Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT: The detailed research study of manufactur- polarized light optical microscopy, and wide-angle x-ray
ing PPS fibers using melt spinning and further enhance- scattering. Changes in dynamic mechanical behavior of as-
ment of tensile properties by drawing and annealing spun fibers manufactured from resins of varying MW and
experiments, a study lacking as of today in open scientific different melt spinning take-up speeds were also studied.
literature, was the focus of this research. This article dis- The study showed that by a combination of higher MW of
cusses the effect of polymer molecular weight (MW) and the polymer and spinning at higher take-up speeds, tensile
melt spinning process variables on the structure and prop- properties of as-spun PPS fibers can be improved. V C 2011
erties development in melt spun fibers manufactured from Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Appl Polym Sci 122: 3110–3121, 2011
proprietary FortronV R linear PPS resins. Structure-proper-
ties relationship was studied using several characterization Key words: high performance polymers; thermoplastics;
tools like tensile testing, differential scanning calorimetry, structure-property relations; extrusion; fibers
Melt spinning
Pilot melt spinning facility comprising of Fourne’ sin-
gle screw extruder was used. Freshly dried samples
of each polymer were fed to feed hopper. Dry N2
gas was continuously supplied to the hopper. The 12
holes spinnerets with 0.8 mm diameter capillary, and
length to diameter (L/D) ratio of 10 and 5 were used
to produce multifilament as-spun yarns. The fila-
ments exiting the spinneret were allowed to cool
under atmospheric conditions in around 2.5 m long
spinline, and wound using a Leesona high speed
winder. In the spinline, upon filament solidification,
spin finish of 10% concentration (by volume), pre-
pared in distilled water at room temperature, was
applied to all the yarns under controlled rate so that
spin finish pick up on the yarn was 1%. Figure 127
shows the schematic of the melt spinning line, and
the spinning process parameters are given in Table I.
Fiber characterization
Fiber denier
Weight of 1 m length of the yarn, and the number of
filaments in the yarn bundle were measured to cal-
Figure 1 Schematic of the melt spinning line. culate the filament denier. Denier is defined as the
mass in grams of 9000 m length of the filament. For
fibers. This article discusses the results of as-spun each sample, five readings were taken and the aver-
fiber studies. The findings of investigations pertain- age is reported.
ing to draw-annealing process will be continued in
subsequent publications. Tensile properties
The tensile properties of the as-spun fibers were
MATERIALS AND METHODS measured using a Thwing-Albert tensile tester
Materials equipped with a 2000 g load cell. The testing was
done on single filaments mounted on specially pre-
Three variations of proprietary FortronV R linear PPS
pared paper tabs, to avoid fiber slippage in the jaws.
resins, varying in MW, in the pellets form were sup- For each sample, 10 single filaments taken from vari-
plied by Ticona Polymers, a business of Celanese ous portions of the yarn were glued on the tabs
Chemicals. The sample codes are 1P, 2P, and 3P. using epoxy resin and allowed to cure before testing.
Gauge length (distance between the tab ends) used
Polymer characterization was 25.4 mm. Since as-spun fibers possessed larger
extensions, the rate of extension for testing as-spun
Melt flow index (MFI), of all three grades of poly- fibers was kept such that fibers broke in 20 6 3 s as
mers was determined using a Tinius Olsens’ Extru- recommended in ASTM standard D3822.28 Average
sion Plastomer MP200. ASTM standard D123826 was of 10 readings is reported for tenacity and breaking
followed for these measurements, with barrel tem- elongation. Tenacity is defined as the breaking force
perature of 315 C and load of 5 kg as recommended per unit linear density, that is, denier. Tensile
for PPS.
Melting behavior of all three grades of PPS was TABLE I
studied using Mettler differential scanning calorime- Melt Spinning Process Parameters
ter (DSC) 822e. As-received pellets were dried under Extrusion Throughput Take-up
vacuum at 120 C for 3 hours prior to characteriza- temperature ( C) (g/12 holes/min) speed (mpm)
tion. The rate of heating in DSC experiments was
10 C/min. After holding the melt at 325 C for 10 Low (315) Low (9) Low (1025)
High (340) High (12) Medium (1750)
min, crystallization from melt was studied at a cool- High (2350)
ing rate of 10 C/min.
Crystalline orientation
Pin-hole patterns of parallel arrays of multifilament
yarn laid on sample holder, were obtained using
Molecular Metrology wide angle X-ray scattering
(WAXS) system, on reusable Fuji image plates. X-
Figure 2 MFI of various PPS resins. rays of wavelength 1.5418 Å were produced using
monochromatic CuKa radiation. It was operated at
modulus was calculated from the load-elongation 45 kV and 0.66 mA, and the beam size was around
plots in the initial region of up to 2% elongation. 30 lm. The sample to film distance was set at 36.52
mm. Images obtained after enough sample exposure
were subsequently read using the scanner, the FujiX-
Morphological evaluations BAS 1800II image analyzer. Since the pin-hole pat-
Crystallinity terns of as-spun fibers exhibited very little crystal-
line orientation, the plot of diffraction intensity of
Degree of crystallinity (X) in fibers was evaluated reflection from (110) plane as a function of azi-
using Mettler 822e DSC. Prior to sample evaluations, muthal angle was constructed using the Polar soft-
DSC was calibrated using the standard indium and ware, to get an idea about the crystalline orientation
zinc samples. The yarn bundle was knotted care- in these fibers.
fully, without changing the sample history, to pro-
vide restraint in the easiest possible way during
thermal analysis. Some kind of restraint was sug- Dynamic thermomechanical analysis
gested by earlier researchers29,30 to prevent any
Since, the as spun fibers were to be drawn subse-
relaxation in fibers during heating in DSC. Around 4
quently at draw temperatures above glass transition
mg of fibers was packed in the aluminum pan and
temperature (Tg), thermomechanical response of as-
heated to 325 C at 20 C/min under N2 atmosphere.
spun fibers was evaluated using TA instruments’
Degree of crystallinity was calculated using eq. (1).
dynamic thermomechanical analyzer (DMA) series
DHf Q-800. The multifilament yarns of 8–10 mm length
X¼ (1) were subjected to constant tension of 0.05N at an
DH0f oscillating frequency of 1 Hz. Temperature profile
used was 25–200 C at the heating rate of 3 C/min.
where, DHf is the heat of fusion of the sample deter-
mined from the DSC thermogram after subtracting
the heat of crystallization, if any, that took place Statistical analysis
during heating. DH0f is the heat of fusion of 100%
crystalline PPS and was taken as 112 J/g.31 The effect of several variables on as-spun fiber mor-
phology and tensile properties was analyzed by con-
structing leverage plots using statistics software JMP
Molecular orientation 8.0. The correlation between the fiber morphology
and properties was also evaluated statistically using
Overall orientation
this software. The solid line in leverage plots is the
Birefringence was measured using a polarized light best fit based upon the data points, and dotted lines
optical microscope equipped with 20 order Ehring- indicate 95% confidence limits.
haus compensator. To determine the extinction with
more accuracy, monochromatic light filter of 587 nm
was placed above the polarizer. From the average of RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
three readings for each sample, measured (uncor-
Polymer characteristics
rected) retardation (Cm) was noted from the retarda-
tion tables supplied by the compensator manufac- MFI of PPS resins is shown in Figure 2. The order of
turer.32 To take into account the fringe jumping MFI is 1P > 2P > 3P, and therefore, the order of
phenomenon that occurs in engineering polymers MW can be deduced as 1P < 2P < 3P. MW of 3P is
like PPS, corrected value of number of orders (Nd) substantially higher than 2P, as compared to the dif-
was calculated using the method as described by ference in MW between 2P and 1P.
Figure 3 Melting behavior of PPS resins. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at
wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Thermal behavior of resins as studied by DSC is up speed, and with decrease in throughput. Increase
not significantly different (Fig. 3). Slightly lower in draw-down ratio leads to more drawing of the
peak melting temperature with increase in MW can fibers and hence decreases the fiber denier. Similar
be ascribed to the fact that with increase in MW, behavior is observed in the fibers spun from 1P and
comparatively lower chain mobility due to more 2P. Leverage plots revealed that the effect of take-up
chain entanglements may lead to development of speed and throughput on fiber denier is highly stat-
somewhat imperfect crystals. Similar dependence of istically significant (P < 0.0001, where P is the prob-
peak melting temperature on crystals’ nature was ability of occurrence of the effect by chance).
reported in other thermoplastic fibers, for example,
polybutylene terephthalate.35 The percentage value
given above each of the thermograms in the figure is Effect of polymer MW
the degree of crystallinity developed in each of the
polymers. With increase in MW, degree of crystallin- Statistical significance of the influence of MW on
ity decreases. Similar MW dependence of degree of fiber properties and morphology is shown in
crystallinity in PPS has been reported earlier by Figure 5. With increase in MW, tenacity increases
other investigators.4–10 [Fig. 5(a)] and breaking elongation decreases
[Fig. 5(b)]. With increase in MW, the number of
defects in the form of chain ends decreases, and
As-spun fiber structure and properties chain entanglement increases. Therefore, due to
In the following sections, the influence of several
variables on as-spun fiber properties is discussed.
Unless mentioned specifically, capillary L/D used
was 10. Leverage plots are constructed using JMP
8.0 statistical software to understand the statistical
significance of the effects. While plotting the effects
of MW, inverse of MFI is taken so that the direct
correlation with MW can be understood.
Fiber denier
Effect of take-up speed and throughput on denier of
fibers spun from polymer 3P at two extrusion tem-
peratures (ET) is shown in Figure 4. Fiber denier
decreases with increase in take-up speed and Figure 4 Factors influencing fiber denier. (Polymer 3P;
decrease in throughput. At given process conditions, throughput: solid lines-high and dotted lines-low; extru-
the draw-down ratio increases with increase in take- sion temperature: circle-low and triangle-high).
Figure 5 Leverage plots of effect of polymer MW (a 1/MFI) on (a) as-spun fiber tenacity; (b) breaking elongation; (c)
birefringence; and (d) degree of crystallinity. (Samples matrix with all spinning process variables for three polymer types).
[Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
higher viscosity of the polymer at given extrusion Figure 6 shows the cold crystallization behavior of
temperature, melt of higher MW polymer experien- the as-spun fibers manufactured from all three resins
ces higher level of spinline stresses at given take-up spun under similar conditions. Higher the MW of
speed. Resulting increase in molecular orientation as
evidenced by increasing trend in birefringence [Fig.
5(c)] leads to increased fiber tenacity and decreased
breaking elongation. Decrease in the level of crystal-
linity with increase in MW [Fig. 5(d)] can be
explained on the basis that, with increase in MW mo-
lecular mobility decreases because of higher number
of chain entanglements. In the spinline, within the
short time available, before filament temperature
drops to Tg due to rapid cooling, lower molecular
mobility may be suppressing the crystallization more
than the enhancement that may occur because of
increase in spinline stress.
Tensile modulus of 3P fibers is found to be
around 25 gpd (grams per denier) whereas that of
1P is found to be around 19 gpd. Higher tensile
modulus of 3P fibers as compared to that of 1P can Figure 6 Influence of MW on cold crystallization behavior
be attributed to higher molecular orientation in the of as-spun fibers. (All fibers were spun at 1750 mpm; extru-
former case. sion temperature 315 C; throughput: 12 g/min/12 holes).
Figure 7 Effect of melt spinning variables on (a) as-spun fiber tenacity; (b) breaking elongation; (c) birefringence; and (d)
degree of crystallinity. (Solid lines: high throughput; dotted lines: low throughput; extrusion temperature: 315 C, capillary
L/D 10).
polymer from which fiber is spun, lower is the tem- 8(b)]. At higher take-up speeds, higher spinline
perature of onset and peak in crystallization exo- stresses exerted on the filaments lead to improve-
therm. It suggests that the higher the polymer MW, ment in the molecular orientation along the fiber
crystallization occurs earlier in the fibers. When axis and improved molecular orientation, as seen by
spun under similar processing conditions, the spin- increase in birefringence results in increase in tenac-
line stress, and therefore, molecular orientation will ity and decrease in elongation. Besides its depend-
be higher in fibers spun from high MW polymers as ence on time and temperature, crystallization is
discussed before. In the presence of chain mobility influenced by stresses as well. The time available for
induced thermally above Tg during DSC experi- crystallization before fiber temperature drops below
ments, the fiber structure with higher orientation is Tg may not be significantly different at various take-
more favorable for crystallization, and hence the up speeds. Under these circumstances, for a given
fiber crystallizes earlier. polymer, increasing spinline stress with increase in
take-up speed causes the degree of crystallinity to
Effect of take-up speed increase due to stress induced crystallization. It is to
Effect of take-up speed and throughput on as-spun be noted that even at highest take-up speed studied;
fiber tensile properties is shown in Figure 7, and the the degree of crystallinity is lower (close to 20%)
corresponding leverage plots are shown in Figure 8. than crystallization potential ( 30–35%) of these
With increase in take-up speed, tenacity [Figs. 7(a) polymers under quiescent conditions as discussed
and 8(a)], birefringence [Figs. 7(c) and 8(c)], and earlier. Slow increase in crystallinity with take-up
degree of crystallinity [Figs. 7(d) and 8(d)] increase, speed up to 4000 mpm was reported by Chen
and breaking elongation decreases [Figs. 7(b) and et al.36 in the case of PET melt spun fibers.
Figure 8 Leverage plots of effect of take-up speed on (a) as-spun fiber tenacity; (b) breaking elongation; (c) birefringence;
and (d) degree of crystallinity (sample matrix of all other process parameters combined). [Color figure can be viewed in
the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Trends in Figure 7 indicate that the rate of change tions were reported in the case of fibers spun from
in fiber properties is higher initially, and decreases isotactic polypropylene37 and from PET.38 Ziabicki39
thereafter with increase in take-up speed. It implies explained this phenomenon on the basis of the com-
that the amount of change brought by the take-up petition between crystallization and rapid cooling,
speed in fiber properties is not linear but rather during fiber spinning. With increase in take-up
decreases with increase in speed. Similar observa- speed, rate of crystallization increases due to higher
Figure 9 WAXS pin-hole patterns (fiber axis vertical). (Fiber spinning conditions: Polymer: 3P; extrusion temperature:
315 C; throughput: 12 g/min/12 holes; capillary L/D: 10).
Figure 11 Effect of throughput on (a) as-spun fiber tenacity; (b) breaking elongation; (c) birefringence; and (d) degree of
crystallinity (all other process variables combined). [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at
wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Effect of throughput
With increase in throughput, changes in fiber prop-
erties follow similar trends as observed with
decrease in take-up speed. Figure 11 shows the
Figure 13 Effect of capillary L/D on (a) as-spun fiber
leverage plots for this variable whereas actual data tenacity; (b) breaking elongation (all other process varia-
of fiber properties versus throughput was shown bles combined). [Color figure can be viewed in the online
earlier in Figure 7. Decrease in draw-down ratio issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
CONCLUSIONS
Dynamic mechanical behavior of as-spun fibers
The structure-properties development in the as-spun
Changes in storage modulus and in length of as- PPS fibers indicates that the fiber tenacity increases
spun fibers recorded during DMA tests are shown and elongation decreases with increase in polymer
in Figure 16. These fibers were manufactured from MW, with increase in take-up speed, and with
all three polymers under similar spinning process decrease in throughput. Within the range of tempera-
conditions. It is clear from Figure 16 that with higher tures studied, extrusion temperature exhibits negligible
polymer MW, the minimum in storage modulus influence on as-spun fiber properties. The most signifi-
occurs at higher temperature. Corresponding change cant variables affecting fiber properties are found to be
in length is also shown on secondary axis in Figure polymer MW, take-up speed and throughput. As-spun
16. Above Tg, as-spun fibers of 1P show viscous flow fibers with tenacities close to 4 gpd and breaking elon-
like behavior without any shrinkage. Comparatively, gations around 30% were obtained by spinning at high
fibers spun from 2P and 3P shrink increasingly in take up speeds. The degree of crystallinity developed
the order of their MW, before exhibiting the viscous in the as-spun fibers as a function of spinning process
flow like behavior. It is further noted that the tem- variables varied in the range of 10–20%. As-spun fiber
perature at which viscous flow begins increases as tenacity is positively correlated with birefringence and
the polymer MW increases. Prior to the onset of vis- the differences are statistically significant. The molecu-
cous flow, increasing amount of shrinkage above Tg lar orientation enhances the crystallization behavior in
in the as spun fibers with increasing polymer MW, fibers. The thermomechanical behavior of as-spun
indicates presence of higher level of stresses and fibers shows a definite trend and is influenced by
therefore molecular orientation due to increasing physical crosslinks.
number of chain entanglements. Higher level of mo-
lecular orientation is supported by higher birefrin- We sincerely thank Ticona Polymers for supplying various
gence in 3P fiber (0.128) than in 1P fiber (0.057). Sim- grades of proprietary FortronV R linear PPS resins used. Con-
ilar behavior was observed during DMA testing of tinued interaction with Dr. Manoj Ajbani, Dr. Ke Feng, and
fibers spun from 1P at take-up speeds of 1750 mpm Lisa Baker (all from Ticona Polymers) is gratefully acknowl-
and 2350 mpm. The fibers spun at 2350 mpm edged. The financial support from Center for Materials Proc-
showed minimum storage modulus and onset of vis- essing, The University of Tennessee, Knoxville during the
cous flow at higher temperature than the fiber spun studies of PG is also highly acknowledged.
at 1750 mpm. Also former showed shrinkage before
the onset of viscous flow. Birefringence of 1P fiber References
spun at 1750 mpm was 0.057, and that of the fiber
1. Edmonds, J. J. T.; Hill, J. H. W. (Phillips Petroleum Company).
spun at 2350 mpm was 0.158. Thus, higher level of U.S. Pat.3,354,129 (1967).
molecular orientation at higher take-up speeds can 2. Lenz, R. W.; Carrington, W. K. J Polym Sci 1959, 41, 333.
be attributed to observed dynamic mechanical 3. Lenz, R. W.; Handlovits, C. E. J Polym Sci 1960, 43, 167.
behavior of the as-spun fibers. 4. Jog, J. P.; Nadkarni, V. M. J Appl Polym Sci 1985, 30, 997.
In a study on heat treatment of PET fibers, Pesz- 5. Menczel, J. D.; Collins, G. L. Polym Eng Sci 1992, 32, 1264.
6. Lovinger, A. J.; Davies, D. D.; Padden, F. J Polym 1985, 26,
kin and Schultz42 reported that the physical cross- 1595.
links are necessary to produce shrinkage during 7. Lopez, L. C.; Wilkes, G. L. Polymer 1988, 29, 106.
heating the fibers by preventing free movement of 8. Lopez, L. C.; Wilkes, G. L. Polymer 1989, 30, 882.
9. Chung, J. S.; Cebe, P. J. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys 1992, 27. Spruiell, J. E. In Structure formation in polymeric fibers;
30, 163. Salem, D., Ed.; Hanser Gardener Publications Inc., Cincinnati
10. Collins, G.; Menczel, J. Polym Eng Sci 2004, 32, 1270. 2000, p 5–93.
11. Hawkins, R. T. Macromolecules 1976, 9, 189. 28. ASTM D3822, Standard test method for tensile properties of
12. Scobbo, J. J., Jr. J Appl Polym Sci 1993, 48 2055. single textile fibers 2007.
13. Scobbo, J. J., Jr. J Appl Polym Sci 1993, 47, 2169. 29. Jaffe, M. In Thermal Characterization of Polymeric Materials;
14. Lopez, L. C.; Wilkes, G. L. J Macromol Sci. Rev in Macromol Turi, E. A., Ed.; Academic Press: Orlando Florida, 1981,
Chem Phys 1989, 29, 83. p 709–792.
15. Brady, D. G. J Appl Polym Sci 1976, 20, 2541. 30. Todoki, M.; Kawaguchi, T. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys
16. Christopher, N. S. J.; Cotter, J. L.; Knight, G. J.; Wright, W. W. 1977, 15, 1507.
J Appl Polym Sci 1968, 12, 863. 31. Huo, P.; Cebe, P. Colloid Polym Sci 1992, 270, 840.
17. Jog, J. P.; Bulakh, N.; Nadkarni, V. M. Bull Mater Sci 1994, 17, 32. Data from manufacturer, Ehringhaus compensator.
1079. 33. Cha, C. Y.; Samuels, R. J. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys
18. Budgell, D. R.; Day, M. Polym Eng Sci 1991, 31, 1271. 1995, 33, 259.
19. Zhang, R.-C.; Xu, Y.; Lu, A.; Cheng, K.; Huang, Y.; Li, Z. M. 34. Faust, R. C.; Marrinan, H. J. Br J Appl Phys 1955, 6, 351.
Polymer 2008, 49, 2604. 35. Chen, S.; Spruiell, J. E. J Appl Polym Sci 1987, 33, 1427.
20. Song, S. S.; White, J. L.; Cakmak, M. Int Polym Process 1989, 36. Chen, G. Y.; Cuculo, J. A.; Tucker, P. A. J Appl Polym Sci
2, 96. 1992, 44, 447.
21. Carr, P. L.; Ward, I. M. Polymer 1987, 28 2070. 37. Shimizu, J.; Okui, N.; Kikutani, T. Sen-i-Gakkaishi 1979, 35,
22. Krins, B.; Feijen, H. H. W.; Heuzeveldt, P.; Vieth, C. R. E. T-405.
(Diolen Industrial Fibers Bv) Neth. Can. Pat. 2,601,751 (2006). 38. Vassilatos, G.; Knox, B. H.; Frankfort, H. R. E. In High speed
23. Murthy, N. S.; Elsenbaumer, R. L.; Frommer, J. E.; Baughman, fiber spinning; Ziabicki, A., Kawai, H., Eds.; Wiley: New
R H. Synth Met 1984, 9, 91. York, Chapter 14, 1985.
24. Suzuki, A.; Kohno, T.; Kunugi, T. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym 39. Ziabicki, A. Fiber world 1984, 1, 8.
Phys 1998, 36, 1731. 40. Spruiell, J. E.; White, J. L. Polym Eng Sci 1975, 15, 660.
25. White, J L.; Dharod, K. C.; Clark, E. S. J Appl Polym Sci 1974, 41. Ziabicki, A.; Jarecki, L. In High Speed Fiber Spinning-Science
18, 2539. and Engineering aspects; Ziabicki, A., Kawai, H., Eds.; Wiley:
26. ASTM D1238-04C, Standard test method for melt flow rates of New York, 1985, p 225.
thermoplastics by extrusion plastometer. 42. Peszkin, P. N.; Schultz, J. M. J Appl Polym Sci 1985, 30, 2689.