Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Semana 1, Articulo 1
Semana 1, Articulo 1
doi: 10.5455/aim.2008.16.219-225
Received: 10 August 2008 • Accepted: 22 September 2008
CONFLICT OF INTEREST: NONE DECLARED 219-225
P R O F E S S I O N A L PA P E R
tion about diagnosis, prognosis, therapy and other cine is the growing number of examples, in which
clinical and health care issues. current medical practice cannot cape pace with the
Instead of routinely reviewing the contents of
dozens of journals for interesting articles, EBM sug-
gests that you target your reading to issues related to
specific patient problems. Developing clinical ques-
tions and then searching current databases may be
a more productive way of keeping current with the
literature. Evidence-based medicine “converts the ab-
stract exercise of reading and appraising the litera-
ture into the pragmatic process of using the literature
to benefit individual patients while simultaneously
expanding the clinician’s knowledge base.”
dences from the randomized controlled studies and caused increasing acceptance of the concepts behind
(or) convincing non experimental evidences. There is evidence-based practice. Cochrane’s work was hon-
still need to refine in which manner should be incor- oured through the naming of centres of evidence-
porated in the complexity of doctor-patient relation based medical research — Cochrane Centres — and
within Family medicine. One of the important con- an international organization, the Cochrane Col-
cepts of EBM is the hierarchy in validating evidenc- laboration. The explicit methodologies used to de-
es based on which decision is made, which means termine “best evidence” were largely established by
that before making decisions it is important to eval- the McMaster University research group led by Da-
uate value of evidences. According to that concept vid Sackett and Gordon Guyatt. The term “evidence
most valuable evidence, for example efficacy of the based” was first used in 1990 by David Eddy. (7,8) The
single therapeutic mean, comes from the results of term “evidence-based medicine” first appeared in the
the multicenter, randomized, comparison, controlled medical literature in 1992 in a paper by Guyatt et al.
clinical study. Evidences of least value are based on (9).
studies of the physiology functions and clinicians The idea of EBM appeared at the Mc Master Uni-
observations. versity in Canada in 1988, but during the 1990s be-
came known throughout the world. however, the
6. CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE – founder of EBM is considered to be English epidemi-
INFORMATION LEVELS ologist Archie Cochrane, who lived in the 19th cen-
Evidence-based medicine categorizes different tury and which has already pointed out the impossi-
types of clinical evidence and ranks them according bility of monitoring all the new discoveries in medi-
to the strength of their freedom from the various bi- cal science. During the last ten years in the world
ases that beset medical research. rapidly is growing the interest in the application of
EBM. The reason for this is the application of elec-
1. Evidences obtained by meta-analysis of sev- tronic records, the Internet phenomenon, an increas-
eral randomized controlled research (RCR). ing number of different clinical tests that doctors
1b. Evidences from only one RCR. cannot track, as well as increase in cost of health
2a. Evidences from well designed controlled re- care (7).
search RCR. Today, in almost all western countries doctors
2b. Evidences from one quasi experimental apply EBM in treatment for every patient with the
research. support of the governments of these countries, the
3. Evidences from non experimental studies ministries of health and pharmaceutical
(comparative research, case study), according to industry. This includes practical guidelines for
some, for example Textbooks. different diseases, a database with the best scientific
4. Evidences from experts and clinical practice. evidence from each category, which is edited by spe-
cial experts and which is continuously updated with
The principle of EBM emphasizes, above all, that new data, medical journals and literature available
the foundation of any medical decisions regarding with the latest objective information. (8)
the optimal diagnostic or therapy procedure are sci-
entific evidences from clinical research, and clinical In recent years EBM has become especially use-
experience and intuition are of great help, but not the ful in answering questions on which there is no intu-
main basis in decision-making. New in the applica- itive answers or for which our clinical observations
tion of EBM is that making decisions about treatment can cause more harm than good. It is a long list of
for each individual patient is a complex process that procedures that appeared useful at one moment, and
allows doctors and patients to select the best possible afterwards shown to be inefficient or even harmful.
solutions for each individual patient. As the EBM in- Example of this is the application of thalidomide dur-
cludes the routine use of the best scientific evidences ing pregnancy and as consequence of that children
obtained by clinical research, they are actually im- was born with anomalies.
possible before electronic databases in the early 90’s
occurred (5,6). 7. HOW TO START: 5 STEPS PROCESS FOR USE
While some find traces of evidence-based medi- OF EVIDENCE ORIENTED APPROACH IN
cine’s origin in ancient Greece, (1,2) others trace its FAMILY MEDICINE
roots to ancient Chinese medicine. (3,4) Although how will family medicine doctors start, if they
testing medical interventions for efficacy has exist- want to apply evidence based approach in their dai-
ed since the time of Avicenna’s The Canon of Medi- ly practice? Group for Evidence Based Medicine Re-
cine in the 11th century, (5,6) it was only in the 20th source from McMaster University identified the ap-
century that this effort evolved to impact almost all proach in 5 steps that each individual physician in
fields of health care and policy. Professor Archie Co- the application of this approach must follow.
chrane, a Scottish epidemiologist, through his book
Effectiveness and Efficiency: Random Reflections a) problem definition,
on health Services (1972) and subsequent advocacy, b) search for wanted sources of information,
based approach and efficiency of its application to a quality medical research. The Cochrane Library
specific patient. During this process it is important to aims to make the results of well-conducted con-
assess whether certain evidence, which is applied to trolled trials readily available and is a key resource
the patient, caused changes to better and that to the in evidence-based medicine.
extent that it is confirmed by research. If the data dif- It consists of a regularly updated collection of ev-
fer significantly, it would be necessary to investigate idence-based medicine databases:
why some patients did not respond to the changes in- • The Cochrane Database of Systematic Re-
troduced in the expected way and what can be done views (Cochrane Reviews)
to change it. • The Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Ef-
fects (DARE)
The EBM-oriented clinicians of tomorrow have • The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled
three tasks: Trials (CENTRAL)
1) To use evidence summaries in clinical • The Cochrane Database of Methodology Re-
practice; views (Methodology Reviews)
2) To help develop and update selected system- • The Cochrane Methodology Register (Meth-
atic reviews or evidence-based guidelines in their odology Register)
area of expertise; and • Health Technology Assessment Database
3) To enrol patients in studies of treatment, di- (hTA)
agnosis and prognosis on which medical practice is • NHS Economic Evaluation Database (NHS
based. EED) (2).