Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(9 Out of 10) Assignment On Supply Chain Management, Group-B
(9 Out of 10) Assignment On Supply Chain Management, Group-B
A supply chain involves a series of steps involved to get a product or service to the customer.
The steps include moving and transforming raw materials into finished products, transporting
those products, and distributing them to the end-user. The entities involved in the supply chain
include producers, vendors, warehouses, transportation companies, distribution centers, and
retailers.
The elements of a supply chain include all the functions that start with receiving an order to
meeting the customer's request. These functions include product development, marketing,
operations, distribution networks, finance, and customer service.
Supply chain management is a very important part of the business process. There are many
different links in this chain that require skill and expertise. When supply chain management is
effective, it can lower a company's overall costs and boost profitability. If one link breaks down,
it can affect the rest of the chain and can be costly.
A typical supply chain begins with the ecological, biological, and political regulation of natural
resources, followed by the human extraction of raw material, and includes several production
links (e.g., component construction, assembly, and merging) before moving on to several layers
of storage facilities of ever-decreasing size and increasingly remote geographical locations, and
finally reaching the consumer. At the end of the supply chain, materials and finished products
only flow there because of customer behavior at the end of the chain; academics Alan Harrison
and Janet Godsell argue that "supply chain processes should be coordinated in order to focus
on end customer buying behavior", and look for "customer responsiveness" as an indicator
confirming that materials are able to flow "through a sequence of supply chain processes in
order to meet end customer buying behavior".
Many of the exchanges encountered in the supply chain take place between different companies
that seek to maximize their revenue within their sphere of interest but may have little or no
knowledge or interest in the remaining players in the supply chain. More recently, the loosely
coupled, self-organizing network of businesses who cooperate to provide product and service
offerings has been called the extended enterprise, and the use of the term "chain" and the linear
structure it appears to represent have been criticized as "harder to relate ... to the way supply
networks really operate. A chain is actually a complex and dynamic supply and demand
network.
As part of their efforts to demonstrate ethical practices, many large companies and
global brands are integrating codes of conduct and guidelines into their corporate
cultures and management systems. Through these, corporations are making demands on
their suppliers (facilities, farms, subcontracted services such as cleaning, canteen, security etc.)
and verifying, through social audits, that they are complying with the required standard. A lack
of transparency in the supply chain can bar consumers from knowledge of where their
purchases originated and facilitate socially irresponsible practices. In 2018, the Loyola
University Chicago's Supply and Value Chain Center found in a survey that 53% of supply
chain professionals considered ethics to be "extremely" important to their organization. Supply-
chain managers are under constant scrutiny to secure the best pricing for their resources, which
becomes a difficult task when faced with the inherent lack of transparency. Cost
benchmarking is one effective method for identifying competitive pricing within the industry.
This gives negotiators a solid basis to form their strategy on and drive overall spend down.
Concept and Understanding the Global Supply Chain Management
practice by this Company
By focusing on maintaining strong relationships with its supply chain partners, Apple can
provide great flexibility in response to demand surges. This, paired with Apple’s large
production capacity, allows them to provide products when and where customers want them.
The company maintains extremely strict standards for its numerous suppliers, which are named
each year in Apple’s Supplier List. The top 200 suppliers in this list make up 98% of the
business’s procurement. Demanding a high-quality service from these partners helps ensure
the final products are reliable and long-lasting.
Because Apple is consistently innovating, its suppliers enjoy a certain degree of stability – even
if one Apple product doesn’t succeed or suffers from setbacks, suppliers can rest assured that
another request, for another product, will likely be coming down the pipeline.
To ensure these suppliers have the skills and experience they need to continue succeeding in
an ever-shifting market, Apple offers educational and upskilling opportunities. More than 3.6
million supplier employees have participated since 2008.
Although the efficacy and efficiency of outsourcing have come into sharper focus in recent
years, Apple provides proof that it can be a sound strategy, the company outsources much of
its manufacturing to China, which has provided them with the revenue needed to launch new
and updated products very quickly over the years.
Tim Cook, Apple’s CEO, is well known for his focus on inventory and the supply chain as a
whole.
It’s no wonder given that retaining a lean, streamlined inventory management system is
especially important in the tech industry, where new items can practically eliminate consumer
interest in older models.
Apple keeps as little inventory as possible, providing them with the agility they need should a
competitor release an innovative new product, thereby decreasing the value of any items in
stock at that moment. Furthermore, having fewer SKUs to keep track of allows for more
accurate forecasting.
Sustainability Focus
Apple has introduced various initiatives throughout the years to improve sustainability across
the supply chain.
The company has also invested heavily in a mix of clean energy technology, such as solar and
wind. Its online Clean Energy Portal allows suppliers across the globe to identify renewable
sources. In 2018, Apple and its suppliers’ clean energy generation equaled approximately the
amount of electricity needed to power more than 600,000 homes in the United States.
Apple ́s key advantages in how it manages its supply chain operations globally:
Apple gain better control over its supply chain by introducing or working with new
suppliers that provide upfront capital in return for growth commitment and a lesser
overall price per unit.
The Company was convinced adequate in its just-in-time supply chain.
Apple’s ability to organize its supply chain on a real-time basis.
Apple’s iPhone supply chain was global, (research and development base in the United
States with 156 suppliers and also assembling operation in China).
Apple was highly incorporated, with centralized R&D and also accounting for the
whole company.
Apple use expensive air-freight for an innovative way to speed up the supply chain.
Apple’s complex supply chain is attributed to the fact that the company has multiple suppliers
located in different parts of the world - primarily in United States, China, Japan and Taiwan.
Apple’s manufacturing facilities are predominantly located in China, where their products are
assembled and shipped in bulk to various parts of the world for sale. Since Apple’s
manufacturing happens overseas in low-cost countries, it has a complex logistical network
because their upstream suppliers are distributed all over the world, the assembly of their
product happens in the Asia Pacific region and their largest downstream consumer base is in
the United States. In the case of product distribution in the United States, this network includes
both intermediary warehouses in collaboration with UPS and FedEx, as well as warehouses in
California that keep final bulk products shipped in from China's production facilities. Because
the majority of Apple's final assembly takes place in Asia Pacific, the company spends a lot of
money on logistics, import/export fees, and warehousing for bulk shipments of products. Apple
distributes its products to end users through three main channels: online sales, in-person Apple
retail shops, and partnerships with retailers such as Amazon, Best Buy, Target, and cell phone
providers such as AT&T, among others. Apple has expanded significantly in size since its
founding by Steve Jobs, staying true to its objective of being a "high-cost, low-supply"
company that delivers innovative products to consumers. As a result, Apple's procurement
department has a particular brand name advantage that boosts its bargaining power during
supplier negotiations. As a response, Apple can purchase the resources it needs for mass
manufacturing of its many product lines at a lower cost and with the most up-to-date
technology.
Here we can take a look at some of the factors that make Apple have such a successful supply
chain,
Suppliers and logistics system
Apple has a massive supply chain, and it has a number of options when it comes to procuring
raw materials. Its top 200 suppliers include component suppliers and others who accounted for
at least 97 percent of its materials, manufacturing, and assembly. A very large number of its
major suppliers are located in Asia in China and Japan. Procurement at Apple is well managed
and a key focus. The brand has managed excellent relationships with its suppliers, however,
also a set of very tight rules. The suppliers must provide the workers with safe working
conditions and products and services as per the standards. All these factors are important to
remaining an Apple supplier. However, Apple is also a major buyer for most of its suppliers
and so it is a mutually beneficial relationship for both sides. Due to its financial strength and
brand reputation, Apple has strong bargaining leverage with its suppliers. It has established
quality criteria for its suppliers to ensure that their goods and services meet the highest quality
requirements. Those who are unable to follow are removed from the supply chain. Apart from
these things Apple has adopted smarter methods to reduce its storage requirements and speed
up the procurement process.
Apple has managed a very large distribution channel consisting of both direct and indirect
channels. From retail stores to online retail and its own branded stores, Apple has managed a
wide range channel for the distribution of its products to the customers. Over time it has focused
on improving its distribution channel and added to its number of brand stores. Apart from these
things the focus has also remained on green packaging and eliminating wastage.
When Steve Jobs returned to Apple in 1997, the company began to improve upon established
concepts. Previously, things were distributed by sea between factories, and the manufacturers
would ensure that the products arrived in perfect condition and on schedule. After sales began
to rise, Apple decided to take to the air and distribute its Macs to clients in a safe manner. When
the iPod was released, the company realized there is a wonderful way to distribute huge
numbers of the product fast and efficiently, therefore air freight became the most cost-effective
option for Apple to carry the goods directly from the manufacturer to the customers.
Some of the major advantages Apple’s supply chain achieved from this factors include,
High quality inputs to offer high quality finished product
Effective incoming input handling to reduce damage
Flexible manufacturing system
Wide product range
Improved product appearance
Prevention of product pre-mature failure
Quick response to unique specifications
Improved customer satisfaction through lower defect rate
Improved product performance due to conformance to technical specifications
Effective handling and better shipping to reduce product damage
Timely product delivery
Flexible delivery capabilities
Effective order processing procedure
Reliable transportation to ensure quick delivery
High quality raw material and replacement parts.
Strengths:
Strengths are the Apple Supply Chain capabilities and resources that it can leverage to build a
sustainable competitive advantage in the marketplace. Strengths come from positive aspects of
five key resources & capabilities - physical resources such as land, building, past experiences
and successes, activities & processes, financial resources, and human resources .
The products and brand portfolio of Apple Supply is enabling it to target various segments in
the domestic market at the same time. This has enabled Apple Supply to build diverse revenue
source and profit mix.
The domestic market in which Apple Supply is operating is both a source of strength and
roadblock to the growth and innovation of the company. Based on details provided in the Apple
Inc.: Managing a Global Supply Chain case study – Apple Supply can easily grow in its
domestic market without much innovation but will require further investment into research and
development to enter international market. The temptation so far for the managers at Apple
Supply Chain is to focus on the domestic market only.
Apple Supply Chain has first mover advantage in number of segments. It has experimented in
various areas Organizational culture, Strategy, Supply chain, Technology. The Leadership &
Managing People solutions & strategies has helped Apple Supply in coming up with unique
solution to tap the un-catered markets.
It helps Apple Supply Chain to further increase its market share as the current customer are
extremely loyal to it. According to Fraser P. Johnson, Ken Mark in Apple Inc. There are enough
evidences that with such a high quality of products and services, Apple Supply Chain can
compete with other global players in international market.
High Margins:
Apple Supply Chain charges a premium compare to its competitors. According to Fraser P.
Johnson, Ken Mark of Apple Inc. Managing a Global Supply Chain case study, this has
provided Apple Supply resources to not only thwart competitive pressures but also to invest
into research and development.
Weakness:
Weaknesses are the areas, capabilities or skills in which Apple Supply Chain’s lacks. It limits
the ability of the firm to build a sustainable competitive advantage. Weaknesses come from
lack or absence of five key resources & capabilities - physical resources such as land, building,
activities & processes, past experiences and successes, human resources, and financial
resources .
Track record on environment consideration is not very encouraging:
Apple Supply track record on environmental issues is not very encouraging. According to
Fraser P. Johnson, Ken Mark , this can lead to consumer backlash as customers are now
considering environmental protections as integral to part of doing business. Project
Management is too focused on internal delivery rather than considering all the interests of
external stakeholders. This approach can lead to poor public relation and customer backlash.
Even though Apple Supply has integrated technology in the backend processes it has still not
able to harness the power of technology in the front end processes.
Organization Culture:
It seems that organization culture of Apple Supply is still dominated by turf wars within various
divisions, leading to managers keeping information close to their chests. According to Fraser
P. Johnson, Ken Mark of Apple Inc.: Managing a Global Supply Chain case study, this can
lead to serious road blocks in future growth as information in silos can result can lead to missed
opportunities in market place.
Even though Apple Supply is having a stable balance sheet, one metrics that needs reflection
is “Return on Invested Capital”. According to Fraser P. Johnson, Ken Mark in areas
Organizational culture, Strategy, Supply chain, Technology that Apple Supply operates in the
most reliable measure of profitability is Return on Invested Capital rather than one favored by
financial analysts such as – Return on Equity & Return on Assets.
Opportunities:
Opportunities are macro environment factors and developments that Apple Supply can leverage
either to consolidate existing market position or use them for further expansion. Opportunities
can emerge from various factors such as - economic growth, political developments & policy
changes, technological innovations, changes in consumer preferences, and increase in
consumer disposable income .
One of the challenges Apple Supply facing right now is limited access to high level talent
market because of limited budget. Expansion into international market can help Apple Supply
to tap into international talent market. According to Fraser P. Johnson, Ken Mark , it can also
help in bringing the talent into domestic market and expanding into new areas Organizational
culture, Strategy, Supply chain, Technology.
E-commerce business model can help Apple Supply to tie up with local suppliers and logistics
provider in international market. Social media growth can help Apple Supply to reduce the cost
of entering new market and reaching to customers at a significantly lower marketing budget. It
can also lead to crowd sourcing various services and consumer oriented marketing based on
the data and purchase behavior.
According to Fraser P. Johnson, Ken Mark, globalization along with boom in digital marketing
and social media has considerably reduced the risks of market entry and marketing in
international market.
Apple Supply can use developments in artificial intelligence to better predict consumer
demand, cater to niche segments, and make better recommendation engines.
Over the last decade and half the market size has grown at brisk pace. The influx of new
customers has also led to evolution of consumer preferences and tastes. This presents Apple
Supply two big challenges – how to maintain loyal customers and how to cater to the new
customers. Apple Supply has tried to diversify first using different brands and then by adding
various features based on customer preferences.
Apple Supply can explore adjacent industries Organizational culture, Strategy, Supply chain,
Technology to further market growth especially by extending the features of present products
and services.
Threats:
Threats are macro environment factors and developments that can derail business model of
Apple Supply. Threats can emerge from various factors such as - changes in consumer
preferences, technological innovations, increase in consumer disposable income, political
developments & policy changes, and economic growth .
The growing inequality is one of the biggest threat to not only globalization but also to
capitalism. Apple Supply first hand witnessed the impact of it where it has seen lower demand
of its products from middle class customers in US and EU market.
Over the years the bargaining power of customers of Apple Supply has increased significantly
that is putting downward pressure on prices. The company can pursue horizontal integration to
consolidate and bring efficiencies but I believe it will be a short term relief. According to Fraser
P. Johnson, Ken Mark , Apple Supply needs fundamental changes to business model rather
than cosmetic changes.
Apple Supply operates in an industry where there is a culture of sticky prices. According to
Fraser P. Johnson, Ken Mark of Apple Inc. Managing a Global Supply Chain case study, this
can lead to inability on part of the organization to increase prices that its premium prices
deserve.
Apple Supply should keep a close eye on the fast changing government regulations under the
growing pressure from protest groups and non government organization especially regarding
to environmental and labor safety aspects.
Describe briefly what Things and Topics learnt from Apple’s Supply Chain
Apple’s supply chain is one of the finest and leading supply chain in the world. There are many
things we can learn from this supply chain and make ourselves knowledgeable to participate in
the future supply chain challenges. In the following section we discussed the major things and
topics we learnt from Apple’s supply chain:
Strategic suppliers
Previously, Apple's supplier list was a closely guarded strategic secret. Apple, on the other
hand, made their supplier list public in 2012 in order to make its supply chain more transparent.
Apple currently publishes an updated list on their official website once a year. According to
Apple, the list's around 200 suppliers account for at least 97 percent of procurement costs for
materials, product assembly, and production. Apple collaborates with only a small number of
strategic suppliers, which offers both benefits and drawbacks. One of the dangers is that Apple's
reputation is inextricably linked to its suppliers. Using a small number of suppliers and
manufacturers has its own set of advantages. Apple is able to form deeper and more meaningful
exclusive relationships. It also gives Apple negotiating power because the company can
guarantee large volumes of production and materials.
Close control
Controlling is another crucial part of good and efficient supply chain management. The
company's image might be seriously harmed without it. Apple has chosen to perform more
factory audits and tighten its control over its suppliers. Apple conducted 451 audits at all levels
of their supply chain in 2013, up from 298 audits the previous year. In 2013, there were also
31 surprise supplier audits. In addition, these audits included 1.5 million workers in 16 nations
in total. Apple also established a Supplier Code of Conduct, which, in conjunction with their
supplier responsibility standards, aims to ensure that suppliers follow the same principles and
values as Apple. The latter document is more than 100 pages long, and it lays out the conditions
that suppliers must meet in order to do business with Apple. The fact that demand in Apple
stores is monitored by the hour and the supply chain may be changed when necessary is further
proof of Apple's strong supply chain control. It only takes 15 days to increase the work force
capacity in the Chinese factories where the Apple products are assembled.
Apple is the world's greatest at developing innovative products. Rather of focusing on one
dimension, the company develops hardware, software and linked digital services, allowing it
to provide an unrivaled user experience. This enables Apple to profit significantly from its
products and services.
When new component technologies such as touchscreens, processors, and LED displays are
first introduced, they are extremely expensive to manufacture, and constructing a facility that
can create them in large quantities is much more costly. What Apple does is utilize its financial
reserves to pay for the factory's building costs, or a large portion of them, in exchange for
exclusive rights to the factory's output production for a defined period of time, followed by a
reduced rate. This has two benefits, Apple stands months or years ahead of its competitors in
terms of component technology. This enables it to develop game-changing items that are very
impossible to replicate in a short period of time. Apple's competitors eventually catch up in
component production technology, but by that time, they've arranged for a discounted rate with
the most experienced and skilled producer of those parts, allowing them to get those parts at a
lower cost.
Apple's primary goal is to make products that improve people's lives. This involves not only
creating whole new product categories, such as the iPhone and Apple Watch, but also
constantly innovating within existing ones. The iPhone camera, perhaps more than any other
feature, reflects Apple's commitment to constant innovation. Since then, iPhone camera
technology has brought plenty of innovative capabilities to the photography world: High
dynamic range imaging (2010), panorama photos (2012), True Tone flash (2013), optical image
stabilization (2015), the dual-lens camera (2016), portrait mode (2016), portrait lighting (2017),
and night mode (2019) are but a few of the improvements.
Apple has a structure that focuses on functional knowledge in order to produce such product
innovations. Its general concept is that people with the most expertise and experience in a
certain task should have decision-making authority over that task. Apple competes in markets
with fast rates of technological change and disruption, therefore it must rely on the judgment
and intuition of people who have a strong understanding of the disruptive technologies. Long
before it can acquire accurate market input and forecasts, the company must make educated
guesses about which technology and designs will thrive in smartphones, laptops, and other
devices. Using technical experts instead of general managers raises the chances of those
investments paying off.
Apple's objective is to run all of its operations on renewable energy, and it's now 93 percent
there. Apple's Chinese offices and retail locations are already carbon-neutral, by a 40-megawatt
solar farm the company established in the nation. The solar farm produces enough electricity
to offset Apple's local carbon footprint. Apple claims that all of its data centers are fueled
entirely by renewable energy. About 99 percent of its packaging is made from recycled or
ecologically managed forest paper.
Apple conducts all of its research and development efforts at its headquarters, the Apple
Campus. Apple's R&D department has been centralized in California to increase R&D
efficiency, as the company emphasizes the value of innovation. Apple's assembly line is located
in China to take advantage of the plentiful human resources and low labor costs. Apple was
highly integrated, with centralized R&D and accounting for the entire firm, allowing the R&D
department's unique technology and design to be shared and used on a variety of products.
Apple's supply chain procedures can be streamlined as a result of this.
In comparison to a traditional product lifecycle, Apple maintains a comparatively shorter new
product development period. The lifecycle of a traditional product is 4-5 years, whereas the
lifecycle of an iPhone is only about a year. It can help Apple maintain its brand name fresh in
the minds of its customers. Furthermore, Apple invests extensively in research and
development to ensure that it has innovative products in the works.
Apple has a unique marketing strategy that is unusual in the consumer electronics business.
Even if there are substantial inventories, it offers limited supply on its new product at first. The
strategy is comparable to "velvet rope" marketing, which attracts customers through
exclusivity. It has the potential to create a halo effect, making people crave new Apple products
while also allowing Apple to generate marketing buzz without losing loyal customers.
Apple uses air freight as a transportation alternative to speed up the supply chain, despite the
fact that it is more expensive. Apple even pre-purchased all available holiday air freight to
ensure that new products arrive in time for any holiday shopping frenzy. Apple, on the other
hand, chooses to ship directly to customers from its Chinese supplier assembly plants in order
to cut costs on transportation.
Market trends are always shifting, and demand is on the rise. Other companies may respond by
developing new items in reaction to these shifts. Apple's goal is to improve its existing goods.
This explains why Apple releases product refreshes and updates on a regular schedule. As a
result, the adjusted or updated versions keep the best elements of the previous versions while
correcting or improving the problematic features. This clearly indicates that the latest iPhone,
the iPhone 6 Plus, is a vastly upgraded version of the old iPhone or even the previously released
iPhone 6. These modifications strengthen the image of the Apple product development team,
especially in the eyes of Apple users, because they imply a commitment on their part to seek
ongoing improvement for their product offerings. It also effectively draws new users, resulting
in an increase in Apple's market share. With ultimate control, Apple consumers are guaranteed
to receive the most recent version of the operating system, with updates being made accessible
to them quickly.
We can come up with a long list of mid-cycle modifications that Apple has made these years
if we look at the number of them. The enhancements to the Air and the new processors in the
Retina MacBook Pro would be on the list. Apple has been doing internal specifications on the
Mac line for many years. The new 16 GB iPod touch, iMac with VESA mount, and 128 GB
fourth generation iPad are just some of the massive modifications that have been made to the
operation of their product cycles.
Tim Cook used to be Apple's COO. His main responsibility was to assist Apple in developing
one of the most efficient and effective supply chains in the world's history. This simply meant
that Apple rarely had product hanging about in the warehouse, costing the company money. It
also means a significant reduction in the number of errors in the entire manufacturing
process. He was also tasked with ensuring that changes and improvements were made on a
regular basis in order to maintain strong profit margins. When we look at the iPod touch, we
can see how it fills a gap in the company's range, simplifies the supply chain, and makes it
easier for developers to create optimized designs for future screen sizes.