You are on page 1of 6

ICACSIS 2018 978-1-7281-0135-4/18/S31.

00 ©2018 IEEE

Analysis of Factors Affecting User’s Intention in


Using Mobile Health Application: A Case Study of
Halodoc
Clarissa Nuralifa Mangkunegara, Fatimah Azzahro, and Putu Wuri Handayani
Faculty o f Computer Science, Universitas Indonesia, Depok, Indonesia
clarissanrlf@gmail.com, putu.wuri@cs.ui.ac.id

Abstract— This study aims to evaluate essential factors that launched in 2016. Based on our interview in April 18th 2018
affect user’s behavioral intention in using Halodoc, a mobile with the Head o f Product o f Halodoc, the interaction with the
health application. This study examines factors from several Halodoc application itself only for 50% o f users from all
theories and perspective such as TAM, TPB and Health Belief over users owned by Halodoc. Therefore, Halodoc continues
Model. A total of 146 Halodoc’s users completed the online to innovate and evaluate its application to improve the
survey. The data is processed by using SmartPLS (v. 3.2.7). services provided to meet customer expectation and lead to
The result shows that perceived usefulness, perceived increasing the numbers o f users and the interaction within the
behavioral control, trust, self-health awareness, system quality, application.
and attitude influence users’ behavioral intention in using
Halodoc. However, in order to achieve success, one should
examine what factors may affect users’ adoption of m-health.
Keywords— Behavioral Intention, Mobile Health This study explores several factors from different IT
Application, Halodoc, PLS-SEM adoption theories such as Technology Acceptance Model
(TAM), Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), dan Unified
I. In t r o d u c t io n Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT). In
addition, this study also uses factors from health theories
Indonesia ranks 113 out o f 188 countries on the Human
such as Health Belief Model (HBM) and Protection
Development Index (HDI) reported in World Human
Motivation Theory (PMT).
Development Report 2016 [1], HDI is calculated using
several dimensions such as health, education and income. This paper organize as follows. First, we provide brief
Indonesian, especially one lives in rural area, still have low overview o f the literature on mobile health in Indonesia and
awareness on health issues such as the importance of IT adoption theories. Second, we draw explanation for our
vaccinating children and doing medical check-up regularly. hyphoteses development. Next, we present the methodology
Limited access to health provider and health education plays as well as research results. Finally, we discuss our finding
a big part to this phenomenon. Mobile health has a along with conclusion.
tremendous opportunity to solve these problems. As reported
by APJII, Indonesia has a high rate o f mobile phone II. L i t er a t ur e Re v i e w
adoption, reaching to more than 10 million users, or 80% of
Indonesia population [2], A. HaloDoc - Mobile Health App from Indonesia
M-health is an application that utilizes smartphone Mobile health (m-health) are medical and public health
devices and their functions to educate users about health and practices supported by mobile devices such as mobile
improve the performance of existing health services [3]. phones, patient surveillance devices, PDAs (Personal Digital
Despite its benefits, the use of m-health in developing Assistants), and other wireless devices [9], In other words,
country such as Indonesia has not been maximized due to m-health is an application that utilizes mobile devices and
inadequate infrastructure and low level of health awareness their functions to educate users about health and improve the
[4], In addition, there are also other factors such as security performance o f existing health services [3]. The use of m-
and privacy issues, lack of regulatory oversight, and limited health brings several advantages such as being able to
evidence-based literature [5]. provide health services to rural areas and faster emergency
services [4]. Additionally, m-health may provide health
Technology-based healthcare trends in Indonesia are services at more affordable prices and faster access while
experiencing considerable growth. This happened due to the mainting the quality with evidence-based health information
existence of many health-related problems that can be solved [5]. However, the benefits of a m-health can only be felt if
with m-health technology. For example, there is a large gap every element of the m-health including infrastructure, health
between number of doctors and patients in Indonesia. The facilities, and medical practitioners are available [10].
imbalanced distribution between doctors and the needs of the
community, especially in rural areas [6]. Halodoc, a startup Halodoc is an m-health application that features a
company that develop mobile health application in doctor's consultation, laboratory checks, and inter-pharmacy.
Indonesia, try to solve this problem by providing Halodoc worked with 19,000 doctors spread across Indonesia
communities with access to doctors through its application and has more than 100 thousand users by early 2017 [11].
[7]. Other health-related startups in Indonesia, such as Halodoc provide scheduled online consultation with doctors
Alodokter and Medika, develop many applications that can via app by utilizing voice and video call. Patients may
help solving health-related issue in Indonesia [8]. Halodoc benefit from Halodoc since they do not have to go to
itself is considered as a new startup since Halodoc was hospitals to consult a doctor. Moreover, patients can also
choose doctor based on their budget. In Indonesia, doctors

87
ICACSIS 2018 978-1-7281-0135-4/18/S31.00 ©2018 IEEE
can have difference consultation fees. Additionally, Halodoc the website again. Therefore, these following hypotheses are
also provide ApotikAntar, a feature that allows patients to proposed:
buy medicines without having to leave the house.
H2a: Perceived usefulness positively influence users’
attitude to adopt Halodoc.
B. Behavioral Intention towards m-health apps
Behavioral intention is a factor that explains a person's H2b: Perceived usefulness positively influence users’
intentions in using or adopting a behavior, in this case, behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc.
adopting a m-health application [12]. Behavioral intention Perceived severity can be defined as a factor that
can be influenced by technological aspects, organization, and describes how serious the impact can be caused by a threat
characteristics of an individual. Ajzen [13] states that the [21]. Perceived severity, one o f the factors in protection
greater a person's intention in adopting a behavior, the more motivation theory (PMT), is important to be considered in
likely he is to do it. This is confirmed by Davis [14] and the context of m-health adoption. This is because perceived
Venkatesh et al. [15] which states that behavioral intention is severity is a factor that describes how a perceived threat can
a strong predictor in determining the adoption o f the actual increase awareness that will affect the attitudes and
use of technology [3]. behaviors that will be adopted, in this case using the m-
Research on m-health adoption are mainly using health application to avoid possible threats [22]. Thus, these
information technology adoption such as TAM, TPB, and following hyphotheses are developed:
UTAUT. These theories have their own strength and H3a: Perceived severity positively influence users’
weakness, so many researchers try to combine several attitude to adopt Halodoc.
theories to provide a more thorough perspective. This study
also combines several IT adoption theories. However, this H3b: Perceived severity positively influence users’
study also uses health-related theories such as Health Belief behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc.
Model (HBM) and Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) [16] Subjective norm defined as the influence or pressure that
to predict what factors affecting users’ intention to use comes from the social environment to someone to do or not
Halodoc. to do a certain behavior [13]. Many researchers referred
subjective norms as determining factor in ones’ intention to
III. H y p o t h eses De v e l o pm e n t
adopt a technology. A study conducted by Verissimo found
Perceived ease of use, a factor from Technology that doctors tend to want to use medical mobile applications
Acceptance Model, describes a person's level of trust in after discussions between doctors that give positive
easiness of using a technology [16]. Perceived ease of use responses towards the application [23]. In the context of
can be assessed based on several characteristics such as the HaloDoc, the desire to use the application can arise due to
clarity and easiness to understand the technology, easy to be the influence of people around the user. Thus, these
learned, flexible, and does not require much effort to use it. following hyphotheses are developed:
Davis [14] states that an application that is easy to use can be
easier to be accepted by users. This argument also supported H4: Subjective norm positively influence users’
by the research of Dwivedi et al. [17] which states that the behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc.
ease of use of a technology is an important factor in Perceived behavioral control is one of the factors in TPB
determining a person's attitude and intention towards new which describes a person's assessment of his ability to use
technology. Additionally, a study from Day et al. [18] found technology [12]. Ajzen [13] states that perceived behavioral
that although an m-health application was very useful for control is an important factor in determining a person's
patients, if it was difficult to use, the patients will have behavioral intention. This is because, one's self-confidence is
negative perception towards the app and reduce their very influential on actions that he will do in the future. Ajzen
intention to use it [19]. Based on this, these following [13] gives an example if there are two people who have the
hyphotheses are developed: same desire to practice skiing, and they have tried it,
Hla: Perceived ease o f use positively influence users’ someone who has better confidence in his ability has a
attitude to adopt Halodoc. greater likelihood o f being able to master skiing than people
who doubt his ability. Therefore, this study wants to see the
Hlb: Perceived ease of use positively influence users’ effect o f perceived behavioral control in the context of m-
behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc. health adoption. Thus, this following hypothesis is
In TAM, perceived usefulness can be defined as a developed:
person's level of trust that using a system will improve their H5: Perceived behavioral control positively influence
performance [14], Perceived usefulness can be measured users’ behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc.
from several aspects, namely faster task completion,
improvement on services quality, improvement on the Trust is a factor that explains a person's level of
efficiency and accuracy o f patient services [19], Davis [14] confidence that using m-health applications is safe and there
states that generally a person will have the desire to use an is privacy threat [16]. In the context of m-health application,
application if he believes that the application will help him the level of trust can be measured by various aspects o f the
doing his work better. This was confirmed by Lim et al. [20] such as the honesty of the service provider, the credibility of
through their research. Lim et al. [20] ask group of women in the service provider, and the reputation o f the m-health
Singapore to read health-related information from mobile service provider. If a m-health application has good
website. The women found that the information is useful to credibility and is trusted by its users, then the user's desire to
improve their health and confidence, so they want to access use the application will increase. Thus, this following
hypothesis is proposed:

88
ICACSIS 2018 978-l-7281-0135-4/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE
H6: Trust positively influence users' behavioral intention influence users’ intention to adoption an application, in this
to adopt Halodoc. case, the m-health application. Therefore, this study proposes
that:
Perceived risk can be defined as a subjective expectation
o f a user against the loss that will be felt when using mobile H9a: System quality positively influence users’ attitude
health application [24]. M-health applications such as to adopt Halodoc.
Halodoc have similar potential risks with online transactions
H9b: System quality positively influence users’
in general. There are possibilities o f transaction failures that
behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc.
may harm users. Additionally, there are possibilities of fraud
that may lead to a decrease in the user's desire to adopt m- Attitude is a factor that explains the level of a person's
health application. The greater the risk a person feels about assessment of things that are beneficial or not profitable from
the m-health application, the person tends to discourage of the behavior in question [29]. Cocosila and Archer (2010) in
using m-health applications [16]. Therefore, this study the study o f Hussein et al. states that attitude is one of the
concludes the following hypothesis: factors that play an important role in the adoption of a
technology [3]. In the context of this research, if a user has a
H7: Perceived risk negatively influence users’ behavioral
positive attitude towards the m-health application, then the
intention to adopt Halodoc.
more likely the user is to adopt it [12]. Based on this
Self-health awareness is a factor that explains a person's explanation, it can be concluded that:
awareness of his/her health condition and has the confidence
H10: Attitude positively influence users’ behavioral
to manage it by adopting healthy behaviour [25]. The use of
intention to adopt Halodoc.
m-health applications such as Halodoc can be categorized as
healthy living behavior because through the use of Figure 1 illustrate the study’s research model that was
applications, users can search information that can improve developed in prior paragraph. There are 15 hypotheses
their health conditions. Aalto and Uutela (1997) in the study proposed in this study.
o f Deng and Liu [26] found that the more a person's
confidence in his ability to manage self-health, the more IV. Re s e a r ch Me t hodol ogy
likely it is for someone to adopt healthy behavior. Therefore,
this hypothesis is given: A. Instrument Development
H8a: Self-health awareness positively influence users’ Questionnaire is utilized to collect data by measuring 11
attitude to adopt Halodoc. variables that examined in this research, namely, perceived
H8b: Self-health awareness positively influence users’ usefulness, perceived ease of use, perceived risk, perceived
behavioral intention to adopt Halodoc. behavioural control, system quality, self-health awareness,
trust, perceived severity, subjective norm, attitude, and
According to Mohamadali & Aziz, system quality is a behavioural intention. The indicators o f each variable are
factor that explains the characteristics expected from an developed based on previous research and then translated to
information system such as ease o f use, system flexibility, Bahasa Indonesia. Five-point Likert scales are employed to
system reliability, feature usage, and response time [27]. The indicate the respondent’s levels o f agreement or
results o f research conducted by Barakovic & Skorin-Kapov disagreement with each statement. Table I shows the
state that system quality aspects such as loading time, example of indicators for perceived usefulness’ construct To
interface design, usability, and information quality have an maintain the meaning o f original instruments, readability test
influence on the user's perception o f the use o f mobile web was conducted before starting the data collecting process.
browsing [28]. Furthermore, good system quality will also

Fig. 1. Research Model

89
ICACSIS 2018 978-1-7281-0135-4/18/S31.00 ©2018 IEEE
C ode Interview Q uotation C lassification
V. Re sea r c h M et h o d o l o g y Jabodetabek, Bandung, Batam,
Denpasar, Jambi, Kuta, Malang,
A. Instrument Development Padang, Palembang, Jogja, Semarang,
Solo, Sidoaijo, Samarinda, and
Questionnaire is utilized to collect data by measuring 11 Surabaya”
variables that examined in this research, namely, perceived
usefulness, perceived ease o f use, perceived risk, perceived VI. Re sea r c h Re s u l t s
behavioural control, system quality, self-health awareness,
trust, perceived severity, subjective norm, attitude, and A. Construct Validation
behavioural intention. The indicators o f each variable are The proposed research model consists o f formative and
developed based on previous research and then translated to reflective indicators. For formative indicators, we assess its
Bahasa Indonesia. Five-point Likert scales are employed to validity by measuring the VIF and T-value as can be seen in
indicate the respondent’s levels of agreement or Table IV. Additionally, we assess the reliability o f reflective
disagreement with each statement. Table I shows the indicators by measuring its Composite Reliability,
example of indicators for perceived usefulness’ construct. To Cronbach’s Alpha and loading factors. Meanwhile, the
maintain the meaning of original instruments, readability test validity o f reflective indicators is measured using AVE. The
was conducted before starting the data collecting process. results o f reliability and validity testing is depicted at Table
IV.
TABLE I. In d ic a t o r s for Pe r c e iv e d u sef u l n ess c o n st r u c t

C ode Indicators Source TABLE IV. Th e Re s u l t s o f Re l ia b il it y a nd Co n v e r g e n t


PU1 HaloDoc App can speed up searching Davis (1989) Va l id it y Te s t in g
process for finding suitable doctor’s schedule
L oading
PU2 HaloDoc App can improve my productivity W u e ta l. (2011) V ariable Indicator CA CR AVE
F actor
PU3 HaloDoc App is effective to use Davis (1989)
ATTl 0,852
PU4 HaloDoc App is efficient to use Davis (1989)
A ttitude ATT2 0,88 0,825 0,896 0,741
PU5 Overall, HaloDoc App is useful to me W u e ta l. (2011)
ATT3 0,851
B. Data Collection BI1 0,841
Behavioral
BI2 0,864 0,728 0,846 0,649
The sample o f this study was HaloDoc users in Intention
BD 0,702
Indonesia that utilize the app for searching health related HA1 0,705
information, reserving doctor appointment, and ordering Self-H ealth HA2 0,825
0,808 0,874 0,635
medicine. The data were collected via an official online Awareness HA3 0,823
survey questionnaire by using Survey UI domain. HA4 0,829
Participants were recruited via popular social networking PBC1 0,862
Perceived
PBC2 0,721
sites for Tokopedia users such as Facebook, Line Square, behavioral 0,805 0,873 0,634
PBC3 0,739
Whatsapp, Twitter, Instagram, dan Linkedln. Limited gifts control
PBC4 0,853
were offered to encourage participation. After deleting PEOU1 0,851
duplicates and incomplete responses, 146 valid surveys Perceived PEOU2 0,82
0,901 0,927 0,717
remained. Besides using a questionnaire, this study also ease o f use PEOU3 0,852
using a qualitative data by doing interview with the PEOU4 0,838
organization (Halodoc). The interview result will be used to PR1 0,918
P erceived
support the quantitative data to provide a more in-depth PR3 0,841 0,791 0,873 0,698
risk
PR4 0,739
analysis. Table II summarizes the demographics of the
PS1 0,899
respondents and Table HI shows some part of interview Perceived
PS2 0,82 0,877 0,918 0,789
result. Severity
PS3 0,941
PU2 0,758
TABLE II. De m o g r a ph y o f r e s po n d e n t s P erceived PU3 0,832
0,815 0,878 0,644
usefulness PU4 0,81
D em ographic C ategory Frequency %
PU5 0,808
Gender Male 42 29%
Female 104 71%
Age <21 26 18%
21-30 105 72% TABLE V. Th e Re s u l t s o f Re l ia b il it y a n d Co n v e r g e n t
31-40 7 5% Va l id it y Te s t in g (c o n t .)
>40 7 5%
P eriod o f using HaloDoc < 1 year 124 85% L oading
V ariable Indicator CA CR AVE
App 1-2 year 22 15% F actor
Frequency o f using < 5 times 120 82% SN1 0,932
Subjective
HaloDoc app in last month 5-10 times 32 22% SN2 0,888 0,9 0,936 0,83
Norm
> 10 times 4 3% SN3 0,912
T1 0,786
TABLE m . In t e r v ie w Su m m a r y T2 0,729
Trust T3 0,83 0,849 0,893 0,625
C ode Interview Q uotation C lassification T4 0,808
Ql “Halodoc was launched in April T5 0,795
21*2016”
Organization
02 “Halodoc is a data-driven company”
Profile
Q3 “Halodoc services have spread in
several big cities in Indonesia, such as

90
ICACSIS 2018 978-1-7281-0135-4/18/S31.00 ©2018 IEEE
TABLE VI. Th e Re s u l t s o f Re l ia b il it y a nd Co n v e r g e n t attach great importance to the use of m-health, especially to
Va l id it y Te s t in g
increase the activities that they carry out on a daily basis
V ariable Indicators T-value V IF [31].
SQ1 1,821 1,193
SQ2 2,667 1,39 The result shows that perceived severity does not have a
System Quality SQ3 7,19 1,385 positive influence on both users’ attitude and behavioral
SQ4 3,214 1,684 intention in using Halodoc application. This contrasts with
SQ5 2,975 1,398 the research of Zhao, Ni and Zhou which states that
perceived severity has a significant relationship to attitude
B. Hypothesis Testing
[16]. However, this finding aligns with Zhao, Ni and Zhou
We tested the hypotheses through Partial Least Squares that found that perceived severity does not have a strong
regression analyses using Smart PLS (v. 3.2.7). The influence compared to perceived vulnerability. Zhao, Ni and
explanatory power of the structural model is evaluated by the Zhou [16] stated that this was caused by the habits of users
R2 value, (see Table VI). In order to examine if each who only wanted to use mobile health if they had contracted
hypothesis is supported, this study assessed the path the disease not to prevent existing risks.
coefficients as can be seen at Table VII. This study utilizes
one-tailed test to examine the proposed hyphotheses. A In this study, subjective norm and perceived risk do not
hyphothesis would be accepted if have p-value less than 0.05 have a positive influence on users' behavioral intention to
with confidence level of 95% [30]. Among 15 hypotheses, 7 adopt Halodoc application. This contrasts with research
are accepted and the rest are rejected. conducted by Zhao, Ni and Zhou [16]. However, Chau and
Hu [32] argue that subjective norms do not have a significant
t a bl e vn. h y po t h e s e s t e s t in g relationship to doctors' behavioral intention to use
telemedicine technology due their concern that the new
V ariable R2
A ttitude 0,753
technology will not fit their daily routines and disrupt their
B ehavioral Intention 0,740 performance. Morover, from patients’ perspective that lives
in developing countries such as Indonesia, health awareness
TABLE V O . Hy po t h e s e s Te s t in g is seldom become their priority. Thus, influence from others
will rarely bring significant impacts on their intention to
H ypo­ adopt m-health application. Meanwhile, this study found that
P ath P -values Results
theses
H la PEOU -> ATT 0,065 Rejected
perceived risk does not have a negative influence on users'
H lb PEOU -> BI 0,275 Rejected behavioral intention in using Halodoc application. This
H2a PU -> ATT 0,0001 Accepted contrasts with research conducted by Zhao, Ni, and Zhou
H2b PU -> BI 0,003 Accepted [16], Based on authors’ observation, Halodoc users may not
H3a PS -> ATT 0,097 Rejected fully aware of the risks that might occur when using the
H3b PS -> BI 0,184 Rejected application. Furthermore, users’ may feel that the benefit
H4 SN -> BI 0,225 Rejected they get exceed its risks [24]. Halodoc provides free health
H5 PBC -> BI 0,016 Accepted
article services to educate users about healthly lifestyle. In
H6 T -> BI 0,034 Accepted
H7 PR -> BI 0,182 Rejected
order to access this useful article, one may be willing to be
H8a HA -> ATT 0,008 Accepted exposed to some risks.
H8b HA -> BI 0,140 Rejected
This study found that perceived behavioral control has a
H9a SQ -> ATT 0,0000001 Accepted
H9b SQ -> BI 0,415 Rejected
positive influence on the user's behavioral intention in using
H 10 ATT -> BI 0,014 Accepted Halodoc application. The majority of respondents in this
study belong to the productive age and live in the Greater
Jakarta area that use technology in their daily routines. Thus,
VII. D is c u s s io n they tend to be more confidence in using Halodoc.
Additionally, trust is also found as antecedent of users'
The results showed that perceived ease of use does not
behavioral intention in using Halodoc app. This is consistent
have a positive influence on users’ attitude and behavioral
with research conducted by Zhao, Ni, and Zhou [16] which
intention in using Halodoc app. This is contrary to research
find that users often rely heavily on their impression towards
conducted by Zhao, Ni and Zhou [16] which states that there
a technology which later will influence their belief in
is a significant relationship between perceived ease of use
adopting it. As new mobile health application, Halodoc
and attitude and behavioral intention. However, one may
employs doctors that registered in the Indonesian Doctors
argue that doctors, one of the subjects in this research, are
Association (IDI) and Indonesian Medical Council (KKI).
professionals who familiar with the use of technology and
This give users assurance they needed when using Halodoc
are open to new technology. Therefore, these doctors do not
service.
attach importance to the ease o f use of technology (Barker et
al., 2003). VIII. L i m i t a t io n a n d Co n c l u s io n

Additionally, this study shows that perceived usefulness This study aims to analyze the factors that influence the
has a positive influence on users’ attitude and behavioral user's intention to use the mobile health application in
intention in using Halodoc app. This finding is in line with Indonesia with the Halodoc case study. This study uses
research conducted by Zhao, Ni and Zhou [16] which states quantitative and qualitative approaches. Based on the results
that perceived uselfidness has a significant relationship to of processing and data analysis, it can be concluded that
attitude and behavioral intention o f users in adopting mobile perceived ease of use and perceived severity does not affect
health. Moreover, this finding is also supported by Rajkovic the attitude and behavioral users in using the mobile health
et al. which states that the users o f health-related technology Halodoc application. Meanwhile, subjective norms,

91
ICACSIS 2018 978-1-7281-0135-4/18/S31.00 ©2018 IEEE
perceived risk, self-health awareness, and system quality do Information Technology M IS Q. 13 319-40
not affect the user's behavioral intention in using the Halodoc [15] Venkatesh V, Davis F D and Morris M G 2007 Dead Or Alive?
mobile health application. Furthermore, perceived behavioral The Development, Trajectory And Future O f Technology
Adoption Research J. A ssoc. I n f Syst. 8 267-86
control, trust, and attitude have a positive influence on users’
[16] Zhao Y, Ni Q and Zhou R 2017 What factors influence the
behavioral intention. Lastly, self-health awareness and mobile health service adoption? A meta-analysis and the
system quality influence users’ behavioral intention through moderating role of age Int. J. I n f M anage.
attitude. [17] Dwivedi Y K, Shareef M A, Simintiras A C, Lai B and
Weerakkody V 2016 A generalised adoption model for services:
All the findings of this study may be explored and A cross-country comparison o f mobile health (m-health) Gov. Inf.
implemented by companies that developed mobile health Q. 33 174-87
related application. For example, this study suggest that [18] Day M, Demiris G, Oliver D P, Courtney K and Hensel B 2007
every organization who developed mobile health application Exploring Underutilization o f Videophones in Hospice Settings
should pay more attention to the usefulness o f the service Telemed. e-Health 13 25-32
provided, since the service must resolve users’ problems. [19] Holden R J and Karsh B T 2010 The Technology Acceptance
Another example is the organization should minimize the Model: its past and its future in health J. Biomed. Inform atics 43
risk of using a mobile health application in order to gain 159-75
users’ trust toward the application. This study does, however, [20] Lim S, Xue L, Yen C C, Chang L, Chan H C, Tai B C, Duh H B
L and Choolani M 2011 A study on Singaporean women’s
pose certain limitations. First, we limited our study to acceptance of using mobile phones to seek health information Int.
Halodoc as investigated application. Second, the J. Med. Inform . 80
demography of respondents did not represents all users [21] Vance A, Siponen M and Pahnila S 2012 Motivating IS security
characteristics of mobile health in Indonesia. Moreover, compliance: Insights from Habit and Protection Motivation
future research must explore other factors that may affect Theory Inf. Manag. 49 190-8
user’s attitude and intention to use mobile health application. [22] Johnston A C and Warkentin M 2010 Fear Appeals and
Further data collection needs to be conducted in order to Information Security Behaviors: An Empirical Study Fear
Appeals and Information Security Behaviors: An Empirical Study
improve the results of this study.
M IS Q. 34 549-66
[23] Alkhateeb F M and Doucette W R 2009 Influences on
Re f e r en ces physicians’ adoption of electronic detailing (e-detailing)
[1] United Nations Development Programme 2016 Human Inform atics Heal. Soc. Care 34 39-52
Development Index (HD I) Hum. Dev. Reports [24] Wu J-H, Wang S-C and Lin L-M 2005 What Drives Mobile
Health Care? An Empirical Evaluation o f Technology
[2] APJH 2016 Survey o f Internet Penetration and Users Behaviour
Acceptance Proc. 38th Annu. H aw aii Int. Conf. Syst. Sci. 0150a-
in Indonesia. Infographic. (Jakarta)
150a
[3] Hussein Z, Oon S W and Fikry A 2017 Consumer Attitude: Does
It Influencing the Intention to Use mHealth? Procedia Computer [25] Loebnitz N and Grunert K G 2018 Impact o f self-health
awareness and perceived product benefits on purchase intentions
Science yol 105pp 340-4
for hedonic and utilitarian foods with nutrition claims Food Qual.
[4] Varshney U 2014 A model for improving quality of decisions in Prefer. 64 221-31
mobile health D ecis. Support Syst. 62 66-77
[26] Deng Z and Liu S 2017 Understanding consumer health
[5] Kao C K and Liebovitz D M 2017 Consumer Mobile Health information-seeking behavior from the perspective o f the risk
Apps: Current State, Barriers, and Future Directions P M R 9 perception attitude framework and social support in mobile social
S106-15 media websites Int. J. M ed. Inform . 105 98-109
[6] Agustian A 2017 Assessing Growth Potential in Health-Related [27] Mohamadali N A and Aziz N F A 2017 The Technology Factors
Startup | Menerka Potensi Perkembangan Startup di Bidang as Barriers for Sustainable Health Information Systems (HIS)-A
Kesehatan D ailysocial Review Procedia Computer Science vol 124pp 370-8
[7] HaloDoc Now, Health Discussion is more practical by utilizing [28] Barakovic S and Skorin-Kapov L 2016 “Multidimensional
Virtual Doctor Application modelling of quality of experience for mobile Web browsing” :
[8] Pratama A 2018 Challenges and Opportunities in Health Related Corrigendum. Comput. Human Behav. 56 376
Startup in Indonesia 2018
[29] Wu I L, Li J Y and Fu C Y 2011 The adoption o f mobile
[9] World Health Organization 2011 mHealth: New horizons for healthcare by hospital’s professionals: An integrative perspective
health through mobile technologies O bservatory 3 66-71 D ecis. Support Syst. 51 587-96
[10] Mechael P N 2009 The Case for mHealth in Developing [30] Kock N 2016 Hypothesis Testing with Confidence Intervals and
Countries Innov. Technol. Governance, Glob. 4 103-18 P Values in PLS-SEM Int. J. e-Collaboration 12 1-6
[11] Liliyah A 2017 Jonathan Sudharta, Facing new Quadrant for the [31] Rajkovic P, Aleksic D, Jankovic D, Milenkovic A and Petkovic I
Sake of Halodoc SW A.co.id. 2018 Checking the potential shift to perceived usefulness— The
[12] Deng Z, Mo X and Liu S 2014 Comparison of the middle-aged analysis of users’ response to the updated electronic health record
and older users’ adoption of mobile health services in China Int. core features Int. J. M ed. Inform. 115 80-91
J Med. Inform. 83 210-24 [32] Chau P Y K and Hu P J H 2002 Investigating healthcare
[13] Azjen I 1991 The theory of planned behavior Organ. Behav. professionals’ decisions to accept telemedicine technology: An
Hum. D ecis. Process. 50 211 empirical test of competing theories Inf. Manag. 39 297-311
[14] Davis F D 1989 Perceived Ease o f Use, and User Acceptance of

92

You might also like