You are on page 1of 12

Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Forensic Science International


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/forsciint

Study on development of forensic blood substitute:


Focusing on bloodstain pattern analysis
Sang-Yoon Leea,b,* , Young-Il Seoa , Byung-Sun Moona , Jin-Pyo Kima , Jae-Mo Goha ,
Nam-Kyu Parka , Se-Hyun Shinb
a
Department of Forensic Engineering, National Forensic Service, Wonju 26460, Republic of Korea
b
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Korea University, Seoul 02841, Republic of Korea

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Article history: Bloodstain pattern analysis, one of the areas of forensic science, is performed to analyze the physical
Received 3 March 2020 characteristics of bloodstains, including their size, shape, and distribution, to reconstruct a crime scene. A
Received in revised form 11 August 2020 bloodstain pattern analyst should obtain through experiments and education the capabilities to both
Accepted 13 August 2020
understand the generation mechanisms of bloodstains and identify the characteristics of the bloodstains.
Available online 19 August 2020
Experiments and education about bloodstain pattern analysis are carried out by using human blood
taken from subjects, animal blood (porcine or bovine) supplied from butcheries, and blood substitute
Keywords:
products developed in other countries. However, these kinds of blood have many limitations in their
Bloodstain pattern analysis
Forensic blood substitute
application due to various problems.
Physical properties The blood substitute developed in the present study is more similar to human blood than other blood
Drip bloodstain substitute products developed in other countries with regard to the physical properties, including
Luminol viscosity, viscoelasticity, and surface tension, as well as the drip bloodstain patterns depending on the
Pattern transfer surface and coordinate characteristics of drip stains impact angle. The blood substitute developed in the
present study is more practical, because the materials that are used in its preparation are readily available
in the market and do not include chemicals that are harmful to the human body, and the blood substitute
has luminol reaction functionality and pattern transfer bloodstain (bloodstain fingerprint, bloodstain
footprint, etc.) dyeing functionality.
© 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND
license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).

1. Introduction have been introduced to identify the causes of the target


bloodstain or the bloodstain pattern. Ultimately, the bloodstain
Bloodstain pattern analysis, one of the areas of forensic science, pattern analyst should be able to secure the probative power of the
is carried out to analyze the physical characteristics of bloodstains, evidence in court by acquiring scientific reliability of the evidence
including their size, shape, and distribution, to reconstruct a crime through the reconstruction of the scene.
scene. Bloodstain pattern analysis enables one to not only Experiments and education about bloodstain pattern analysis
reconstruct the crime scene of a bloody murder but also determine are carried out by using the human blood taken from subjects,
the authenticity of a suspect's statement and assume a suspect animal blood (porcine or bovine) supplied from butcheries, and
depending on the case [1,2]. blood substitute products developed in other countries. The
A bloodstain pattern analyst should obtain through education problems of human blood include the objection that the subjects
the capabilities to understand the generation mechanisms of have against blood sampling, the possibility of offensive smell and
bloodstains and to identify the characteristics of the bloodstains. A decomposition, the danger of biological infection, the difficulty of
bloodstain pattern analyst should find out, from an experiment massive blood supply when needed, and the difficulties involved in
based on the identified characteristics, the assumption that can the control of experimental conditions due to the change of the
best explain the crime scene among the many assumptions that physical properties caused by the use of an anticoagulant. Animal
blood also has problems such as the possibility of bad smell and
decomposition, the danger of biological infection, the difficulty of
supply due to the low marketability, and difficulties involved in the
* Corresponding author at: Department of Forensic Engineering, National
Forensic Service, Wonju 26460, Republic of Korea. control of experimental conditions due to the physical properties
E-mail address: sylee1221@korea.ac.kr (S.-Y. Lee). that are different from those of the human blood. In addition, the

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2020.110461
0379-0738/© 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
2 S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

Fig. 1. Blood substitutes for reproducing bloodstain patterns and those for reproducing luminol reaction intensity, which were developed and sold by foreign companies.

blood substitute products developed in other countries have as much as possible. A long shelf life was sought by selecting
problems such as the economic burden due to their high price, and mixing a preservative that does not disturb the realization
incomplete validation of the physical properties through experi- of the desired physical properties [Table 1].
mental comparison with the human blood, and difficulties of Distilled water and Hyaluronate acid were added to the
preparation and sale due to the separate functionalities of the prepared Amino acid solution at the predetermined ratios and
pattern reproduction and luminol reaction. mixed with an agitator. Sodium chloride, Potassium ferricya-
Studies on forensic blood substitute have been steadily nide, Hemoglobin from bovine blood, and Bovine serum
conducted by Millington J. (2000) [3], Theresa Stotesbury. (2017) albumin were then added to the resulting mixture at the
[4,5], and Jingyao Li. (2018) [6]. Although various effective blood predetermined ratios and mixed with an agitator. The resulting
substitute products have been developed by these studies, they mixture was subsequently kept at room temperature for about
may not be practically applied because the details about the one hour. When the supernatant layer of bubbles and
materials and preparation methods are not specifically recited. impurities is separated from the lower layer, the mixture
The present study was conducted to develop a forensic blood solution of the lower layer is separated for further use by using
substitute that is more similar to human blood and more practical a pipette or a fine sieve. To the separated mixture solution, R#
then the previous products and thus the blood substitute 504 (tar color) and V# 401 (tar color) were added according to
developed here may be applied to the education of bloodstain the predetermined ratios, and the resulting mixture was mixed
pattern analysis, relevant experiments, and various studies in by using an agitator and kept at room temperature for about
forensic science. one hour. Again, when the supernatant layer of bubbles and
impurities separated from the lower layer, the mixture
2. Materials and method solution of the lower layer was separated for further use by
using a pipette or a fine sieve. The completed NFBS was then
2.1. Human blood and blood substitute developed in other countries kept at room temperature. If the NFBS is stored in a refrigerator
for a long time, Phenoxyethanol is mixed at a predetermined
The human blood (HB) used in the present study was the fresh ratio.
whole blood taken from a healthy male in his 30 s. For the
experiment, the HB injected to an EDTA tube was kept at 20℃ in a
“digital water bath (Lab Corporation, Korea)” and rolled at 30 rpm by
using a “digital roller (Thermo Scientific, USA)”. The blood substitute
products developed in other countries were the spatter blood samples
from “AFBS (Arrowhead, USA)”, “SFBS (Sirchie, USA)”, and “TFBS
(Tritech Forensics, USA)” [Fig. 1].

2.2. Choice of materials and method of preparation

The materials for the preparation of the blood substitute


developed in the present study (NFBS) [Fig. 2] were selected by
considering the physical properties such as viscosity, visco-
elasticity, and surface tension, to make the properties similar
to those of the HB, as well as properties to add luminol reaction
functionality and pattern transfer bloodstain dyeing function-
ality. “Hyaluronate acid (WizGarden, Korea)” [7,8,9,10] was
included to adjust the viscosity and viscoelasticity, “Hemoglo-
bin from bovine blood (Sigma-Aldrich, USA)” [11], and
“Potassium ferricyanide(Daejung Chemicals, Korea)” [12] to
adjust the luminol reaction functionality, and an “Amino acid
solution” prepared according to Schwarz, L. (2009) [13] and
“Bovine serum albumin (Sigma-Aldrich, USA)” [14,15] to adjust
the pattern transfer bloodstain dyeing functionality. The
selected materials were mixed at appropriate composition
ratios to prepare the NFBS. In the choice of the materials,
chemicals that are harmful to the human body were excluded Fig. 2. Developed blood substitute (NFBS).
S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461 3

Table 1
Materials used in the preparation of NFBS and their composition ratios.

No. Material Artificial Blood Substitute

Content (g, %)

Type-1 Type-2
(Not Preservative)

1 Distilled Water 27.00 27.40


2 Amino acid solution L-Serine 45.00 5.1654 45.00 5.1654
Glycine 3.0992 3.0992
DL-Alanine 1.5496 1.5496
L-Lysine 2.0556 2.0556
L-Leucine 0.5165 0.5165
L-Threonine 0.7695 0.7695
L-Asparagin Anhydrous 0.7695 0.7695
(Asparagin acid)
L-Histidine 0.7695 0.7695
L-Valine 0.5165 0.5165
Sodium chloride 34.7873 34.7873
Magnesium chloride hexahydrate 0.0002 0.0002
Calcium chloride anhydrous 0.0008 0.0008
Zinc chloride 0.0001 0.0001
3 Bovine serum albumin 1.00 1.00
4 Hemoglobin from bovine blood 0.15 0.15
5 Potassium ferricyanide 2.30 2.30
6 Hyaluronate acid 22.00 22.00
7 Sodium chloride 0.90 0.90
8 R# 504 (Tar color) 1.00 1.00
9 V# 401 (Tar color) 0.25 0.25
10 Phenoxyethanol 0.40  
Total 100.00 100.00

2.3. Measurement of physical properties similarity between individual blood substitute and HB were
confirmed. The measurement was performed by using a “Viscom-
Through many major measurements related to the engineering eter (DV-III ULTRA, Brookfield, USA)”, a “Rheometer (RS-6000,
of viscosity, viscoelasticity, density, and surface tension, the Thermo Scientific, USA)”, a “Density Meter(DDM2910/2911,
physical properties of the individual blood substitute and the Rudolph Research Analytical, USA), and a “Tensionmeter (K11,

Fig. 3. Drip stain generating system.


4 S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

Fig. 4. Viscosity of the individual blood samples.

Fig. 5. Viscoelasticity of the HB sample.

Fig. 6. Viscoelasticity of the AFBS sample.


S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461 5

Fig. 7. Viscoelasticity of the SFBS sample.

Fig. 8. Viscoelasticity of the TFBS sample.

Fig. 9. Viscoelasticity of the NFBS sample.


6 S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

Table 2
Density and Surface tension data of the individual blood samples.

No. Blood Type Temperature [ C] Surface Detection Speed [mm/min] Density Surface Tension [mN/m]
[g/㎤]
1 HB 20 10 1066.03  1.92 47.65  1.25
2 AFBS 1021.80  1.84 38.99  1.16
3 SFBS 1016.14  1.83 45.50  1.41
4 TFBS 1026.74  1.85 44.23  1.61
5 NFBS 1031.71  1.86 46.93  1.35

Fig. 10. Density of the individual blood samples.

Fig. 11. Surface tension of the individual blood samples.

KRUSS, Germany & Theta Flex, Biolin Scientific, USA)”, applying the and NFBS. To perform the test upon different surfaces, a sheet of
same settings and conditions for all the individual blood samples. A4-sized paper (porous surface), a glass plate (nonporous
surface), and a stainless steel plate (nonporous surface) were
2.4. Drip bloodstain pattern characteristics used. Each of the blood samples was dripped on the different
surfaces ten times under the same conditions of temperature
The drip bloodstain pattern characteristics on different 20℃, volume 20㎕, height 30 cm, and angle 90 to generate the drip
surfaces were compared between the HB, AFBS, SFBS, TFBS, bloodstain.
S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461 7

Fig. 12. Droplets that have formed prior to release from the tip of a 1cc syringe for surface tension measurement.

Table 3
Drip bloodstain patterns of the individual blood samples on different surfaces.

No. Surface Blood Type

HB AFBS SFBS TFBS NFBS


1 Paper

2 Glass plate

3 Stainless steel plate

Fig. 13. Image J quantitative analysis of the drip bloodstain patterns on a porous surface(paper).
8 S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

Table 4
Image J quantitative analysis of the drip bloodstain patterns on a porous surface(paper).

Surface Blood Type Drip bloodstain Image J analysis


Paper HB

AFBS

SFBS

TFBS

NFBS
S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461 9

Fig. 14. Image J quantitative analysis of the drip bloodstain patterns on a nonporous surface, (left: glass, right: stainless steel).

2.5. Coordinate characteristics of drip stains impact angle 1.92), however, all blood substitute showed a difference in density
from HB. The surface tension was measured ten times for each
The coordinate characteristics of drip stains impact angle on sample at room temperature of 20℃ and a detection speed of 10
paper were compared between the HB, AFBS, SFBS, TFBS, and mm/min. The results showed that the surface tension of NFBS
NFBS. Drip bloodstains were generated by using a home-built (46.93  1.35) was most similar to the HB (47.65  1.25) (Table 2)
drip bloodstain generator comprising a “Digital pipette (FP Novus (Figs. 10–12).
5-50㎕, Thermo Scientific, USA)”, a “Pipette tip (DIAMONDⓇ Tip
D200, France)”, a “Copy stand (PROSPOT, CS Studio Light, 3.2. Comparison of drip bloodstain pattern of individual blood samples
Korea)”, a “Magic arm (Manfrotto, Italy)”, and an “Angle vise on different surfaces
(Bluetec, Korea)” (Fig. 3). With an amount of 20㎕ and at a
temperature of 37℃, a height of 30 cm, and angles of 20 , 30 , 40 , The experimental results showed that the drip bloodstain
50 , 60 , 70 . A total of 1,000 tests were conducted, forty times for pattern of all the blood samples was a circle of less than 1㎜
each blood sample and angle. The obtained experimental results diameter on the paper surface (porous surface). The HB and NFBS
were analyzed using HemoSpat software (Queen‘s Univ, Canada). samples showed a similar drip bloodstain pattern of a circular shape
having a diameter of less than 1㎜, while the AFBS, SFBS, and TFBS
3. Results samples showed a spread drip bloodstain pattern similar to a circle
having a diameter of 1 to 1.5㎜ (Table 3). A quantitative analysis of the
3.1. Comparison of physical properties drip bloodstains of the individual blood samples on the paper,
performed by using the “Image J software program (Wayne Rasband,
3.1.1. Rheological characteristics USA)”, showed that the result of the NFBS (47.56  1.45) was the
The rheological change of the viscosity with respect to the shear most similar to the HB (67.36  1.05). The analysis was performed by
rate was measured by using a viscometer in the cone&plate mode, converting images of the individual blood samples by using split
at room temperature of 20℃, an initial rate of 1/s, a final rate of 2000/ channels, analyzing the converted images as 8-bit data values (0-
s, at a point per decade of 20 and a measurement time of three 255), and comparing the resulting data values (Fig. 13, Table 4) [16].
minutes. The results showed that the rheological characteristics of the A quantitative analysis of the diameter of the bloodstains of the
viscosity of the NFBS were most similar tendency to the HB (Fig. 4). individual samples, formed by dripping the blood samples on a glass
The rheological behavior of the viscoelasticity with respect to the plate and a stainless steel plate, showed that the diameter of the
frequency was measured at room temperature of 20℃, a strain of NFBS (9.74  0.76, 9.68  0.54) was the most similar to the HB
800%, an initial frequency of 1/s, a final frequency of 100 rad/s, and a (9.58  0.93, 9.72  0.81) (Fig. 14).
point per decade of 10. The results showed that the rheological
characteristics of the viscoelasticity of the NFBS was most similar 3.3. Comparison of the coordinate characteristics of drip stains impact
tendency to the HB. However, AFBS, SFBS, and TFBS showed angle
different tendency results(Figs. 5–9).
As a result of the experiment, AFBS, SFBS, TFBS, and NFBS
3.1.2. Density and Surface tension characteristics simulated impact angles at 50 , 60 , and 70 showed similar results
The Density was measured ten times for each sample at room to those of HB. However, with acute angles of 208, 308, and 408,
temperature of 20℃. The results showed that the Density of NFBS showed similar results in comparison with HB than AFBS,
NFBS (1031.71  1.86) was most similar to the HB (1066.03  SFBS, and TFBS (Tables 5,6) (Figs. 15–18).
10 S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

Table 5
Drip stain patterns for each blood type and angle.

No. Impact angle Blood Type

HB AFBS SFBS TFBS NFBS


1 20

2 30

3 40

4 50

5 60

6 70
S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461 11

Table 6
Data on the coordinate characteristics of drip stains impact angle for each blood sample.

No. Blood Type a McDonnell Result value


formula
208 308 408 508 608 708
1 HB W/L (Mean) 0.32 0.48 0.63 0.74 0.86 0.93
W/L (Std) 0.15 0.18 0.14 0.15 0.11 0.15
angle (Mean) 18.8 28.8 39 48.2 58.8 68.9
angle (Std) 2.8 3.5 3.3 3.0 3.3 3.8
2 AFBS W/L (Mean) 0.29 0.42 0.56 0.75 0.87 0.95
W/L (Std) 0.1 0.11 0.15 0.13 0.14 0.16
angle (Mean) 14.9 24.9 34.4 48.4 61.3 71.3
angle (Std) 2.8 2.3 2.7 3.2 2.7 4.2
3 SFBS W/L (Mean) 0.26 0.43 0.57 0.76 0.87 0.92
W/L (Std) 0.1 0.11 0.17 0.12 0.20 0.17
angle (Mean) 15.1 25.8 34.5 49.3 60.6 69.4
angle (Std) 3.0 2.7 3.3 3.9 2.8 4.2
4 TFBS W/L (Mean) 0.26 0.4 0.59 0.72 0.85 0.93
W/L (Std) 0.1 0.14 0.18 0.12 0.23 0.19
angle (Mean) 14.2 23.6 36.1 46.2 58.8 69
angle (Std) 2.1 3.4 1.9 2.7 3.2 3.3
5 NFBS W/L (Mean) 0.31 0.48 0.62 0.75 0.86 0.93
W/L (Std) 0.09 0.17 0.15 0.18 0.16 0.15
angle (Mean) 18 28 39 48.9 58.8 68.1
angle (Std) 1.7 3.7 2.6 2.4 3.9 3.3

Fig. 15. Compares the coordinate characteristics of drip stain's impact angle Fig. 17. Compares the coordinate characteristics of drip stain's impact angle
between the AFBS and HB. between the TFBS and HB.

Fig. 16. Compares the coordinate characteristics of drip stain's impact angle Fig. 18. Compares the coordinate characteristics of drip stain's impact angle
between the SFBS and HB. between the NFBS and HB.
12 S.-Y. Lee et al. / Forensic Science International 316 (2020) 110461

4. Conclusions Acknowledgments

The physical properties of the NFBS, including the viscosity, This study was supported by the Scientific Investigation and
viscoelasticity, and surface tension, and its drip bloodstain pattern on Appraisal Technique R&D Program of the National Forensic Service
different surfaces and coordinate characteristics of drip stains (NFS) of the Ministry of the Interior and Safety (MOIS) of Korea, and
impact angle were more similar to those of the HB in comparison by the Engineering Research Center (ERC) of the Basic Research
with the blood substitute products developed in other countries. In Program funded by the National Research Foundation of Korea
addition, the NFBS developed in the present study is more practical, (NRF).
because the materials that are used in the preparation of the NFBS are
readily available in the market and do not include chemicals that are References
harmful to the human body, and the NFBS has luminol reaction
functionality and pattern transfer bloodstain (bloodstain fingerprint, [1] D. Attinger, C. Moore, A. Donaldson, A. Jafari, H.A. Stone, Fluid dynamics topics
in bloodstain pattern analysis: Comparative review and research opportu-
bloodstain footprint, etc.) dyeing functionality. nities, Forensic Sci. Int. 231 (1) (2013) 375–396.
Although the results of viscosity and viscoelasticity are similar in [2] T.L. Wolson, F.L. Miami, Serology: bloodstain pattern analysis. USA. Elsevier
general to those of other blood substitute, it is difficult to say that they Ltd. All rights reserved, Encycl. Forensic Legal Med. 4 (2016).
[3] J. Millington, Development of a Synthetic Blood Substitute for use in Forensic
are very similar to HB, and verification by measurement will be Science Teaching. LSTN Report, (2000) .
necessary even under low conditions of less than 1 second. For the [4] Theresa Stotesbury, Mike Illes, Paul Wilson, Andrew J. Vreugdenhil, Forensic
similarity of the density results, precision should be complemented blood substitute development: Investigation of the spreading dynamics onto a
paper surface, Forensic Sci. Int. 275 (2017) 308–313.
by mixing erythrocyte substitutes at an appropriate prices that meet
[5] Theresa Stotesbury, Mike Illes, Andrew J. Vreugdenhil, The application of
the practical purposes, quantitative analysis through the expansion silicon sol-gel technology to forensic blood substitute development: mimick-
of the number of HB samples in consideration of the physical ing aspects of whole human blood rheology, Forensic Sci. Int. 270 (2017) 12–19.
[6] Jingyao Li, Synthesis of Artificial Blood Substitute for Forensic Purposes,
characterisitics of each person's blood, and reliability through
Raleigh, North Carolina. PhD, 2018.
changes in physical properties due to the use of anticoagulants. [7] Syang-Peng Rwei, Saint-Wei Chen, Ching-Feng Mao, Hsu-Wei Fang, Viscoelas-
Further studies will be conducted to measure the physical ticity and wearability of hyaluronate solutions, Biochem. Eng. J. 40 (2) (2008)
properties of the NFBS more precisely, to analyze the luminol 211–217.
[8] L. Ambrosio, A. Borzacchiello, P.A. Netti, L. Nicolais, Rheological study on
reaction functionality and the pattern transfer bloodstain dyeing hyaluronic acid and its derivative solutions, J.M.S. Pure Appl. Chem. A36 (7&8)
functionality comparatively and quantitatively, and to examine the (1999) 991–1000.
compatibility with the various reagents and kits used in the DNA [9] Wendy E. Krause, Enrico G. Bellomo, Ralph H. Colby, Rheology of sodium
hyaluronate under physiological condition, Biomacromolecules 2 (2001) 65–
analysis so that the NFBS may be applied to various fields of 69.
forensic science. In addition, the method of preparing the NFBS will [10] Mary K. Cowman, Tannin A. Schmidt, Preeti Raghavan, Antonio Stecco,
be shared with competent authorities including the National Police Viscoelastic properties of hyaluronan in physiological conditions, F1000Re-
search 4 (2015) 622.
Agency and the Ministry of National Defense so that it may be [11] Terence I. Quickenden, Paul D. Cooper, Increasing the speci1 city of the forensic
independently prepared and used according to need. luminol test for blood, Luminescence 2001 (16) (2001) 251–253.
[12] Jianxiu Du, Yinhuan Li, Lu Jiuru, Flow injection chemiluminescence
determination of polyhydroxy phenols using luminol-ferricyanide/ferrocya-
CRediT authorship contribution statement nide system, Talanta 55 (2001) 1055–1058.
[13] L. Schwarz, An amino acid model for latent fingerprints on porous surfaces, J
Sang-Yoon Lee: Conceptualization, Methodology. Young-Il Forensic Sci 54 (6) (2009) 1323–1326.
[14] Xijuan Tan, Zhenghua Song, Donghua Chen, Zhuming Wang, Study on the
Seo: Formal analysis, Investigation. Byung-Sun Moon: Formal
chemiluminescence behavior of bovine serum albumin with luminol and its
analysis, Investigation. Jin-Pyo Kim: Software, Validation. Jae-Mo analytical application, Spectrochim. Acta Part A: Mol. Biomol. Spectrosc. 79 (1)
Goh: Writing - original draft. Nam-Kyu Park: Writing - review & (2011) 232–235.
editing, Funding acquisition. Se-Hyun Shin: Supervision, Funding [15] Lydia C.A.M. Bossers, Claude Roux, Michael Bell, Andrew M. McDonagh,
Methods for the enhancement of fingermarks in blood, Forensic Sci. Int. 210
acquisition. (2011) 1–11.
[16] Yeong-Mi Park, Eui-Young Cha, A study on digital color representation and
Declaration of Competing Interest management, KDDA 7 (2004) 85–92.

To the best of our know ledge, the named authors have no


conflict of interest, financial or otherwise.

You might also like