You are on page 1of 8

ORIGINAL RESEARCH

An Empirical Study of Adopting Mobile


Healthcare Service: The Family’s
Perspective on the Healthcare Needs
of Their Elderly Members

Wen-Yuan Jen, Ph.D.,1 and Ming-Chien Hung, Ph.D.2 attitude (58.1%), and perceived usefulness (33.8%). Overall, this
study shows that attitude was an important determinant of MHS
1
National United University, Institute of Information and Society, adoption. Gender also significantly affected the relationship between
Miao-Li, Taiwan. attitude and behavioral intention to adopt MHS.
2
Department of Information Management, Nanhua University,
Chia-Yi, Taiwan. Key words: mobile healthcare service, aging people, theory of
planned behavior, technology acceptance model

Abstract
In an aging society, the issue of increased medical costs troubles both Introduction

T
government agencies and families with aging parents. Many elderly aiwan is currently facing a demographic dilemma; fewer
people require long-term care, and the medical and financial prob- children are being born, and the overall population is aging.
lems associated with long-term care worry their entire family. Mobile At the same time, the cost of medical care is increasing
healthcare service (MHS) has been widely applied by medical yearly.1 The issue of increased medical expenses for an
practitioners and researchers for years. Unfortunately, the elderly aging population is a thorny issue awaiting solution.2 A report on
often fear both the technology and the cost its use incurs; hence, they healthcare for elderly Americans shows that 85% of people age 65
seldom actively adopt MHS without the prompting and support of and older report at least one chronic condition; more than half report
other family members. This study highlights this issue of long-term at least two; and more than a quarter report three or more.3 Hence, we
healthcare for the elderly and extracts the factors affecting their have to work hard to provide effective healthcare resources for the
family’s intentions in adopting MHS. Based on the integration of the elderly. With increasing improvement in mobile technology, mobile
Theory of Planned Behavior and the Technology Acceptance Model, healthcare is becoming an increasingly effective and economical
the factors associated with the family’s intention of the aging people approach for providing healthcare services to the elderly.
toward MHS are explored. Data were collected from 200 students in Chronically ill elderly require more long-term care than other
the ‘‘Job Master’’ track in a local ‘‘Executive Master of Business segments of the population. Providing healthcare for the elderly is an
Administration’’ program. Half of them had at least one immediate increasingly heavy burden and an important issue for families with
family member who was older than 65 years of age. A partial least elderly parents, insurers, and government agencies. Loera points out
squares (PLS) analysis shows that ‘‘attitude’’ significantly affected that the elderly perceive that mobile healthcare service (MHS) might
the behavioral intention of adopting MHS, and ‘‘perceived useful- positively improve their access to healthcare services.4 Although
ness’’ and ‘‘perceived ease-of-use’’ had an indirect effect via ‘‘atti- Loera found the application of MHS was a convenient approach for
tude.’’ The PLS model explains the variance in intention (64.1%), most elderly people, some of them might have difficulty using MHS

DOI: 10.1089=tmj.2009.0093 ª M A R Y A N N L I E B E R T , I N C . . VOL. 16 N O . 1 . J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH 41


JEN AND HUNG

technology. Moreover, fear of increased financial burden may cause attitude mediates the link between intention and beliefs about PU and
the elderly to delay their use of MHS, thereby worrying family PEOU. That is,
members and endangering their own health.
B ¼ BI ¼ w1 A þ w2 PU
Information provided by MHS is shared by patients, their families,
A ¼ w3 PU þ w4 PEOU
and medical care providers. However, past studies provide an in-
complete picture of a family’s intention to provide MHS for their PU ¼ w5 PEOU
elderly. While identifying the benefits of innovative mobile service to In past studies, the explanatory power of TPB and TAM has been
users is important,5 it is also important to investigate the factors inconsistent. While TAM focuses on the characteristics of system
affecting the acceptance of mobile healthcare technology.6 As con- design and is particularly useful as a guide to design efforts, TPB pays
cerned family members are the primary buyers of MHS services for more attention to normative and control factors so that organizations
elderly patients, this study investigates MHS purchaser intention can easily implement the system based on those characteristics.9 In
(immediate family of elderly patients) rather than user intention Chinese tradition, long-term healthcare of the family’s elderly is a
(elderly patients). Employing an intention-based approach, this study filial obligation. As perceived ability and control may be important
examines the integrated model derived from Theory of Planned Be- determinants of behavior,8,9 we used TPB as a direct predicting model
havior (TPB) and Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) to extract the of behavior intention and regarded the PU and PEOU as determinants
factors influencing a family’s intention of providing MHS services to of attitude that indirectly influence behavior intention. That is,
their elderly members.
TPB is grounded on the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA),7,8 which BI ¼ w1 A þ w2 SN þ w3 PBC
focuses on the behaviors of people who have incomplete volitional A ¼ w4 PU þ w5 PEOU
control.8 TRA regarded behavior (B) as a direct function of behavioral PU ¼ w6 PEOU
intention (BI) and represented the antecedents of BI through attitude
BI is the most important determinant of behavior for current
(A), which reflects the favorable or unfavorable feelings to perform
predicting models for information technology (IT) use,9 and the
a behavior, and subjective norm (SN), which reflects individual per-
formation of an intention to carry out a behavior is regarded as a
ceptions of social pressure to perform or not to perform the behavior.
necessary precursor to behavior.8,9 As behavior can be predicted from
As an extension of TRA, TPB adds the concept of perceived behavioral
intention with considerable accuracy when behavior poses no serious
control (PBC), which reflects the perceptions of ease or difficulty of
problems of control,8 selecting intention as the measurement of be-
performing the behavior to address conditions in which the individual
havior is theoretically justifiable and pragmatically adequate for IT in
does not have complete control over the performed behavior.8,9 In TPB,
the early stages, especially because use is not yet widespread.6 This
behavior is determined by BI and PBC; BI is a weighted function of
article assessed the effects of attitude, SN, and PBC on BI, but it did
attitude, subjective norm, and PBC. TPB can be formally stated below:
not directly measure behaviors. Additionally, attitude often plays a
B ¼ w1 BI þ w2 PBC major role in deciding IT use, and because personal demographics
BI ¼ w3 A þ w4 SN þ w5 PBC (e.g., age, gender, education level, monthly salary, marital status, and
age and residency of parents) may influence attitudes toward IT, the
where w is weight.
moderator effect of demographics should be further explored. Thus,
Using TRA and TPB, it is difficult to identify a stable set of belief
we modified the function of BI as below:
structures for attitude.9 Likewise, SN is difficult to draw out from the
mediator effort of attitude.8 TAM is a special case of TRA in which BI ¼ w1 A þ w2 SN þ w3 PBC þ w4 ADemographics
two beliefs are specified: perceived usefulness (PU), which reflects The aim of this study is to explore the factors that affect the
user’s subjective belief that using the technology will increase family’s intention to adopt MHS for their elderly. In the following
her=his performance, and perceived ease-of-use (PEOU), which in- pages, material and methods are briefly described, and an overview
dicates the degree to which the mobile health service technology is of the survey results and discussion are presented.
easy to understand or operate. These factors comprise attitude and
exclude the roles of subjective norm9,10 and personal control factors Materials and Methods
on behavior.9 TAM regards behavior as a direct function of BI, and BI TPB and TAM provided taxonomies of variables affecting the in-
is modeled by attitude and PU. PEOU is a direct determinant of PU; tention to adopt innovative technology. Following the purpose of this

42 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0


EMPIRICAL STUDY OF ADOPTING MOBILE HEALTHCARE SERVICE

study, the research model and hypotheses are proposed (Fig. 1 family elders (end users). Questionnaires were distributed to students
presents the research model): enrolled in an Executive Master of Business Administration (EMBA)
H1: Perceived ease-of-use is positively associated with perceived program at a university in central Taiwan. Generally speaking, most
usefulness. EMBA students are of good economic status, are strongly motivated
H2: Perceived ease-of-use is positively associated with attitude. learners, and are open to adopting innovative services=products;
H3: Perceived usefulness is positively associated with attitude. hence, this study invited EMBA students to be our sample.
H4: Perceived usefulness is positively associated with behavioral The questionnaire consisted of two parts. The first part elicited
intention of adopting MHS. respondent demographics, including age, gender, education, marital
H5: Subjective norm is positively associated with behavioral in- status, monthly salary, age of parents, and parent’s residency status.
tention of adopting MHS. The second part contained the questionnaire proper, which consisted
H6: Perceived behavioral control is positively associated with of 27 statements to which respondents were asked to indicate their
behavioral intention of adopting MHS. degree of agreement. All 27 statements of the instrument had been
H7: Attitude is positively associated with behavioral intention of validated by prior research.9 In order to assess the face validity of the
adopting MHS. questionnaire, the help of 3 healthcare professionals and 2 mobile
H8: Demographics have a moderating impact on the relationship service researchers was enlisted. After discussion, the initial ques-
between attitude and behavioral intention of adopting MHS. tionnaire was revised to ensure that there was a good match between
In Chinese society, the family is a very important source of sup- the information the questionnaire elicited and the factors upon which
port. The obligation to take care of one’s parents is especially em- the intention to adopt MHS would be measured.
phasized, and this intergenerational transfer is a safeguard against A review of the literature shows that partial least squares (PLS) is a
aging for the elders. Hence, providing long-term care for one’s family powerful second-generation multivariate technique for analyzing
elders is an age-old tradition that continues today. Today’s elderly causal models involving multiple constructs with multiple observed
experienced post-World War II reconstruction and economic re- items.11 The PLS analysis was used to assess associations between
cession; hence, they tend to be less well educated and less inclined factors and behavior intention. Both measurement and structural
to learn new things, and to be generally more conservative in their model were run simultaneously using Visual PLS 1.04b. The detailed
spending habits. In addition, some elderly are economically disad- descriptive analysis of demography was made by SPSS 13.0 (SPSS,
vantaged because they have already distributed their assets to their Inc., Chicago, IL).
children, another tradition. Influenced by these traditional values
and attitudes, most elderly will adopt innovative services=products Results
only at the urging and under the guidance of family members. Since Of the 200 questionnaires distributed, 192 were returned. After
most elderly are not MHS primary purchasers, this study investigates excluding incomplete questionnaires and questionnaires indicating
immediate family (purchaser) intention rather than the intention of no elder family member, a total of 100 usable questionnaires re-
mained, a validation rate of 50%. The question items
for the abovementioned constructs are listed in the
Subjective Norm Appendix. Respondents of valid questionnaires were
59% male; 49% were between the ages of 41 and 50;
H5
Perceived
and 72% of respondents’ parent’s residency status was
Behavioral Control H6 ‘‘living with children.’’ All data are listed in Table 1. An
Behavioral analysis of the measurement model and structural
Perceived H4 Intention of model based on those samples is presented below.
Usefulness H7
H3 adopting MHS In the measurement model, convergent validity is
H1 Attitude H8 commonly used to assess construct validity.12 There
Perceived Ease are three recommended criteria.13 First, factor load-
H2 Demographics
of Use ings of all standardized items are suggested to be
higher than 0.5. Second, the composite reliability is
Fig. 1. Research model. MHS, mobile healthcare service. suggested to be higher than 0.6.14 Third, the average

ª M A R Y A N N L I E B E R T , I N C . . VOL. 16 N O . 1 . J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH 43


JEN AND HUNG

Table 1. Demographic Analysis (N ¼ 100) Table 1. Continued


ITEM % ITEM %
Gender Parent residency status

Male 59% Living alone 28%

Female 41% Living with children 72%

Age

<30 1%
variance extracted needs to be higher than 0.5. The results of con-
>31–40 39%
struct validity of the instrument are listed in Table 2 and showed good
41–50 49% construct validity. This means that the measurement model is ac-
51–60 9% ceptable in terms of construct validity. Overall, the results provided
empirical support for the instrument used to test our suggested model.
>60 2%
In the structural model, we use the BootStrap procedure15 to test the
Education significance for all paths. Figure 2 shows the relative strengths of each
College 61% path specified by the research model and the variance (R2) explained
by each path. First, as hypothesized, PEOU is significantly associated
Masters 39% with PU (b ¼ 0.582, t ¼ 8.942, p < 0.01) and R2 is 0.338. Second, PEOU
ITEM % is significantly associated with ATT (b ¼ 0.145, t ¼ 1.978, p < 0.05).
Month salary (USD) Third, PU is significantly associated with attitude (ATT) (b ¼ 0.668,
t ¼ 10.186, p < 0.01.) Collectively, PEOU and PU constructs account
<1,875 57%
for 58.1% of variance in ATT. Finally, among PU, SN, PBC, and ATT,
1,875–3,125 31% only ATT has significant impact on BI (b ¼ 0.547, t ¼ 5.744, p < 0.01)
>3,125 12%
and accounts for 64.1% of the variance in BI. In contrast, SN and PBC
are not significantly associated with the BI of adopting MHS. There-
Marital status fore, H1, H2, H3, and H7 are supported. The results indicate that the BI
Single 24% of adopting MHS is explained by PEOU, PU, and ATT.
Married 76%
In testing the moderator effect of demographics, the hierarchical
procedure was used to compare the R2 value for the interaction
Age of father models with the main effects model, which excluded the demo-
<65 years 1% graphic constructs. The difference of R2 value was used to judge the
overall effect value (f2) for the interaction where 0.02, 0.15, and 0.35
65–74 years 45%
had been suggested as small, moderate, and large effects, respec-
75–84 years 24% tively.16 As is shown in Table 3, gender and monthly salary moder-
>84 years 3% ated the relationship between attitude and behavior intention toward
MHS more greatly than in the main effect model and other interac-
ITEM %
tion effect models. Although the effect values for the moderated
Age of mother effects of gender and monthly salary were small (f2 ¼ 0.043 and
<65 years 1% 0.029), the effect of gender and monthly salary constructs still cannot
be ignored. Gender, specifically, has a significantly greater moder-
65–74 years 11%
ating effect than other demographics. The mean analysis for both
75–84 years 47% males and females toward MHS is listed in Table 4. Males demon-
>84 years 19% strate a greater intention to use MHS and have higher attitude scores
toward MHS than do females. With regard to the determinants of

44 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0


EMPIRICAL STUDY OF ADOPTING MOBILE HEALTHCARE SERVICE

Table 2. Descriptive Statistics and Psychometric Properties of Reflective Measures


CONSTRUCT CR AVE ITEM LOADING MEAN SD T-VALUE
SN 0.81 0.59 SN1 0.84 4.48 0.66 18.80

SN2 0.80 4.18 0.66 10.77

SN3 0.66 3.49 0.69 7.09

PBC 0.82 0.61 PBC1 0.52 3.40 1.02 3.25

PBC2 0.83 3.50 0.93 11.42

PBC3 0.93 3.60 0.77 26.90

ATT 0.94 0.81 ATT1 0.84 4.30 0.62 23.17

ATT2 0.92 4.10 0.72 49.26

ATT3 0.96 4.19 0.71 63.05

ATT4 0.89 4.18 0.63 31.29

PU 0.92 0.79 PU1 0.89 4.30 0.64 36.39

PU2 0.89 4.30 0.54 27.47

PU3 0.89 4.26 0.66 34.67

PEOU 0.78 0.54 PEOU1 0.82 4.18 0.72 13.16

PEOU2 0.68 3.89 0.68 7.77

PEOU3 0.68 3.86 0.84 8.46

BI 0.91 0.78 BI1 0.87 4.01 0.63 26.95

BI2 0.85 4.06 0.75 12.47

BI3 0.93 4.03 0.77 67.89


CR, composite reliability; AVE, average variance extracted; SD, standard deviation; SN, subjective norm; PBC, perceived behavioral control; ATT, attention; PU, perceived
usefulness; PEOU, perceived ease of use; BI, behavioral intention.

attitude, males place more emphasis on PU of MHS, while females help their elderly use the MHS technology. Similarly, Wu et al.17
value ease-of-use. pointed out that PU and PEOU significantly affected healthcare
professional BI in adopting the mobile healthcare information sys-
Discussion tem. Obviously, whether it be medical care professions or the family
This study objective integrated TAM and TPB, and the research of elderly patients, the primary factor in deciding to adopt MHS are
model explains 64.1% of families’ intention to adopt MHS for their PU and PEOU. Hence, we may conclude that, to be successful, all
elderly. The results indicated that attitude was the most important providers of mobile healthcare services and related products have to
factor in determining a family’s intention to accept MHS. Ad- simplify their service functions and interfaces. Ensuring that MHS
ditionally, while PEOU has a significant direct impact on PU of using purchasers and users will readily perceive how easy MHS technology
MHS, it also has an indirect effect on attitude of using MHS through is to use will also ensure future growth for the MHS industry.
the mediator of PU. As PEOU has an indirect effect on ATT, we have to Table 3 shows that both gender and monthly salary moderated the
focus on its impact. If an elderly patient’s family perceives MHS as relationship between attitude and behavior intention toward MHS.
easy to use, they also perceive it as useful; they then adopt MHS and This is an interesting issue that awaits researcher exploration. This

ª M A R Y A N N L I E B E R T , I N C . . VOL. 16 N O . 1 . J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH 45


JEN AND HUNG

cantly moderated the family’s attitude toward adopting


Subjective Norm MHS for use by their elderly family members.
(SN) In this study, we integrated TAM and TPB, and
explored whether normative and control factors affect

0.1 .841
a family’s intention to purchase MHS services for their
(1
59 )
Perceived

ns
elderly members. However, our findings indicated that
Behavioral Control
0.0 SN and PBC were not significantly associated with the
(PBC) (0. 55 ns
93 BI to adopt MHS. The study subjects, EMBA students,
2) Behavioral
Perceived
0.142ns Intention (BI) of had relatively high socio-economic status as well as
Usefulness (PU)
(1.913) Adopting MHS the competence and confidence to operate MHS
R2=0.338 2
0.6 .18

R =0.641
**
(1

technology. In Chinese society, long-term care for


68 6)

7
0

4
0.5 744)
**
0.582**
(8.942)

Attitude (ATT) ( 5. elders is provided for by the family. The subjective


R2=0.581 norm, a function of beliefs about the expectations of
(-2.202)
.9 *

-0.130*
(1 .145

important referent others, had no significant effect


)
78
0

Perceived Ease of
upon the subjects’ BI toward MHS. In other words, the
Use (PEOU) subjects did not consider these referents’ opinions;
Gender they cared only about the services and functions MHS
ns
non -significance
* p< 0.05 could provide. In sum, our findings indicated that
**p< 0.01 PEOU, PU, and ATT could efficiently explain and
predict family intention to purchase MHS services for
Fig. 2. Results of partial least-squares analysis. MHS, mobile healthcare service. their elderly members. During the present economic
recession, it is important that low-cost, effective long-
study extended prior research by theorizing and confirming a mod- term healthcare be provided for the elderly. As technology ad-
erator role of demographics in the link between attitude and behavior vances and more and more useful mobile healthcare services can
intention toward MHS. The results demonstrate that gender signifi- be conveniently provided18–20 for the elderly through easy-to-use

Table 3. Hierarchical Test


R2 **F 2 T-VALUE
Main effect model 0.625

Interaction effect model with gender of respondents 0.641 0.043 2.045*

Interaction effect model with monthly salary of respondents 0.636 0.029 1.442
(cut-off point ¼ $3,125 [USD])

Interaction effect model with education of respondents 0.632 0.019 1.288

Interaction effect model with age of respondents (cut-off point ¼ 40 years) 0.628 0.008 0.909

Interaction effect model with residency status of parents 0.628 0.008 0.316

Interaction effect model with marital status of respondents 0.626 0.003 0.663

Interaction effect model with age of parents (cut-off point ¼ 74 years) 0.625 0 0.958
*p < 0.05.
**f2 ¼ [R2 (interaction effect model)  R2 (main effect model)]=[1  R2 (main effect model)].

46 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0


EMPIRICAL STUDY OF ADOPTING MOBILE HEALTHCARE SERVICE

8. Ajzen I. The theory of planned behavior. Organiz Behav Hum Decision Process
Table 4. Means Analysis of Each Construct 1991;50:179–211.
PU EOU ATT PBC SN INT 9. Taylor S, Todd PA. Understanding information technology usage: A test of
Means Male 4.33 3.97 4.22 3.44 4.07 4.09 competing models. Inf Syst Res 1995;6:144–176.
10. Davis FD, Bagozzi RP, Warshaw PR. User acceptance of computer technology: A
Female 4.23 3.99 4.16 3.51 4.02 3.95 comparison of two theoretical models. Manage Sci 1989;35:982–1003.
PU, perceived usefulness; EOU, ease of use; ATT, attitude; PBC, perceived 11. Fornell C. A second generation of multivariate analysis, methods: Vol. 1. New
behavioral control; SN, subjective norm; INT, behavioral intention to adopt MHS. York: Praeger, 1982.
12. Sethi V, Carraher S. Developing measures for assessing the organizational
impact of information technology: A comment on Mahmood and Soon’s paper.
Decision Sci 1993;24:867–877.

interfaces, MHS will continue to contribute much to improving the 13. Fornell C, Larcker DF. Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable
variable variables and measurement error. J Market Res 1981;18:39–50.
quality of long-term healthcare services for the elderly.
14. Jőreskog KG, Sőrbom D. LISREL8: Users’ reference guide. Chicago, IL: Scientific
This research model is suitable for the areas of intergenerational Software International, 1993.
transfer cultures such as China, Japan, Taiwan, and other countries
15. Chin WW. The partial least squares approach for structural equation modeling.
whose social structures are based on Confucian values. However, this Modern methods for business research. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
research model will not necessarily be suitable for other cultures, Associates, 1998:295–336.
which is the limitation of this study. Finally, regardless of the local 16. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, 2nd ed.
culture, there is no doubt that family elders will benefit greatly from Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1988.
the extended healthcare services mobile devices deliver if their 17. Wu JH, Wang SC, Lin LM. Mobile computing acceptance factors in the
families purchase MHS services and guide them in their use. healthcare industry: A structural equation model. Int J Med Inform
2007;76:66–77.
18. Bonroy B, Schiepers P, Leysens G, Miljkovic D, Wils M, Maesschalck LD, Quanten
Disclosure Statement S, Triau E, Exadaktylos V, Berckmans D, Vanrumste B. Acquiring a dataset of
No competing financial interests exist. labeled video images showing discomfort in demented elderly. Telemed
e-Health 2009;15:370–378.
19. Bendixen RM, Levy CE, Olive ES, Kobb RF, Mann WC. Cost effectiveness of a
telerehabilitation program to support chronically ill and disabled elders in their
REFERENCES homes. Telemed e-Health 2009;15:31–38.
1. Bureau of Health Insurance. The solutions of health insurance revolution. 20. Yoshida T, Mizuno F, Hayasaka T, Tsubota K, Imai Y, Ishikawa T, Yamaguchi T.
Available at: http:==www.nhi.gov.tw=webdata=webdata.asp?menu¼6&menu_ Development of a wearable surveillance system using gait analysis. Telemed
id¼168&webdata_id¼1070&WD_ID¼ (Last accessed May 18, 2009). e-Health 2007;13:703–714.
2. Garrett N, Martini EM. The boomers are coming: A total cost of care model of
the impact of population aging on the cost of chronic conditions in the United Address correspondence to:
States. Dis Manage 2007;10:51–60. Ming-Chien Hung, Ph.D.
3. AHRQ 2001. Improving the health care of older Americans. Available at: Department of Information Management
http:==www.ahrq.gov=research=olderam= (Last accessed June 21, 2004). Nanhua University
4. Loera JA. Generational differences in acceptance of technology. Telemed No. 55, Sec. 1, Nanhua Rd.
e-Health 2008;14:1087–1090.
Zhongkeng, Dalin Township, Chia-Yi County 62248
5. Vanagas G, Žaliũnas R, Benetis R, Šlapikas R. Factors affecting relevance of tele- Taiwan
ECG systems application to high risk for future ischemic heart disease events
patients group. Telemed e-Health 2008;14:345–349.
6. Chau PYK, Hu PJH. Investigating healthcare professionals’ decisions to accept
E-mail: chemyhmc@gmail.com
telemedicine technology: An empirical test of competing theories. Information
Management 2002;39:297–311. Received: July 8, 2009
7. Fishbein M, Ajzen I. Belief, attitude, intention and behavior: An introduction to Revised: August 13, 2009
theory and research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1975. Accepted: August 13, 2009

ª M A R Y A N N L I E B E R T , I N C . . VOL. 16 N O . 1 . J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH 47


JEN AND HUNG

APPENDIX: Items of Instrument APPENDIX: Continued


CONSTRUCTS SCALES CONSTRUCTS SCALES
Subjective Norms (SN) Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU)

SN1 The experts who influence my behavior PEOU1 Instructions for using equipment in the
would think that I should use the mobile healthcare service will be easy
mobile healthcare service for my to follow.
elderly family.
PEOU2 It will be easy to learn how to use the
SN2 My family would think that I should mobile healthcare service.
order the mobile healthcare service for
my elderly family. PEOU3 It will be easy for elderly people to
operate the equipment in the mobile
SN3 My friends would think that I should healthcare service
order the mobile healthcare service for
my elderly family. Behavior Intention (BI)

Perceived Behavioral Control (PBC) BI1 I am glad to introduce the mobile


healthcare service to my elderly family.
PBC1 I have knowledge and ability to operate
the mobile healthcare service for my BI2 I will adopt the mobile healthcare
elderly family. service for my elderly family.

PBC2 I think I can handle the mobile BI3 I will adopt the mobile healthcare
healthcare service for my elderly service based on my elderly family’s
family. necessity.

PBC3 Helping my elderly family to use the


mobile healthcare service is entirely
within my control.

Attitude (ATT)

ATT1 Using the mobile healthcare service


is a good idea for the families with
elderly people.

ATT2 The mobile healthcare service increases


the elderly family’s healthcare service
quality.

ATT3 Adopting the mobile healthcare service


improves the elderly family’s safety.

ATT4 The mobile healthcare service


is valuable.

Perceived Usefulness (PU)

PU1 The mobile healthcare service will be


beneficial to the care of elderly people.

PU2 Using the mobile healthcare service will


reduce psychological burden of family.

PU3 The advantages of the mobile


healthcare service will outweigh the
disadvantages.

48 TELEMEDICINE and e-HEALTH J A N U A R Y=F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 0

You might also like