Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1: 47-56
Abstract
Greenhouse Gases (GHG) consists of various types of gases that are produced either naturally from the
environment or from the activities of living things, some examples of the dominant GHGs are water
vapor, carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrogen oxides (NOx) and Sulfur Oxide (SOx), the largest
contributors to GHG emissions are in the Energy sector, amounting to 175.62 million tons of CO2.
Microalgae are the most primitive plants, can grow in low water quality with the availability of adequate
nutrients and sunlight. The amount of CO2 that can be absorbed by 1 kg of dry spirulina is 1.83 kg of
CO2. In addition, Spirulina Platensis can tolerate gas content of SOx, NOx and CO2 whose concentrations
are <12%. This study aims to determine the process of utilizing CO2 gas emissions from power plant for
the cultivation of Spirulina Platensis microalgae at PT. Indonesia Power UPJP Perak Grati. Based on the
research results, the average emission load value generated from power plant, especially HRSG 1.1, is
10,403.31 tons CO2/ month on average. The temperature factor has a significant correlation with the
growth of microalgae cells with an inverse correlation. Based on the tests carried out to determine the
relationship between changes in the flow rate of CO2 in microalgae cultivation ponds to the growth of
microalgae cells, it was found that the addition of CO2 in the cultivation pond with a flow rate of 1 L/
minute had a greater effect than other treatments. The amount of CO2 absorption by microalgae
installations with a flow rate variation of 1 liter CO2/ minute is able to absorb 0.2766 tons of CO2/ month,
or is only capable of <1% of the average emission load of HRSG 1.1 per month.
Keywords: CO2, Microalgae Spirulina Platensis, Power plant emissions, Emission Loads
47
Analysis of Reducing CO2 Emissions Using Spirulina Microalgae
emissions from power plant activities, namely source), and salinity. The following is the
utilizing CO2 from exhaust gas emissions from environmental quality standard for microalgae
the generation process, especially power plan. growth based on several literatures (Kawaroe,
CO2 gas is a gas produced from the combustion 2010). Spirulina is the type of microalgae that is
process of fossil fuels. In this case the emissions most widely cultivated; this is due to its fast
are generated from the Gas and Steam Power growth process, relatively low maintenance
Plant (GSPP), which in the process uses gas as costs, and high nutrient content. The pigment
the fuel. The amount of CO2 gas produced from content of Phycocyanin in spirulina is useful as
gas fuel is 12% (Pusdatin ESDM, 2016). an antioxidant, a natural colorant for food,
cosmetics, and medicine, especially as a
Therefore it is necessary to reduce CO2 gas
substitute for synthetic colors and can reduce
emissions, one of which is by mitigating CO2.
obesity (Muhammad, 2010).
CO2 in nature is the main source in the process
of plant photosynthesis, one of which is the At PT. Indonesia Power UPJP Perak Grati
Microalgae Spirulina Platensis (Istiyanie, 2011). microalgae spirulina platensis is used as an
effort to reduce CO2 gas emissions generated
Microalgae are the most primitive plants, with
from the GSPP chimney. According to Yusuf
cellular size and commonly known as
Setiawan (Setiawan & et al, 2014), the amount
phytoplankton. The habitat for microalgae lives
of CO2 that can be absorbed or used by Spirulina
in almost all waters in the world. Microalgae can
Platensis biomass is in the range of 0.36-1.78 g
carry out photosynthesis like other plants;
CO2/ g biomass with an average CO2 absorbed
therefore microalgae need sunlight and CO2 gas
of 0.78 g CO2/ g biomass. In addition, the dry
to carry out the photosynthesis process. One
biomass produced from the cultivation process is
type of microalgae is Spirulina Platensis
processed to become a fish feed mixture in
(Bunowo & et al, 2018). Spirulina Platensis is a
collaboration with the community around the
microalga that can grow well in low quality
company as a Corporeate Social Responsibility
water such as wastewater in alkaline conditions
(CSR) program.
with sufficient availability of nutrients and
sunlight. Spirulina Platensis contains protein, In this study, we will discuss the use of
amino acids, vitamins, minerals and pigments Microalgae Spirulina Platensis to reduce CO2
that can be used as additional food ingredients gas emissions generated from emissions from
(supplements) for humans, animals, and the power generation process of PT. Indonesia
aquaculture (Setiawan & et al, 2014). Power Unit for Generation and Generation of
Grati Silver (UPJP PGT), especially in the Heat
One type of microalgae is Spirulina Platensis.
Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) chimney.
Spirulina requires CO2 gas to carry out
This research was conducted at the Microalgae
photosynthesis; one kilogram of dry microalgae
Cultivation Unit which utilizes emissions from
uses about 1.83 kg of CO2 while the amount of
Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG)
use of CO2/ biomass of Spirulina Platensis
number 1.1.
ranges from 0.36-1.78 g CO2/ g biomass with an
average of 0.78 g CO2/ g of biomass at a rate of Methodology
750 ml/ min. (Setiawan & et al, 2014). Type and Conceptual of the Research
Growth of Spirulina Platensis is influenced by This study uses a quantitative approach. The
environmental conditions including temperature research method used is an experimental method
(temperature), nutrients (nutrients), light (Min, 2016). The scope of this research activity
intensity, degree of acidity (pH), aeration (CO2 includes field activities. Field activities include
48
Journal of Community Based Environmental Engineering and Management, 2021, Vol. 5, No. 1: 47-56
49
Analysis of Reducing CO2 Emissions Using Spirulina Microalgae
the CO2 emission load data for the 2nd and 3rd for Thermal Power Plants Appendix VII (F) with
Quarter (April-September) periods are still in the the Equation (1).
process of being compiled by the company.
Study literature by conducting theoretical studies (1)
through books and other sources of information Where OF is Oxidation Factor ( 0.95), MW CO2
relating to the learning media that will be is Molecular Weight CO2 (44), AN C is Atomic
developed. Number C (12), E CO2 is Emission Load CO2
(ton), ∑F is Actual Carbon Content 154 ton/
Research Design
month.
This research includes 2 stages, namely: the
Observational research stage and the Environmental factors are one of the factors that
Experimental research stage. The observational influence the growth of a living being.
research stage includes secondary data analysis Environmental factors that will be observed in
to determine the CO2 emission load generated this study include:
from HRSG 1.1. The data period to be analyzed 1) light intensity,
is data in January-March 2018. While the 2) pH of water
experimental research stage is to cultivate 3) water temperature
microalgae spirulina platensis with the variations Observation of environmental factors was
that have been determined during July 16 2018- carried out in all observation ponds (control
July 29 2018. In the experimental stage the pool, variation 1, variation 2 and variation 3).
observations will be divided into 4 pools, The data that has been collected will then be
namely Control Pool, Variation Pool 1, analyzed using the SPSS application to
Variation Pool 2, and Variation Pool 3. Each determine the correlation between
pool will get different treatments. This treatment environmental factors and microalgae growth
includes adjusting the flow rate of CO2 that is using the correlation test method using the
flowed into the pool, there are 3 variations of the Pearson Correlation. Person correlation is a
flow rate of CO2, namely as follows: statistical method used to measure the strength
1) Control Pool: Raw Water + Microalgae + and direction of the linear relationship of two
Ordinary Aerator (Control) variables. The correlation between these
2) Variation Pool 1: Raw Water + Microalgae + variables is connotated with a value of 1 to -1.
CO2 Aerator with V1 = 1 Liter/ minute. The higher the correlation value is indicated by
3) Variation Pool 2: Raw Water + Microalgae + the closer the value to 1 or -1.
CO2 Aerator with V2 = 2 Liter/ minute.
In this study, the influence of CO2 gas will be
4) Variation Pool 3: Raw Water + Microalgae +
calculated on the growth of the Spirulina
CO2 Aerator with V3 = 3 Liter/ minute
Platensis Microalgae. The calculations are
Data Analysis carried out still using the SPSS application using
In calculating the GSPP Emission Load, the the one-way ANOVA (Analysis of Variance)
calculation method in this study includes the test, because only one factor of concern is the
calculation of CO2 Emission Load and the growth of microalgae. In this experiment,
calculation of CO2 absorption by microalgae. several different treatments will be given to each
The method for calculating the CO2 load microalgae sample.
generated from HRSG 1.1 refers to the Minister
The principle of the Anova test is to analyze the
of Environment Regulation No. 21 of 2008
variability of data into two sources of variation,
concerning Fixed Emission Quality Standards
namely variations within groups and between
50
Journal of Community Based Environmental Engineering and Management, 2021, Vol. 5, No. 1: 47-56
groups. The results of this method are in the MW. Since 2015, Block 3 (Combine Cycle) has
form of a comparison of the values of the two been built consisting of 2 x 150 MW Gas
variants, where if the results get closer to the Turbines and 1 x 150 MW Steam Turbines and
number one, there is no difference in the effect is expected to be COD (Commmercial On Date)
of the intervention carried out, in other words in November 2019.
the mean value being compared is no difference
Characteristic of Power Plant Emission
and vice versa (Anisa, 2010).
Monitoring exhaust emissions at GSPP Grati,
The analysis of the amount of CO2 that can be using external laboratory analysis services and
absorbed by this microalgae installation is direct measurement using the Continous
calculated based on the amount of CO2 Emission Monitoring System (CEMS) tool. The
emissions (tonnes) that are produced, reduced by data obtained from the last examination in
the assumption that the amount of CO2 gas that March 2018 are as seen in Table 1.
can be absorbed by microalgae. The amount of
Table 1. Emission Characteristics Data
CO2 that can be absorbed or used by biomass.
The strength of the CO2 absorption capacity of
Standard***
Tolerance of
Microalgae*
CEMS
Lab.
Spirulina Platensis is in the range of 0.36 - 1.78 No Parameter Unit
g CO2/ g of biomass with an average CO2
absorbed of 0.78 g CO2/ g of biomass (Setiawan 1 Particulate mg/Nm3 30 1 2.2 200,000*
2 SO2 mg/Nm3 150 <1 0.06 400,000**
& et al., 2014). The formula for calculating the 3 NO2 mg/Nm3 320 302 8.62 240,000*
absorption of CO2 by microalgae is as Eq. (2). 4 Opacity % - <20 - -
Oxygen
51
Analysis of Reducing CO2 Emissions Using Spirulina Microalgae
Lighting is an environmental factor that can The temperature changes that occurred in the
affect the photosynthesis process of microalgae, cultivation pond were very fluctuating but
and can affect the increase in surface tended to decrease, and the pond temperature in
temperature of microalgae cultivation pond all treatments was still at the optimal
water. The Figure 3 is the result of the average temperature for microalgae growth, which was
change in lighting intensity around the between 25-33C.
aquaculture pond.
Another environmental factor is the pH of water,
where the ideal pH for microalgae growth is in
the range of 5.5-9.5. The following is data from
monitoring results and trending changes in the
experimental pond pH during the observation
period.
52
Journal of Community Based Environmental Engineering and Management, 2021, Vol. 5, No. 1: 47-56
not normal. Furthermore, if the significance is Based on the data, it can be seen that the growth
above 0.05, it means that there is no significant of microalgae with variation 1 or with a CO2
difference between the data to be tested and the flow rate setting of 1 liter/ minute shows a more
standard normal data. Based on the results of the stable growth, when compared to other
Kolmogorov Smirnov distribution test data in variations.
this study, a significance value was obtained
Furthermore, based on the data that has been
above 0.05, which indicates that the data was
obtained, an ANOVA test will be carried out to
normally distributed. So that the correlation test
determine the effect of adding CO2 gas to the
can be done. Based on the results of the Pearson
growth of microalgae. Before the ANOVA test
Correlation Test with the SPSS application, a
is carried out, the variance homogeneity test and
summary of the correlation values is obtained as
normalized test will first be carried out to ensure
seen Table 3.
that the data obtained is homogeneous and
Table 3. Correlation Test Results between normally distributed.
environmental factors and microalgae growth
Based on the results of calculations using the
Statistic Light Temper SPSS application, the ANOVA test results were
pH
test intensity ature
Microalgae
Korelasi 0.009 -0.329 -0.487 obtained as follows:
Signifikan
Growth 0.946 0.013 0.000
si
Table 4. ANOVA Test Results on Microalgae
Analysis of the Effect of CO2 on Microalgae Growth
Growth
ANOVA
Microalgae cultivation ponds that are given a Sum of Mean
regulation of the amount of CO2 flow will then Squares Df Square F Sig.
be observed for cell growth by weighing the dry Between 113.243 3 37.748 5.262 .003
weight every day from the beginning of Groups
cultivation to the harvest period. Based on the Within 372.996 52 7.173
results of observations, data were obtained as Groups
seen in the Fig. 6. Total 486.238 55
53
Analysis of Reducing CO2 Emissions Using Spirulina Microalgae
Table 5. Post Hoc Test Results (Benferoni) Kg. If it is assumed that each cultivation cycle
Multiple Comparisons
produces the same biomass as in pond V1, here
Dependent Variable: Microalgae Growth
Bonferroni is the amount of CO2 that can be absorbed by the
Mean 95% Confidence Interval GSPP Grati microalgae installation for 1 month
(I) Flow Difference Lower Upper
rate (J) Flow rate (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Bound Bound
(2 cultivation cycles):
Control CO2 1 L / min -3.08071* 1.01228 .022 -5.8574 -.3041
CO2 2 L / min -1.17214 1.01228 1.000 -3.9488 1.6045
CO2 Emission Load Average HRSG 1.1:
CO2 3 L / min .66500 1.01228 1.000 -2.1116 3.4416 10,403.31 Ton CO2/ Month
CO2 1 L / Control 3.08071* 1.01228 .022 .3041 5.8574
min CO2 2 L / min 1.90857 1.01228 .390 -.8681 4.6852 CO2 Absorption/ Pool: 0.00173 Ton CO2/
CO2 3 L / min 3.74571* 1.01228 .003 .9691 6.5224
Cycle
CO2 2 L / Kontrol 1.17214 1.01228 1.000 -1.6045 3.9488
min CO2 1 L / min -1.90857 1.01228 .390 -4.6852 .8681
Number of Microalgae Ponds: 8 Ponds.
CO2 3 L / min 1.83714 1.01228 .452 -.9395 4.6138
CO2 3 L / Kontrol -.66500 1.01228 1.000 -3.4416 2.1116
Microalgae Installation CO2 Absorption:
min CO2 1 L / min -3.74571* 1.01228 .003 -6.5224 -.9691
CO2 2 L / min -1.83714 1.01228 .452 -4.6138 .9395 = 8 × 0.00173
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
54
Journal of Community Based Environmental Engineering and Management, 2021, Vol. 5, No. 1: 47-56
changes in light intensity are directly Perikanan dan Kelautan. Vol. 10(1): 26-
proportional to the growth of microalgae 33.
cells. In addition, there is also a correlation
Hairiah, K. (2007). Perubahan Iklim Global :
between changes in pH and the growth of
Penyebab Terjadinya GRK. Malang:
microalgae cells, where the growth of
Universitas Brawijaya, Fakultas
microalgae cells is inversely proportional to
Pertanian.
changes in the pH of culture water.
Istiyanie, D. (2011). Pemanfaatan Emisi CO2
3. Based on the analysis, it is concluded that the
dari PLTU Batu Bara dalam Pengolahan
addition of CO2 gas emissions from HRSG
Limbah Cair Domestik Berbasis
1.1 affects the growth of microalgae cells. Of
Mikroalga. Jakarta: Universitas Indonesia.
the 4 (four) variations in the flow rate of CO2
emissions given, the pond with a flow rate of Kawaroe, D. (2010). Mikroalga Potensi dan
1 Liter CO2/ minute showed a significant pemanfaatannya untuk Produksi Bio
change in growth. Bahan Bakar. Bandung: ITB.
4. The amount of CO2 absorption by microalgae Matsumoto, H.A., N.Hamasaki, Y. Sioji, Ikuta.
installations with a flow rate variation of 1 1997. Influence of CO2, SO2, and NO in
liter CO2/ minute can absorb 0.2766 tons of flue gas on microalgae productivity.
CO2/ month, or only <1% per month of the Jurnal Chemical Engineering. Japan.
average emission load of HRSG 1.1. So it is Ministry of Environmental of the Republic of
necessary to do further studies to increase the Indonesia, PermenLH no. 21 Tahun 2008.
productivity of the microalgae spirulina
Min, M. (2016). Jenis Jenis Metode dalam
platensis in order to reduce the burden of
Penelitian Kuantitatif dan Pengertian
greater CO2 emissions.
Terlengkap. (Team Pelajaran.co.id)
References Retrieved Agustus 04, 2018, from
Anisa, W. (2010, Oktober 31). METODE Pelajaran.co.id:
PENELITIAN KORELASIONAL. http://www.pelajaran.co.id/2016/21/jenis-
(Wordpress.com) Retrieved Agustus 05, jenis-metode-dalam-penelitian-kuantitatif-
2018, from BINTANGKECILUNGU'S dan-pengertian-terlengkap.html
BLOG: Muhammad. (2010). Pengembangan Spirulina
https://bintangkecilungu.wordpress.com/2 Sebagai Super Food. Retrieved Agustus
010/10/31/metode-penelitian- 18, 2018, from http://repository.ipb.ac.id:
korelasional-2/ http://repository.ipb.ac.id/jspui/bitstream/
Brown, L.M. 1996. Biodiesel from microalgae: 123456789/44442/4/INTI-PKMGT-2010-
Commplementary in a fuel development IPB-Muhammad-
strategy. National Reneawable Energy Pengembangan%20Spirulina%20Sebagai.
Laboratory. pdf
Bunowo, N.R., Nurhasanah, Q.R. (2018). Studi Pusdatin ESDM. (2016). Data Inventory Emisi
Pertumbuhan Populasi Spirulina sp. pada GRK Sektor Energi. JAKARTA:
Skala Kultur yang Berbeda. Jurnal Ilmiah Kementerian Energi dan Sumber Daya
Mineral Republik Indonesia.
55
Analysis of Reducing CO2 Emissions Using Spirulina Microalgae
Setiawan, Y., & dkk. (2014). Pemanfaatan Emisi Soekidjo. 2005. Metodelogi Penilitian
Gas CO2 untuk BUdidaya Spirulina Kesehatan. PT Rineka Cipta. Jakarta.
Plantensis dalam Upaya Penurunan Gas
Rumah Kaca (GRK). Jurnal Riset Industri
Vol. 8 No.2, 83 - 89.
56