Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/272232807
CITATIONS READS
10 2,214
1 author:
Predrag Dašić
Academy of Professional Studies Sumadija
222 PUBLICATIONS 729 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Interdisciplinary research in the field of dynamics and strength of mechanical systems View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Predrag Dašić on 14 February 2015.
1. INTRODUCTION
Life cycle is consecutive and interlinked stages of a product system, from raw
material acquisition or generation of natural resources to the final disposal.
Product and process life cycle topics are 7, 12-13:
LCA (Life-Cycle Analysis),
LCA (Life-Cycle Assessment),
LCC (Life-Cycle Cost),
LCD (Life-Cycle Design),
LCI (Life-Cycle Inventory),
LCIA (Life-Cycle Impact Assessment),
LCM (Life-Cycle Management),
LCS (Life-Cycle Strategy),
SCM (Supply Chain Management) etc.
High Technological Technical School, Kosanciceva 36, 37000 Krusevac, Serbia and
Montenegro
University of Bacău
Technical Faculty Cacak, Svetog Save 65, 32000 Cacak, Serbia and Montenegro
Dašić P., Nedeff V., Curčić S. -7-
All listed topics for life-cycle incorporate all scientific areas called LCE (Life-
Cycle Engineering).
Methodology for the life-cycle and sustainability analysis of manufacturing
processes is given in paper 6.
LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) is a methodology used to evaluate the potential
environmental impact of a product, process or activity throughout its entire life cycle
by quantifying the use of resources ("inputs" such as energy, raw materials, water) and
environmental emissions ("outputs" to air, water and soil) associated with the system
that is being evaluated.
The most important applications are:
Analysis of the contribution of the life cycle stages to the overall environmental
load, usually with the aim to prioritise improvements on products or processes and
Comparison between products for internal or external communications.
The first predecessor of LCA was the REPA (Resource and Environmental
Profile Analysis) in the 1960s and 1970s. First studies that were performed by REPA
were for Coca Cola Company and Mobil Corporation. Interest studies continued
through the 1980s as more sophisticated analysis 2.
Modern LCA methodology is root in the development of standards through the 1990s.
The SECAT (Society for Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, available on Web
site: http://www.setac.org/) in 1991 published A Technical Framework for Life Cycle
Assessments 3 as a first international LCA standard. Detailed LCA methodologies
were specified in 1995 by Nordic Council of Ministers.
ISO (International Organization for Standardization or International Standards
Organization, available on Web site: http://www.iso.org/ or http://www.iso.ch/)
released for the first time a general introductory framework on LCA (ISO 14040
standard) in 1997, and the ISO 14040 to 14043 standard series in late 1990s and early
2000s.
A partnership was launched in 2002 between UNEP (United Nations Environment
Programme, available on Web site: http://www.unep.org/) and SETAC in order to
form the UNEP/SETAC Life-Cycle Initiative to evaluate products using practical tools
and services to achive sustainable development (available on Web site:
http://www.uneptie.org/pc/sustain/lcinitiative/home.htm) and other initiatives 8.
In June 1992 a society for LCA called SPOLD (Society for Promotion of LCA
Development) was established, which is available on Web site: http://www.spold.org/
or http://lca-net.com/spold/.
Application of LCA is given in paper 1, LCA in industry and business in
paper 10, evaluation of environmental impacts in LCA 9 and integrating LCA
analysis and LCA in paper 25.
Structure of the life cycle assessment (LCA) is show in figure 1 5, 6.
2. STANDARDIZATION OF LCA
The ISO 14040 to 14043 standards describes the method presenting the
different options for the release of LCA. The ISO 14040 standards are a general
standard for the LCA area and were issued in 1997 from ISO subcommittee ISO TC
207/SC 5 (available on Web site: http://www.tc207.org/). Based on a goal and scope
definition, the environmental impacts of the important elements are scrutinized in a so-
called inventory analysis 14. After that, the impacts are assessed and interpreted in
order to improve the sustainability and the environmental friendliness of the analyzed
product. According to ISO 14040, the general framework of LCA is illustrated in
figure 2 14, 24.
The ISO 14040:1997 standard outlines the principles and the conduct of LCA
studies and how to reduce the overall environmental impact of products and services
14.
The ISO 14041:1998 standard in conjunction with ISO 14040 specifies
requirements and procedures to define the goal and scope for life cycle assessment,
performing, interpreting and reporting a LCI (Life-Cycle Inventory) analysis 15.
The ISO 14042:2000 standard provides guidance on a general framework for the LCIA
(Life-Cycle Impact Assessment) phase of LCA, and the key features and inherent
limitations of LCIA 4, 16.
Dašić P., Nedeff V., Curčić S. -9-
The ISO 14043:2000 standard summaries the final phase of the LCA
procedure, including the LCI (Life-Cycle Inventory) analysis and LCIA (Life-Cycle
Impact Assessment) 17.
The ISO 14047:2003 standard provides examples of application of ISO 14042
18 and ISO 14049:2000 standard provides examples of application of ISO 14041
20.
The ISO 14048:2002 standard provides the requirements and a structure for a
data documentation format, to be used for transparent and unambiguous documentation
and exchange of LCA (Life-Cycle Assessment) and LCI (Life-Cycle Inventory) data
19.
Fig.2 The framework of LCA with four interrelated phases, according to the ISO 14040
standard 13
Today there is a large number of developed software tools for LCA, whose
review is given in book 3 and paper 4. The list of the most important software tools
for product and process LCAs given in alphabetical order is as follows 5, 7-8, 21-22,
26-30, 32-34:
ACE (Active Community / Stakeholder Engagement Software), available on Web
site: http://www.acttiv.com/,
AME (A Modeling Environment), available on Web site:
http://helios.bto.ed.ac.uk/ierm/ame/,
ATHENA, available on Web site:
http://www.athenasmi.ca/ath_model/model_main.htm,
Boustead Model, available on Web site: http://www.boustead-consulting.co.uk/,
BeCost, available on Web site: http://pim.vtt.fi/becost/html/index.htm,
CLEAN (Comprehensive Least Emissions Analysis),
-10-
Analysis and evaluation of software tools for life cycle assessment
TEAM (Tool for Environmental Analysis and Management), available on Web site:
http://www.ecobalance.com/uk_team.php,
TEMIS (Total Emission Model for Integrated Systems),
TIET (Teleworking Impact Estimation Tool), available on Web site:
http://greenmfg.me.berkeley.edu/green/SoftwareTools/Telework/,
Umberto, available on Web site: http://www.umberto.de/en/home/,
WISARD (Waste - Integrated Systems Assessment for Recovery and Disposal),
available on Web site: http://www.ecobalance.com/uk_wisard.php,
WPC (Web-Based Paper Calculator), available on Web site:
http://www.ofee.gov/recycled/cal-index.htm and etc.
Out of a large number of software tools for LCA listed in chapter 3 an analysis
was performed of ten chosen software tools: GaBi, KCL-ECO, LCAiT, PEMS,
SimaPro and TEAM (table 1) 11, 26. The following criteria were taken into
consideration: Functionality, Flexibility, Database, User – friendliness, Software
properties, Service and Cost. The evaluation ranges from 1 (very negative) to 5 (very
positive). As this is a very subjective evaluation method we decided to disclose the
results and publish a non-aggregated rating for each tool and criterium. Even these
ratings are based on subjective impressions, therefore other individuals may come to
different findings.
According to evaluation in paper 11, 26 the new releases of software tools:
GaBi, KCL-ECO, LCAiT, PEMS, SimaPro and TEAM for LCA are the most
interesting software tools on the market.
In table 2 is presented a condensed and comparative evaluation of these unique
software tools (GaBi, KCL-ECO, LCAiT, PEMS, SimaPro and TEAM) features for
product and process LCAs 23.
5. CONCLUSION
All listed topics for life-cycle (LCA, LCC, LCD, LCI, LCIA, LCM, LCS etc.)
incorporate all scientific areas called LCE (Life-Cycle Engineering).
The general standard for the LCA area is ISO 14040 standards and was issued in 1997
by ISO subcommittee ISO TC 207/SC 5.
There is a large list of software tools for LCA, for example: BEES, CMLCA,
CUMPAN, ECO-it, EcoMan, EcoPro, EDIP, GaBi, KCL-ECO, LCAiT, PEMS,
REGIS, REPAQ, SDES, SimaPro, TEAM, TRACI, Umberto etc.
New releases of software tools: GaBi, KCL-ECO, LCAiT, PEMS, SimaPro and TEAM
for LCA are the most interesting software tools on the market.
Dašić P., Nedeff V., Curčić S. -13-
Table 1. Evaluation of the software tools for product and process LCAs
Characteristics GaBi KCL- LCAiT PEMS SimaPro TEA
ECO M
Functionality 5 4 4 3 2 4
Flexibility 3 3 3 3 3 4
Database 4 2 4 3 4 5
User – friendliness 5 4 3 2 2 3
Software properties 3 4 3 3 3 2
Service 5 3 4 3 3 5
Cost 4 2 3 3 5 2
Table 2. A condensed and comparative evaluation of these unique software tools for LCA
features
Characteristics GaBi KCL- LCAiT PEMS SimaPro TEA
ECO M
Graphical Interface
Data Protection
Unit Flexibility
Use of Formulas
Uncertainty Analysis
Impact Assessment
Comparison of Results
Graphical Display of Results
REFERENCES
[7] Dašić, P.: Encyclopedia of the Technical and ICT Abbreviations (in preparation
in Serbian language). Electronic Edition. Trstenik: High Technical Mechanical School. ISBN
86-83803-12-0.
[8] Dašić, P.; Nedeff, V.; Petropoulos G.: Internet resources and software tools for
life cycle assessment. Plenary and Invitation paper. In: Proceedings on CD-ROM of 6th
International Conference Research and Development in Mechanical Industy - RaDMI 2006,
Budva, Montenegro, 13-17. September 2006. Edited by Predrag Dašić. Kraljevo: Faculty of
Mechanical Engineering and Trstenik: High Technical Mechanical School, 2006, pp. 68-87.
ISBN 86-83803-21-X.
[9] Evaluation of environmental impacts in life cycle assessment. Meeting report,
Brussels, Belgia, 29-30. November 1998 and Brighton, 25-26. May 2000. Paris: United Nations
Environment Programme (UNEP), 2003. – 97 pp. ISBN 92-807-2144-5. Available on Web
site:http://www.uneptie.org/pc/sustain/reports/lcini/UNE.%20P_US%20EPA%20LCIA%20mtg
%20report.pdf.
[10] Frankl, P. and Rubik, F.: Life cycle assessment in industry and business.
Heidelberg (Germany): Springer, 2000. – 279 pp. ISBN 3-540-66469-6.
[11] Frühbrodt, E.: LCA software review – An up-to-date overview of the European
market. Workshop on life cycle data for assessment of environmental performance of EEE and
EU funded RTD activities on EEE ecodesign. Brussels, 9 October 2002. Available on Web site:
http://europe.eu.int/comm/enterprise/ electr_equipment/eee/workshop9-10-
02/present/lcasoftwarere.pdf.
[12] Hauschild, M.; Alting, L. and Poll, C.: Life cycle engineering – from
methodology to enterprise culture. Keynote paper. In: Proceedings of 11th International CIRP
Life Cycle Engineering Seminar: Product Life Cycle – Quality Management Issues, Belgrade,
Serbia and Montenegro, 20 - 22. June 2004. Edited by Leo Alting and Vidosav Majstorović.
Belgrade: Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and Association Serbia and Montenegro for
Quality and Standardization (JUSK), 2004, pp. 7-15. ISBN 86-903197-3-5.
[13] Herrmann, C.; Mateika, M.: Quality aspects of life cycle strategies. In:
Proceedings of 11th International CIRP Life Cycle Engineering Seminar: Product Life Cycle –
Quality Management Issues, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 20 - 22. June 2004. Edited by
Leo Alting and Vidosav Majstorović. Belgrade: Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and
Association Serbia and Montenegro for Quality and Standardization (JUSK), 2004, pp. 57-61.
ISBN 86-903197-3-5.
[14] ISO 14040:1997 Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment --
Principles and framework. Geneve: International Organization for Standardizations (ISO).
[15] ISO 14041:1998 Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment -- Goal
and scope definition and inventory analysis. Geneve: International Organization for
Standardizations (ISO).
[16] ISO 14042:2000 Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment -- Life
cycle impact assessment. Geneve: International Organization for Standardizations (ISO).
[17] ISO 14043:2000 Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment -- Life
cycle interpretation. Geneve: International Organization for Standardizations (ISO).
[18] ISO/TR 14047:2003 Environmental management -- Life cycle impact
assessment -- Examples of application of ISO 14042. Geneve: International Organization for
Standardizations (ISO).
[19] ISO/TS 14048:2002 Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment --
Data documentation format. Geneve: International Organization for Standardizations (ISO).
[20] ISO/TR 14049:2000 Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment --
Examples of application of ISO 14041 to goal and scope definition and inventory analysis.
Geneve: International Organization for Standardizations (ISO).
Dašić P., Nedeff V., Curčić S. -15-