You are on page 1of 6

Review Article

A review on good distribution practices


Sohini Kandar*, H. V. Gangadharappa

ABSTRACT

Quality in the manufacturing and distribution of medicinal product is regarded to be the most important component
of the pharmaceutical industry. The quality of the medicinal products corresponds to its goal of patients’ healing.
Distribution of the drug is a central operation in the integrated pharmaceutical supply chain management. Specific
storage environments and shelf life are the two difficulties of the supply chain for pharmaceutical products. Therefore,
the management of the quality of medicinal products during delivery is crucial. To resolve this issue, regulatory
authorities have provided guidelines on good distribution practices (GDPs). It is regarded as an integral basis of the
pharmaceutical supply chain of management for ensuring the orderly delivery of medicinal products. Everyone involved
in the supply chain must conform to relevant laws and regulations to preserve the actual quality of medical products.
This article basically deals with the basic concept, importance, elements, global picture, and chapters involved in the
GDPs guidelines.

KEY WORDS: Good distribution practices, Medicinal product, Pharmaceutical supply chain management, Quality

INTRODUCTION manufacturers to customers.[3] The different types of


medication (e.g., syrups, tablets, injectables, etc.) must
A core principle for the pharmaceutical supply chain be carried and stored under varying environmental
of management is good distribution practices (GDPs) conditions. The storage specifications for liquid, solid,
to ensure the efficient delivery of medicinal products and injectables shall differ considerably. The drugs
from production site to retailers.[1] GDP leads to the of the cold chain are maintained at a temperature of
regulatory standards for the wholesale business of 2–8°C. Therefore, the degree of concern is increased
pharmaceutical goods so that their consistency and for cold chain products because of the risk of product
authenticity are protected from producer to final failures during customers’ quality checks.[3]
consumers in the supply chain. Good manufacturing
practice (GMP) goes beyond delivering the final
product, including the purchase, storage, and transport
of APIs and other components before production.[2] GDP
has been established as a quality assurance component
by the World Health Organization (WHO) to ensure
reliable storage, transport, and handling of products
in acceptable condition, as specified under the
marketing authorization or product specification. The
complexities of the supply chain for pharmaceutical
products are due to their established shelf life and
storage conditions. Figure 1 described the distribution
process of drugs and pharmaceuticals from

Access this article online

Website: jprsolutions.info ISSN: 0975-7619


Figure 1: Distribution method of pharmaceutical product[3]

Department of Pharmaceutics, Pharmaceutical Quality Assurance Group, JSS College of Pharmacy, JSS Academy of Higher
Education and Research, Sri Shivarathreeshwara Nagara, Mysuru, Karnataka, India

*Corresponding author: Sohini Kandar, Department of Pharmaceutics, Pharmaceutical Quality Assurance Group, JSS
College of Pharmacy, JSS Academy of Higher Education and Research, Sri Shivarathreeshwara Nagara, Mysuru - 570 015,
Karnataka, India. Phone: +91-9932633232. E-mail: sohinikandar1995@gmail.com

Received on: 16-01-2020; Revised on: 14-02-2020; Accepted on: 22-03-2020

Drug Invention Today | Vol 13 • Issue 7 • 2020 1111


Sohini Kandar and H. V. Gangadharappa

BASIC CONCEPTS OF GDP[4] Supply Chain Risk Management


To determine, define, and understand the critical areas of
Nine core principles are defined briefly in accordance
the supply chains, importers should develop a risk-based
with the GDP guidelines:
method and precisely delegate responsibility. For supply
1. National legislation must ensure that pharmaceutical
chain activities, a structuralized quality assurance system
products are sold under the GDP guidelines
and a process to publicize supply chain details should
2. The distributor should be licensed and approved
be developed within the company. Drug substances and
and responsible for the safe delivery of medicines
excipients may be supplied by a short supply chain or
or medical products
a long and complicated supply chain involving several
3. Only licensed individuals or corporations should be
countries. Importers should themselves test or use
able to purchase or sell pharmaceuticals
existing third party auditing companies on product
4. Distributors should only sell a drug product in
substances and excipients producers and should
countries where it is allowed
not depend on manufacturer’s questionnaire. If the
5. Distributors may only provide their services to
substance’s identity and its exact production locations
companies approved to manufacture the drug
are not established or verified (show factory) then
product or work with it
either the original company or subcontractors may be
6. Duty and obligation can only be subcontracted to
producing the item in another location (shadow factory)
third parties holding a suitable license
on condition that it does not meet GMP requirements.
7. Distributors or their agents can only distribute
The following are the suggested measures:
pharmaceutical products to individuals or organizations
approved to purchase the pharmaceutical drugs • Suppliers and subcontractors’ names and
8. The organization or person under contract must be geographical locations are verified
accurately approved • The credibility of a company is investigated
9. Pharmaceutical products shall be available in online • The products or materials are checked by inspection
only for licensed and approved pharmacies or other or checking at different points/stations of the supply
approved organizations only. chain.[8]

IMPORTANCE OF GDP Efficient Supplier Relationship Creation


A necessary initial investigation and assessment
GDPs define the minimum requirements that should
of the supplier should be performed on site or
be followed by the distributors or wholesalers for
person, as a quality audit, and in conformity with
assuring that the drugs are maintained over the entire
appropriate regulatory requirements for the country of
supply chain. GDP should be enforced by means of a
importation (e.g., current GMP [cGMP] adherence to
quality program managed by the supply chain staff and
the U.S. markets). This method ensures that a reliable
the pharmaceutical product network to assure that:[5,6]
framework of quality is in place and that the product
1. The medicinal products are approved in compliance
or service to be imported is properly understood. To
with the law of land
resolve any areas of concern, corrective or preventive
2. Medicines are kept in the appropriate environment
measures should be dealt with and addressed where
throughout all times even during shipping
appropriate. The recommended measures include:
3. Contamination is avoided by or from other goods
• Analyzes the credibility of the distributor by
4. Supply of stored medicines is properly turned-over
checking his company ranking or any misuse or
5. In a sufficient time frame, the right goods hit the
other breaches of intellectual property or trademarks
correct address or[7]
• Determine the company’s long-term market
6. Harmonizing supply of drug in the public sector[7]
sustainability and commitment to the health and
7. To make sure that medicines are distributed fairly (and
quality of the drug and its reputation as a supplier
re-distributed, if necessary) throughout the world.[7]
for the pharmaceutical industry
The supplier will also implement a monitoring system • Determine the regulatory compliance of the
for the identification and successful recovery of manufacturer with the exporting and importing
defective items. GDP also refers to the manufacturing, countries.[8]
storage, and transport of active pharmaceutical materials
Creating a Reliable Supply Chain Network
and other materials used for medicinal products.[5]
Importers may strengthen methods, policies,
ELEMENTS OF GDP AS PER USP specifications, procedures, and documents related to
product protection and supply chain integrity by meeting
According to USP <1083> the main components the criteria of Security Assurance Standard of the
of good distribution practices are mentioned in American National Standards Institute other equivalent
Figure 2[6]. The components are as followed. standards. The following are the required measures:

1112 Drug Invention Today | Vol 13


xx • Issue 7x • 2020
xxxx
Sohini Kandar and H. V. Gangadharappa

Figure 2: Main good distribution practices components depending on USP<1083>[6]

• Develop a management framework based on the They may also manufacture false labels and primary
safety of products and integrity of the supply chain packaging with altered shelf-life dates.[8]
• Develop and record specified roles and duties for
resolving credibility issues in the product and supply Packaging Technologies
chain, including falsification robbery and diversion Packaging techniques such as authentication, tamper-
of products evident designs, and serialization are an essential
• Assuring that employees have adequate preparation, component for brand security and refer to both the
expertise, experience, and skills to fulfill their duties main and/or secondary packaging product labels.
and responsibilities.[8] Techniques for authentication are categorized as
transparent, hidden, and forensic. In an approach
Counterfeit Drugs and Medical Devices described as “layering,” tamper-evident designs can
Counterfeit medicines are false medicines. It may be be combined with more elaborate authentication
toxic or it may contain incorrect active components or technologies. One drawback of these methods is that
no active components. The correct active ingredient it does not protect the product.[8]
may be present but at the wrong dose. Counterfeit
medicines are illicit and can affect health.[9] The most Drug Pedigrees System
common reason for manufacturing a counterfeit drug A drug pedigree is a declaration of origin which
product is to achieve a commercial benefit by supplying established the date and address of all parties
a small quantity of the medication or even by failing to concerned with each prior selling, purchase, or
supply some medication substance or replacing another exchange of a drug. The details should be stored in
cheaper drug substance. Counterfeited medicines may paper or electronic form (e-pedigree) so that the supply
include the right quantity of ingredients but may not chain for drugs can be protected against the entry of
be produced by GMPs and/or manufactured at sites not counterfeit, lost, misreported, adulterated, sub-potent,
registered with the appropriate regulatory authorities. misbranded, non-standard, or expired products. An
Counterfeiters are also using modern techniques for e-pedigree is just electronic documentation that meets
packaging and printing to make false labels as well the specification of a pedigree.[8] When a product
as primary and secondary packaging to confuse passes through the supply chain, any organization
pharmaceutical firms, regulators, and consumers. handling the product shall have all of the details of

Drug Invention Today | Vol 13 • Issue 7 • 2020 1113


Sohini Kandar and H. V. Gangadharappa

the prior e-pedigree. When it hits the final destination, • Billing, confidentiality, and shipping charges are
the seller will have a full chart detailing the location clearly mentioned on websites
of the delivery shipment and the person managed • Stable and authenticated website links are used for
the contents. An e-pedigree is specifically designed payment.
for the protection of consumers from harmful or
falsified medicines. Furthermore, e-pedigrees help Illegitimate websites for online pharmacy are as
manufacturers for serializing down to the unit level follows:
which can reduce recall costs and manage deliveries • Postal address or telephone number are not given
more effectively.[10] • Rates substantially lower than the competitive prices
are offered
Usage of Machine-readable Data Carriers for • A prescription is not needed for prescription drugs
Drugs or give access to faulty prescriptions
Two-dimensional (2D) bar codes and/or radio- • Non-FDA licensed prescription pharmaceutical
frequency identification (RFID) tags are provided on products are sold
the primary, secondary, or tertiary packaging(s) or • Are included in the list of internet pharmacies on
pallets for determining an e-pedigree. Various types the NABP’s “Not Recommended Sites.”[8]
of carriers can be chosen for different packaging
levels, such as the RFID tag or 2D bar code for the WORLD WIDE PICTURE OF GDP
distribution unit and RFID tags for cases and pallet
grade applications. For parenteral items, the details WHO[11]
can be applied directly to the container itself by WHO published a guideline on GDP, WHO GDPs
laser-etching 2D bar codes on the surface of the glass for pharmaceutical products in 2010 technical report
or plastic container. If the 2D bar code is applied to the no 957, Annex 5. This guidance can apply equally
container at the pharmaceutical plant, the product label to human products and to veterinary applications, in
may contain details on the drug product. The insertion compliance with regional and national pharmaceutical
of 2D barcodes on the surface of the container or the regulations. The guidelines also include for which the
label of the product at the pharmaceutical plant gives patient needs a prescription and products that can be
details on the drug product. RFID tags are available on distributed without a prescription. It is also applicable
or under the label of the product or on the container’s to biologics and vaccines.
cap or bottom. When a data carrier is attached to
the container closure system, it shall not affect the European Commission[12]
health, identification, power, consistency, or pureness On March 7, 2013, the latest guideline on GDP was
of the product. Sometimes RFID tags can affect the finalized and issued by the European Commission.
biopharmaceuticals because of the electromagnetic It substitutes the existing GDP guidance issued in
emission. Therefore, 2D bar codes are used on the 1994 (94/C 63/03) and applies to wholesalers and
biopharmaceuticals primary packaging as it does not pharmaceutical companies, as well as to the unique
include emission of electromagnetic waves.[8] criteria for pharmaceutical dealers. On September 8,
2013, their specifications (Ref: 2013/C 68/01) came
Overcoming Illegal Drugs on the Internet into effect.
Legal online pharmacy sites offer customers a
convenient and private means of purchasing drug India[12]
products, but a range of illegitimate sites claim to Draft guidelines for GDPs of pharmaceutical products
be legitimate sell low cost licensed and unlicensed for public opinion were published in January 2013
prescription and herbal drugs. Many patients use illicit by the Central Drugs Quality Control Organization
Internet pharmacy not only to cut costs but also to of India, the authority of country’s medical products.
escape getting a licensed doctor’s valid prescription. The purpose of these recommendations is to assure
Items sold by illicit Internet pharmacies pose a range the quality and identity of pharmaceutical products
of health risks. Listed online pharmacies must follow during the distribution process. Such aspects comprise
the National Association of Boards of Pharmacy procurement, manufacturing, storage, distribution,
(NABP) approval requirements for federal and state transport, documentation, and record-keeping.
legislation. The following are classified as legal
websites for online pharmacy: Canada[12]
• The doctor’s prescription is requested normally by In 2013, Health Canada initiates its 3-year upgrade
e-mail, (if the doctor approves fax, the approved process of the standards for Drug Products during
doctor will also be asked to confirm the prescription) Temperature Regulation in Storage and Transport
• A telephone number or physical address is given (GUI-0069). The new recommendations of Health
• A thorough medical history is required Canada, GUI-0069, came into force on April 28, 2011.

1114 Drug Invention Today | Vol 13


xx • Issue 7x • 2020
xxxx
Sohini Kandar and H. V. Gangadharappa

USA and seasonal changes, which should be repeated on the


The chapter <1079> Good Storage and Distribution basis of risk analysis.[12] There is definitely a variation
Practices for Drug Products offered specific in the regulations for the use and the handling of
guidelines on good distribution and storage practices sensitive items such as radioactive and flammable
to guarantee that the quality of the drugs remains materials.[15] This chapter also includes a computerized
unaffected when the end-user receives it.[12] The forum system, temperature, and environment control and
of US Pharmacopeia introduced a new chapter <1083> qualification and validation of equipment.[14]
GDPs – supply chain integrity, which substitutes the
chapter <1079>. The new chapter mainly focuses on Chapter 4 – Documentation
counterfeit medicines.[13] This chapter outlines a range Good documentation is an integral element of the
of best strategies for maintaining the quality of the quality system. Written reports would avoid errors in
supply chain for drug components (active substances communication and allow the follow-up of appropriate
and excipients) and medicinal products.[8] medicinal product distributors. The documents
must be understood by the customer and operator
Singapore[12] for procedures, and focus should be put on updated
Singapore – Health Sciences Authority (HSA) documentation.[16]
guidance notes on GDP. The HSA of Singapore
published guidelines for GDPs in August 2010. Chapter 5 – Operations
This guide is intended for the storage, transport, and More specific instructions about the qualification of
distribution of the starting materials and medicinal consumer and distributor, storage, destruction, pick-up,
goods. This guide refers to all stages of the supply/ supply, and exportation of the product to other countries
delivery chain. The aim of the guide is to ensure that can be found in this chapter.[14] The “first in first out”
product quality and integrity are sustained throughout principle was substituted by a “first expired first out in,”
the supply chain. which is now the new definition for storage.[15]
Brazil[12] Chapter 6 – Complaints, Returns, Suspected
On 4 April, Brazil’s National Health Monitoring Falsified Medicinal Products, and Medicinal
Agency (Anvisa) started a consultation to recommend Product Recalls
the creation of an electronic drug tracking network,
All grievances, returns, reported fraudulent medication,
from the point of development to the point of
and recalls must be registered and treated in writing.
dispensing. The introduced monitoring device shall be
The responsible authorities will have access to
based on the data matrix, a 2D barcode used in sales
documents. Until clearance for resale, an evaluation of
packets and secondary packaging such as pill packs
the medicinal products that have been returned should
and hospital parquets.
be performed. The new guidance indicates that the 10-
day time limit for returning medications outside the
CHAPTERS OF GDP AS PER authorized chain may be appropriate.[16]
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Chapter 7 – Outsourced Activities
According to the European commission, GDPs have
ten following chapters. Any outsourced operation covered by the GDP
guideline must be properly described, accepted, and
Chapter 1 – Quality Management monitored to prevent misconceptions that can impact
Quality management defines the Principe, quality the product’s credibility. The giver of the contract
system, including management review and monitoring, and the receiver of the contract must enter into a
handling of outsourced actions, and management of written agreement that clearly sets out each party’s
risk.[14] Deviations have to be examined and the CAPA responsibilities.[14] Contract criteria between parties
mechanism is applied as a preventive measure.[12] in which GDP is outsourced are very evident. As part
of the management analysis, the reported activities
Chapter 2 – Personnel would be verified.[16]
This chapter addresses the roles and responsibilities
of the individual responsible and other main staff. Chapter 8 – Self-inspection
Further information on training and hygiene is given Self-inspections are carried out to monitor and comply
in the chapter.[15] with the concepts of GDP and to recommend appropriate
corrective action.[14] Personnel apart from responsible
Chapter 3 – Premises and Equipment personnel may perform self-inspections. An unbiased
It poses new storage area requirements. Temperature external audit should be conducted. The findings should
mapping should involve initial mapping before use be regulated by the principles of CAPA.[16]

Drug Invention Today | Vol 13 • Issue 7 • 2020 1115


Sohini Kandar and H. V. Gangadharappa

Chapter 9 – Transportation Education and Research, Mysuru, for constant support


The wholesale supplier is responsible for securing and encouragement.
drugs from breaking, adulteration, and theft and
ensuring that temperature is retained within acceptable REFERENCES
limits throughout transportation. Irrespective of the 1. Kumar N, Jha A. Quality perspective of ‘Good Distribution
mode of transportation, it should be possible to prove Practices’ in Indian pharmaceutical industry. IOSR J Bus
that the drugs were not subjected to the conditions Manage 2015;17:28-32.
2. Good Distribution Practice-GDP Guidelines-Pharma
which can affect their efficiency and integrity. A risk-
Experts. Pharma Experts; 2020. Available from: http://
based strategy can be used for transport planning.[14] www.pharmaexpertsltd.com/good-distribution-practice-gdp-
This chapter has very detailed instructions and a few guidelines. [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 18].
changes. For example, items in a warehouse cannot 3. Kumar N, Jha A. Pharmaceutical good distribution practices-a
review of global scenario. Int J Pharm Sci Res 2015;6:1449-52.
be kept more than 24 h. If the transportation does
4. The Principles of Good Distribution Practices. Pharmaceutical
not occur within this time period, the property would Training-Astra Nova; 2020. Available from: https://www.
be considered a storage facility and must be given a crotraining.co.uk/the-principles-of-good-distribution-
delivery authorization for wholesalers.[15] practices. [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 19].
5. Good Distribution Practice-European Medicines Agency. European
Medicines Agency; 2020. Available from: https://www.ema.
Chapter 10 – Specific Provisions for Brokers europa.eu/en/human-regulatory/post-authorisation/compliance/
This chapter explains the roles of the broker. Brokers good-distribution-practice. [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 20].
are not protected by property laws because they do 6. Kumar N, Jha A. Pharmaceutical ‘Good Manufacturing
Practices’ and ‘Good Distribution Practices’-a comparative
not manage the products they buy and sell directly. review of diligence in regulatory standards. Indo Am J Pharm
However, they need a quality management program Res 2016;6:4018-25.
and must be accountable for appropriate training 7. Good Distribution Practices-Expectations for Coming
of their employees – as far as falsified drugs are Decade|PharmaTutor; 2020. Available from: https://www.
pharmatutor.org/articles/good-distribution-practices-
concerned. This chapter also includes a standard expectations-coming-decade. [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 21].
operating procedure list to comply with by a dealer.[15] 8. Available from: https://www.uspnf.com/sites/default/files/usp_
pdf/EN/USPNF/revisions/c1083.pdf. [Last accessed on 2020
Chapter 11 – Final Provisions Apr 22].
9. Counterfeit Medicine. U.S. Food and Drug Administration;
These guidelines substitute the GDP guidelines of 2020. Available from: https://www.fda.gov/drugs/buying-
medicinal products for human drugs, published on using-medicine-safely/counterfeit-medicine. [Last accessed on
March 1, 1994 and the GDP guidelines for human use 2020 Apr 23].
10. What is E-Pedigree and why is it Important?|Blog|Gintzler
for drugs published on March 7, 2013.[14] International; 2020. Available from: https://www.
gintzlerinternational.com/blog/2016/12/07/what-is-e-pedigree-
CONCLUSION and-why-is-it-important. [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 24].
11. Available from: https://www.who.int/medicines/
GDP ensure that the sold goods have been approved areas/quality_safety/quality_assurance/
GoodDistributionPracticesTRS957Annex5.pdf. [Last accessed
under the applicable regulations. Adequate conditions on 2020 Apr 25].
for storage, including the transfer of goods between 12. Available from: http://www.iqpc.com/media/8378/34072.pdf.
different parts of the network for distribution, must [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 26].
always be maintained. Contamination of drugs by other 13. New USP. 1083 on Good Distribution Practices-ECA Academy;
2020. Available from: https://www.gmp-compliance.org/gmp-
medicinal products is prevented and goods are kept in news/new-usp-chapter-1083-on-good-distribution-practices.
a clean and secure environment in the supply chain. [Last accessed on 2020 Apr 27].
Apart from that, GDP also opposes the counterfeiting 14. Available from: https://www.eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/
of drugs and helps to identify the defective drugs and LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:C:2013:343:0001:0014:EN:PDF. [Last
accessed on 2020 Apr 28].
recalled them as per regulations. As a result, more 15. EU Commission Publishes Important New Draft Guideline on
emphasis has been imposed to cGDP. Therefore, the Good Distribution Practice of Medicinal Products for Human
management of the pharmaceutical distribution chain Use-ECA Academy; 2020. Available from: https://www.
needs to continuously update procurement activities gmp-compliance.org/gmp-news/eu-commission-publishes-
important-new-draft-guideline-on-good-distribution-practice-
with an organized network. of-medicinal-products-for-human-use. [Last accessed on 2020
Apr 29].
ACKNOWLEDGMENT 16. Bhaskaran J, Venkatesh MP. Good storage and distribution
practices for pharmaceuticals in European Union. J Pharm Sci
I would like to convey my deep gratitude to the Principal Res 2019;11:2992-7.
and Head of the Department of Pharmaceutics,
Source of support: Nil; Conflicts of interest: None Declared
JSS College of Pharmacy, JSS Academy of Higher

1116 Drug Invention Today | Vol 13


xx • Issue 7x • 2020
xxxx

You might also like