Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER OUTLINE
21
21.1 Introduction................................................................................................................................202
21.1.1 The Basic Process..............................................................................................202
21.1.2 Specifying for Durability.....................................................................................202
21.1.3 Using Water Reducers and Cement Replacements.................................................202
21.1.4 Mix Design in Industry.......................................................................................203
21.1.5 Measurement of Strength...................................................................................203
21.1.6 Water in the Aggregate.......................................................................................203
21.1.7 Traditional Mixes...............................................................................................203
21.2 UK Mix Design............................................................................................................................203
21.2.1 Stage 1. Calculating the Target Mean Strength...................................................203
21.2.2 Stage 2. Initial Strength Value..........................................................................204
21.2.3 Stage 3. Draw the Curve for the W/C Ratio.........................................................204
21.2.4 Stage 4. Obtain the W/C Ratio..........................................................................204
21.2.5 Stage 5. Choice of Water Content......................................................................205
21.2.6 Stage 6. Calculate Cement Content...................................................................205
21.2.7 Stage 7. Estimate Wet Density..........................................................................206
21.2.8 Stage 8. Calculate Aggregate Content................................................................206
21.2.9 Stage 9. Obtain Proportion of Fine Aggregate.....................................................206
21.2.10 Stage 10. Calculate Fine and Coarse Aggregate Quantities...................................206
21.2.11 Stage 11. Calculate Quantities for a Trial Mix.....................................................206
21.3 US Mix Design............................................................................................................................207
21.3.1 Step 1. Choice of Slump....................................................................................207
21.3.2 Step 2. Choice of Nominal Maximum Size of Aggregate.........................................207
21.3.3 Step 3. Estimation of Water Content....................................................................207
21.3.4 Step 4. Selection of Water/Cement Ratio..............................................................209
21.3.5 Step 5. Calculation of Cement Content................................................................210
21.3.6 Step 6. Estimation of Coarse Aggregate Content...................................................210
21.3.7 Step 7. Estimation of Fine Aggregate Content.......................................................210
21.4 Mix Design with Cement Replacements.........................................................................................211
21.5 Mix Design for Air-entrained Concrete..........................................................................................212
21.5.1 Effect of Air Entrainers.......................................................................................212
21.5.2 UK Practice......................................................................................................212
21.5.3 US Practice.......................................................................................................212
201
202 CHAPTER 21 Concrete mix design
21.1 INTRODUCTION
21.1.1 THE BASIC PROCESS
“Mix design” or “mixture proportioning” is used to calculate the quantities of the different constituents
required to achieve the properties that are specified for a batch of concrete. The design properties are,
normally, the workability and the compressive strength. The slump test that measures workability, and
the compressive test for strength, are described in detail in Chapter 22. In this chapter, two methods of
mix design are considered; the first is common in the United Kingdom (Design of Normal Concrete
Mixes, Building Research Establishment report BR331), and the second in the United States (Standard
Practice for Selecting Proportions for Normal, Heavyweight, and Mass Concrete, American Concrete
Institute Standard 211.1).
The basic steps of mix design are as follows:
• Establish the water/cement (w/c) ratio for the required strength. The approximate relationship
between strength and w/c ratio is:
Water 1
∝
Cement Strength
to add more cement, and this increases the cost. The solution to these conflicting requirements is to use
a plasticising admixture (see Section 24.2).
Most concrete also contains cement replacements of the type described in Chapter 18. These bring
benefits of reduced cost, reduced environmental impact, and often improved durability.
The initial methods presented in this chapter do not, however, include the use of cement replace-
ments or admixtures. Modifications to these basic mix designs to include these materials are discussed
in Sections 21.4, 21.5, and 21.6.
Table 21.1 Approximate Compressive Strengths (MPa) of Concrete Mixes Made With a Free
w/c Ratio of 0.5
Age (Days)
Table 21.2 Approximate Free Water Contents (kg/m3) Required to Give Various Levels of
Workability
Slump (mm) 0–10 10–30 30–60 60–180
FIGURE 21.4 Relationship Between Proportion of Fine Aggregate and w/c Ratio
© IHS, reproduced from BRE BR 331 with permission.
21.3 US mix design 209
freeze–thaw resistance, it is air that has not been removed by the normal amount of compaction
(vibration) used on site.
Slump mm (in.) 9.5 (3/8) 12.5 (1/2) 19 (3/4) 25 (1) 37.5 (1.5)
25–50 (1–2) 207 (350) 199 (335) 190 (315) 179 (300) 166 (275)
75–100 (3–4) 228 (385) 216 (365) 205 (340) 193 (325) 181 (300)
150–175 (6–7) 243 (410) 228 (385) 216 (360) 202 (340) 190 (315)
Approximate amount 3 2.5 2 1.5 1
of entrapped air (%)
Data taken from American Concrete Institute Standard 211.1 and reproduced with the permission of the ACI.
40 (5800) 0.42
35 (5075) 0.47
30 (4350) 0.54
25 (3625) 0.61
20 (2900) 0.69
15 (2175) 0.79
Data taken from American Concrete Institute Standard 211.1 and reproduced with the permission of the ACI.
Table 21.6 Dry-Rodded Volume of Coarse Aggregate Per Unit Volume of Concrete, for Each
Size, and Fineness Modulus of the Aggregates
Fineness Modulus of Fine Aggregate
Nominal Maximum Size of
Coarse Aggregate mm (in.) 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0
The mass of cement from step 5, in kilogrammes per cubic metre (lb/yd3), is divided by the absolute
density, also in kilogrammes per cubic metre (lb/yd3) (normally taken as 3150 kg/m3 = 3.15 kg/L = 5311
lb/yd3) to give the volume in cubic metres per cubic metre (cubic yards per cubic yard) of concrete.
The coarse aggregate quantity from step 6 is similarly divided by the absolute density.
The water mass from step 3 is divided by the density of water = 1000 kg/m3 (1686 lb/yd3)
The volume of entrapped air from Table 21.4 is expressed as a percentage, so it must be divided by
100 to give a fraction of the 1 m3 (1 yd3) total volume.
The total volume is 1 m3 (1 yd3), so all of these volumes are subtracted from 1 to give the volume
of fine aggregate. This is then multiplied by the absolute density to give the mass.
that 10 kg of PFA will be equivalent to 3 kg of cement, when calculating the strength. The efficiency
factor concept only works when the PFA content is less than 40% of the total cementitious content. If
it is more than 40%, some of it will not react, so it will not contribute to the strength.
GGBS will normally (but not always) act as a water reducing agent. The efficiency factor may be as
high as 1 at 28 days. Silica fume substantially decreases workability and increases strength.
21.5.2 UK PRACTICE
In UK practice, the mix design process is adjusted as follows:
• It is assumed that there is a 5.5% loss of strength for each 1% by volume of entrained air. The
target mean strength is increased to account for this.
• The free water content is reduced by one level of workability in Table 21.2.
• The calculated density is reduced by an amount equal to the saturated surface dry density of the
aggregate × the volume fraction of entrained air.
21.5.3 US PRACTICE
In US practice, the water contents in Table 21.4 are reduced as shown in Table 21.8.
The w/c ratios in Table 21.5 are reduced as shown in Table 21.9.
The density in Table 21.7 is reduced as shown in Table 21.10.
Table 21.8 Estimated Water Contents for Air Entrained Concrete in kg/m3 (lb/yd3)
Maximum Aggregate Size mm (in.)
Slump mm (in.) 9.5 (3/8) 12.5 (1/2) 19 (3/4) 25 (1) 37.5 (1.5)
25–50 (1–2) 181 (305) 175 (295) 168 (280) 160 (270) 150 (250)
75–100 (3–4) 202 (340) 193 (325) 184 (305) 175 (295) 165 (275)
150–175 (6–7) 216 (355) 205 (345) 197 (325) 184 (310) 174 (290)
Data taken from American Concrete Institute Standard 211.1 and reproduced with the permission of the ACI.
21.7 Redesigning mixes using trial batch data 213
35 (5075) 0.39
30 (4350) 0.45
25 (3625) 0.52
20 (2900) 0.60
15 (2175) 0.70
Data taken from American Concrete Institute Standard 211.1 and reproduced with the permission of the ACI.
and 24.3). Normally, both of these methods are used. The high powder content also prevents “aggre-
gate interlock” that prevents a mix flowing through narrow spaces.
If a high cement content is used, this will result in high cost and, normally, high strength (assuming
a superplasticiser is used with a low water content). Thus, the high powder content will often include
a lot of PFA.
There are many published methods for mix design of self-compacting concrete, but a simplified one
is as follows:
• Design the concrete mix to achieve the required strength and a slump of 100 mm (4 in.).
• If the cement content is less than 500 kg/m3 (850 lb/yd3), add PFA so that the total cementitious
(cement + PFA) is 500 kg/m3 (850 lb/yd3), and the equivalent cement content
(= Cement + 0.3 × PFA, assuming an efficiency factor of 0.3) is the same as the cement content
from the original mix design.
• Add superplasticiser and VMA in the amounts specified by the manufacturers.
the same as the design mix. A method to improve the mix design based on trial mix data is shown in
Fig. 21.5. The actual w/c used and strength observed are plotted, and an estimated line drawn through
them. The new w/c ratio is then obtained for the target mean strength.
21.8 US UNITS
In some US literature and websites, the cement content of a mix is quoted in sacks per cubic yard. This
is based on traditional sacks of 94 lb (42.5 kg) so 1 sack/yd3 = 55.6 kg/m3. Bags of cement are now
generally restricted to 25 kg for health and safety reasons.
21.9 CONCLUSIONS
• The workability of concrete is determined by the water content.
• The strength of concrete is determined by the w/c ratio.
• The cement content is obtained by dividing the water content by the w/c ratio.
• US and UK practice use slightly different methods to obtain the aggregate content.
• Cement replacements may be assumed to have an efficiency factor that gives their contribution to
strength relative to an equal mass of cement.
• Self-compacting concrete may be made by using a VMA.
TUTORIAL QUESTIONS
1. a. C
alculate the quantities for a 0.15 m3 trial concrete mix to the following specification using the
UK method:
Characteristic strength: 35 MPa at 28 days
Cement: OPC (EN class 42.5)
21.9 Conclusions 215
Percent defectives: 5%
No. of test samples: 5
Target slump: 50 mm
Coarse aggregate: 10 mm uncrushed
Fine aggregate: Uncrushed 50% passing a 600 mm sieve
b. The mix is to be used to make self-compacting concrete, for which a minimum cementitious
content of 500 kg/m3 is required. Assuming that PFA develops 30% of the strength of an equal
mass of cement, calculate new cementitious quantities to include PFA as a partial replacement
for the cement.
c. Which two types of admixture would normally be used to make the self- compacting concrete?
Solution:
a. Stage 1. Standard deviation = 8 MPa (Fig. 21.1 with five results)
Target mean strength = 35 + 8 × 1.64 = 48.12 MPa (equation (12.3))
Stage 2. Starting point for Fig. 21.3 = 42 MPa (Table 21.1)
Stage 3 and 4. w/c = 0.45
© IHS, reproduced from BRE BR 331 with permission.
b. To calculate the quantities for the SCC mix two equations are formed.
The total cementitious will be 500 kg/m3, thus:
Cement + PFA = 500
Also the equivalent cement content must be 455 kg/m3 from the original design, and the
assumed efficiency factor is 0.3, thus:
Cement + 0.3 × PFA = 455
Solving these two equations gives:
PFA = 65 kg/m3 = 9.75 kg in a 0.15 m3 trial mix
Cement = 435 kg/m3 = 65 kg in a 0.15 m3 trial mix
c. Superplasticiser and viscosity modifier.
2. Calculate the quantities for the mix from question 1 using the US method. The following
additional data should be used:
Cylinder strength: 40 MPa (this is approximately equivalent to a cube strength of 48. See
Chapter 22)
Fineness modulus of fine aggregate: 2.8
Dry-rodded density of coarse aggregate: 1600 kg/m3
Absolute density of aggregate: 2600 kg/m3
Solution:
Step 1. The slump is 25–50 mm.
Step 2. The maximum aggregate size is approximately 9.5 mm.
Step 3. The estimated water content is 207 kg/m3 and the entrapped air is 3% (Table 21.4).
Step 4. The w/c = 0.42 (Table 21.5).
Step 5. The cement content = 207/0.42 = 493 kg/m3.
Step 6. Dry-rodded volume of coarse aggregate per unit volume of concrete = 0.46 (Table 21.6).
Thus, mass of coarse aggregate = 0.46 × 1600 = 736 kg/m3.
Step 7. (Using a mass basis.)
Estimated density = 2280 kg/m3 (Table 21.7)
Thus, fine aggregate = 2280 − 207 − 493 − 736 = 844 kg/m3.
(Using an absolute volume basis.)
Volume of water = 207/1000 = 0.207 m3
Volume of cement = 493/3150 = 0.157 m3
21.9 Conclusions 217
3. Calculate the quantities for the following mix using the US method:
Cement: OPC
Target slump: 2 in.
Coarse aggregate: 3/8 in.
Cylinder strength: 5800 psi
Fineness modulus of fine aggregate: 2.8
Dry-rodded density of coarse aggregate: 2700 lb/yd3
Absolute density of aggregate: 4400 lb/yd3
Solution:
Step 1. The slump is 1–2 in.
Step 2. The maximum aggregate size is 3/8 in.
Step 3. The estimated water content is 350 lb/yd3 and the entrapped air is 3% (Table 21.4).
Step 4. The w/c = 0.42 (Table 21.5).
Step 5. The cement content = 350/0.42 = 833 lb/yd3.
Step 6. Dry-rodded volume of coarse aggregate per unit volume of concrete = 0.46 (Table 21.6).
Thus, mass of coarse aggregate = 0.46 × 2700 = 1242 lb/yd3.
Step 7. (Using a mass basis.)
Estimated density = 3840 lb/yd3 (Table 21.7)
Thus, fine aggregate = 3840 − 350 − 833 − 1242 = 1415 lb/yd3
(Using an absolute volume basis.)
Volume of water = 350/1686 = 0.207 yd3
Volume of cement = 833/5311 = 0.157 yd3
Volume of coarse aggregate = 1242/4400 = 0.282 yd3
Volume of entrapped air = 0.03 × 1 = 0.03 yd3
Thus, volume of fine aggregate = 1 − 0.207 − 0.157 − 0.282 − 0.03 = 0.324 yd3
Mass of fine aggregate = 0.324 × 4400 = 1425 lb/yd3
Thus, the final quantities in lb/yd3 are: