Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C4KInvestorSeries Chanos
C4KInvestorSeries Chanos
Series
Investment Insights from Jim Chanos of Kynikos Associates
O CTO B E R 1 8 & 1 9, 2 0 1 7 | TO R O N TO
On October 18th and 19th, 2017, join 400 world-class 2017 Presenters
investors from prominent family offices, pension plans,
and asset managers at Arcadian Court in Toronto. Dan Dreyfus
3G Capital
Over 20 world-renowned money managers will present
Jeffrey Smith
their highest conviction ideas and discuss industry trends.
Starboard Value
All proceeds help solve the toughest challenges in
Prem Watsa
children’s brain and mental health. Fairfax Financial
Jeffrey Olin
400 INVESTORS $1 TRILLION+ $4 MILLION Vision Capital
IN ATTENDANCE COMBINED AUM RAISED FOR CHARITY
Richard Pilosof
& Mike Quinn
RPIA
Early Bird Tickets Questions and
Now Available! Partnership Inquiries
Visit our website to learn Contact Evan Sequeira to Many more to
more and to register for the learn how you and your firm be announced.
Capitalize for Kids Investors can get the most out of your
Conference. conference experience.
evan@capitalizeforkids.com
Engaging Canada’s
capital markets
community in support
of children’s brain
and mental health.
Investment Insights grown meaningfully. How has
your ability to detect frauds
or bad actors in the financial
www.CapitalizeforKIDS.org 3
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
7
-10
-10
-11
-11
-12
-12
-13
-13
-14
-14
-15
-15
-16
-16
16
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-
b
ug
ug
ug
eb
ug
ec
eb
ug
ug
b
ug
b
ug
b
eb
ug
ug
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
-A
-D
-A
-A
-A
-A
-A
-A
-F
-F
-A
-A
-A
-F
-
-
28
31
-
28
28
29
27
29
30
29
26
31
31
31
30
31
28
31
27
29
29
31
are flowing and when bad actors said the same words at the same with the firm and it was great
are playing games with you. time, Tyco International. Tyco having some institutional memory
was an aggressive roll up run by for pattern recognition. The
CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: You spoke two guys who ended up going ability to see a story, have it put
at length about information to prison, Dennis Kozlowski and out for you on a whiteboard
becoming more ubiquitous. Mark Swartz. They were playing and suddenly say, “Wait a
How has the past experience of some of the most aggressive minute I’ve seen this before.”
your team allowed you to see roll-up type accounting games.
what could potentially unfold? The situation was different but It’s not always exactly the same
they were still employing some of course, but there were enough
JIM CHANOS: I’ll give you great of the same stuff that Mike clues that I felt it was worth doing
Canadian example from a Pearson was doing at Valeant. a deep dive on the idea. Now, as
little company called Valeant a follow-up on that regarding the
Pharmaceuticals. I’ve been on When we said ‘Tyco International’ information issues that we were
record saying I believe it might every other person in the room talking about - the challenges of
be the largest single stock loss looked at us blankly. They were either getting it or processing it.
in the hedge fund industry and too young to go through that In 2015, I saw on a website called
greater than Lehman, Enron, and
a number of others because the
hedge fund concentration was When we said ‘Tyco International’ every
so high. When we first discussed other person in the room looked at us
the idea in late 2013 in this room,
our pharma analyst, who was a blankly. They were too young to go
CPA, brought up the idea. Two of
the partners who’d been here a through that with the firm and it was great
long time and were here in 2000
looked at me and we all basically
having some institutional memory.
4
FiercePharma, which is a daily of it. That became crucial to the of lots of different aspects here
website for the pharmaceutical whole Valeant story, just this little but not least of which, as you say,
industry that shows up in my piece of information that they is having some good institutional
inbox every day. There was were using these mail order memory where senior decision
a story about an aggressive pharmacies and that they were makers at the firm have seen
pharmacy called Philidor and booking through the pharmacies these kinds of things before.
someone had pointed me to that they in effectively controlled.
the link. I looked at the link and CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: As you
under the comment section, of all CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: The timing look forward over the next
places, was a series of comments gap sounds similar to what decade, how do you see Kynikos
by people saying Philidor fills transpired at Baldwin-United. evolving? Machine learning has
Valeant Pharmaceuticals orders. become the topic de jour for
Well, then there were a couple of JIM CHANOS: That was a whole hedge funds. Are there aspects
comments that said no, Philidor is different scenario, but there, of technology that you see
Valeant. That set off alarm bells in it was getting the information being integrated into the firm?
my head. This was April of ‘15. Now because again it was a series
Roddy Boyd and others wrote of very blatant documents and JIM CHANOS: That’s the big
about it in late September, early letters that were sitting in a question. To what extent will
October of ‘15. We had already public file that we didn’t know Wall Street decision making be
sent our analyst in the summer about in Arkansas. So, that automated at the most basic
of ‘15 to go check out Philidor. We really underscores it beautifully. level, doing research, and will
drove out to Pennsylvania, and Getting the information and we be supplanted? My guess
we expected to find a mail drop, seeing the letter from the State is at some point the answer is
we expected to find just some of Arkansas saying basically yes. I think that is probably be
sort of paper thing that Valeant that the company is insolvent. last thing anyone would want
was using as a pharmacy of to say about their business or
convenience. Instead we were That letter was published by The their career. Maybe I’ll be dead
actually stunned. We saw a Wall Street Journal in October. We and buried by then, but I think
big operation – warehouses, had passed it on to the Journal that there are some things the
drops, the whole nine yards and the stock went up for another human brain still does very well
and it was enormous. And 6 weeks, I mean, in the face of – having institutional memory
that’s when we began looking that. Which was remarkable. But, being a key differentiator. This is
back. Where was the disclosure then it collapsed on Christmas one thing that makes us a little
of this thing? Obviously, this Eve. But in that situation, we didn’t less susceptible to big data and
is a huge operation. It wasn’t know that this file existed and machine learning. You have to
disclosed properly. So we an insurance analyst told me remember that most of that is
started asking ourselves, ‘what about it. In Valeant’s case, Philidor only as good as it’s inputs, right?
else don’t we know here?’. was sitting out there, hundreds
of people saw it, thousands of JIM CHANOS: In our universe
That was right around the stock’s people saw it and apparently companies are actively trying
peak, around $240 or $260. knew it, but Wall Street didn’t know to give you false inputs. They’re
Now that was sitting out there in it. Wall Street didn’t understand trying obscure the numbers.
the public domain from April to what it meant because when They’re trying to basically make
October, before the rest of the we went and asked them about it look better than it really is and
world figured out what Philidor that and they replied with, “I so, if you are analysing reams
was, but it was there. And you just have no idea what that is, I’ll call of reams of stocks based on a
had to go find it or be pointed to the company and find out”. P/E ratio, momentum, whatever
it, or whatever the case might be, factors are en vogue, you’d
and understand the significance Valeant is a wonderful example better be sure that you don’t
www.CapitalizeforKIDS.org 5
have a Valeant that is puffing
up their earnings in a bunch of But there’s certainly a growing amount
one time ways because that
algorithm will kill you. So, I think of evidence that nationalism is rising,
it’s one area, where because
you’re questioning the actual
protectionism is rising, authoritarianism is
inputs and not how they interact rising.
with the market price, that you
might still have an edge. Might.
I’m always willing to consider see it in lots of places now and because of the feeling that Putin
the opposite. You have to. arguably the US of A. And where has their back. So, people like
strong leaders who want to the Serbs, the Greeks and all of
CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: In previous make the country great again that area, which was a hot bed
interviews, you’ve talked becomes the ethos and the in the 90’s, the temperatures
about challenges surrounding mantra, that’s right out the 1930’s. seems to be rising again. No
unmet expectations in today’s one’s talking about that.
administration and regional So, the questions become,
tensions in the Pacific being what are the investment You have borderline failed states
two areas that could potentially implications? What are the now in Africa. Both South Africa
heat up. In your opinion, where economic implications? More and Nigeria are increasingly
are investors most significantly ominously, what are the political showing signs of major political
miscalculating risk? ramifications? Because, in an problems, due in part to the
increasingly globalist world, lines on commodities and other
JIM CHANOS: Well, with the we’re all interconnected and we factors but not least of which is
obvious caveat that I’m not a all get along in an increasingly internal corruption. I still argue
geopolitical strategist or a macro nationalist way. You fraction into that I don’t think South America’s
guy, but someone who just sees nations, states and blocks and completely out of the woods. I
the world as part of my every conflict is really the watch word think all the commodity exporting
day job. I’d have to say I think not trade. So, that’s kind of the countries are still probably facing
one of the least appreciated big picture stuff. Then we get more trouble than opportunity
risks is the political set of risks into some of the more interesting because of the inextirpable
the world is now facing. hotspots. Clearly, we’re beginning slowing down of China.
to see tensions rise in the Pacific,
We are at one of those great with the South China Sea and the China and the countries
turning points. Are we at a point new dynamics in Korea and the that export commodities to
where the pendulum between Philippines and an apparently China represent almost 40%
capital and labour has swung so hardening posture by the new of global GDP. So, it’s a big
far over to capital or globalism Trump Administration toward big group of countries and
or whatever you want to call it, China. But, there are some unless every Chinese citizen
that populism, nationalism, and other places that people aren’t can own four apartments, the
labour are beginning to swing paying attention to that I think demand for hard commodities
back? If so, then lots of things are worth zoning in on. One is has got to slow over time.
will change. Who knows but the Balkans. The Balkans are
we’ll see. But there’s certainly a getting to be a simmering place CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: Earlier
growing amount of evidence that again. You’ve got the rise of today we were sitting down
nationalism is rising, protectionism Erdogan in Turkey, who wants to with a peer of yours, Glenn
is rising, authoritarianism is rising. bring a second Ottoman empire. Dubin. When we mentioned
We see it in Russia, we see it in You’ve got increasing activity by that we were going to be
China, we see it in Turkey, we the Slavic people in that region sitting down with you and he
6
fed us a question. He wanted And in the ‘90’s it’s very clear or companies with really, really
to know if short opportunities it was the internet. It was the low returns on capital that have
are more prevalent under a digitisation of an analogue been using financial engineering
Trump Administration than they economy. And that went for a to bolster their results, those
otherwise would have been good period, almost a decade, are sort of the things that
under a Clinton Administration. until you had the inextirpable we’re interested in right now.
excess and blow off. The fraud
JIM CHANOS: (Laughs) I tell my cycle, interestingly, lags the CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: In today’s
republican friends, only half financial market by a little bit, but world, a single tweet can move
tongue in cheek, that although it’s that’s a separate discussion. markets and a short presentation
a well-known that I’m a democrat, And then the next one, really, can cause a stock to drop 10%.
I guess my clients should be was the rise of China and the How are you and your team
happy that a Republican came leveraging up of the American staying on top of information that
in because all the big money consumer in real estate. can affect your investments?
we’ve ever made has been
under Republican presidencies. Basically in ‘02 to ‘07 you had this JIM CHANOS: So first let
monstrous rally in commodities, me just point out that was
So, the toughest eight years you had an emerging market, always the case, we’re just
I had on the short side were you had this monstrous rally in the more aware of it today.
under Bill Clinton and Barack US off the back of consumption
Obama. So, basically, both of and increased debt by But I can tell you in the ‘80’s and
them had unrelenting, long consumers. That led to ‘08, ‘09. ‘90’s there was all kinds of big
bull markets. Whereas under stock movements and then you’d
Raegan, Herbert, Bush and his Since ‘08, ‘09 I think we’re going find out a day later that someone
son, the markets were quite to look back and say that it was spoke at some event, you read
volatile. So, I’ll leave it at that. the advent of central banking, about it in the Wall Street Journal.
‘the central bank saves the world That was your news flow. And
CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: You and makes you all rich’. So, QE so, we’ve become much more
talked about current risks and zero interest rates, I suspect instantaneous. We have at our
and the value of institutional we’re going to look back and fingertips the reasons or the
knowledge. Does today’s say well 8 years of that policy ostensible reasons why prices
market environment remind you kind of got us to where we are fluctuate but it used to happen.
of a similar time in history? now, so how is that going to You just didn’t kind of know
change if it does, and how does why until maybe much later.
JIM CHANOS: They’re all different that change manifest itself? Are
because different things drive we going to see companies So, the question is struggling
different bull markets. Late 80’s that just can’t possibly do well if with the information flow and
we had the first bout of economic interest rates go up by 400 bases that’s where again, having a
boom and then too much points or 300 bases points? bigger staff and a good trading
leverage and you had the stock That’s certainly one thought. desk is highly important. For
market crash and credit crash in us, we use our trading desk as
‘89, ‘90 which kind of punctuated On a macro basis, I mean, I’m much for information gathering
that one. In my fraud class, we not positioning the portfolio as we do for execution. They
teach about the concept of because that’s what I think but help make sure the partners
displacement which is a fancy on the other hand I’m keeping and the analyst are in the flow
word for things on which a new an eye out for companies who on things happening that we
financial cycle is built upon, might get into additional trouble need to follow up ourselves.
typically an idea or concept. should that regime be ending.
And whether it’s in the auto cycle
www.CapitalizeforKIDS.org 7
120
100
80
60
40
-15
-15
-15
-15
-15
15
-15
-15
15
15
-16
-16
-16
-16
-16
-16
-16
16
-16
-16
16
16
16
17
-1
l-1
-1
n-
ul-
-
n-
c-
ay
un
ug
eb
ar
pr
ay
ay
ug
ep
ct
an
ep
ct
ov
ec
ec
ov
eb
ar
ar
pr
Ju
Ja
De
Ju
-J
-O
O
-M
-A
-M
-A
-J
-N
-
-N
-D
-D
-M
-M
-M
-A
-A
-J
-F
-F
-S
-S
-
15
24
-
-
-
11-
17
26
27
22
02
16
07
08
04
13
04
24
06
05
06
18
09
12
21
02
30
20
01
29
CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: If capital, odd accounting, flows the results look better. In many
you’re willing to share, you’ve that you can’t track, byzantine cases, they’re using a myriad of
typically been a bit ahead corporate structures, not the least transactions with affiliates where
of the packwhen it comes to of which is the VIE structure where you can’t really track what’s going
insights on individual names, Western investors don’t even on, or tell who controls what. Are
own the assets. Shareholders Alibaba affiliates advertising
JIM CHANOS: Way too just own a piece of paper on the Alibaba platforms?
early. I wish I wasn’t. with a promise and as these Unconsolidated Alibaba affiliates
Chinese companies get more that they put money into but it
CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: But and more leveraged, the debt just comes back? The so called
if there was a say Baldwin- is on the entity that has the VIE. “Lazy Susan Problem”. And let’s
United today, would you be face it, Alibaba has a history
willing to share with us? So, God forbid anything happens, here where they in effect took
you get nothing. This is all very Yahoo, took the stake of Alipay,
JIM CHANOS: I will talk about problematic and I’m increasingly (what’s today Alipay) and
some situations that I think are concerned by companies like detached it out of the company
worth pointing out that your Alibaba and others that are to the horror and surprise
readers might want to explore seemingly employing all kinds of of their other shareholders
a little further. First of all, as you aggressive accounting to make like Softbank and Yahoo.
know, I have a big big problem
with most Chinese companies. I
think, and I don’t say that lightly, It’s amazing to me every time we’ve
but it’s amazing to me every
time we’ve actually gone from
actually gone from the macro in China to
the macro in China to the micro, the micro, it looks worse.
it looks worse. Low returns on
8
It was amazing. Today, that 25
subsidiary is worth tens of billions
of dollars. So, these kinds of
20
things, these kinds of governance
and accounting issues, are right
in our wheelhouse and we would 15
urge your readers to be cautions
on too good to be true stories 10
coming out of China. Because
even if they are true, 9 times out
of 10, the Western shareholders 5
www.CapitalizeforKIDS.org 9
You can only do so many. Right?
I think this will be one area in particular
Having Kynikos involved in certain
that a run up in rates would probably hit charities has always been
hard, because everybody buying cars is something we’ve done when we
had the wherewithal to do it. More
doing so on monthly payments. specifically, we’ve never pushed
the partners to do anything say,
“well the firms doing something
At that point, the SAAR had sort good. What’s going to happen you have to do something
of peaked out and stayed flat when things are bad? Today, it too.” That’s not something I feel
for the next few years but the is trading at its highs right now. comfortable in doing because
rate of change had slowed everybody has their own causes
dramatically. Cars are usually the CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: When and their own beliefs and their
first thing out of the cycle and you think of your philanthropy, own set of priorities and I know
so now we’ve been at this sort how has that evolved, if at all my partners are philanthropic but
of 17 million SAAR now for a while again over time as you’ve gone they’re all doing their own thing.
and what we’re seeing is what from yourself and the secretary Whether it’s a hospital in Jersey
you would classical see. You see to where you are today? or Alzheimer’s or whatever it
more incentives. You’re seeing may be. People give of their time
car manufacturers beginning JIM CHANOS: Well, obviously, which is maybe the most valuable
to cut plant production on the we have greater means for the of all. Whether it’s serving on
margin. We see more aggressive few things that we do at the boards, serving on foundations,
use of credit, lengthening lease corporate level. We got involved a teaching, whatever the case
terms, lowering residuals. All the with the Prince’s Trust way back might be. That’s something I
sort of stuff that you typically as it was getting going, when encourage not discourage.
see to keep moving the iron off it was starting it’s outreach to It keeps you grounded for
the lots. I think this will be one the London community, through lots of good reasons.
area in particular that a run up our London office. And that’s
in rates would probably hit hard, something we’ve stayed with CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: Aside
because everybody buying cars because we love the mission. from that, is there one that you’re
is doing so on monthly payments. We think it’s doing exactly the particularly proud of? Whether
These applied loan rates really kinds of things that it should be it be teaching or providing
affect the current industry quickly, doing. As in many philanthropic your time in another manner?
faster than I think housing. endeavours it also depends
on the individuals. If you have JIM CHANOS: Well I’ve really
CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: If you were a connection to someone who enjoyed teaching over the past
to express your views in a specific brought you in and you think number of years up at Yale and
security, how would you do so? they’re doing good work, there’s the University of Wisconsin, my
so many myriad worthy causes. alma mater, my family’s alma
JIM CHANOS: Well, I’m not going
to disclose that. However, at the
peak of the cycle the company It earned below its cost of capital when
was earning about 6% on their
capital. It’s a giant company things were good. What’s going to
in the industry. It’s not one of
the OEM’s and has a finance
happen when things are bad? Today, it is
arm. It earned below its cost trading at its highs right now.
of capital when things were
10
mater in a course on the history the New York historical society. and the dollars. We’ve built an
of financial market fraud. It’s been organisation and that’s been
great to teach MBA students. CAPITALIZE FOR KIDS: How fun. It’s the ultimate irony right, of
do you think of your own a short seller, you know building
As you know, we have a few legacy and what you’ve things up. I always joke to
scars to be able to show off and been able to accomplish? people about that but it’s been
it’s been a lot of fun. I’ve hired amazingly satisfying for me. To
some of my best students who’ve JIM CHANOS: Oh that’s a tough have great partners do this and
worked out great here and I really question, I mean I don’t think help me and be part of it and
do enjoy talking and instructing about my legacy. I have 4 stay with us for so long is really,
students. I think it’s just something amazing kids so my first and it’s something I’m really proud of.
that keeps me energised. My foremost priority was always
clients have been lovely about my own family. Spending the
DISCLAIMER: The content provided within this
it. It’s 17 Mondays a year. So, it’s time making sure that they’re document is property of Capitalize for Kids. Any views
or opinions expressed herein are solely those of
one out of every three Mondays well-adjusted, productive Capitalize for Kids or the third-party who expressed
them and do not represent that of any other firm or
for half a day and I feel blessed members of society. For the institution. This document is for educational and/
to be able to do it but I also most part, I think that’s true. or entertainment purposes only. Opinions, advice,
statements, services, offers, or other information
really enjoy it and I like to think or content expressed or made available by third-
parties, are those of the respective author(s) or
that the students are getting In terms of the firm, I’m very proud distributor(s) and not of Capitalize for Kids. Neither
Capitalize for Kids nor any third-party provider of
something out of it too. That’s of what we’ve built here. I just information guarantees the accuracy, completeness,
or usefulness of any content, nor its merchantability or
something that I hope to continue think that doing anything for 30 fitness for any particular purpose. In many instances,
to do on a very much part-time plus years is tough in a society the information available through Capitalize for
Kids represents the opinions and judgments of
basis. Beyond that, serving on that is increasingly seemingly the respective information provider. Capitalize for
Kids neither endorses nor is responsible for the
New York based boards is just short-cycled. Having partners accuracy or reliability of any opinion, advice or
statement made in this document or distributed
something I’ve always done that have been with me for so by Capitalize for Kids. Under no circumstances will
Capitalize for Kids be liable for any loss or damage
and to the extent I still do it, I’m long, and in continuity for so caused by a reader’s reliance on information
obtained through this document or distributed
doing it a little bit less than I long, and clients that have been by Capitalize for Kids. It is the responsibility of the
used to. It gets a little harder with us for years and years reader to evaluate the accuracy, completeness or
usefulness of any information, opinion, advice or
as you get older but I’m still on and years and years. There’s other content available through this document or
distributed by Capitalize for Kids. Please seek the
a few of them and raise money something satisfying about advice of professionals, as appropriate, regarding
the evaluation of any specific information, opinion,
for these sorts of institutions like that, away from the numbers advice or other content.
www.CapitalizeforKIDS.org 11