Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geology and Assessment of Unconventional Oil and Gas Resources of Northeastern Mexico
Introduction By U.S. Geological Survey Mexico Assessment Team Sabinas Basin Discussion
The quantitative methodology used by the USGS for this assessment of unconventional oil and
2015 The USGS approach to defining AUs in the Turonian Agua Nueva Formation and gas resources differs from that used in other unconventional assessments. The differences in method-
The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), in cooperation in the Tithonian La Casita Formation of the Sabinas Basin began with the map showing ology must be considered when attempting to compare assessment results. The potential area assessed
by the USGS must have source rocks with greater than 2 weight-percent TOC, have greater than 15
with the U.S. Department of State, quantitatively assessed the distribution of TOC greater than 1 weight-percent (figs. 17 and 18). Using analog
28° 100° 99° 98° 97° 96° 100° 99° 98° 97° 96°
Agua Nueva Shale Oil AU Agua Nueva Shale Gas AU La Casita Shale Gas AU 29° TURONIAN TITHONIAN
(table 1). The distribution of potential area incorporates TOC, maturity, depth, and thickness data,
lack of required geological information. Unconventional
100° 99° 98° 97° 96° 100° 99° 98° 97° 96°
Sabinas Basin
Province TITHONIAN TITHONIAN TITHONIAN TITHONIAN and represents one of the key sources of geologic uncertainty. The distributions for estimated
Ma
Ma
102° 101° 100° 99° 98° 102° 101° 100° 99° 98° 103° 102° 101° 100° 99° 98° 29°
TOC THERMAL
gis
TOC FINAL
gis
Tau
Burgos
cat
ultimate recovery (EUR), well drainage areas, and success ratio are from U.S. analog
Burgos Burgos
Ma
TURONIAN TURONIAN
cat
TITHONIAN
resources include shale gas, shale oil, tight gas, tight oil,
Burgos Basin 29° 29°
ma
Basin
Tau
zin
Basin Basin
gis
Tau
zin
Tau
26° Province
ulip
Ma
Province
Ba
m
cat
Province Province
Ba
Agua Nueva
m
> 2 WEIGHT - AU MAP
ma
aul
Burgos Basin
unconventional accumulations.
gi
aul
si
24°
as
24° 28°
zin
si
24° 24°
Shale Oil
n
sca
ul
ipa
n
Province
Arc
ipa
ipa
Ba
29°
tzin
53000461
sA
sA
h
sin
sA
28°
Pro
Sabinas
PERCENT
rch
PERCENT
Ba
rch
rch
Pro
vin
Basin Province
sin
vin
GULF
ce
Assessment Results
24°
ce
OF USA
sources were assessed in Mexico in 2012 (U.S. Geological
MEXICO 28° 28°
MEXICO
23° 28°
Quantitative assessment results for 11 unconventional AUs of northeast Mexico are sum-
23° 23° 23° 27°
27°
Tampico–Misantla
USA USA
billion cubic feet (BCFG), with a range from 7,431 to 44,630 BCFG; and a mean total of 883 mil-
22°
20° GULF GULF GULF GULF
53000462 Basin Basin MEXICO MEXICO
Veracruz Basin OF OF Province Province
OF OF
Province MEXICO
lion barrels of natural gas liquids (MMBNGL), with a range from 278 to 1,690 MMBNGL.
SIE
MEXICO Burgos
SIE
Methodology
MEXICO
SIE
MEXICO
SIE
UNITED STATES Basin
RR
RR
Area of
Sabinas Sabinas 26°
Province
RR
RR
Of the mean unconventional oil total of 776 MMBO, about 82 percent is in the Tampico-Misantla
figure 26° 26°
Burgos 25°
ATLANTIC
A
Basin Basin
A
MEXICO MEXICO
OCEAN
A
18° GULF OF
PACIFIC
MEXICO MEXICO 21° 21°
130°0'0"W 120°0'0"W 110°0'0"W 100°0'0"W 90°0'0"W 80°0'0"W 70°0'0"W 60°0'0"W
Basin (55 percent; 426 MMBO) is estimated to be in the Agua Nueva Shale Oil AU; (27 percent;
OCEAN
Burgos Province
M
D D Burgos
M
A
D
A
R R D Basin
A
E R Basin
A
EXPLANATION
Eagleford Gas
212 MMBO) is in the Pimienta Shale Oil AU. The Agua Nueva Shale Oil AU in the Burgos
The USGS approach to assessing continuous shale-oil
Assessed provinces Province
Smackover
Area of
Land
25°
Unassessed province study ATLANTIC
O O UNITED STATES
OCEAN
RI UNITED STATES RI O UNITED STATES
O 24°
16° PACIFIC
GULF OF
MEXICO
EN Area of EN Area of RI Area of RI MEXICO
EN
Basin contains the remaining (18 percent; 138 MMBO).
0 50 100 150 200 MILES OCEAN
study 25° 25°
EN
ATLANTIC
study study
TA TA
ATLANTIC
MEXICO OCEAN
OCEAN ATLANTIC
TA
GULF OF OCEAN
L MEXICO
L TA
GULF OF PACIFIC GULF OF
0 50 100 150 200 KILOMETERS 20° 20° PACIFIC MEXICO
L
OCEAN
PACIFIC OCEAN
OCEAN
20° 24°
L
OCEAN
For the mean unconventional gas total of 23,474 BCFG, about 66 percent (15,591 BCFG)
MEXICO
Tithonian Organic Richness EXPLANATION
1 to 2 weight-percent (2,985,373.05 acres) EXPLANATION EXPLANATION
Eagleford Gas
EXPLANATION Tithonian Thermal Maturity 24° La Casita Shale Gas AU
Tithonian Assessment Units
Eagleford Oil
is estimated to be in the Burgos Basin; 25 percent (5,822 BCFG) in the Sabinas Basin; and
> 2 weight-percent (793,400.95 acres)
Smackover
Land
Oil 23°
Pimienta Shale Oil AU
> 2 weight-percent TOC EXPLANATION
0 70 MILES 0 80 MILES
boundaries Geologic province Geologic province
Veracruz Basin Veracruz
9 percent (2,061 BCFG) in the Tampico-Misantla Basin.
boundaries 24° 24°
Veracruz boundaries 0 70 KILOMETERS 0 80 KILOMETERS
19° 0 25 50 75 100 MILES Province 19° 0 25 50 75 100 MILES Basin Veracruz
considered in this study. Province 19° 0 25 50 75 100 MILES Basin 19° 0 25 50 75 100 MILES Basin EXPLANATION
Figure 17. Map showing the outline of Figure 18. Map showing the outline of
Agua Nueva Shale Oil AU Agua Nueva Shale Gas AU
Assessment Team
0 70 MILES 0 70 MILES 0 80 MILES
potential shale-gas area (3,667,000 acres) potential shale-gas area (8,961,000 acres)
ing petroleum systems and unconventional assessment units
Tampico-
Age Sabinas Basin Burgos South Misantla Figure 4. Map showing the area of Figure 5. Map showing the total organic Figure 6. Map showing the extent of Figure 7. Map showing the intersection
Christopher J. Schenk, Ronald R. Charpentier, Timothy R. Klett, Marilyn E. Tennyson,
Basin Texas Basin
the Tampico-Misantla Basin with carbon (TOC) data greater than 2 weight- thermally mature Tithonian shale in the of figures 5 and 6, and represents the Figure 12. Map showing the outline Figure 13. Map showing the outline of Figure 14. Map showing the outline of po- in the Agua Nueva Formation with greater in the La Casita Formation with greater Stephanie Gaswirth, Michael E. Brownfield, Mark J. Pawlewicz, and Jean N. Weaver.
(AUs) within these systems. We developed specific geolog-
Quaternary Pleistocene Continental beds in valleys Lissie Fm. Terraces Continental
Pliocene
Goliad Fm. Goliad
Deposits
greater than 1 weight-percent total percent for Type II marine Tithonian shale onshore part of the Tampico-Misantla resultant area with both greater than 2 of potential shale-oil area (1,100,000 potential shale-gas area (3,530,000 acres) tential shale-gas area (3,941,000 acres) in than 1 weight-percent total organic car- than 1 weight-percent total organic car-
Lagarto Fm. Tuxpan
acres) in the Agua Nueva Formation in the Agua Nueva Formation with great- the La Casita Formation with greater than 1 bon (TOC) by PEMEX (2012) in the Sabinas bon (TOC) by PEMEX (2012) in the Sabinas References
ing Gp.
Miocene Fleming
organic carbon (TOC) within Tithonian in the onshore part of the Tampico- Basin. Maturity data were categorized weight-percent total organic carbon and
ic criteria and a series of maps that define areas of resource Oligocene
Flem-
Oakville Fm.
Anahuac Fm.
Norma Cgl.
Frio Escolin
Coatzintlas marine shales. About 21 percent Misantla Basin. Values of TOC greater by Tmax values from Rock-Eval analy- adequate thermal maturity for oil and gas with greater than 1 weight-percent er than 1 weight-percent total organic weight-percent total organic carbon (TOC) Basin. For the U.S. Geological Survey as- Basin. For the U.S. Geological Survey as- Charpentier, R.R., and Cook, T.A., 2011, USGS methodology for assessing continuous
Frio Fm.
Vicksburg Fm.
Burgos Basin. For the U.S. Geological is 704,000 acres (table 1), which is the is 565,000 acres (table 1), which is the
Jackson Fm. Jackson Chapapote
1 weight-percent is characterized by study that pass the threshold for quan- fined the area of source rock thermally modal area of the Tithonian Shale Oil (2012) in the Burgos Basin. For the U.S. the U.S. Geological Survey assessment, the PEMEX, 2012, Mexico’s shale oil/gas resources: PowerPoint presentation, July 10, 2012, 42 slides.
assessment, the potential shale-oil or shale-gas reservoir
Claiborne Gp.
Claiborne Gp.
Yegua Fm. Yegua Fm. Tantaoyuca
Eocene
Cook Mtn. Fm.
Mt. Selman Fm.
Cook Mtn. Fm.
Carrrizo
Guayabal
Aragon values greater than 2 weight-percent titative assessment. Note that much of mature for gas (red area); Tmax values Assessment Unit (AU), and the red area Geological Survey assessment, the Survey assessment, the potential area potential area at the mode is 828,000 acres total area (3,667,000 acres) multiplied by total area (8,961,000 acres) multiplied by Peterson, J.A., 1985, Petroleum Geology and Resources of Northeastern Mexico: U.S. Geologi-
Wilcox
at the mode is 2,259,000 acres (table 1), the Tampico-Misantla Basin analog area the Tampico-Misantla Basin analog area
must possess the following criteria: (1) contain greater than TOC (data from PEMEX, 2012). the Tithonian shale in this basin contains between 435 and 465 °C defined the defines the modal area of the Tithonian potential area at the mode is 704,000 (table 1), which is the total area (3,941,000 cal Survey Circular 943, 30 p.
Wilcox Fm. Lobo
Paleocene
Midway Fm. Midway Chicontepec
Escondido Fm. Escondido Escondido
less than 2 weight-percent TOC. Of the oil maturity window (green area), and Shale Gas AU. Both AUs were quantita- acres (table 1), which is the total area which is the total area (3,530,000 acres) acres) multiplied by the Tampico-Misantla in the Aqua Nueva Formation with greater in the Pimienta Formation withgreater
Mendez U.S. Geological Survey World Energy Assessment Team, 2012, Assessment of undiscovered
2 weight-percent total organic carbon (TOC); (2) be within
Maastrichtian
Olmos Fm. Sh. Olmos Olmos Mendez
area greater than 1 weight-percent, 21 values less than 435 °C were defined as tively assessed in this study. (1,100,000 acres) multiplied by the Tam- multiplied by the Tampico-Misantla Basin Basin analog area in the Pimienta Forma- than 2 weight-percent TOC (64 percent), than 2 weight-percent TOC (21 percent), conventional oil and gas resources of Mexico, Guatemala, and Belize, 2012: U.S. Geological
Series
Late Cretaceous
Sh.
San Miguel Fm. Mendez San Miguel
percent is greater than 2 weight-percent thermally immature for Type II kerogen. pico-Misantla Basin analog area in the analog area in the Aqua Nueva Forma- tion with greater than 2 weight-percent and then multiplied by 30 percent for the and then multiplied by 30 percent for the Survey Fact Sheet 2012–3069, 4 p.
the proper thermal maturity window for oil or gas gener-
Campanian
Upson Fm. Sh. Anacacho Ls.
Santonian San
Felipe
Austin San
Felipe TOC. This value of 21 percent was used The boundaries on this map as derived Aqua Nueva Formation with greater tion with greater than 2 weight-percent TOC (21 percent). effects of structural complexity on the effects of structural complexity on the Warwick, P.D., 2007, Assessment of undiscovered oil and gas resources in Cretaceous-Tertiary
San Felipe Fm. Fm.
ation; (3) have greater than 15 meters (m) of organic-rich
In
Gulfian
coal beds of the Gulf Coast Region, 2007: U.S. Geological Survey Fact Sheet 2007–3039, 2 p.
ur
Agua
a
Buda Ls.
available for those basins only illustrated
Wilcox-Lobo Tight Gas AU Coalbed Gas AU
Cenomanian
Del Rio Sh.
Tamaulipas
El Abra
M
rock with greater than 1 weight-percent
Georgetown
Upper
on Upper Upper
va
Stuart
Albian Kiamichi 102° 101° 100° 99° 98° 102° 101° 100° 99° 98°
Acatta Fac Aurora Tamaulipas Fm. Tamaulipas Fm. Fm.
ies
TOC (data from PEMEX, 2012).
Early Cretaceous
Ls.
gas or oil in matrix storage (Charpentier and Cook, 2011).
Evap.
Glen Rose Ls. 29° 29°
La Pena Fm.
Aptian
La Pena Fm. Otates Fm. Pearsall Otates Fm.
Rio Escondido Table 1. Key assessment input data for unconventional assessment units in northeast Mexico. Table 2. Northeast Mexico unconventional oil and gas resource assessment results.
Assessment Unit
Fm.
The USGS approach to defining AUs in the Turonian Agua Nueva Formation of the Tampico-Misantla Basin began with the map showing the distribution of TOC (fig. 8).
Wilcox-Lobo Tight Gas
and calculated mean]
Coahuilan
(green) and shale-gas area (red) used in the assessment. Rio Escondido Olmos Coalbed Gas AU 53000281 La Casita Shale Gas AU 53000361
Province
Assessment input data
Cotton Province
La Casista
27° 27°
Jurassic
Tithonian
Pimienta
Fm.
Kimmeridgian Olvido Fm. Haynesville
Minimum Mode Maximum Calculated mean Minimum Mode Maximum Calculated mean Field
Oxfordian La Gloria Zuloaga Ls. Smackover Ls. Smackover Smackover 100° 99° 98° 97° 96° 100° 99° 98° 97° 96° 100° 99° 98° 97° 96° 100° 99° 98° 97° 96° USA USA
Potential production area of AU (acres) 10,000 250,000 750,000 336,667 100,000 828,000 2,500,000 1,142,667
(TPS) Proba- Oil (MMBO) Gas (BCFG) NGL (MMBNGL)
Type
TURONIAN TURONIAN TURONIAN TURONIAN and Assessment Unit (AU) bility F95 F50 F5 Mean F95 F50 F5 Mean F95 F50 F5 Mean
Burgos Burgos
Average drainage area of wells (acres) 40 80 160 93 80 120 160 120
TOC TOC THERMAL FINAL
26° 26°
Tau
BURGOS BASIN
ma
Tau
Tau
Tau
Ma
Ma
ul
Ma
Burgos Basin Province Province Province
cat
An important part of the geologic phase of this study > 1 WEIGHT- > 2 WEIGHT- MATURITY
ipa
ma
ma
AU MAP
m
gis
gis
gis
24° Province
and southeast Texas. The Pimienta Formation of the
zin
aul
24° 24° 24°
sA
ul
ul
Success ratios (%) 50 70 90 70 40 60 80 60 Olmos Coalbed Gas TPS
cat
cat
cat
ipa
ipa
ipa
Ba
rch
zin
zin
zin
si
sA
s
sA
Arc
Pro
nP
PERCENT PERCENT
Ba
Ba
Ba
Average EUR (MMBO, oil; BCFG, gas) 0.03 0.2 1 0.24 0.3 0.6 0.9 0.61
rch
Tampico-Misantla Basin is equivalent to the La Casita
rch
Rio Escondido Coalbed
rov
vin
h
sin
sin
was a formal USGS-PEMEX (Petroleos Mexicanos)
sin
1.0 Gas 125 479 1,544 612 0 0 0 0
25° 25°
i
ce
nce
Agua Nueva Shale Oil AU 53000461 Agua Nueva Shale Gas AU 53000462
23° 23°
Mexico City, Mexico, in June, 2012. The geology and cur- Group; Fm., Formation; Cgl., conglomerate; Ls., limestone; 22° MEXICO
22° MEXICO 22° MEXICO 22° MEXICO
EXPLANATION EXPLANATION
Potential production area of AU (acres)
Average drainage area of wells (acres)
100,000
160
704,000
280
1,100,000
400
634,667
280
100,000
80
2,259,000
120
3,530,000
160
1,963,000
120
53000361
Turonian Agua Nueva TPS
Wilcox-Lobo Tight Rio Escondido Olmos
GULF
GULF GULF GULF Gas AU
0 70 KILOMETERS
SIE
SIE
Success ratios (%) 50 70 90 70 50 70 90 70 1.0 Oil 52 129 251 138 96 252 533 275 2 5 11 6
RR
RR
RR
53000461
RR
and shale-gas assessment units (AU) of northeast Mexico
A
A
Average EUR (MMBO, oil; BCFG, gas) 0.04 0.08 0.2 0.086 0.4 0.8 1.2 0.813
130°0'0"W 120°0'0"W 110°0'0"W 100°0'0"W 90°0'0"W 80°0'0"W 70°0'0"W 60°0'0"W
Figure 15. Map showing the extent Figure 16. Map showing the extent of
21°
21°
21°
M
D
M
M
1.0 3,211 9,320 15,982 9,403 127 368 654 376
M
A
UNITED STATES R D D D
Burgos Basin Sabinas Basin Gas
of the Wilcox-Lobo Tight Gas Assess- Olmos Formation coals in the Burgos
A
A
E
A
R R R
53000462
were discussed in detail. PEMEX later supplied several
Area of
study ATLANTIC
E E E
O
Wilcox-Lobo Tight Gas AU 53000561 La Casita Shale Gas AU 53230161
OCEAN
PACIFIC MEXICO
GULF OF UNITED STATES UNITED STATES
RI O O
ment Unit (AU) in the Burgos Basin. This Basin, as mapped by Warwick (2007).
O
MEXICO
RI
OCEAN
EN Area of
RI RI
Paleogene TPS
UNITED STATES Area of
study
EN EN study
ATLANTIC
EN
ATLANTIC
TA
Minimum Mode Maximum Calculated mean Minimum Mode Maximum Calculated mean
Area of OCEAN OCEAN
PACIFIC MEXICO
GULF OF
MEXICO
maps with geologic data that were critical to the USGS as-
TA
GULF OF
20° L study ATLANTIC MEXICO
TA PACIFIC MEXICO
TA
Ro < 1.3% Ro > 1.3% mapped area is an extension of a much The coals define the extent of the Rio
OCEAN OCEAN OCEAN
EXPLANATION 20° MEXICO L L L
Wilcox-Lobo Tight Gas AU
GULF OF
PACIFIC MEXICO
20° 20°
Turonian Organic Richness
Potential production area of AU (acres) 10,000 550,000 700,000 420,000 94,000 565,000 1,882,000 847,000
OCEAN
SABINAS BASIN
Agua Nueva Shale Gas AU
50 75 100 MILES
Veracruz
Basin
Geologic province
boundaries
Veracruz
Basin
Geologic province
boundaries
Veracruz States. Sandstones of the Wilcox-Lobo ment Unit (AU). Percent of AU untested 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100
Basin
Upper Jurassic La Casita TPS
combined to outline areas within the Sabinas, Burgos, and
0 25 50 75 100 MILES