Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UNIT-I
Define system.
A collection of objects or equipment arranged in a predetermined procedure to perform one
or more operation is called as system
Define process
It is a Physical or chemical change of matter or conversion of energy; (e.g., change in
pressure, temperature, speed, electrical potential,) carried out in a system as per a procedure
to achieve a predetermined result.
Define process control
It is the regulation or manipulation of variables influencing the conduct of a process in such
a way as to obtain a product of desired quality and quantity in an efficient manner
Why we need process control
To ensure safety in the work environment.
Operability: To ensure that particular flows and holdup are maintained at chosen values
within operating ranges.
To control product quality, process energy consumption etc. Production rate
To have pollution control and Environmental regulations
List the steps in process control
a)Measurement-means of sensor b) Comparison-means of comparator
c)Computation-means of controller d) Correction-means of final control element
Define mathematical modeling and mathematical model
A Procedure by which the physical system or a process is represented in terms of
mathematical equation is called as modeling of process
The mathematical equations that represent the process is called as mathematical model
Why you need mathematical model of a system
To analyse the system behavior for various test signals this is difficult in the real system.
To test and study the system characteristics for various environmental conditions this may
lead to hazardous condition if done with real time system.
List the various methods of modeling a system
A physical system can be represented in terms of
(i) Representation in differential equation
(ii)Representation in Laplace transformation as transfer functions
(iii) Representation as state space equation
List the assumptions done while modeling a thermal system
1. The system is thermally shielded against thermal losses such as conduction,
convection and radiation.
2. The contents of the tank are stirred well for uniform distribution of heat.
3. There is no heat generated or absorbed by the system on its own.
4. The temperature of tank content and outflow mass are considered to be same.
Write any two characteristics of first order process modeling
The first order process are characterized by :
1. Their capacity to store material, energy, or momentum
2. The resistance associated with the flow of mass, energy, or momentum in reaching the
capacity.
Thus the dynamic response of tanks that have the capacity to store liquids or gases can be
modeled as first order. The resistance is associated with pumps , valves, weirs and pipes
which are attached to the inflowing or outflowing liquids or gases.
What is meant by non-self regulation ?
Some process ( especially pure capacity process) may not have the tendency to adopt a
specific value of the controlled variable for nominal load with no control operation. Such a
process is known as ‘non-self-regulation’. If any small change in the flow rate of the inlet
stream will make the tank flood or drain in the case of a pure capacity process (example : a
tank with constant displacement pump at the outlet )
Define non-interacting system and give an example.
In the system shown below, tank1 feeds tank2 and thus its affects the dynamic behaviour of
tank2, whereas the reverse ( ie tank2 does not affect the dynamic behaviour of tank1 ) is not
true. Such system is characteristics of non-interacting capacities or non-interacting first
order systems in series.
Mathematically;
f =V −E
A tank operating at 3 m head, 5 lpm outflow through a valve and the tank has a cross
sectional area of 2 square meter . Calculate the time constant?
The time constant τp = Resistance to flow X storage capacity
= h / F X storage capacity = 3m / 5 lpm X 2 m2
= 3 m / (0.005 m3 / min) X 2 m2 = 1200 min
The flow rate through an exist pipe Fo in m3 / sec is given by the relation Fo = 0.6 √h
where 'h' is the tank level in meter . Find the time constant ιp for the steady state levels
of 2 m and 5 m. Cross sectional area of the tank A is 2 m2 .
The time constant τp = 2A √hs / β for the relation Fo = β√h
For hs = 2 m τp = 2 x 2 x √2 / 0.6 = 9.43 sec
For hs = 5 m τp = 2 x 2 x √5 / 0.6 = 14.9 sec
Give the transfer function of two tank interacting liquid level system or parallel two
tank liquid level system
Give the transfer function of two tank non interacting liquid level system or series two
tank liquid level system
What do you meant by self regulating system and give one example
A system when disturbed from its normal working condition by some means and then attains
a steady state condition on its own in open loop condition is called as self regulating system.
Eg: simple liquid level system.
Define non self regulating system and give one example
A system when disturbed from its normal working condition by some means and then does
not attains a steady state condition on its own in open loop condition is called as non self
regulating system. Eg: liquid level system with constant discharge
Define transfer function of a system
It is the Laplace transformation of ratio between the system output with the system input at
zero initial conditions.
Define dead time or delay time
The time taken by the system to response for a change in its input is called as dead time or
delay time
What are the effects of dead time
The presence of dead time may cause the controller to take wrong decision and it may go to
its maximum output condition and results in affecting the stability of the system that may
cause very dangerous effects and bring unsafe condition to the system
UNIT-II
Cavitations occurs in control valve when the inflow liquid pressure goes below the vapour
pressure of the liquid resulting in the formation of voids and cavities within the liquid
system; and then there will be a collapse or implosion of this cavities back into in all-liquid
state.
Give the conditions for cavitations in control valve
Cavitations in control valve occurs when
(i) The fluid at both the inlet and outlet must be in all-liquid condition.
(ii)The liquid must be sub cooled state at the inlet, because if the liquid will be in a
saturated state, then any pressure drop across the valve will cause the presence of
vapor downstream;
(iii) The valve outlet pressure must be either at or above the vapor pressure of the liquid.
List the effects of cavitations
Following are the effects of cavitations
1. Noise: At fully developed cavitations it sounds like a gravel passes through the valve;
2. Vibration: There occurs vibration depending on the mass of the system, how well the
system components are anchored, whether valve-mounted instruments are vibration-
sensitive.
3. Material Damage: Damage of valve plugs, development of eroded holes through the
valve body, damage of the guiding surfaces and valve plug seating surfaces, etc.
What do you meant by flashing?
Flashing occurs in control valve when the inflow liquid pressure goes below the vapour
pressure of the liquid resulting in the formation of voids and cavities within the liquid
system. If the pressure downstream of the valve continues to be in a value below the liquid’s
vapor pressure, the vapor bubbles persist in the liquid. This is called as flashing.
Give the conditions for flashing in control valve
Flashing in control valve occurs when
1. The fluid at the inlet must be in all-liquid condition, but some vapor must be present at
the valve outlet;
2. The fluid at the inlet may be in either a saturated or a sub cooled condition;
3. The valve outlet pressure must be either at or below the vapor pressure of the liquid.
The pressure drop at which choked flow begins is called the terminal pressure drop.
CAVITATIONS:-Cavitations occurs in control valve when the inflow liquid pressure goes
below the vapour pressure of the liquid resulting in the formation of voids and cavities
within the liquid system; and then there will be a collapse or implosion of this cavities back
into in all-liquid state.
CAVITATIONS IN CONTROL VALVE OCCURS WHEN
(i)The fluid at both the inlet and outlet must be in all-liquid condition.
(ii)The liquid must be sub cooled state at the inlet, because if the liquid will be in a
saturated state, then any pressure drop across the valve will cause the presence of vapor
downstream;
(iii) The valve outlet pressure must be either at or above the vapor pressure of the liquid.
EFFECTS OF CAVITATIONS:-
1. Noise: At fully developed cavitations it sounds like a gravel passes through the valve;
2. Vibration: There occurs vibration depending on the mass of the system, how well the
system components are anchored, whether valve-mounted instruments are vibration-
sensitive.
3. Material Damage: Damage of valve plugs, development of eroded holes through the
valve body, damage of the guiding surfaces and valve plug seating surfaces, etc.
FLASHING:Flashing occurs in control valve when the inflow liquid pressure goes below
the vapour pressure of the liquid resulting in the formation of voids and cavities within the
liquid system. If the pressure downstream of the valve continues to be in a value below the
liquid’s vapor pressure, the vapor bubbles persist in the liquid. This is called as flashing.
FLASHING IN CONTROL VALVE OCCURS WHEN
1. The fluid at the inlet must be in all-liquid condition, but some vapor must be present at
the valve outlet;
2. The fluid at the inlet may be in either a saturated or a sub cooled condition;
3. The valve outlet pressure must be either at or below the vapor pressure of the liquid.
EFFECTS OF FLASHING
1. Material damage is associated with the formation of sand-blasted surfaces;
2. Decreased efficiency, i.e., it reduces the ability of the valve to convert pressure drop
across the valve into mass flow rate.
STEPS TO AVOID CAVITATIONS AND FLASHING
1. Ensuring by suitable arrangements that the flow liquid pressure does not goes below its
vapour pressure value.
2. By connecting large volume tanks closer to the valves so that the there will not be
significant pressure changes in the liquid flowing through the valve
3. By following special design procedures for the inner flow areas of valve so that the liquid
entering the valve does not undergoes a sudden pressure loss but there will be a gradual
decrease in the liquid pressure.
Discuss in detail about the points to be considered in selecting a control valve
Following are the points to be considered while selecting the control valve
1.Need for a control valve:Before going through the valve selection process, it should be
decided whether a control valve is really needed in the work place or not.
2.Process Data Collection:The anticipated values of flow rates, pressures, vapour pressure,
density of flowing medium, temperatures, viscosities etc must be identified considered in the
selection process.
3.Assigning valve pressure drop: The proper approach to the selection of valve pressure
drop is to first determine the total friction drop of the system at normal flow and assign 50%
of that to valve pressure drop and then to determine the resulting valve drop at minimum and
maximum flows and select a valve which can handle the required CV rangeability.
4.Control valve performance: the control valve performance inters of following factors
such as valve characteristics, control loop gain, process non linearity, valve rangeability and
control valve sizing should be considered.
5.Process applications considerations: The properties of the process liquid must be
fully considered. The factors such as high pressure service, high differential pressure
usage, vacuum service, high/low temperature service, cavitations and erosion,
flashing, viscous and slurry service leakage, noise, piping and installation, climatic
and atmospheric effect should be considered.
Define normal maximum flow rate
It is the maximum value of flow rate required to sustain the controlled variable under any
condition of process operation.
Define valve characteristic co-efficient (α)
Differential pressure with control valve wide open
α=
Differential pressure withcontrol valve closed
Define rangeablility of control valve.
Rangeability of a control valve is the ratio maximum controllable flow to minimum
controllable flow
Maximum controllable flow
R=
Minimum controllable flow
Define turndown of a control valve and give its relation with rangeability
Turndown of a control valve is the ratio of normal maximum flow to minimum controllable
flow
Normal maximum flow
T=
Minimum controllable flow
The relation between turndown and rageability of a control valve is given as
T ≅ 0.7 R
Compare inherent and installed characteristics
S.NO inherent characteristics installed characteristics
1 The flow-lift characteristics are The flow-lift characteristics are obtained for a
obtained for a valve at standard valve at installed conditions in its work
test conditions. environement
2 It is also called as ideal It is also called as practical characteristics.
characteristics
3 There will not be any external The valve is influenced by many disturbing
disturbance parameters acting parameters usually and also when obtaining the
on the valve while obtaining the characteristics.
characteristics
Compare electrical actuator and pneumatic actuator
S.No Electrical actuator Pneumatic actuator
1. It is an electrically operated It is an pneumatically operated device
device
2. Electrical coils or motors are Elastic membranes such as diaphragms, bellows
used to drive the control valve are used to drive the control valve
3 Rarely used type of actuators Generally preferred type of actuators
Explain the working of control valve
Control valve is a valve with a pneumatic, hydraulic, electric or other externally powered
actuator that automatically, opens or closes the valve to either a fully or partially position
according to the control signals given by the controller.
The major parts of control valve are
Actuator: The part of control valve which receives control signal to open or close the
control valve. Generally actuators are operated by pneumatic signal made up of elastic
diaphragms.
There are also electrical type actuators available with motors for same operation.
Stem: A long moving part of the control valve connected with the actuator at one end and
with valve plug at other end the stem is operated by the actuator to open and close the valve.
Plug: A specially designed mechanical part of control valve connected with one end of the
valve stem that closes and opens the flow path inside the control valve proportional to
control signal.
The shape of the plug determines the outflow rate of valve and the valves are classified
based on the plug shape generally.
Spring: It is connected with stem below the actuator in order to provide counter balancing
force for the deflection in actuator to move the stem to its exact position.
The spring also plays a main role in making the stem to return back to its original position
when the applied control signal is removed.
Input/output port: The part through which the valve is connected with other parts of the
flow line and through which the liquid enters and leaves the valve.
Working: The control valve actuator receives signal from controller and drives the stem
with plug to move, the stem is now moved to the exact new position with the help of counter
balance force offered by spring
The movement of stem and plug opens the flow path in the control valve and allows the
water to flow through the valve.
When the control signal to the valve is altered or removed the spring along with the actuator
reposition the plug connected with stem to establish the new flow rate through the valve.
Define equal percentage valve and give its applications
It is the most commonly used control valve, in this type of valve equal increments of valve
travel produce an equal percentage of flow through it.
Here the valve co-efficient characteristic function is given by f ( x )=α x−1
Applications: 1. Used in processes where large changes in pressure drop are expected
2. Used in process applications where small percentage of the total pressure drop is
permitted by the valve
Define linear valve and give its applications
In this type the valve travel and valve stroke are in direct proportion.
Here the valve co-efficient characteristic function is given by f(x)=x
Applications: 1. Used in systems where the pressure drop across the valve is expected to
remain fairly constant
Define quick opening valve
In this type of valve a large increase in flow can be observed with small changes in valve
stroke.
Applications: 1. Used for process where instant large flow is required.
2. Used for frequent on/off service
Compare single seated valve and double seated valve
S.N SINGLE SEATED VALVE DOUBLE SEATED VALVE
O
1. It has one plug These type has two plugs
2. Provides satisfactory shut off Provides tight shut off
What are the different shapes of plugs used in a control valve and give its shape
The different shapes of plugs used in a control valve are
An equal percentage control valve has a rangeability of 32. If the maximum flow rate is
100 m3 / hr, find the flow at 2/3 rd and 4/5 th opening.
Minimum flow rate = maximum flow rate / rangeability = 100 / 32 = 3.125 m3 / hr
Then flow rate at 2/3 opening is Q = Qmin R( S/Smax ) = 3.125 X (32 ) (2/3) = 31.5 m3/hr
Then flow rate at 4/5 opening is Q = Qmin R( S/Smax ) = 3.125 X (32 ) (4/5) = 50 m3/hr
What is meant by control valve sizing ?
The proper selection of the size of a control valve for the given specific process parameters is
known as ‘Valve sizing ‘. Guidelines for sizing of control valve are
a. The valve shall be sized for normal maximum flow rate which is normally about 70 % of
the ultimate design capacity.
b. Most of the pressure drop of the system should be across the control valve. As a general
rule around 70 % of the system drop should be across the control valve.
c. When the pipeline is dimensioned with normal allowable velocities ( low pressure loss )
the control valve will be few sizes smaller than the pipeline. Only in the extreme case
where very high velocities have been used in the pipeline, the size of the control valve
will be same as that of the pipeline.
d. The final selection must be done such that the calculated Cv is attained at about 75 to 80
% of the full valve travel. In case of high pressure gases and steam where expansion take
place after the control valve, calculated Cv must be attained at about 50 to 60 % of the
valve travel.
Why the control valve is a non linear in characteristics?
The non linearity is normally caused due to :
a. The non linear spring response
b. Nonlinear effective area of the diaphragm as it deflects.
c. The changing thrust forces that act on the movement of the plug in the controlled fluid.
Differentiate between air-to-close and air-to-open control valve?
In the air-to-close valve , as the air pressure above diagram increases, the stem moves down
and consequently the plug restricts the flow through the orifice. In the air-to-open valve , as
the air pressure above diagram increases, the stem moves down and consequently the plug
allows the flow through the orifice.
What is the use of I/P converter ?
The current –to-pneumatic converter or I / P converter is an important element in the process
control. Often, when we want to use the low level electric current signal to do work, it is
much easier to let the work be done by a pneumatic signal. The I / P converter gives us linear
way of transulating 4 – 20 mA current into a 3 – 15 psi signal. The I/P converter uses
Flapper – nozzle system for this purpose.
Suppose a force of 600 N must be applied to open a valve using pneumatic diaphragm
actuator. Find the diaphragm area if a control gauge pressure of 0.7 kg/ cm2 must
provide this force.
We may calculate the area from the formula
Force = Pressure X Area
Area = Force / Pressure = 600 N / 0.7 Kg / cm2
= 600 N / 7 N / cm2 = 85.7 cm2
Or about 10.5 cm in diameter.
When should a positioner be fitted on a control valve.?
A positioner should be considered in the following circumstances
a. When accurate valve positioning is required.
b. To speed up the valve response.
c. To increase the pressure that a particular actuator and valve can close against ( to act
as an amplifier )
d. When friction in the valve ( especially the packing ) would cause unacceptable
hysteresis
e. To linearise a non-linear actuator.
f. Where varying differential pressures within the fluid would cause the plug position to
vary.
Give the classifications of Control Valve
C O N T R O L V A L V E C L A S S I F IC A T I O N S
B A S E D O N O P E R A T IO N B A S E D O N S E N S I T IV IT Y
B A SED O N N U M B ER O F P LU G S
A IR T O O P E N A IR T O C L O S E IN C R E A S I N G D E C R E A S IN G
S E N S IT IV IT Y S E N S I T IV IT Y
L IN E A R S IN G L E THREE
SEA TED SEATED
D O U B LE
B A SED O N V A LV E B O D Y SEATED
S L I D IN G DAM PERS/
STEM LO U V ER S
RO TARY
STEM
Step 6: Calculate Valve Reynolds Number Rev and Reynolds Number Factor FR
Step 9: Calculate the Final Cv Using the value of FP, calculate the required
ma
u(t)
x U(0)
u(t) mi
n
- u(t +
Proporti e(t)
e onal ) e
band
0 0
Define reverse acting controller?
For increase in error magnitude if the controller output decreases instead of increase then the
controller is called as reverse acting controller.
m (t)
m a x m (t)
m in
m (t)
-e 0 +e0
-e (t) e (t)
What is meant by differential gap or neutral zone or dead zone or bandwidth in ON –
OFF controller?
It is the region above and below the set point of the controlled process variable in which the
controller does not response to any changes in the controlled process variable.
Discuss about merits of on-off controller
1. Design and implementation is very simple
2. Low cost
Give the draw backs of on-off controller
1. It will not give accurate control over the process.
2. It cannot be used in places where accurate control is needed since it has only two states.
Why differential controller cannot be used alone?
1. The differential controller will not produce any output for constant error and error signal
that changes at constant rate.
2. Also the differential controller response will not be in one to one correspondence for error
and it takes decision by comparing the previous state error value.
Why integral controller cannot be used alone?
The output of integral controller is based on summation of error for specified time, the
controller will not respond instantaneously for changes hence it cannot be used alone
Why derivative controller should not be used for noisy process
When used in process with harmonic noises the harmonic component of the noise signal that
are associated with the error will amplify the magnitude of the error signal.
Let the error signal associated with harmonic component can be given as
e h (t)=sin awt
d eh (t )
=a cos awt
dt
Here the error signal is amplified by ‘a’ times.
Give the mathematical equation of ON-OFF controller and PID controller
ON-OFF CONTROLLER
m (t) = 100; e(t)>0
= 0; e (t) ≤0
PID CONTROLLER
1 de (t)
{
m ( t )=K C e ( t ) +
Ti
∫ e ( t ) dt +T D
dt } + mo
As shown above for every Ti the controller output is integral multiples of Kc hence the
integral controller is called as reset controller.
Explain in detail about ON-OFF CONTROLLER
It is a two state controller has its output as either ON state else OFF state that works
according to the equation mentioned below
m (t) = 100; e(t)>0
1 ; e (t) ≤0
The controller remains ON when the process variable under control is below the set point
and remains OFF when the process variable is above the set point as shown below
P .V
s .p
t
C O
O N 1 0 0 %
O F F 0 %
t
Disadvantages
The controller has a drawback that it switches at faster rate so more wear and tear occurs and
reduces the life time of the controller
Advantages
1. Cheaper in cost
2. Simpler in construction
On-off controller with neutral zone(OR) hysteresis effect in on-off controller
Since the on-off controller switches very fast the life time of the controller is small in order
to overcome this problem the zone called neutral zone is introduced in the control action of
the controller.
The working of the controller is as shown in the figure
Neutral zone:
The zone above and below the set point value in which the on-off controller retaining its
previous state output even the magnitude of the error changes is called as neutral zone
The value of the neutral zone will be a maximum ±5% of set point
It is also called as dead band or neutral band or bandwidth or differential gap of the on-off
controller
Bandwidth:
The total length of the neutral zone of the on-ff controller is called as bandwidth of the
on-off controller.
Hysteresis in on-off controller
co
100%
0%
x' error
Hysteresis exists in on-off controller with neutral zone. Because the controller output
does not remains same for the particular magnitude of the error.
The reason for hysteresis is the controller output is based not only upon the magnitude of
error but also position of error in the neutral zone.
Hence it can be observed for the same magnitude of error
The controller may be found ON at certain points i.e., when the process variable move
towards the upper limit of the dead zone and
The controller in OFF state at certain points i.e., when the process variable move towards
the lower limit of the dead zone. Hence we say there exist hysteresis in ON-OFF
controller
Advantages
1. Controller life time is increased due introduction of neutral zone
2. Cheaper in cost
3. Simpler in construction
Disadvantages
1. There is no accurate control over the process.
2. It makes the system response oscillatory
ON-OFF controller applications:
1. It is used in places where accurate control action is not required
Example: Temperature control in a home water heater
PROPOTIONAL CONTROLLER (Throttling Controller):
e (t) m (t)= K ce (t)
K C
Proportional control is the primary alternative to on-off control
Simplest and most commonly encountered of all continuous control modes.
The controller produces an output signal, which is proportional to the error.
The Greater the magnitude of the error, the larger is the corrective action applied by the
controller
The gain of the controller is given as Kc
Output equation of P-controller can be given as
In Time domain
m ( t )=K C e ( t ) +m 0
• The PB is generally centered on the set point causing the output to be at 50% when the
set point and the process output are equal.
INTEGRAL GAIN (KI): It is the gain of the integral controller expressed as KI = 1/Ti;
unit = sec-1
INTEGRAL TIME or RESET TIME (Ti): It is the time taken by the integral controller to
repeat the action of the proportional controller the integral, or reset time (T i), may be
expressed in terms of:
• Repeats Per Minute - How many times the proportional action is repeated each
minute.
• Minutes Per Repeat - How many minutes are required for1 repeat to occur.
Generally Ti is represented in terms of repeats per minute
Advantages:
Eliminate the proportional offset over time.
Disadvantages:
1. Integral control changes the order of the system, so a second order system becomes a
third order system when you use an integral controller.
2. Integral control produces a slower system because of the pole(s) constrained to the right of
the rightmost pole in the system.
3. Adding integral control to a system may sacrifice speed of response, and even stability, for
the sake of zero SSE.
4. Integral wind-up
5. P+I give rise to a higher maximum deviation, a longer response time and a longer period
of oscillation than with proportional action alone.
INTEGRAL WIND-UP
Since the integral function is accumulating proportional offset over time, the accumulated
value will tend to increase as long as the offset is positive (above set point) and decrease
when the offset is negative (below set point).
If the equipment controlled by the control loop does not have the “muscle” to eventually
force the offset to be negative, the controller will simply keep accumulating positive
offset, resulting in a huge accumulated value.
This will drive the output of the control loop to its maximum value and it will remain
there until conditions change to the point where the system can recover and force the
offset to be negative and the negative offset has been big enough and lasted long enough
to bring the accumulated positive value back down.
This is generally called as integral windup
PURE DERIVATIVE CONTROL (RATE CONTROLLER (OR) PRE-ACT
CONTROLLER)
In derivative action, the controller output is proportional to the rate of change of the
measurement or error; it does not know what the set point actually is, hence it is called as
rate controller.
The controller first compares the current PV with the (previous) last value of the PV. If
there is a change in the slope of the PV, the controller determines what its output would
be at a future point in time and immediately increases /decreases the output by that
amount.
Generally used in large process where a step change in the input of the process is not
significant
The controller gain is given by Kd = Td; Unit=Seconds
Pure derivative mode cannot be used in real time and must be combined with proportional
mode
The output equation of the controller can be given as
In time domain:
de (t)
m ( t )= +mo
dt
Output of controller
• The derivative action is used wherever there is a change in the rate of change of the
error since the controller will not response to constant input or input changing at a
constant rate
Derivative mode output for constant change in error input
In time domain:
1
{
m ( t )=K C e ( t ) +
Ti∫ }
e ( t ) dt +mo
In Laplace domain
m(s ) 1
Gc ( s )= =K C [1+ ]
e (s ) TiS
Where,
1/Ti= Integral gain(KI); Ti = Reset time; KC= Proprotional gain; mo = Bias;
e(t) = error
The controller can be electronically given as
In time domain:
de(t )
{
m ( t )=K C e ( t ) +T D
dt } +mo
In Laplace domain
m(s )
Gc ( s )= =K C [1+T d S]
e (s )
Where,
Td= derivative time or derivative gain (KD); KC= Proportional gain; mo = Bias;
e(t) = error
The controller can be electronically given as
ADVANTAGES
1. Due to derivative action a lead term is introduced in the loop this compensate
the lag in the process loop
2. P+D mode eliminates excessive oscillations
3. Offset is not eliminated
DISADVANTAGES
1. It can not eliminate the offset but makes it smaller
In Laplace domain
m(s) 1
G C ( s )= =K C [1+ +T D S ]
e (s) Ti S
Where,
KC= Proportional gain
1/Ti= Integral gain(KI); Ti = Reset time;
Td= derivative time or derivative gain (KD)
mo = Bias;
e(t) = error
VELOCITY FORM:
UNIT-IV
Define evaluation criteria (2 marks)
The performance of the process for the implemented control action or the strategy and
parameter values of the controller is analysed to verify the proper selection and
implementation of the controller by evaluating certain process parameters is termed as
evaluation criteria
List the various methods of evaluation criteria (2 marks)
E V A L U A T IO N C R IT E R IA
S T E A D Y S T A T E P E R F O R M A N C E C R IT E R IA D Y N A M IC R E S P O N S E P E R F O R M A N C E C R IT E R IA
S IM P L E P E R F O R M A N C E C R IT E R IA T IM E IN T E G R A L P E R F O R M A N C E C R IT E R IA
IN T E G R A L S Q U A R E E R R O R IN T E G R A L O F T IM E W E IG H T E D
C R IT E R IO N ( IS E ) A B S O L U T E E R R O R ( IT A E )
IN T E G R A L O F A B S O L U T E V A L U E O F
E R R O R C R IT E R IO N ( IA E )
Give the role of evaluation criteria (2 marks)
i. Evaluation criteria plays a vital role in anlaysing the behavior of process for a particular set
of controller gains (KP, KI , KD)
ii. It helps to select proper controller gain values (KP, KI , KD) for a process so that optimum
control can be implemented for the process.
DISCUSS IN DETAIL ABOUT EVALUATION CRITERIA
The performance of the process for the implemented control action or the strategy and
parameter values of the controller is analysed to verify the proper selection and
implementation of the controller by evaluating certain process parameters is termed as
evaluation criteria
Evaluation criteria can be broadly classified into two types as
1. Steady state performance criteria
2. Dynamic response performance criteria
1.Steady state performance criteria: Here the error in the process is accounted, according
to the criteria the steady state error eSS of the process should be zero, for the implemented
control action and controller parameters.
2.Dynamic response performance criteria: This criteria is carried out in two different
ways as described follows
(i)Simple performance criteria:
few parameters of the process is considered and only approximate
The parameters considered are as follows
i. Overshoot, ii. Rise time, iii. Settling time, iv. Decay ratio, v. Frequency of oscillation
in transient
All the above parameter should posses’ minimum value including the decay ratio value to
be ¼ for considering the controller and its parameter to best selection
Also referred as isolated characteristics anlaysis
(ii)Time-Integral performance criteria:
The entire response of the process from time, t=0 is considered for analyzing the
controller characteristics
Give accurate analysis of the controller
The performance is analysed in the following three ways
(a)Integral of the square error (ISE):
x
ISE=∫ e 2 ( t ) dt
0
Used in system where we want strongly suppress large error, because the errors are
squared and thus contribute more to the value of the integral.
It should not be used for analyzing process with small magnitude of errors.
(b)Integral of the absolute value of the error (IAE):
x
IAE=∫ |e (t)|dt
0
Used to suppress small errors, squaring of errors makes them smaller for smaller magnitude,
like 0.01
(c)Integral of the time weighted absolute error (ITAE):
x
ITAE=∫ t |e (t)|dt
0
Used to suppress error that persist for long time, since the presence of the time ‘t’ in equation
multiplies the smaller magnitude error and makes it significant
The above time integral criteria’s is considered for analysis based upon the characteristics of
the system, level of accuracy required.
Each criterion is gives to a different controller design with different system output.
The system output for the controller designed based on ISE will not be same with the
controller designed with IAE and also with ITAE.
How would you select the most appropriate out of the three time integral criteria ISE,
IAE and ITAE for a particular application ?
To suppress errors that persist for long times, the ITAE criterion will tune the
controllers better because the presence of large t amplifies the effect of even
small errors in the value of the integral.
If we want to strongly suppress large errors, ISE is better than IAE because the
errors are squared and thus contribute more to the value of the integral.
For the suppression of small errors, IAE is better than ISE because when we
square small numbers ( smaller than one ) they become even smaller.
DEFINE TUNING OF CONTROLLERS(2 mark)
The method by which the exact magnitude of controller gain parameters Kp, KI, KD of the
PID controllers are obtained is called as tuning of controllers.
The tuning is generally carried out by considering the process environment in which the
controller is to be installed
GIVE THE BROAD CLASSIFICATION OF TUNING METHODS(2 mark)
1. open loop tuning
2. Closed loop tuning
OPEN LOOP TUNING: In this method the process control loop is opened and the loop
characteristics are studied to determine the parameters of the PID controller.
eg: Cohen-Coon tuning method
CLOSED LOOP TUNING: In this method process characteristics are studied with the
process control loop in closed condition and the loop to determine the parameters of the PID
controller.eg: Ziegler Nichols(Z-N) tuning method, Damped oscillation method or ¼ decay
ratio method
LIST THE VARIOUS TUNING METHOD FOR HIGHER ORDER SYSTEM(2 mark)
1. Ziegler-Nichols tuning method
2. ¼ decay ratio method
3. Damped oscillations method
4. Coohen-coon tuning method
P -m o d e
S .P PID
FINA L
+- C O NTR O LLER
C O NTR O L PRO C ESS
ELEM ENT
P .V K C
T X
O /P s te p I /P
FINA L
+- PID C O NTR O L PR O C ESS
ELEM ENT
TX
The output will be as given below
O U T P U T
T A N G E N T
B
S L O P E = S
td
T IM E
This method is a open loop tuning method
The control loop of the system is opened between the controller and the final control
element
Now the process is subjected to a step change in its input through the region at which
the loop is opened
The output is obtained from the other end of the loop breaking point which resembles
like the English alphabet ’S’ called as S Shape curve or sigmoidal curve
Draw a tangent with maximum point of inflection on the S-shape curve as shown in
the figure
The point at which the tangent cuts the x-axis or time axis denotes the value of dead
time, td
From the maximum value of the output(B) and slope of the curve(S) the time
constant(τ) can be calculated as τ =B/ S
The system gain is calculated as
output at steady stae B
K= =
input at steady state A
K e−t S
d
Now from the above values the controller settings for the various control mode is calculated
as mentioned below
1 τ t
P mode K C= ( )
K td
1+ d
3τ
------------ ------------
1 τ t 30+ 3t d /τ
K t ( 12 τ )
d
P+I mode K = 0.9+ T i=t d ------------
C
d
9+ 20 t d /τ
P+I+D 1 τ 4 t 32+6 t d /τ 4
K t (3 4τ )
K = d
+ T i=t d T D =t d
mode C
d
13+ 8t d /τ 11+ 2t d / τ
Merits:
The controller tuning method does not take the process to unstable condition.
Demerits:
The control loop has to be opened for performing the tuning.
METHOD-II: TWO POINT METHOD
O /P s te p I /P
FINA L
+- PID C O NTR O L PR O C ESS
The
ELEM ENT output
will be
as
given
TX below
K e−t S
d
List the drawback of Ziegler Nichols closed loop tuning method(2 mark)
1. The method is totally unsafe since the gain of the system is increased till marginally
stable condition
2. By means of increasing the controller gain; in this process if the gain is slightly increased
further the system will go to unstable condition which is very dangerous in the real time
environment.
What is the need for tuning of controller? (2 mark)
The proper working and performance of the controller depends upon its gain parameters,
hence tuning of controllers is necessary to find the exact magnitudes of controller gains
P -m o d e
S .P FINA L
+- C O NTR O LLER C O NTR O L PRO C ESS
ELEM ENT
P .V K C
T X
( τ 1 S +1 ) ( τ 2 S+1)
Let us replace S→jω
Therefore
K (τ jω+1) jω
G ( jω )= e−t d
( τ 1 jω+1 ) ( τ 2 jω+ 1)
The system is said to be marginally stable when Amplitude Ratio (A.R) = 1; i.e., when ϕ = 180°
At ϕ=-180°; Let ω = ωCO
Now the amplitude ratio (A.R) of the above transfer function can be given as
K √ (τ jω CO )2 +12
A . R= 2 2 2 2
( √( τ 1 jω CO ) +1 ) ( √(τ 2 jω CO ) + 1 )
At phase cross over frequency the system’s phase equation can be given as
τ ω CO τ ω τ ω 180
−180=tan −1 ( 1 ) ( )
−tan−1 1 CO −tan−1 2 CO −t d ( ωCO ) ×
1 1 π ( )
The value of ωCO can be found from the phase plot corresponding to the bode diagram of the
system; G(S) as given below
o
-1 8 0
co
Now with the value of ωCO from the phase plot the value of amplitude ratio is calculated and
Now the ultimate gain can be given as
1
KU=
A. R
The ultimate period is calculated as follows
Here ω CO =2 π f o
Substituting fo = 1/Pu; where PU = ultimate period
Therefore
2π 2π
ω CO = ⟹ PU=
PU ωCO
From the values of Ku and PU the controller settings for various modes of PID controller can
be given as
Ti TD
KC
(min) (min)
Proportional KU/2 ------ ------
Proportional-integral KU/2.2 PU/1.2 ------
Proportional-integral-derivative KU/1.7 PU/2 PU/8
It is an anticipatory controller which measures the disturbance directly, anticipates its effect
on the process output and eliminates the impact of the disturbance on the process through its
control action on the manipulated variable.
Example: Drum level control
In the above example the drum water level control is done not by placing level sensor inside
the drum but the disturbance parameters such as feed water inflow rate and steam outflow
rate are measured and based on the impact of these parameters in drum level the feed
forward controller adjust the feed water inflow rate to maintain the drum level in the set
point.
The detailed generalized control system block diagram can be given as
From the above figure the overall system equation can be given as
---- (1)
In order to eliminate the effect of disturbance (i. e ., d́ =0) the equation for controller can be
derived from the above equation (1) as follows
---------- (3)
Now to make the system to track the set point [i. e ., ý ( S )= ý SP ( S ) ¿ the term
-------- (4)
Substituting the controller equation (3) in equation (4) we get
Here GP, Gf, Gc, Gd, Gm are unalterable hence the set point tracking can be achieved only if
Thus the control loop shown in above figure eliminates the effect of disturbance with the
help of controller and set point tracking is achieved by means of GSP(S) in the block diagram.
Merits
1. Acts before the effect of a disturbance has been felt by the system.
2. It is good for slow system
3. It does not introduce instability in the closed loop response
Demerits
1. The controller should have knowledge about the process and disturbances acting on the
process.
2. The controller does not have any action over the disturbances that act on the process after
the control action.
3. Measuring all the disturbances and implementing the control increases the complexity of
the control loop and increases the total cost of the control mechanism.
4. There is no control action with unmeasured disturbances.
Explanation:
In fig(a):conventional scheme: The temperature inside the reactor to be maintained at a set
point is measured, compared and the required corrective action is implemented by adjusting
coolant flow rate using control valve. The main drawback is the reactor temperature changes
to new value before the control action taken reflects on the system because of the slow
response in the coolant flow rate.
In fig(b):cascade scheme: The Primary controller in order to maintain the reactor
temperature, measures the reactor temperature and give its control signal, this control signal
is transferred to the secondary control loop as set point, where the coolant temperature, a fast
changing variable than the reactor temperature is considered as secondary variable and
measured, the resulting control action from the secondary controller adjusts the coolant flow
rate through control valve.
The block diagram of fig(b) can be given as
From the block diagram
Primary loop: The loop that receives the user defined set point and controls the main
process variable by suitable measurement devices is called primary of master or outer control
loop
Secondary loop: The loop that receives primary controller output as its set point, measures
and through final control element controls a fast changing secondary variable than the
primary variable in order to maintain the primary process variable at its set point.
Explain in details about dead time compensation or smith predictor algorithm for
deadtime compensation
The effect of dead time in a system is removed by using smith predictor algorithm.
Let the process with dead time (td) is given by
S
G P (S)=G ( S ) e−t d
From the above diagram the resulting feedback loop is given as additive of two components
i.e., ý ¿ ( S )= ý ' ( S ) + ý ( S )_ _ _ _ _ _(4)
Substituting equation (1) and equation (3) in equation (4)
∴ ý ¿ ( S )=G C ( s ) G(s) ý sp (s )
Thus as per the smith predictor algorithm the effect of dead time is removed by introducing
the term ý ' ( S ).