You are on page 1of 7

The place where pure water is

running in the depths of the forest


in the deep mountains, where
no human has ever set foot, the
Japanese have long held such a
place in their heart.
Hayao Miyazaki 19981

J
APANESE ADORE THE ANIMATED FEATURE FILMS OF computerised anime house where artists are exhorted to draw
Hayao Miyazaki. Children often know the dialogues by everything by hand.
heart, and grandparents, salarymen and teenagers enjoy
them just as enthusiastically. Toys and merchandise of his ani- In addition to examining his recent box-office success Spir-
mated creations occupy an important space in Japan’s ‘char- ited Away, this essay will offer an alternative reading of one of
acter culture’. Miyazaki’s Princess Mononoke (1997) eclipsed Miyazaki’s earliest feature films, Nausicaa of the Valley of the
Steven Spielberg’s E.T. to create a new domestic box-office Winds (1984). Nausicaa marked his expansion from comic artist
record, only to be nudged out by James Cameron’s Titanic in the to film director with the translation of his popular and long-run-
same year. Four years later, Miyazaki’s follow-up, Spirited Away ning manga (comic) of the same name into an animated film. Our
(2001) became Japan’s highest grossing film and received global specific focus is how Miyazaki infuses his richly detailed works
recognition with the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature with an animistic worldview that references Japanese beliefs,
and the Golden Bear Award at the Berlin Film Festival. Despite practices and mythology deriving from Shintoism. In these films,
commercial success and increasing global attention, Miyazaki’s pre-modern expressions of Shintoism are visually transformed
production studio, Studio Ghibli, is a self-contained, proudly non- and introduced to a largely urban audience through symbolic

46 • Metro Magazine No. 143


LUCY WRIGHT & JERRY CLODE

moments that offer a resonant connection, albeit a mediated one, export are prone to mu-kokuseki—the erasure of racial and ethnic
with the natural and spiritual worlds revered by the Japanese. characteristics and any context that would embed a specific cul-
ture or country.4 The strategy has been refined and ‘perfected’ in
Hayao Miyazaki: Global Gaze, Local Focus Japan’s immediate cultural markets in East and South-east Asia,
where a resurgent Japanese presence sits uncomfortably with
The global reception of Miyazaki’s work has accompanied a historical memory and narratives of nation.
wider export of Japanese popular culture which Douglas McGray
coins Japan’s ‘Gross National Cool’.2 It is suggested that such Initial academic focus on Miyazaki has similarly scrutinized his
success is built on Japan’s unique ability to ‘glocalise’ a host of films for diluted identity, in particular, there is debate as to wheth-
foreign influences for re-packaging to a global market. As media er Miyazaki’s characters can be described as ‘Japanese’. While
and cultural critic Koichi Iwabuchi notes, Japan’s recent cultural most of Miyazaki’s characters have distinctly Western features—
expansion is premised on a strategy of blurring distinctively Japa- large eyes, pale skin, red hair—they have, however, also curiously
nese attributes of exports to create ‘culturally odourless prod- been (reverse) assimilated and ‘Japan-ized’ for consumption by a
ucts’.3 In particular, animation and game software destined for local audience. American anime scholar Susan Napier suggests

Metro Magazine No. 143 • 47


that Miyazaki’s non-committed expression ing appeal is located in the creation of a RIGHT PAGE BOTTOM LEFT-MIDDLE:
of ethnic features allows his characters hybrid Japanese ‘modern myth’ that is ac- SPIRITED AWAY; PRINCESS MONONOKE ALL
OTHERS: NAUSICAA
to exemplify more Western models of cessible (in different ways) to post-indus-
courage and heroism. By merging Japa- trialized audiences all over the world. Nau-
nese and foreign traits, he is able to subtly sicaa exemplifies the kind of ‘globalizing’
erase traditional distinctions, providing a of storytelling that is intrinsic to his work.
textual template to infuse his characters He has previously noted that the inspira- circulating narratives of environmental de-
with new possibility and optimism.5 Most tions for the film’s narrative and charac- struction, whereas a Japanese audience
of Miyazaki’s lead characters are young ters derive from such diverse sources as are also likely to simultaneously engage
girls whose bravado stands in contrast to Homer’s Odyssey, Frank Herbert’s Dune here with specific allusions to kami, or
the scarcity of convincing female protago- and the Japanese folk tale The Princess gods, and Shintoist tenets of respecting
nists presented in the passively feminine Who Loved Insects. and communing with nature’s deities.
shojo genre that dominates mainstream
anime. In one of Miyazaki’s earlier films, While openly acknowledging the impor- The Way of the Kami
Kiki’s Delivery Service (1989), the enter- tance of hybridity to his work, Miyazaki
prise and courage of a young witch is admits his primary concern is how his I’ve come to the point where I just can’t
brought out by a thoroughly European films are viewed and received in Japan. make a movie without addressing the
setting, complete with unfamiliar continen- We would argue here that Japanese audi- problem of humanity as part of an ecosys-
tal architecture, puzzling geography and ences have been able to form a cinephiliac tem.
troublesome traffic. relationship to Miyazaki’s work built on Hayao Miyazaki 19987
his transformation and reinvigoration of
As an artist, Miyazaki works within a the tenets of Shintoism and local mythol- One of the few surviving animistic and
continuous local tradition of cultural and ogy, which form a constellation of filmic pantheistic religions, Shinto is deeply
aesthetic appropriation, which anima- codes peculiar to his cinematic style and connected to the Japanese landscape.
tion theorist Paul Wells identifies as a reception. For example, a non-Japanese Awe-inspiring aspects of the natural
fundamental attribute of Japanese artistic audience viewing Princess Mononoke can world are seen to possess kami, or gods,
expression.6 Rather than a convention of clearly read the symbolic beheading of who are celebrated through ritual and
covert creolization, Miyazaki’s broaden- the spirit of the forest in terms of globally ceremony. During the crystallization of

48 • Metro Magazine No. 143


Shintoist beliefs in the early Jomon period fascination with nature, two young girls tem. Many of Miyazaki’s films address the
(10,000 BC-300 BC), respect for the kami are connected with a gentle, teddy bear- consequences of upsetting this balance,
was seen as inseparable from people’s ish woodland kami, O-Totoro, (King Totoro) either through wholesale destruction of
intuitive reverence and love of nature. who provides them with solace and guid- the natural environment (Nausicaa) or via
While ethereal, kami were not considered ance during their mother’s illness. the inevitable separation of spheres born
omniscient and distant in the Christian or of urbanization and modernity (Spirited
Muslim sense, but often thought of in a Shinto does not strictly divide the world Away).
similar way to the Greek gods: capable of between material and spiritual, nor

Rather than a convention of covert creolization, Miyazaki’s broadening appeal is


located in the creation of a hybrid Japanese ‘modern myth’ that is accessible (in different
ways) to post-industrialized audiences all over the world. ‘Nausicaa’ exemplifies the kind of
‘globalizing’ of storytelling that is intrinsic to his work.

human emotion and accessible to mortal between this world and an alternative Nausicaa: In Awe of the Natural
communication. The Japanese character- perfect realm, but instead emphasizes that World
ize this relationship in terms of oya-ko: as intuitive spirituality facilitates the fusion
ancestor to descendent or parent to child. and equilibrium of all realms. The nature of In the thirtieth century world of Nausicaa,
humanity is considered essentially good, the world has been destroyed in a human-
One of Miyazaki’s most celebrated films and pure evil does not stain the soul, it inflicted holocaust called The Seven Days
in Japan, My Neighbour Totoro (1988), only obscures its true nature temporarily. of Fire. Yet, instead of a dry, radioactive
exemplifies the benevolent relationship Conceptualizing continuity between man wasteland, the lands are abundant with
that can be enjoyed between the kami and nature, Shinto views humankind in life. Toxins have caused widespread plant
and humans. Through their pre-intellectual harmonious accord with the wider ecosys- and insect mutations and a giant breed

Metro Magazine No. 143 • 49


of insectoid called Ohmu rule the planet. this to the world?’ in a tone not of disgust equilibrium, reconciling and harmonizing
Simultaneously, a new ecosystem evolves but of naïve incredulity. She is in effect extremes.
that is poisonous to humans, variously asking why anyone would act to create
called the Sea of Corruption, the Toxic disharmony in the world. Later, after an Spirited Away: Rediscovering
Jungle, the Acid Sea and the Wasteland. It aerial battle, she crash-lands in the jungle the Spiritual
is the humans who must now adapt to the and finds herself, along with a Pejite boy
by-products of a different species. This she was trying to save, in a subterranean In his most recent film, Spirited Away,
kind of ecological influence is apparent cavern of clean water and non-toxic Miyazaki takes a more contemporary look
in Nausicaa’s many symbolic moments, sands. They realize that the entire forest at the spiritual life of Japan. Instead of
which, as Wells suggests, ‘become the operates as a purifying organism; the trees a war between gods and humans, this
locus for narrational emphasis and the absorb the poisons from the soil, crystal- time Miyazaki examines how folk beliefs
nexus of spiritual and philosophic ideas’.8 lize and neutralize them, before eventually of Shinto can be integrated into modern
As well as carrying the trope of the mes- dissolving into sand. The Toxic Jungle is lives. Like many other girls her age, petu-
siah, the character of the princess embod- effectively purifying the planet, a task the lant ten-year-old Chihiro knows little about
ies certain ideas about how to live with the scattered humans are unable to do. In her cultural heritage, and while Miyazaki
natural world. Her characterization can be Nausicaa, pollution comes not from the re- doesn’t set out to educate children, he
read as signifying transitional and purify- versal of power relations between humans would like ‘[young audiences] to be in the
ing aspects, and the unusual power she and insects, but in the interruption to the movie theatre with a sense of humility
possesses as affirmative of the ‘rightness’ continuity of nature by humans placing about the complexity and difficulty of the
of her mode of thought. themselves outside of the natural order. world that we live in’.9 But he is adamant
about avoiding Disney techniques, such
One of the few remaining refuges of The character of Nausicaa physically as simplifying the world for children: ‘To
humanity is Nausicaa’s home in the Val- moves between the insect realm of the make a true children’s film is a real daunt-
ley of the Wind. Ocean breezes keep the Jungle and the human world of the Valley ing challenge and this is because we need
Valley free of toxic spores and enable a of the Wind—in fact, her liminality serves to clearly portray the essence of a very
small, pastoral community to live a semi- to merge the two. Like an emergent complex world.’10 This includes sharing
feudal life. With its windmills, castle and lifeform, Nausicaa has evolved to com- with them his kindly worldview that is
cultivated grapes, the Valley connotes a municate with the now-dominant insects. expressed symbolically through Shinto.
pre-modern idyll. The people present as Besides her mentor Master Yupa, she is
friendly and good-hearted in their hearty the only one of the Valley folk to venture Shinto and the kami play a very prominent
greetings to one another and their concern from the safety of the Valley. This intuitive role in this film. At the beginning, as Chihi-
for the princess. They stand in contrast to talent sets her apart from the other hu- ro and her parents get themselves lost on
the warring states of Torumekia and Pejite: mans, despite her love and protection of the way to their new home, Chihiro notices
where the Valley folk are agrarian and gen- them, and empowers her as a harmonizing a grinning statue by the side of the road.
tle, the other states are violent and cling to agent. Nausicaa leads the Valley not into Surrounded by tiny stone houses ‘where
their militaristic way of life. When the Val- the restoration of an old way of life, but spirits live’, the squat statue seems to leer
ley has been invaded and occupied by the into a new mode of survival in contact with and grimace at her, however it is closely
Torumekians, one Valley man says to the the Toxic Jungle. modelled on Douso-jin—a roadside Shinto
Commander: ‘You use fire. We use a little deity and protector of travellers. Statues of
of that too, but too much fire gives birth to The Ohmu, aware of the purifying func- this deity were often put at the boundary
nothing. Fire turns a forest to ash in one tion of the forest, act to defend it from the of a village or at crossroads to indicate the
day. Water and wind take a hundred years actions of humans. They are a god-like right direction. This metaphor-heavy place
to nurture a forest. We prefer water and race, intricately connected to the new symbolically marks the family’s movement
wind.’ In this juxtaposition of high-tech ecosystem and able to telepathically feel from the known to the unknown. The old
weaponry and the simple life of the Valley, the pain of all creatures in the Jungle, not torii gate leaning against a tall camphor
the latter is clearly privileged as the more just their own kind. Despite suffering from tree also offers the subtext of passage
desirable community and settlement. the aggression of the Torumekians and from the secular into the sacred. Chihiro’s
Pejites, the Ohmu are not vengeful—but initial fear of this ancient statue and her
Nausicaa takes a scientific and beatific seek to restore the balance. Nausicaa’s reluctance to join her parents as they ex-
interest in the forest and joyfully uncov- grandmother, the sage of the Valley, wisely plore the strange area they have stumbled
ers the complexity of her surroundings. sees this when she whispers; ‘The anger into is borne from her unfamiliarity with
In a secret laboratory, she grows spores of the Ohmu is the anger of the earth’ and these supposedly reassuring objects.
collected from the Jungle and discov- later ‘what sympathy they possess …’
ers that, given clean water and soil, the The Ohmu acknowledge the sacrifices A little later, after Chihiro’s parents have
fungi and plants do not give off poisonous Nausicaa makes, and seem aware of succumbed to greed and a spell turning
vapours—it is the soil that is toxic, not the their shared purpose. They embody, like them into pigs, Chihiro watches awe-
plants that grow in it. When she discov- Nausicaa, the core idea of Shinto—that struck as the way home is now filled with
ers this, she asks, ‘Who could have done the natural world will relentlessly find water and a brightly lit barge arrives on

50 • Metro Magazine No. 143


the banks. The barge seems initially to what was at the bottom of it, which was humanity’s return to an intuitive relation-
be empty, but then hundreds of float- truly putrid. In the river there was a bicycle ship with the natural world as revered by
ing paper masks emerge and the gods’ with its wheel sticking out above the sur- Shinto—a message that has endeared
ghostly forms materialize behind them. face of the water. So they thought it would Miyazaki’s animated worlds to Japanese
The masks, called zoumen, have been be easy to pull out, but it was terribly and increasingly global audiences.
described as similar to those that Ama difficult because it had become so heavy
dancers wear. Ama is an ancient form from all the dirt it had collected over the This article has been refereed.
of Japanese dance that is performed at years. Now they’ve managed to clean up
Shinto shrines as well as at the Imperial the river, the fish are slowly returning to it, Lucy Wright is a Ph.D. candidate at Mel-
palace. so all is not lost. But the smell of what they bourne University, and recently completed
dug up was really awful. Everyone had just a Masters project at RMIT University on
Thus there are many elements of the mise- been throwing stuff into that river over the Hayao Miyazaki’s anime and Shinto.
en-scéne that are Shinto-inspired—includ- years, so it was an absolute mess.
ing offerings of salt, the use of white to Hayao Miyazaki12 Jerry Clode lectures in Asian Media and
indicate the presence of magic, death or Culture at the School of Applied Communi-
kami, and purification by water. However Sen is pushed forward to undertake the cation, RMIT University. •
the overriding idea in the film seems to be task of helping the Stink God with his
that the kami are continuing to live along- bath. She does so courageously and Endnotes
side humans. It is not the case that the discovers that he has a ‘thorn’ in his side. 1
David Goldsmith, ‘An interview with Hayao
kami have been killed off by the rational When Yubaba hears this, she rallies all the Miyazaki’ in Mononoke-hime Theater Program,
thought of modernization. A number of workers to help Sen pull out the offend- translated by Ryoko Toyama, July 1997, www.
anthropologists have subscribed to this ing object. It turns out to be the handle of nausicaa,net/miyazaki/interviews/m_on_
myth of secularization in industrialized a bicycle and heaving it loose unleashes mh.html. Accessed 15 May 2003.
societies, epitomized in Max Weber’s a flood of appliances and debris: fridges, 2
Douglas McGray, ‘Japan’s Gross Domestic
‘disenchantment’ theory.11 What Miyazaki old microwaves, the junk of modern life. Cool’, Foreign Policy, June/July 2002, pp.45-
has attempted here is to re-enchant his But finally, the radiant, dynamic form of a 54.
modern, often very young, audiences by River God is revealed and, enveloping Sen 3
Kochi Iwabuchi, ‘From Western Gaze to Global
transforming and re-presenting the time- in a bubble of water, his wizened, wood- Gaze: Japanese cultural presence in Asia’ in
less ideas and practices of Shinto. en-masked face thanks her. He also gives Global Culture: Media, Arts, Policy and Globali-
her a ball of bitter material that seems to zation, Crane et al. (eds), Routledge, New York,
When Chihiro and her family initially stum- contain self-knowledge. 2002, pp.258-260.
ble into this magical realm they think it is 4
ibid, p. 258.
an abandoned theme park. Full of colour The theme of self-knowledge is integral 5
Susan Napier, Anime from Akira to Princess
and intriguingly ancient architecture, it to the narrative, as it is the key to her Mononoke, Palgrave, New York, 2000, pp.132-
stands empty and forgotten. ‘They built so love for Haku that facilitates her return 35.
many of them’, explains Chihiro’s father. to normalcy. Sen realizes that she has 6
Paul Wells, ‘Hayao Miyazaki: Floating worlds,
By mistaking the kami realm for a man- met Haku before, and that his presence floating signifiers’, Art + Design, vol. 32, no. 9,
made construction, Shinto itself could be here is due to events in the ‘real’ world. November 2001, p.23.
metaphorically read to be an abandoned She says, finally understanding: ‘I don’t 7
David Chute, ‘Organic Machine: The World of
theme park, an antiquated oddity. But remember it but my mum told me. Once Hayao Miyazaki’, Film Comment, vol. 34 (6),
when they enter this magical realm, im- when I was little I fell into a river. She said November/December 1998, p.64.
mediately life is breathed back into it. As they drained it and built things on top, but 8
Wells, op cit., p.23.
if just by being present, they are suddenly I’ve just remembered. The river was called 9
Mark Vallen & Jeannine Thorpe, ‘Spirited Away:
able to see the spirits that live there. … its name was the Kohaku River. Your Miyazaki at the Hollywood Premiere’, The
real name is Kohaku.’ Filling in rivers is a Black Moon, 13 September, www.theblack-
The local gods in Japan have proved common practice in Japan where space is moon.com/deadmoon/spiritedaway.html.
much more resilient than originally a rare commodity. Yet perhaps the result Accessed 10 March 2003.
thought. We can see this when Chi- of that action is that Haku is stuck in 10
ibid.
hiro (now called ‘Sen’, as the bathhouse Yubaba’s clutches, as he seeks to regain 11
Max Weber, The Sociology of Religion, trans-
proprietess Yubaba has stolen her name) knowledge of who he is and his true lated by E. Fischoff, Methuen & Co, London,
rescues the Stink God. Miyazaki describes name. This knowledge comes to Sen after 1965.
his inspiration for this scene, which is her contact with the natural world. The film 12
Tom Mes, ‘Hayao Miyazaki Interview’, Midnight
almost exactly what happens in the film: gently suggests that children, and adults, Eye, July 1, 2002, www.midnighteye.com/in-
can benefit from Shinto’s typically word- terviews/hayao_miyazaki.shtml. Accessed 12
No, it doesn’t come from mythology, but less communion with nature even amidst May 2003.
from my own experience. There is a river the abstractions of the modern world.
close to where I live in the countryside.
When they cleaned the river we got to see Both Nausicaa and Spirited Away privilege

Metro Magazine No. 143 • 51

You might also like