Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/23164828
The effects of bio-solid and tea waste application into different levels of
eroded soil on N, P and K concentrations
CITATIONS READS
5 525
3 authors:
Orhan Dengiz
Ondokuz Mayıs Üniversitesi
201 PUBLICATIONS 1,276 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Burgazada ve Heybeliada Topraklarından Nonomuraea Türlerinin İzolasyonu ve Moleküler Tiplendirilmeleri View project
Ephemeral gully erosion observation using unmanned aerial vehicle View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Tugrul Yakupoglu on 30 April 2015.
Received: 15 February 2008 / Accepted: 26 June 2008 / Published online: 12 August 2008
© Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
Abstract The main objective of the study was results, it was found that while BS treatments
to find out the effects of various organic matter increased total N, available P and exchangeable
sources such as bio-solid (BS) and tea waste (TW) K content of all eroded soils comparing to con-
on macro nutrient content of eroded soils. In or- trol treatment, effectiveness of TW on P is very
der to determine different soil erodibility levels low in slightly and moderately erosion levels. BS
(slightly, moderately and severely), erosion ratio and TW applications increased K content in soils.
(ER) and soil erodibility factor (K) parameters However, it was determined not significant sta-
were used. Soil samples used in this research were tistically between effectiveness of these various
taken from bulk surface (0–20 cm depth) located organic residues whereas, N and P values signifi-
on agricultural lands of Asagi Aksu village that cantly correlated with BS and TW (P < 0.05). In
is 20 km far from Samsun province in the north addition, change of N, P and K values depending
part of Turkey. These lands have been used as on the application doses and soil erosion levels
agricultural activity. Some properties of the soil were found statistically significant (P < 0.001).
classified as Vertic calciudoll were determined as
follows; fine in texture, organic matter content Keywords Bio-solid · Tea waste · Soil ·
varies between 0.83% and 0.90%. In addition, pH Erodibility · Erosion · Fertility
and EC values of these soils are 8.0–8.1 and 0.64–
0.79 dSm−1 respectively. This study was conducted
by applying four different doses of BS and TW
(0%, 2%, 4% and 6%) in eroded soils under Abbreviations
greenhouse condition. Each treatment was repli-
cated three times in a split block design. After BS Bio-solid
18 weeks incubation period associated parameters TW Tea waste
were determined in all pots. According to analysis ER Erosion ratio
K factor Soil erodibility factor
N Total nitrogen
P Available phosphorous
K Exchangeable potassium
N. Ozdemir · T. Yakupoglu · O. Dengiz (B)
OC Organic carbon
Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agriculture,
Ondokuz Mayis University, 55139 Samsun, Turkey SOM Soil organic matter
e-mail: odengiz@omu.edu.tr CEC Cation exchangeable capacity
110 Environ Monit Assess (2009) 156:109–118
Fig. 1 Location
of the study area
Environ Monit Assess (2009) 156:109–118 111
This site is located in the Black Sea Region, Scheibler calsimeter and pH, EC—electrical con-
Northern Turkey (Latitude 41◦ 19 N; longitude ductivity by method of the Soil Survey Laboratory
36◦ 02 W). The climates is semi humid (R f = (Soil Survey Staff 1992). Particle size distribu-
47.21) with monthly mean temperatures ranging tion was determined by the hydrometer method
from 6.6◦ C in February to 23◦ C in August. The (Bouyoucos 1951). Exchangeable Na and micro
annual mean temperature is 14.2◦ C, annual mean nutrient content were measured by Kacar (1994).
precipitation 670 mm (Anonymous 2002). Some soil properties were determined as Table 1.
Soils of the study area were classified as ver- According to Table 1, clay, silt and sand con-
tic calciudoll according to soil taxonomy (Soil tents for slightly eroded soil are 59.4%, 26.0%,
Survey Staff 1999). Some physical and chemi- and 14.6% respectively. While clay, silt and sand
cal soil properties were determined as follows; distribution are 56.1%, 30.8%, and 13.1% for
Organic matter was determined in air-dry samples moderately eroded soil, severely eroded soil has
using the Walkley–Black wet digestion method 53.1%, 31.7%, and 15.2% respectively. The soils
(Nelson and Sommers 1982); Lime content by showed a slightly alkaline reaction having a pH
value (in 1:2.5 soil–water suspension as w/v) 8.0, This case was also determined in the study area
8.1 and 8.1, respectively. Electrical conductivity soils.
values of soils were determined as 0.79, 0.65, and
0.64 dSm−1 , respectively. Organic carbon (OC) Bio-solid and tea waste
values belong to soils are 0.573%, 0.486%, and
0.480% respectively. Total nitrogen (N) contents The bio-solid (BS) was obtained from Bafra Mu-
into the soils are 0.14%, 0.13%, and 0.11% and nicipality. BS used in the present study had 37%
C/N ratios 4.093, 3.739, and 4.364 respectively. organic matter content. As based on weight,
ER and K values of three different eroded soils 22.2% and 2.4% of the organic fractions were car-
were found as 5.36, 6.65, 12.17 and 0.014, 0.015, bon and nitrogen, respectively, having a C/N ra-
0.016 respectively, and were given in Table 1. Lal tio of 9.25. Non-organic fractions of the bio-solid
(1988) indicated that ER and K parameters are includes 2.3% Fe2 O3 , 11.5% CaO, 1.34% MgO,
used as indices to evaluate soil sensitivity agains 1.3 P %, 0.23% K, 0.22% NaO and 4.4% Al2 O3 .
to erosion and values of these parameters increase pH, and water-soluble P content of the bio-solid
whereas, structural stabilities of soils decrease. were found to be 7.2 and 581 μgg−1 respectively.
Table 6 LSD0.05 analysis of the N data Table 7 LSD0.05 analysis of the P data
N content P content
Erosion level Erosion level
Slightly 3,304.2a Slightly 76.8a
Moderately 3,004.2b Moderately 39.8b
Severely 2,866.7c Severely 23.0c
Organic wastes Organic wastes
BS 3,119.5a BS 49.1a
TW 2,997.2b TW 44.0b
Application doses Application doses
0 1,266.7a 0 20.7a
1 2,350.0b 1 35.6b
2 3,627.8c 2 54.5c
3 4,988.9d 3 75.3d
LSD values: for erosion level: 53.014; for organic waste: LSD values: for erosion level: 3.105; for organic waste:
52.097; for application dose: 38.789 3.057; for application dose: 1.930
114 Environ Monit Assess (2009) 156:109–118
Fig. 3 Changes in
available P (μgg−1 )
content of the soils
depending on erosion
levels (slightly,
moderately, and
severely), type of organic
wastes (BS and TW)
and application doses
(0%, 2%, 4% and 6%)
Statistical assessment was done using Statistical (Dahlgren et al. 1997). Variance analysis results
Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) software of these properties are presented Tables 3, 4,
program (1998). and 5.
As shown in Table 3; total N values were
significantly influenced from the organic condi-
Results and discussion tioners depending on erosion level (P < 0.001),
kind of residues (P < 0.05), and application
After incubation period for 18 weeks, changes doses (P < 0.001). Mean of square values of the
in total N, available P, and exchangeable K of amendment materials and their levels were found
eroded soils were determined. Significant differ- statistically significant. As shown Table 3; also
ences in these properties were observed depend- interactions of erosion level × application dose,
ing on soil erosion levels, kind of organic residues, conditioner × erosion level, and erosion level ×
and application doses. Soil organic matter content conditioner × application dose were significant
depends on the complex interaction of several fac- (P < 0.001) while interaction of erosion level ×
tors including the quantity and quality of litter fall, conditioner was not significant, statistically. As
climatic factor, soil properties, and soil erosion shown Table 4; available P values were signifi-
Fig. 4 Changes in
Exchangeable K (μgg−1 )
content of the soils
depending on erosion
levels (slightly,
moderately, and
severely), type of organic
wastes (BS and TW)
and application doses
(0%, 2%, 4% and 6%)
116 Environ Monit Assess (2009) 156:109–118
cantly influenced from the organic waste appli- soils is 900–1,700 μgg−1 (FAO 1990). Therefore,
cations depending on erosion levels (P < 0.001), it is necessary to increase organic matter content
variety of residues (P < 0.05), and application of the eroded soils. Thus, application with 2%
doses (P < 0.001). This table illustrated that in- both BS and TW is enough for total N content
teractions of erosion level × conditioner (P < to improve soil physical, chemical and biological
0.01), erosion level × application dose, condi- properties in all soil erosion levels. In addition,
tioner × application doses, and erosion level × in the all eroded soils; the most effective material
conditioner × application dose were statistically for available P content is BS (Fig. 3). The highest
significant (P < 0.001). Variance analyses results increase was occurred in moderately erosion level
belong to exchangeable K data were given at by 6% BS application dose in terms of available P
Table 5. According to Table 5, it was deter- content ranging from18.03 μgg−1 to 164.49 μgg−1 .
mined that organic waste applications affected Similar relationships were notified with related
on changes of K contents in eroded soils. While, to available P by Aganon et al. (1997), Zarkovic
this case depends on erosion level and appli- et al. (2000), Özenç et al. (2006). Enough amount
cation dose (P < 0.001), effectiveness of or- of available P for tillage soils is 14–26 μgg−1
ganic waste types was not significant, statistically. (Olsen et al. 1954). Control soils belong to all ero-
Also all interactions were significant (P < 0.001), sion levels have enough quantity P content. Con-
statistically. sequently in this study, waste application doesn’t
According to variance analyses results, F val- important for P content into these eroded soils.
ues were found significant. Therefore, LSD0.05 It was also found that the highest increasing oc-
(least standard deviation) comparison test was curred in moderately level by 6% BS application
used to evaluate the effect of application dose, dose in terms of K content ranging from 181.49 to
erosion level and residue type on N, P and K 489.35 μgg−1 . Besides, both organic waste applica-
contents of the soils. Results of tests were given in tions increase contents of these eroded soils. Also
Tables 6, 7 and 8. Tables 6 and 7 show that ef- some researchers (McGrath et al. 1988; Whalen
fects of all applications on N and P mean values et al. 2000; Aşık and Katkat 2004) had reported
was found different each other. In the same time, that organic waste application increases K content
according to Table 8, each erosion levels and in soils. Moderate level of exchangeable K for
application doses have different effects whereas, agricultural soils is 150–200 μgg−1 (Pizer 1967).
residue type has no effect on increasing of K It was determined that used organic conditioners
values. increase exchangeable K content in eroded soils
Changes in macro element contents of eroded but doses for 4% and 6% were needless.
soils compared with control treatments are shown
in Figs. 2, 3 and 4. Whereas, the erosion level
ranging from slightly to severely of the control soil Conclusion
samples increased, their total N, available P, and
exchangeable K contents decreased from 1,400 Soils of the study area have consistently low or-
to 1,100 μgg−1 , from 28.96 to 14.94 μgg−1 , and ganic matter. In the study area, the reasons of the
from 221.33 to 168.51 μgg−1 , respectively. It was low level organic matter are attributable to soil
determined that N content increased in all eroded erosion, rapid decomposition and mineralization
soils applying BS and TW. The highest amount of organic matter especially due to intensive agri-
of the N content in all eroded soils was occurred cultural activities. As a conclusion, in this paper,
in severe erosion level using 6% BS dose taken in order to maintain a sustainable agricultural ac-
into consideration control treatments. Similar re- tivity, it should be increase organic matter of soils
sults are supported by different many researchers that was especially affected by erosion. Therefore,
(Mueller et al. 1998; Hartl et al. 2003; Kara and BS and TW can be used as a soil conditioner
Uygur 2004; Hadas et al. 2004) used organic to improve soil physico-chemical and biological
residues. Enough amount of total N for tillage properties of eroded soils.
Environ Monit Assess (2009) 156:109–118 117
by extraction with sodium bicarbonate. United States SPSS (1998). SPSS Inc. Version 9.0. Chicago: 233 S Wacker
Department of Agriculture circular: 939. Drive 11ft flor.
Özenç, B. D., Ozenc, N., & Caycı, G. (2006). Effects Tümsavaş, Z., & Katkat, A. V. (2000). Bursa ili civarındaki
of different organic materials on soil pH and avail- eğimli tarım topraklarının laboratuvar koşullarında su
able phosphorus and cation exchange capacity. In Pa- erozyonuna karşı duyarlılıklarının belirlenmesi üzer-
per presented at the 18th International Soil Meeting, ine bir araştırma. Turkish Journal of Agriculture and
Şanlıurfa, Turkey. Forestry, 24, 737–744.
Pizer, N. H. (1967). Some advisory aspect. Soil potassium Uyanöz, R., Cetin, U., Zengin, M., & Gür, K. (2002). Effect
and magnesium. Technical Bulletin, 14, 184. of different organic wastes on nitrogen mineralization
Renard, K. G., Foster, G. R., Weesies, G. A., McCool, and organic carbon contents of soil. In Paper pre-
D. K., & Yoder, D. C. (1997). Predicting soil ero- sented at 16th International Soil Meeting, Canakkale,
sion by water: A guide to conservation planning with Turkey.
the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE). Whalen, J. K., Chang, C., Clayton, G. W., & Carefoot,
Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. J. P. (2000). Cattle manure amendments can increase
Rowell, D. L. (1996). Soil science methods and applications. the pH of acid soils. Soil Science Society of America
Harlow, U.K.: Wesley Longman. Journal, 64, 962–966.
Ryan, J., Estefan, G., & Rashid, A. (2001). Soil and plant Wong, J. W. C., Ma, K. K., Fang, K. M., & Cheung, C.
analysis laboratory manual. Aleppo, Syria: Interna- (1999). Utilization of a manure compost for organic
tional Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry farming in Hong Kong. Bioresource Technology, 67,
Areas (ICARDA). 43–46. doi:10.1016/S0960-8524(99)00066-8.
Smith, S. R. (1996). Agricultural recycling of sewage sludge Zarkovic, B., Blagojevic, S., & Stevonovic, D. (2000).
and the environment. Guildford: CAB International. Agrochemical properties of a calcareous chernozem
Soil Survey Staff (1992). Procedures for collecting soil soil after long-term application of mineral and or-
samples and methods of analysis for soil survey. ganic fertilizers. Yugoslavia, Zemljiste i biljka, 49,
Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. 59–67.
Soil Survey Staff (1999). Soil taxonomy: A basic of soil Zibilski, L. M., Clapham, W. M., & Rouke, R. V. (2000).
classification for making and interpreting soil sur- Multiple applications of paper mill sludge in an agri-
vey. USDA Handbook No: 436, Washington, DC, cultural system: Soil effect. Journal of Environmental
USA. Quality, 29, 1925–1932.