You are on page 1of 8

Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988

DOI 10.1617/s11527-006-9192-y

O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E

Influence of recycled aggregate on slump and bleeding


of fresh concrete
C. S. Poon Æ S. C. Kou Æ L. Lam

Received: 10 November 2005 / Accepted: 21 June 2006 / Published online: 17 October 2006
Ó RILEM 2006

Abstract The recycling of construction and Résumé Le recyclage des déchets de construc-
demolition (C&D) waste as a source of aggre- tion et de démolition (C&D) en tant que source de
gates for the production of new concrete has at- granulats pour la production de béton, a attiré des
tracted increasing interests from the construction intérêts croissants de l’industrie du bâtiment. Bien
industry. While the environmental benefits of que les avantages environnementaux de l’emploi
using recycled aggregates are well accepted, some des granulats recyclés soient reconnus, quelques
unsolved problems prevent this type of material problèmes irrésolus empêchent une plus large
from wide application in structural concrete. One application de ce type de matériau en tant que
of the major problems with the use of recycled béton structurel. Un des problèmes majeurs de
aggregates in structural concrete is their high l’utilisation des granulats recyclés dans le béton
water absorption capacity which leads to diffi- structurel, est leur fort pouvoir absorbant menant à
culties in controlling the properties of fresh con- des difficultés de control des propriétés du béton
crete and consequently influences the strength frais et par conséquent, influençant la résistance et
and durability of hardened concrete. This paper la pérennité du béton durci. Cet article présente
presents an experimental study on the properties une étude expérimentale sur les propriétés du bé-
of fresh concrete prepared with recycled aggre- ton frais préparé avec des granulats recyclés. Des
gates. Concrete mixes with a target compressive systèmes de dosage, ayant pour cible une résistance
strength of 35 MPa are prepared with the use of à la compression de 35 MPa, sont préparés à base
recycled aggregates at the levels from 0 to 100% de granulats recyclés avec différents dosages du
of the total coarse aggregate. The influence of total de granulat grossier de 0 à 100%. L’influence
recycled aggregate on the slump and bleeding are des granulats recyclés sur l’affaissement et le res-
investigated. The effect of delaying the starting suage est étudiée. L’effet du retardement du déc-
time of bleeding tests and the effect of using fly lenchement des tests de ressuage, ainsi que l’effet
ash on the bleeding of concrete are explored. de l’emploi de cendres volantes sur l’affaissement
du béton sont explorés.

C. S. Poon (&) Æ S. C. Kou Æ L. Lam Keywords Recycled aggregate Æ Fresh


Department of Civil and Structural Engineering,
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Properties Æ Bleeding
Kowloon, Hong Kong, China
e-mail: cecspoon@polyu.edu.hk
982 Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988

1 Introduction concrete mixes with high W/C ratios, low cement


contents, coarsely ground cement or poorly gra-
The recycling of construction and demolition ded aggregates [5, 6]. The use of retarding mix-
(C&D) waste as a source of aggregates for the tures will also increase the degree of bleeding. A
production of new concrete has attracted number of studies have exhibited that the use of
increasing interests from the construction indus- fine mineral powders such as fly ash can reduce
try. While the environmental benefits of using the bleeding and segregation of concrete [11, 12].
recycled aggregates are well accepted, some un- This paper presents an experimental study on
solved problems prevent this type of material the properties of fresh concrete prepared with
from wide application in structural concrete. recycled aggregates. Concrete mixes with a target
One of the major problems with the use of compressive strength of 35 MPa are prepared with
recycled aggregates in structural concrete is their the use of recycled aggregates at the levels from 0 to
high water absorption capacity which leads to 100% of the total coarse aggregate. The influence
difficulties in controlling the properties of fresh of recycled aggregate on the slump and bleeding
concrete and consequently influences the strength are investigated. The effect of delaying the starting
and durability of hardened concrete. Hanson [1] time of bleeding tests and the effect of using fly ash
and Sagoe-Crentsi et al. [2] suggested that recy- on the bleeding of concrete are explored.
cled aggregates should be pre-wetted or saturated
with water to prevent a rapid decrease in concrete
workability. Poon et al. [3] demonstrated that the 2 Experimental details
initial slump of a concrete mixture depended on
the initial free water content, while the slump loss 2.1 Cement and fly ash
of the mixture with time was related to the initial
moisture state of the aggregates. They also The cement used in this study was a Portland
reported that in the case of using recycled cement equivalent to ASTM Type I cement and
aggregates in the saturated surface-dried (SSD) the fly ash used was a low calcium fly ash equiv-
state, the high water content inside the aggregate alent to Class F fly ash, both commercially avail-
particles may result in bleeding during casting. able in Hong Kong. The properties of the cement
The Concrete Technology Unit of University of and fly ash are shown in Table 1.
Dundee [4] showed that the use of recycled
aggregate as a partial replacement of natural 2.2 Aggregates
aggregate leads to slight increases in slump and
compacting factor, and a high degree of bleeding. The coarse aggregates used in this study included
Bleeding has negative effects on the properties natural aggregates and recycled aggregates. The
of concrete, which is referred to the movement of natural aggregates were crushed granite sourced
water to the surface of fresh concrete a result of from a local quarry, with nominal sizes of 10 and
the settlement of solid particles [5, 6]. A high 20 mm. The recycled aggregates were derived
degree of bleeding can significantly increase the Table 1 Properties of cement and fly ash
near-surface water-to-cement (W/C) ratio, lead-
ing to a lower concrete strength at the cover zone Cement Fly ash
[7, 8]. The formation of a network of capillary Chemical composition (%)
pores due to the movement of bleeding water also SiO2 19.61 56.79
reduces the durability of concrete in this zone [9]. Fe2O3 3.32 5.31
Al2O3 7.33 28.21
In addition, bleeding water trapped along the
CaO 63.15 <3
underside of reinforcing steel can reduce the bond MgO 2.54 5.21
strength and increase the risk of corrosion [10]. SO3 2.13 0.68
The degree of bleeding in fresh concrete is Loss on ignition (LOI) 2.97 3.90
Density (g/cm3) 3.16 2.31
dependent on a number of factors. It is known
Specific area (cm2/g) 3519 3960
that a high degree of bleeding can be observed for
Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988 983

Table 2 Properties of aggregates


Type Nominal Density Water Moisture content Crushing strength Porosity (%)
size (kg/m3) absorption (%) at mixing (%) (10% fines) kN

Crushed 10 mm 2620 1.1 0.7 159 1.62


granite 20 mm 2620 1.1 0.5
Recycled 10 mm 2490 4.3 1.1 126 8.69
aggregate 20 mm 2570 3.5 1.0
Sand – 2620 0.9 2.4 – –

from unwashed construction and demolition recycled aggregates were used at the levels of 0%,
(C&D) wastes, which had been processed by 20%, 50%, 80% and 100% of the total mass of the
mechanized crushing and sieving at the a local coarse aggregates, respectively. In Series I mixes,
C&D waste recycling plant to produce fine only the Portland cement was used as the cemen-
aggregate and coarse aggregate according to the titious material but in Series II mixes, 25% of the
particle size requirements of British Standard BS cement was replaced by the same weight of fly ash.
812 [13]. Only coarse recycled aggregates with the The proportions of the concrete mixes were de-
maximum nominal sizes of 10 mm and 20 mm signed using the absolute volume method. The mix
were used in this study. The fine aggregate used in proportions for aggregates at the saturated surface-
this study was natural river sand with a fineness dried (SSD) condition are shown in Tables 3 and 4.
modulus of 2.11. The physical and mechanical The actual proportions of the mixes at mixing were
properties of aggregates are shown in Table 2, adjusted according to the moisture contents of the
where the porosity of the aggregates was deter- aggregates which are given in Table 2.
mined using mercury intrusion porosimetry
(MIP) and the strength of the aggregates was 2.4 Tests
measured as the force (in kN) required to pro-
duce 10% of fine materials according to BS 882 The slump of the fresh concrete prepared was
part 111 [14]. In the concrete mixtures, the 10 mm measured using the standard slump test appara-
and 20 mm coarse aggregates were used in a tus. A portion of about 20 liters (3 times the
proportion of 1:2. A river sand was used as the quantity required for the slump test) of fresh
fine aggregate in this study, the terms ‘‘natural concrete was taken for the slump test. Slump
aggregate’’ and ‘‘recycled aggregate’’ refer to values were regularly measured at 15 min inter-
only the coarse aggregates used hereafter in this vals, with the first value measured immediately
paper for simplicity. after mixing and the last value measured at 180th
minute. After each test, the concrete samples
2.3 Concrete mixtures were poured into a steel container and then
plastic film was used to cover the samples during
Two series of concrete mixes were prepared at a the intervals between tests.
water-to-cementitious materials ratio (W/CM) of ASTM C232 standard test method [15] was
0.55. Each series contained five mixes, where the used to measure the bleeding of the concrete

Table 3 Mix proportions of Series I concrete mixes


Notation Recycled aggregate (%) Constitution (kg/m3)
Water Cement Sand Granite Recycled aggregate

R0 0 225 410 642 1048 0


R20 20 225 410 642 840 204
R50 50 225 410 642 524 506
R80 80 225 410 642 210 814
R100 100 225 410 642 0 1017
984 Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988

Table 4 Mix proportions of Series II concrete mixes


Notation Recycled aggregate (%) Constitution (kg/m3)
Water Cement Fly ash Sand Granite Recycled aggregate

R0F25 0 225 307.5 102.5 628 1048 0


R20F25 20 225 307.5 102.5 628 840 204
R50F25 50 225 307.5 102.5 628 524 506
R80F25 80 225 307.5 102.5 628 210 814
R100F25 100 225 307.5 102.5 628 0 1017

mixture. Fresh concrete was filled into a container where the slump values are averages of two
in two layers and was vibrated for 10 s for each measurements. It can be seen from this figure
layer on a vibrating table. The conical container that the initial slump increased with an increase
had diameters of 290 mm and 285 mm at the top in the percentage of recycled aggregate. The
and the bottom respectively, and a height of mix prepared with 100% recycled aggregate
285 mm. The container was then placed on a level showed the greatest slump of 195 mm. This is
platform free from vibration and covered with a due to the higher initial free water content in
lip to prevent the evaporation of water. A pipette the concrete mixture. This higher initial free
was used to draw off the bleed water at 10 min water content for concrete prepared with recy-
intervals during the first 70 min and at 30 min cled aggregates was due to the higher water
intervals thereafter until cessation of bleeding. absorption of the recycled aggregate. The recy-
The ASTM standard [15] specified that the cled aggregate was used at the air-dried condi-
bleeding test has to be conducted immediately tion with the initial moisture content of the
after mixing. In this study, tests started at 30, 60, aggregate at mixing much lower than its
120 min after mixing were also conducted. For absorption capacity. Additional amounts of
these additional tests, the concrete in the mixer water were added to maintain the mix propor-
was remixed at the above intervals. The proce- tions (designed at the saturated surface-dried
dures described above were followed to measure state) as given in Tables 3 and 4. Detailed dis-
the amount of bleed water. The effect of the cussion on this aspect has been presented in a
starting time of amount of bleeding was measured recent paper of the authors [3]. It is also shown
because, in practice, the casting of concrete is in Fig. 1 that the rate of slump loss was quicker
likely to be any time between 0 and 2 h after within the first hour after mixing, but was
mixing [10]. slower afterward. The mix without recycled
Twelve standard cubes of 100 mm in dimensions aggregate took about 130 min to decrease to the
were cast for each concrete mix and cured in water
at 27°C. Compression tests were conducted on the 240
cubes at the ages of 3, 7, 28 and 90 days to deter-
210
mine the compressive strength of the concrete. R0
180
All the tests were conducted in the laboratory R20
R50
environment at the room temperature of about 150
R80
Slump (mm)

20–24°C. 120 R100

90

3 Results and discussions 60

30
3.1 Initial slump and slump loss 0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240
Time (min)
Figure 1 shows the changes of concrete slump
with time for Series I mixes without fly ash, Fig. 1 Changes of slump of concrete mixes without fly ash
Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988 985

zero slump, while the mix with 100% recycled recycled aggregate. The rate of slump loss with
aggregates took over 3 h. time was also lower for the mixes with fly ash. As
Figure 2 shows the changes of concrete slump a result, these mixes took longer to reach the zero
with time for the Series II mixes with 25% fly ash, slump than the mixes without fly ash.
where averages of two measurements are also
used. All the mixes showed higher initial slumps 3.2 Bleeding of concrete
when compared with the corresponding mixes
without fly ash. The highest initial slump of The results of the bleeding tests are summarized
210 mm was recorded for the mix with 100% in Table 5 for mixes without fly ash and in
Table 6 for mixes with 25% fly ash. The bleeding
240 rate is defined as the volume of water in ml col-
210
lected per cm2 per second during the first 60 min
R0F25 of the test. The bleeding capacity is defined as the
180 R20F25
total volume of bleeding water collected during
Slump (mm)

R50F25
150
R80F25 the entire course of the test, expressed as the
120 R100F25 fraction of the initial volume of the concrete. The
90 cumulative bleeding curves are shown in Figs. 3
60 and 4 for Series I and Series II mixes respectively,
30 where the accumulated volume of bleeding water
0 is plotted against time (minutes after mixing).
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 A recent study at the Hong Kong Polytechnic
Time (min)
University [3] suggested that the use of recycled
Fig. 2 Changes of slump of concrete mixes with 25% fly ash aggregates that was over-wetted should be

Table 5 Results of Bleeding tests of Series I concrete mixes


Mix Test started immedi- Test started at 30 min after Test started at 60 min Test started at 120 min
ately after mixing mixing after mixing after mixing
Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding
capacity rate 10–6 capacity rate 10–6ml/cm2/s capacity rate 10–6ml/ capacity rate 10–6ml/
10–3 ml/ml ml/cm2/s 10–3 ml/ml 10–3 ml/ml cm2/s 10–3 ml/ml cm2/s

R0 18.8 47.9 13.2 19.6 8.3 12.2 5.2 9.6


R20 19.9 50.9 14.2 20.5 8.7 13.1 5.4 10.0
R50 21.2 53.6 15.2 20.9 9.1 13.5 5.6 10.4
R80 22.6 56.6 16.2 21.3 9.6 13.9 5.8 10.5
R100 23.0 60.1 17.1 22.2 9.9 14.4 6.1 10.5

Table 6 Results of Bleeding tests of Series II concrete mixes


Mix Test started immediately Test started at 30 min Test started at 60 min after Test started at 120 min
after mixing after mixing mixing after mixing
Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding Bleeding
capacity rate 10–6ml/ capacity rate 10–6ml/ capacity 10–3 rate 10–6ml/ capacity rate 10–6ml/
10–3 ml/ml cm2/s 10–3 ml/ml cm2/s ml/ml cm2/s 10–3 ml/ml cm2/s

R0F25 16.2 43.5 9.6 17.4 7.3 10.9 4.6 6.5


R20F25 16.9 45.7 10.4 18.3 7.6 11.3 4.8 6.7
R50F25 18.1 49.2 10.8 20.5 8.1 12.2 5.0 7.1
R80F25 19.5 52.3 11.4 21.8 8.1 12.6 5.1 7.3
R100F25 20.0 54.5 12.0 22.7 8.8 13.9 5.4 7.8
986 Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988

(a) 200 (c) 200


180

Cumulative bleed water (ml)


Cumulative bleed water (ml)

180
160
160
140 R0
140
120 R20
120
100 R50
R0 100
R80
80 R20 80
R100
60 R50 60
40 R80 40
20 R100 20
0 0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Time (min) Time (min)

(b) 200
180
Cumulative bleed water (ml)

160 R0 (d) 200


R20

Cumulative bleed water (ml)


140 180
R50 160
120 R80
140
100 R100 R0
120 R20
80 100 R50
R80
60 80
R100
60
40
40
20 20
0 0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Time (min) Time (min)

Fig. 3 Cumulative bleed curves of Series I mixes without fly ash (a) Tests started immediately after mixing; (b) Tests started
at 30 min after mixing; (c) Tests started at 60 min after mixing; (d) Test started at 120 min after mixing

avoided to reduce the bleeding which has nega- bleeding rate and bleeding capacity might be
tive effects on the properties of hardened con- attributed to the initial hydration of cement
crete. The results of the present study as shown which reduced the content of free water in the
in Table 5 indicated that the use of recycled system. It should be noted the delays slightly
aggregates, even at an air-dried state, resulted in prolonged the process of bleeding. When the
higher bleeding rates and bleeding capacities. tests were started immediately after mixing, it
The use of 100% recycled aggregates increased took about 220 min for the bleeding to stop.
the bleeding rate and bleeding capacity by 26% However, when the starting time of tests was
and 22%, respectively. Delaying the starting time delayed by 30 and 60 min, the same process took
of bleeding tests resulted in significant reductions about 300 min. The effect of recycled aggregate
in both the bleeding rate and bleeding capacity content and the starting time of the bleeding test
for all the concrete mixes. For example, for the can also be seen from Fig. 3.
mix with 100% recycled aggregates, a 30-min It is clear by comparing the results in Tables 5
delay of the starting time of the bleeding test and 6, that the replacement of cement by 25% fly
reduced the bleeding rate by 63% and the ash reduced the bleeding rate and bleeding
bleeding capacity by 26%. This result is similar capacity for all the mixes when the bleeding tests
to the results reported by Wainwrigt et al. [10] were conducted immediately after mixing. For the
on the bleeding of concrete containing ground mix with 100% recycled coarse aggregates, the fly
granulated blast furnace slag. The reduction in ash reduced the bleeding rate and bleeding
Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988 987

(a) 200 (c) 200


180 180

Cumulative bleed water (ml)


Cumulative bleed water(ml)

160 160
R0F25
140 140 R20F25
R0F25
120 120 R50F25
R20F25
100 100 R80F25
R50F25
80 80 R100F25
R80F25
60 R100F25 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Time (min) Time (min)

(b) 200 (d) 200


180 180
R0F25
160
Cumulative bleed water (ml)

Cumulative bleed water (ml)


160 R20F25
140 R50F25 140 R0F25
R80F25 R20F25
120 120
R100F25 R50F25
100 100 R80F25
80 80 R100F25

60 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Time (min) Time (min)

Fig. 4 Cumulative bleeding curves of Series II mixes with 25% fly ash (a) Tests started immediately after mixing; (b) Tests
started at 30 min after mixing; (c) Tests started at 60 min after mixing; (d) Tests started at 120 min after mixing

Table 7 Compressive
Series Notation Recycled aggregate (%) Fly ash (%) Compressive strength (MPa)
strength of Series I and II
concrete mixes 3 days 7 days 28 days 90 days

I R0 0 0 25.1 30.2 48.6 52.7


R20 20 23.2 29.1 45.3 50.8
R50 50 21.6 27.6 42.5 49.5
R80 80 19.1 25.3 39.2 47.6
R100 100 17.9 23.4 37.1 45.5
II R0F25 0 25 21.4 26.4 47.1 57.9
R20F25 20 19.2 24.8 43.8 57.3
R50F25 50 17.2 22.9 42.8 53.4
R80F25 80 15.9 20.1 38.9 52.8
R100F25 100 13.2 19.7 36.7 50.1

capacity by 9% and 13%, respectively, when effect of using fly ash on the bleeding of concrete
compared with the mix without fly ash. Further might be due to its lower density and higher
reductions in the bleeding rate and bleeding specific area as compared to cement, which held
capacity were observed when the starting time of more free water and blocked the paths of bleed
the bleeding tests was delayed. The beneficial water channels.
988 Materials and Structures (2007) 40:981–988

3.3 Compressive strength Civil Engineering Department of the Hong Kong SAR
Government is thanked for providing the recycled
aggregate samples.
The results of the compression tests on concrete
cubes are shown in Table 7, where each value is the
average of three measurements. It can be seen References
from Table 7 that the compressive strength
decreases as the percentage of recycled aggregate 1. Hansen TC (1992) RILEM Reported 6, Recycling of
Demolished Concrete and Masonry. E&FN Spon,
increases. When 100% recycled aggregate was Bodmin, UK
used, the compressive strength of concrete was 2. Sagoe-Crentsil KK, Brown T, Taylor AH (2001)
reduced by about 24%. The replacement of cement Performance of concrete made with commercially
by 25% fly ash resulted in slight reductions in produced coarse recycled concrete aggregate. Cem
Conr Res 31:707–712
strength at the ages of up to 28 days, but increased 3. Poon CS, Shui ZH, Lam L, Fok H, Kou SC (2004)
strength at 90 days as compared to the corre- Influence of moisture states of natural and recycled
sponding mixes with the same percentage of recy- aggregates on the properties of fresh and hardened
cled aggregate without fly ash. For the mix with concrete, Cem Concr Res 34(1):31–36
4. Concrete Technology Unit of University of Dundee,
100% recycled aggregate, the fly ash increased the Demonstration project utilizing coarse recycled agg-
90-day compressive strength by about 10%. regates, Http//www.Dundee.ac.uk/civileng/research/
concrete/pii.I
5. Powers TC (1939) The bleeding of Portland cement
paste, mortar and concrete. Research Laboratory of
4 Conclusions Portland Cement Association, Bulletin 2, 1939
6. Steinour HH (1945) Further studies of Portland ce-
This paper presents the results of an experimental ment paste. Research Laboratory of Portland Cement
investigation on the properties of fresh concrete Association, Bulletin 4, 1945
7. Kasai YMI (1979) Studies on concrete strength of
prepared with recycled aggregates. The following structural in Japan. Symposium Papers, vol. 2, Quality
conclusions can be drawn: control of concrete structural, RILEM, Stockholm,
Sweden, June 1979
1. The use of recycled aggregates at an air-dried 8. Giaccio G, Giovambattista A (1986) Bleeding: evalu-
state in concrete resulted in higher initial ation of its effects on concrete behavior. Mater struct
slumps which took longer to decrease to zero (RILEM) 112:265–71
when compared with the concrete prepared 9. Devar JD (1982) Concrete durability: specifying
more simply and surely by strength. Concrete
with natural aggregates. The use of recycled 12(2):19–21
aggregates also resulted in a higher rate of 10. Wainwright PJ, Rey N (2000) The influence of ground
bleeding and bleeding capacity. granulated blastfurnace slag (GGBS) additions and
2. Delaying the starting of bleeding tests re- time delay on the bleeding of concrete. Cem Concr
Compos 22(4):253–257
duced the bleeding rate and bleeding capacity 11. Klieger P, Gebber SH (1986) Effect of fly ash on some
for both concrete mixes with and without of physical properties of concrete. Report of the
recycled aggregates. However, this delay Portland Cement Association, Item Code: RD
prolonged the process of bleeding. 089-USA
12. Aba M, Shoya M, Sugita S (2001) Application of fine
3. The replacement of cement by 25% fly ash mineral powders to reduce bleeding of concrete. 2001
increased the slump of concrete mixtures with Second International Conference on Engineering
and without recycled aggregates. It also had Materials, vol I, 607–614, 2001
beneficial effects in reducing the bleeding rate 13. BS 812: Part 103.1 Methods for determination of par-
ticle size distribution. British Standard Institution,
and bleeding capacity, with only minimal 1985
negative effects on concrete strength at or 14. BS 812: Part 111 Methods for determination of ten
before 28 days, but positive effects on the percent fines value (TFV). British Standard Institution,
strength at 90 days. 1990
15. American Society for Testing and Materials (1992).
ASTM C232–92, Standard test methods for bleeding of
Acknowledgements The authors wish to acknowledge concrete. ASTM Standards 4.02:139–42
the Environment and Conservation Fund and the Hong
Kong Polytechnic University for funding support. The

You might also like