8/21/2021 Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded | Financial Times

Afghanistan
Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded
Increasing inevitability about the Taliban advance made soldiers wonder what they were fighting for

Afghan army commandos held the line against the Taliban in some cities, such as Lashkar Gah, until they were withdrawn © Elsie
Blanchard/AFP via Getty Images

Amy Kazmin and Benjamin Parkin in New Delhi and Katrina Manson in Washington
DC AUGUST 15 2021

Afghanistan updates
Sign up to myFT Daily Digest to be the first to know about Afghanistan news.

Enter your email address Sign up

Just six weeks ago, Joe Biden seemed confident that the 300,000 men of the Afghan
National Defence and Security Forces had the training, equipment and competence to
hold off a Taliban takeover of the country after the US withdrew its military forces.

“The likelihood there’s going to be the Taliban overrunning everything and owning the
whole country is highly unlikely,” the US president said in early July, as he affirmed
his determination to complete the US pullout by August 31. “We provided our Afghan
partners with all the tools — let me emphasise all the tools, training and equipment of
any modern military.”

https://www.ft.com/content/b1d2b06d-f938-4443-ba56-242f18da22c3 1/6
8/21/2021 Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded | Financial Times

Yet despite the Afghan forces’ superior weaponry and training, Taliban fighters this
week mounted a lightning offensive that enabled them to capture more than two-
thirds of Afghanistan’s territory and reach the outskirts of the capital Kabul, often
with little resistance.

The Afghan army troops simply melted away, stood down or retreated to their bases,
despite the billions spent on their training and equipment by the US and its allies. In
some cases, they left advanced weaponry to be seized by the motorbike riding,
Kalashnikov-wielding Islamist militiamen.

Former western military officials and independent academics say the collapse of the
Afghan armed forces reflects widespread public disillusionment with President Ashraf
Ghani’s government, chronic corruption and mismanagement within the armed
forces, and a sheer lack of confidence among the troops that they could win against
the Taliban without US military and intelligence support.

A handover ceremony from the US army to the Afghan national army, in Helmand province, south Afghanistan, in May © Afghan
Ministry of Defense Press Office via AP
“The problem with the army was not lack of training or weapons. The most important
thing in war is politics,” said Mike Martin, a former British army officer and author of
a book about Afghanistan’s decades-long conflict, An Intimate War.

Martin said that Ghani, a World Bank technocrat who wrote a book on reconstructing
failed states before he was elected president in 2014, lacked the political skills to keep
the country’s many different ethnic groups loyal to the idea of a national cause.

https://www.ft.com/content/b1d2b06d-f938-4443-ba56-242f18da22c3 2/6
8/21/2021 Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded | Financial Times

When faced with an imminent US pullout, many Afghans’ more traditional ethnic,
tribal and even family ties overshadowed any loyalty they might feel to the nascent
Afghan army, enabling provincial Taliban commanders to negotiate the virtually
peaceful surrender of many troops.

https://www.ft.com/content/b1d2b06d-f938-4443-ba56-242f18da22c3 3/6
8/21/2021 Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded | Financial Times

“The Taliban political franchise was able to peel off bits of the government because the
government did not tend to its constituents enough — the tribes, clans, militias and
ethnicities. That is the fundamental issue,” Martin said. “The army commanders just
surrendered in return for amnesty, which the Taliban granted them and let them go
home.”

Former US president Donald Trump’s February 2020 deal with the Taliban, combined
with Biden’s determination to adhere to it without a well-planned military transition
plan, emboldened the Taliban and hit the morale of the Afghan armed forces just as
the country was beginning its fighting season. This generally runs from April to
October, before winter leaves much of the country snowbound.

Ali Yawar Adili, country director of the Afghanistan Analysts Network, said Afghan
troops were deeply rattled by the abrupt manner in which US logistical and air
support was withdrawn. Many Afghans — including Ghani — never expected that.

“[Afghan forces] heavily relied on the air support provided by the US forces, and also
logistical support provided by US contractors, and those supports are no longer
there,” he said.

Afghan troops were rattled by the speed with which US logistical and air support was withdrawn © Wakil Kohsar/AFP via Getty
Images
Elizabeth Threlkeld, a former US state department official and now a senior official at
the Stimson Centre in Washington, said the Taliban’s rapid advance and the peaceful
surrender of some army units had encouraged many others to follow suit.

https://www.ft.com/content/b1d2b06d-f938-4443-ba56-242f18da22c3 4/6
8/21/2021 Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded | Financial Times

“It takes on an air of inevitability,” she said. “If you’re in one of those provincial
capitals that remains, you have to ask yourself, ‘what am I fighting for and what are
my odds of success?’ What we’ve seen is [Afghan troops] recognising the writing on
the wall and taking steps to protect their own interests rather than putting up a fight.”

A former senior US military official said that the Afghan Air Force was especially hard
hit by the departure of more than 15,000 contractors who used to help keep US-
provided planes and helicopters flying.

“Its [the air force’s] operational readiness is being degraded as it is being pushed all
over the country trying to respond to different desperate situations,” the official said.
“Once the troops realise no one is coming to the rescue . . . they will desert, flee or
surrender.”

Not all Afghan forces have given up without resistance. Special Forces commandos
fought hard and held the line against the Taliban in some cities, like Lashkar Gah,
until they were withdrawn. But they were simply too few to stave off the nationwide
onslaught.

Meanwhile, the armed forces have been plagued by corruption, such as the issue of
“ghost soldiers” who exist on paper but are not real — allowing others to collect their
salaries.

Although there are officially 300,000 Afghan troops, Threlkeld said that “it’s fair to
say that in reality there are far fewer”.

But what also contributed to the collapse is the Ghani government’s denial that Biden
would indeed withdraw the last US troops and their military contractors from
Afghanistan this year — and its resultant failure to prepare.

“Ghani and those around him just couldn’t believe that the Americans had just
deserted them like that,” said Pakistani analyst Ahmed Rashid, author of several
books on central and south Asia. “There was this hope that the worse the situation
became the more obvious it would be that they had to stay.”

Letter in response to this article:

Biden’s withdrawal of air support was key / From Steven Canby, Retired Military
Analyst, Adjunct Professor of Military History, Georgetown University,
Washington, DC, US

https://www.ft.com/content/b1d2b06d-f938-4443-ba56-242f18da22c3 5/6
8/21/2021 Low morale, no support and bad politics: why the Afghan army folded | Financial Times

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2021. All rights reserved.

https://www.ft.com/content/b1d2b06d-f938-4443-ba56-242f18da22c3 6/6