Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Working Capital
Management
To Thi Thanh Truc
Faculty of Finance and Banking
University of Economics and Law
1-1
Learning outcomes
After finishing this chapter you should be able to:
Understand the operating cycle and the cash conversion
cycle.
Explain how different amounts of current assets and
current liabilities affect firms’ profitability and thus their
stock prices.
Discuss how the cash budget is constructed, and how
each is used in working capital management.
1-2
Learning outcomes
After finishing this chapter you should be able to:
Explain how companies decide on the proper amount of
each current asset—cash, marketable securities, accounts
receivable, and inventory.
Discuss how companies set their credit policies and
explain the effect of credit policy on sales and profits.
Describe how the costs of trade credit, bank loans, and
commercial paper are determined and how that
information impacts decisions for financing working
capital.
Explain how companies use security to lower their costs
of short-term credit.
1-3
Materials
Handout
Brigham & Houston, Fundamentals of financial
management, chapter 16.
Brealey, Myers, Marcus, Fundamentals of Corporate finance,
Section 2, page 165.
Jim DeMello, 2006, Cases in Finance, Mc Graw- Hill (Case
19, 20)
1-4
Outline
1-5
Working Capital Definitions
1-6
Working capital definition
Raw materials
Receivables inventory
Finished goods
inventory
1-9
Why firms have to invest in
working capital?
It take a period of time for firms to eventually
collect the cash that they have paid for their
materials.
1-10
Why firms have to invest in
working capital?
1-11
Why firms have to invest in
working capital?
The longer the production process, the more cash
the firm must keep tied up in inventories.
Similarly, the longer it takes customers to pay
their bills, the higher the value of accounts
receivable.
On the other hand, if a firm can delay paying for
its own materials, it may reduce the amount of
cash it needs. In other words, accounts payable
reduce net operating working capital.
1-12
Working Capital and Cash
conversion cycle
customers.
This process is called operating cycle.
1-13
Working Capital and Cash
Conversion Cycle
Inventory Cash
sold received
Inventory
purchased
Operating cycle
1-15
Cash conversion Cycle
Cash conversion cycle: The length of time between
when a company makes payments to its creditors and
when a company receives payments from its
customers.
Cash conversion cycle is the difference between the
operating cycle and the payables deferral period.
Payable deferral period: time between purchase of
inventory and payment for the inventory
1-17
Example Information
Inventory:
Beginning = 200,000
Ending = 300,000
Accounts Receivable:
Beginning = 160,000
Ending = 200,000
Accounts Payable:
Beginning = 75,000
Ending = 100,000
1-18
Example – Operating Cycle
Inventory conversion period
Average inventory = (200,000+300,000)/2 = 250,000
1-22
Working capital Policy
1-23
Current assets investment policies
Relaxed investment policy: the firm holds
relatively large amounts of cash, marketable
securities, receivables and inventories relative
to its sales
Restricted investment policy: holdings of
current assets are minimized.
Moderate investment policy lies between the
two extremes
1-24
Costs of holding current assets
Carrying costs: opportunity cost of capital invested in
current assets. Carrying costs encourage firms to hold
current assets to a minimum. The smaller the amount
of current assets the higher the expected return on
investment.
Shortage costs: too low a level of current assets
makes it more likely that the firm will face shortage
costs. This policy also exposes the firm to risks
because shortages can lead to work stoppages,
unhappy customers, and serious long-run problems
1-25
Costs and benefits of Investment
Policies
A restricted policy results in a high ROE. However,
this policy also exposes the firm to risks.
The relaxed policy minimizes such operating
problems, but it results in a low turnover,
which in turn lowers ROE.
The moderate policy falls between the two
extremes.
1-26
An important job of the financial manager is
to strike a balance between the costs and
benefits of current assets, that is, to find the
level of current assets that minimizes the sum
of carrying costs and shortage costs.
1-27
Selected ratios for SKI Inc.
SKI Ind Avg
Current ratio 1.75x 2.25x
Debt/Assets 58.76% 50.00%
Turnover of cash & securities 16.67x 22.22x
Days sales outstanding 45.63 32.00
Inventory turnover 4.82x 7.00x
Fixed assets turnover 11.35x 12.00x
Total assets turnover 2.08x 3.00x
Profit margin 2.07% 3.50%
Return on equity 10.45% 21.00%
1-28
How does SKI’s working capital
policy compare with its industry?
Working capital policy is reflected in the
current ratio, turnover of cash and
securities, inventory turnover, and days
sales outstanding.
These ratios indicate SKI has large
amounts of working capital relative to its
level of sales.
SKI is either very conservative or
inefficient.
1-29
Is SKI inefficient or conservative?
A conservative (relaxed) policy may be
appropriate if it leads to greater
profitability.
However, SKI is not as profitable as the
average firm in the industry.
This suggests the company has excessive
working capital.
1-30
Working capital Policy
1-31
Classifications of Working
Capital
Components
1-32
Permanent current assets
The amount of current assets required to
meet a firm’s long-term minimum needs.
DOLLAR AMOUNT
TIME
1-33
Temporary Current assets
The amount of current assets that varies with
seasonal requirements.
TIME
1-34
Working capital financing need
1-36
Working capital financing policies
Moderate (Hedging) – Match the
maturity of the assets with the maturity
of the financing.
Aggressive – Use short-term financing
to finance permanent assets.
Conservative – Use permanent capital
for permanent assets and temporary
assets.
1-37
Moderate policy - Hedging (or
Maturity Matching) Approach
A method of financing where each asset would be offset with a financing
instrument of the same approximate maturity.
$ Temporary NWC.
Fixed Assets
Time
1-41
Risks vs. Costs Trade-Off
(Conservative policy)
Long-Term Financing Benefits
Less worry in refinancing short-term obligations
Less uncertainty regarding future interest costs
Long-Term Financing Risks
Borrowing more than what is necessary
Borrowing at a higher overall cost (usually)
Result
Manager accepts less expected profits in exchange for
taking less risk.
1-42
Aggressive Policy
$ Temporary NWC.
Short term Loans
Permanent NWC
Long term financing:
Stock,
Bond.
Fixed Asset
Time
Firm increases risks associated with short-term borrowing by using
a larger proportion of short-term financing.
1-43
Aggressive Approach
Short-Term Financing Benefits
Financing long-term needs with a lower interest cost
than long-term debt
Borrowing only what is necessary
Short-Term Financing Risks
Refinancing short-term obligations in the future
Uncertain future interest costs
Result
Manager accepts greater expected profits in exchange
for taking greater risk.
1-44
Summary of Short- vs. Long-
Term Financing
Financing
Maturity
SHORT-TERM LONG-TERM
Asset
Maturity
High
LONG-TERM Moderate
Risk-Profitability
(Permanent) Risk-Profitability
1-45
Financing policy example: ABC
Inc.
Peak Bottom Peak Bottom
Cash $ 100 $ 60 Accounts Payable $ 60 $ 20
Marketable securities 0 40 Note Payables 100 0
Accounts Receivable 80 40 Long-term Debt 600 600
Inventory 200 100 Common Equity 620 620
Net fixed assets 1,000 1,000 Total $1,380 $1,240
Total $1,380 $1240
1-46
Working capital policy and
firm’s value
Risk/ Return Tradeoff
Investment E(ROIC)
decision s
Level of current Financial Vs ROIC
assets Distress
Risk
Working Firm
capital Value
policy
Financing Risk/Return Tradeoff
Decisions
S-T Vs L-T Excess Uncertain
Debt Debt L-T Vs S-T
Financing Financing
1-47
The cash budget
1-48
Cash budget
Forecasts cash inflows, outflows, and ending
cash balances.
Used to plan loans needed or funds available to
invest.
Allows a company to plan ahead and begin the
search for financing before the money is
actually needed
Can be daily, weekly, or monthly, forecasts.
Monthly for annual planning and daily for
actual cash management.
1-49
Example: Cash Budget
Information
Pet Treats Inc. specializes in gourmet pet treats and receives all income
from sales
Sales estimates (in millions)
Q1 = 500; Q2 = 600; Q3 = 650; Q4 = 800; Q1 next year = 550
Accounts receivable
Beginning receivables = $250
Average collection period = 30 days
Accounts payable
Purchases = 50% of next quarter’s sales
Beginning payables = 125
Accounts payable period is 45 days
Other expenses
Wages, taxes, and other expense are 30% of sales
Interest and dividend payments are $50
A major capital expenditure of $200 is expected in the second
quarter
The initial cash balance is $80 and the company maintains a minimum
balance of $50 1-50
Example: Cash Budget – Cash
Collections
ACP = 30 days, this implies that 2/3 of sales are
collected in the quarter made and the remaining 1/3
are collected the following quarter
Beginning receivables of $250 will be collected in the
first quarter
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Beginning Receivables 250 167 200 217
Sales 500 600 650 800
Cash Collections 583 567 633 750
Ending Receivables 167 200 217 267
1-51
Example: Cash Budget – Cash Disbursements
1-52
Example: Cash Budget – Net Cash
Flow and Cash Balance
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Total cash collections 583 567 633 750
Total cash disbursements 475 743 607 628
Net cash inflow 108 -176 26 122
Beginning Cash Balance 80 188 12 38
Net cash inflow 108 -176 26 122
Ending cash balance 188 12 38 160
Minimum cash balance -50 -50 -50 -50
Cumulative surplus (deficit) 138 -38 -12 110
1-53
SKI’s cash budget:
For January and February
Net Cash Inflows
Jan Feb
Collections $67,651.95 $62,755.40
Purchases 44,603.75 36,472.65
Wages 6,690.56 5,470.90
Rent 2,500.00 2,500.00
Total payments $53,794.31 $44,443.55
Net CF $13,857.64 $18,311.85
1-54
SKI’s cash budget (con’t)
Net Cash Inflows
Jan Feb
Cash at start if
no borrowing $ 3,000.00 $16,857.64
Net CF 13,857.64 18,311.85
Cumulative cash 16,857.64 35,169.49
Less: target cash 1,500.00 1,500.00
Surplus $15,357.64 $33,669.49
1-55
How could bad debts be
worked into the cash budget?
Collections would be reduced by the
amount of the bad debt losses.
For example, if the firm had 3% bad
debt losses, collections would total
only 97% of sales.
Lower collections would lead to
higher borrowing requirements.
1-56
Analyze SKI’s forecasted cash budget
Cash holdings will exceed the target
balance for each month, except for
October and November.
Cash budget indicates the company is
holding too much cash.
SKI could improve its EVA by either
investing cash in more productive assets,
or by returning cash to its shareholders.
1-57
Why might SKI want to maintain a
relatively high amount of cash?
If sales turn out to be considerably less than
expected, SKI could face a cash shortfall.
A company may choose to hold large
amounts of cash if it does not have much
faith in its sales forecast, or if it is very
conservative.
The cash may be used, in part, to fund future
investments.
1-58
Current assets
management
1-59
Cash management
1-60
Reasons for Holding Cash
1. Transactions – must have some cash to
operate.
2. Precaution – “safety stock”. Reduced by
line of credit and marketable securities.
3. Compensating balances – for loans and/or
services provided.
4. Speculation – to take advantage of
bargains and to take discounts. Reduced
by credit lines and marketable securities.
1-61
The goal of cash management
To meet the above objectives, especially to
have cash for transactions, yet not have
any excess cash.
To minimize transactions balances in
particular, and also needs for cash to meet
other objectives.
Trade-off between opportunity cost of
holding cash relative to the transaction
cost of converting marketable securities to
cash for transactions
1-62
Setting the Target Cash
Balance
Theoretical models such as the Baumol model
have been developed for use in setting target
cash balances. The Baumol model is similar to
the EOQ model, which will be discussed later.
Today, companies strive for zero cash balances
and use borrowings or marketable securities as
a reserve.
Monte Carlo simulation can be helpful in setting
the target cash balance.
1-63
Minimizing cash holdings
Insist on wire transfers from customers
Synchronize inflows and outflows
Use a remote disbursement account
Reduce need for “safety stock” of cash
Increase forecast accuracy
Hold marketable securities
Negotiate a line of credit
1-64
Investing Cash
Money market – financial instruments with an original
maturity of one year or less
Temporary Cash Surpluses
Seasonal or cyclical activities – buy marketable securities
1-65
Characteristics of Short-Term
Securities
Maturity – firms often limit the maturity of short-term
investments to 90 days to avoid loss of principal due to
changing interest rates
Default risk – avoid investing in marketable securities
with significant default risk
Marketability – ease of converting to cash
Taxability – consider different tax characteristics when
making a decision
1-66
Receivables Management
1-67
Elements of credit policy
1. Credit Standards: The minimum quality of credit
worthiness of a credit applicant that is acceptable to
the firm.
2. Credit Period – How long to pay? The total length of
time over which credit is extended to a customer to
pay a bill. For example, “net 30” requires full
payment to the firm within 30 days from the invoice
date.
3. Cash Discounts – Lowers price. A percent (%)
reduction in sales or purchase price allowed for early
payment of invoices. For example, “2/10” allows the
customer to take a 2% cash discount during the
cash discount period.
4. Collection Policy – How tough?
1-68
How does the credit policy
have affect on receivables?
Quality of Length of
Trade Account Credit Period
(1) Average
Collection Period
(2) Bad-debt
Losses
Firm
Possible Cash Collection
Discount Program
1-69
How does the credit policy
affect receivables
1. Credit Standards:– Tighter standards tend to
reduce sales, but reduce bad debt expense.
Fewer bad debts reduce days sales outstanding
(DSO).
2. Credit Period – The longer the credit period, the
longer the days sales outstanding.
3. Cash Discounts – Lowers price. Attracts new
customers and reduces DSO.
4. Collection Policy – How tough? Tougher policy
will reduce DSO but may damage customer
relationships.
1-70
Costs arising from relaxing credit policy
1-71
Example of Relaxing Credit
Standards
Basket Wonders is not operating at full capacity
and wants to determine if a relaxation of
their credit standards will enhance
profitability.
1-73
Example of Relaxing
Credit Standards
Profitability of ($5 contribution) x (4,800 units) =
additional sales $24,000
1-76
Example of Relaxing the
Credit Period
Profitability of ($5 contribution)x(10,000 units) =
additional sales $50,000
1-77
Example of Relaxing the
Credit Period
New ($2,000,000 sales) / (6 Turns) =
receivable level $333,333
Shortage costs
Lost sales due to a restrictive credit policy
1-80
Sources of Information
The company must weigh the amount of
information needed versus the time and
expense required.
Financial statements
Credit ratings and reports
Bank checking
Trade checking
Company’s own experience
1-81
Credit Analysis
A credit analyst is likely to utilize
information regarding:
1-82
Five Cs of Credit
Character – willingness to meet financial
obligations
Capacity – ability to meet financial obligations
out of operating cash flows
Capital – financial reserves
Collateral – assets pledged as security
Conditions – general economic conditions related
to customer’s business
1-83
Credit – Scoring System
1-84
Collection Policy
Monitoring receivables
Keep an eye on average collection period relative
to your credit terms
Use an aging schedule to determine percentage of
payments that are being made late
Collection policy
Delinquency letter
Telephone call
Collection agency
Legal action
1-85
Inventory Management
1-86
Inventory Management
Inventory can be a large percentage of a firm’s
assets
There can be significant costs associated with
carrying too much inventory
There can also be significant costs associated
with not carrying enough inventory
Inventory management tries to find the optimal
trade-off between carrying too much inventory
versus not enough
1-87
Types of Inventory
Manufacturing firm
Raw material – starting point in production process
Work-in-progress
1-88
Inventory costs
Types of inventory costs
Carrying costs – storage and handling costs,
insurance, property taxes, depreciation, and
obsolescence.
Ordering costs – cost of placing orders, shipping,
and handling costs.
Costs of running short – loss of sales or
customer goodwill, and the disruption of
production schedules.
Reducing inventory levels generally reduces
carrying costs, increases ordering costs, and
may increase the costs of running short.
1-89
Short term financing
1-90
Short-Term Financing
Spontaneous Financing
Negotiated Financing
Factoring Accounts Receivable
1-91
Spontaneous Financing
1-92
Spontaneous Financing
Types of spontaneous
financing
Accounts Payable (Trade Credit from
Suppliers)
Accrued Expenses
1-93
Trade Credit as a Means
of Financing
What happens to accounts payable if a
firm purchases $1,000/day at “net 30”?
$1,000 x 30 days = $30,000 account balance
What happens to accounts payable if a
firm purchases $1,500/day at “net 30”?
$1,500 x 30 days = $45,000 account balance
A $15,000 increase from operations!
1-94
Cost to Forgo a Discount
What is the approximate annual cost to
forgo the cash discount of “2/10, net
30” after the first ten days?
Approximate annual interest cost =
% discount 365 days
X
(100% - % discount) (payment date -
discount period)
1-95
Cost to Forgo a Discount
What is the approximate annual cost to forgo
the cash discount of “2/10, net 30,” and pay
at the end of the credit period?
1-99
Negotiated Financing
1-100
Negotiated Financing
Types of negotiated financing:
1-101
“Stand-Alone” Commercial
Paper
Commercial Paper -- Short-term, unsecured
promissory notes, generally issued by large
corporations (unsecured corporate IOUs).
Commercial paper market is composed of the
(1) dealer and (2) direct-placement markets.
Advantage: Cheaper than a short-term business
loan from a commercial bank.
Dealers require a line of credit to ensure that
the commercial paper is paid off.
1-102
“Bank-Supported”
Commercial Paper
A bank provides a letter of credit, for a fee,
guaranteeing the investor that the company’s
obligation will be paid.
Letter of credit (L/C) -- A promise from a
cost funds.
1-103
Bankers’ Acceptances
1-105
Unsecured Loans
Line of Credit (with a bank) -- An informal
arrangement between a bank and its customer
specifying the maximum amount of unsecured
credit the bank will permit the firm to owe at any
one time.
One-year limit that is reviewed prior to renewal to
determine if conditions necessitate a change.
Credit line is based on the bank’s assessment of the
creditworthiness and credit needs of the firm.
“Cleanup” provision requires the firm to owe the
bank nothing for a period of time.
1-106
Unsecured Loans
Revolving Credit Agreement -- A formal, legal
commitment to extend credit up to some
maximum amount over a stated period of time.
Firm receives revolving credit by paying a
commitment fee on any unused portion of the
maximum amount of credit.
Commitment fee -- A fee charged by the lender for
agreeing to hold credit available.
Agreements frequently extend beyond 1 year.
1-107
Unsecured Loans
Transaction Loan -- A loan agreement that
meets the short-term funds needs of the
firm for a single, specific purpose.
Each request is handled as a separate transaction
by the bank, and project loan determination is
based on the cash-flow ability of the borrower.
The loan is paid off at the completion of the
project by the firm from resulting cash flows.
1-108
Cost of Borrowing
Interest Rates
Prime Rate -- Short-term interest rate
charged by banks to large, creditworthy
customers.
Differential from prime depends on:
Cash balances
1-109
Cost of Borrowing
Computing Interest Rates
Collect Basis -- interest is paid at maturity of the
note.
Example: $100,000 loan at 10%
stated interest rate for 1 year.
$10,000 in interest
= 10.00%
$100,000 in usable funds
1-110
Cost of Borrowing
Computing Interest Rates
Discount Basis -- interest is deducted from
the initial loan.
Example: $100,000 loan at 10%
stated interest rate for 1 year.
$10,000 in interest
= 11.11%
$90,000 in usable funds
1-111
Cost of Borrowing
Compensating Balances
Non-interest-bearing demand deposits maintained by
a firm to compensate a bank for services provided,
credit lines, or loans.
Example: $1,000,000 loan at 10% stated interest rate for
1 year with a required $150,000 compensating balance.
$100,000 in interest
= 11.76%
$850,000 in usable funds
1-112
Example: Compensating
Balance
We have a $500,000 line of credit with a 15%
compensating balance requirement. The
quoted interest rate is 9%. We need to borrow
$150,000 for inventory for one year.
How much do we need to borrow?
150,000/(1-.15) = 176,471
What interest rate are we effectively paying?
Interest paid = 176,471(.09) = 15,882
Effective rate = 15,882/150,000 = .1059 or 10.59%
1-113
Cost of Borrowing
Commitment Fees
The fee charged by the lender for agreeing to hold
credit available is on the unused portions of credit.
Example: $1 million revolving credit at 10% stated
interest rate for 1 year; borrowing for the year was
$600,000; a required 5% compensating balance on
borrowed funds; and a .5% commitment fee on
$400,000 of unused credit.
What is the cost of borrowing?
1-114
Cost of Borrowing
Interest: ($600,000) x (10%) = $ 60,000
Commitment Fee: ($400,000) x (0.5%) = $ 2,000
Compensating
Balance: ($600,000) x (5%) = $ 30,000
$60,000 in interest +
$2,000 in commitment fees
= 10.88%
$570,000 in usable funds
1-115
Cost of Borrowing - example
The firm can borrow $100,000 for 1
year at an 8% nominal rate.
Interest may be set under one of the
following scenarios:
Simple annual interest
Installment loan, add-on, 12 months
1-116
Simple annual interest
“Simple interest” means no discount or
add-on.
1-117
Add-on interest
Interest = 0.08 ($100,000) = $8,000
Face amount = $100,000 + $8,000 = $108,000
Monthly payment = $108,000/12 = $9,000
Avg loan outstanding = $100,000/2 = $50,000
Approximate cost = $8,000/$50,000 = 16.0%
To find the appropriate effective rate, recognize
that the firm receives $100,000 and must make
monthly payments of $9,000 (like an annuity).
1-118
Add-on interest
From the calculator output below, we have:
rNOM = 12 (0.012043)
= 0.1445 = 14.45%
INPUTS 12 100 -9 0
N I/YR PV PMT FV
OUTPUT 1.2043
1-119
Secured
(or Asset-Based) Loans
Security (collateral) -- Asset (s) pledged by a
borrower to ensure repayment of a loan. If
the borrower defaults, the lender may sell the
security to pay off the loan.
Collateral value depends on:
Marketability
Life
Riskiness
1-120
Accounts-Receivable-
Backed Loans
One of the most liquid asset accounts.
Loans by commercial banks or finance
companies (banks offer lower interest rates).
Loan evaluations are made on:
Quality: not all individual accounts have to be
accepted (may reject on aging).
Size: small accounts may be rejected as
being too costly (per dollar of loan) to handle
by the institution. 1-121
Accounts-Receivable-
Backed Loans
Types of receivable loan arrangements:
Nonnotification -- firm customers are not
notified that their accounts have been pledged
to the lender. The firm forwards all payments
from pledged accounts to the lender.
1-124
Types of
Inventory-Backed Loans
Trust Receipt -- A security device
acknowledging that the borrower holds
specifically identified inventory and
proceeds from its sale in trust for the
lender.
Terminal Warehouse Receipt -- A receipt
for the deposit of goods in a public
warehouse that a lender holds as
collateral for a loan.
1-125
Types of
Inventory-Backed Loans
Field Warehouse Receipt -- A receipt
for goods segregated and stored on
the borrower’s premises (but under
the control of an independent
warehousing company) that a lender
holds as collateral for a loan.
1-126
Factoring Account
Receivables
1-127
Factoring
Accounts Receivable
Factoring -- The selling of receivables to a financial
institution, the factor, usually “without
recourse.”
Factor is often a subsidiary of a bank holding
company.
Factor maintains a credit department and performs
credit checks on accounts.
Allows firm to eliminate their credit department and
the associated costs.
Contracts are usually for 1 year, but are renewable.
1-128
Factoring
Accounts Receivable
Factoring Costs
Factor receives a commission on the face value of the
receivables.
Cash payment is usually made on the actual or average
due date of the receivables.
If the factor advances money to the firm, then the firm
must pay interest on the advance.
Total cost of factoring is composed of a factoring fee
plus an interest charge on any cash advance.
Although expensive, it provides the firm with substantial
flexibility.
1-129
Example: Factoring
Last year your company had average accounts
receivable of $2 million. Credit sales were $24
million. You factor receivables by discounting
them 2%. What is the effective rate of
interest?
Receivables turnover = 24/2 = 12 times
EAR = (1+.02/.98)
12 – 1 = .2743 or 27.43%
1-130