Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ორესტეა - განმარტებები და კომენტარები
ორესტეა - განმარტებები და კომენტარები
6cr3
, U\rooroo
,:"i \ U \ mmotrqclr,rtr
b.:6c.> .>6l.rqAmBm,: \ UU ,rmro
\U
-
3 3 or 3 6 3 6 r. o 3 q 6 cn l-' ts g o j 3 6,:,,3 co3 3 6 cn l,' oUt U q o " or j 3 j q3 b36 o. g3bo iq36 3oq33 ,:3%tsoo,33rn6g 3o - or$r3%3, Lrb3o bog-
Sobo 36c',o
g33boo, 6cn3 3c.,j3rc',, ob ".166 Bo6Sgqoo q.: o66 5.:bqoqo, o66
4$g36m6ob; qr p6oLcornl-,o/-, 3o33dob - c$633bob.: qo oro3b$3-
6q.:o3os ms 16,> 3o6.:%r- 16r> Ll.:b.:borBo: n:s s6r, 8ob rs6cm". (clr
bol-: - qr
3rc', Bcn6ob 3qq6m6oL 33b.:b36 oboq3 8336o t,36oob 6og6tso
3 o c., o 3 rn 6 3,: g rn6 b Lr 3 o 6m Lr o tr,: q b c Lr 63q U. 3 6 3$ oL 3 g g 3 3 o 6rn b o,: 3,: -
,,$6crob rn3o", c.rr,3o,, Jpq,r"JoqpSo 4) c6$.rq"rn6o l: 3 co q 6 3,: ". 3
%.:6.rEomsonm6n[, rm,somLrolr.1.>o.r33.>..:Jrnocncrrm6or|.lo---rJo,&m-
224
22;i
3u", l, 13). 6o3cn-,j3Uqoc Scnl;o%636c, 6cn3 oj obob3q., l."eUr(Jo,.) Eoc, L:cqca 3goboc.rl-rolr 8-Jq3qo 3o[:. 8CAco5dr33o qr 3cbc6q6sLro
o33co63Ab 3cno63q o6qcn336cnJUq 8oo,b Sf Ef dn6U3%f ,6cn33q,- qo 8ob" tbgUJ3boc qo36doqflqo (Jcal:o6oc|.-ro,11,16,5 eo 111,19,5).
oG JAeCbo %ogbjqol: 3%olr 8f8-COlA.,Lr eqIU, CDqqSf 6-%!,
6cn33qo6 SoLr qrqr$cn&b qr BDflo^83oq%C,6co33qo13 3361r odo36lr
3c 3ob 83qlq rn8 oboo,3olr. @
JqohiS6gb$6;l: 6oxsbo - L:;8CRCn doqcaRql6.l, .i6,l0Uq() 5 U 6 nO 6. e r A r 6 o ; 6O f E o.co63lig3boloo er Cq3j$6otr
"
L:o36cnqrnD. tsfl.rcbgb 36o3oqo r6OoJU6o 6g;6c.r 8-A3oc.,b 6"n3b: 3A6.Joq!,
Jqo\CSfub$icb; er rA o3g36m6ob "b$m6o; J3qcnJcn63licntrot, ,,cn 63 lr(b C 1r. ", 268 - 27 a ; 4 62,,,o R o 6 3 6 o c o 3 q o b 3. ", 622 ;,,C q I C(b 6 o ",
^33q
qoJo6obJo6flUqo qo6o[:6"l6ob q3al6q.Lr 6cScndcboqo U6e- 14 qo ESea .,253 qc ts8q g;289;320 qo 5.,4a9-412;542 qo ts8qg.,
ogmlr. Jqo&3363b96o oycn g,:bgolr LrJc6Olq" 3f3,:Aoe6t. [rJc6- 617 qo 33ga.; ULrC"qC, ,,r6c3336c",6o",87 7 e" ts8ea. ,,C-CRc"r633o",
'33q6.; 431; 732;973 33ea.; 1038;
6fqf3o r3qb3o3Cbq636, c.,oorjcotrqo 8oc., 6o6oJ;63o $o6qc63cnb3c 130 q.: ts3ea .;269 gc ,,t3336oq3bo"
o5c3336cn6o 3o336ob $cb$%3 ;og3o6o.Ct, J. o3o%3 U6ec 3.Uc.,ocn36- 592, 622;Jo6qo6rn[ro,,,Joo,o36. -qr", X, ,22; 34-36 go bjrnqocoC-
qCtr, 6c"r3 bJ.:6$Oq3bAr r3o3q3t:oor3.,L, S6dcnqcBo 3o3363qfb%l 3o; 3o6o6g11o,,,3oc.,36.", 117 ,119,122; oJcnqrnqcn6cnbo,,,3Jo$cn8o", lll,
Aro3o63g3Cb. o3o3q'3'3o Jo J"OoAl, LrOl3q636 rar3336cn6lrog er 3; Vl ,24,25;g36oJoe3b ,,cndr3b$3Lrols" [rC-qoc.r36o 33,765, er 1233;
JqoOC363tr66olso6. 33 6o Joe C,,,oR o 6 36 o c $ o 3 6o b'3 o", 9 21;cn Ao q oU
1r.,,,6 36o ql A o J cq6-
b 6b o - 4 ; 3j 36 m6o, o 6g,,d q.16 goSb bcnRCrJqC,,,Celj$6o", ts8q b.;326 e" ts8ga";
CqDAo" %33bo, B C|., cd q3 c]3- tb-eo6", ,2,95-98;
lll 11
qor, oUm q3oloC66o3o 6"q}Uqo,6cn83qtrrG c$o6gbq636 c(n; 3k,cn- 379 gr EOq 6.; 417 qr ^33q4., 516 e" 33qa.,47-50 eo 1223 qo bjco-
qme 3o336ot 8Cgf CE., c6c33q Lrb3c 8lef Obo6. ^333cn6ts36oqo 6"OU- qorn36o. 3cn336c.,Lro,,,oeob!"", lll, 306 qo ts3qg.; Jt3l:c6oobo l, .22, 6;
rq36o gJocol$o,,%g3lro-ogo3336cn6o" o3o%3 U6ec 3o3c.,oc.,35q3b, Lr363oULr., AC66oqojt:o[-r,,363oe.,lr" 3cn336$a6g6o, Xl, 268;
6cn8 og o3g36cn6o, 83l.rcdqoD, cDr3erJo633qre oUCo c.,c 3obo $cn[J oL; %rngo o36-bec, 6cn3 rar3336co6o[: Bo8-lr3qc8ef Jq"6l3-
O6--X6o,o 6ob336oeq3f6o)o-3g"6alqo, 6cn8qob gU6Cgo3?.,,, 63l.166o0 c"r63L:63l.ro gcn3ob Bo 6oog%;36o ( 336o JoqC,,,C(OCg6o", 14
rnqo 3 J o p 6o J c6o,gcn6olr Bo 8c.r g rq o 6 3 b ot: ot-: % 33b % C A r q r A o e r. qo ts8qs.).
,: g ;
fu 3 6 m 6 o b 6 o Z 3 a/-, o qo g g o b otm [: o b oto 6 o 3 b 6; fug q g d o b 3 g 6 rit - -6CLr63bol.: go3%6qlqre odbo1mrL 6o33qoq o[:ob3q36f6
d-nqglo oo636olo or3oro ?gG,>?gg, q>(rb 8cnbqo.33g;3AOC eesb 6m[]- cr.JcooccSools
\-\(j\
o6 roc".,oloolr.
ts.G eqC[rob6r3qcnbq636. 8ob oq36o S6coe3b-qr. oA., BCCbr- 36o,o 336booo, n6gbggbob q>d8 CqCl$6;3 ScnbobboStso 6,:;b-
tb
"U a
t,
C
6 caq o l.r o
3
ls3 3 c., c 6
C e
3 o6 ob Jg 6 o c.rq [r, 6c.r 6 o J r q
U q o c., 3 3 3 3 o 6 Aoo B3oqo qr
,joqcjoqcE go6pqre AroUBrEo. lqfd66"3 Scnls;b-
3o13o6olr c.rBCCAb 3o,o6o66qC6-eo. 6cqArr6G Bo6b, SLrbal6JqL, bc3%3 Ao6CUqo Gb-ACqCAo ;3cnj;6g,:, cn6glr$3lrol.: 5oqo8cq3o8o
UrnACq cn 3ob bo3b3 3c., 3o6ol, qq3lr l.:6 o6 ;3 q6C6. .lqog g363lrqg6 c odr 8cb 3c0o[: oq3%6e3qo
3b3 o635 cnqo (oJcoqc.rq cn6coLro,,,!J o$ro3,)",
^33gA.;
ts3p3o6qo q3o,rl36o3 tsp6olrdo33cb er UCoBOqo c.r3olr 33g;33tbf eq.,f Y 1,24;336oJoeC,,,Cq! C66o", 542 qo CbC oqC,,,C-CRcn63bo",
eq3tr rlso6 o 3 qr e g o3cn,:6b o q o. % co 6 3r A Dqo6 U Af O o q 33 o 8cn 3 5 cn 6o, 232)
%rng8o 3o Boc.,Aoqc, 6cn3 JqoOCS6gb$t6oA Crq'olr 8-Cq 3qoqc6lr rgo3336cn6olr ere qc b$6cngocnl:ob Gcnqrq bc6 sb$ornCColt,bo6
lo ; 3
3 qo 3 rnq q c o Lrb o c.,o 3 Lr q rR o ( Lr cn g co,.Jq C,,,N e 3 CO 6 o ", 27 B -281; c6,:jbodosb, bo6 3o 3o6q> ioAmdsb ot:ob3qlb16.
3c"r336cn[:o,,,oeob3o", Ul, 263; Xl, 405). %cngo 336lro00, ndgb$Cbn q>o Joq,oq>p{-,o O-qCJo og3616. 3,:cno
;g;fu36rq6o[: 6go3o oLro-oLm oB3bglr,6rn3 3o6ot,Caf tsf c.,^3o ^3j-n,-r 336cn66c.r6o 333qgcn3^3o boSoArqoocne (oJcnqmecodc.rlro,
"COc.
c6 3do" SJBqfqlb%1. ,,3Jo$cn8J", Ylr,24).
Jo3[:o6oobotr g oq3cn633oc.,, b Jc6qb3qSa o o663 j 636o;6, 6cn8 r Ar - %rngo3 6,o,o 3o oBqbJoGCAb, 6cn3 n63b$Cbn 33aqo 3o sds, nGo
qo36dDq3q.,. .,d ;go3336ro6olo bcgqc3ob,
3336co6o oEo3q'Cts. ouro 6q,ob 3$qCa B33cg gcB6g6qo 3o336tso. (;Jcnqcoqco6c',Lro, ,,f,Jo-
JqoOC363bg6;ls ja6q;336obr qr 3;Lro6q6clr god6ob 6ob3o B3odq3- $rn8c",Vl, 25)
6cqqo. bo6oSq3oq3tso Jo, cao3g36rn6ol: LrogqrAo 3o336ob 6c6gdrIASA-
{
226 227
bb3o 336Lroocn, co6ql.163root : 6s3obhSn3 jco6q\), (n-rr i),>l), rtr i), j,1,.,,.,1 t6 Amb o,6cn g co6 6 ts c 5b, 3 g 6cn g c 6 cnc.) a I co
A 6 oEo3q o O 6l B o,:,
qsab Lro3o6o36cnb;6 3o3%q,r3er, boorq JC*r"re" )
; q 3 c.r q o
q?,, Ir.rt,,ri'r.rr,,l;i;rir
Boe6C 3qg6o.
3 co b
3 Lr g q, o ( f t, q, l,,l,C -,: g - 6 .,t, 6 ct 6 o Lr 6 6
C
"
d.,
3 )
.
r 3E c., 6 36, 6 cn 3m6 g b O Sb o o,o 3 3 o ts c",b i E%
f f Sqf ro-
1-a"r6c',o o36coblr, 6-3 36.,b-lrbni, ,* ct1$,1i)6; r(,t$/,i,) ,) { . t.r,r , tit qobcL 3g3c.,bAlAool qoogjJo.
"J
3a 3m.iqr6 336ob
Te.lbolrr"rq,ot, 3rb"ar eIt;,,,',.1rr1',[',',(rJ(,v,,1i,,,,[, oSoloo6 o33c.r636, 6c.r 3 rn63b$gb3,> ;6ofu06m6ob l-,ogq,-: a%C cqcC-
?b,3qrq'cn6ot'qo6g36;3ec.gg.,t-rnbb 53-ralrc.,3oL k,.>r.',1y ,r1(rq\,,.r ,'lr), 66;b 3m$6oqro ffiq7qoqa $o6Lr;633qo Jo ;6c er,3o3o[: LrJoqrnb
6.6o 3bb3g6Jq.e qr aaoca3"solr;cn3ob 5o6$,-,f, qq,,,1q;1,,,[, ,);r,(,r{,,.i.;i,, r
Boqo6rXSAUqSo cn63b6gta" i 6 ro *
.,.i c rir.
t rjOr,r i
"l 33 ;
rr, r I 4
3cn6o6oq3colo! o6
ot6 "q33t,-u3oc b3qb gr!-a[: oaoo,6cnE !3.[r,n.,t.,-
go33o6%3 o6oBc6i; ;36-b[rl cb"gcn3o6 ;g"3356,,,t,, r .l,r-
fi
-c"o3ob
f
ts:, 6gb$ 6o q o ar 6r q t,
es-t' - lr " 3 o 3 % o trCcr fr - a Ju al 6r,r s, .: t,. [,. -
c'^r o
t,,
3f 6 j36ob go36o63tq joql, (,,;;.,[3o,,, lll, 235, 3 10; ty ; ;
I
_Slo.ia.:6
xt, 409-4a; 424-434, 4s2-4s1; xXrv, g 6-gi xXw, ,,),) ;
T
z00) r$
F
8au eq"!-A.iQqcqo Jqo6l363L56o 3
-d36cnLr oL, 3;13q,3 r,, I g ; (i',r,, - ) 6 a3 rn6o r q U 6o 333 33 o q63 cobo
t6ec q 3
Jrnlr c8o 6 gqa
S o 3
-G - :"arr
q.r e,,3 o J -r.3 5 ?)... (, r.i [,' v 1
I
4/
!
l'r o g o g g 6 o ; b E L: b g 6 J q ts ",,6
] 3
oSotr ts3lrob36 ob. 8336o b36oob
3
6 6
" "
t, a
" [,-,-
asq B
3
" -6
( q.> [!
3
-r o . i5,,,, ;
$_
6o b €c.,o o
3 6 3.1 a q C q r e q o6 I S 63 tr6 6 - o q o Lr"" b q A q o
I I i U {"
t
%c',go36or3bo o%oo63ag6 c.ia a;aq,rq;r, o-..,g.rt,?r,,
bqo, "a "totr,
6 o 33 3O ;" ol dl g, 6cn 3 ; g c O 6cn 6ob l, o q r %t,.j
lco I :a 33 R a e,,g 1 I - ) 3oL:o oGCqq-
63bg 6 ; 3 % 3q o B3t-' g o b ;qi ar q o
a i6 ; co c.,38 o b " ;; d, 3 6., il.r [, T];1 r )- 6rn3 o$t eCeDb,
Sla, 6oG bo%c6rq o tro%3o6o ob "q" " gtr"%56o, -;;;,r1, [ ).
6o gc6cnGbqer, ra"b?:tri, j"acoaqoS(r "3,> ;r)[,r,,-
.lar6o,b" er []r,ti.:?J,, [i.>,.,.y-
qr o' J 3r6cD
! " 3 6?Cso, u e cn 66 3 6 q o o[ J e r, 6
aoo g1
-O I bo go .-).> q..,,r fl
gc "
8or3q,o 3o336o Solr ff6qoqJ3l;-"qar,ASql. ;1
22rS
Eqq
bo6o, o3o Lr;3bb336Jqco 6oXobocn JBAC6o. olr , 6c,-,3 q$o6lr,>13Als"'bl, r b g c.r 3 c 6 o ; 66 ts ar 63 Lrlg ! Lr. J q oO I 3 63 Lr$ 6 o L: 3.3 3 3 c q o 6 3 c q rt.:
" G [] Ab
6cn33qB.G 3oqol-:o8 obb6r m63btbIL,",,,c3cn jo 6a qo oLJ (rr A,>fi,;.1
U I!- b;bo3c 6o,qrob, o6c33e co,)Bobo b3qoo JqDAl., 3.:tr,6oLr Sf Bqf arG 3rl:
o 3 c 6c., q
q,o 3tr3636o", r3rbc.,;633 obo13 ,6mB Solro og3%6glqo oll(,r l)6i138Lrcr f A b b D A 3 6 d 63 c., 3 n U A I q r % g 3 6 o 3 a 6f q rn 3o 6n L: o U o 3,: 6 o q, cn
3qo6o63 $r6oc.rlrnqo6 : g! r g cn6gb i: g6cnSoq lr.Ufl COb 83,;3r,b I i3,,c.% 3, ( c 6 g co J o
6 o ) . lt, b q 3 5 I % 3 3 b o b cn; 6; q 5 cn 3 o c.,D e s ; J co q' rn6 o Lr J o 6 o q o
6cn33qL:r3 l.roSlgco $o6bocAlqBo tsf baCU qb 1$(n il I)i, 3ti,,l) rn.) % l" tsr633olr 6g.:qc.r8nc',. dn6UBIAb U6e-eccn 36orblq qr LrcOgqcscnq
Ao63flq 3bfO36r,c6. tsf ilef A oL, b3p36; 36y13b.3&c.n6 q.r L,>l.rqr(')(y)e1 rf 6-qco Srnlqcrol o3 6lqoao36o 6c63-ea!6.Lroor3olr, 6c.r3qolJ
3ob go6l!c68qoL: 3ob3g3oor o66cnbg6. w cnc6ob8rer(J erer^": bo 8;1mda%g 8oq,q,c oeer.
8oc.,o dodob 3o36 ?ggob 33oqo/-'6cqo b;6fu6;co rn)IJ(-t[,,,33,rq,oL 6c.r5c.r6g g63o3bo og6o36r3b, SomoLr BlOaqoq 3,:6oo668o 96-
3bfu36Jqoe 6oq.,pJol-' TjbcbgJ 6lqogoob otrlqcn6or?1,r,,[) .;Jor;J.rb r errA ;?oa q; EcorllrrcnBol: Jrrg 6o1m6oUq,o bo[:$33o oqoj83&c'rgo
cbcbcalo, 6cngo 3bb3g6Jq'cq'336o6Uqo Sggob 3l3oe q[jq. 3.r'r33o dr-a-6G cnc3ol:c.,r3Deo ec C6o6o36lr og6o6e;qo 36o^3363qm5o
.TJ3C loo83gc.r g3.:6lr oqo6 CJUCr,BEcnqc. rq16 gooB6gDcD. lq3d1}6r (6cn3qol: Lrcb3qo ,,jr63o" S.Ucnoc.rgbl:,
lncoS oAo 3oJg66co633q,o cJrnqcn6olr J.:$;66cq36 JUqOt, IJU-A-
g6o6og6ob 3$oScnqcqAoc 8co, 6g636ob 3od;Are AIJ(', 3;1.t,1.r[i.[,, 4 j
31 3 q3 5 o 6 o cn o,g 3 n [: ot: t g c 6, 6 cn8 q o
6 ob g o6lrb Lr lo lo; b q o g r b Lr g 63 E Lr,
) 3 3
6 oq 6c63 6 co 3 g q n G tO o 3 cn q c.r g o 3 dr.r q 3 -r o 6 -n ; [r
6 o',': q 3 6 cno Lr o$ a, 3.:g6oo6Coq36. 3o6cn636.tr jdaf q3lro araC6r 3(Cd .,lrl3
g3 [ ,{
'* 6cn3
(6UfAqo) UJoAtso6q35o, o6o|-: %36o ,,36o631.6",6oG 6oE6o3Lr ,,?]3;- oUCo bc336d63o3. e., 6c.r3 gfeolr ,,3cn6Boq36r" ]CC6
Gcogbcqo
6cnbb, 6cn6co6t: f 6o6or". JoeOA 6c'r6cn6O Caoro[:Scelror-rbc, oLrS rqod33bcoqr. lq3d$6. 3o 3r-
36a6qJo 63o6o11 3onoJ36 6c63cnq3f 6f Bb g13cnbo$o3q6N6,r-rbo6cr 8ob 3b.:63%l oUCn, l.:6c.,63q obl,6cngcn66 %33bob cnr3oqo6 tscoboq'o
UCnBSqor3oL-' 8tsc.,8q3bob 3br63lr o93636, o6c 3c61gcn e3Aob c6 3c- oo,36c.
,n
3 o lr, ;6 c 33q
U g6 cnl: o d 3 ob 3b o 6 glr o6 ( 3 rn 33 6 cot-r o,,,o q' oE D ", X V, 20 4) .
e
3
o g o'3 3 o qo L: 3 g o6 3
co q3 6 o g 6Brn 6 o [:, 3 o cl U q36 - lo o$ g3o c., c 5 b r ;j 3 o cn
I
A3bcdqcor, rB ADAdGDqlbUq 3oor3o cJc.,qm6ob) er rcnf6clr 8oc.,ob %cngog6c.,o 336lroob 8ob3e3oo, Jqo\C3fub66ob SSSqf
dn6U3f6o o3 66"qo6osb og3bgqdq5C6, 6m3q'olr cr,.>5rb8.:grO, cimbo{: 3l3pm 8$Cq;mbo 3o3qo c.ro3olro qog6cn3oqo jcn636ocn
c"t5 ;bj6o 3Lroc3cn3636oLrob 336oob qoobob qoboL, (,,e.eo q [][;.[ >"; 6o3Jqocq6b 3c.,oq6D. oC 33cn33%ot:ogc6 Aro6m, 6cn3 laoborrnlro q,:
o6q} 3
6f t,
f B ob g c c., 3 o q o L: 6 o 63 6,: fl B 6- 3 6 o ts
36 lq rn B
r 6o o y m . il, r c, olr
J q o(b I 3 63 i:g 6r c cn 6 3bg 3 3 ; 3 cn 3 q c . 3 I 6 f q ; c.,L 3 o I q 0 6 I c 3 E o[: g c l.: c -
l.:
{r
230 231
I
AlArq 3o3363o BpSce qo33 goog%o35c,6c.,3 $6coolrc.,o6 ere3JUq- bo3oc', Lr"J36oblAlqb c8cn3gc66g5. Sc"rUcl:bo3ob daf8 Scb3oqSbl,
c.,o cbqcobq36lr o6 366c.rc., er D6 Bo3jcnq'oo,. 3oqo3e6l6 qo bScSogqo Scncn j3o3q636.CqI63Lr Sooro b3o ts33co3lr3;,
CqC6C3 o,3o 3cno'46o, 3oLr6r er bc.,bcn3r, 3q'o€)33-
Celj$6otr EfBUAoOr Jqoef36fl,O6rl, LrDgq;B%l eobog36o Soor3qro 3c.,-
63b$6ob loogqrA%C er3ern go 8olr. trUqolr 8c.,boblr3636q"e %3q;- l:olrb,:3o1.: jtr c.r3 r e D L:obobq3B. 33o Jo$ot r. cn63lr$3b3; go Jo qoq3bSo
tsOA erCq3o6o.CqlC$6c3 jo6ocn gcol.-'$j36;. ':6 3co35rn6o, (][]o- 3;b3oql6. o3oB3q3b, Joqoq3bo 96ogocq 3cn63El.r qca6oo, 6o633-
er8 6c.,3 Sbc.rqcnq c.,8ob 6cnq'cnl6. Aroqco qc c3 bojEob Bltrob-n3- go 3c.,p6qcn3o, cn63b$llr" Jo lqt6ll, Scobo3qDBDe 3o3o6qr.3;g6;3
qCb q oq SoLr j rq o"3 B o q 3 g63 o cn 63b c.,o6 3 oc g % ;3 6o. C q 6 CB 3 3 -'r 8,, - C
%331:oL: 66do636oo.,, cJcnqcn6so 3ql6l q6Ubql&3o gcob3oo, c.rqo3-
-60 Lrotrcbqoqo6 go8coob8c",. c,6c, 6b6c 6qol.: oum,6co13c aq363 J.>- Jc.rlr%3 oog3o6r eD UJaeDBrq ojgoo (8ctr tsr8era Oqc6c cDr3ob d333
6olrlr g;393o. $6cnlb c.,8o 6co3 qoo6gcn,3363qornb3; 3363ocn63 ,.1(,o- q o cnLr 3p 63 b c.rc 6 3 6c.,o q g o 61, G q q 3. Bo 3o 6q 6. q 3 r % cs o 3 636 Lr
O
"
g3363log6cb erflOcn3o.CoqoB3oqSo goqo b6olo j6;b;3cl eteo er- 3gr633qcn6go),
6cb3obcm6r33 o66rn qc c.,bcn36o UUCqUAr6cnq 33gl.r63qr. o3;Lrc.rb o3o CqcCO6oS 3 363o -5c 33oJ g6cn, lr oLro bq33o Soog
3o6o
oSobcnboEo bcLrobq3ts. Sf 6Oqocntro 8co3oqr, cDr3obo Lro3o36o e"6- q o gf o 3 3o 6 o o 6 c % o . 3 363 q o cn 3 o 3 6 d o 6;, j oq o'3 a o q o E r c o,r a., U R -
B L: l.,
qo6gcnbo 6obo. $o6qo6gcnbo bJo66oq,:6 BoSco3oeD er jcqo83oqoL> qlAo6o-. SC6lqocobob bcqbSo d"ts3o6o b6cn63q ..,3 q 6.nt, 3r-
tr. J e o q b A q cn B c'l 6 e o . $ o 6 q o 6 3 cn 3 c 3 3 6 g q o c"r Lr J.: 66 o Lr 3 o 6., % I
O
L: Lr L: c 3qb 6 o o, 6 cn
3 6 c cn 6 g b$ 3 b b o l-r.: b q C U 6 e D g o q c a 6 3 c, 3 3 6 3 o c., 63 3 - J -
Lr
C
g3bolr qreAAo oj36doq'o, oU ob qo36rtso3g qol.:6pqCAL, ,:6 gcalr- qr er cDAocDCo6oG 3%;q oUCn erq3J3qourn.Ul66oq cJc.rqco6o ar-
6 rn 6q 3 b cn q o. $ n 6qo 6 g cnb o g o j 6 cn b eo, 6 rn 3 J q oO 3 6 3 b$ 16 c cnc 3 o o
C
l.-r 3cnB6qr, r6c3336cn6ob df t, Bo6cqqr6o b3q.ec6 SoBcobgc6o qo 3363-
qo6c 3 o 3q obo c., 3o Sbcn q coe C tq o j oq oE 6 od 33 3E ; Lr o 3Lr o b 3 63 6 q ;,
L-: q'rc.,bob boqbog Aogo6t. oJcoqco6Sr 66do6o, 336Cqrcqlrll obrqo
bcnqcn c.,U 3rnjoqoj336o Sobo Lr.J3qoq'ocD ecl:3e ab 3c'roo,bco3q6C6, GCoqo 6cBcogd365;, c.r63lo6llr" 33-n3ocn6f %f qo jr-,66o638 jqoUm qr
c.r63b$Clrl., eler U6ec er3GB.:. obqr 3o rn63bg3loo6r er CqICO6c6, b Jo6gcSo qcB6j6f BOqoUCn,
deo63363bg6cls 3;aqlqcnb c%3 o gc6
8ot:o c%6oo.,, Bobcjc.rq36o og3636. Ce;6er eD 3b boj3l e8f 6c.,33olrcor3o[-: Sog6qcn (336oJoel,"m63b&f-
$ o 6 q o 6 3 cn Lr 3 o c.r 6 3 Lrtb I " e C q o b 3,"i q I q cn b o 3 o q D D e r 6 ; c a q .>
^3
1., Lr.").
qo 3o3C6Cq. U bU O lb 33 o 3 o 3o - qC 16 e 6 (n qc"r l., o
Scno go36 ao 6 m 3 3 6 o 6 o g 3 o b 3 m ofu m 3 6 o bJ q oO 3 3 63 [-'qg 6 o lo
-l
c.rb o b 3 co. e "6q c fl % cn o3 3 cn b to,
lo oL: o3 o 6 c., q rnlr o 3 cn q.> J,: -
*{ J36oqllr.,
3 cno cn b cn
A er,
o qo6
A lO
g b oB QC r 6 o 6 6odcts3oqo o3c6ocntrol: 3cgo^33oqoG, BlUc6-eo (Jca-
6
"q A 5
6o33brner c,r63L:$SLrLro er CqSCO6rtr, o63ob 3o36c 3cc.,c.,3o[) cDrA- L:o6oolro, Vlll, 34, 2).
"33lro9o6o,6gcqo qr
GCGbq..co63lr$Ct L, URqCbo o6 8obg3b lrolrbq-
3o 3cno,b36oq. bCqCEo qca6o6o. A r63 o 66 S E f 6 o.8;ggq,oo, froA6oA6oqa qog6ob ggo6g3o6o
SC6Cqccololr c6 jEqcoer $o6qc63rnl:ol.r 6g36o636o qc c.,63b$3bo o Jc.rq'c.r6olr 3 go63 3q cnScb 6oB 6rAer.
b obr3o6c.,qrnb goq ct Gu. b oLr o3 o6cnqcob cn63lr$31:og 3lr663b coqc. areS-G38o o8ol, 83bobCa, 6-3 Jqo\CSfub66ob 36o6ogb3;
ogo3336rn6ob d3 66d6cnbqo Joqoq3l-iob o,;6cg6d6cn6ol.: qc doqo 334- ndgbgCbn CeU"go6 Areroy 3s62b, c6 33odq3bo ctb.JCqo q6o3o-
OIE-qo. Joqog3l:ol.r 3o3o3 3o6o -CAo 33oq%f (8;aqDqcoAc8r-, 3c",- O U 66 3 6 o b 3 3 6c q c.r g o 3c.r6r g c.r6o q 3 o 3 o 86o cn c.,' U dB 3q 3lo 3 Jco j o o
^3
6 o q 3 rn b o c 6 c JoO o ) . l.: o b c 3,: 6 c., q rn 3 cn 6 3 b6 3 l.r b c., 3 o c., 3 J 3 q C q r, - ol.: c6c 3;615cn 3cn6go616&u 6 Lr ob
6o
" 36d63oBo, c6o3ce .lu6duql] %le
6o 8o3lro5o. Joqoq3[:3o o6 8o;tb-Bo 33gc.r6o6o er cDr3o[ro qo6o6- go6c.,cre oU cq aTA6GCqCA Uqo.
e3qo CqCCO6o, Eggcn8636b p6Boo, 6"qAc6 bo8o3C6. gc66.6Uq- ndgbficbb Snqcqre o8ogc.r8 -aqoq636,6rn3 3o6 o6 Sgotr6u-
eo L:o33qoql: ot3oqo6 406 roGoq3bq636, Lr.,JBeoqob 6o6
6o og36C6 qc 83oqob Arqo eo blqo c6 333tsoqc 3o3l6Cql6b, bot:6pq3Eo
boSbqoqot:o er qr qc$olso crr3 ol., 3f 6f qoc.rbo qo 3bo3q rcD er 8rn 33 q'ccn 3-C g3o6co, bclro33qoq c.l A c6cB36o. 6co6-6G Bo6L:, lo;Lr o3o6c., qcr)
CqC6C, 6cn8q.t, a3qol:c.,3 ot, oG cO q36o r 6re3633 c qr
rOU erc, cn>3[ r - re3oqre o(JAqoer o%6b,6.eAc6o1y 3f 6f qorn[-t3o qc $o6qc63cnb3c
3qCC66o joqojolr JCAqSbb 3oq3o qc6Bo.3oloc6 J jcn6qc a3g3.r, eroUmqo3b oAo, cn63lr$3boboc.,3o[: [:obo33eoqr, go6o836o g,:8co-
U6e-er, Jeog3363trg6ob bogqo3oqc6 Scn8r3oqo 3363o-6C Sdll- ggo6;.
qre a3g3c6r qr o3oc., Sf 6lqcrnbo c.,o3o[: ,*;Uo%C IOr63bo6c. cSct-,rn- g 6 o 6o C6 n 3 c6or q 8Lr o3g U q C A r q 3 o oB 6l Se 6 I 6 o,o 3 l.r q o 3 JA q 3 q b,
b o^3o c.r63l:$Clr. qo Joqo qSlo o Lrobob q0ts. 3Ca.e6r6. 3c., b c',361q l- 8co g 3 o Lr o b lo o L:bq o b q o 3q A 6 f q |.r, Lr., J B e o q,o c, f S U C 6 3 b cn g 636.
232 233
\
{
J
36o6o13. 5c6brbo3636oo bo6qob"L, C,:6x6ob, 6cn33qL,cG ;k qc6
t P,AlUqo LcboLr tsftrrG3qlqre tr3q36ob 3-6U3l6clrr,c6 UJAI
5o163o6oUq, 33qo63%ooBo tslf .jq oc 3rn 3qrlr,:q o3o ;6o, 6m3 3q3cg
J r(r6,:3o6 caca8o636L.
636l.,rocn co3 U636qo3q err6q3.., Oobn. cb3oo cqoSooSo c6 a-63- I
6oL: 3o6go3L, eo jcnjcnbol: JcqSoqc6 c.,r3eDqSo B;6ql]o o6, drcoSc'r63
co6 3 L:$ C Lr., c.,.: 3Lr o36c aL:, 3 ; 6L-t o 3 b cn B Lr Lr oL: 3 f q - L, o,* 3 f q % !, A o Q 6 C
I q,o
3
oUCn
q C
6C,
333-ncq
6 rn g cn 6g
TR6-
c 6 o Lr C q C 3 3 6 oro, 3 % q o g 6 6 o lr 3 g; 6
3 cn
Dq6C,3oq6!
"
3
q3mr;b6o3o
I A 3
6UTJ;3o
af
(Jc.rqo-
-
234 2Js
)
eD,3qo pc 8rc.,o Aflqo Lrcbmqce mq 3cno6co. Jmqco5rnlrE,r13, [,.rg-3.i1; %cngo36o133o o33c.,3 36, mdgb$gbob ;o>963o 3o c6o qr o66cnqolr-
^3
c63olr Bfldqm 3(no6o3bou ndtlqilL 63o6qo $cdr6?o 7J11lr{l('.),) s.t,r o 3 6 q., B" 3rb o 6o o 6$ 3 3 oL: ob 5 o Scob ob U q I A r ( 3 o g o631r.,,,3oc.,3 6. ",
odf nd 3g6n533Bo6,lrcecg nr6lt tbltrBc l-,o6r-,6bqob 3r'r(.r"r[, l),r.)(t) 2q
8.,1., $;dc6o og3o6c.,r,8rcn l3336oq33t nBcnelAp[i35-
(itlt,?,,,J,,t\]ll, 3oc.,o[: %cngo 336boot: c,o6;b3oq , odOCSob $q6obgqob jgdgSo
,,ogob35oo $;3dnolr^3o",968 qr ts8g:g.;3m33qorng6.5,nc"rl>o ,Jl( )qlil[lt'r[,, r, 1,oqn 3oo,6oJo6b or;333go636Uqo tlUe llroor3ob 6o6ob6o6 b6o6"A-
G oO.: L; rn g c.r J q Cb,,crlo e o J c.rlr o J q m6 cob B o ", 42 i - q .; 3 [, ;i,,.- l t, .,i -
CO Lr
] ) i J
qo 5r636336q 3lrbaf6Jql., e" 3f6l rgf6oqo 8c[r c',33b1o, 3o66o3 o6
336oeI6r-rb"3-Jqt?o6o;6l.-to; Jo3bo6ocl-ro,Vll ,25,A;Bc!oJ(.l(l(,1i,..(v)()- Jqr3eo (336cnecn63,lY,26).
qoJcobo Jcoqcn6cnl,E.",37 e" 42- 43. l.rb3c a36lrooo, j.:6o^3boq8o co63l:$Clr. .iU6dUq 6-ernl.r%3 3oo-
6fu6oqr3Jol-' 3q3nfu3o, brqog Sbcoqc"re 3.>,, .rr;i .J;j.r[i-
oc.,36Bo Sgqoc.rlrob c.r6capqob o,o6cb3re, joGqcaCbo Coqod.t, Jl-
93o6o. .,C,
ercr, tsftraq.l, UBqlSo,Bo6G qoo$o6f t , 6cngcn66 333crr.>r7,,',,,)(rtir),) ACq%C eDe6o. %cn3 o36c.rgb ob o%6oor, 6o eAc6c 6 olcnqcn6So 366d o-
LroSo 3-no6ool:3c8ort:;bjqlAr. ll" So8cnl:ubUqtbfbo;(7r flr[],'v-rf i,\(')- 6ojo6qo33bo o$o3,:^3o BoOcoS$;6o, oo65o3 oAo bSo6oroo'3o 3c.ro6obp-
e C
b r" q r E; <r, 6 A [] 6q n cr, 3 q g r 6 3 o6 ob j 3 3 ts 3 cnob g 3 3 -n cnl ]
3 . It - .J,r r.r,' )
- qr qr gb6do6o, goSco[:rbgqCbr brbo%q36- CoqoC 66o36cn63"3o
33633bo1i,: a?n e3eo-3n6ob - 6r3cnl:rbgqgBrlr oJ Uglq,rt,, 'i, ,[,,',1
l.:o[-,, i er3eAo. ot: o6qb33o[: go36cnJc.rqob godo6"3o p6qr oqa3t, q" AUqo
t 6 3 c"r J,: g col: o S3Aq Cq cnA ; B o g q ; 6o 3 o 3 q c., g B c c., S q o S? i, T),r'i, ),., i 1 )
oeoSoo6ol, Ulqoer6 A"qEcnl.r3qo Lrobbqoor U6eo Srnoq6c-rl:rn.
6olo Sbbel6Jqo j6qo tsff6o6o. ;cn36clr qoJo63bob;033 i,, if iil';[ir,- oc.,36o6 oRoAC6oo c3 qgod6o[: CU6uSre qDogg6c cb godo6o l":o- qr
qCAL, bb3r 3Lrb336Jqlro6 [-t6o6.rAg6l6.o3o[:o,c6-At, oo.llcy)[)T],i'.[, ll,',- Grngbqols bcnq-8e3 8olro c.,ca^83bogo 6o g obq o. o3ob cno6o33, 3olror
Alqo cn3olr L:,:8o qrSoqc6 36o,-36oro f dqA6lbcnqc q,: c[J g;(7rl tt, ,',(')l )- u Aob U6ec ts3X6o6ocn 3'3cn6o,:6cnEol: Arqrucnqoq 3qoqo6 joqc.,o
c,rJogcnloo 333q3qc.r3o[:l"",C8ft, go6oboqo3eo
(33Lro;J,,,'t[r,,, (\]I)';'l* $c6lro6 3C q.,. c6c.,b 8ob 3q3oo, c.r63lr$3bol.r 5333o bobcnqcqme
oO 5 g
ii,
,, cnqo CGqCAT er cDrBDe oao 6o6Scne636oqor 6c.rgrn6g Egg6c6-
I
boqo,6c.r8gqo6 3%oerr Bcoqo6cnb oboqo bo^3o63qCB16o. c.r63l.rtbf -
yl
loo 3363qccnbolr Sr8erg l.:Jo6$ctso 83gcober, %cngo36o,o 6U" 6m
( o J rn q cn q cn 6 c.,b o,,,! J o$ cn 3 r", 6, 28)
a g 3 cn A B Gl 3 b, 6 cn 3 co 6 g btb I Lr.
I
,l
6 U
-6c'r Cb. er B r6 oc 66 f 3 o. nigb$gbob ogoyCSo;lsrn;G ( "
o6 3 o qo,:'8 o a A Cq o b 6 c a 6 3 6o Lrc g c 6 6 r6e r oGA rq D.
3 # A l q 6 o l.-t ; 3 3 r A |., 3 m g 3 o c., b 6 c., 5 b : a J m q co e co 6 co o,,,! J o $ cn 3 o ", V l,
I
Lr qt
ts lo'5 d q o r, c 3 cn q 3 c 6 b 3 3 cn b q ; co6 3 L:$ 3lr o Lr, 6 rn 6 cn 6 6 r e a o -
26,27; 336oJrrq3: ,,0gog36oo $t36olr^3o", 32,4A er ts8ea .,77, BB, 3
" C
63qo Jo3bo6o.>Liob l, 43, 1-oL,t 3ob3q3ocn; o3oo63[i 3c633q'o63bo, X X ll, Bre, trJc6qSo8o Arero$c631*r (336c.rqcn$I ,1,67 33ea.)
,*\
8,34.
2s6 2s7