Professional Documents
Culture Documents
05 09 14
Crypto Industry Global Evolution of Emerging Trends in Crypto
Overview CryptoTech Industry
Overview Growth of Crypto Industry Bitcoin as digital gold
Key Concepts and Use Cases and Case Studies Ethereum and smart contracts
Terminologies Decentralized finance
The wave of tokenization
Non-Fungible Tokens
Crypto Capital
CBDCs and Public Sector
Adoption’at the end
23 32 44
Crypto Industry Potential Benefits of CryptoTech in India – The Way
Landscape in India Crypto Industry Forward
Role of CryptoTech to solve Benefits for Citizens, the Key impediments and areas of priority
emerging challenges and drive Industry,and the Indian intervention
efficiencies Economy Need for collaborative consultations
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Foreword
India has a very dynamic and rapidly growing technology
ecosystem. With innovation and emergence of new the
digital technologies, technology sector in India continues
its growth momentum in 2021.
The emergence of Crypto technology showcases a
decentralized, block-less and miner-less system which
holds promise of greater efficiencies, faster pace of
business processes, and significant economic benefits.
Globally, organizations and countries have started
realizing the benefits of early adoption of CryptoTech
Nischal Shetty and the technology holds similar, if not greater potential
Sangeeta Gupta Nischal Shetty
in the Indian context.
Senior Vice President and Founder and CEO
Founder and CEO
Head of Strategy It is heartening to see that industry and government
stakeholders in India are taking a very pragmatic
approach towards Cryptotech with use-cases being
explored in areas ranging from health & safety, land
registry, education, farm insurance, to fertilizer
subsidies.
With over 230 CryptoTech startups in the country, the
country is already witnessing the benefits of crypto
in form of emergence of new class of investors, and
promotion of art through NFT. Over the next decade,
we expect the technology to make significant advances
leading to innovative use-cases, magnifying the positive
impact at a grassroots level.
3
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Executive Summary
CryptoTech is a fast growing Industry globally CryptoTech in India Has Started To Pick up CryptoTech Market In India Poised To Grow 2X
Faster, and Create 800k+ Jobs By 2030
• Estimated to be USD 1.6 billion in 2021, Crypto • USD 74.2 million in market size in India in
Industry globally is expected to reach a size of FY2021, a growth of 39% in last five years • USD 184 billion in economic value addition by
USD 2.3 billion by 2026 Indian Crypto Industry by 2030
• CryptoTech provides employment for 50,000
• CryptoTech application in trading accounts for individuals in India • CryptoTech Market is Expected to Reach USD
70% of the market, followed by P2P payments, 241 million by 2030
retail and remittances • USD 6.6 billion in Investments from retail
investors • Crypto Market is likely to account for 15.6
Bitcoin, DeFi, and Crypto Capital Are Driving the billion in investments
Crypto Market Growth • CryptoTech landscape is fast evolving with
• CryptoTech promises to solve emerging
• Bitcoin has become the fastest asset to reach a – 230+ startups challenges such as Health & safety, Digital
market cap of USD 1 trillion surpassing gold and – 150+ proof of concepts and projects identity, Trade finance, and Remittances
US Dollar
• 60%+ States In India Are Emerging As Key Areas Of Priority Intervention To Promote
• Decentralized finance market size has jumped CryptoTech Adopters The Nascent Technology
100x over the last one year
• 15 million+ retail investors in crypto in India • Awareness, Regulatory Ambiguity and Higher
• USD 86 billion in lending on DeFi platforms Capex Cost Of Crypto Technologies Are
as of May 2021, up ~650% from $11 billion in The Key Impediments In Future Growth of
October 2021 CryptoTech in India
4
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
CRYPTO INDUSTRY
OVERVIEW
5
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
06
cryptocurrency are verified and added to the blockchain digital
IDENTITY, AUTHENTICATION & SECURITY ledger
The process of verifying the identity of a user, Crypto
process, or device, often as a prerequisite to allowing
access to resources in an information system 02 Technology
CRYPTO CURRENCIES
A digital currency in which transactions are verified and records
05 maintained by a decentralized system using cryptography, rather
than by a centralized authority
INFRASTRUCTURE &
APPLICATION DEVELOPMENT 03 04
A set of roles, policies, hardware, software and CRYPTO-EXCHANGES
procedures needed to create, manage, distribute, A cryptocurrency exchange, or a digital currency exchange, is a
use, store and revoke digital certificates and manage business that allows customers to trade cryptocurrencies or digital
public and private key encryption currencies for other assets, such as conventional fiat money or other
digital currencies
6
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
• Chip Manufacturer
• Development
END USER
• Peer-to-Peer Payment
R&D • Remittance
• Prototype
• Retail
• Development
• E-Commerce
• Others
NVIDIA Corporation, Xilinx Inc, LeewayHertz, IBM (US), Microsoft (US) Bitmain Technology Bitpay Inc, Xapo Ltd, Coinbase, Gemini, Aave
Treehouse Technology Group Ltd, ImpactQA
7
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
1. Improving Standardization
TRANSACTION STORED 2. Privacy
ON CLOUD/ DATA CENTER 3. Security
4. Scalability of Data
IDENTIFY MANAGEMENT
TRANSACTION MANAGEMENT
EXECUTION AND
TRANSACTION 1. Automatization via Smart Contracts
COMPLETED THROUGH 2. Decentralized Micropayments
SMART CONTRACTS
8
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
CRYPTO INDUSTRY
GLOBAL EVOLUTION
9
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
38 Years of Cryptotech
Evolution Timelines of Crypto Tech
Implemented – Digicash a Bitcoin – Bitcoin was first Cryptocurrency Boom and Legal Tender – June 2021
cryptographic electronic payment. decentralized cryptocurrency ICO – 1800+ cryptocurrency El Salvador became the
This would require software in order created by Satoshi Nakamoto specifications existed. Cardano first country to accept
to withdraw notes from a bank and using SHA-256, a cryptographic has been the largest proof-of- Bitcoin as legal tender.
designate specific encrypted keys hash function, in its proof-of- stake cryptocurrency since 2018.
before it can be sent to a recipient) work scheme Initial coin offering (ICO)
is a type of funding using
cryptocurrencies.
Way
1983 1995 2008 2009 2011 2018 2021 Forward
Conceived – ecash was conceived White Paper – Satoshi Decentralized Domain Name First Crypto Stock Listing
as an anonymous cryptographic Nakamoto publishes a System (DNS) – Namecoin was – Coinbase, the largest
electronic money by American detailed White paper created to help decentralized cryptocurrency exchange
cryptographer David Chaum DNS system which was crucial in the U.S got listed and is
for long-term Internet privacy publicly traded.
and censorship reduction.
Litecoin, Peercoin.
In 1996, the National Security Agency published a paper entitled How to Make a Mint: the Cryptography of Anonymous Electronic Cash, describing a Cryptocurrency system, first publishing it in
an MIT mailing list
10
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
TRUSTED
IDENTITIES TRANSACTIONS COUNTERPARTY PUBLIC
THIRD-PARTY
IN-FINITE MONEY
2008 FINANCIAL GOVERNMENT INFLATION
SUPPLY
CRISIS/ SUB- BAIL OUTS (ZIMBABWE AND
(ARTIFICIALLY PRINTING
PRIME CRISIS (LEHMAN CRISIS) VENEZUELA)
CURRENCY)
11
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
70%
Banks Owning Blockchain-Based Systems – Global banks across US, Europe & Asia started creating their own blockchain-based systems, including digital currencies, to enable B2B
cryptocurrency payments between their customers.
Corporations Accepting Crypto – Globally 20+ leading corporations started accepting crypto for payments from Microsoft to PayPal. 2020 PayPal announced that its customers will be able to
buy, sell, and hold Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies using their PayPal accounts, allowing customers to buy things from the 26 million sellers who accept PayPal.
12
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
13
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
TRENDS IN
CRYPTO INDUSTRY
14
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
01 02 03 04 05 06 07
Bitcoin as Smart Decentralized The Wave of Non-Fungible Rise of Crypto Increased
Digital Gold Contracts – Finance Tokenization Tokens Capital Adoption of
Ethereum CBDCs
Bitcoin as Smart Contracts – Decentralized Finance Tokenization Non-Fungible Tokens Crypto Capital – Public Sector Adoption
Digital Gold Ethereum Driving Alternate Source of in form of CBDCs
Growth Funding
$1 Trillion Market $150 Million $48 Billion $1.9 Billion $250 Million $86 Billion in 5 Countries By
Cap Market Size Market Cap Market Size Market Cap Lending Deployment
12 Years to Trillion 30+ Countries 10+ Countries 21+ Countries 222,179 Active 2oo+ DeFi Lending 15 CBDCs Under
Deployed Deployed Deployed Wallets Platforms Development
<10 Years to 75M 6,800+ Enterprise 88X Growth in *FINMA 1% Currency 650%+ Growth 14 CBDCs
Users Users a Year Approved Market share YoY Under Pilot
Platform Phase
15
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
16
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
8+ Countries 6+ Countries 4+ Countries 3+ Countries 1. Of the fifty companies, thirty-two are building on Ethereum or
Enterprise Ethereum derived blockchains platforms. Over Ten
Online Voting Registration of Digital Identity *Govt companies are using own Ethereum blockchain.
Property/Land Administration
2. ~6,863+ Companies are using Enterprise Ethereum derived
blockchains for Smart Contracts
50
Forbes Billion-Dollar
$245 Million Global Smart Contracts market by 2024 and growing at 18.1% Blockchain Babies
$ Million $245 32
$208
Companies
$176
$149 Building on Ethereum
$126
$107 or Enterprise
Ethereum
blockchains
platforms
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
17
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
03. DeFi (Decentralized Finance): $85 Billion Total Value Locked in DeFi
Global Decentralized Finance (DeFi) DeFI (Decentralized Finance ) Adoption Indicators
Market Size
$85.0 Traditional Financial
Products in DeFi Market
Total value locked (TVL) of cryptocurrency in DeFi
(In $ Million)
Monetize Blockchain
Gaming
Cross-Chain-Technology
Adoption Indicators
To Scale
Decentralized Exchanges
(DEXs) Fuel DeFi Growth
$8.5
0 $0.2 $0.5
Jan-17 Jan-18 Jan-19 Jan-20 Jan-21 Governance Tokens Become
More Important
18
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
$3.3
19
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
05. Non-Fungible Tokens (NFT): USD 350M Market Largely Driven by Art,
Collectibles and Gaming Industry, Inching Towards Mainstream Adoption
Global Non-Fungible Token (NFT) Market Size in $ MN Sectors Driving Adoption and Growth
Non-fungible token (NFT) in $ Mn <1% Penetration across Sectors leaving a huge potential for Non-Fungible Tokens (NFT) to disrupt
Metaverses, Art/Fashion, Gaming, Sports, Collectibles and Utility over next decade
$1,882
NFT Market Share Overall Size NFT Market Share Overall Size
$1,345
Metaverses
25% $ 280B 25% $ 280B
$960 Sports
$686
$490 23%
$ 12B 23%
$ 12B
$350 Arts/Fashion Collectibles
$250
Key Insights for Non-Fungible Tokens (NFT): Drivers of Adoption in 2020 and 2021
1. Growing Adoption in Gaming Industry – Gaming Industries are coming up with innovative
1. NFT is short for “Non-Fungible-Token”, and it is essentially a special token with a unique ID that is impossible advance games such as Strategy Role Playing Game, where the user can create a game
to replicate. character and using NFT can get the ownership of created character which later can be put up
2. Digital Ownership Rights – NFTs help the digital artists to attain ownership for their digital artwork. They can on sale on various marketplace.
receive more income through NFTs, as they can get royalty each time the NFT is transacted after the initial 2. Increasing Asian Penetration – WazirX India’s Bitcoin and cryptocurrency exchange & trading
sale. platform launched a non-fungible tokens (NFT) marketplace for Indian artists and creators for
3. NFT trading was worth $250 million in 2020, a 300% increase from the previous year and 2021 it touched the auction of their digital assets and earn royalties. Asian and India market is unorganized and
$350 million a 40% growth. NFTs have seen application in digital art, trading cards, collectibles, or video largely driven by large players so NFT can play role similar to eCommerce which aggregated
games artefacts, digital music, concert tickets, etc. and will soon be used as collateral in decentralized finance. sellers
20
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Crypto Finance and Lending 5G would reduce current financial bottlenecks and enhance blockchain-
powered decentralized projects while simultaneously bolster crypto
USD 86 billion in lending on DeFi platforms as of May 2021, up
adoption in India; attributable to rising smartphone users
~650% from $11 billion in October 2021.
Funds raised by Framework will support several DeFi tokens and applications as well as Crypto wallets with tangible UX operate as a gateway to an unexplored
centralized projects experimenting on DeFi blockchains and services. digitally financial infrastructural world. 5G is the backbone for manifesting
this vision. While complex functions run in the background, low latent 5G will
The massive growth of DeFi applications, most of which run on the Ethereum blockchain, has enable the crypto wallet’s UX to work seamlessly.
put the spotlight on digital assets and lifted major cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin and ether
to record highs 5G will simplify the crypto usage experience. Crypto wallets can be imagined
as mobile wallets plugged into the Web, along with the promising landscape of
streaming and gaming.
21
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
22
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
CRYPTO INDUSTRY
LANDSCAPE IN INDIA
23
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Crypto Investments
53.1
USD 6.6 billion investments in crypto
assets by retail Investors in India
Crypto Startups
Crypto Industry in India has
registered a growth of Over 230 crypto startups operating in
India in Crypto space
39%
Between FY 2016 and FY
2021 Projects and Proof of Concepts
India has witnessed deployment of over
150 crypto Projects and POCs
FY 2016 FY 2021
24
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
40%
Revenue Growth
8X Growth in Institutional Funding for Crypto Startups in India 612% Growth in Retail Holdings of Crypto Assets in India
Overall Startup Funding Crypto Startup Funding Retail Ownership of Stocks by Retail Ownership of Crypto
growth in India growth in India Value – Growth Rate Assets by Value – Growth Rate
*Growth between 2019 and 2021 YTD *Growth between 2019 and 2020
*Top 15 crypto companies in India | Source: UnearthInsight Research and NASSCOM Research
25
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Crypto Start-ups in India (Active Use Cases) Public Sector Adopters in India
Note: This is not an exhaustive list of entities participating in the Indian blockchain ecosystem
Source: UnearthInsight Research
*COVID-19 Test Certificate issued by Polygon in Maharashtra
26
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Sector Wise View of Providers of Blockchain & Crypto Start-up in India Sector Wise View of Providers of Blockchain & Crypto Start-up in India
Banking/Financial Sevices 25
Others, 40
IT Sevices (Product) 20
Healthcare, 20 Telecom 3
Banking and Financial Services, 220
27
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Funding & Investment into Crypto Funding & Investment into Crypto
and Blockchain Start-ups in India Tech Ecosystem Currency Ecosystem and Blockchain Start-ups in India
2.2X 20X
Invested by 25+ Banks, Financial Growth Growth
IBBIC $25M+ Services and Insurance Companies
7 Million – 2020 $20M – 2020
28
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
75% of cyrpto investors in India are aged Through its NFT platform, WazirX
between 18-35 years old is showcasing artwork from diverse
categories including space 3D artists,
Of these, 70% are first time investors digital artists, muralist photographers,
who have never traded in stock market canvas artists, street artists and visual
or securities before. The company has artists. Through the platform, the company
witnessed a 2,648 per cent growth in is empowering artists, creators, and
user sign ups from tier-II and tier-III collectors to create and trade unique
cities in India. digital assets.
New class of Women Financial Promotion
Investors Empowerment Literacy of Art
Women from tier-II and tier-III regions account for 65 per cent of the total Through initiatives such as WazirX Warrior program and Binance Academy, the
signups by women from all over the country. Female traders have voiced crypto exchange has been spreading financial literacy and actively engaged in
that crypto helped them achieve financial independence, raise their living knowledge dissemination and increasing awareness of the crypto market and
standards, and added a great source of secondary income for the family. do’s and don’t’s
29
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
7 Projects/
Use Cases
Land Registry Remittances
Duty Payment (Token/NFT)
30
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
60%
Of Government Use Cases have a
The Government of India is actively looking at adoption
possibility of Crypto/DeFi Deployment of CryptoTech in solving challenges pertaining to areas.
Few notable ones are-
31
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
POTENTIAL
BENEFITS
OF CRYPTO
INDUSTRY IN
INDIA
32
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Best Case
CryptoTech led by:
• Most policy recommendations accounted for and enabled
• Conducive regulatory framework that promotes innovation and grass-root
adoption of crypto technologies
• Accelerated investment in crypto space from institutional and retail investors
• Heightened awareness of the benefits of CryptoTech leading to a favorable
outlook and reduced skepticism
33
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
USD Bn
Figures in USD Million 15.6 Figure in ‘000’
CAGR 14.1%
241.1 10.2 877
9.7
8.0
6.6 6.6 691
123.2 336
73.8 120.8 55 303
73.8 91.3
55
Best Case Base Case Base Case Best Case Best Case Base Case
Crypto Market Size (by Crypto Market Growth Crypto Market Investments Crypto Market Jobs (by
2030) USD 241 million Multiple 3.3x Growth (2021) USD 6.6 billion 2030) 877,000
34
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
1 2 3 4
35
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Existing Use
Cases HEALTH AND DIGITAL TRADE
REMITTANCES
and SAFETY IDENTITY FINANCE
Realized Over 38M Beneficiaries across Over 1M Students Digital 5% to 10% Cost Savings for Significant reduction
benefits Rajasthan saving $800 Million
annually reducing need for
Diploma Certificate to
help companies verify and
30M to 40M traders for over
$2.4 Trillion trade annually
in transaction time for
Remittances from 3-5 days
reprinting or rechecks of authenticate Identity in <1 to 3 seconds
medical records day
Potential benefits
of CryptoTech’s
Existing Use
Cases USD 30 billion in USD 3 billion+ in USD 5 billion+ in USD 5-6 Billion in
savings on Savings on verifications cost savings savings on
rechecks across India On Trades and Margins remittance fees
Source: UnearthInsight Research
36
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Case Study I: Health and Safety – India’s First Electronic Health Records on
Blockchain (1/2) Blockchain Impediments
• The First and Only “Digital Health Records” Use Case in
India
• 100% In-House, 100% Open with Open Standards and
Partnered to implement Blockchain Open APIs
solution in electronic health records • Fully Compliant to HIPAA and other international
standards / guidelines
Auxesis Group • Can integrate with Any Hospital Anywhere Any Day
Government of Rajasthan
4 Blockchain Interventions
37
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Case Study I: Health and Safety – India’s First Electronic Health Records
on Blockchain (2/2)
Enhancing Patient Healthcare Click of Button Health Information &
Experience through Rajasthan Dashboard
38
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Brief – Maharashtra State Board of Skill Development(MSBSD) was looking to automate student certificate
issuance and verification across 8 academic years for 1,084 training institutions approved by the board
Solution: LegitDoc a unique SaaS-based platform that leverages a combination of Ethereum blockchain and cryptographic
techniques, has facilitated issuing and verifying of around 1 million digital diploma certificates for students of MSBSD across 8
academic years. These certificates can be instantly verified from anywhere around the world.
Scale of Deployment: 1+ Million documents digitally certified and verified. Government of Maharashtra becomes only the 4th
government entity in the world to deploy blockchain-based educational document registry after full-scale implementations by 4 to 5 Weeks ~10 Seconds
Government of Malta, the Government of Singapore and the Government of Bahrain. Average Time to Verify the Average Time to Verify the
Certificate Certificate
39
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Brief – LegitDoc makes use of Ethereum blockchain combined with modern cryptography to issue digital
diplomas that are tamper-proof, hack-proof, instantaneously verifiable and privacy-centric.
Software 1 Software 2
40
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Case Study III: USD 2.45 Trillion India Trade Connect which is a Blockchain
Based Network for Trade Finance (1/2)
$2.4T Trade $2.4T Trade
Finance in 2020 Domestic Trade Finance Finance in 2020
High Time
Banks Consortium
moves into
Production
8-9 days 2-3 days
2017 2018 2019 Average Cycle Time for Inland Average Cycle Time for Inland
Letter of Credit Letter of Credit
Seven banks meet and demo Seven banks fully
Finacle Trade Connect live on Finacle Trade
ICICI and Axis Pilot Connect High Cost
Solution – Domestic trade finance blockchain based network, enabling automation and transparency, and improving risk 15% <5%
mitigation in domestic trade and supply chain finance operations. India Trade Connect’s goal is to digitize trade finance workflows Average Inefficiencies Average Inefficiencies
within a distributed, trusted, and shared network.
Related Hidden Costs Related Hidden Costs
Framework Used – It is agnostic to which blockchain infrastructure is used (e.g., Hyperledger, Corda, Ethereum, and Bitcoin).
Workflows include validation of ownership, certification of documents, and payments. It covers a wide scope of transaction types:
1% to 2% Related to Document 0% Related to Document
purchase order, invoice, bill lodgment request, bill acceptance request, documentary credit request, documentary credit, advance Courier Fees Courier Fees
payment, bill payment transaction, customer-to-customer (both use same bank), and open account
Scale of Deployment – 7 banks have signed up for Pilot on India Trade Connect which are ICICI Bank, Axis Bank, IndusInd Bank, 5% to 10% Average Per <5% Average Per Transaction
RBL Bank, Yes Bank, Kotak Bank, South Indian Bank Transaction Cost Cost
41
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Case Study III: $2.45 Trillion India Trade Connect Which is a Blockchain
Based Network for Trade Finance (2/2)
~40M Indian $2.4T Trade
Traders Domestic Trade Finance Finance in 2020
Agile Testing
Efficient Collaboration
42
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Case Study IV: Remittances Pilot through Ripple Across 5 to 6 Large Banks
Reducing Time of Transaction From 3-5 Days to 3 Seconds
35M Indian Living $83B Remittances
Abroad Cross-Border Remittance in 2020
High Time
Kotak Bank used use
xCurrent to power instant
remittance payments into
the country 3-5 days 3 Seconds
Average International Average international
2017 2018 2019 Payment Transaction payment transaction
7% 1% to 2%
Solution – RippleNet uses xCurrent with On-Demand Liquidity (ODL), which allows them to begin sourcing liquidity on demand Average Fees on Principal Average Fees on Principal
(i.e., instant foreign exchange when they need it) with the digital asset. RippleNet solution does not use the digital asset XRP in Value Value
India considering the regulatory landscape.
Scale of Deployment – 5 to 6 banks have signed up for Pilot on RippleNet which are Axis Bank, Yes Bank, Kotak Mahindra Bank,
IndusInd Bank and Federal Bank.
Potential Impact – $5 to $6 Billion savings on remittances fees assuming a stagnant inflow of cash into the country
43
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
01 • Awareness gap
• Limited understanding of benefits
• Inadequate supporting infrastructure
Operational Bottlenecks
Financial Bottlenecks
Regulatory Bottlenecks
04 • Regulatory ambiguity
• Lack of clarity on GST and applicable taxation
Source: UnearthInsight Research and NASSCOM Research
44
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Industry Quotes
Time to Proof of Concept Stage
Hovers Around ~6 Months
My belief is that we should think of Crypto as an asset class. I think Indian regulators aslo accept the
concept of central bank digital currencies (CBDC); like a digital rupee
70% Nandan Nilekani, Non-Executive Chairman
of adopters interviewed took less I have invested in Bitcoin because I believe in its potential, the capacity it has to transform global
than 6 months for PoC with global payments is very exciting.
cross border payment solution
providers because the use case is Richard Branson, Founder
fairly matured across Africa, US and
Europe.
If crypto succeeds, it’s not because it empowers people, It’s because it empowers better
Time From Pilot to Deployment
institutions
Stage Hovers Around ~6 Vitalik Buterein, Co-Founder
Months
Tracking the utilization of benefit distribution programs, birth, death and marriage certificates, municipal
70% authority approvals and permissions, police clearances, etc., will work in a more foolproof way with
Blockchain
of adopters interviewed took less
Gopikrishnan Konnanath
than 6 months for deployment with
global cross border payment solution Blockchain is useful for mobile number portability, curbing unsolicited calls, and more. It helps share data
providers because the use case is
for solving complaints and to bring in standardization and transparency across the telecom ecosystem.
fairly matured across Africa, US and
Europe. Jitan Chandanani
45
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
NASSCOM Recommendations
A consultative and enabling regulatory approach towards Crypto technologies can help drive the growth of Crypto ecosystem and innovation
in India
03 Regulatory Sandbox
A regulatory sandbox can enable the use and adoption of specific high-potential use cases of crypto-
tech, such as financial instruments (e.g., fund raise, payments), utility tokens (e.g., authentication for
use of a resource)
Appendix
Case Studies
Change Healthcare’s
Tokenization Case
Intelligent Healthcare
Colombia’s Study: Austria’s virtual
Network (IHN) for
Blockchain-based citizen card - “Identity
Transparent Healthcare
e-Procurement to Link”
Colombia’s Digital Transaction in USA Moscow’s Blockchain-
reduce corruption Democracy for based Smart City
Inclusive Electoral Project
Process
47
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
GOVERNMENT
TRANSPARENCY
Reduced Corruption
CHALLENGE/PAIN POINT BLOCKCHAIN SOLUTION IMPACT
$9.5 Trillion Spent by Governments on on Transparency Project is first Blockchain for procurement of the 80% PAE vendors are selected via
Every year, governments spend procurement contracts Colombian PAE public-school meal programme e-procurement system
between 10% and 30% of national GDP
on procurement
10%–30% of a public contract’s overall value Capabilities of Software Solution 100% student meal programme procurement
is commonly lost to corruption (OECD) 1) Permanent and tamper-evident record-keeping transactions closed virtually
48
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
01 02 03 04 05
REGISTRATION TENDER OFFER OPEN FEEDBACK FINAL OFFER PROVISIONS
START
10 09 08 07 06
PHASE 2 + PUBLIC
PHASE 1 + PUBLIC
COMMENTS AUTO DOWNLOADS BID END BID START
COMMENTS
Phase 2 Tenderer downloads
Phase 1 Tender Bidding period Bidding period
Tender bids of registered
Winner Evaluation closes begins
Declared Evaluation vendors
END
49
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
DIGITAL
DEMOCRACY
Inclusive Electoral
Processes CHALLENGE/PAIN POINT BLOCKCHAIN SOLUTION IMPACT
90% of the 6 million Colombians living abroad Digital Plebiscite was launched as the digital voting platform by Digital Literacy – 23.2 million Colombians,
10% Colombians living abroad had not registered to vote in consulate or non-profit Democracy Earth Foundation nearly half of the total population, are still
Registered to vote in consulate or embassy offline
embassy Digital Plebiscite was powered by blockchain technology,
Trusted Platform for foreign-based testing a new way of validating and authenticating electoral Regulatory barriers regarding “data as
Colombians a voice and to challenge the votes jurisdiction”
traditional electoral system
Blockchain-based
Voting Worked with several civil society organisations to allow Cultural resistance in public organisations
80% to 90% additional costs incurred to Colombians abroad to cast symbolic votes through the platform
campaign outside Colombia
Lack of sufficient maturity of Voting
Blockchain Technology
50
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
TRANSPARENT
HEALTHCARE
TRANSACTION
CHALLENGE/PAIN POINT BLOCKCHAIN SOLUTION IMPACT
~15% Cost Reduction in Claim
4.6 million claims submitted per day Intelligent Healthcare Network (IHN) is $1 Trillion in claims processed
Processing & Administrative Costs. first enterprise-scale Blockchain solution for
US Spends $315 Billion for Billing, healthcare
Insurance Related Inefficiencies 15%–20% of healthcare spending and 50 million transactions per day (claim events
processing costs are associated with Billing per day)
and Insurance (BIR) related activities IHN provides efficiency to optimize
Blockchain- administrative cost, time, and transparency for
better auditability & traceability related to claims <1 Day insurance eligibility check (7 to 14
powered Intelligent $315 billion BIR costs in 2018/19 days traditional insurance eligibility check)
adjudication process
Healthcare Network
51
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
52
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
SMART CITY
MOSCOW
52% of Smart Cities project biggest obstacle is Active Citizens – Aallows citizens to vote on city issues 4.8 million registered users offered Active
gaining the support of citizens Citizen 4,800 polls conducted & 1,500 cases
Blockchain-based citizen decisions implemented
Crowd – Citizens a discussion board to propose ideas
Hyperconnected 75% of Lower Income Citizens believe smart and make suggestions on improving community projects
digital platform initiatives as more beneficial for the 13% average increase in travel speed since
2013
Rich Moscow Online School – Connects Schools, Parents &
Citizens
$10M annual savings from eHealthcare
Long time for permits and approvals for
businesses
53
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
CITIZEN ENGAGEMENT
02
• Active Citizen: 1.9m users, 1709 initiatives already implemented
• Our City: 1m users, 2m problems successfully resolved
• crowd.mos.ru: 15 projects implemented, 140,000 users, 2,700 ideas selected for further elaboration
EDUCATION ON BLOCKCHAIN
03 Moscow Online School –Integrated 980,000+ connected pupils, 65,000, connected teachers, 773
connected schools. online school diary and registry with Wi-Fi in each classroom resulted in 15% growth
of academic performance
HEALTHCARE ON BLOCKCHAIN
IMIAS – Integrated medical information analytical system: 9m connected patients, 22,000 connected
04 physicians, 660 connected clinics and labs
54
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
DIGITAL CITIZEN
CARD AND
MOBILE ID
CHALLENGE/PAIN POINT BLOCKCHAIN SOLUTION IMPACT
1.5 Million Mobile e-IDs active
First European country to implement a Identity Link is Virtual Citizen Data Card “SourcePIN”—a 300+ Public Services like tax portal, social and
users national ID system based on an electronic unique identifier created by strong encryption of the health security portal, pensions and several
18% Adoption Rate (8.8M ID, strongly embedded in the e-government 12-digit unique ID (CRR) number. private services for 8.8 population
population) initiative
ssPIN – Created from the SourcePIN using one-way 1.6 million registered users of SMARTCARD
Tokenized Virtual 30% delayed Citizen data and Services derivation, a method through which a sector specific-PIN (Health Insurance Card)
because corporates work with 26 Austrian is algorithmically computed from the SourcePIN.
Citizen Card
public administration departments
25% Reduction of Public Sector Services
Mobile ID is free for citizens and for public & private Budget
20% Data Errors reducing inter-department service providers
efficiencies
Acceptance of countries’ e-ID since 2008 and
e-IDAS notification planned for 2021
55
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
56
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Non-Fungible Tokens (NFT) Case Study: The World’s First Real Estate NFT
located in Kyiv, Ukraine
FIRST PROPERTY TO BE
SOLD USING BLOCKCHAIN
TECHNOLOGY
NFT IN REAL
ESTATE
CHALLENGE/PAIN POINT BLOCKCHAIN SOLUTION IMPACT
Smart Contract on the Ethereum First property to be sold using blockchain Propy facilitated the purchase through blockchain $1 Billion transactions via their easy-to-use
Blockchain using NFT technology back in 2017, was owned by technology and apartment was tokenized as an NFT and secure online platform
$93,000 Auctioned in Ether Michael Arrington, founder of TechCrunch
and Arrington XRP Capital.
Transaction – The ownership of the property was 20% Reduction or $1.7B in annual savings for
actually held and recorded in Ukraine as a US LLC. The US mortgage loan industry due to adoption of
Currency – Contract was made between the auction winner became the owner of the NFT that gives blockchain technology
Apartment relevant parties with Ether (the currency used the rights to the LLC, with Arrington signing proprietary-
converted to Non- on the Ethereum blockchain) being used to developed legal papers for NFTs to transfer ownership to
Fungible Token (NFT) make the purchase. all future buyers.
57
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
• Land Registration
• Duty Payment
West Bengal • Record Management Lynked – The municipal corporations of Bankura and Durgapur districts in West Bengal have partnered with the Netherlands-based company Lynked.
Pilot • Cybersecurity World to build a blockchain-based platform for issuing legal documents such as birth certificates.
• Digital Birth Certificate
• Data Management
• Agriculture
• Digital Certificate
Karnataka • Forest and Land Acquisition PwC – Karnataka government in collaboration with PwC has announced the creation of a database or a marketplace for intellectual property rights
using block chain technology and also for preparation of digital certificates, public service delivery systems, and forest and land acquisition record
Pilot • Public Services Delivery maintenance.
• Idea Marketplaces
• IP Protection
Gujarat • Fertilizer Subsidy Management
Zebpay – Gujarat Government collaborated with Zebpay to explore blockchain technology applications in the state.
Pilot • e-Governance
• Blockchain Database
• Cybersecurity
Andhra Pradesh Zebi – The government of Andhra Pradesh is working with Zebi data for blockchain-based solutions in land registry. The government is also partner-
• Healthcare
Live ing with Hitachi to set up an online citizen governance platform.
• Land Registry
• Vehicle Title Registration
• Land Registration LegitDoc – Maharashtra government partnered with LegitDoc to issue tamper-proof diploma certificates as an intent on part of the authorities to
• Digital Certification tackle such misuse of technology.
Maharashtra
• Organ Transplant Polygon Network – Maharashtra government partnered with Polygon Network to track the results of RT-PCR tests.
Live
• Rationing Distribution Swiss Government – The Maharashtra government has signed a MoU to share and implement ideas on block chain technology and its application with
• Farm Insurance the Swiss government.
58
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Power Ledge – Uttar Pradesh is the first States in India to launch blockchain-enabled solar power trading. The pilot project (to be undertaken on few
Uttar Pradesh
• Power Sharing government buildings in Lucknow) will test the feasibility of energy trading through blockchain from rooftops with solar power to neighboring house-
Live
• Land Registry holds and buildings.
UNDC – Uttar Pradesh government has partnered with UNDC to implement a Blockchain solution in land title management
• Digital Public Services – Nambikkai Centre of Excellence (CoE) – Established CoE in Tamil Nadu e-Governance Department. Tamil Nadu has adopted Blockchain-as-a Service model,
Inaiyam (NI) wherein the departments will not have separate nodes.
Tamil Nadu • Agriculture IIT Chennai – The Tamil Nadu government has signed a MoU with IIT Chennai to explore Blockchain applicability in different use cases.
Live
• Healthcare Trust Link – State-wide blockchain infrastructure that can be leveraged by all Government departments, which is named Nambikkai Inaiyam (NI)
• Education which roughly translates to ‘Trust Link’
Kerala Blockchain Academy (KBA) – State established the Kerala Blockchain Academy (KBA) to explore the capacity of the technology to promote
Kerala • Farm Insurance Research, Development and Entrepreneurship.
Live • Agriculture Supply Chain Next five years, the State plans to make its financial system more efficient and implement pilot government schemes by creating a talent pool of pro-
fessionals in the area of blockchain
Auxesis – The Rajasthan government has partnered with Mumbai-based Auxesis group to implement a Blockchain solution in electronic health re-
• Land Registry cords and land registration.
Rajasthan
Live • Electronic Health records Electronic Health records (EHR) – State has already successfully launched EHR (Electronic Health Record) using blockchain technology.
(EHR)
Land Registry – Implementation of blockchain for land records which will help create an immutable digital record of transactions.
• Land Registry Tech Mahindra – Besides having developed a Blockchain District near Hyderabad, the Telangana government has signed a MoU with Tech Mahindra
Telangana • Chit Funds Operations and is collaborating with IIIT Hyderabad and C-DAC to build a state-level Blockchain platform. It is also collaborating with NITI Aayog for blockchain
Live • Microfinance for SHGs in governance.
• Digital Education Certificate Accelerator – Launched a blockchain accelerator in its recently created Blockchain District, in collaboration with Tech Mahindra.
59
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
The Distributed Ledger Technology Law, Cyprus has proposed a bill governing smart contracts and cryptocurrencies as assets. The objective of the bill is to facilitate the application of distrib-
Cyprus
2021 (Bill, open for public consultation) uted ledger technology, and to safeguard consumer rights as well as avoid money laundering. The bill is open for public consultation.
Singapore Payment Services Act, 2020 The Payment Services Act lays down a framework for licensing and compliance for cryptocurrency businesses in Singapore.
The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) regulates the public offerings and issue of digital coins. MAS ascertains if digital tokens are capital mar-
ket products, and such products are thereafter governed by Securities & Futures Act.
Singapore Securities and Futures Act, 2001
Additional Resource: A Guide to Digital Token Offerings, Monetary Authority of Singapore < https://www.mas.gov.sg/-/media/MAS/Sectors/Guid-
ance/Guide-to-Digital-Token-Offerings-26-May-2020.pdf >
General Policy for Future Trading of All entities dealing with crypto assets as commodity futures in Indonesia must comply with anti-money laundering/ combating of financing of terror-
Crypto Asset, 2018 (MoT Reg 99/2018) ism (AML/CFT) norms. Such entities must report to the Indonesian Financial Transaction Reports & Analysis Center.
Indonesia
& Technical Regulations (BAPPEBTI Reg
5/2019)
The Virtual Financial Assets Act regulates issuers and service providers, and initial virtual financial asset offerings. They need to comply with certain
requirements and register themselves with the authority which ensures that they are in compliance with anti-money laundering laws etc.
• Virtual Financial Assets Act, 2018
The Malta Digital Innovation Authority (MDIA) Act establishes the Digital Innovation Authority. The Act empowers the MDIA to certify innovative
• Malta Digital Innovation Authority technology arrangements of a platform.
Malta Act, 2018
The Innovative Technology Arrangements and Services Act (ITAS) lays down the framework for certification of innovative technology arrangements.
• The Innovative Technology Arrange-
ments and Services Act, 2018
Note: The financial regulator, Malta Financial Services Authority, has also launched a Fintech Hub and Sandbox Environment. The objective of this
Sandbox is to help in orderly adoption of innovative technologies in the financial services market.
60
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Acknowledgements
This report has been developed through a comprehensive study to understand the Crypto
landscape in India.
The preparation of this report has been facilitated by extensive research and interactions
with 25+ respondents across the crypto ecosystem who have extended great help to the
research team. We wish to sincerely thank all of them for their valuable contributions
without which this report would not have been possible.
61
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
ABOUT ABOUT
NASSCOM is the premier trade body and chamber of commerce of the Tech industry in UnearthInsight delivers critical market information to drive decision insights for CXOs
India and comprises over 3000 member companies including both Indian and multinational and equips them with actionable insights to understand the opportunity and prepare
organisations that have a presence in India. Our membership spans across the entire the market strategy. UnearthInsight depends on database gathered from more than 20
spectrum of the industry from start ups to multinationals and from products to services, countries, more than nine million start-ups globally along with over 32,000 start-ups and
Global Service Centers to Engineering firms. Guided by India’s vision to become a leading private firms in India. On an average more than 25 data elements are injected daily in the
digital economy globally, NASSCOM focuses on accelerating the pace of transformation of data pool. It relies on strong social capital built over the years with key industry leaders and
the industry to emerge as the preferred enablers for global digital transformation. clients such as Accenture, EY, HCL, Tech Mahindra and Mphasis.
Plot 7 to 10, Sector 126, Noida - 201303 # 11/2, Ground Floor, 1st Cross, Vinayaknagar Nyappanahalli Main Rd, B G Road
delhi@nasscom.in Near DLF New Town, KA 560076, India
www.nasscom.in www. https://unearthinsight.com
Visit our community at www.community.nasscom.in
62
CRYPTO INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Thank You
www.nasscom.in
delhi@nasscom.in
www.community.nasscom.in
+91-120-4990111 /NASSCOMOfficial
Visit our community at www.community.nasscom.in NASSCOM Plot 7 to 10, Sector 126, Noida - 201303 /nasscom
/NasscomVideos
63