Professional Documents
Culture Documents
, 2016.
Original Russian Text © E.V. Ovchinnikova, L.A. Isupova, I.G. Danilova, V.V. Danilevich, B.A. Chumachenko, 2016, published in Zhurnal Prikladnoi Khimii,
2016, Vol. 89, No. 5, pp. 545í552.
INORGANIC SYNTHESIS AND INDUSTRIAL
INORGANIC CHEMISTRY
Abstract—Possibility of using products formed in centrifugal thermal activation of hydrargillite to obtain alumina
catalysts washed to remove admixtures of alkali metals was considered. A comparison of the physicochemical and
catalytic properties of the samples demonstrated that washing with water is more favorable than that with nitric
acid; the catalytic activity and acid-base properties of the catalyst surface are determined not only by the content
of Na, but also by the whole set of catalyst preparation conditions. The most active of the samples obtained in the
study has acidity close to that of industrial aluminum oxide produced by the reprecipitation method, but surpasses
it in activity: at 370°C, the total yield of ethylene and diethyl ether reaches a value of 88.8 mol %, which is 4%
higher than that for the reference sample.
DOI: 10.1134/S1070427216050013
Despite the endothermic effect, the dehydration of active centers [7, 9, 10], and effect of the AO morphology
ethanol to ethylene readily occurs on acid catalysts at on the activity and apparent activation energy [3, 11].
elevated temperatures, owing to which it is widely used as It has been found that the activity of AOs in the
a model reaction. Industrially, this reaction is performed dehydration of ethanol is mostly determined by the
on alumina catalysts or those containing aluminum oxides optimal combination of surface Brɲnsted and Lewis
(AOs) in reactors of different types, including those of acid centers (LACs) [6]. Admixtures of Na in samples
tubular design [1]. are a kind of a catalytic poison because of changing the
At present, the interest in studying the properties of surface properties and the morphology of AOs [4]. It has
aluminum oxides in dehydration of ethanol to ethylene been shown that the activity and selectivity of AOs in the
has noticeably increased [2–12]. This is due in no small dehydration of ethanol to ethylene is favored by a high
part to two main factors: (i) intensive development of low- concentration of weak and medium-strength acid centers,
tonnage technologies for obtaining polyethylene-based which is observed in samples with the lowest content
composites [13], which require shops for low-tonnage of Na [7, 14, 15]. Therefore, AOs with the minimum
production of ethylene, unattached to sources of petro- content of sodium, produced by reprecipitation and
chemical raw materials; and also (ii) high activity and hydrolysis of alcoholates, are commonly accepted as the
stability of AOs in operation in a high-concentration reac- most active in the catalytic synthesis of ethylene from
tion mixture [1, 6, 8], which is promising as regards their ethanol [2, 6–8, 12]. However, the production of AOs
practical application. It has been shown that temperature by these techniques necessarily involves utilization of a
strongly affects the pathways of ethylene synthesis both large amount of wastewater or use of expensive reagents,
directly from ethanol and via intermediate formation of which makes larger the number of technological stages
diethyl ether [3, 8]. The following issues are under discus- in catalyst preparation and raises the production cost of
sion: mechanisms of ethylene formation [3, 9], nature of the manufactured products.
683
684 OVCHINNIKOVA et al.
Table 1. Preparation conditions and texture characteristics of AOs prepared by the CTA HG technique
Preparation
Sample no. Ssp, m2 g–1 Vpor, cm3 g–1 D, Å4
washing peptization
1 H2O HCl 311 0.35 45
2 H2O HNO3 208 0.35 67
3 HNO3 HCl 255 0.32 50
4 HNO3 HNO3 256 0.31 48
reduces the content of pseudoboehmite in the moldable insignificantly because the IR spectra in the range of
hydroxide (which is related to the content of Ȗ-Al2O3 stretching vibrations of OH groups are close. The acid
in catalysts), or hinders formation of the Ȗ-Al2O3 phase properties of the least active sample no. 1 were not studied.
in thermal treatment of the modified catalysts due to the It was shown that modification leads to an increase in the
higher removal temperature of Cl– anions. acid strength of bridge Al–O(H)–Al groups, compared
The content of Na and K in the finished catalysts with similar groups of the unmodified Al2O3 whose IR
(sample nos. 1–4) strongly decreased, compared with the spectrum shows, upon low-temperature adsorption of CO,
starting (unwashed) product formed in hydration of CTA a shift of the absorption bands of bridge hydroxy groups
HG (1400 ppm of Na and 200 ppm of K), and, irrespective to lower frequencies (ǻȞO–H…CO) by 130–140 cm–1 [22].
of the electrolyte used for washing and(or) peptization, In the case of CO adsorption on sample no. 2, the shift is
was the same: 200 ppm of Na and 20 ppm of K. ǻȞO–H…CO = 160–170 cm–1, whereas for sample nos. 3–5,
The main product of ethanol dehydration at tempera- an insignificant amount of more acid bridge OH groups is
tures of 370–400°C and contact duration of 0.28 s was additionally observed (ǻȞO–H…CO = 190–200 cm–1). The
ethylene (ETEN) for all the catalysts, with other products later is apparently due to the presence on the surface of
also observed in the course of the reaction: diethyl ether residual NO3– and Cl– ions, which may indicate that the
(DEE), acetaldehyde (AA), and butylene (C4). Under the acidity of hydroxy groups in the catalysts increases upon
reaction conditions, sample nos. 1–4 were characterized their modification with the acids. The concentrations of
by ethanol conversions X of 74 to 93% and yields of valu- isolated terminal OH groups exhibiting basic properties
able products, ȈY, of 72 to 89 mol %. The highest activity are close on the surface of most of the samples: a decrease
among the samples tested in the study was observed for in the concentration of Al–OH groups is observed for
sample no. 2, washed and peptized with HNO3, ad the sample no. 3 (peptized with HCl), presumably because
lowest, for sample no. 1, washed with water and peptized of the interaction with residual Cl– ions.
with HCl (Table 2). At the same time, the samples strongly differ in the
A study of the hydroxy surface cover of sample concentration of LACs. According to low-temperature
nos. 2, 4, and 5 demonstrated that the concentrations of CO adsorption data, LACs of varied strength are present
OH bridge groups exhibiting weak acid properties differ on the surface of all the samples: super-strong (ȞCO =
DEE
under study, produced by the CTA method, sample no. 2
has acid surface properties close to those of the reference
(sample no. 5). The data obtained indicate that the num-
AA, C4
ber of LACs is not directly dependent on the content of
alkaline ions, contrary to that observed in [7].
Ethylene is formed in the catalytic dehydration of
ethanol on alumina catalysts by the parallel-consecutive
X, %
scheme both directly from ethanol and via intermediate
Fig. 1. Correlation between the selectivities S with respect to
formation of DEE [8]. At high conversions, the formation ethanol dehydration products and the conversion X of ethanol
of ethylene by the consecutive pathway from DEE can for AOs produced by the CTA HG technique. Experimental
be observed. Figure 1 presents the data obtained for the conditions: T = 370°C (crossed symbols), T = 400°C (full
activity of the samples at temperatures of 370 and 400°C symbols), IJ = 0.28 s, ethanol concentration 73.8 mol %. The
in the form of dependences of the selectivity with respect sample numbering corresponds to that in Table 1.
to the products on the conversion of ethanol. Larger
values of the selectivity toward DEE are observed for The highest activity among the catalysts prepared
all the samples at lowered X, whereas with increasing X, by the CTA HG method is exhibited by sample no. 2
the selectivity with respect to DEE decreases due to its (Table 3) having the lowest total concentration of LACs,
consumption for ethylene formation, with the selectivity whereas sample no. 3 having a higher total concentration
toward ethylene accordingly becoming higher. An of LACs shows a lower activity. At the same time, sample
additional evidence in favor of the ethylene formation no. 4 also characterized by high concentration of LACs,
by the consecutive pathway is the invariable sum of the similarly to sample no. 3, demonstrated higher conversion
selectivities toward the useful products, ȈS = (97.1 ± and yield of valuable products, and, therefore, the effect
1.7) mol %. In this case, the value of ȈS at 400°C is, on of the concentration and strength of LACs on the activity
average, 1% lower than that at 370°C due to the formation and selectivity of the catalysts invites an additional study.
of by-products (Fig. 1). It is noteworthy that the electrolytes used for peptization
The selectivities with respect to the by-products AA (HCl or HNO3, Table 1) more strongly affect the yield of
and C4, observed in the conditions of a concentrated useful reaction products, ȈY (Table 2), than the washing
mixture and high conversions, were, on average, 1.5 and solutions. Nevertheless, it can be seen that use of H2O
2.2 mol %, respectively, for the samples tested in the for washing is more favorable, compared with HNO3,
study. An exception is presented by sample nos. 1 and 2, despite the same content of admixtures of alkali metals
which have at 400°C somewhat increased selectivities in sample nos. 1–4.
toward AA and C4, respectively (Fig. 1). The activity of the catalyst samples decreased to varied
Thus, taking into account that ȈS varies only slightly extent on changing the reaction temperature from 400
with X for different samples, we chose as an indication to 370°C (Table 2). The process of ethanol dehydration
of activity for comparing the catalytic properties of the on an alumina catalyst in a tubular reactor is accompa-
AOs tested in the study the total yield of useful products, nied by a decrease in temperature along the tube, with
ȈY (Table 2). a characteristic extremum, minimal temperature. For
Table 3. Acid properties of AOs prepared by the CTA HG technique (sample nos. 2–4) and industrial AO produced by the
reprecipitation method (sample no. 5)
Concentration of LACs, ȝmol g–1
Sample no.
super-strong strong weak and medium-strength
2 3 20 876
3 8 28 1100
4 4 22 1042
5 6 15 815
example, at a heat-carrier temperature of 390–450°C Thus, the acid-modified alumina catalyst (sample
in the intertubular space, the minimum temperature in no. 2) produced by the CTA HG technique exceeds in
the catalyst base in the tube may be 330–385°C [8]. activity in the reaction of ethanol dehydration to ethylene
Consequently, an important characteristic of a catalyst the industrial samples: AOK-63-22 catalyst formed by
for the endothermic reaction of ethanol dehydration is a similar thermal activation method and IK-VGO-01
its activity at low temperatures. Let us compare sample catalyst support formed by the reprecipitation technique.
no. 2, the most active acid-modified AO produced in the It can be assumed that this catalyst is promising for
study by the CTA HG method, with industrial AO samples practical application.
produced by reprecipitation (sample no. 5, support for It should be noted that, of the two samples, no. 2
IK-VGO-01 catalyst) and thermal activation (sample (200 ppm of Na and 20 ppm of K) and no. 5 (80 ppm of Na
no. 6, AOK-63-22, Special Design-Technology Bureau and <20 ppm of K) having close acid properties (Table 3),
SKTB Katalizator AO [2]). The activity of sample nos. but different contents of alkali metal admixtures, a higher
2, 5, and 6 characterized by comparable ȈY at the high activity at the low temperature was exhibited by the
temperature, noticeably changes at the low temperature: sample with higher content of Na. This fact gives reason
at 370°C ȈY decreases in the following order: sample to conclude that the catalytic activity and the acid-base
no. 2 > no. 5 > no. 6 (Fig. 2). properties of the catalysts are affected not only by the
content of sodium, but also by the whole set of catalyst
ȈY, mol % ȈY, mol % preparation conditions. Presumably, the whole set of these
conditions can determine the defect nature of the oxide
surface [4], which requires further analysis.
CONCLUSIONS
determined not only by the content of sodium, but also et al., Chem. Eng. J., 2011, vol. 176–177, pp. 188–194.
by the whole set of catalyst preparation conditions, which 9. Phung, T.K. and Busca, G., Catal. Commun., 2015, vol. 68,
presumably predetermine the defect nature of the oxide pp. 110–115.
surface. 10. Hu, J.Z., Xu, S., Kwak, J.H., et al., J. Catal., 2016, vol. 336,
(3) It was shown that the thermal activation technique pp. 85–93.
yields catalysts with higher activity at low temperatures, 11. Lee, J., Jeon, H., Oh, D.G., et al., Appl. Catal. A, 2015,
compared with catalysts produced by the reprecipitation vol. 500, pp. 58–68.
method. 12. Garbarino, G., Travi, I., Pani, M., et al., Catal. Commun.,
2015, vol. 70, pp. 77–81.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 13. Queiroz, A.U.B. and Collares-Queiroz, F.P., Polym. Rev.,
2009, vol. 49(2), pp. 65–78.
The study was supported by the Ministry of Education 14. Ross, R.A. and Bennett, D.E.R., J. Catal., 1967, vol. 8,
and Science of the Russian Federation, unique project pp. 289–292.
identifier RFMEFI60714X0046.
15. Narayanan, C.R., Srinivasan S., Datye, A.K., et al.,
J. Catal., 1992, vol. 138, pp. 659–674.
REFERENCES
16. Pinakov, V.I., Stoyanovsky, O.I., Tanashev, Yu.Yu., et al.,
Chem. Eng. J., 2005, vol. 107, pp. 157–161.
1. Yakovleva, I.S., Banzaraktsaeva, S.P., Ovchinnikova, E.V.,
et al., Catal. Ind., 2016, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 152–167. 17. Danilevich, V.V., Lakhmostov, V.S., Zakharov, V.P., et al.,
2. Chumachenko, V.A. and Ovchinnikova, E.V., Catal. Ind., Kataliz Prom–sti, 2016, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 13–28.
2016, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 134–138. 18. Isupova, L.A., Tanashev, Yu.Yu., Kharina, I.V., et al., Chem.
3. Phung, T.K. and Busca, G., Chem. Eng. J., 2015, vol. 272, Eng. J., 2005, vol. 107(1–3), pp. 163–169.
pp. 92–101. 19. RF Patent 2 438 775 (publ. 2012).
4. Phung, T.K., Herrera, C., Larrubia M A., Garcia- 20. Chesnokov, V.V., Paukshtis, E.A., Buyanov, R.A., et al.,
Dieguez, M., et al., Appl. Catal. A, 2014, vol. 483, Kinet. Catal., 1987, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 566–570.
pp. 41–51. 21. Prokudina, N.A, Chesnokov, V.V., Paukshtis, E.A., and
5. Phung, T.K., Lagazzo, A, Crespo, M.Ȼ.R., et al., J. Catal., Buyanov, R.A., Kinet. Catal., vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 835–839.
2014, vol. 311, pp. 102–113. 22. Paukshtis, E.A., IK spektroskopiya v geterogennom
6. Ivanova, A.S., Kinet. Catal., 2012, vol. 53, no. 4, pp. 425– kislotno–osnovnom katalize (IR Spectroscopy in
439. Heterogeneous Acid-Base Catalysis), Novosibirsk: Nauka,
7. Zotov, R.A., Molchanov, V.V., Volodin, A.M., and 1992.
Bedilo, A.F., J. Catal., 2011, vol. 278, pp. 71–77. 23. Soltanov, R.I., Paukshtis, E.A., and Yurchenko, E.N., Kinet.
8. Kagyrmanova, A.P., Chumachenko, V.A., Korotkikh, V.N., Catal., 1982, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 135–141.