Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Apoorva Javadekar
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 1 / 62
Agenda
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 2 / 62
Term Structure or Yield Curve
Spot Curve: Govt issues ZCB for maturities from 1 month to 1 year. Plotting
the ytm on these gives a spot-curve or zero-curve
Problem: But what to do for longer maturities?
I Invariably we have to mix zcb’s and coupon-bonds - a sub-optimal but only
choice in real-world
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 3 / 62
US Yield Curve
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 4 / 62
India Yield Curve
India Yield Curve - 1 Dec 2019
India Government Bonds
7.5%
7%
6.5%
6%
5.5%
5%
4.5%
2Y 4Y 6Y 8Y 10Y 12Y 14Y 16Y 18Y 20Y 22Y 24Y 26Y 28Y 30Y
Residual Maturity
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 5 / 62
Stylized Facts
Term spread is volatile ytm10 and ytm2 are not perfectly correlated ⇒ Term
Spread = ytm10 − ytm2 is time-varying with high volatility.
I This is the slope factor
I Just before recessions (in fact all 7 of them in US history), term spread has
been negative!
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 6 / 62
Yield Comovement
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 7 / 62
Term Spread USA
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 8 / 62
US Bonds Moments
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 9 / 62
Information Content of the Yield Curve
Maturity premium
Horizon specific risk-premium
Expectations
Segmented demand
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 10 / 62
Forward Rates
Forward rate ⇒ rate determined today for lending that will happen in future
n
Notation: ft,t+h ⇒ forward rate decided today (time t) for n-period ZCB
to be purchased at time t + h (i.e h periods from now)
Example: Assume no default risk. Let yt,1 , yt,2 be ytm on 1 and 2 year ZCB
at time t. Then two risk-free ways of investing over 2 year horizon
I Buy 2-year ZCB
1
I Buy 1-year ZCB + lock-in 1-year forward , 1 year from now ft,t+1
No Arbitrage If you invest 1$ in each strategy, you should get exactly the
same at year 2 given that both the methods are risk-free
2 1
1 × (1 + yt,2 ) = 1 × (1 + yt,1 ) × 1 + ft,t+1
2
1 (1 + yt,2 )
⇒ ft,t+1 =
(1 + yt,1 )
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 11 / 62
Forward Rates Example
Rollover Strategy: Give 104 $ at the end of year 1. At rate should 104 be
rolled-over to get 110.25 at year 2?
110.25
100(1.04) (1 + forward) = 110.25 ⇒ forward = − 1 = 6.009%
| {z } 104
payoff at year 1
Takaway: Forward rate captures the increasing structure of spot rates in this
example. This is the arbitrage free forward rate market should offer you
Forward Curve: Like spot curve, one can plot forward curve as well. Note
that nothing in the forward curve has more information than spot curve!
Finally you derive forward rates from spots
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 12 / 62
Expectation Hypothesis
Example: Only way 2 year ZCB is offering 10% ytm compared to 5% ytm on
1 year ZCB is because market must be expecting that 1 year ZCB will offer
really high rate (around 20%) in one year from now
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 13 / 62
Three ways of Expressing Expectation Hypothesis (EH)
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 14 / 62
Three ways of Expressing Expectation Hypothesis (EH)
Pt+1
Holding period return for ZCB = Change in prices ⇒ hprt,t+1 = Pt
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 15 / 62
Does EH Holds?
Average hpr from 1953-2013 in the USA not much different across maturities
⇒ seems like EH is doing fine!
1 5.83 2.83
2 6.15 3.65
3 6.4 4.66
4 6.4 5.71
5 6.36 6.58
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 16 / 62
Fama-Bliss Test
EH Prediction: β ≈ 1
Evidence: β ≈ 0 for 1 year horizon but 0.80 for 4 year horizon
I ⇒ EH fails in short-run but holds in long-run
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 17 / 62
Fama-Bliss Test
Observe the left hand panel and how b builds over time. Right hand panel
regressed excess returns on long-term bonds as a function of slope of the yield
curve (forward spread / expected yield change). If actual yields don’t change
enough (left panel), long-bonds will earn higher returns if yield-curve is upward
sloping
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 18 / 62
Take-away for Active Bond Management
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 19 / 62
Segmentation Hypothesis
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 20 / 62
Segmentation in Action: Gap-Filling Theory of Maturity
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 21 / 62
Implications for Term Structure of Gap-Filling Theory
Corporate issues short-term bonds then. But from Fama-Bliss tells us that
when yield curve is upward sloping, borrowing costs with rollover strategy are
much lower than issuing a long-bond.
I In essence, managers are timing the yield curve
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 22 / 62
Another Example: Financing Frictions and Maturity Choices
A more recent contribution is that by Chakraborty - Mackinlay (2019).
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 24 / 62
Corporate Debt Maturity Dynamics By Size
Smaller firms can’t borrow long-term in recessions, but that’s exactly when larger
firms issue long-bonds!
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 25 / 62
Level, Slope and Curvature Factors
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 26 / 62
Factor Model for Yield - Curve
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 27 / 62
A simple factor model
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 28 / 62
Factor Model Results
Maturity an bn sn R2
y1 0.09 0.9998 -0.77 0.97
y2 -0.08 1 -0.28 0.97
y3 -0.04 0.9999 0.1 0.97
y4 -0.02 1.0008 0.38 0.98
y5 0.04 0.9993 0.56 0.98
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 29 / 62
Litterman-Scheinkman Approach (optional)
Interpreting backed-out factors: These factors are just time series variables -
we don’t know what they mean. We need to see how these recovered factors
correlate with some postulated aggregate factors
Example: Postulate that cash flow growth for a firm are given as
yit = αi + βi × GDPt
Then after running PCA, we would see if first factor looks like GDP or not
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 30 / 62
Litterman-Scheinkman Approach (Optional)
Step 1: Collect the data on yields of various maturities over time and
compute var-covariance matrix Σ
Σ = QΛQ 0
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 31 / 62
Equilibrium Level of Interest Rates
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 32 / 62
What Determines he Interest Rate Level?
Impatience Rate: If savers in the economy are impatient, then interest rates
are higher as investors need more compensation to over-come their
impatience of consumption
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 33 / 62
Credit and Transition Risk
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 34 / 62
Credit Risk
Credit risk ⇒ Bond issuer fails to repay coupons / face value as promised
Components of Credit risk
I default risk ⇒ probability that issuer fails to repay
I recovery risk ⇒ conditional on default, recovery could be very low
Credit loss
Credit Loss = P (default) × (1 − recovery )
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 35 / 62
Default Rates
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 36 / 62
Default Rates By Industry
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 37 / 62
Default Rates: Financial vs Non-Financial
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 38 / 62
Default Rates Hazard Rates
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 39 / 62
Recovery Rates
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 40 / 62
Recovery Rates
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 41 / 62
Type of Bond Matters
Loans 80.40%
Senior Secured 62.30%
Senior Unsecured 47.90%
Subordinate 29%
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 42 / 62
Credit Risk Summary
Leisure / media and Energy / natural gas sector with highest defaults (> 3
%) in last 40 years
Utility and ironically Real estate, Insurance are least defaulted sectors in last
40 years
Non-financials default way more financial firms
I but maybe because financial firms are bailed out?
Risk of default for speculative bonds is very early in life and recedes later
Recovery rates: 40% for bonds, 75% for bank loans. Lastd ecade saw much
better recovery even for bonds
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 43 / 62
Credit Migration and Transition Risk
Observations:
I Ratings Inflation: Downgrades more frequent than upgrades!
I Horizon is important: AAA stay AAA with 87% chance over 1-year, but just
with 22% chance over 10-years
I Clustering: Downgrades clustered in recession. but so are upgrades!!
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 44 / 62
1 Year Global Transition: 1980-2018
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 45 / 62
10 Year Global Transition: 1980-2018
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 46 / 62
Asymmetric Nature of Transition
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 47 / 62
Asymmetric Nature of Transition
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 48 / 62
Credit Spreads ⇒ Price of Risk!
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 49 / 62
Various Spreads
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 50 / 62
Moody’s Corporate Bond G-Spread
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 51 / 62
Moody’s Corporate Bond Credit Spread
Moody's Seasoned Baa Corporate Bond Yield-Moody's Seasoned Aaa Corporate Bond Yield
3.5
3.0
2.5
%-%
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 52 / 62
Observations on Spreads
Quantum: Baa-AAA ≈ 1%
Post GFC, Baa-AAA spread has been around 1% after peaking to 3% during
2008
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 53 / 62
What Determines Credit Spread? We don’t know!
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 54 / 62
Results: Not default risk, but risk-premium
r: Rising r pushes down CS. This sensitivity is higher for low credit bonds
R 2 ≈ 25%: ⇒ host of factor explain only 25% of the variation in the credit
spreads
π × 40 + (1 − π) 100
= 90 ⇒ π = 9.16%
1.05
Risk-Neutral default-probability (implied by prices) is 9.16%
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 56 / 62
Quantifying Risk-Premia
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 57 / 62
GZ Spreads
Bond by Bond Credit spread measure: For each bond, create a hypothetical
matched treasury security with exact cash flow structure
I discount the cash-flow using zero-curve
I compute ytmrf of this matched security
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 58 / 62
GZ Spread
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 59 / 62
GZ Spread and Economic Activity
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 60 / 62
Excess Bond Premia
Excess bond premia ⇒ Credit spread in excess of that due to firm level
factors
I Step 1: Estimate S[
it [k] = f (firm factors)
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 61 / 62
Excess Bond Premia and Economic Activity
Apoorva Javadekar (Indian School of Business) Fixed Income Securities December 11, 2019 62 / 62