Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kinds of Credit
transactions Simple loan (mutuum) in whatever form including bank loans
1.Loan and overdrafts
Sale on credit
2.Price deferment
agreements Mode of extending credit through a non-cancellable lease
contractunder which the lessor acquires at the instance of the
3. Financial lease lessee, machinery or equipment, motor vehicle , appliances
business and office machines and other immovable or movable
property in consideration of the periodic payment by the lessee
of a fixed amt of money sufficient to amortize a certain
percentage of the purchase price or acquisition cost including
incidental expenses
Voluntary and legal Credit transactions are created by will of the parties; meeting of
minds; with all eelments of contract (object, consent,
consideration)
Onerous or gratuitous
Contract of commodatum
gratuitous
Bailment of contracts
Bailment Delivery of personal property by bailor for some use on a mere
deposit, express or implied that after purpose has been fulfilled,
it shall be delivered back to bailor or kept until bailor claims it
back
Delivery for use but expected to return it
Commodatum
Delivery for safekeeping but expected to return it
deposit
Kinds of bailment
1. Actual bailment There is Actual delivery or constructive delivery
7. Involuntary
bailment
2. Lucrative bailment
Art 1933 By the contract of loan , one of the parties the bailor delivers to
Contract of loan another the bailee either something not consumable so that
Commodatum and mutuum bailee may use it for a certain time and return the thing or
money or consumable so that the borrower may consume it
with the obligation to pay the same amount of the same kind
and quality
Characteristics of a loan
1. Real contract Commodatum or simple loan is not perfected until the delivery
of the object is perfected
*contract of loan is perfected when check is encashed
Kinds of loan
commodatum Bailor delivers to bailee something consumable so that the
bailee may use the same thing for a certain time and return the
thing
Revolving credit
Mutuum
Fixed sum credit Can be fixed sum credit or revolving credit
Borrower agrees to take a fixed amount of credit to repay this
with interest or charges and the transaction is terminated upon
full payment.
Sps granted 5.7 m credit line by BPI. The bank claimed that
ther was no credit line as there as was no PN for the said
amount. The SC ruled that PN is not required to have a fixe
credit limit. But the bank is not obliged to grant the full amount.
BPI only released 800 k to the spouses.
In Sps Pio Dato v BPI
Art 1935
Art 1940
Main purpose Latin “COMMODATUM” means usefulness
Thing supposed to be returned; owner has title to fruits
(accession discreta) civil, industrial and natural ‘
Republic vs Ca GR 46145 The director of lands opposed the registration of the land of
Baloy and his heirs saying that the land had become public .
The land had been used as US naval reserve.
The court held that the US Navy was not the owner of the land.
And its occupancy is only of a commodatum. Baloy did not lose
possession. His rights were only suspended because of the US
Navy occupancy
COMMODATUM USURFRUCT
Bailee cannot enjoy fruits Jus fruendi included in the right of the usurfructuary
unless stipulated
(jus fruendi) May convey his right; alienate his right; mortgage
Right of bailee is personal Can allow 3rd persons to use the thing
cannot be transferred
There is right of retention
3rd person cannot be
allowed to use
No right of retention
(except for damages under
1951 and 1944
LEASE
In Pajuyo v CA
1938
Bailor need not be owner of
the thing loaned
Because the purpose is for temporary use only
Bailor may not be the Real right transferred is possession now ownership
owner
Lessee or usurfructary can be bailor
Bailee cannot be bailor in same thing as the right is not
transferable and personal
Necessary to be bailor
1. Right to possess and use the thing
2. The right to transfer such right to use and possess
Art 1939
Commodatum is purely
personal
As it is gratuitous there is presumption that th bailor conveyed
Death of bailee or bailor the temporary use of the thing for free if not for bailee only.
extinguishes the contract Cannot be assumed that other are to allowed to benefit
Liability of bailee for loss 1. Devotes the thing for other purpose for which it was
loaned
2. Keeps it longer than stipulated
3. If the thing loaned is with appraisal value unless the
bailee is exempted from responsibility in case of
fortuitous event
4. Lends to a third person
5. He chooses to save his own thing over the borrowed
thing
Bailee cannot retain the thing loaned on the ground that bailor
owes him something
Right of retention But has right of retention for damages (bailee suffered because
of the defect of the thing)
Art 1950
Ordinary expenses For the use and preservation of the thing;routine or regular
expense
Bailee
Extra ordinary expenses For the preservation of the thing; bailor;not routine expense
Bailee
Art 1950
Hidden defect/flaw 1.there is hidden defect
2. Bailor is aware of the hidden defect
3. Bailee is not aware of the h.defect
4. Bailor did not notify bailee
4. Bailee suffered damages bec of the h.defect
Art 1952
Abandonment Return of the thing does not excuse the payment of the
damages due. From bailee.
Value of the thing returned may be less than the value of the
damages
Extinguishment
1. Expiration of term
2. Accomplishment of the purpose or use of thing
3. Return of the thing with conset of bailor
4. Return of thing in precarium
5. Return of the thing for acts of ingratitude
6. Death of party
Simple loan mutuum Person receives a loan of money or any fungible things
acquires the ownership of it and is bound to pay to the creditor
an equal amount of the same kind and quality
Money or fungibles Are those that can be replaced by another property of the
same kind
Ex. sack of rice
Chartp45
Art 1954
barter Barter or exchange; exchange of properties without any
obligation to return the thing received
In simple loan the object is money and fungible things; if the
thing to be exchanged is non fungible then the contract is barter
Art 1955
Legal tender and inflation Payment of debts shall be in stipulated currency or in the legal
art 1249 tender in Phil
General rule
Value of currency at the time of establishment of obligation
shall be the basis of payment
Exceptions:
If parties agreed thaht currency at the time of payment shall be
basis
In case of extraordinary inflation or deflation
*extra ordinary inflation and deflation must be declared
Art 1956-1961
Interest Price paid for the use of money for a period of time and are
expressed as a percentage of the total outstanding balance
either fixed or variable
Cost of borrowing money-borrowing rate
Cost of lending money- lending rate
Kinds of itest
Regular interest for the use of money
Monetary interest Requisites:
1. Payment of interest is agreed upon
2. Stipulation must be in writing
3. Rate not against the law
May be paid in kind its value appraised at the time of payment
Legal rate is 6%per annum
P 58
Art 2209-2013
Escalation clause Party cannot unilaterally increase the rate of interest
Not wrong but should be on reasonable and valid grounds
Interest must be mutually agreed upon
Sec 4 lof Lending Act Violation of the Lending Act when borrower is made to sign in
blank the PN or docs and where the bank unilaterally fill them
up later
Finance charge
USURY LAW
Usury is non existent BSP removed the interest ceilings prescribed by the Usury
Law
Interest can now be charged as lender and borrower agreed
upon
ARt 1306 Interest rate may be void if grossly excessive and contrary to
morals, good customs and public policy
Suspended the usury law effectivity but did not repeal it; only
CP Circular no 905 law can repeal law
Issued by CB’s Monetary Board pursuant to PD 1684
Monetary Board prescribes the maximum rates of interest for
loans and forbearances
1. Prescribed max rate of interest for loan or renewal of
forbearance for money
Monetary Board 2. Max rate for loans of low priority such as consumer
loans loans by pawnshps, finance companies
3. Different max rate for different types of borrowings
including deposits loans of financial intermediaries
New Central Bank Act or It supplemented the law with loans by banks and other financial
RA 7653 did not repeal institutions
Usury law
Whenever abnormal movements in the prices endanger the
Sec 63 of the New Central stability of the economy the Monetary Board shal take such
Bank Act as amended by remedial measures
RA 11211
Rate of interest including commissions , premiums, fees and
other charges on any loan and forbearance of money and
goods regardless of maturity shall not be subject to regulatory
Manual of Regulations for ceiling
Banks (MORB) consistent
with CB cis=rcular 905
Mas service charge of 5.00 but not to exceed 1% of the
principal loan
Prinicipal obligation valid In usurious loans the entire loan does not become void, the
unpaid balance still stand s and valid.
Only the usurious interest is void
Paid in exces of the interest may be recovered of debtor with
interest thereon from the date of payment
1. Loans
2. Forbearance of
money goods, or
credits
Does not apply to contract
of sale or contrac to sell Cover loans by bank, pawnshops, finance companies and other
financial institutions
Creditors
If compounded interest is agreed upon, the effective rate shall
not exceed the max rate imposed by BSP
Compounded interest
Where in the lawful loan there are additional charges
disguised providing payment by the borrower for the lender’s
services which are of little or no value
Time price differential
Does not apply in time price differential
Conditional sale based on installment plan
Ex car oan
Encourage cash sales for reduced price
Increase in the price for credit; does not constitute interest
Stipulation on attorney’s
fee
CREDIT CARD
Credit card Any card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device for the
purpose of obtaining money, goods, property, labor or services
or anything of value on credit
RA 8484
The consumer-credit arrangement that exists between the
issuer and the holder of the credit card enables the latter to
procure goods or services on a continuing basis as long as
outstanding balance does not excess limit.
The cardholder has the power to obtain present control of
goods or service on a promise to pay for them in the future
parties
Credit card issuer- card In our jurisdiction we adhere to the Gray ruling, the
holder relationship relationship is a contractual one governed by the terms and
conditions found in the card membership agreement. This
contract provides the rights and liabilities of a credit card
company to its cardholders and vice versa
Surety credit card holder Solidarily liable with the credit card holder
Issuer can proceed against surety
Does not incur liability unless the credit cardholder is held
liable
Surety remains liable although there was novation of the
agreement by upgrading the ccard
Obligation of merchant If it refuses to accept the card without following the prescribed
procedure causing humiliation to the customer
No duty to approve Issuer has the right to deny authorization for any request
charge
Terms and conditions With pre approved card the issuer must prove that the client
read and consented to the term and conditions governing the
card’s use
Under MORB sending of pre approved cards are prohibited
;unsolicited call offering cc; sending supplementary cards
Escalation clause Rate of interest in the credit card agreement maybe sustained
as long as not against the law, morals, p policy and p order
Accelaration claus Any provision in the contract between the bank and the
cardholder that gives the bank the right to demand the
obligation in full in case off default or non payment
Compliance and breach Issuer cannot implement conditions not stated in the
agreement like:
Cancellatiion of card due to non submission of form when the
obligation is just to pay the outstanding balance
Premature cancellation of card
Issuance of a supplementary card to fraudulently
Failure to honor the card
Credit limit Excess payment does not amount to novation and does not
increase the limit
Loss of credit card Must notify issuer to be absolved from the fraudulent use of
the lost card
Disclosure omitted Does not impose fee in connection with telephone solicitation
….