Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Entrance examination is currently used as part of the admission criteria for higher education
institutions in the Philippines. It is very vital to determine its predictive validity in order to ensure
the objectivity and accuracy of admission decisions. This study was conducted to determine the
predictive validity of entrance examination in predicting academic performance of BS in Hotel
and Restaurant Management (BSHRM) and BS in Hospitality and Tourism Management
(BSHTM) freshmen students enrolled at University of Saint Louis in the school year 2013-2014.
It utilized descriptive-correlational design in analyzing the Verbal Intelligence Test (VIT), Non-
Verbal Intelligence Test (NVIT) and Grade Point Average (GPA) of the respondents.
Correlational and regression analysis were conducted to analyze the relationship between the
entrance examination score and the academic performance of the respondents. Results showed
that VIT scores of HRM freshmen students are highly correlated to their average GPA and
GECs while moderately correlated to their GPA in major subjects. Their NVIT scores also
showed high correlation to their average GPA, GECs and GPA of major subjects. On the other
hand, the VIT and NVIT scores of HTM freshmen students showed moderate correlation to their
average GPA and GECs while high correlation to their GPA in major subjects. Finally, the study
has shown that VIT and NVIT scores in the entrance examination are found to be statistically
significant predictors of GPA, GPA of Major courses and GPA of GECs of BSHRM and BSHTM
freshmen students.
INTRODUCTION
Earlier studies had focused on determining the predictive validity of admission test on
the academic performance of students in various courses and programs but the findings of
these studies and conclusions showed different results. For some fields of study, for instance,
college entrance examination scores as an admission criterion was found as a valid process
since it significantly predicts the grade weighted average and units earned by the students (Bai,
Chi, & Qian, 2013; Fabito, Rodriguez, & Bangit, 2019; Belfield, Krishnakumar & Dutt, 2017;
Sebastian, A. and Sebastian, J., 2014). There are also research findings which disclose the low
association of college entrance test scores with college grade point average (Belfield & Crosta,
2012; Zekarias et. al, 2015). Wambugu & Emeke (2013) also found that entry qualification and
academic performance were found significantly correlated but not in all subjects. Thus, it
concluded that entrance exam is not the best variable to predict academic performance, though
this parameter should not be ignored in admission exercises.
In spite of the number of studies that examined the predictive validity of admission tests
with respect to various courses or programs, there seem to be no studies made in the field of
BS in Hotel and Restaurant Management (BSHRM) and BS in Hospitality and Tourism
Management (BSHTM) programs that explores a possible correlation between an entrance
exam and their academic performance. Thus, the study intends to determine the possible
correlation between the result of entrance examination and the academic grades of freshmen
students.
This study sought to determine the predictive validity of entrance examination in predicting
the academic performance of BS in Hotel and Restaurant Management (BSHRM) and BS in
Hospitality and Tourism Management (BSHTM) freshmen students. Specifically, it answered the
following questions:
1. Can the Verbal Intelligence Test (VIT) scores predict the following:
a. Grade Point Average (GPA)
b. Grade Point Average (GPA) of Major Courses
c. Grade Point Average (GPA) of General Education Courses (GECs)
2. Can the Non Verbal Intelligence Test (NVIT) scores predict following:
a. Grade Point Average (GPA)
b. Grade Point Average (GPA) of Major Courses
c. Grade Point Average (GPA) of General Education Courses (GECs)
Hypotheses
1. There is no significant relationship between results in the Verbal Intelligence Test (VIT)
and Academic Performance of Hotel and Restaurant Management (HRM) and
Hospitality and Tourism Management (HTM) freshmen students.
2. There is no significant relationship between results in the Non-Verbal Intelligence Test
(NVIT) and Academic Performance of Hotel and Restaurant Management (HRM) and
Hospitality and Tourism Management (HTM) freshmen students.
The result of this study can be valuable in various ways. First, the findings will be
significant to the USL administrators and policymakers as it will provide guidance in developing
better admission policy and screening process given to incoming freshmen in predicting
academic performance. Second, the findings might help the guidance counsellors in assisting
college transition needs by being able to better identify students at risk for dropping out. Third, it
will also inform intervention programs and thus serves as a motivation for further research that
can be designed to enhance success and retention rates of the existing admission policy and
career placement of students.
Theoretical Framework
This study is anchored on Gardner’s Multiple Intelligence Theory which states that
individuals differ in the strength of intelligences such as in linguistic, logical-mathematical
analysis, spatial, musical, bodily-kinesthetic, naturalistic, interpersonal, intrapersonal intelligence
(Armstrong, 2019). This theory further believed that intelligence can be measured in person’s
many diverse characteristics which can be independent of each other, hence, test
measurements can be deliberated with concrete strategies for addressing the needs of every
learner. In this current study, entrance exam results are assumed to have an effect on the
academic performance of HRM and HTM freshmen, represented by their grade point average
(GPA). Since the kind of entrance exam in the University is an aptitude test intended to predict
an individual’s potential to learn certain skills. It is reasonable to assume that entrance test
scores (VIT and NVIT) are significantly correlated to the academic performance of students. The
results would be suggestive of what type of intelligence one has, thus increasing the chances of
one’s success in his chosen course.
Literature Review
Over the years, most colleges require entering students to take entrance tests and use the
scores as the sole determinant of whether students are ready for college-level coursework. The
scores obtained during the entrance test indicate the baseline academic preparation when they
enter the university. The type of entrance test conducted in University of Saint Louis is an
aptitude test which is known as Acorn National Aptitude Test-Verbal and Non Verbal Test.
Similarly, some schools are administering aptitude tests such as General Aptitude Test (GAT) in
KSA, Differential Aptitude Test (DAT) in Argentina, American College Test (ACT) or Scholastic
Aptitude Test (SAT) in United States and so on. It is assumed that the primary role of aptitude
tests is to predict students’ likely performance on a college or university course (McDonald,
et.al, 2001).
Moreover, Takele (2019) stated that college entrance exam is an assessment designed to
measure a student’s readiness for college academic success. It was further cited that the
number one goal of using college admission variables or factors in the admission decision
process is to accurately identify and admit potentially successful applicants.
Sulphey, Al-Kahtani, & Syed (2018) also revealed that better grades in standardized
eligibility tests are considered a basic requirement for admission to university programs. This is
based on the thought pattern that, learning being an accumulative process, student admitted
with higher entry qualification is expected to be well prepared for the course content than those
with lower qualifications.
On the other hand, there were studies found that entrance exam scores are positively but
low associated with college grade point average such as (Belfield & Crosta, 2012) and
university in Ethopia (Zekarias et. al, 2015). In addition, Wambugu & Emeke (2013) found that
there was a significant positive correlation between entry qualification and academic
performance of undergraduate science courses in chemistry and biology but no correlation in
physics, whereas in others such as nursing and medicine, its prediction capacity is not
significantly in the statistical meaning (Corengia, et., al, 2012). Thus, it further concluded in
some studies, that entrance exam alone does not yield strong predictions of how student will
perform in college, though this parameter should not be ignored in admission exercises.
Research Paradigm
VIT GPA
NVIT
The paradigm shows that the independent variable, which is the entrance exam scores
that is categorized as Verbal Intelligence Test (VIT) and Non Verbal Intelligence Test (NVIT)
maybe correlated to the dependent variable which is the academic performance of freshmen
students.
METHODS
The study made use of the descriptive-correlational research design since it seeks to
determine the correlation between the scores in the entrance examination and the first semester
grade point average of Hotel and Restaurant Management (HRM) and Hospitality and Tourism
Management (HTM) freshmen students enrolled at University of Saint Louis Tuguegarao in the
school year 2013-2014. The study made use of correlation and regression to determine the
relationship of the entrance examination and the student’s grade point average. Their scores in
Verbal Intelligence Test (VIT) and Non Verbal Intelligence Test (NVIT) and their corresponding
grade point average were determined from the data gathered by the College Guidance Center
and the Registrar respectively. The scores of the HRM and HTM students in the entrance exam
and their grades in general education and major courses were analyzed using the following
scales:
Legend:
RESULTS
Table 1: Correlation of VIT Scores in the Entrance Examination with College GPA of HRM
Freshmen Students
Table 1 shows that the VIT scores of HRM freshmen and their GPA, GPA of Major
courses and GPA of GECs are significantly correlated. Specifically, the VIT scores of HRM
freshmen students are strongly correlated to their GPA and GPA of GECs while moderately
correlated to their GPA of Major courses. The table further shows that the VIT scores could
predict the academic performance of HRM freshmen in their GPA, GPA of Major courses and
GPA of GECs. It further suggests that the higher the VIT scores it is most likely that the GPA is
higher.
Table 2: Correlation of NVIT Scores in the Entrance Examination with College GPA of HRM
Freshmen Students
Table 2 indicates high correlation between NVIT and GPA which means that the
academic performance of freshmen students can be predicted by their NVIT examination score.
Their NVIT scores are also found to have high correlation with their GPA in Major courses while
moderate correlation to their GPA in GECs. This implies that the NVIT could predict the
academic performance of the HRM freshmen students. It further implies that the higher the
NVIT, the higher the GPA.
Table 3: Correlation of VIT Scores in the Entrance Examination with College GPA of HTM
Freshmen Students
Variables Mean R R2 p-value Interpretation
GPA(Total) 81.3448 .433 .187 .000 Reject Ho
VIT 51.8522
GPA (Major Courses) 82.5304 .737 .544 .000 Reject Ho
VIT 51.8522
GPA (GEC) 81.4222 .491 .241 .000 Reject Ho
VIT 51.8522
Table 3 shows that the VIT scores of HTM freshmen and their GPA, GPA of Major
courses and GPA of GECs are significantly correlated. The table also indicates that the VIT
scores of HTM freshmen students is moderately correlated with GPA and GECs while highly
correlated with their GPA in Major courses. This also suggests that the higher the VIT scores, it
is most likely that the GPA is higher. Finally, it suggests that the VIT scores are found to be
statistically significant predictors of HTM freshmen in their GPA, GPA Major and GECs subjects’
academic performance.
Table 4: Correlation of NVIT Scores in the Entrance Examination with College GPA of HTM
Freshmen Students
Table 4 shows that the NVIT scores of HTM freshmen and their GPA, GPA of Major
courses and GPA of GECs are significantly correlated. The table further shows that the NVIT
scores has moderate correlation in the GPA and GPA in GECs of students while strong
correlation in GPA of major subjects. This means that the NVIT scores could predict the
success in the academic performance of HTM freshmen students in their GPA, GPA major
subjects and GPA GEC subjects. The table also suggests that the higher the NVIT scores, the
higher the GPAs in the above mentioned areas.
DISCUSSION
The result of the study shows a positive relationship between the entrance examination
and the academic performance of HRM and HTM students which implies that the VIT and NVIT
scores could aptly predict academic performance of the students. The existence of a positive
relationship in the VIT and NVIT entrance exam result and the GPA also signifies that the higher
the respondents’ VIT and NVIT scores, the higher their GPAs.
Specifically, the findings of this study revealed that the HRM freshmen performed
average low to their VIT scores which implies that most of the respondents failed to perform the
necessary learning competencies along verbal competencies. In short, they lack the needed
potential to perform certain skills on the basic understanding of verbal domain which suggests
that they need more training to enhance their verbal reasoning or else majority of the students
would most likely to perform poorly to their future academic training. Moreover, it can also be
gleaned that majority of the respondents performed fairly to their GPA in Major courses which
suggests that HRM students can handle their academic performance in major subjects. It further
shows that the respondents have good knowledge on this domain, thereby, they would most
likely to succeed in their professional subjects. In contrary, majority of the students performed
poorly to their GPA and GPA in GECs. This could signify that most students have not grasped
the essential content and performance to meet the requirement of the course or some may have
not completed the subjects hence they performed poorly. Furthermore, the NVIT scores of HRM
freshmen students scored average which means that they have obtained the standard skill in
assessing the consistency, objectivity and credibility of non-verbal reasoning. Their GPA in
major courses performed fairly which also signifies that majority of the respondents can handle
their academic performance in major subjects. This result illustrates that they show competence
along professional subjects using their non-verbal intelligence such as spatial, motor skills and
so on. Their GPA and GPA in GECs also performed poorly which suggests that the respondents
find difficulty to meet the necessary requirement of the course. Since majority of the
respondents obtained low scores to their VIT and NVIT, it is safe to assume that they would
most likely to obtain low scores in the future. However, possible assistance such as tutorial
classes, guidance on study skills, academic counseling and continuous monitoring and other
basic academic skills can be organized in order to help HRM students with low scores to meet
the standard requirement of the program.
On the other hand, HTM freshmen performed average both to their VIT and NVIT scores
while performed fairly to their GPA, GPA of Major courses and GPA of GECs. This implies that
HTM freshmen would most likely to succeed in their academic training in the university. It further
suggests that the HTM freshmen students can handle their academic performance in GPA, GPA
of Major courses and GPA of GECs since they show necessary skills and competence of the
course or program. Thus, majority of the HTM freshmen students would most likely to succeed
academically in the above-mentioned areas.
The result of the study in this regard affirms the findings of Montalbo, Evangelista &
Bernal (2018) showing significant level that suggests that the admission test scores has a
significant relationship with academic performance. It further stated that the higher the
admission test result, the higher the academic performance and the reverse is also true for low
scores on the admission test of political science and psychology students. Similar results were
also taken such as in Chinese Universities (Bai, Chi, & Qian, 2013), computing and information
programs (Fabito, Rodriguez, & Bangit, 2019), engineering programs (Tupas, 2005, Belfield,
Krishnakumar & Dutt, 2017), business administration programs (Sebastian, A. and Sebastian,
J., 2014), However, in the study Corengia, et., al (2012) the entrance exam scores predict
moderately in some programs only such as business, engineering, law and social
communication, whereas in others such as nursing and medicine, its prediction capacity is not
significantly in the statistical meaning. Moreover, some studies found that entrance exam scores
are positively but low associated with college grade point average (Belfield & Crosta, 2012;
Zekarias et. al, 2015). Wambugu & Emeke (2013) also confirmed that there was a significant
positive correlation between entry qualification and academic performance of undergraduate
science courses in some subjects. This further means that in some studies, admission test
scores alone do not yield strong predictions of how student will perform in college, though this
parameter should not be ignored in admission exercises.
Looking further at the result, the direct relationship in the VIT scores and GPA, GPA of
Major courses and GPA of GECs of HRM and HTM freshmen students could be explained by
the fact that academic learning is predominantly verbal in nature, thus, a verbal intelligence test
will usually predict academic success (McLeod & Cropley (2013). Moreover, in Gardner’s
multiple intelligence theory, verbal intelligence is defined as the ability to think words and use
those words to express one’s thoughts to others. In school, this intelligence is vital to good
school performance, as most subjects require reading and writing skills. Basic verbal reasoning
may also be evaluated through VIT in order to identify how well an individual can do this, and
then to improve upon it if necessary. It is also added by Dawson (2013) that a person’s verbal
intelligence is usually assessed through performance on one or more specific tests involving
receptive and/or expressive spoken language. Since success in school places heavy demands
on students’ abilities to use language to express their thoughts and to understand other people’s
attempts to express their thoughts, it only shows that the respondents, whose abilities lie on the
verbal aspect, which could be measured through tests, have higher probability to succeed in
their academic endeavors. In short, students’ who would most likely to succeed in formal
schooling will be those who are best able to reason verbally, which is measured by the VIT.
On the other hand, the correlation result of the NVIT scores and GPA, GPA of Major
courses and GPA of GECs of HRM and HTM students means that the NVIT could aptly predict
their academic performance. This result may have been due to the fact that NVIT has scales
that could measure a wide variety of academic skills or abilities for the HRM and HTM students
such as the ability to analyze information and solve problems using visual or hands-on
reasoning. The non-verbal intelligence usually describes thinking skills and problem-solving
abilities about visual information that do not fundamentally require verbal language production
and comprehension but it may vary in the amount of internalized, abstract, or conceptual
reasoning and motor skills that are required to complete a task (Kuschner, 2013). This is further
supported by the description of the test that NVIT is designed to assess intelligence in the form
of pictures or diagrams rather than words (McLeod & Cropley, 2013). Hence, it is reasonable to
assume that those who would score high in this test has propensity for training in technical
subjects and could predict the probability of success in these areas.
CONCLUSION
Based on the findings of this study, it is concluded that entrance test results are found to
be significantly related with the academic performance of BSHRM and BSHTM students.
Specifically, the VIT and NVIT scores are found to be statistically significant predictors of GPA,
GPA of Major courses and GPA of GECs of BSHRM and BSHTM freshmen students. It is
therefore important to administer these tests in order to guide and advice examinees as to the
program that would suit them in the university.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The findings of this study seem to have some practical implications to the selection
criteria of USL and future direction of research.
References
Bai, C. E., Chi, W., & Qian, X. (2013). Do College Entrance Examination Scores Predict
Undergraduate GPAs? A Tale of Two Universities. SSRN Electronic Journal. doi:
10.2139/ssrn.2304089
Belfield, C.R. & Crosta, P.M. (2012). Predicting Success in College: The Importance of
Placement Tests and High School Transcripts. Retrived November 19, 2019, from
https://ccrc.tc.columbia.edu/media/k2/attachments/predicting-success-placement-tests-
transcripts.pdf
Dawson M. (2013) Verbal Intelligence. In: Volkmar F.R. (eds) Encyclopedia of Autism
Spectrum Disorders. Springer, New York, NY
Fabito, B.S., Rodriguez, R.L. & Bangit, A. C., (2019). Correlation between Student Entrance
Exam Results and Academic Performance: Case of a College in a Philippine University.
Retrieved Novermber 20, 2019, from https://www.national-u.edu.ph/wp-
content/uploads/2019/08/6-JSTAR5-Fabito.edited.edited1.pdf
How to Use Gardner's Multiple Intelligences Theory to Help Struggling Students. (2019, July 8).
Retrieved November 29, 2019, from https://www.waterford.org/education/multiple-intelligences-
activities/.
Hudson, J. B., Mcphee, S. A., & Petrosko, J. (1993). The Relationship Between Tests, Course
Placement, and the Academic Performance of College Freshmen. NACADA Journal, 13(2), 5–
14. doi: 10.12930/0271-9517-13.2.5
Krishnakumar, K., & Dutt, S. (2017). Predictive value of Engineering entrance test on academic
performance in Engineering Degree course. International Journal of Recent Engineering
Research and Development, 38-43.
Kuschner E.S. (2013) Nonverbal Intelligence. In: Volkmar F.R. (eds) Encyclopedia of Autism
Spectrum Disorders. Springer, New York, NY
McLeod, J. & Cropley, A. (2013). Fostering Academic Excellence. Great Britain: Pergamon
Press.
Fabito, B.S., Rodriguez, R.L. & Bangit, A. C., (2019). Correlation between Student Entrance
Exam Results and Academic Performance: Case of a College in a Philippine University.
Retrieved Novermber 20, 2019, from https://www.national-u.edu.ph/wp-
content/uploads/2019/08/6-JSTAR5-Fabito.edited.edited1.pdf
McDonald, A., et al (2001) Aptitude Testing for University Entrance: A Literature Review.
Retrieved on December 20, 2019 from https://www.suttontrust.com/wp-
content/uploads/2001/02/SAT-Literature_Report.pdf
Montalbo, A., Evangelista, Y. & Bernal, M. (2018). Admission Test as Predictor of Student
Performance in Political Science and Psychology Students of Rizal Technological University.
Retrieved on December 10, 2018 from
http://www.apjmr.com/wpcontent/uploads/2018/07/APJMR-2018.6.3.09a.pdf
Sebastian, A. N., & Sebastian, J. F. (2014). Correlation between performance in the entrance
examination and academic achievement of BSBA students. JBLFMU institutional Research
Journal. Retrieved from John B. Lacson Foundation Maritime University:
http://www.jblfmu.edu.ph/?q=node/571
Sulphey, M., Al-Kahtani, N., Syed, A. (2018). Relationship between admission gradescand
academic achievement. Retrieved on November 24, 2019 from https://hal.archives-
ouvertes.fr/hal-01829634/document
Takele, S. (2017). Validity Strength of College Entrance Assessment Score and High School
Academic Records in Predicting College Academic Performance. Retrieved on December 20,
2019 from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1137552.pdf
Tupas, S. V. (2005). Entrance Examination and Academic Grades: Basis for Predicting
Students' Performance. Retrieved on November 18, 2019 from http://www.jblcf-
bacolod.edu.ph/tupas.php
Wambugu, L. & Emeke, A. (2013). Relationship between Entry Qualification and Academic
Performance in Undergraduate Science Courses at the University of Nairobi, Kenya. Retrieved
on November 24, 2019 from http://oasis.col.org/handle/11599/1807
Zekarias, Z., Aba-Milki, N. & Mikre, F. (2015). Predictors of Academic Achievement for First
Year Students. The Case of Wolaita-Soddo University, Ethiopia. Retrieved on November 24,
2019 from https://eujournal.org/index.php/esj/article/view/6382