Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2. Celtic Belinos (Celtic †Belenos not attested, only Latinized Belenus; Prósper 2017)
Name of god identified with Apollo (associated with light in Gaul) and patron of Aquileia. Generally
connected with *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ (cf. overview in Schrijver 1999:24; Olmsted 1994:386–7).
BUT other proposals possible (Schrijver 1999; de Bernardo Stempel 2013:78–9; Prósper 2017)
Cult of Belinos in Roman province of Noricum continued by that of mythical Saint Belin, protector
against blindness, who was still worshipped in 19th century Slovenia (Šašel Kos 2001).
A2. Proposal
ON Baldr, Celtic Belinos, and OIr. Balar may all be reflexes of the same -r-/-n- heteroclite derivative
of PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’, namely *bhól(H)-r-/bhélH-n- ‘light, splendor’.
• Formal and semantic parallels in Old English, Slavic, Vedic Sanskrit, and Ancient Greek.
• Structural and onomastic correspondences between Norse and Irish mythical narratives.
1
By JOSEPH’S RULE: PCelt. *-aRa- < *-eRa-. Gaul. *Balaro- exclusively attested by French place-names (Delamarre 2003:65).
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)
2. OE *Bældæg
Name of a son of OE Woden (= ON Óðinn)) identified with Baldr by Snorri (Formáli 10).6
Synchronic perspective: compound of bæl° ‘fire, flame’ and °dæg ‘day’; semantics unclear.
Rather: PGmc *bēla-daga- (a) ‘(who has/controls the) light(-filled) day’7 or (b) ‘(… the) shining day’.
Archaic formation: *bēla°(PIE *bhēlH-o-) either (a) subst. ‘light’ : OE bæl fire, flame’
or (b) adj. ‘shining, white’ : OCS bělъ ‘white’.
2
Theoretically Norw. galder could reflect an unattested ON *galr (cf. Norw. older ‘alder’ < ON ǫlr < PGmc *aluz-), as well.
3
On d-epenthesis in all these languages, cf. e.g. Page 1996:177; Ohala-Solè 2008:338; Żygis 2010:123–4.
4
Analysis as -ró- adjective not probable: zero-grade root expected, i.e. *bhl̥H-ró-. Maybe -o- root grade substantivation (S. Höfler, p.c.).
5
Cf. Zair 2012:18527 with literature; aliter Kloekhorst 2008, s.v.
6
Attested as Beldegg in Snorri’s Edda, whose sources were OE genealogies (Faulkes 1978–9:9–10).
7
If double possessive compound (Schindler 1986:395–6).
2
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)
́ ikā
4. Flower-names: ON Baldrs brá, OE dæges eāge, Ved. divyásya suparṇásya kanīn
(1) ON flower-name Baldrs brá ‘Baldr’s brow’ (Gylf. 22), cf. Modern Scandinavian flower-names:
Sun-flowers (Helianthus)
(1-3) IE kenning [EYE11 – of the LIGHT/DAY/SUN-GOD] for [FLOWER] (of the Asteraceae family).
8
Cf. the antonymic PSl. theonym *Čьrnъ bogъ ‘black god’, attested e.g. by the Sorbian oronym Černi bog and Helmold’s Chronica
Slavorum 1.52 (XII c.): […] Zcerneboch, id est nigrum deum […].
9
Cf. also G. Chaucer, Legend of Good Women F 184–5: the ‘dayesye’, or elles the ‘ye of day’, / the empertice and flour of floures alle.
10
On divyá- suparṇá- ‘heavenly eagle’ as a kenning for [SUN], cf. Massetti 2016.
11
[BROW] metonymy for [EYE], cf. kennings brá-regn ‘rain of the brows’ and augna-regn ‘r. of the eyes’ for [TEARS] (Meissner 1921:131–2)
3
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)
Semantics: (a) ‘provided with light’ or (b) ‘pertaining to light, of the light’.
Both closely matching Saint Belin’s association with [SIGHT] in Slovenian folklore:
[2] Rutar 1882:21 […] Tega ima ljudstvo za velikega zdravitelja in daje mu pridevek „sveti“. Z njegovim
„ključem“ se bajé lahko ozdravlja slepota. […]
“People consider him to be a great healer and bestow on him the epithet "holy". With
his "key", so it is said, one can cure blindness” (tr. L. Repanšek).
12
Dat.sg. Βελεινο in RIG I G-28 (Calissane, Saint-Chamas, Bouches-du-Rhône); cf. also CIL V, 745. Cf. Prósper 2017:260; 269 fn.33.
13
An -īno- suffix unlikely: usually “denominative genitival adjectives mainly from o-stems and ii̯o-stems”, e.g. in Lat. (Weiss 2009:288).
14
For a similar derivational process, cf. Lat. seuērus ‘steadfast’ < *seǵhu̯ ēr-ó- ⟵ *seǵh-u̯ ḗr ‘steadfast-ness’ (Nussbaum 1998:536).
15
The Latinized variant Belenus (on which, however, cf. Prósper 2017) and the variant Βέλεν (Hrdn. Hist. 8.3.8) may indeed support a
derivation from PIE *bhelH-ḗn ‘light’ (option [a]), as its expected Proto-Celtic outcome would have been precisely *bél-en.
4
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)
B3. Lusitanian MN Balarus, Gaulish *Balaro-, and Old Irish Balar (/Balor/Bolar) 16
Formation: thematic derivative of strong stem of reflex of PIE *bhól(H)-r-/bhélH-n- ‘light, splendor’
PCelt. *balar-o- < * bhelH-r-ó- ⟵ *bhélH-r̥ -/bhélH-n- (analogy) ⟵ *bhól(H)-r̥ -/bhélH-n-
Last option may be supported by Old Irish variant Bolar, outcome of *bolar-o- (⟵ PCelt. *bolar-).
ON Baldr, PCelt. *belīno- and *balaro-: reflexes of same -r-/-n- heteroclite by paradigm splits, cf.
(a) *fatar-V- ⟵ PCelt. *fatar-/fatan- : PIE *pót-r̥ -/pét-n- ‘wing, feather’
(: OW atar, MW adar (cf. MW hadein (: Hitt. pattar/pattan- ‘id.’; cf. Ved. pátra- ‘wing’ : *po/et-r-o-;
‘pl. birds [*with feathers]’) ‘wing’) ON fjǫðr ‘id.’ : *pet-r-eh2-; Lat. penna ‘id.’ : *pet-n-eh2-)17
Semantics: either (a) ‘provided with light, with splendor’ (if possessive derivative like OW atar)
or (b) simply ‘light, splendor’ (if functionless thematization like OIr. galar).
Both match OIr. Balar’s probable role as [SUN]-god (O’Rahilly 1946:58-60). Cf. also section C infra.
B4. Hom. (κύµατα) φαληριόωντα ‘(waves) shining/white [with foam]’ (Il. 13.799)
Verb φαληριάο/ε- denominative from *φαληριo- (‘(the) shining, white (one)’?)
Cf. Att. place-name Φάληρον (Hdt.), Dor. adj. φάλαρος ‘white’ (Theoc., hyperdorism?).
Phonology: may all be traced back to *φαλήρ, expected outcome of *bhl̥H-ḗr ‘(in the) light’.
Cf. τεκµηριόο/ε- ‘to prove’ (Thuc.), denominative from τεκµήριον ‘proof’ (Hdt.), presupposing
*τεκµήρ (*ku̯ (e)ḱ-mḗr), hysterokinetic derivative of τέκµαρ (*ku̯ éḱ-mr̥ /-mén- ‘sign’).20
16
For the alternation OIr. -ar/-or, cf. olar/olor ‘fat’, galar/galur (above). Thanks to Jan-Niklas Linnemeier for useful discussion.
17
Zair 2012:185 and fn. 27 with literature; cf. also the analysis of Matasović 2009, s.v. fatar. Aliter Kloekhorst 2008, s.v.
18
Meaning not very clear, but may be reconstructed from -astu derivatives MIr. galannas ‘slaughter’ and MW galanas ‘id., hate, enmity’.
19
On the Hittite reflexes ,cf. Kloekhorst 2008, s.v. On the Germanic reflexes, cf. Kroonen 2013, s.v. *galra-. On the root, Driessen 2003.
20
As per Nussbaum 1998:536; aliter Nussbaum 2014:229–30.
5
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)
(a) Baldr’s name is a reflex of PIE *bhól(H)-r-. God associated with light (e.g. text [1] supra).
(b) Loki’s name reflects PGmc *luk-an- : PIE *lu(ǵ)-on-. Trickster god (de Vries 1933).
(c) Baldr is slain with a misteltoe shot by (Hǫðr at the direction of)21 Loki.
2. The Irish myth of Balar’s killing by Lug (Cath Maige Tuired II 619ff et al.)
[4] CMT. 619-45: imma-comairnic de Luc & di Bolur Birugderc esin cath […]
Fucaird Luc íer sin líic talma dó, co ndechaid an súil triena cend.
“Lug and Balor of the piercing eye met in the battle […]
Then Lug cast a sling stone at him which carried the eye through his head.”
(a) Balar’s name is a reflex of PIE *bhól(H)-r-. Probably sun or sky god (O’Rahilly 1946:58-60).
(b) Lug’s name reflects PCelt. *lug-u- (Gaul. Celtib. Lugus) : PIE *lu(ǵ)-u-. May be a trickster.
(c) The *bhól(H)r- god is slain with a projectile weapon by the *lu(ǵ)- god.
21
Hǫðr blind, only a puppet in the hands of Loki, the real ráðbani Baldrs “killer of Baldr by plan” (Skáld. 16).
22
On a common etymology for ON Loki and OIr. Lug, cf. Ginevra 2018:337-375.
6
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)
D. To sum up
(1) ON Baldr (*baldra-) reflex (with d-epenthesis) of PIE *bhol(H)-r-ó- ‘provided with light, splendor’,
possessive derivative of PIE *bhól(H)-r-/bhélH-n- ‘light’, matching his association with light (Gylf. 22).
PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ (ON bál ‘flame, fire’, OE bæl ‘id.’, OCS bělъ ‘white’): parallels in
Old English (*Bæl-dæg ‘[who has control over the] shining day’) and Slavic (*Bělъ bogъ
‘white god’, kenning for [SUN] or [SKY]); correspondence between flower names Baldrs brá
́ ikā ‘pupil of the Sun’.
‘B.’s brow’, OE dæges eāge ‘day’s eye’, Ved. divyásya suparṇásya kanīn
(2) PCelt. *Belīno- (cf. Gaul. Βελεινο-) reflex of *bhelH-ēn-ó- ‘provided with light’ (possessive) or
‘pertaining to light’ (pertinentive), to be traced back to delocatival *bh(e)lH-ḗn ‘(in the) light’ (PIE
*bhól(H)-r-/bhélH-n-), matching Saint Belin’s association with sight in Slovenian folklore.
(3) PCelt. *Balaro- (Lusit., Gaul.; OIr. Balar / Bolar / Balor) originally ‘provided with light’ (possessive)
or ‘light, splendor’ (functionless thematization), to be traced back to analogical *bhelH-r- (PIE
*bhól(H)-r-/bhélH-n-; expected outcome *bolar-/balan- maybe attested by OIr. Bolar).
Possible parallel: Hom. Gk φαληριάω*, denominative from *φαληριo- (‘(the) shining, white
(one)’?), if from hysterokinetic *φαλήρ (*bhl̥H-ḗr from loc. sg. *bhl̥H-ér- of *bhól(H)-r-?).
(4) Parallels in narrative structure and onomastics of Norse myth of Baldr’s killing by Loki (*lu(ǵ)-on-)
and Irish myth of Balar’s killing by Lug (*lu(ǵ)-u-): direct connection between all these characters.
Bibliography
Bernardo Stempel, P. de. 2013. Celtic and other Indigenous Divine Names found in the Italian Peninsula. In:
A. Hofeneder and P. de Bernardo Stempel (eds.), Théonymie celtique, cultes, interpretatio – Keltische
Theonymie, Kulte, Interpretatio, X. Workshop F.E.R.C.AN, Wien, 73–96.
Bloomfield, M. 1896. Contributions to the Interpretation of the Veda. The American Journal of Philology
17.4.399–437.
Casaretto, A. 2004. Nominale Wortbildung der gotischen Sprache. Die Derivation der Substantive.
Heidelberg.
Delamarre, X. 20032. Dictionnaire de la langue gauloise. Paris
Driessen, C. M. 2003. Evidence for *ĝhelh2, a new Indo-European root. JIES 31/3–4.279–305.
Evans D. E. 1967. Gaulish Personal Names: A Study of Some Continental Celtic Formations. Oxford.
EWA = A. L. Lloyd – R. Lühr – O. Springer. 1988–. Etymologisches Wörterbuch des Althochdeutschen.
Zürich/Göttingen.
Faulkes, A. 1978–9. Descent from the gods. Mediaeval Scandinavia 11.92–125.
Ginevra, R. 2018. Fraseologia e onomastica nella Vǫluspá a confronto con le lingue indoeuropee di più antica
attestazione / Phraseologie und Onomastik in der Vǫluspá im Vergleich mit den altindogermanischen
Sprachen. Unpublished PhD dissertation, Università per Stranieri di Siena and University of Cologne.
7
ON Baldr, Celt. Belinos, OIr. Balar, PIE *bhelH- ‘be white, shine’ “IG Arbeitstagung – A Ljubilee”
Riccardo Ginevra (Cologne) Ljubljana (4-7/6/2019)