Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Brian Kaspar’s company was not even five years injection to eradicate the disease.
old. But in that short time, it was already worth
$8.7 billion. Zolgensma finds and replaces the defective gene
with a normal, healthy gene… the way it was
Kaspar and cofounder John Carbona started the supposed to be. This gives the child control of
company in July 2013. They called it AveXis, its muscles again. The child can live a relatively
and it had one goal. The team at AveXis wanted normal life.
to create a cure for babies with a deadly genetic
disease called spinal muscular atrophy (SMA). For children suffering from SMA, it’s a miracle
cure.
SMA is a horrible genetic disease that causes
people to lose control of their muscles. Those It’s hard to put a price tag on life. But AveXis
with the disease get weaker and weaker, did… $2.1 million. That made Zolgensma the
struggling to move, eat, or breathe. A very severe most expensive drug on the market.
form of SMA, Type 1, affects children at birth
Even though the price tag of $2.1 million seems
or within the first months of life. If untreated,
high, it was cheaper than the alternative. The
most die before their second birthday. It’s
previous treatment for Type 1 SMA had to be
heartbreaking.
administered on a regular basis. It required
Kaspar and his team at AveXis set out to cure hundreds, if not thousands, of trips to a medical
Type 1 SMA… and give these babies a life facility. And it didn’t restore bodily functions to
they may not have otherwise had. The team the same degree as Zolgensma. Over a 10-year
succeeded. It created a drug called Zolgensma. period, the previous treatment cost over $4
million – roughly double that of Zolgensma.
Zolgensma was a new kind of precision
medicine called a gene therapy. SMA is caused This makes Zolgensma a relative bargain… so
by mutations – “typos” – in a person’s genetic insurance companies will pay the price tag for
material. If we fix those mutations, we can cure the cure.
the disease permanently.
And as you can see in the chart on the next
That’s precisely what Zolgensma did. And page, AveXis made investors a lot of money.
incredibly, all it takes is one intravenous In February 2016, AveXis had its initial public
Cost in USD
companies already pay to have $100K
genetic screens – a subset of a
full sequencing – run for specific $10K
things like cardiovascular or The cost to sequence a human genome
metabolic conditions. has fallen exponentially, dropping below
$1,000 in 2019 $1K
And that leads us to this report’s The second part that the FDA must approve is
recommendation… the modality, or the method of applying a gene
therapy.
Gene Therapy for Genetic Disorders
One of the most common modalities is a virus.
BioMarin Pharmaceutical (BMRN) was
founded in 1997 to leverage its proprietary This might be surprising to some of us, but if
enzyme technology and develop therapies for the we think about it, a virus is a perfect delivery
treatment of numerous genetic diseases. mechanism for these changes.
Its first drug was approved in 2003. It’s called Viruses have evolved for one specific task… to
Aldurazyme – an enzyme replacement therapy for infiltrate our cells and make changes. Why not
a disease called mucopolysaccharidosis type I (MPS use that ability for good?
I). MPS I occurs when a person has a deficiency in
a lysosomal enzyme, which prevents the body from If scientists can strip out the harmful aspects of
clearing waste and debris from its cells. a virus and get it to transmit healthy changes,
they’ll have an effective modality for treating
Since then, the Federal Drug Administration genetic diseases.
(FDA) has approved six other drugs by BioMarin
for the treatment of various genetic disorders. For instance, in BioMarin’s new drug,
researchers use the adeno-associated virus
BioMarin’s current top seller, Vimizim, is the (AAV) to introduce the genetic changes.
only enzyme replacement therapy approved for
people with Morquio A – a genetic disease that The AAV is nonpathogenic, meaning it won’t
causes skeletal deformities and problems with cause a disease. In fact, most people always carry
internal organs. this harmless virus. And because it’s harmless,
most people don’t develop an immune system
What’s important for our investment thesis today response to it. This allows the AAV time to
is that BioMarin has one of the best gene therapy deliver the genetic changes to your cells.
platforms in the industry. It has been able to
leverage its unique enzyme technology to bring This may sound simple, but it takes a lot of
seven therapies to market. careful planning and precision to get the formula
just right.
While developing a gene therapy and
getting FDA approval may be expensive and But once the FDA approves a delivery mechanism,
complex, administering a therapy is actually the company doesn’t have to prove its safety every
straightforward. A gene therapy is comprised time. In other words, it is much easier to get FDA
of the healthy genetic material and a delivery approval the second time around.
method to get the genetic material into the cells.
BioMarin’s technology platform for gene therapy
Before a company can bring a therapy to market, is among the best in the industry. That is why
the FDA needs to approve both parts of the gene I believe it will get its drugs in the pipeline
therapy. approved quicker than any potential rivals… This
But that won’t be needed for long. Patients in This is a large base of patients. If BioMarin got
the Roctavian clinical trials have seen their just 10% of U.S. patients – or 2,000 people a year
average number of bleeding instances go from – that would be $4 billion in revenue. That alone
16.5 episodes down to zero. This impact has been would cause revenue to more than double. And it
sustained over a three-year period. isn’t a stretch to say that once the FDA approves
Roctavian, anyone with hemophilia A will want it.
That’s worth repeating. Patients in the trial, from
just one shot, have had zero bleeding instances. CEO Jean-Jacques Bienaimé believes reaching
They can lead relatively normal lives and not 2,000 patients a year is realistic. He cited a study
worry about excessive bleeding over a minor saying doctors would switch 34% of hemophilia
scrape. A patients over to a gene therapy after its launch.
When that happens, BioMarin won’t be able
Now, it’s worth noting that in some people, the to produce Roctavian quickly enough to meet
level of clotting proteins started to diminish after demand. That’s a great problem to have. And
three to eight years. But another shot will get the when the word gets out about how effective the
body to produce enough proteins again. therapy is, other doctors will follow.
Roctavian is incredible. The worst-case scenario
A New Buying Opportunity
is to get a shot every few years. For most, it will be
even less frequent – or even just a one-and-done In August 2020, the market got some news about
cure. Roctavian that it didn’t like. Shares of BioMarin
dropped 30% after the FDA requested more data
And after four years, this gene therapy showed This is a major buying opportunity for BioMarin
a 95% reduction in the annualized bleed rate for a couple of reasons. First, this setback only
(ABR), which is the key metric the FDA wants delays revenue by a couple of years at most. The
more information on. therapy is still likely to get approved.
In its complete response letter, the FDA said that Second, BioMarin’s other drugs are performing
differences between the Phase 1/2 study and the well. And BioMarin has one of the most robust
Phase 3 study limited its ability to rely on the pipelines in the market. It has plenty of potential
Phase 1/2 study to support the durability of the approvals coming up.
drug.
That makes this a fantastic chance for new
So the FDA wants to see follow-up safety investors to build their positions in BioMarin.
and efficacy data for two years in all Phase 3
participants. The last Phase 3 participant started
Action to Take: Buy shares of BioMarin
in November 2019. So final results won’t be
(BMRN) up to a price of $91. At this time,
available for review until November 2021. FDA
we will not set a stop loss for this position.
approval most likely won’t happen until early
As such, let’s make sure to position size
2022 but could happen as soon as the end of this
rationally. We don’t want to go “all in” on
year.
any single recommendation.
This was the first time the FDA brought up this
Note: If this stock is trading above its
point to BioMarin. It’s rare to see new criteria
recommended buy price when you read
for a drug trial show up at the end of a Phase
this research, my official recommendation
3 trial. BioMarin said it was “surprised and
is patience. Technology stocks have natural
disappointed that the FDA introduced new
volatility that often brings them back within
expectations for the first time in the Complete
range. I will always alert readers if we raise
Response Letter.”
our recommended buy prices. And you can
While this was a setback for BioMarin, it is always check our most up-to-date buy price
temporary. The Phase 2 data clearly shows the by visiting our model portfolio here.
therapy is effective for over four years. And none
of the participants had any negative side effects. Regards,
So this will just delay revenue for a bit longer.
It was hardly a reason for a 30% drop in stock Jeff Brown
price. Editor, The Near Future Report