems to with piroxicam increases the implantation rate and PR after
increase the implantation of human blastocyst by calming uter- IVF–ET in both fresh and frozen–thawed cycles. These
ine contraction rather than inhibiting embryo development and results suggest that administration of piroxicam just before
blastocyst hatching. ET is very effective in the priming of the uterus to be suitable
for embryo implantation. However, our study did not eval-
Second is the increase of uterine blood flow with piroxi-
uate whether piroxicam calms the uterus by reducing uterine
cam treatment. A few studies used aspirin, another inhibitor
contractions or if it increases uterine blood flow. Further
of PG, to improve the pregnancy outcome of IVF–ET. They
study is needed to elucidate the mechanism of the action of
concluded that low-dose aspirin improved implantation rates
piroxicam.
and PRs in IVF patients (16 –18). Rubinstein et al. (18)
explained that the effect of aspirin is attributable to an References
1. Tabibzadeh S, Babaknia A. The signals and molecular pathways in-
increase in uterine blood flow. volved in implantation, a symbiotic interaction between blastocyst and
endometrium involving adhesion and tissue invasion. Hum Reprod
Studies similar to ours were conducted by Fanchin (19) 1995;10:1579 – 602.
and Ayoubi (20) and their colleagues. Uterine contractions 2. Oike K, Obata S, Tagaki K, Matsuo K, Ishihara K, Kikuchi S. Obser-
vation of endometrial movement with transvaginal sonography. J Ul-
are increased by rising E2 levels during the follicular phase trasound Med 1988;7:S99.
(21–23) and are reduced by P exerted during the luteal phase 3. Zaidi J, Pittrof R, Shaker A, Kyei-Mensah A, Campbell S, Tan SL.
(21, 24, 25). These researchers administered vaginal P start- Assessment of uterine artery blood flow on the day of human chorionic
gonadotropin administration by transvaginal color Doppler ultrasound
ing on the day of oocyte retrieval to relax uterine contrac- in an in vitro fertilization program. Fertil Steril 1996;65:377– 81.
tility at the time of ET. As a result, they found a decrease in 4. IJland MM, Evers JLH, Dunselman GAJ, Van Katwijk C, Lo CR,
Hoogland HJ. Endometrial wavelike movements during menstrual cy-
uterine contraction frequency on the day of ET, suggesting cle. Fertil Steril 1996;65:746 –9.
that a uterine relaxation effect by P administration before ET 5. IJland MM, Evers JLH, Dunselman GAJ, Volovics L, Lo CR,
Hoogland HJ. Relation between endometrial wavelike activity and
is likely to improve IVF–ET outcome. fecundability in spontaneous cycles. Fertil Steril 1997;67:492– 6.
820 Moon et al. Piroxicam increases pregnancy rate of IVF Vol. 82, No. 4, October 2004