Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pierre ROCHELLE
Laboratoire de Mécanique Physique, Université de Paris VI
2 Place de la Gare de Ceinture, F - 78210 Saint-Cyr l'Ecole - France
Phone: + 33 130854878, E-mail: rochelle@ccr.jussieu.fr
Pascal STOUFFS
Laboratoire de Thermique-Energétique, ISITEM,
La Chantrerie, B.P. 90604, F - 44306 Nantes Cedex 3 - France
Phone: + 33 240683150, E-mail: Pascal.Stouffs@isitem.univ-nantes.fr
Abstract
This paper presents a first order analysis of four types of overdriven free-displacer Stir-
ling machines. All the presented types of machines can work as refrigerating machines,
prime movers or heat exchange accelerators depending on parameters such as the hot to
cold source temperatures ratio, the nondimensional mass of working gas in the ma-
chine, the displacer rod to displacer cross sectional area ratio, the corrected dead space
to piston cylinder volume ratio and the displacer to piston cylinder volume ratio.
In its analytical form this theory holds for machines at low speed as it is assumed that
the piston displacement can be neglected during the displacer movement duration. This
analysis may be used to find the conditions and values giving either the best theoretical
refrigerating cycle or the best theoretical prime mover cycle, the associated reference
work, reference time, efficiency and heat quantities involved. A table gives the analyti-
cal expressions and the limiting values of the main parameters for the four different
types of Ringbom machines considered.
The preliminary design of a Ringbom prime mover is then presented. The main pa-
rameters influences are predicted and the magnitude of work, rotational speed limit and
efficiency are obtained.
Keywords: Stirling machine, Ringbom machine, free-displacer, first order analysis,
ideal analysis, Schmidt analysis.
= p
x 0S0 (
1− x
* ) ( )
+ Σ 1 − s* y*
3. Basic Equations rTC
Σ(1 − y ) + σΣ
In order to generalize the results of the cal- *1
+
culations we use dimensionless parameters and τ
variables with the following reference parame- where:
ters: y y S
x * = xx ; y * = y ; Σ = x 0S2 ; Vw = x 0 S 0 ;
0 0 0 0
- temperature: TC working cylinder temperature TE p T V
* *
τ= ; s = S ; p = p ; σ = TC y Sd .
s
- volume: Vw = x0 S0 working cylinder volume TC 2 B d 0 2
- pressure: pB bounce space mean pressure The dimensionless total mass of working gas is
thus:
( )
*
m Σ
p 1* x * =
(
1− x + Σ 1+ σ − s*
*
) (6)
We have a refrigerating machine or a heat pump
*
Moreover a value of x (with 0 < x < 1) must * (counterclockwise cycle); when pressure p*0
exist which makes p* equal to 1 to permit the passes under 1 (x* decreasing) the displacer takes
displacer take-off. When the displacer is down, off and y* increases from 0; when pressure p*1
this leads:
It is possible to deduce some particular Hence the possible temperature ratio range is:
additional parameters such as:
1 1
m* m* <τ< or + ∞ (20)
p *max = ;p *min =
( ) ( )
*
1+ Σ σ + 1− s 1 − s * − Σ1
Σ 1 + σ − s* 1
τ
and the maximum pressure to minimum pressure We have a prime mover (clockwise cycle):
ratio: when pressure p1* passes over 1 (x* increasing)
p *max (
1 + Σ σ + 1τ ) the displacer takes off from the upper position
Π= =
p *min (
Σ 1+ σ − s *
) (16) y* = 1 ; when pressure p*0 passes under 1 (x*
decreasing) the displacer takes off from the lower
4.2 Second case (Figure 4) position y* = 0 . Heat is given to the 'expansion'
The dimensionless guiding-rod area and the space and rejected from the 'compression' space.
temperature ratio are related by: The particular parameters are:
1 m* m*
1− s* > (17) p *max = ;p *min =
τ (
Σσ+ 1
τ
) (
1 + Σ 1 + σ − s* )
It yields:
( )
p 1* x * < p *0 x * ( ) (18)
and the maximum pressure to minimum pressure
ratio:
Relations (8), (10) and (17) give:
Π=
p *max
=
(
1 + Σ 1 + σ − s* )
( *
) 1
*
Σ 1 + σ − s < m < 1 + Σ σ + (19) p *min (
Σ σ + 1τ ) (21)
τ
From relation (17) the minimum temperature 5. Analysis of the Prime Mover Cycle
ratio is:
1 5.1 Thermodynamic analysis
τ min =
(1 − s ) *
From the first law of thermodynamics and
Relation (19) gives a maximum temperature ratio from the assumption of isothermal process in the
depending on Σ value: 'expansion' volume the cycle averaged heat
supplied to the engine is given by:
1 1
τmax = =
1 − s* − Σ1 1
τ min
− Σ1 Q E = pdVE ∫
84 Int.J. Applied Thermodynamics, Vol.2 (No.2)
The dimensionless heat supplied is written as: Σ * Σ 1
A0 = ηth ,ls = * 1 − s* − (27)
m* τ
QE = ∫
p dVE
p B VW
S y
= p* 2 0 d 1 − y*
VW ∫ ( ) m
(22) we obtain the following expressions:
∫
* *
= − Σp dy
− m*
Q*ls, E = ln 1 − A 02 (28)
ηth ,ls
At very low speed of rotation, let us assume that
the piston displacement can be neglected Wls* , E = m* ln 1 − A 02 (29)
as: It implies
1 1
dy * A 0,opt = (32)
Q *ls,E = − ∑∫
0 1 + Σ* 1 − s * − 1τ ( )
m*opt
m (23) 1
Σ opt = (33)
1 dy * ηth ,ls, max
− ∫ (
0 1− Σ 1− s* − 1 1− y*
)( )
m* τ where ηth,ls,max is the maximum thermodynamic
which gives, after integration: efficiency:
1 1 1
− m* ηth ,ls, max = 1 − s* − = − (34)
Q *ls,E = τmax τmin τ max
(1 − s * − 1τ ) (24)
2 This leads to the following expressions for the
Σ
ln 1 − * (1 − s * − 1τ )
maximum work:
m
1
Wls* , max = m*opt ln 1 − (35)
The dimensionless low speed cycle averaged m*opt
2
d 2 y*
2
= 1− p y *
( *
, x *0 ) = 1− 1
(37) The dimensionless time t *T gives the order of
dt * 1 + y*A 0
magnitude of the dimensionless revolution time
and for a take-off from y * = 1 (displacer moving lower limit. Figure 6 gives values of that time
down) and of the dimensionless work Wls* m* versus
d 2 y* A0. We should remember that according to
(
= 1 − p * y * , x 1* = 1 −
1
(38) )
dt *2 1− 1− y* A 0 ( ) relations (19) and (27) A0 is in the range:
η th ,ls η th ,ls
(
Let us define z * = − 1 − y * and Y = 1 + y*A 0 or ) 0≤ 1 1
+ τ +σ
< A0 <
1− s* + σ
<1
Y =1+z*A0 , then Eq. (37) and Eq. (38) have Σ
6. Preliminary Design of a Prime Mover
the same expression:
We shall use the lower part (crankcase and
d2Y
1 crankshaft) of an existing single cylinder S.I.
= A 0 1 − (39)
*2 Y
dt
which gives after integration:
dY
= ±[2A 0 (Y − ln Y ) + C] 2
1
*
(40)
dt
< τhea < 1 < τ < 1 /(1 − s* ) 1 − s* < τ < 1 1 < τ < 1 /(1 − s* ) 1 − s* < τ < 1
1 /(1 − s* ) < τ <
1 /(1 − s* + 1 / Σ) Σ(1 − s* ) /(Σ + 1) 1 /(1 − s* ) < τ < Σ / (1 − s* )(Σ − 1) / Σ
< τprim <
or + ∞if (
< τ < 1 − s* ) [(1 − s* )(Σ − 1)] < τ < (1 − s* )
Σ < 1 /(1 − s* )
< m*ref Σ(1 / τ + σ) Σ(1 + σ) < m* Σ(1 / τ + σ) − 1 / τ Σ(1 + σ) − 1
& < m* < 1 + < 1+ Σ < m* < < m* < Σ
*
m hea < Σ(1 − s* + σ) [(1 − s* ) / τ + σ] Σ(1 − s* + σ) [(1 − s* ) / τ + σ]
Σ(1 − s* + σ) [(1 − s* ) / τ + σ] Σ(1 − s* + σ) [(1 − s* ) / τ + σ]
< m prim < < m* < 1 + Σ < m* < 1 + − (1 − s* ) < m* Σ − (1 − s* ) / τ
Σ(1 / τ + σ) Σ(1 + σ ) < Σ(1 / τ + σ) < m* < Σ(1 + σ )
(1 − s* − τ) (1 − s* − 1 / τ) (1 − s* − τ)
ηth ,ls = 1 − s* − 1 / τ
/(1 − s* ) /(1 − s* ) /(1 − s* )
*
*
m τ[ln[(1 − ηth ,ls ) m [ln[(1 − ηth ,ls )
+ ηth ,lsΣσ / m* ] + ηth ,lsΣσ / m* ]
m* ln[1 − m* ln[1 −
Wls* , prim = − (1 − ηth ,ls ) + (1 − ηth ,ls )
(Σηth ,ls / m* ) 2 ] (Σηth ,ls / m* ) 2 ]
ln[(1 − ηth ,ls ) ln[(1 − ηth ,lsΣσ / m* )
*
(1 − ηth ,lsΣσ / m )]] (1 − ηth ,ls )]]
1 + (1 / τmax + σ) (1 + σ) (1 / τmax + σ) (1 + σ)
m*opt =
/ ηth ,ls, max / ηth ,ls,max − σ / ηth ,ls,max / ηth ,ls,max
y0 [ M D / y 0 [M D / y 0 [M D / y 0[ M D /
t0 =
( p BVw Σs* )]1 / 2 (p BVw Σs* )]1 / 2 (p BVw Σs* )]1 / 2 (p BVw Σs* )]1 / 2