You are on page 1of 44

CASE STUDY: FLC GROUP

Group 1

GROUP 1
Table of Contents
I.    COMPANY BACKGROUND 5

1. History 5

2. Remarkable milestones 6

II. VISION AND MISSION 8

1.  Vision 8

2. Mission 8

III. GOALS & STRATEGIES 8

1.  Goals 8

2. Strategies 9

IV. BUSINESS MODEL 11

1.  Core Value 11

2. Overview of FLC Joint Stock Company’s operation 11

V. COMPANY PERFORMANCE 13

1.  Financial performance 13

2. Company strategy 15

3. Competitor 16

VI. MANAGEMENT CHARACTERISTICS 17

1.  Board of Managers 17

2. Corporate culture and value 19

3. Organizational structure 19

VII. SWOT ANALYSIS 20

1.  Strength 21

1
2. Weaknesses 23

3.  Opportunity 23

4. Threat 25

VIII. INDUSTRY ANALYSIS 25

1.  Overview of industry 25

2. How the company operates and manages in the industry 30

IX. Problem: FLC’s PROJECTS ARE SLOWED 32

1.  Problem 32

2. Cause 34

3. Impact 35

4. Solution 36

X. CHALLANGES 36

1.  Real Estate 36

2. Bamboo Airway 37

XI, SOLUTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 38

1.  Real Estate 38

2. Bamboo Airway 39

XII, CONCLUSION 40

II. REFERENCE LIST 41

2
I.    COMPANY BACKGROUND

1. History
Formerly known as Vietnam Trade Corp Joint Stock Company, FLC Group
Joint Stock Company was founded by Trinh Van Quyet and 2 co-founders in
2001. After considering a significant event that would have a big effect on the
company's growth, the top executive agreed to start the Management
Consultancy & Investment Tracking Joint Stock Company (SMic). At this
time, when the organization was faced with the criteria of professionalization
and business policy consulting, the law consulting department was split into
the law office of SMiC. The law office was formally turned into SMIC Co.,
Ltd. in 2006.
As a result, FLC Group Joint Stock Company (FLC) was formally formed as a
result of the merger of the member companies in 2010. FLC is the
abbreviation of Finance, Land and Commerce, which are the main business
fields of the Company. The FLC logo was inspired by the DNA pictures, the
gene sequence and the evolution of the living organisms. After 17 years of
formation and growth, FLC has become one of Vietnam's most strong
business companies with three main business segments:
 Approximately concentrate on investment consulting and project
management for associated firms to achieve higher income, as well as on
the study and review of real estate companies.
 Resort property (FLC Sam Son Beach & Golf Resort, FLC Sea Tower
Quy Nhon, FLC Quang Binh Eco Resort), leasing office, commercial
property services, real estate brokerage services, real estate advisory
services, etc.

3
 Trade and services: manufacture and sale of advanced surgical devices,
trade in sporting facilities, in particular golf courses.
 Other major enterprises which have a strategic partnership with the main
business: high-tech agriculture; air transport business; financial investment.
Hanoi is also involved in other operations such as resorts and hotel
facilities, civil construction, medical machinery and equipment trade,
education and labor exports, industrial law and mining and mineral
processing, etc.

2. Remarkable milestones

In the last 20 months of expansion and growth since 2001, FLC has
experienced substantial improvements in its three main segments, including
property investment, finance and commerce. In particular, an increasing
number of significant milestones have been achieved:

2001: Vietnam Trade Corp JSC has been founded and operates in the
commercial and service fields. Subsequently, Supervision Management
Investment Consulting JSC (SMiC) was also founded.

2006: SMiC law office was transferred into SMiC Law firm Co., Ltd.

2007: FLCS Securities JSC (formerly regarded as Artex Securities JSC).


FLCS officially was operated in 2008.

2008: Companies have been formed such as: Truong Phu


Investment Co., Ltd (its name was already changed to FLC JSC
since January 2010); SaiGon Invest Co., Ltd and most noticeably,
Ninh Bac financial investment JSC (the Precursor of FLC land
JSC - owner of Landmark Tower project).

2009: stock company and was renamed as Investment Corporation Truong


Phu Fortune Investment Co., Ltd changed its operation model as a joint on
General CRV JSC.

4
2010: Merged company members into FLC Joint Stock Company.

2010: 170 billion VND. FLC JSC renamed as FLC Group Joint Stock
Company with the charter capital of

2011: Ticker FLC was officially listed and traded on HNX.

2012: Increased the charter capital up to 771.8 billion VND.

2013: FLC was moved from HNX to HOSE.

2014: in Thanh Hoa with a total investment of 5,500 billion VND. FLC
started Golf Course and FLC Samson Golf Links international resort project

2015: Increased the charter capital up to 5,299 billion VND.

2016: Increased the charter capital up to 6,380 billion VND.

2017: billion Viet Bamboo Airways Co., Ltd was established with the charter
capital of 700 VND. FLC has officially expanded its investment in civil
aviation.

2017: Opened representative office in Japan.

2018: FLC and Airbus reached an agreement of $3 billion on purchasing 24


aircrafts for Bamboo Airways.
2020: the airline aims to develop a fleet of 40 aircraft, develop 85 domestic
and international routes to economic and tourism centers, and promote
domestic and foreign information connections.
“Besides, FLC Group also won honorable awards such as Gold Cup“
Enterprise of the year in real estate ”(International Business Awards 2019)
(Hồng, 2019), top 10 most impressive travel brands - destinations (The Guide
Awards 2019) (Le, 2019), top 5 "Enterprises investing in Vietnam's top
tourism in 2019" (Vietnam Tourism Awards) ("Tập đoàn FLC giành “cú đúp”
Giải thưởng Du lịch Việt Nam 2019", 2019) and top 10 best real estate
developers in Vietnam 2016, 2018, 2019 (BCI Asia Awards) (Trung, 2019).

5
The valuation of the FLC Group's project properties is valued at $9 billion by
the UniCap Fund at October 2017 ("FLC Group – Vietnam’s ‘Land Genie’ to
go international - Vietnam News | Politics, Business, Economy, Society, Life,
Sports - VietNam News", 2019). Brand Finance has been listed as one of the
50 most important brands in Vietnam in 2016 (Haigh, 2016).

II. VISION AND MISSION

1.  Vision

 Grow a multi-sector economic corporation that functions successfully on an


international scale and thus contributes significantly to Vietnam's prosperity
(Universal, 2019).
 Become a diverse and strong economic group with a high strategic capability
that constantly aims to accomplish higher goals and is the first option for
both corporate partners and consumers (FLC, 2020).

2.   Mission

FLC is committed to unceasingly innovating and investing extensively in


designing and supplying consumers with the highest quality and
environmentally friendly goods and services at fair costs, thus creating long-
lasting and durable confidence and partnership with customers and partners.
 For shareholders and partners: to create a clear commitment for long-
term gains, as well as the pride of shareholders and partners, and to
develop a corporate culture among individuals.
 For employees: to create a welcoming, friendly, involved and competent
work climate in which all people feel excited about serving the growth of
the FLC Community.
 For society: seriously contribute to the long-term interests of the
company and society, and show the sense of responsibility and national
identity of the citizen.

6
III.        GOALS & STRATEGIES

1.  Goals

 Being a multinational group of business and multi-sector firms with clear


trademarks in Vietnam
 Enhancing continuous product and service efficiency.
 Minimize expense and risks and profit from every possibility, every
incentive, for maintaining and using productive capital.
 Increasing collaboration with national and international partners in the
promotion and enhancement of opportunities.

2.  Strategies

The FLC Group builds its mission in terms of maintainability, expert


management and sustainable development principles with a view to being an
incredibly dynamic, future competitive organization having strong brand in
Vietnam and hitting international markets. As one of the Vietnamese
market's leading real estate developers, FLC Group produces revenue of
more than 10 000 billion VNDs (about 430 million USD) in 2017 and 2018,
in a row. In 2019,The Group's revenue increased significantly, particularly
with respect to the commercial operation of Bamboo Airways. Latest
financial reports for Quarter IV reveal that the FLC Company (FLC – HOSE)
has earned before taxes a profit of nearly USD 783 billion (nearly USD 34
million) and VND 679 billion (over USD 29 million) respectively,
respectively, before taxes and after-tax profit. This marks an expansion of
almost 16% and almost 45% over the target of 2018 (Universal, 2019).
Specifically, three out of the 24 schemes, including the 95.5 ha Ha Long
Start Golf course, FLC Ha Long Complex with a 51.4 ha total area and Ha
Khanh Urban Area, including 2,600 terraced households and 927 flats, are
currently under execution. The corporation also explores Ngoc Vung Island,
Cai Rong wharf, and Van Don's high tech industrial medicine and
pharmaceuticals complex (Biz Hub, 2019). Moreover, The FLC Group

7
achieved revenue of almost VND 5.093 billion, which increased 21 percent
over the same period last year with special regard to quarter IV/2019. Despite
the expense price rise, sales from financial operations climbed dramatically
to 1.482 billion VND (USD 63,7 million), which resulted in a tax benefit of
almost VND 591 billion (USD 25,4 million), double the same span last year
alone in the last 3 months of the year alone. The FLC Group generated net
sales in 2019 of 16,419 billion VND (US$ 705,6 million), more than 40%
more than in 2018, and 82% of the annual target. The tax return hits VND
679 billion, which is a big increase of approximately 45% and 119% of the
schedule laid out for the general meeting for 2019. The benefit after fiscal
growth amounts to USD 29,2 million (Universal, 2019).

(Based on FLC.vn)

Aside from its main market sector, the FLC Group has also achieved high
business success in other major fields such as the aviation industry.
Following the completion of almost 20,000 flights, Bamboo Airways has
struggled aggressively over the year to produce almost 3 million passengers
with over 94 percent on-time performances, which is the highest in Vietnam
(Universal, 2019). The airline has been running 34 domestic and
international routes since its arrival in January 2019. To date, it has flown
almost 20,000 and has registered almost 3 million passengers (Son, 2020).
Financial operations also help FLC to cover market and operational expense

8
losses in 2019 as a whole. Total Company revenues last year surpassed
VND16.4 billion ($707.6 million). It was over VND340 billion in gross loss
($14.67 million). Financial benefit surpassed VND2.5 billion ($107.9
million) in revenues. Last year (US$33.6 million) FLC posted earnings after
tax of over VND 780 billion, up 16 percent from 2018 (Son, 2020).

IV.       BUSINESS MODEL

1.               Core values

“ PIONEER - CONSTRUCTIVENESS - ENTHUSIASM - LOYALTY - HUMANISM”

1. Pioneer: always be a pioneer in the discovery of new future markets and


possess a daring spirit

2. Constructiveness: Never stop refining and innovating to achieve better,


more complete, meaningful and productive goods.

3. Enthusiasm: Be always enthusiastic about feeling, choice and motion.

4. Loyalty: Still value l oyalty in all ties to promote sustainable growth.

5. Humanism: Take the core always on civilization, evolve because of human


beings and focus on the overall societal growth and national stability.

2.      Overview of FLC Joint Stock Company’s operation

FLC revenues comes from some following main business activities:

a. REAL ESTATE

In early 2010, FLC Group established the property exchange floor and
started company’s business with some services:

 Real Estate Business

Trading floors allow consumers to transact their property, purchase or rent


infrastructure, homes, villas, and property. Investment is also being made
in land reconstruction projects and leased land Facilities.

 Real Estate Brokerage Services

9
The property brokerage services may be the type of transaction where a
commercial arrangement may be formed between two or different
individuals. In the general trading floor, real estate investment firms play a
significant role. 
For clients such as: property, apartments, villas, hotels, resorts, offices,
factory construction, warehouses, industrial parks, and other services the
FLC Group offers brokering services of different product categories. The
key operations of this floor include the recipient can be acquired from the
parent corporation, funds obtained from associates and businesses or
properties sold to individuals and clients.

 Real Estate Transaction Service

Notary public and personal notary and other real estate related services.
This service combines with federal departments to provide the owners
with such resources, such as supplying and moving.

 Advertising Service for Real Estate

The real trading floor is where daily consumers are asked to purchase, sell,
rent, and analyze their properties. There are a lot of users who use the site
to get information and use customer care services. Communication
services for this area on the website or on the trading platform are also
very successful. Resources used across the trading floor include
consultancy firms that execute state-owned projects, investment
companies, housing design services, office design and a variety of
companies. All of them have equipment, chairs, building materials.
Posters are submitted to the office, mission pictures on the trade floor and
on the internet, 3D movies on the website, banners are film types.

 Real Estate Consulting Service

The FLC Group also offers legal counsel and services on investment
ventures and on state management contracts. In addition, credit and
financial advice programs, building licenses and legal papers for clients
are also provided by this exchange floor.

10
b. HOSPITALITY & SERVICES

Starting at Cam Quy Lake, the FLC Group currently operates a number of
luxurious hotels and resorts in Vietnam, which include FLC Quy Nhon, the
FLC Luxury Resort (international standards), the FLC Quy Nhon Playa and
Camp; the FLC Ha Long Bay Golf Club and the Camp and Camp; the Gold
Resort (premium resorts and villas); and the Luxury Resort.

c. FINANCE INVESTMENT

FLC focuses on financial guidance and project management to fund multiple


units which are the foundation for joining the $64,000 property market. In
order to improve skilful growth in technical investments and in land project
management, FLC will also partner with giant and international businesses.

In addition, FLC's numerous operations in conjunction with neoliberal


development are still involved. These operations produce tremendous
company income and sales. Specifically, FLC contracts provide equipment
for the 60 billion worth VND institution of FLC Landmark House to FLC
Land Finance Acquisition Joint Stock Firm. The firm has so far fitted steel
with an entire VND 25 billion contract mark.

V. COMPANY PERFORMANCE

1. Financial performance

2019  2018 2017

Total Revenue 11695895.79


15780749.43 11216595.38

Gross Profit  -1010981.67 1222815.67 1064678.51


Net Income 695926.12 470031.77 385275.11

Total Assets 32012714.14 25889289.5 22795168.39

FLC Group’s Annual Financial Report (According to Investing.com)

11
FLC Income Statement (by Investing.com)

FLC Balance Sheet (by Investing.com)

12
 FLC Cash Flow Statement (by Investing.com)

2. Company strategy

The Sustainable Development FLC is suggested by reducing to the lowest


degree and continuously enhancing organizational procedures to meet market
goals the threats of industry, climate and social administration.

In particular, the growth factors of the FLC Community include:

 Resources and properties: express the stature of the company by


cultivating in quantity and consistency all capital sources and assets
 Market value: retaining its integrity and the best price reputation. The
biggest obstacle in the future is to maintain and improve this price.
 HR: this is an important aspect influencing a company's pace and
performance. In order to build a safe workplace atmosphere that facilitates
self-effectiveness, FLC supports staff recruiting practices and
comprehensive preparation.
 Skills for administration: human management is the most critical
capability in the FLC. The administrator should be an informed
employee and a vital advocate of corporate executives in addition to the
flexibility to communicate, plan and handle.

13
 Developing corporate culture and community responsibility: while
business identity is a corporate culture, serious social responsibility
commitments help cement the image of the brand and bind the
company with the community

3.               Comparing to Industry and Competitors

'Share of voice' of real estate corporations. Source: Reputa Report

Vinhomes is the most mentioned real estate brand in Q2 / 2020, accounting


for 55% of total mentions about units in this field. The reason is that
investors and consumers are very interested in Vinhomes' new real estate
projects such as Vinhomes Ocean Park, Vinhomes Grand Park and the
program "buy a house from afar" or the lucky draw "House. happiness "of
this corporation. Despite the complicated evolution of Covid-19, Vinhomes
is the brand with the most communication activities.

14
Top 10 most mentioned real estate projects in Q2 / 2020. Source: Reputa Report

FLC Group (14%) is the second largest brand after Vinhomes. Most of the
talk was about the Condotel - FLC Coastal Hill Quy Nhon project. Ecopark
accounts for 13% and is the third brand to mention. The content of this news
mainly focuses on propaganda about new projects and urban areas of
Ecopark.

VI.        MANAGEMENT CHARACTERISTICS

1.               Board of Managers

Full Name Date of Positions Qualifications Others


birth

Trịnh Văn Quyết 27/11/1975 CHAIRMAN OF - Chairman


-Master of
BOARD OF of the Board
Business
EXECUTIVE (FLC Faros
Administration
-Bachelor of Laws Construction
JSC)
- Member of

15
the Board
(SG Invest
Real Estate
Co., Ltd)
-General
Director (SMiC
Law Firm)
19/08/1978 Doctor of Laws
EXECUTIVE -President

VICE (FLC

CHAIRWOMA Helicopters
Hương Trần Kiều N OF BOARD and Helicopter
Dung OF Service

EXECUTIVES Company)

FLC GROUP - Director (FLC

JSC Land Co., Ltd)

05/04/1977 MEMBER OF
BOARD OF
EXECUTIVES
FLC GROUP
Lã Quý Hiển JSC

07/12/1976 MEMBER OF GENERAL


BOARD OF DIRECTOR
EXECUTIVES FLC GROUP
FLC GROUP JSC
Bùi Hải Huyền
JSC
(Based on flc.vn)

2.               Corporate culture and value

16
In FLC, people live and work together as a family to accomplish a traditional
perfect and a like goal. The basis for progress is a solid establishment. All
have a confident chance to communicate what specifications are. FLC allows
each delegate to show in accordance with the ideal aggregate their own
identities. As any individual's accomplishment contributes to the overall
success of the company, business achievement is for the good of everyone.

By creating a strong, inviting, dynamic and expert workplace where all people
look forward to helping develop the FLC, FLC pursues harmonized
advantages and business interests.

3.               Organizational structure

FLC Group Organization Chart (by Flc.vn)

17
Most of the provisions of the FLC Community are governed by the FLC
Group and its members. In specific, nineteen small businesses are to be
partly limited under the FLC Group, FLC Foreign Capital & Trade Co., Ltd
to Yacht  and Rosland Joint Stock Company.

(Based on cafef.vn)

VII.               SWOT ANALYSIS

Strengths Weakness:
1. FLC has large land bank with projects 1. Raising capital on the stock market
potentials in Sam Son, Binh Dinh and for investment for projects. Real
Hanoi. estate should
2. Good financial potential thanks to not yet generate cash flow and profits
mobilization is a large amount of capital right. Efficient profitability from the
over the years recently from the stock project only come after 1-2 years
market. 2. Pressure of being a pioneer

18
3. High project implementation capacity
makes time to put the project into operation
short, increase business efficiency.
4. Continuous innovation facility
5. Strong brand equity
Opportunity: Threat:
1. The real estate market has recovered 1. The level of competition in the
strong and in an uptrend. market
2. The demand for vacation tourism will real estate, especially products
increase when the standard of living of the resort villas, resorts are
people is increased. increasingly.
2. Large-scale projects should be
possible
Product consumption is a challenge
awake is not small.

( Base on mbs.vn)

1. Strength
a. Smart investment in land
 A significant volume of land is owned by the FLC, as the Vietnamese
property market is slowing and evolving into big ventures, by
purchasing "frozen" commercial land. FLC Group's current owner
currently holds a land fund of over 9,000 hectares, has established
over 50 projects covering more than 40 kilometers of coastline
covering 8 provinces across the world. In all, VND 135 thousand
billion of investments (Đình Hiếu, 2019).
 FLC provides local people a range of work opportunities and a major
commitment towards society to foster economic and social
development in this area.

b. Substantial financial capital

19
The FLC's chartered capital has risen considerably in the decade from VND
1800 to VND 7100 billion because of its phenomenal success in eccolic
capital on the stocks.
c. Successful execution of the project
 The FLC Group has consistently concentrated in recent years on
ensuring exponential growth rates for project execution. The
programs of each FLC are done as quickly as possible, regardless of
scale and scope. FLC Quy Nhon Beach & Golf Resort are two golf
courses, setting an estimated half year with a new golf course in Asia
(FLC News, 2017). FLC, however, does not stand as a speed-linked
firm. In reality the Organization only operates to ensure its market
efficiency is straightforward and effective, where pace is the strategic
weapon. It helps to lift the competence level of the FLC Community
at low cost, create consumers morale, and boost society well-being.
d.  Innovation facility
 One of the major strategies for allowing the FLC group to develop its
multisectoral companies is its ongoing innovation facility. In addition
to being founded in three strategic industries (financial investment,
immovable growth and mining), FLC is aggressively engaged in new
fields of industry.
e. Strong brand equity
 In the sense of the development of a powerful brand over the past 17
years, FLC Group has reinforced its role in the domestic sector to
steadily enter the overseas market. FLC has been listed among the top
50 in the Vietnamese market, according to Brand Finance (Haigh,
2016).

 FLC has policies in particular, like Go Green, to protect the


environment, and provide disadvantaged children with scholarships to
increase brand recognition and encourage consumer engagement,
while fostering social development in the long run (Dương, 2019).

20
2.     Weaknesses
a. Not yet generate cash flow and profits right
 Raising capital in the stock market to invest in real estate projects has
not yet created cash flows and profits. Effective profitability from the
project after only 1-2 years. Looking at the market, it can be seen that,
instead of investing in many pieces, listed real estate companies seem
to be focusing on certain types of real estate to avoid spreading
capital and meeting the right needs of the market. In addition, looking
at the 2020 plans of listed real estate companies, it is easy to see a
common point about the trend of implementing large-scale projects,
integrating multi-utility, towards real needs (Hà, 2020).
b. Pressure of being a pioneer

 To choose to be an innovator in the discovery and investment in


untouched tourism areas costs FLC lower investment costs and
offers the first mover the advantage to pick optimal sites. However
the super-projects of these FLCs are bound to demonstrate a strong
loss to guarantee their performance.
3.     Opportunities

a. The real estate market has recovered strong and in an uptrend.


 In the third quarter of 2020, the Ministry of Construction has
released the study on the immobiliari sector. The report thus
claimed that the building industry and the immovable sector
generally still had a range of good points and relevant indicators
despite various difficulties. Immobilien businesses around the
country have generally advanced faster, more dynamic and have
been exhibiting optimistic and positive signs. The sector is
showing good signs of recovery by the end of the year (Vu, 2020).
 In particular, in the third quarter of 2020, the average overall
propertial goods transaction throughout the nation amounted to
approximately 110–125% compared with the second quarter of

21
2020, considering the rapid adjustment and control of supportive
policies. After a time of social divide, government funding (Vu,
2020).
 In October 2020, tourism and the resort property were back on
track in the aftermath of the second Covid-19 Surge, which took
place in some locations such as TP, and have adopted various
promotion policy measures to raise domestic tourism demand. Da
Nang, Quang Nam, Hai Duong, Ho Chi Minh City (Vu, 2020)
 After the heavily affected period of COVID-19 in the first two
quarters of the year, FLC had a relatively positive third quarter.
Contributing to this figure is a positive recovery in most core
sectors such as real estate, resort tourism and aviation (Linh, 2020).
b. The demand for vacation tourism will increase when the standard of
living of the people is increased.
The middle class in Vietnam is expected to reach 30 million people by 2020.
As the population gets richer, they want to experience vacation tourism
services that they have not previously been able to "reward themselves.
myself "will also have breakthrough changes. Nielsen's research shows that
three-quarters of Vietnamese people are comfortable spending and are
willing to spend money on 5-star resort services to relieve stressful lives and
take care of their own health ("Người Việt tăng chi cho du lịch nghỉ dưỡng |
VAKALAND", 2020).

22
( Based on Nielsen)

4.            Threats

a. Competition

The FLC responds to high competition from other firms with a view to
dominating the domestic real estate industry. Vin Group is the highest
competent firm. Competition in these firms arose from value for money to
architectural design of buildings and structures, which disrupted the FLC
Group's expansion.
b. Risks of large-scale projects
Immobilien is a high risk business, but the incentive is still very tempting.
Nothing can ensure customers' maximum usage in terms of the high
profitability, especially in the large-scale enterprise of FLC and the
company will result in a loss of billions.

VIII.    INDUSTRY ANALYSIS

1. OVERVIEW OF THE INDUSTRY:

23
Within the past 3 years, there have been exceptionally few ventures recently
authorized, particularly low-cost housing ventures and social houses. In
addition, the Covid-19 epidemic added further difficulties to the market. But
the truth appears that the current troublesome period is also an opportunity to
screen and reposition businesses within the real estate industry clearly.
(Ngan, 2020)

COVID-19 has had a negative impact on the real estate industry, with the
first half of 2020 housing transactions falling to their lowest level in four
years. Many investors and economic experts consider this as a necessary gap
to look back and meet the higher level of development of the country.
(Nguyen, 2020)

The Ministry of Construction said that by the end of May 2020, the whole
country had only about 200 real estate transaction floors operating in
moderation, with more than 800 trading floors suspended or closed. These
numbers show the real estate market of our country before the Covid 19
transaction, hundreds of exchanges have sprung up like mushrooms after the
rain, doing business in the "surfing" style to make temporary profits;
Currently, a number of large real estate businesses also reduce their output
by 30% - 70%, forcing to lay off workers, increasing the number of
unemployed people, creating a burden on society. (Nguyen, 2020)

As an economic sector that plays an important role in building technical and


social infrastructure, economic zones, industrial parks, urban areas,
housing ... so when the real estate market falls into a state of decline. The
withdrawal has impacted about 50 other industries such as construction
materials production, interior equipment, transportation, brokerage…; the
bank's bad debt ratio increased. (Nguyen, 2020)

Within the long term, Vietnam's real estate market is on the rise with the
request of 100 million individuals pointing to have a tall middle-income
salary by 2030, of which approximately 15% are middle-class. Therefore,

24
the demand for housing is rapidly increasing, new urban areas and industrial
zones with technical and social infrastructure are being built. (Nguyen,
2020)

The influence of the Covid epidemic has changed the movement trajectory
of the real estate market in 2020. Here are 6 outstanding movement trends of
the real estate market in 2020.

(Source: Vietnam Report, Survey of Vietnam real estate enterprises 2020, February
2020)

a. Industrial real estate will continue to grow in 2020

According to experts in the survey of Vietnam Report, the industrial park


real estate will be the bright spot of the market in 2020, with many
advantages when the economy develops stably, Vietnam participates in
many The trade agreement, in addition to the Covid outbreak, had a strong
impact on the world economy, disrupting the global supply chain, and also
created a shift in production from China to ASEAN countries. FDI inflows
into the real estate sector continued to increase. (Nam, 2020)

25
b. Foundation soil is the first choice of customers

Survey results of Vietnam Report show that, for customer groups, land plots
are chosen the most with 62.77%; followed by apartments for rent (34.89%),
apartments (28.09%), retail: Shophouse, shopping mall ... (10%), industrial
real estate (12.13%). (Nam, 2020)

c. The trend of shifting investment to neighboring markets

As clean land funds in big cities like Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City are
increasingly scarce, real estate businesses will continue to move to other
provinces with advantages in developing economic, mineral, industrial, and
industrial sectors. especially tourism development. In addition, many
investors tend to choose local provinces to make new towns because of
favorable land bidding procedures and a shorter investment cycle than
projects in Hanoi and HCMC. (Nam, 2020)

d. Housing segment maintained growth momentum

The residential housing segment is assessed to still grow steadily, according


to experts, this segment is not affected by Covid's translation, the purchase
of houses and apartments is based on the needs and plans to live in long-
term. Low-cost apartments are still scarce, while luxury apartments may
increase sharply in 2020. (Nam, 2020)

e. Promote technology application and investment in green real estate

Some real estate businesses have changed their business plans, deployed
sales apps, used newsletters with video, 3D scanning; or the livestream
brokerage to introduce products to customers to support buyers. By applying
technology, customers can know information about the project, visit an
apartment through virtual reality with just a smartphone, and at the same
time help customers save time, create flexibility. mobility for customers and
limit movement and contact with many people during the epidemic season.

26
This is the driving factor for online transactions in the real estate sector.
(Nam, 2020)

Besides, when the environmental pollution is high and the epidemic breaks
out, people pay more attention to ensuring their health. One of the responses
of real estate businesses to the Covid-19 translation is to restructure
products, through green projects, to bring peace of mind to residents' health
in order to stimulate the demand for healthy living. quality of home buyers
today. (Nam, 2020)

g. M&A will continue to be active in 2020

In 2020, the M&A channel will continue to increase strongly. Because


financial investment is an effective investment channel, in the case of
difficult credit, this is an opportunity for people with money, foreign
investors, domestic or overseas Vietnamese. They are all interested in the
Vietnamese market with financial investment aspects. Real estate businesses
are also willing to accept "sharing a piece of cake" with people with
financial capacity, including abroad. (Nam, 2020)

From short-term and long-term estimates of Vietnam's real-property


marketplace, underneath center on two sorts of markets with fast
development potential with large scale, industrial real estate and new urban
areas. (Nguyen, 2020)

After the Covid epidemic has gradually been controlled, real estate is
appearing signs of recovery and growth once more. Analysts said that real
estate is still one of the relatively safe channels to store assets in the event of
an economic crisis, especially in the affordable housing segment, meeting
real need, continues to play the leading role and sustainable development,
the reality has been demonstrated through the freezing crises of the real
estate market in 2008 and 2011. (Vu, 2020)

27
2. HOW THE COMPANY OPERATES AND MANAGES IN THE
INDUSTRY

FLC is the leading private multidisciplinary and multi-sector economic


group in Vietnam. According to a report by Unicap Fund Management
Company, the value of FLC has exceeded 9 billion USD. FLC has risen to
the list of leading Asian corporations.

FLC Group's full name is FLC Group Joint Stock Company (FLC stands for
Finance, Land and Commerce - finance, real estate and commerce). This is a
company in Vietnam mainly trading in real estate, formerly known as
Truong Phu Fortune Investment Company Limited, on October 25, 2011,
FLC Group Joint Stock Company was born. This event marks a new stage in
the company's growth.

Real estate is the key business line of FLC. From its initial activities of
corporate finance and investment consulting, in 2010 FLC Group has had a
resounding reputation in the market with sensitive and discernible
investment strategies.

The Group's real estate products span all segments. These include resort real
estate, houses, offices and industrial zones. However, FLC Group is best
known for its resort real estate product line. These properties are built
according to international standards. Resort real estate system includes hotel
area, commercial townhouse, resort, villa, golf course.

Since its foundation, FLC Group has invested in 10 following areas:

1. REAL ESTATE

2. AIR TRANSPORT

3. HOTEL SERVICE, RESTAURANT, COURS GOLF

4. TOURISTS, TRAVEL FISHERIES

28
5. HIGH-TECH AGRICULTURE

6. PHARMACY

7. EDUCATION

8. MINING AND PROCESSING OF MINERALS

9. PURE WATER

10. FINANCIAL INVESTMENT

FLC Group's subsidiaries include 14 companies:

1. Khanh Hoa Real Estate Development and Investment Company Limited

2. FLC Do Son Golf & Resort Company Limited

3. FLC Sam Son Beach Mining and Management Company Limited

4. FLC Ha Long Investment and Development Company Limited

5. Viet Aviation Company Limited  (Bamboo Airways)

6. FLC Resort Service Company Limited

7. FLC Jewelry Company Limited

8. FLC Industrial Park Development and Management Company Limited

9. FLC Quang Binh Golf & Resort Company Limited

10. FLC Sam Son Golf & Resort Company Limited

11. Star Hanoi Real Estate Joint Stock Company

12. Investment and Management Co., Ltd. of Ion Complex

13. FLC Beverage Joint Stock Company

29
14. Alaska Real Estate Investment Corporation

IX. Problem: FLC’s PROJECTS ARE SLOWED

FLC Group has launched projects in many provinces, but some of them are
behind schedule. These projects have been planned for a long time but have
not been implemented in practice yet. Moreover, a number of projects have
been delayed in completion and in deviation from customers' contracts. Each
project has its own problems, going into detail, the above projects are as
follows:

FLC Diamond 72 Tower

-        Location: Tran Phu street, Ngo Quyen, Hai Phong province

-        Total area: 13,485 m2

- Total investment: 4,000 billion VND

-     

30
 

FLC's 72 Diamond Tower project has been invalidated due to delay in


procedures. This is FLC Group's project of a hotel complex, commercial
center and office for lease in Hai Phong, which has been decided by the City
People's Committee on investment policy on November 4, 2019. On May 8,
2020, FLC Group held a groundbreaking ceremony for the project and
pledged to focus all resources on completing the project quickly. However,
in practice, up to now, FLC Group has not implemented the “basic”
procedures to implement the project (Tien Thang, 2020).

FLC’s projects in Quang Tri

-        Location: Quang Tri

-        Total area 484ha

-        Total investment: 8,855 billion VND

31
FLC Group has been proposing to invest in the province 8 projects, of which 3
are tourism projects. However, after 3 years, most of the projects have not been
implemented yet. Based on the approved plan, FLC proposes to implement 3
eco-tourism projects in Trung Giang commune, Gio Linh district, including:
Gio Linh 1 eco-tourism project, Gio Linh 2 and Gio Linh 3 with total area
35.57ha, total investment capital of 1,303 billion VND. Chairman of the
Provincial People's Committee Vo Van Hung said the province has directed
local departments and agencies and mobilized people to create the most
favorable conditions for investors to implement the project. And Mr. Hung
emphasized that if FLC group is determined to implement the project as
committed on the progress, it is urgent to complete the remaining procedures to
start the implementation of the projects (Le Chi, 2020).

 2. Cause of problem: Change in initial plan and legal difficulty

Regarding the Diamond 72 Tower project, FLC Group's representative said


that, according to the initial planning plan of Hai Phong, the project's utility
items did not match the criteria of products and services , so it was difficult
to meet market demand, especially in the current changing market context.
Therefore, the investor has proposed to add a mixed function to the project
(additional adjustment of high-end apartments next to the office and hotel
block) to ensure efficiency and feasibility in operation. While waiting for the
response from the city, enterprises cannot implement related investment
procedures (Tran Luu, 2020).

Regarding projects in Quang Tri, the research shows that the implementation
of small projects is difficult to ensure uniformity, affecting the advantages of
the project. Site clearance work still faces many problems and a number of
other causes. FLC Group Chairman Trinh Van Quyet stated that the Group's
opinion is the determination to implement successful projects on a large
scale if receiving the cooperation agreement of Quang Tri province (Thanh
Truc, 2020).

32
3. Impact:

These issues can negatively affect the image of the FLC. As can be seen
from figure 1, FLC Group ranks 3rd in the top 10 prestigious real estate
companies in 2019. However, FLC's prestige is severely reduced when it is
out of the top 10 prestigious companies. in the year 2020 (figure 2). This
means that customers' confidence in FLC Group is decreasing. A decline in
reputation can lead to a decline in FLC's profit and reputation.

Top 10 Prestigious Real Estate Investors in 2019 (by Vietnam Report)

33
Figrue 1. Top 10 Prestigious Real Estate Investors in
2020 (by Vietnam Report)

 4. Solution:

Making a specific long-term plan before starting a new construction project


is essential. Preparing a specific plan and step-by-step helps forecast
potential business risks and establish specific timeframes for the activity.
This will eliminate mistakes or omissions that lead to a change in the
original plan and other complications. Therefore, the managers of FLC
Group should develop a detailed plan of activities within a specific
timeframe to avoid wasting time waiting for the license approval process and
reducing unnecessary risks.

X, CHALLENGES

a. REAL ESTATE

In the residential real estate sector, FLC is inferior to the names Vingroups,
Novaland or Khang Dien House,… FLC's outstanding residential real estate
project is FLC Complex Pham Hung; FLC Landmark Tower and a number

34
of ongoing projects such as FLC Star Tower; FLC Complex Thanh Hoa,…
These projects are only in the mid-range compared to projects that real estate
giants on the market are implementing (Quang Thang, 2020).

FLC's apartment and workplace projects are essentially found in the most
densely populated areas, mainly attracting many potential high-income
clients. Focusing on high-paying customers, FLC is competing fiercely with
competitors such as Vin Group, Hoa Phat, Bitexco Group, Ciputra Ha Noi,
CENLAND and Sun Group. While competitors are expanding their products
and services to promote the mid-end segment, FLC should have the right
plan to support and grow in the market.

b. BAMBOO AIRWAYS: COVID-19 - DEBTS AND LOSS

2020 was not a bright year since FLC Group's tourism, aviation, resort and
real estate businesses are all severely affected by the COVID-19 epidemic.

FLC Group has to cope with a new challenge: Pay their huge debts for the
brand new airline company which is known as Bamboo Airways. COVID-19
has forced the airline to reduce the number of its flights, leading to a loss of
more than VND1.5 trillion ($65.2 million) in this year’s first quarter. 

Similarly, many lenders claimed that this company has delayed many
payables. Bamboo Airways admitted it has encountered heavy financial
losses after over one year in the local aviation market. The local carrier is
still slow at making payments despite being reminded to pay its debts
multiple times. Many creditors including Airports Corporation of Vietnam
(ACV), Vietnam Air Traffic Management Corporation (VATM), Saigon
Ground Services Company and Hanoi Ground Service JSC from February to
early April had sent dozens of notices urging the airline to pay its debts
promptly, reported Dan Tri news site. The creditors also reported the late
payment issue to the Ministry of Transport. Since June last year, Bamboo
has regularly been late in paying flight-related service fees that it collected

35
on behalf of VATM. The debt that Bamboo Airways currently owes to
VATM is 38.6 billion VND, though VATM had asked the company to pay
the debt by the end of March, noted a VATM representative. Similarly, ACV
has sent 24 notices since May last year to urge the aviation subsidiary of
FLC Group to pay a total debt of over 205 billion VND, with overdue debt
reaching some 178 billion VND, but Bamboo Airways has been sluggish
with payments. Of the overdue debt, fees for security screening and services
supplied by ACV to passengers exceeded VND107 billion. The remaining
VND71 billion was the cost of ground and airport services provided to the
carrier by ACV, according to an ACV official. Following the Transport
Ministry’s order, the Civil Aviation Authority of Vietnam recently asked
Bamboo Airways to quickly report its debts, its payment plan for aviation
service providers and its financial situation. A Transport Ministry
representative on May 6 told the paper that Bamboo Airways had neither
paid the debt nor sent any reports.

In the light of enormous competitive pressure, an expanded business model


and a surge in gasoline prices, it can be seen that the chances of success of a
new competitor like Bamboo Airways will be very unpredictable.

 XI, SOLUTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

a. REAL ESTATE

First, FLC should continue to focus on investing in the current residential


real estate segment as its main product line in this market. FLC Group tends
to use a discount strategy aimed at targeting high customer segments with
high quality apartments in the center. Meanwhile, a number of rival groups
focus on many types to satisfy a wide range of customers. Therefore, to
compete with other strong competitors, FLC should deploy mid-range
housing to expand its product line and meet many different needs of
customers. Besides, FLC can cut newcomers by adopting a worthy
penetration strategy.

36
Moreover, when the land fund in big cities is decreasing significantly, FLC
can focus on exploiting suburban areas, small provinces where there are
many vacant land funds. According to forecasts in the coming years, the
urbanization rate will spread across the provinces and cities nationwide,
along with a strong increase of the middle class with about 50% of the
population living in urban areas. by 2020, so it opens up opportunities for
real estate businesses. FLC Group has a lot of real estate, mainly located in
the northern half, so it can focus on developing more in the south. Especially
the Southwest is always - where it has the highest average PCI score among
6 regions in the country continuously from 2014 to present. With great
potential and abundant development space, the South West is expected to
become the focus of the real estate market in the near future.

b. BAMBOO AIRWAYS:

FLC has a fast capital growth rate, with real estate investment projects in
resorts in many provinces of Vietnam. However, a corporation with a bad
reputation is not considered as a strong player in the game. Therefore, the
company should improve on their responsibilities of paying debts earlier by
boosting the company business operations, reducing operation cost and
promoting selling more products with an appropriate pricing strategy which
increases the revenue stream.3

In the case of Bamboo Airway, there are several problems surrounding the
Covid-19 pandemic which continues to happen. Here are our
recommendations on this challenge:

1. The company should make a  reserve fund for fluctuations and situations that
can not be predicted in the future.

2. Bamboo Airway should promote a pricing strategy which include a bundle


of discounting airline tickets, hotels room, resorts, other services to attract
more users and gain market shares

37
3. Third, the company should propose to the government on tax exemptions.

4. Fourth, the company should deal with creditors for debts rescheduling
because this time is quite hard and difficult for businesses to pay their debts
on time.

XII, CONCLUSION

In short, FLC Group Joint Stock Company is currently in the process of


rapid growth in quantity and importance and retains its leading role in
Vietnam as a non-public multi-line company. The FLC Company was
backed up in 2001 and probably a small multibillion-dollar developer in
most regions that it wanted to strategically enter. FLC actively innovates in
corporate development and consumer loyalty, but also included global social
well-being, with a strong knowledge of the macro world and real social
responsibility in Vietnam. The look. The look. In Vietnam, FLC Group aims,
in view of possible barriers and threats, to extend its business globally in
future. While the past year is a tough year with the post-translation
development prospects, for the Vietnamese economy in general and for the
FLC Group in particular, FLC Group has the potential to turn and open up.
Broad spectrum of operations.

38
XII, Reference Lists:

Báo cáo từ Reputa về ngành Bất động sản Việt Nam dựa trên Social
Listening, Quý 2 năm 2020. (2020, August 27). Retrieved December 02,
2020, from https://blog.tomorrowmarketers.org/bao-cao-nganh-bat-dong-
san-viet-nam-quy-2-nam-2020/

Biz Hub. (2019). FLC Group to build 24 projects in Quang Ninh. Retrieved
13 December 2020, from http://bizhub.vn/property/flc-group-to-build-24-
projects-in-quang-ninh_303494.html

Công bố Top 10 Công ty uy tín ngành Bất động sản năm 2019. (2019).
Retrieved December 02, 2020, from https://toptenvietnam.vn/Cong-bo-Top-
10-Cong-ty-uy-tin-nganh-Bat-dong-san-nam-2019-8355-1006.html

Công bố Top 10 Công ty uy tín ngành Bất động sản năm 2020. (2020).
Retrieved December 02, 2020, from https://vietnamreport.net.vn/Cong-bo-
Top-10-Cong-ty-uy-tin-nganh-Bat-dong-san-nam-2020-9146-1006.html

Dương, Á. (2019). FLC Tropical City Ha Long tràn ngập sắc xanh sau sự
kiện Go Green 2019. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from https://cafef.vn/flc-
tropical-city-ha-long-tran-ngap-sac-xanh-sau-su-kien-go-green-2019-
20190403142233664.chn

Đình Hiếu, T. (2019). FLC Group - Tất Tần Tật Thông Tin - Top 3 dự án
2020| SALEREAL. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from
https://salereal.com.vn/flc-group/

FLC : Công ty cổ phần Tập đoàn FLC: Công ty con - Công ty liên kết.
(2020). Retrieved December 02, 2020, from

39
http://s.cafef.vn/hose/FLC/cong-ty-con.chnhttp://s.cafef.vn/hose/FLC/cong-
ty-con.chn

FLC Group – Vietnam’s ‘Land Genie’ to go international - Vietnam News |


Politics, Business, Economy, Society, Life, Sports - VietNam News. (2019).
Retrieved 13 December 2020, from https://vietnamnews.vn/flc-group-
%E2%80%93-vietnams-land-genie-to-go-international/288

FLC, G. (2020). About FLC. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from


https://www.linkedin.com/company/flc-group/about/

FLC. (2017). FLC Group – Vietnam’s ‘Land Genie’ to go international -


Vietnam News | Politics, Business, Economy, Society, Life, Sports -
VietNam News. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from
https://vietnamnews.vn/flc-group-%e2%80%93-vietnams-land-genie-to-go-
international/288

Hà, H. (2020). Tập đoàn FLC: Hành trình “đánh thức” những tiềm năng.
Retrieved 13 December 2020, from
https://nhipsongdoanhnghiep.cuocsongantoan.vn/dia-oc/tap-doan-flc-hanh-
trinh-danh-thuc-nhung-tiem-nang-3546949.html

Haigh, D. (2016). Vietnam 50 2016. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from


https://brandirectory.com/download-
report/20160911_bf_vietnam_2016_en.pdf

Hồng, T. (2019). Tập đoàn FLC đoạt cúp vàng tại International Business
Awards 2019. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from
https://thanhtra.com.vn/kinh-te/bat-dong-san/Tap-doan-FLC-doat-cup-vang-
tai-International-Business-Awards-2019-155570.html

Le Chi. (2020). Chủ tịch tỉnh Quảng Trị: 'Hầu hết các dự án của FLC đề xuất
vẫn chưa được thực hiện'. Retrieved from https://vietnamfinance.vn/chu-
tich-tinh-quang-tri-hau-het-cac-du-an-cua-flc-de-xuat-van-chua-duoc-thuc-
hien-20180504224243643.htm

40
Le, C. (2019). The Guide Awards 2019: Sức bật du lịch Việt Nam – Nhìn từ
nỗ lực của khu vực tư nhân. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from
https://leisure-travel.vn/du-lich/tin-tuc-du-lich/the-guide-awards-2019-suc-
bat-du-lich-viet-nam-nhin-tu-no-luc-cua-khu-vuc-tu-nhan/

Lĩnh vực đầu tư. (n.d.). Retrieved December 02, 2020, from
https://www.flc.vn/linh-vuc-dau-tu/

Linh, L. (2020). FLC ước lãi gần 600 tỷ đồng quý III/ 2020. Retrieved 13
December 2020, from http://cand.com.vn/doanh-nghiep/FLC-uoc-lai-gan-
600-ty-dong-quy-III-2020-617951/

Nam, H. (2020, June 06). Thị trường bất động sản 2020 sẽ dịch chuyển ra
sao? Retrieved December 02, 2020, from https://reatimes.vn/thi-truong-bat-
dong-san-2020-se-dich-chuyen-ra-sao-20200606095307818.html

Ngan, H. (2020, October 30). Thị trường bất động sản 2020: Khoảng lặng
tạm thời. Retrieved November 25, 2020, from https://vneconomy.vn/thi-
truong-bat-dong-san-2020-khoang-lang-tam-thoi-20201030004055963.htm

Nguyen, M. (2020, September 09). Thị trường bất động sản Việt Nam:
Khoảng lặng để nâng cấp. Retrieved November 25, 2020, from
http://tapchitaichinh.vn/thi-truong-tai-chinh/thi-truong-bat-dong-san-viet-
nam-khoang-lang-de-nang-cap-327624.html

Người Việt tăng chi cho du lịch nghỉ dưỡng | VAKALAND. (2020).
Retrieved 13 December 2020, from https://vakaland.vn/nguoi-viet-tang-chi-
cho-du-lich-nghi-duong/

Quang Thang. (2020). Nợ nần của FLC ra sao?. Retrieved from


https://zingnews.vn/no-nan-cua-flc-ra-sao-post867464.html

Son, M. (2020). FLC Group’s shares of Bamboo Airways down by half -


VnExpress International. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from

41
https://e.vnexpress.net/news/business/companies/flc-group-s-shares-of-
bamboo-airways-down-by-half-4047310.html

Tập đoàn FLC giành “cú đúp” Giải thưởng Du lịch Việt Nam 2019. (2019).
Retrieved 13 December 2020, from https://baotainguyenmoitruong.vn/tap-
doan-flc-gianh-cu-dup-giai-thuong-du-lich-viet-nam-2019-251716.html

Tien Thang. (2020). Hải Phòng dừng dự án xây tòa tháp 72 tầng của FLC vì
chậm làm thủ tục. Retrieved from https://tuoitre.vn/hai-phong-dung-du-an-
xay-toa-thap-72-tang-cua-flc-vi-cham-lam-thu-tuc-20201123170517532.htm

Thanh Truc. (2020). Bao Quang Tri : Các dự án của Tập đoàn FLC trên địa
bàn Quảng Trị: Đề xuất của nhà đầu tư và phương án xử lý của tỉnh.
Retrieved from http://baoquangtri.vn/Th%C6%A1%CC%80i-s
%C6%B0%CC%A3/modid/445/ItemID/153711

Tran Luu. (2020). Hải Phòng 'khai tử' dự án FLC Diamond 72 Tower trị giá
hơn 3.472 tỷ đồng. Retrieved from https://vietnamfinance.vn/hai-phong-
khai-tu-du-an-flc-diamond-72-tower-tri-gia-hon-3472-ty-dong-
20180504224246399.htm

Trung, T. (2019). FLC lọt Top 10 chủ đầu tư hàng đầu tại BCI Asia Awards.
Retrieved 13 December 2020, from https://bnews.vn/flc-lot-top-10-chu-dau-
tu-hang-dau-tai-bci-asia-awards/124085.html

Universal, T. (2019). VISION - MISSION - CORE VALUES. Retrieved 13


December 2020, from

Vu, A. (2020). Thị trường bất động sản phục hồi mạnh mẽ và nhiều tín hiệu
lạc quan. Retrieved 13 December 2020, from http://tapchitaichinh.vn/thi-
truong-tai-chinh/thi-truong-bat-dong-san-phuc-hoi-manh-me-va-nhieu-tin-
hieu-lac-quan-329844.html

Vu, A. (2020, June 28). Nhìn lại "biến cố" nửa đầu năm 2020 của thị trường
bất động sản. Retrieved November 25, 2020, from https://reatimes.vn/nhin-

42
lai-bien-co-nua-dau-nam-2020-cua-thi-truong-bat-dong-san-
20200626153056037.html

43

You might also like