Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7.1 Introduction
7.1.1 Hazards
A hazard has the potential to cause harm. This can take the form of death, ill
health, injury to people, damage to property/plant/products/the environment,
production losses, business harm and increased liabilities [13]. Ill health includes
acute and chronic ill health caused by physical, chemical or biological agents as well
as adverse effects on mental health.
Many of hazards, which give rise to such incidents, are readily identified. In
the process industries such hazard include those falling into one or more of the
following categories:
1. Chemical hazards (include acidity, alkalinity, corrosivity, explosiveness,
flammability, reactivity, toxicity and asphyxiation).
2. Thermodynamic hazards (include high pressure and vacuum, heat transfer, high
and low temperature and fluid jets).
3. Electric and electromagnetic hazards (include high voltage, radiation, static
electricity and electrical current).
4. Mechanical hazards (include mechanical energy, stresses, forces and impact blows
and contact laceration).
5. Health hazards (include noise, pollutants, chemicals, vibration, radioactivity and
temperature extremes).
143
internal changes to pipe work and vessels, such as increase in flow rate and pressure,
but also changes which arise in design, operation and maintenance which effect
performance of plant and equipment, personnel and procedures, communication and
information processing. Further more such changes may not be immediately
recognized as undesired events, but only appear at much later time to effect
behaviour.
So the position is more complicated than it first seems. The analyst cannot
simply aim at any particular time to study all hazards but must restrict the study to
the area of interest at that time. Paying particular attention to the way incidents
develop can do this.
7.1.2 Risk
144
ten minutes’ walk. Apart from the risk most people consider these items to be ugly
installations anyway. Less clear cut are environmental objections to a main road
through fields at the bottom of the garden, as many people benefit from the detriment
to a few. So it has to be expected that there will be never be acceptable to which
everyone will agree. If the case seems fair then most social groups accept the
majority opinion. Even so there exist groups within community, which tend to be
vociferous and committed to a cause and will argue most about the tolerability of
risk. So confrontation will always arise.
TYPES OF
ACUTE HAZARDS/ FIRST AID/
HAZARD/ PREVENTION
SYMPTOMS FIRE FIGHTING
EXPOSURE
NO open flames, NO
FIRE In case of fire in the surroundings: all
Flammable. sparks, and NO
extinguishing agents allowed.
smoking.
Closed system,
ventilation,
EXPLOSION In case of fire: keep cylinder cool by
Gas/air mixtures are explosive. explosion-proof
spraying with water
electrical equipment
and lighting.
EXPOSURE Avoid all contact
Burning sensation. Cough.
Ventilation, local Fresh air, rest. Half-upright position.
INHALATION Laboured breathing. Shortness of
exhaust, or breathing Artificial respiration if indicated. Refer
breath. Sore throat. Symptoms
protection. for medical attention.
may be delayed (see Notes).
Redness. Skin burns. Pain. Cold-insulating ON FROSTBITE: rinse with plenty of
SKIN
Blisters. ON CONTACT WITH gloves. Protective water, do NOT remove clothes. Refer for
LIQUID: FROSTBITE. clothing. medical attention.
145
Face shield, or eye
First rinse with plenty of water for
EYES Redness. Pain. Severe deep protection in
several minutes (remove contact lenses if
burns. combination with
easily possible), then take to a doctor.
breathing protection.
INGESTION
7.1.3.1 Identification
146
alkaline, corrosive solution. Floats and "boil" on water.
Poisonous, visible vapour cloud is produced. Gas is
lighter than air, hugs the ground when cool.
Contact with liquid may cause frostbite. Corrosive to skin, eye, nose, throat
and lungs. There is no antidote for ammonia poisoning. Chemical-protective clothing
is recommended because ammonia can cause skin irritation and burns. Repeated
exposure may cause chronic irritation of the respiratory tract. Chronic inflammation
of the bronchi and airway hyperactivity has been reported. Chronic irritation of the
eye membranes has also been reported.
IDLH: 300 ppm
Odour Threshold: 5.75 ppm
OSHA Table Z-1-A Air Contaminant
OSHA Process Safety Management of Highly Hazardous Chemicals: (29 CFR
Part 1910.119, Appendix A) TQ = anhydrous 10,000 lb; solutions (>44% ammonia
by weight) 15,000 lb
NIOSH Criteria Document: NIOSH 74-136
250 ppm: CCRS (any chemical cartridge respirator with cartridge(s) providing
protection against the compound of concern); or SA (any supplied-air respirator)
300 ppm: SA: CF (any supplied-air respirator operated in a continuous-flow mode);
or PAPRS (any powered, air-purifying respirator with cartridge(s) providing
protection against the compound of concern); or CCRFS (any chemical cartridge
147
respirator with a full face piece and cartridge(s) providing protection against the
compound of concern); or GMFS [any air-purifying, full-face piece respirator (gas
mask) with a chin-style, front-or back-mounted canister providing protection against
the compound of concern]; or SCBAF (any self-contained breathing apparatus with a
full face piece); or SAF (any supplied-air respirator with a full face piece)
Escape: GMFS [any air-purifying, full-face pieces respirator (gas mask) with a chin-
style, front-or back-mounted acid gas canister providing protection against the
compound of concern]; or SCBAE (any or SCBAE (any appropriate escape-type,
self-contained breathing apparatus)
Note: Substance reported to cause eye irritation or damage, may require eye protection
148
7.1.3.5 Fire Information
Flash Point: Gas. Indefinite below 32oF (0oC); sometimes difficult to ignite
Flammable Limits in Air: LEL 15%; UEL 28%
Autoignition Temperature: 1204oF (651oC)
Move victim to fresh air. Call emergency medical care. Apply artificial
respiration if victim is not breathing. Do not use mouth-to-mouth method if victim
ingested or inhaled the substance; induce artificial respiration with the aid of a pocket
mask equipped with a one-way valve or other proper respiratory medical device.
Administer oxygen if breathing is difficult. Remove and isolate contaminated
clothing and shoes. In case of contact with substance, immediately flush skin or eyes
149
with running water for at least 20 minutes. For minor skin contact, avoid spreading
material on unaffected skin. In case of contact with liquefied gas, thaw frosted parts
with lukewarm water. Keep victim warm and quiet. Keep victim under observation.
Effect of contact or inhalation may be delayed. Ensure that medical personnel are
aware of the material(s) involved and take precaution to protect themselves.
The Health and Safety Act. 1974 provided a new legal and administrative
framework to promote, stimulate and encourage even higher standards of health and
safety at work. Its aim is to promote safety awareness and effective safety
organization and performance in companies. Besides, a contractor must ensure that
all work activities carried out, must fully comply with Unichema Malaysia Safety
Rules as well as the Occupational Safety & Health Act (OSHA) 1994. A contractor
150
also should apply for Permit-To-Work from Unichema Contact. If there is HOT
WORK required, the contractor needs to apply for ‘HOT WORK PERMIT’.
Contractors are supposed to ensure that all tools and equipment are in good condition
and suitable for the job. Employers are required to carry out certain specific duties
and employees must co-operate with the employer to comply with the law and not
misuse safety equipment. Every employer must prepare a statement of policy on
health and safety, together with the arrangements for the policy. It is essential that
the new chemical operator acquaint themselves with the details of this policy at the
commencement of their training. Suggestion for safety improvements should be
made to the member of the Company Health and Safety Committee representing the
Chemical Operator’s own department.
(Chemical Process Safety, Fundamentals with Application by Daniel A. Crowl and
Joseph F. Louvar).
151
Its is mandatory that all persons working in the plant wear hard hats and
safety glasses 100% of the time while in the plant. In some plant area, other
protection may be required (i.e. hearing protection). If anyone of employee,
management or visitor enters without this proper safety equipment, it is the
responsibility of the operator in that department to kindly asks him or her to
leave and check back in at the main office. He or she should notify his/her
supervisor of this action.
Horseplay can only lead to accidents and will not be tolerated in the plant.
Horseplay is cause for immediate disciplinary action including discharge.
Each employee is expected to help maintain the cleanliness of the plant.
Failure to do this helps to create an atmosphere conductive to the accident.
Possession or use of liquor illegal drugs is not permitted on the plant premises
anyone under the influence of either will not be permitted on the plant
premises.
Visitor must apply to the main office, sign a release, and be instructed of
plant safety rules before they are allowed to enter the plant. Visitor will not
be taken into the plant areas that are experiencing production problems. It is
the duty of all employees to challenge anyone not having temporary or
permanent pass.
There are so many factors influencing the safety of a plant, especially one that
is associated to the chemical sector. Among the factors are:
i) Chemical Storage
The chemical storage is important because it has a huge amount of
raw material or complicated product along with chemicals used for other
processes such as water treatment, cleaning, waste treatment etc. To avoid
any form of unnecessary risk, the storage tang farm should not be situated
adjacent to urban development to eliminate any possibility of Vapor Cloud
Explosion (VPE), fireball or toxic cloud drift over population. A buffer zone
152
is suggested around the plant. Thus, storage area for ethylene, oxygen and
any other chemical should be situated in a safe position. The distance of
minimum chemical storage is 100m from the nearest process equipment. The
storage area should also be equipped with facilities to contain any spillage
from the vessel.
ii) Transportation
This factor related to work in handling the chemicals inside a plant . A
safe handling program must be installed and practiced by every personnel
because unforeseen events can create a big disaster due to human error.
Personal involvement with handling and transportation of such chemicals by
the tanker lorry and forklift drivers makes it compulsory for them to follow
all the handling procedures because they are the ones who are closely
associated with these materials and thus indirectly the safety of other workers
depend on them.
153
v) Chemically Hazardous Environments
In addition to flammable or explosive conditions, chemical hazards
are also common. As you consider the possible sources of chemical hazards
in your environment. You’ll want to know the characteristics of all material,
you’ll be in contact with drums of open fluids, open tanks and vessels,
process ingredients, all fluids that run through pipelines even cleaning agents
and others incidental chemicals. The plant should have standards for
personal protection for each type of chemical hazard present. The plant
obligation is to have these standards and observe the pertinent information on
the MSDS sheet.
There are few basic safety rules, which must be observed when working in all
chemical-manufacturing areas:
i. No smoking or eating.
ii. No drinking of alcoholic liquor.
iii. Safety instruction and danger sings must be observed.
iv. Wear all personal protective equipment provided and replace
damaged items immediately.
v. Do not tamper with faulty equipment or electrical fitting-report
such faults to your supervisors.
vi. Get immediate medical attention for injuries, however minor
they appear to be.
vii. Report all accidents to your supervisors.
viii. Know the location of fire alarms, extinguishers and escape
routes.
ix. When in doubt-ask you supervisors.
154
7.2.4 Detection of Possible Hazards
The skilled chemical operator uses all their sense to detect and recognize the
symptoms of a potential safety hazard. They will get themselves-and others-clear of
the source of danger and report their observation to supervisor immediately. Most
danger can be avoided if readily recognized and the right corrective action taken
promptly. Some of the ways in which the sings of possible hazards may be
recognized as follows:
i. Seeing
Look for warning signs, tags and safety instruction. Smoke, fumes or
sparks, particularly from electrical equipment, is symptom of overheating and
constituents a fire hazard. A blue flash may indicate a discharge of static
electricity. Observe gauges for sudden increase in temperature, rapid pressure
changes, rise or fall in liquid levels in tanks and gauge glasses. Look for
cracks or other visible damage to equipment, particularly glassware and glass
linings and leaks at valves, gaskets or seals. Keep watch for physical changes
of chemicals, such as a change in color, lumpiness, change in crystal form,
bubbling or frothing. Do no poke your head into any vessel to see it is clean.
Look out for reddening of the skin or rashes: they may indicate contact with
an irritating, corrosive or dermatitis chemical.
ii. Hearing
Whistling or hissing noises may be a warning of the escape of gas or
steam under pressure. Banging, rattling, grinding or whining sounds usually
indicate faults in moving parts of machinery. In the line, dripping or
splashing noise may lead to the detection of leaking vessels; pump seals,
valves or gaskets. The sound of shattering or cracking of glass is associated
with fracturing of glass pipeline, glass vessels or fittings caused by excessive
pressure, being struck or being subjected to a sudden change in temperature
(thermal shock). A cracking noise may indicate the discharge of static
electricity, which constitutes a fire hazards.
155
iii. Feeling
Unusual vibrations indicate pressure change or uneven running, for
example misalign moving parts of a basket of a centrifuge loaded unevenly.
Excessive heat radiating from reaction vessels may be a warning of an
exothermic reaction; in the case of electrical equipment or machinery it may
indicate an unusual overload due, perhaps, to less of lubricant. Burning,
irritation or itching of the skin indicates contact with corrosive, irritants or
dermatitis chemicals. Dryness of the lips or skin may indicate contact with
organic solvents. Smarting, irritating, watering or itching of the eyes may be
caused by contact with certain dusts or lachrymatory vapors. Difficulty in
breathing, choking, giddiness or feeling of weakness at the knees may be the
effects of harmful gases, dusts or vapor.
iv. Smelling
The chemical operator learns to identify certain chemicals by their
distinctive smell and be they may be forewarned of possible danger. It is
often difficult to describe a particularly smell and the sense varies
considerably from person experience is the only reliable guide. Some
chemicals may irritate the mucous membranes: some are sweet and sickly
(such as nitrous oxide). Purging and suffocating and may cause gasping (such
as ammonia). A pungent, irritating smell is characteristic of chlorine or
bromine: a sweet, scented smell may indicate the organic chemicals called
esters (such as amyl acetate). Organic compounds of benzene give a
characteristic aromatic smell, which is easily recognizable. There are also
many chemicals, which give smells identifiable with common day to day
smells. For example: hydrogen sulfide (rotten eggs) or carbon disulfide
(decaying vegetables).
v. Tasting
Chemicals must never be tested, as this very dangerous practice.
However in the event of accidental contact with the lips or mouth, an acute
sense of taste may the person effected to take the appropriate action quickly
by washing the mouth with copious quantities of cool water for at least 15
minutes. For example, the sour taste of acids, the sweet, sickly taste of nitrous
156
oxide or even the loss of taste caused, for example, by phenol may be
recognized readily.
i. Safety Hats
Soft caps of plastic or leather give protection against chemical
splashes, especially when working with overhead pipes, tanks, heat
exchangers and other equipment, which may leak. Reinforced hats of metal,
laminated plastic or other materials resistant to impact from falling objects
should be worn when overhead work is performed (a properly fitting hat
gives maximum protection).
157
iii. Dust Mask
Many types are now available, all giving protection against the
inhalation of harmful dust. Special absorbent pads are covered by a
perforated metal disc or fitted to a molded rubber face piece: the pads should
be changed regularly and the face piece cleaned after use. It is most important
to remember that dust masks offer no protection against gases.
v. Safety Footwear
Industrial safety shoes and boots, with steel touchups, which are of
good appearance and comfortable are supplied free or at reduced cost.
Ordinary shoes are most unsuitable as they offer little resistance to corrosive
chemicals or at falling objects. Sparks from nailed boots are a source of
danger. Rubber boots are water weight and resistant to most corrosive
chemicals, but may be attack by much organic solvent.
158
vi. Basic Hand Protection
Accident records continue to shows that hand and finger injuries are
one of the more common types of personal injury in many plants. Many
different kinds of gloves are available. Some are made of material that
provide protection against toxic and caustic chemicals. Some are suitable for
use in high temperature applications. Others types will ‘break away’, or come
apart, if caught in rotating or moving machinery. Other will cushion against
vibration when working with power tools. Selecting and always wearing the
right glove for the job is the first step in preventing hand injuries. Beyond
that, one must also consider what types of hazards they may be working with,
and be on constant guard to keep one’s hand safe.
i. Eye Contact
Immediately flush with large amounts of water for at least 15 minutes,
occasionally lifting upper and lower lids. Seek medical attention.
159
ii. Skin Contact
Quickly remove contaminated clothing. Immediately wash
contaminated skin with large amounts of soap and water.
iii. Breathing
Remove the person from exposure. Begin rescue breathing if
breathing has stopped and CPR if heart action has stopped. Transfer promptly
to a medical facilities.
7.3.1 General
A preliminary study can be made from a description of the process and the
process flow sheets. For a detailed, final, study of the design, the flow sheets, piping
and instruments diagrams, equipment specifications and layout drawings would be
needed. For a batch process information on the sequence of operation will also be
160
required, such as that given in operating instructions, logic diagrams and flow charts.
A written record is not normally made of each step in the study; only those
deviations that lead to a potential hazard are recorded. If possible, the action needed
to remove the hazard is decided by the team and recorded. If more information or
time is needed to decide the best action, the matter is referred to the design group for
action, or taken up at another meeting of the study team.
When using operability study technique to vet a process design, the action to
be taken to deal with a potential hazard will often be modifications to the control
systems and instrumentation; the inclusion of additional alarms, trips or interlocks. If
major hazards are identified, major design changes may be necessary; alternative
processes, materials or equipment.
161
To reduce cost due to operability problems in increasingly larger and complexity
plants so that profitability is increased.
To meet the legislative requirements for example, DOSH.
To identify and prevent hazards in process plants that are growing in complexity
with standards are no longer adequate.
162
GUIDE WORDS MEANINGS COMMENTS
NO or NOT The complete negation of No part of the intention is
these intentions. achieved but nothing
happens.
MORE or LESS Quantitative increase or These refers to quantities
decrease. and properties such as
flow rates and
temperature, as we ll as
activities like ‘HEAT’
and ‘REACT’.
AS WELL AS A quantitative increase. All the design and
operating intentions are
achieved together with
some additional activity.
PART OF A quantitative decrease Only some of the
intentions are achieved;
some are not.
REVERSE The logical opposite of This is mostly applicable
the intention. to activities, for example
reverse flow or chemical
reactions.
OTHER THAN Complete substitution. No part of the original
intention is achieved.
Something quite different
happens.
The consequences of the identified deviations typically fall into the following areas:
163
i. Effect on other sub-system or system
ii. Effect on local operators
iii. Effect on surrounding public
iv. Environmental impact
v. Damage to property
The main objective of the Hazop study on heat exchanger is maintaining the
inlet and outlet temperature of heat exchanger equipment as best as possible to a
desired temperature. For safe and satisfactory operation of the heat exchanger,
certain constraints must be observed when doing Hazop. For example, shell and tube
pressure drop should be high enough to maintain effective operation.
Hazop analysis for the heat exchanger in the Phthalic Anhydride plant is as
follow. The analysis is through study of streams: inlet and outlet streams of coolant,
hot oil, and process streams.
164
Hazop for Inlet and Outlet of Coolant Streams
Install high
pressure/
temperature
emergency
shutdown.
165
Water. Back flow. Install check valve
to prevent the others
material
Install high
pressure/
temperature
emergency
shutdown.
Valve failure
166
Pressure The pressure Temperature Same as MORE.
inlet is not will increase
stable
(disturbance)
167
MORE OF Flow Valve failure Possible Install flow
to be thermal indicator.
functioning in runaway.
good condition. Install pressure
Not achieve a /temperature indicator
Control system desire for process stream
failure temperature.
Install high
Temperature / pressure/temperature
pressure might alarm to alert
increase and operator.
explosion can be
occurs
Effects on
further process
Temperature Temperature Same as Same as MORE.
controller MORE.
failure
Valve is
failure function.
168
NOT failure Process stop maintenance
Ammonia reactor for this plant need external heating which perform
by a heat exchanger (X-3 ) and operate at rather high temperature that is at 450 C
169
with pressure drop = 0.03 atm. Since the process involves reactions at rather high
temperature, the Hazop study is important to ensure plant safety.
Regular
maintenance.
170
Temperature Heat Low Install LOW
exchanger TEMPERATURE
temperature to
failure. ALARM.
reactor. Reaction
Consider
rate drops.
alternative heat
Product failure. exchanger.
Loss of reactants.
Regular
Downtime to maintenance.
overall process.
REVERSE Flow Reverse Back mixing, Install check valve
pressure no reaction. on line.
differential. Reduced
reaction rate.
PART OF Composition Failure of Product failure. Install reactant ratio
maintaining controller.
reactant ratio.
Plant shutdown.
MORE OF Temperature Poor heat Higher Install backup
transfer in the temperature to the control valve or
water jacket, next equipment. manual bypass in
increased duty, cooling water
or cooling water stream or install
failure. control valve that
fails open.
Pressure Pipeline Back mixing in Install flow
blockage. reactor. indicator or HIGH
Reaction stops. Flow Alarm.
LESS OF Flow Valve leaking, Discharge of Install LOW
line fracture or chemicals into FLOW ALARM.
control valve the
failure. surroundings.
171
Loss of feed to Regular
reactor. maintenance.
Reduction in
product.
Temperature Higher Lower Ensure regular
throughput of temperature to the maintenance.
cooling water. next equipment.
Valve for
coolant stream
fails open.
Temperature
controller
failure.
Pressure Changes in Temperature Ensure regular
flow. drops. maintenance.
Reactor
leakage.
Line leakage.
Plant shutdown.
MORE OF Temperature Heat Higher Install backup
exchanger temperature to the control valve or
failure next equipment. manual bypass in
cooling water
stream or install
control valve that
fails open.
Pressure Pipeline Back mixing in Install flow
blockage. flash unit. indicator or HIGH
Flow Alarm.
172
Product loss.
Downtime to
overall process.
Fire, explosion
and health
hazards.
LESS OF Flow Valve leaking, Discharge of Install LOW
line fracture or chemicals into FLOW ALARM.
control valve the
failure. surroundings. Regular
Loss of feed to maintenance.
distillation tower.
Reduction in
product.
Temperature Flash unit Lower Ensure regular
leakage temperature to the maintenance.
next equipment.
Heat
exchanger
failure
Pressure Changes in Temperature Ensure regular
flow. drops. maintenance.
Flash leakage.
Line leakage.
7.3.5.1 Introduction
Normally, start-up and shut-down of plant must proceed safely and easily, yet
flexible enough to be carried out in several ways. The operating limits of the plant
must not be exceeded and dangerous mixtures must not be formed. Where necessary
introduce additional equipment, sampling point, instrumentation and lines and
identify their use on the engineering line diagram. There are several important things
that we must take into consideration during the start-up and shut-down of the plant.
173
7.3.5.2 Plant Start-Up
174
19. Gas blanketing.
20. Catalyst should be activated and sufficiently warm reaction to commence
when flow of reactants is started.
The start-up procedures should be inclusive of the five procedures listed below:
Preparation for the shut-down include the following checks to the advanced
planning:
1. The “ Turnaround Worklist “ are to be prepared to include all items for
repair, cleaning, inspection and modification.
2. The detailed plan of the shut-down and turnaround for the day to day and
probably hour by hour schedule of the sequence of the events are to be
prepared. This is called the Critical Path Monitoring Chart.
3. Before shutting down the unit , check the following:
The fire fighting equipment are to be correctly located
The personal protective equipment are to be available for immediate
use,
4. All items that are required during the shut-down of the unit are available.
These items include blinds, hoses for steaming out circuits and
equipment, hoses for draining circuits equipment of liquid, connections
for connecting those hoses.
175
7.3.5.5 Summary of Plant Shut-down Procedure
The shut-down procedure should be inclusive of the five phases as shown below:
176
other personnel clearly can act in this manner as well as wide range of other
instrumentation. It should be noted that warnings by people are only effective if that
person has the authority. A major problem with alarms is that several may go off at
similar times and computers can print out a whole range of information. If people are
overload with information they either fail to analyze it or simply do nothing. Some of
the different warning and detection systems in common use are indicated below:
Fire or smoke detectors
Photoelectric cells
Ionization, ultraviolet and infrared detectors
Gas analyzers and alarms
Low pressure and low flow detectors
Breakage movement detectors
Visual and plant surveillance system
Environmental pollution control
The actual alarms used must be clear in meaning, as different responses are required
to toxic and flammable events. The use of audible messages by loudspeaker, radio,
etc. should augment sirens or bells.
177
temperature and possible rupture. Depressurization can take a long time which its
effectiveness. Transfer to material can conveniently be done back into the process. It
is particularly useful to transfer liquid into a dump full of quench liquid or inhibitor
to stop an undesired reaction. Depressurizing is of course vital prior to maintenance
as is effective isolation, which is continued for as long as plant is not pressure tight.
178