Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2015;2(4)
Original Article
a
Polymer Research Lab., School of Chemical Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran,
Iran
Cite this article as: Khaje S, Jamshidi M. The Effect of Aging and Silanization on the Mechanical Properties of Fumed Silica-
based Dental Composit. J Dent Biomater, 2015;2(4):124-132.
Mechanical Properties of Fumed Silica-based Dental Composite
Specific
Size Purity
Filler Shape surface area Company
(nm) (%)
(m2/g)
FS-CCW Bis-GMA/TEGDMA(50:50) containing 12wt% fumed silica exposed cyclic to cold water
FS-CHW Bis-GMA/TEGDMA(50:50) containing 12wt% fumed silica exposed cyclic to hot water
following the method of Karabella and Sideridou The Photo curing unit consisted of a LED lamp,
[11]. For this purpose, at first the fumed silica (5 ± which emitted radiation between 420 and 500 nm
0.05 g), the silane (0.5 ± 0.01 g), 100ml cyclohexane with a maximum peak of 470 nm. The LED Intensity
and n-propylamine (0.1 ± 0.01 g) were stirred at was 550 mWcm-2 (Panaloux, China). Samples were
room temperature for 30 min. Then, the mixture casted into 25mm × 2mm × 2mm moulds based
was stirred at 600C at atmospheric pressure for on ISO 4049:2009 for dental polymers [12]. The
another 30 min. To achieve the silanized powder moulds were made of Teflon, because stainless steel
and removal byproducts, the mixture was placed in was not appropriate for separating the specimen
a rotary evaporator at 600C for 30 min. The powder from the mould. Samples were light-cured by
was then heated at 95 ± 50C for 1 hr in a rotary overlapping irradiations for a total of 40s on both
evaporator. At the end, it was dried at 800C by a sides. In the case of hybrid composite, nano-silica
vacuum oven for 24 hrs. particles were mixed with fumed silica in advance.
Then, the powder was added to the resin and the
Preparation of composites process continued.
The resin was composed of Bis-GMA/
TEGDMA mixture (i.e. 50:50 by weight) which Degree of Conversion
contained CQ (0.2 wt%) and 4EDMAB (0.8 wt%) as The FT-IR analysis was conducted to find out
the photo initiating system. At first, TEGDMA was the degree of conversion of the matrix. Spectra were
added to viscose Bis-GMA to dilute the polymer, obtained over 600–4000 cm-1 region by a Perkin-
causing incorporation of more filler. Then, the fumed Elmer Spectrometer. First, a small amount of the
silica particles were added and mixed by spatula matrix of the composite before curing was placed
well till the color of the paste changed into semi- between two Mylar strips. The FT-IR spectrum was
transparent to assure well dispersion of particles in recorded at zero time, immediately after exposure
the paste. Because of high specific surface area of to visible light for 40 seconds. The spectrum of
these particles, it was not possible to wet more than the cured resin was recorded. For each spectrum,
12 wt% of the particles in the resin. Then, photo we determined the height of aliphatic C = C peak
initiating system was added and the composite was absorption at 1637 cm-1, and the aromatic C = C
casted into moulds. Finally, the paste was light- peak absorption at 1580 cm-1 was measured using
cured with the light curing device. a baseline technique which proved the best fit to the
Beer–Lambert law. The aromatic C = C vibration flexural strength was calculated using the following
was used as an internal standard. The degree of equation [14]:
conversion was calculated by the following equation
[13]: Flexural Strength = 3.F.l./2b.h2
Table 3: Degree of conversion of the matrix at different times of exposure to day light
60
fracture, d is diameter of the specimen, and t is a)
Flexural Strength(MPa)
50
thickness of the specimen. 40
30
Nano-hardness test 20
To measure the hardness of the surface of 10
Flexural Modulus(MPa)
1000
Evaluating the aging of the samples 800
1.6
removed and placed for 2 hrs at room temperature. 1.4
1.2
60 Cycles were continued on the basis of this
1
procedure. C) Cyclic exposure to hot water: The 0.8
0.6
sample was placed for 2 hrs in hot water at 70 ± 5 0.4
0C then was kept for 2 hrs at room temperature. The 0.2
0
cycle was repeated for 60 times. FS FS-S(12) FS-S(16) FS-S(20)
Sample Code
Data Analysis
Figure 3: Flexural properties of silanized samples
Mechanical properties were analyzed to find a) Flexural strength b) Flexural modulus and c) Toughness
outliers. Each sample consisted of 5 specimens.
Average and standard deviation of these specimens
Degree of conversion was measured and shown
were calculated. Then the numbers out of average
in Table 3. The conversion here is defined as the
± standard deviation were removed. Average and
number of double bonds of monomer methacrylate
standard deviation of the remaining data were
groups which react. Usually, most of the conversion
calculated and approved as a reliable data in the
happens in the first hours. Based on the results,
paper.
conversion increases rapidly in the first hour
up to 60%. Then, the rate of increment declines
Results
significantly and it almost stops at 80% which shows
high rate of conversion at the first day of exposure.
Result of the FTIR analysis is shown in Figure 1.
Figure 2 is presenting the results of the flexural
80
strength values for FS and FS (70:30), showing a
70 difference between the samples. The FS (70:30)
sample had higher flexural properties, but there was
Flexural Strength(MPa)
60
50
40
a big problem in this sample. Here, dispersion of the
30 fillers to the resin was done manually. Because of the
20 highly specific area of the fumed silica and higher
10
content of Bis-GMA, the workability of the created
0
FS FS(70:30) paste was so low in a way that it was not applicable
Sample Code in dentistry. Therefore, to improve workability, we
increased diluent in resin content and tried to mix
Figure 2: Flexural strength value of FS and FS (70:30)
the filler as much as possible. On the other hand,
1200
60
a) b)
Flexural Strength(MPa)
Flexural Modulus(MPa)
50 1000
40 800
30 600
20 400
10
200
0
0
FS FS-N
FS FS-N
Sample Code
Sample Code
2 30
1.8 c) d)
Toughness(mMPa/m)
25
1.6
Diametral Tensile
Strength(MPa)
1.4 20
1.2
1 15
0.8
0.6 10
0.4
5
0.2
0 0
FS FS-N FS FS-N
Sample Code Sample Code
Figure 4: Mechanical properties of fumed silica composite with the hybrid fillers;
a) Flexural strength b) Flexural modulus c) Toughness d) Diametral tensile strength
FS sample had an acceptable workability which can By increasing the filler content from 12 to 16
be more economical with low content of Bis-GMA. wt%, the flexural strength improved significantly
A silane coupling agent was used to bridge from 21.95 MPa in FS-S (12) to 35.35 MPa in FS-S
between organic and inorganic materials in the (16). Flexural strength of the sample FS-S (20)
resin and also to disperse the fumed silica particles almost had no changed in comparison to FS-S (16).
uniformly to the resin. As we expected, silanization Flexural modulus also followed the same trend.
gave us the ability to disperse more filler into the Toughness decreased from FS-S (12) to FS-S (20).
resin, from 12 wt% in FS-S (12) to 20wt% in FS-S Hybrid composites have been reported to have
(20) sample. Flexural strength, flexural modulus and good mechanical properties [16]. Fumed silica
toughness of silanized samples are shown in Figure 3. particles were hybridized with nano-silica particles.
Results for mechanical properties are shown in
60 Figure 4.
a)
Due to the environment of the mouth and
Flexural Strength(MPa)
50
1200
b) 2
1.8 c)
Flexural Modulus(MPa)
1000
1.6
Toghness(mMPa/m)
800 1.4
1.2
600 1
0.8
400
0.6
200 0.4
0.2
0 0
FS FS-CW FS-CCW FS-HW FS FS-CW FS-CCW FS-HW
Sample Code Sample Code
Figure 5: Flexural properties of FS aged samples a) Flexural Strength b) Flexural Modulus and c) Toughness
of the different tested groups after all procedures are decrease which happened in FS-S (20) was the
summarized in Figure 5. result of poor links between the filler and matrix.
Surface hardness is clinically the most relevant Interfacial interaction plays an important role in the
for mechanical performance of restorative materials. strength of the composite and as the result of adding
Surface hardness of the samples FS and FS-N was more filler, the coherence between the resin and filler
measured by a nano-indentation instrument. These diminished. Toughness showed the strength of the
two samples had the best mechanical properties with material toward crack propagation. By adding more
respect to the previous test results. AFM photo of filler, the continuity of resin composite lowered;
the Berkovic tip on the surface of the FS-N is shown therefore, the toughness decreased.
in Figure 6. Nano-hardness measurements of the Figure 3 also shows that silanization of fumed
samples are shown in Figure 7. silica caused a decrease in the strength of the
composite. This result is not in the same line with
Discussion that of previous studies. We used n-propylamine as
a stabilizer of silane connections and cyclohexane
Degree of Conversion as solvent. Based on Chen and Brauer, although the
When particle size of the filler is about half of silanization process would be more efficient using
the wavelength of the photo curing device, the that method, the strength of the resulting composite
maximum conversion is achieved [5]. In this study, would decrease greatly [9]. We found that the tests
the visible light wavelength range was 420–500 nm have been performed after a long time and this may
for photo curing the matrix resin and average filler be the reason for the weak result of silanization on
particle size of the filler was 200-300 nm; therefore, mechanical properties of the sample.
the increased light scatterings during photo curing
caused an increase in the degree of conversion. Effect of Hybridizing fumed silica with nano-silica
Besides, the high percentage of TEGDMA in particles
the resin caused easy mobility of the monomers; The flexural strength, flexural modulus and
therefore, the rate of reaction increased. toughness of the sample FS-N are significantly
lower than FS. Nano-silica particles agglomeration
Mechanical Properties
The main objective of this research was to
investigate the mechanical properties of dental 0.3
0.1
and intervention between fumed silica particles and filler, but mechanical properties decreased
the matrix caused discontinuity in the composite; significantly. The silanization method was not
therefore, the strength was lowered. The amounts of efficient enough and the bonds which were
diametral tensile strength of both samples are almost created by coupling agent between organic resin
equal and similar to commercial restoratives [17]. and inorganic filler were so weak.
• Thermal cycling in both cold and hot water had
Effect of Thermal Ageing negative effect on flexural strength and modulus.
All the processes had a significant deteriorating Cyclic ageing in hot water deteriorated the
effect on mechanical properties of the sample. polymer matrix greatly.
Ageing in cold water had worse effects than cycling • Hybridization of fumed silica composite with
in cold water. Ageing in cold water caused 55% fall nan-osilica improved the surface hardness by
in the flexural strength but cycling in cold water 24 times. The mechanical properties decreased
decreased it about 25%. The same trend was seen to some extent.
for flexural modulus. Cycling in hot water had a • Due to using lower contents of fumed silica (i.e.
tremendous effect on mechanical properties. The 10 wt%) and polymer to diluent proportions (i.e.
flexural strength of FS-CHW was 72% less than FS 50:50) in comparison to traditional competes,
sample. Flexural modulus decreased, too. Although the prepared samples can be considered as an
flexural strength of the sample aged in cold water economic dental retrofitting material. In this
(FS-CW) was more than FS-CHW sample, its flexural study, by attention to low weight percentage
modulus was less than all the other samples. It was of fumed silica in the composite and high
attributed to the low temperature of refrigerator in amounts of diluent in the resin, this dental resin
which FS-CW was aged. The low temperature didn’t composite is economical in comparison to other
allow the molecules to have enough mobility, so the products.
flexural modulus which showed elasticity decreased
more than even FS-CHW which was exposed to hot References
water. Toughness, like flexural strength, was more
inspired by hot water and hot water tremendously 1. Moraschini V, Fai CK, Alto RM, et al. Amalgam
reduced the resistance of the sample toward cracks. and resin composite longevity of posterior
restorations: A systematic review and meta
Nano-hardness analysis. J Dent. 2015;43:1043-1050.
Light nature of fumed silica as a filler gives the 2. Ferracane JL. Resin composite—State of the
resulting composite a low surface hardness property. art. Dent Mater. 2011;27:29-38.
Hybridizing improved the hardness 24 times based 3. F e r r a c a n e J L , P f e i f e r C S , H i l t o n T J .
on Figure 7. This can be attributed to hard nano- Microstructural Features of Current Resin
silica particles which were presented in the surface Composite Materials. Curr Oral Health Rep.
of FS-N. 2014;1:205-212.
4. Canché-Escamilla G, Duarte-Aranda S, Toled-
Conclusions ano M. Synthesis and characterization of hybrid
silica/PMMA nanoparticles and their use as
The effect of fumed silica particles as a filler on filler in dental composites. Mater Sci Eng.
mechanical properties of dental resin composite 2014; 42:161-167.
composed of Bis-GMA/TEGDMA was studied. 5. Karabela M, Sideridou I. Synthesis and study
• Maximum amount of 12 wt% fumed silica of properties of dental resin composites with
relative to resin matrix composed of Bis-GMA/ different nanosilica particles size. Dent Mater.
TEGDMA (50:50) could be mixed manually 2011;27:825-835.
into the matrix. Increment of Bis-GMA content 6. Albuquerque P, Bertolo M, Cavalcante L, et
improved the flexural strength significantly, but al. Degree of conversion, depth of cure, and
workability of the paste was not applicable. color stability of experimental dental composite
• Silanization of the particles enhanced the formulated with camphorquinone and
capacity of the composite to accept more phenanthrenequinone photoinitiators. J Esthet