Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research On Anthropometric Factors and Balance Stability of Figure Skaters
Research On Anthropometric Factors and Balance Stability of Figure Skaters
DOI: 10.37393/JASS.2020.01.7
ABSTRACT
One of the characteristics of modern figure skating is the progressive complication of the
competitive programs. This process develops, in particular, in the way of athletes’ mastery of
complex coordination elements and compounds of a rotating nature, which appear to be a strong
irritant to the vestibular analyzer. The aim of the present study was to investigate the influence of
anthropometric factors on the balance stability of female figure skaters. The study’s tasks, which
are divided into three groups, as well as the subject and object of the study, are presented. The
used methods are described. The methodology of the study is separated and detailed. Also, the
different abilities of the body for balance resistance, in various motor actions are described. One
of the main used methods is called Stabilometry. The design of the study is followed. The results
are visualized in six tables, which are illustrated by five figures. In conclusion, the dependence
of Anthropometric status is noted in accordance with the height and length of the lower limbs
and the width of the pelvis. The dynamic retention of the balance in landing position is more
effective than the static balance in the Romberg posture, which is explained by the specificity of
the sport figure skating. There is a worsening of the balance in the increase of anthropometric
parameters – height, weight and chest circumference. Balance fluctuations in the Romberg
position are significantly dependent on the weight and chest circumference, while the height of
the skaters affects the balance – with increasing amplitude there is also an increase in balance
fluctuations in the landing position after a jump, i.e. the balance is unstable, which is explained
by a higher placement of the center of gravity of the body.
balance, the beginner learns the art of ice skat- at opposing the forces of gravity under condi-
ing (Gikova, Tishinov, Zareva & Albert, 2012; tions of predominantly vertical gravity – de-
Tishinov, Albert, 2010). fined as a static balance (i.e. balance in static
In Free Skating Jumps, Spins, Spirals and posture). The presence of oscillating move-
Step Sequences are connected in conditions ments from the center of gravity of the body is
of continuous gliding in different poses and present due to unsustainable, according to the
require a good sense of balance (Panin, 1956). sports biomechanics, peculiarity of the pos-
No matter how technically well the jumps ture of the skater – the support of the athlete
are performed, losing balance in the landing is lower in relation to the general center of
phase or falling after the landing, touching of gravity of the body. In the dynamic balance of
the ice with hand or with the “free” foot spoil the figure skater besides the vertical force of
the impression of the figure skater’s perfor- the weight, there is also an acting inertial cen-
mance and diminish the judges’ marks. trifugal force resulting from the movement of
One of the characteristics of modern fig- the athlete on a curvilinear trajectory over
ure skating is the progressive complication the ice surface. Thus, when sliding along the
of the competitive programs. This process arc, the centrifugal force is directed towards
develops, in particular, in the way athletes the outer side of the trajectory. The power of
master complex coordination elements and weight forms a balancing torque directed in-
compounds of a rotating nature, which ap- ward to the radius of the curved trajectory.
pear to be a strong irritant to the vestibular The two rotating momentums are mutually
analyzer. The leading place in the programs balanced against the supporting surface of the
of the highly qualified skaters today is oc- skating blade. The power of weight counter-
cupied by Jumps, executed in three and four acts the action of centrifugal force, the torque
revolutions by 360°, Spins and Steps with the of which is directed in the opposite direction.
highest level of complexity. Good balance Thus, this kind of balance is dynamic (bal-
stability plays a major role in the implemen- ance in motion). While preserving a certain
tation of all these elements. posture, the body of a person is not absolutely
The figure skater’s ability to orient them- stationary, but fluctuates all the time – as if
selves in space and time, to quickly and ac- for a moment a person loses the balance and
curately perform the most complicated move- restores it again. The more perfect the func-
ments under conditions of small and unstable tion of balance in a person is, the quicker it re-
support is achieved by improving the analysts covers, the less the amplitude of fluctuations
involved in the balance reactions. To them, are. Therefore, those who are good at balance
except the vestibular analyzer, relate also the aren’t the ones who never lose it, but who
visual and motor analyzers. A sufficient level quickly regain it. According to the authors
of development of the balance allows for a (Gikova, Tishinov, Zareva & Albert, 2012;
faster mastery of the intricate technique of dif- Tishinov, Albert, 2010) balance stability is
ferent physical exercises at a higher technical characterized by amplitude and frequency of
level (Bondarevskiy, 1976). fluctuations of the center of the gravity of the
Balance is the ability of people to hold body relative to the support. It is evident that
the body or certain segments of the body at a with the descending centrifugal force and the
certain position as a result of a complex col- support on the skating blade, the support is
laboration of many organs and systems aimed not positioned vertically, but at an angle to the
88
JOURNAL of Applied Sports Sciences 01/2020
89
RESEARCH ON ANTHROPOMETRIC FACTORS AND ... Tatiana Yordanova
velopment of the individual signs and compo body height, body weight, chest circumfer-
nents of the motor abilities of the subjects ence, lower limb length, shoulder width,
studied, all participants took part in sports-pe pelvic width, foot length (Table 1 – Param-
dagogical testing. eters 1-8). Participants were wearing light
The measurement of anthropometric fac- clothing and no shoes during measurements.
tors is associated with sports typology. It Body height was measured with the use of
informs about the state of physical devel- a Martin anthropometer with an accuracy of
opment and the ergonomic anthropometric 0.1 cm and body weight was measured with
characteristics of the athletes. The anthro- calibrated electronic weighing scale with a
pometric profile of the athletes of a certain precision of 0.1 kg. To measure the shoulder
sport provides information about the spe- and pelvis width and foot length a spreading
cific morphological selection, as well as the caliper with an accuracy of 0.5 cm was used.
impact of this sport on the measurement of Chest volume and length of the lower limbs
body development of the athlete. Anthropo- were measured to the nearest 0.1 cm with the
metric measurement took place during the Lufkin W606PM tape measure. The anthro-
testing procedure twice: in July 2015 and in pometric procedures for those measurements
August 2017. All athletes underwent an an- were followed strictly.
thropometric assessment of 8 parameters:
Table 1. Measured parameters
№ Measured parameter Measure units Measurement accuracy
Anthropometric Factors
1 Body height [cm] 0.1
2 Body Weight [kg] 0,1
3 Chest Volume [cm] 0.1
4, 5 Length of right and left lower limbs [cm] 0.1
6, 7 Shoulder width, pelvis width [cm] 0.5
8 Foot length [cm] 0.5
Biomechanical Dynamic Indicators
9 Average (Romberg and Landing Test) [cm] 0.01
10 Frequency (Romberg and Landing Test) [Hz] 0.01
Balance stability is determined by the plifier-converter, from where the signals are
ability of the human body to maintain a verti- received through an interface in a computer
cal position at rest, when walking, jogging, or where they are recorded and analyzed. The
during various physical activities. The study technical diagram of the static testing device
of balance of the human body during a ba- and the algorithm for processing the signals
sic posture is carried out by Posturology. The according to the weight of the examined per-
method is called stabilometry. The results of son were published in 1980 (Tishinov, Mikov,
the static stabilometry of the examinees were Yordanov). The device is accompanied by a
obtained by means of a balance stability test- copyright certificate by the Republic of Bul-
ing device. It is made up of two platforms garia.
with four sensitive pressure detectors placed Biomechanical dynamic indicators – av-
between them and located on the corners of a erage and frequency. The “average” dimen-
square. The detectors are connected to an am- sion represents the mean of the maximum
90
JOURNAL of Applied Sports Sciences 01/2020
Range – difference
Biomechanicalbetween maximum
dynamic and indicators –
minimum value.
average and analysis
Correlation frequency. The to“average”
was used evaluate dimension
the strength of the relationship between quan-
represents the mean of the maximum amplitude
titative variables, and what the relationship
deviations,
between and the “frequency”
anthropometric factors and biome-is the number of
chanical dynamic balance characteristics is.
changes of the equilibrium function for the whole
Comparative analysis T-criterion of Stu-
test.for
dent Each participant
the dependent was measured
samples was appliedby to the method
find differences between first and second mea-
Figure 1. Landing pose
of stabilometry in the Romberg pose and during the
surement.
Figure 1. Landing pose
landing
All dataposition after a high
were initially jump
recorded in (Figure
Excel, 1). During
amplitude deviations, and the “frequency” and the analyses were performed with Statis-
the Romberg
is the number of test, the athletes
changes raise their foot
of the equilibrium ticaltoPackage
their knee, without
for the touchingVersion
Social Sciences it, and execute the
function for
balance on the
onewhole test.the
foot for Each 19.time, but no less than 30 seconds in static mode
participant test
designated
was measured by the method of stabilometry
Upon landing pose
in the Romberg afterandtheduring
jump,thethey aim as RESULTS
landing quickly as AND possible
DISCUSSION to achieve a minimum of
position after fluctuations,
equilibrium a high jump (Figure
which 1).is anDur- The movements
active process of the of figure skating
muscles. Theirathletes
aim is to maintain
ing the Romberg test, the athletes raise their are spatial and are performed on two- and
their
foot tobalance whilewithout
their knee, performing
touchingtheit,test
andandone-foot
also to skating,
establishasthewellpresence
as in theofnon-sup-
a descending trend
execute
in the balanceofonthe
the amplitude one des- porting Each
foot for the fluctuations.
equilibrium position (in themade
athlete execution
two of the jumpfor each test
attempts
ignated test time, but no less than 30 seconds elements) and depend on both the dynamic
of whichmode.
in static the better
Upon result
landingwasafterused for data.
the jump, parameters of the movement and the anthro-
they aim as quickly as possible to achieve a pometric factors of the athlete (Vinogradova,
minimum Data analysis fluctuations, which 2013). The studies carried out by V. Vino-
of equilibrium
is an active process of the muscles. Their aim gradova – 2013 indicate that skaters with a
The results from the research were processed with math-statistical methods.
is to maintain their balance while perform- conical shape of the body keep the skating
ing the testDescriptive statisticsthewas
and also to establish used tobalance
presence determinebetter.the variability
To create of the
the initial studied
rotation on indicators
of a descending trend in the amplitude of the the jumps, a cylindrical shape of the body is
calculation of sample’s mean (𝑋𝑋̅), standard deviation (S), coefficient of variation (Var) –
equilibrium fluctuations. Each athlete made preferable. For the skaters with a cylindrical
percentage,
two attempts for whicheachcharacterizes
test, of which thethe bet-
homogeneity
shape of the of body,
the studied
the angularpopulation,
velocity ωskewness
of (As)
ter result was used for data. the balance sliding is higher. The transforma-
kurtosis (Ex), maximum, minimum valuetionand Range
of this – difference
velocity between
into the rotational maximum and
speed
Data analysis
minimum value. during the phase of flight around its longitudi-
The results from the research were pro- nal axis increases the jump’s rotations.
cessed with Correlation analysis
math-statistical methods.was used to evaluate the strength
All anthropometric data of thetherelationship
from first and between
Descriptive variables,
quantitative statistics wasandusedwhat
to deter- second measurement
the relationship between are shown in Figure 2, factors and
anthropometric
mine the variability of the studied indicators: where we can clearly see an increase in all fac-
biomechanical dynamic
calculation of sample’s balance
mean ( ), characteristics
standard tors, whichis. is normal for adolescent girls. The
deviation Comparative
(S), coefficient analysis
of variation (Var) – highest
T-criterion of Studentgrowth is in height and the length of
for the dependent samples was applied to
percentage, which characterizes the homoge- the lower limbs, and the lowest – in the width
find
neity differences
of the studiedbetween
population,first and second
skewness (As), measurement.
of the pelvis.
kurtosis (Ex), maximum, minimum value and
All data were initially recorded in Excel, and the analyses were performed with
Statistical Package for the Social Sciences
91 Version 19.
I measurement II measurement
160.0 149.7
141.0
120.0
86.7
81.1 81.2
80.0 67.0
62.4
41.2
40.0 33.3 31.5 33.9
21.7 22.7 21.6 22.8
0.0
Height Weight Chest Length Length Shoulders' Pelvis Foot length
[cm] [kg] vol.[cm] r.leg [cm] l.leg [сm] width [cm] width [cm] [cm]
92
JOURNAL of Applied Sports Sciences 01/2020
of the test sample with the T-criterion of Stu- Some influence on them is also due to the ac-
dent for the dependent samples, due to the fact celeration factor of adolescent athletes, which
that the same contingents of investigated indi- has been observed in recent decades. Accel-
viduals were compared. The empirical value of eration is observed in the physical data but
the t-Student’s test exceeds the tabulated and also in the anthropometry of the body: today
identified critical levels (Table 4). An addition- children who are engaged in figure skating are
al circumstance is the fact that the guaranteed tall, slender and with long legs. In Table 4 and
probability Pt [%] exceeds the critical (95%) Figure 3 we present the data from the initial
value. Thus, with confidence we may reject the and final studies, as well as the absolute value
null hypothesis and accept the alternative for of the growth and its percentage equivalent.
the presence of a significant increase in data For clarity, the line shows the calculated ratio
from the test sample, relating to the growth of Student’s t-distribution and the guaranteed
in the anthropometric parameters (Figure 2). probability Pt.
Table 4. Comparative analysis of the variables
Variables I meas. II meas. d D [%] t Pt [%]
Body height [cm] 141.0 149.7 8.8 6.2 -16.5 100.00
Body weight [kg] 33.3 41.2 7.9 23.7 -13.6 100.00
Chest vol. [cm] 62.4 67.0 4.6 7.4 -12.1 100.00
Length right leg [cm] 81.1 86.9 5.8 7.1 -11.8 100.00
Length left leg [cm] 81.2 86.7 5.5 6.7 -11.4 100.00
Shoulder width [cm] 31.5 33.9 2.4 7.6 -11.0 100.00
Pelvis width [cm] 21.7 22.7 1.0 4.5 -4.2 99.98
Foot length [cm] 21.6 22.8 1.1 5.3 -10.0 100.00
93
RESEARCH ON ANTHROPOMETRIC FACTORS AND ... Tatiana Yordanova
their foot to their knee, without touching it, and A large load on the vestibular system is
execute the balance on one foot for the desig- caused by performing multi-revolution jumps,
nated test time, but not less than 30 seconds spins, etc. The execution of repeated rotations
in static mode. Upon landing after the jump, during jumps, followed by a soft landing on
the participants aim as quickly as possible to one-foot sliding, requires the precision of
achieve a minimum of balance fluctuations, movement in time and space.
which is an active process for the muscles in Scientists’ research shows that skaters are
their aim to manage the balance when perform- able to withstand significant rotational loads,
ing the test and also to establish the presence of while retaining the accuracy of performed
a descending trend in the amplitude of the bal- movements.
ance fluctuations. This quality of the balance The balance oscillations after landing in
apparatus is valuable in terms of improving the jumps are characterized by a downward trend.
technical mastery and skills of figure skaters. Even in the researches of L. V. Latmanizova’s
The basis of figure skating is sliding, main- (1931) it was found that there is a connec-
ly in a single support position. The art of slid- tion between balance, dynamic indicators and
ing is achieved as a result of management of a speed-force capabilities.
number of components, such as a correct pose, The manifestation of the speed-force ca-
sense of balance etc. (Mishin, 1981). G. Lyussi pabilities in performing a wide range of tasks
and M. Richards (1959) considered that “the is determined by the level of muscle develop-
first condition for practicing figure skating, ment, which simultaneously perform a func-
without which progress is absolutely impossi tion against gravity. It is known that the correct
ble, is to find a proper and natural balance. Only mutual disposition of the units of the body has
with a sense of balance can the movements of a significant influence on muscle tension and
figure skating be successfully absorbed.” fluctuations of the center of gravity.
Figure 4. Standing in balance position – landing after a jump – maximum amplitude deviations
In Figure 4 the vector sum is in a declining “average” dimension represents the mean of
trend, which is a proof of a good balance. The the maximum amplitude deviations, and the
94
JOURNAL of Applied Sports Sciences 01/2020
“frequency” is the number of changes of the statistically significant (Pt was higher than
balance function for the entire duration of the 95%). This is completely logical, since both
study. It is evident that the quality of mini- exercises are quite different in nature. On the
mizing balance fluctuations is very useful in other hand, the frequency of the balance func-
sports practice. tion does not change in statistically signifi-
The studied amplitude average variables cant way, since the guarantee probability is
and the instability factor found in the Rom- 80% and is lower than the limit value (95%)
berg test and upon landing after a jump are (Table 5).
Table 5. Comparative analysis of the variables between two tests – Landing and Romberg
“Landing” test “Romberg” test
Variables average frequency factor average [cm] frequency [Hz] factor
[cm] [Hz]
3.60 4.63 0.72 7.62 4.94 1.76
S 1.82 0.94 0.43 3.56 0.51 0.94
Var 51% 20% 59% 47% 10% 54%
Ex 1.68 10.56 2.28 1.35 -0.21 -0.17
As 1.02 -2.92 1.25 1.05 0.30 0.72
Max 8.65 5.50 1.95 17.05 6.01 3.77
Min 1.17 1.11 0.21 3.21 4.00 0.53
R 7.48 4.39 1.74 13.84 2.01 3.24
t Romberg/Landing -4.96 -1.35 -4.65 Statistically significant differences
Pt [%] Romberg/Landing 100.0 80.5 100.0 were found between two tests
An interesting fact is that during the Rom- retention of balance after the jump is more
berg test we received higher average values efficient than the static balance position Rom-
(average = 7,62 cm), as opposed to the test berg, which is explained by the specificity of
landing after a jump, which obtained the the sport figure skating.
average = 3,60 cm (Figure 5). The dynamic
Figure 5. Differences in absolute values in “Romberg” test and landing after the jump
The correlation analysis of the variables in vided into two groups. One of these groups is
the study sample of the group of competitors the results of the anthropometric tests, and the
(Table 6) includes an analysis with Pearson’s second one is balance variables.
multiple correlation. The variables can be di-
95
RESEARCH ON ANTHROPOMETRIC FACTORS AND ... Tatiana Yordanova
96
JOURNAL of Applied Sports Sciences 01/2020
of the lower limbs, and the lowest in the width Glyazer, S. V. (1969). Azbuka nachinay-
of the pelvis. The comparative analysis with ushtego figurista, Fizkultura i sport, Moskva.
T-criterion of Student for the dependent sam- // Глязер, С. В. (1969). Азбука начинающего
ples proved statistically significant increase фигуриста, Физкультура и спорт, Москва.
in anthropometric factors of tested athletes in Latmanizova, L. V. (1931). Ergebnisse aus
figure skating. The dynamic retention of the zephalographischen Aufzeichnungen. Arbe-
balance in landing position is more effective iten des Leningrader Inst. Zum stadium von
than static balance in the Romberg posture, Berufskrankheiten, Bd. 5.
which is explained by the specificity of figure Lyussi, G., Richards, M. (1959). Figurnoe
skating. However, there is a worsening of the katanie na konkah, Fizkultura i sport, Moskva.
balance in increasing of anthropometric pa- // Люсси, Г., Ричардс, М. (1959). Фигурное
rameters – height, weight and chest circum- катание на коньках, Физкультура и спорт,
ference. Balance fluctuations in the Romberg Москва.
position are significantly dependent on the Mishin, A. N. (1981). Biomehanika dviz
weight and chest circumference – r – .499- heniy figuristov, Fizkultura i sport, Moskva.
.508, while the height of the skaters affects // Мишин, А. Н. (1981). Биомеханика дви-
the balance – with increasing amplitude there жений фигуристов, Физкультура и спорт,
is also an increase in balance fluctuations Москва.
in the landing position after a jump, i.e. the Monsma, D. & Malina, R. (2005). Anthro-
balance is unstable, which is explained by a pometry and somatotype of competitive fe-
higher placement of the center of gravity of male figure skaters 11-22 years. Variation by
the body. competitive level and discipline. J Sports Med
Phys Fitness. 2005 Dec; 45(4):491-500.
REFERENCES Mostaert, M., Deconinck, F, Pion, J., Lenoir,
Bondarevskiy, E. Ya. (1976). Otsenka M. (2016). Anthropometry, Physical Fitness
fizicheskoy podgotovlennosti, Fizkultura i and Coordination of Young Figure Skaters
sport, Moskva. // Бондаревский, Е. Я. (1976), of Different Levels. International Journal of
Оценка физической подготовленности. Sports Medicine. 2016 Jun; 37(7):531-8. doi:
Физкультура и спорт, Москва. 10.1055/s-0042-100280.
Vinogradova, V. I. (2013). Osnovi biome- Paluchowska, M. (2015). The Role of In-
haniki prizhkov v figurnom katanii, Sovetskiy tense Physical Activity in the Formation of
sport, Moskva. // Виноградова, В. И. (2013). Body Shape – Research Based on Female Fig-
Основы биомеханики прыжков в фигурном ure Skaters. Pomeranian journal of life sci-
катании, Советский спорт, Москва. ences, 61 (3), pp.310-4.
Gikova, M., Tishinov, O., Zareva, I. & Al- Panin, N. A. (1956). Iskusstvo figurista,
bert, E. (2012). “Comparative analysis of the Fizkultura i sport, Moskva. // Панин, Н. А.
balance stability in ballet, rhythmic gymnas- (1956). Искусство фигуриста, Физкультура
tics and chi gunk athletes”, Sport and Science и спорт, Москва.
(56) LVI (5), pp. 33-39. Tishinov, O., Albert, E. (2010). Izsled-
Gigova, V. (2014). Statisticheski metodi vane na ravnovesnata ustoychivost pri stat-
sus SPSS Statistics 19, Sofia. // Гигова, В. ichno-silovi uprazhnenia v iztochnite boyni
(2014). Статистически методи със SPSS iskustva, 5-ti mezhdunaroden kongres “Sport,
Statistics 19, София. stress, adaptatsia”. // Тишинов, О., Алберт,
97
RESEARCH ON ANTHROPOMETRIC FACTORS AND ... Tatiana Yordanova
Corresponding author:
Tatiana Yordanova
Technical and Ice Sports department
National Sports Academy “Vassil Levski”
21, Acad. Stefan Mladenov str.
Sofia 1700, Bulgaria
E-mail: tania.yordanova@online.bg
98