Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original Russian Text © A.P. Nedashkovsky, M.G. Shvetsova, 2010, published in Okeanologiya, 2010, Vol. 50, No. 6, pp. 910–917.
MARINE
CHEMISTRY
Abstract—The method proposed for determining the total inorganic carbon (TC) concentrations in sea ice
(Arctic region, North Pole35 expedition) based on the measurement of the total alkalinity (TA) and the pH
in the melt waters without the CO2 exchange with the atmosphere is considered. It is shown that the TC/Sal
and TA/TC values through the entire ice section remain similar to these parameters in the subice water. The
surface snow and the uppermost ice layers are characterized by elevated TA/TC values, which indicate the
–
reaction Ca2+ + 2HC O 3 = ↓CaCO3 + ↑CO2 + H2O. The release of CO2 to the atmosphere due to the
decomposition of calcium hydrocarbonate is as high as ~20 mmol/m2. The meltwater of the examined ice is
undersaturated with CO2, which may result in a sink of atmospheric CO2 (~30 mmol/m2).
DOI: 10.1134/S0001437010060056
861
862 NEDASHKOVSKY, SHVETSOVA
the latter was added 30 ml of 0.2 M HCl and 3 ml of parameters, the total inorganic carbon content was
saturated HgCl2 solution. Table 3 presents some char then calculated. In this procedure, the quantity of СО2
acteristics of the carbonate system for the seawater in the gas phase that is formed in the container during
used for filling the container and for the liquid phase in the melting of the ice was taken into account (the СО2
the container after the ice’s melting. content in the gas phase was calculated as the equilib
rium one at the container’s temperature before the pH
The weight of the ice and the added seawater was measurement). The total inorganic carbon content,
determined using a GX2000 electronic balance the total alkalinity, and the salinity of the ice
(made by the A&D Company in Japan; the weighing (ТСic, TAic, and Salic) were calculated using the follow
accuracy was 0.01 g). After the complete melting of the ing formula:
ice (the next day), the pH value, the alkalinity, and the
salinity were measured in the container. Using these Sal cont – Sal w ( 1 – α ic )
Sal ic =
, (1)
α ic
Table 2. Characteristics of the sampling sites TA cont – TA w ( 1 – α ic )
TA ic =
, (2)
Number of the α ic
Characteristics of the ice sampling site
sampling site
( TC + ΔCO 2 ) cont – TC w ( 1 – α ic )
1 Ice field (>1 km across) formed ~1 km away TC ic =
, (3)
from the camp in October of 2007 α ic
2 Ice in the icefree water area 5–10 m wide formed m ic
in the initial part of January 2008 near the camp α ic =
, (4)
m ic + m w
3 Ice field (~1 km across) formed ~1 km away
from the camp in January of 2008 ( CO 2 ) gas
4 Ice in the icefree water area 5–10 m wide ΔCO 2 =
, (5)
m ic + m w
formed on April 16, 2008, near the camp
–6
5 Ice in the icefree water area 5–10 m wide ( V gas × P ( CO 2 ) ) × 10
formed on April 26, 2008, near the camp ( CO 2 ) gas =
. (6)
22.4 × ( T/273 )
6 Ice massif ~1 km away from the camp formed
after the substantial reorganization of the ice The indices “ic,” “cont,” and “w” designate the ice,
fields in the station’s area. the container (the melted ice and seawater in the con
Table 3. Some parameters of the carbonate system in the seawater used for filling the container and in the liquid phase formed in the
latter after the melting of the ice (core 25). The pH, carbon dioxide pressure, and saturation degree with calcite are given for 15°C
Sample Sal, psu pH TA, mequiv/kg TC, mmol/kg P(CO2), μatm Calcite saturation, %
Seawater 34.15 6.88 1.860 2.136 7522 19
S.w. + snow 31.91 7.44 2.006 2.044 2177 70
S.w. + ice 0–5 cm 26.34 7.12 1.370 1.487 3329 21
S.w. + ice 5–10 cm 21.58 7.15 1.212 1.316 2856 17
S.w. + ice 10–20 cm 21.69 7.20 1.257 1.352 2676 20
S.w. + ice 30–40 cm 20.17 7.17 1.157 1.255 2677 16
S.w. + ice 50–60 cm 20.14 7.14 1.148 1.254 2850 15
S.w. + ice 70–80 cm 20.59 7.10 1.172 1.29 3134 14
S.w. + ice 90–100 cm 19.96 7.09 1.132 1.25 3119 13
S.w. + ice 112–122 cm 20.66 7.09 1.168 1.288 3179 14
tainer), and the water added to the container with the The electromotive force of the cell was measured
ice, respectively. Sal, Ta, and TC are the salinity, the using a SEVEN MULTI S80 converter (Mettler
total alkalinity, and the concentration of the total inor Toledo, Switzerland) with an accuracy of 0.1 mV. The
ganic carbon measured in psu, mequiv/kg, and pH was measured with an accuracy up to 0.01 pH unit.
mmol/kg, respectively. αic is the share of the ice in the The alkalinity was determined by the method of
container; ΔСО2 is the correction for the carbon diox direct titration by HCl (~0.02 M) during the CO2
ide contained in the gas phase that is formed in the blowing by air free of carbon dioxide and ammonia
container during the melting of the ice (mmol/kg); (Bruevich’s method [5]). The air expenditure was
(СО2)gas is the quantity of carbon dioxide contained in ~1.3 l/min. The volume of the sample used for the
the gas phase (mmol); Vgas is the volume of the gas titration was 50 ml. For the calibration, a sodium car
phase (ml); and P(CO2) is the pressure of the carbon bonate solution with an exact weight was used. The titra
dioxide (μatm), which is in the equilibrium state with tion was potentiometrically performed in an ATP02
the liquid phase in the container at the temperature T autotitration cell (Akvilon, Moscow) using the auto
(degrees K). matic titration regime with the determination of the
Vgas = Vcont – (mic + mw)/d, where d is the density of equivalent point. The parameters of the regime were
the liquid phase in the container accepted to be equal the following: the drop volume was 0.01 ml, the pause
to 1. was 4–8 s, and the stabilization level of the electrode
potential was 0.2 mV. The initial acid dose V0 was
The Salic, TAic, and TCic calculated in line with the accepted in such a manner that its subsequent volume
system of equations (1–6) may be used for assessing added to by drops up to the equivalency point was at least
the carbon dioxide pressure in the water formed during 0.7 ml. The titration was conducted for 17–20 min up to
the melting of the ice. a pH of ~ 4.5. The equivalency point was determined
by the method of “manual processing” at pH = 5.5–
The pH value was potentiometrically determined 5.4. The determination accuracy of the equivalent vol
in a closed (preventing the СО2 exchange with the ume was 0.01 ml, which corresponds to an error of
atmosphere) thermostated cell at a temperature of 0.004 meqiv/l in the alkalinity assessment.
15.0°С using an ESL4307 measuring electrode and
an EVL1M reference electrode (made at the plant for In the calculations of the total inorganic carbon
measuring instruments in Gomel). The working vol contents, the components of the carbonate system, the
ume of the cell was ~10 ml. The reference electrode constants of the carbonic acid dissociation after
was located in a saturated KCl solution placed into the Mehrbach [6], the constant of the boric acid dissocia
measuring cell only during the readings. For its cali tion after Yman [6], the СО2 dissolubility after Weiss
bration, firstclass buffer standards manufactured by [12], and the calcite dissolubility after Millero [9] were
VNIIF3 and phosphate and tetraborate buffer solu used.
tions characterized by a pH of 6.857 ± 0.004 and 9.179 ± The ice’s salinity was determined using a GM65
0.004, respectively, at 25°C were used. The solutions electric salimeter. For its calibration, seawater stan
were prepared using deionized water free of dissolved dards (K15 = 1.00025 and K21 = –0.3254) prepared at
gases, which were removed by boiling. The measuring the Shirshov Institute of Oceanology of the Russian
cell was thermostated using an F12 electronic ther Academy of Sciences were used. The measurements
mostat (Julabo, Germany) with an accuracy of 0.1°C. were preceded by the testing of the consistency
The measuring cell was filled using a siphon tube. between the temperature in the conductometric cell
H, cm
H, сm
40
0 10
40
80
80
25
120 120
39
160
42
160
200
0 4 8 12 16
Sal, psu
200
0 20 40 60 80
Sal, psu
Fig. 1. Vertical salinity variations in the examined ice. The inset shows the distribution of the salinity in cores 25, 39, and 42 (the
high salinity values in the snow at the ice’s surface are not shown). The snow’s thickness calculated for the meltwater is given in
the negative direction of the ordinate axis.
and the salimeter reading at the beginning of the expe 42 is characteristic of ice already subjected to summer
dition (October 2007). The testing was performed melting. This is evident from the strongly desalinated
using an F12 electronic thermostat (Julabo, Ger upper layer and the salinity minimum at a depth of
many), which yields an accuracy of 0.1°С, and a mer ~130 cm [7].
cury thermometer, which was verified at the Men Figure 2a demonstrates the correlation between the
deleev AllRussian Institute of Metrology. total alkalinity and the salinity of the ice (data on all
the ice layers were used for constructing the plot).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION As follows from the figure, all the measured values
are located near the straight line that crosses the origin
Figure 1 demonstrates the vertical salinity varia of the coordinates and whose incline is determined by
tions in the examined ice. Its distribution in all the the TA/Sal value for the subice water. Notable devia
samples (except for core 42) is characteristic of young tions are observed for the surface snow, which is char
and firstyear ice in this observation period [7]. The acterized by a higher TA/Sal value as compared with
maximal salinity was registered in the upper layer that in the subice water, and the latter increases with
including the surface snow (up to 80 psu). With its the snow desalination. Similar values were obtained by
growth, the ice becomes desalinated with the minimal the drifting SP34 station [4]. These data are consid
salinity being confined to its middle part. The sole ered as an indirect indication that the thin snow layer
exception among the examined ice samples is core 39, at the ice’s surface accumulates the calcium carbonate
where the salinity of the snow and the upper ice layers phase. The main ice body is either free of reaction (1)
(ΔH = 10 cm) is lower as compared with that in the or the СаСО3 phase is removed together with the brine.
underlying ice, which evidently indicates the onset of As a whole, the examined ice is characterized practi
the summer melting. The salinity distribution in core cally by the same TA/Sal values as in the subice water.
15
3
5
Subice water
4 18
13
2 18
3 25
21 10 25 16
Subice water
10
2 39
39
1 21
0 20 40 60 80 0 20 40 60 80
Sal, psu Sal, psu
Fig. 2. Correlation of the total alkalinity (a) and the total inorganic carbon concentrations (b) in the examined ice samples with
the salinity. For comparison, data on the subice water layer are shown. The numbered data points designate the surface snow sam
ples with similar numbers.
Figure 2b demonstrates the correlation between the increase to values close to 2. Such a TA/TC value
total inorganic carbon concentrations and the salinity means that the СаСО3 represents the main form of the
in the examined ice. When constructing the plot, we inorganic carbon; i.e., reaction (1) in the snow at the
used the data obtained for the bedbybed sampled ice ice’s surface may proceed practically up to its comple
core. In most cases, the data points coincide with the tion.
straight line that crosses the origin of the coordinates Figure 3b presents the calculated Р(СО2) values for
and whose incline is determined by the TC/Sal value the water that is produced by the ice’s melting at 0°С
for the subice water. This means that the TC/Sal value under conditions that the calcium carbonate is dis
in the main ice body is practically the same as in the solved. In all the samples, except for core 42, the СО2
subice water. This fact is consistent with the assump pressure in the meltwater is substantially lower as com
tion that no reaction (1) occurs in the main ice body. pared with that in the atmosphere. The lowest СО2
Otherwise, both the reaction (1) products (СаСО3 and pressure is characteristic of the snow and the upper ice
СО2) remain united and are removed together with the layer, which is explained by the release of the produced
brine. СО2 into the atmosphere. For the young ice (cores 32,
Similar to the TA–Sal plot, notable deviations 34, and 36), the P(СО2) values are relatively high. This
from the straight line that crosses the origin of the is probably explained by the fact that the CO2 was not
coordinates is observed for the surface snow. At the yet released into the atmosphere. The high Р(СО2) val
same time, the TC/Sal value in the snow is lower as ues observed in two layers of cores 10 and 16 represent
compared with that in the subice water layer. This sup exceptions and probably resulted from measurement
ports the assumption that reaction (1) proceeds at the errors. The obtained data imply that the meltwater
ice’s surface with carbon dioxide released into the produced by the firstyear ice should consume atmo
atmosphere. spheric СО2, owing to which the ice melting should be
Figure 3a demonstrates the correlation between the accompanied by a sink of carbon dioxide.
total alkalinity and the total inorganic carbon concen Before going into the discussion of the potential
trations in the examined ice. It is seen that the vertical physical factors responsible for the different parame
distribution of the TA/TC values is uniform except for ters in the upper desalinated part of core 42 as com
core 42: the TA/TC is equal to 1.07 ± 0.06 practically pared with the general trend, it should be noted that
through the entire ice section, which is well consistent the TA and TC values, as well as their ratios, are char
with its value in the subice water (1.069 ± 0.005). Only acterized by large errors under low ice salinity and the
in the snow at the ice’s surface does the TA/TC ratio methods used. Unfortunately, the heavy ice conditions
H, сm (а) H, сm (b)
–10 Subice water –10 36
10 10 32
42 10
30 30 42
16
50 50
70 70
90 90
110 110
130 130 Subice water
150 150
170 170
190 190
210 210
0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 0 100 200 300 400 500
TA/TC P(CO2), μatm
Fig. 3. Parameters of the carbonate system in the sea ice. (a) The ratio between the total alkalinity and the total inorganic carbon
concentrations in the examined ice samples (mol/mol); (b) the carbon dioxide pressure calculated for the water produced by the
melted ice at 0°C. The numerals correspond to the core numbers.
in the area of core 42’s sampling prevented us from Based on the observations, the TC1 value may be
obtaining additional ice samples. derived from the ice’s total alkalinity, since the TA/TC
The anomalous characteristics of core 42’s upper value in the formed sea ice is equal to that in the subice
part indicate high carbon dioxide contents in the liq water layer (1.07). Then, TC1 = TAmeasured/1.07.
uid phase that produced the ice layer. It may be The total flux of СО2 released during the ice’s for
assumed that the upper desalinated part of the ice sec mation— F(CO2), mmol/m2—may be obtained by
tion was formed due to the freezing of snow mixed summing the CO2 losses for all the ice layers:
with water oversaturated with СО2. This may be n
explained by the fact that such water becomes in equi
librium with the atmospheric СО2 before freezing, but
F ( CO 2 ) = ∑ Δ ( CO ) .2 i (8)
the subsequent oxidation of the organic matter iso i=1
lated from the atmosphere is accompanied by the Figure 4 presents the results of these calculations.
additional growth of the carbon dioxide pressure. The general trend of the F(CO2) variations, except for
The obtained data allow the СО2 quantity released core 18, is presented in the inset. The observed СО2
into the atmosphere during the sea ice formation to be loss under Н = 0 is explained the fact that the snow’s
assessed. For the ice layer with the thickness Н, the thickness is given, as was mentioned, with a negative
equation is characterized by the following form: sign. The main СО2 loss is observed in the snow at the
ice’s surface and in the upper part of the core. There
ΔСО2 = 10 × (ТС1 – ТСmeasured) × d × H, (7) fore, the quantity of the released СО2 is practically
independent of the ice’s thickness. The obtained data
where ΔСО2 is the СО2 loss by the ice layer with the show that the formation of the firstyear ice during the
thickness H (cm) per unit of the ice’s area (mmol/m2), observation period lasting from January to the initial
TC1 is the concentration of the total inorganic carbon part of May was accompanied by a CO2 release as large
in the ice layer under the condition that no СО2 is as 20 ± 4 mmol/m2. According to [2], reaction (1) in
released (mmol/kg), TCmeasured is the observed concen ice proceeds up to its completion. Our data provide no
tration of the total inorganic carbon in the same ice grounds for such a conclusion: the ice layer 1 m thick
layer (mmol/kg), and d is the ice’s density (kg/dm3) releases approximately 10% of the potential СО2.
(for the snow at the ice’s surface, the thickness of The presented data on the concentrations of the
which is calculated for the meltwater, d is the water’s total inorganic carbon and the alkalinity in the first
density). year ice allow the potential quantity of СО2 that may
F(CO2), mmol/m2
28
18 21
24
39
15
10
20 13
F(CO2)
25
16 20
15
10
25
12 5
16
0 40 80 120 160
H, сm
8
0 40 80 120 160
H, сm
Fig. 4. The CO2 loss per unit of the ice area depending on its thickness. The numerals correspond to the core numbers. The inset
shows the general variations depending on the ice’s thickness.
be consumed by the meltwater to be estimated. Under observed in the subice water layer is preserved in the
the ice’s thickness of 1 m, the СО2 consumption forming sea ice cover.
should be as large as ~50 mmol/m2. The resulting
effect of the sea ice’s formation (CO2 release of The snow at the ice’s surface and the upper ice layer
~20 mmol/m2) and its subsequent melting (CO2 con become depleted in carbon dioxide due to the reaction
sumption of ~50 mmol/m2) should consist of a sink of of the calcium hydrocarbonate decomposition accom
carbon dioxide (~30 mmol/m2). This result is satisfac panied by СаСО3 and СО2 formation.
torily consistent with the estimates obtained for the
firstyear Arctic ice [4]. The density of the released CO2 flux during the
period lasting from the beginning of the ice’s forma
The CO2 released during the ice’s formation and its tion to its summer melting is estimated to be 20 ±
consumption during the ice’s melting may be respon
4 mmol/m2. This constitutes approximately 10% of
sible for insignificant seasonal variations of the СО2
concentrations in the nearice atmospheric layer. the potential CO2 quantity that could be released in
the case of the complete decomposition of the calcium
hydrocarbonate in the ice layer 1 m thick.
CONCLUSIONS The water produced by melted firstyear sea ice is
Using the method proposed for measuring the total sharply undersaturated with carbon dioxide. Conse
inorganic carbon concentrations in young and first quently, the ice’s melting may result in a sink of atmo
year sea ice, it is demonstrated that the ratio between spheric carbon dioxide, which is estimated to be as
the total inorganic carbon contents and the salinity large as ~30 mmol/m2.