Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diarrhea Associated With Typhoid Fever: Paratyphi
Diarrhea Associated With Typhoid Fever: Paratyphi
6· JUNE 1985
© 1985 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved. 0022-1899/85/5106-0020$01.00
S. K. Roy, Peter Speelman: Thomas Butler.t From the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease
Sumir Nath, Hamidur Rahman, and B. J. Stoll Research, Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
To study the pathogenesis of diarrhea occurring with typhoid fever, we selected 42 pa-
tients with diarrhea and blood cultures positive for Salmonella typhi or Salmonella
paratyphi A, but without diarrheal copathogens, for measurement of stool output and
examination of fecal composition. The mean duration of fever before hospitalization was
9.5 days, and the mean duration of diarrhea was 5.8 days. All patients passed liquid stool
on their first day in the hospital, ranging in volume from 4 to 172 ml/kg with a mean
of 45 ml/kg. Red blood cells were in the stools of 570/0 of the patients. All patients had
fecal leukocytes with a mean of 4,950 Ieukocytes/rnm", predominantly polymorphonuclear
leukocytes. In the stools, the mean protein concentration was 9.3 g/liter; the mean pH
Clinical descriptions of typhoid fever emphasize the These differences in the prevalence of diarrhea in
cardinal features of prolonged fever; abdominal typhoid fever may not be absolute; differences in de-
pain, distention, or tenderness; splenomegaly; tection methods and definitions of diarrhea used by
hepatomegaly; and rose spots. Diarrhea is usually the various authors may account for the variation.
relegated in importance to a common finding that The frequency is reportedly higher in young children
is not regularly present and not diagnostically use- than in older children and adults [4, 13].In 1946, Stu-
ful. On the other hand, diarrhea has been reported art and Pullen [14] described the diarrheal stool of
recently in greater numbers of cases [1]. The reported patients with typhoid fever as foul-smelling with a
frequency of diarrhea in patients with typhoid fever consistency of pea soup and occurring as often as
was varied by geography from <330/0 in five reports 20 times a day, sometimes with severe and protracted
from India [2-6] to between 33% and 50% from occurrences.
African countries [7-12], Jordan [13], and the United In 1983Stoll et al. [20] reported in a retrospective
States [14] and to >500/0 in Chile [15], Ethiopia [16], study of 62 patients with typhoid fever and diarrhea
Nigeria [17], Sweden [18], and the United States [19]. in Bangladesh that most of the patients showed wa-
tery diarrhea with mucus that revealed >10 white
Received for publication August 17, 1984, and in revised form blood cells per high-power field (hpf) and had an
December 5, 1984.
Informed consent was obtained from patients or their parents
alkaline pH. The present study planned prospectively
or guardians. Guidelines for human experimentation of the In- to obtain complete quantitative measures of the rates
ternational Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh of purging and the fecal composition in patients with
were followed in the conduct of the clinical research. typhoid fever and to observe the course of diarrhea
Wethank Abul Alim, J. P. Butzler, H. Conguan, and Drs. Asma during treatment with chloramphenicol.
Khanam and M. Rahman for technical assistance and Mahbooba
Shamsuddin for typing the manuscript.
Please address requests for reprints to Dr. Thomas Butler, In- Patients and Methods
ternational Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh,
Dhaka, Department of State, Washington, D.C. 20520. Patients. The International Centre for Diar-
* Present address: Department of Medicine, Harborview Med- rhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh operates a hos-
ical Center, 325 Ninth Avenue, Seattle, Washington 98104.
t Present address: Department of Medicine, University Hos- pital and outpatient clinic in Dhaka for the treat-
pital of Cleveland and Case Western Reserve University, Cleve- ment of patients with diarrhea. All male and female
land, Ohio 44106. patients, six months to 60 years of age, who were
1138
Diarrhea Associated with Typhoid Fever 1139
consulting the outpatient clinic with a history of fe- colorimetric procedure [23]. COz was measured
ver and diarrhea for four or more days and who had directly by the same TCO z electrode methodology
not received chloramphenicol or cotrimoxazole since as is used in IL blood gas systems (lL-446) [24].
the start of their illness were eligible for the study. Treatment. Patients were rehydrated with iv so-
Diarrhea was defined as three or more bowel move- lution containing sodium (133 mEq/liter), potassium
ments of loose or liquid stools per 24 hr. Initially, (13mEq/liter), chloride (98 mEq/liter), and acetate
fifty patients with a blood culture positive for (48 mmollliter). No oral rehydration solution was
Salmonella typhi or Salmonella paratyphi A were used. Twenty-nine patients were treated with chlor-
included, but eight were later excluded because they amphenicol orally (Parke-Davis, Dhaka, Ban-
were infected with diarrheal copathogens. Five pa- gladesh) and 13 patients were initially treated iv with
tients had Entamoeba histolytica; two had Giardia chloramphenicol sodium succinate (Rachelle
lamblia; two had enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli Laboratories, Long Beach, Calif) given every 6 hr
reportedly from three to 30 times per day (mean, 10.2 Table 1. Clinical features and fecal composition of 42
± 1.1 times). Stools were described as watery in 41 patients with blood-culture positive typhoid fever and di-
arrhea.
(98070) of the cases, and large amounts of blood had
been noted in the stools by only three (7070) of the Mean ± SE or
patients; one patient described the stools as soft. The percentage of
patients with
dehydration detected in these patients by physical ex-
Clinical features feature Range
amination was mild or absent in all but nine patients,
who showed moderate dehydration. The highest Prehospital duration of:
Fever (days) 9.5 ± 0.9 2-30
value of serum-specific gravity obtained was 1.028,
Diarrhea (days) 5.8 ± 0.5 1-20
a result confirming that dehydration was never more No. of stools passed during
than moderately severe in these diarrheal cases. The 24 hr before admission 10.2 ± 1.1 3-30
means of serum electrolytes were as follows: sodium, Stool characterization:
enw 40·0
0:
::::>
~
0:
W 39·5
a..
~
w
I-
o
W
o
0:
o
U
W
0:
~
Figure 1. Hospital course of fever <i
ow
and output of diarrhea in 37 patients ~~
wO:
with typhoid fever who completed at IQ
(91-
least nine days of antibiotic treatment -z
Iw
in volunteers [27] who had the disease and did not higher concentrations of potassium. The diarrhea
develop diarrhea; this difference suggests that nat- of these patients with typhoid fever contrasts with
urally acquired typhoid fever shows a lower thresh- that associated with shigellosis in that it is generally
old of resistance for diarrhea that could be caused more watery, does not cause frank dysentery except
by an association with intestinal diseases or by nutri- in the few patients who passed grossly bloody stools,
tional factors in developing countries. The wide and contains lower counts of fecal leukocytes (P. S.,
range in the severity of diarrhea in our patients, from unpublished observations).
three to 30 stools passed per day and from 4 to 172 The earlier view of diarrhea associated with ty-
ml of diarrheal fluid/kg of body weight passed dur- phoid was that diarrhea developed late in the course
ing the first day in the hospital, suggests also that of the disease. Stuart and Pullen [14] found that di-
these patients were not preselected for severe diar- arrhea occurred usually on the eighth or ninth day
rhea and were an appropriate group for the study of illness, and Ikeme and Anan [17] described diar-
of the pathogenesis of diarrhea in typhoid fever. rhea occurring two weeks or more after the onset
Our results confirm the findings of Stoll et al. [20] of fever. The onset of diarrhea at this later period,
that the diarrhea of patients with typhoid fever is when ulceration in the ileum is advanced and the
watery and contains leukocytes. Our results further complications of perforation and hemorrhage typi-
establish that the stools contained leukocytes over cally occur, implies that local inflammation in the
a wide range of counts, with a mean of 4,950 ileum causes the diarrhea. Our findings, on the other
cells/rum", and a predominance of PMNLs. Red hand, suggest that diarrhea occurred earlier than two
blood cells were less regularly present and were usu- weeks in most patients. The histories of our patients
ally in smaller numbers than white blood cells. The revealed that the mean prehospital duration of fe-
stools contained high concentrations of protein and ver and diarrhea was 9.5 days and 5.8 days, respec-
had a mean acidic pH of 6.1. The overall fecal com- tively, a finding indicating that diarrhea started at
position in these patients indicates that diarrhea as- an average time of "-'3.5 days after the onset of fe-
sociated with typhoid contrasts with that associated ver. Furthermore, the diarrhea in these patients
with cholera by showing more fecal leukocytes and resolved during treatment with chloramphenicol at
more protein, containing lower concentrations of so- a rate that approximately paralleled the resolution
dium, chloride, and bicarbonate, but containing of fever. This close temporal association of fever and
1142 Roy et at.
termination of total carbon dioxide in blood and plasma 30. Maenza RM, Powell OW, Plotkin GR, Formal SB, Jervis HR,
by means of the cediometer: theory and experimental verifi- Sprinz H. Experimental diarrhea: Salmonella Enterocoli-
cation. Clin Chim Acta 1968;22:261-70 tis in the rat. J Infect Dis 1970;121:475-85
25. Osada Y, Nakajo M, Ogawa H. Application of experimental 31. Powell OW, Plotkin GR, Maenza RM, Solberg LI, Catlin DH,
keratoconjunctivitis shigellosa in chemotherapeutic evalu- Formal SB. Experimental Diarrhea. I. Intestinal water and
ation of rifampicin to bacillary dysentery. Japanese Jour- electrolyte transport in rat salmonella enterocolitis. Gas-
nal of Microbiology 1972;16:329-32 troenterology 1971;60:1053-64
26. Merson MH, Sack RB, Kibriya AKMG, Abdullah-Al- 32. Rout WR, Formal SB, Dammin GJ, and Giannella RA.
Mahmood, Adamed QS, Huq I. Use of colony pools for Pathophysiology of salmonella diarrhea in the Rhesus
diagnosis of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli diarrhoea. monkey: intestinal transport, morphological and bacteri-
J Clin Microbiol 1979;9:493-7 ological studies. Gastroenterology 1974;67:59-70
27. Hornick RB, Greisman SE, Woodward TE, DuPont HL, 33. Giannella RA, Gots RE, Charney AN, Greenough, WB III,
Dawkins AT, and Snyder MJ. Typhoid fever: pathogene- Formal SB. Pathogenesis of salmonella-mediated intesti-
sis and immunologic control. N Engl J Med nal fluid secretion. Gastroenterology 1975;69:1238-45