You are on page 1of 17

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/272711504

Vittorino da Feltre Humanistic pedagogy in Italy during the early renaissance

Article · November 2013

CITATIONS READS

0 1,639

1 author:

Erni Gustafsson
Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences
16 PUBLICATIONS   8 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Prosjekts to be soon published in different international journals on attitudes toward women in Palestine, Attitudes toward companion animals in Palestine and
Norway and attitudes toward disabled in Palestine and Norway. View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Erni Gustafsson on 24 February 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


abstract Current Educational Research
Erni Gustafson:
Vittorino da Feltre.
Nordic Studies in Education,
Vol. 33, pp. 155–170 Oslo.
ISSN 1891-5914.

Vittorino da Feltre: Humanistic


pedagogy in Italy during the early
renaissance

Vittorino da Feltre (1378–1447)


Vittorino da Feltre
can be regarded as a pioneer of
humanistic education and peda-
gogy. The article describes da
Feltre’s pedagogic activities as Humanistic pedagogy in Italy during
the school master of La Giocosa,
owned by marquis Gonzaga in the early renaissance
Mantua, Italy. Some of the eco-
nomic, political, and social pre-
conditions for humanistic peda- ERNI GUSTAFSON
gogy during the first decades of
the 15th century are also dis- Vittorino (Rambaldoni) da Feltre (1378–14471) studied and
cussed. Finally, the article places
da Feltre’s educational ideas and took inspiration from Quintilianus (Woodward, 1963, p. 26)2
practices in the academic and in his pedagogic practice in service for the Marquis of Mantua, 155
cultural context of the early Gianfrancesco Gonzaga. da Feltre (and as also shortly discussed
Renaissance in Italy.
in this article, Pier Paolo Vergerio [Petrus Paulus Vergerius,
1368–14443) appears to be little known in pedagogic circles.
Texts from da Feltre’s own hand do not exist, nor have they
Keywords: education · peda-
gogy · Renaissance · humanism ever existed. This includes pedagogic memoranda, exercises,
or, which was common for the scholars of that time, some
Manuscript received: Novem-
ber 2011 (peer reviewed) «elegant epistles» of rhetoric value. He himself considered there
to be enough written on the topic by others (Woodward,
1963, p. 80)!
Why is it then important to know of a humanistic, pedagog-
ic approach and a child-friendly praxis from as far back in time
as the classical antiquity, and as here discussed, young Renais-
sance? Partly, it is important to emphasize that this kind of ped-
agogic and didactic thinking and praxis, a psychological view
on children’s upbringing and learning conditions that we often
count as a phenomenon in modern times alone, actually have
parallels to times long ago. This means that not everything is as
new and distinctive for modern times as many wish to believe.
From a purely pedagogic history of ideas angle it is thus im-
portant to show that significant exceptions to the common
Erni Gustafson, Lillehammer
University College, Norway. pedagogic praxis exist. This, which is now considered «black
erni.gustafson@hil.no pedagogy,» consisted of learning through memorization (with
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

minimal subject comprehension for the stu- and diplomatic bureaucracy to secure their
dent), bodily punishment and oppression of financial and political interests, and, in sever-
pupils, teachers with little or no knowledge al ways, these duchies preserved part of the
about (and minimal interest for) «pedagogic» former republican structure. One can thus
questions, and generally inhuman teaching say that the Italian city-states were similar in
strategies. many ways to ancient Greece and Rome.
This particular similarity made schooled in-
Changed Structure – Changed dividuals look to ancient Rome for inspira-
tion and guidance in how to best manage the
Needs – Changed Pedagogy
new society that emerged (Nauert, 2006).
Several explanations exist for why the emer- During the dynamic and fast development
gence of humanism, here defined as the stud- toward the progressive capitalistic society of
ies of Roman (later even Greek) antiquity and 14th century Italy, a natural interest devel-
associated changes of study program, curricu- oped in how the application of common ex-
lum and syllabus, happened exactly in Italy isting laws and regulations were being imple-
and exactly at that time. The following is a mented, along with an interest in public po-
brief discussion of two possible explanations. litical debate and how audiences are
Humanism as a cultural epoch can be influenced (through rhetoric). This interest,
connected to the birth of capitalism, the de- for natural reasons, did not exist amongst the
velopment of trade and banking, as well as to earlier omnipotent aristocrats (like the Ger-
the increased need of competent administra- man emperors) or in the autocratic theocra-
156 tive personnel in both the profane and eccle- cy (papacy). But with the city-states’ and the
siastical administrations of society. The fore- «free» cities’ increasing political and eco-
most concern was that the profane, sovereign nomic power, at the expense of the emper-
aristocracy, as well as the upper echelons of or’s court and curia, ancient Rome and its
society’s leading administrative strata (in- different institutions represented an instruc-
cluding the ecclesial bureaucracy) was in tive example of how a society could be
need of a more extensive general education formed. Here one could find sources to rules
than what the church could provide with its for legislation, juridical pleading, influential
narrow self-interest-targeted instruction in techniques, i.e. how to express oneself in
monasteries, cathedral schools, and also part- speech and writing, both between states and
ly universities. between individual rulers (Seigel, 1968).
The cities and emerging city-states that All in all, at the end of the 14th and into
were ruled by powerful merchant families the 15th century, exactly what was needed to
and artisans characterized the northern half prepare the upper class’ sons for their future
of Italy during the 14th century. However, occupation as rulers of society was present in
these cities and city-states came under pro- the historically built educational program
gressively greater influence of powerful con- that was passed on by the Romans and prop-
dottiere, more or less despotic generals that agated strongly by the humanists. «The suc-
raised themselves up by defeating others of cess of humanism in defining the goals and
the same kind in the many small local wars methods of education rested on its suitability
that typified Italy during the Middle Ages for political and social needs of the
(and later during the entire Renaissance). time»(Nauert, 2006, p. 16).
Nevertheless, even they were on an in- With the development of capital forces
creasing scale in large need of a mercantile followed thus the need for a different type of
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

education, with other aims than during the tion of legal means, and stylistic and gram-
Middle Ages, where the teaching in monas- matical precision in the design of corre-
teries and cathedrals (as well as the few uni- spondence. As the complexity of the admin-
versities) was primarily associated with scho- istrative apparatus increased, a trend toward
lastic knowledge, mainly characterized by increased specialization and «sophistication»
the church’s theological/administrative/ju- in the bureaucracy also developed. It took
ridical needs, and distinctively «theoretically» those who, for instance, were especially
oriented. adept at writing Latin to linguistically deco-
In a time of expanding trade and budding rate diplomatic and legal documents with
nation-states’ ambitions an increasing need quotations from ancient and Christian au-
of heightened general knowledge arose, thorities (of cause, this counted for the curial
which included the ability to express oneself administration, i.e. the Church’s own bu-
through text and spoken word in a purpose- reaucracy; Garin, 1965).
ful way, e.g. in diplomacy. People were Some utilized this tendency toward spe-
needed who could think independently, cialization in order to specifically acquaint
however still within the frames of a cultural themselves more deeply with the ancient
canon that made it possible to «understand» Roman, and later ancient Greek, languages,
each other across borders and local cultural literature, institutions, and habits. The an-
differences. As Nauert (2006, p. 17) writes: cient ideas of a general education that can be
«The new culture of humanism was an en- referred to as educated, enlightened, or cultivat-
during solution to the need of this distinctive ed5 were adopted. The ideal was the classical
society for a type of culture and education humanitas: a cultivation of the whole hu- 157
suited to its character.» man’s character: body, spirit, emotion, and
Italy was the leading nation in the emerg- reason (Marrou, 1977). This foundation
ing capitalistic Europe, based on individual paved the way for the «movement,» which
ownership and private contracts. In Italy at later came to be known as humanism, or the
this time, one of the most important groups Italian Renaissance.6 Thus, the foundation
came to be those who administered con- was also laid for studia humanitatis7, the hu-
tracts and industrial activities. Lawyers and manists’ design of education that would re-
notaries established and interpreted the spond to the changing needs of the emerg-
agreements that made large-scale trade pos- ing capitalist society and the new rulers; the
sible. The capitalistic society that was devel- education which da Feltre, amongst others,
oped had a much larger need of functionar- developed and perfected.
ies educated in recording contracts and
agreements, verifying the authenticity of The Need of Learning What Is
deeds, archiving business records, etc. These
Beneficial
experts needed a long, thorough, and broad
juridical education in order to formulate and Medieval scholasticism was characterized by
interpret laws, however, training in accurate a high degree of abstraction, nearly always
expression and rhetorical efficiency in writ- from a theoretical (literary) study. In a socie-
ten and spoken Latin – ars dictaminis4 – was ty distinguished by the Catholic Church’s
also necessary. needs to as high a degree as in medieval Eu-
Along with the creation of business docu- rope, security (theological, ontological, and
ments, the professional educators taught epistemological) was of course placed first in
some elements of Roman law, the applica- the academic study. To obtain absolute
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

knowledge about God and his creations was predominantly Latin or Greek to Latin trans-
perhaps the main reason for the medieval lated) texts. These were not read with a mu-
scholars to study. seological gaze as during the Middle Ages.
This was increasingly unsatisfactory for Instead, the texts functioned as stylistic ar-
young men and their families who applied chetypes and were contemplated through a
for an administrative, legal, or political career utilitarian approach. They were subjected to
in the new power constellations. The society a growing literary scientific examination and
that emerged during the 1300s questioned criticism. The texts were to be utilized as ar-
the utility of these often metaphysical ten- chetypes and their substance used in practical
dencies toward abstraction and logical sub- contexts. Included were both philosophical
tlety(Nauert, 2006). As we know, politics and scientific texts from, but not limited to,
(and economic theory!) is not scientifically Plato and Aristotle, and even rhetorical
based on absolute certainty and logic. The models from Cicero’s speeches.
ability to correctly express oneself in text and Something entirely new replaced the me-
speech, to argumentatively influence an au- dieval study of Trivium and Quadrivium.8 On
dience (readers or listeners, e.g. in a court), a superficial level, it may appear that this new
or to make practical decisions in a non-abso- study effortlessly continued as humanism’s
lute, however probabilistic way, seemed con- «fine arts,» however, when looking at what
siderably more appealing to many people. was emphasized and how different topics
The new studia humanitatis promised stu- were presented, the divergence is noticeable.
dents to satiate these needs and more. They of- Latin as a scientific language obtained a
158 fered rhetorical proficiency, linguistic excel- new identity. Source criticism and linguistic
lence, and moral training as subjects. With research purged distortions and neologisms
these, the study also composed a segment of that crept in during the Middle Ages. Schol-
the education for political participants, regard- ars searched back to original sources to find
less of the future role of the student as an in- the «right and proper» Latin (Grendler,
fluential but «ordinary» citizen, a courtier, or a 1989). Petrarca initiated this process as early
ruler. Conservative as they always had been, as the 14th century.
the universities, holding fast to the scholastic Through this process of ancient cultural
tradition, could not deliver this whole, «edu- studies, more rigorous and strict methodol-
cational package» to their students. ogies were invented and adapted than during
Nevertheless, outside the universities, the the Middle Ages. In the humanist’s Latin
independently operating humanists could study, unlike in the former medieval Latin
fulfill the requests. Here the dominant and schools, the objective was not only to learn a
affluent families’ promising sons could seek (written) language, but also to more deeply
the knowledge needed. However, if no in- understand Roman literature, society, and
dependently operating humanist was availa- history. The language skills were used to
ble to receive pupils, the students were con- «enter» the mindset of a civilization that dis-
nected with the princely court or the appeared, but was considered qualitatively
wealthier city-states’ administrative systems. far superior to the contemporary. Reclama-
tion of the Roman civilization was desired,
Reorientation and exactly herein lays the root of the appel-
lation Re-naissance.
The teaching of the new time was character- The interpretation of texts (primarily the
ized primarily by the study of classical (i.e. Bible) had, ever since the Carolingian period
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

throughout scholasticism, been ranked in northern Italian city-states’ increased eco-


four categories of meaning: the literal or his- nomic and political power was also a signifi-
torical, the metaphorical or tropological cant factor in the change of needs and de-
(moral), the allegorical, and the anagogical mands of teaching–something that the pio-
(toward the ultimate, reaching beyond). The neers of the new time’s spirit could offer.
frame of interpretation that these four cate- The Renaissance and humanism were ur-
gories constituted was replaced by freer ban phenomena, which characterized the
interpretation praxis where the aim was to early 15th century school system organiza-
explore the intention of the text, what the tion in Italy. The school system, beginning
author «really meant». This change in in the early 1400s, began moving away from
hermeneutics was based on other texts than the homogeneous and monolithic monopo-
the Bible becoming the subject of interest ly which the Catholic Church held for ap-
for researchers. proximately 1,000 years, toward a more
Dialectics, which during the Middle Ages power political and curricular, if not geo-
had dominated all other areas, now fell back graphically decentralized, condition.
to a much less prominent position. Histori- Typically, the humanists conducted the
cal studies, with attempts toward source- education of the leading elite in boarding
critical examination, took the place of the schools. Even earlier this was common and
infallible authorities’ established interpreta- referred to as «to board» (stare a dozzina) or
tion of past that was supreme during the «to live at the boarding school» (a dozzina).
Middle Ages. The mathematical and natural These expressions were not worthy enough
scientific subjects in Quadrivium were even- for the humanists. Their schools became 159
tually liberated from authoritarian shackles, known as gymnasium, or that of Guarino Ve-
and developed toward knowledge based on ronese who borrows a concept from classical
logical thinking and verification through ex- Latin, contubernium, which is a shared accom-
perimentation. modation that includes companionship, inti-
The changing needs that emerged with macy, and intellectual exchange(Grendler,
the feudal society’s slow languish and the 1989, p. 131).9
birth of capitalism created the demand for Although da Feltre accepted students as
new forms of organizing the education sys- young as four (Woodward, 1963, p. 130), the
tem, along with new forms of didactic prac- typical student moved to the boarding
tice, pedagogic focus, and curricular con- school at age ten to twelve, after having pre-
tent. viously received private teaching in the
It was during this transitional stage that home, first from parents, followed by a gov-
people such as Vergerio and da Feltre found erness, and later a magister. Once in boarding
their place in pedagogic history. Organiza- school, students commonly stayed until their
tion of da Feltre and others’ teaching was di- early twenties.
rected entirely privately, or as an institution The insistence on the boarding school as
subordinate to one of the new rulers. For ex- the ideal arena for learning can explain the
ample da Feltre’s patron, Gonzaga, spon- heavy emphasis found in Renaissance peda-
sored the education completely separate gogic literature that a teacher must have high
from the Catholic Church or a university. ethical standards and be well educated and
Thereupon, a different and new economic knowledgeable, as well as the necessity of
base for financing studies and maintaining close and secure bonds that unite pupil/stu-
the teaching force was developed. The dent and teacher. This may also explain the
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

profound belief that this method of teaching were Gonzaga’s own daughters (according to
paired with ideal content was a necessity (de- Woodward (1963), at least one of them, Ce-
spite obvious proofs to the contrary even in cilia, appeared to have an extraordinary in-
the authors’ own time!) in shaping good rul- tellectual capacity) and the third was a Bar-
ers immune to authoritarianism, corruption, bara of Brandenburg, who was brought to
and generally profligate living. By all means Gonzaga’s court at the age of twelve, with
the boarding school, as it appears in the Ital- the intention to later become his eldest son,
ian Renaissance, came to be the educational Ludovigo’s, bride.
institution per preference for higher pre- Generally, the boys and girls of the poor
university education. This is true for most of were not considered to be in need of school-
the leading Western nations’ educational sys- ing. Sons of merchants and more prosperous
tems, continuing contemporarily. artisans could expect to learn to read and
In the early Renaissance, the budding idea write in Italian as well as gather rudimentary
of humanism, in the spirit of the new time, knowledge of arithmetic and «accounting».
asserted that it was of less importance for a To learn advanced mathematics, logic, rhet-
student to hold an imprimatur with a univer- oric, and physical education was reserved for
sity than to have studied under one of the the upper class. Girls could in general not
era’s great humanists. Commonly, these were hold any positions as secular or ecclesiastical
in the service of a secular or ecclesiastical officials, nor could they enter into law, and
prince or in service at one of the many citi- obviously not hold any office associated with
zen-driven city-states. This was one of the political or military power. They could not
160 aspects that made it possible for a private study at universities and were not to learn
school like the one da Feltre was head of to Latin (Grendler, 1989, p. 88).
achieve a status and influence that surpassed
several universities.10 Having studied under The Life of Vittorino da Feltre
da Feltre would likely imply a far higher de-
gree of documented knowledge than an ac- Vittorino (Ramboldini) da Feltre was born
ademic degree from most universities.11 in 1378 in the small town of Feltre in the
Woodward writes, with reference to the foothills of the Dolomites in Northeast Italy.
quality of the curriculum used by Vittorino, He was an only child to a notary and his
that even in comparison to universities with wife. Almost no records exist from da Feltre’s
pronounced humanist sympathies, it had a childhood. In 1396, at the age of 18, da Fel-
«thoroughness and breadth» which was tre matriculated into the University of Padua
probably «far in advance of the standard usual (Woodward, 1963, p. 6).
for the degree of Master or Doctor»(Wood- Amongst some of the highly reputable
ward, 1963, p. 61). universities in Italy at the time, such as Flor-
From a class and gender perspective, how- ence, Ferrara, and Bologna, was also Padua,
ever, nothing essential was changed by the nearby Venice. da Feltre stayed in Padua for
emergence of humanism. A person such as almost 20 years. Venice’s major trading with
da Feltre represents a very special exception, countries and territories belonging to the
in him even very poor parents could find a Byzantine, former Eastern Roman, empire,
master teacher for their gifted sons. Regard- made knowledge of Greek language and his-
ing females, we know with certainty of only tory highly valued. da Feltre gradually be-
three who received the same education as came well educated in classical Greek. How-
male students from Vittorino. Two of them ever, his main studies were Latin, rhetoric,
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

dialectics, and «moral philosophy». He re- household. He waived tuition fees and, in
ceived his Ph.D. in these subjects before some cases, even supported them financially
1411. After da Feltre obtained his Laurea he in other ways. He maintained good contacts
also studied mathematics. with parents and other guardians. Neverthe-
Although he now had a doctorate degree, less, if any of the students showed «unsatis-
da Feltre was a poor man. To support him- factory morals», laziness, or were somehow
self, on the side of his teaching work at the disappointing, da Feltre did not hesitate in
university, he began working for his teacher expelling them from instruction.
in mathematics, Pelacani, as a famulus, a pre- In 1422, at 44 years old, da Feltre accept-
ceptor for Pelacani’s children and others in ed, with great hesitation, an offer to take the
the household (Woodward, 1963, p. 8). To professorial chair in rhetoric at his own uni-
begin service as a private tutor for a wealthy versity(Woodward, 1963, p. 24). At this point
person, merchant, prince, or, as in this case, he had developed into a very knowledgeable
a professor who made a fortune through pri- person, but he also had deep religious feel-
vate teaching, was common for academics ings and lived a very pious and ascetic life.
before the stabilization and institutionaliza- There is no evidence that he belonged to any
tion of the university system in Europe. order or was part of the ecclesiastical hierar-
Vittorino was soon known as a particular- chy, so it is assumed that his religiosity was
ly good teacher, especially in mathematics, completely personal in nature.
and in 1415 he left Padua to join forces with In many ways, it looks as if da Feltre’s
his colleague Guarino Veronese in Venice. In ultimate project was to merge the religious
exchange for Guarino’s lessons in Greek, da requirements of a righteous existence with 161
Feltre taught Guarino Latin, in which he the ancient Stoic ideals of a fulfilling life
had almost perfect mastery. Then followed (Woodward, 1963, p. 27). He dressed simply
some years about which little are known of and engaged in religious contemplation as
da Feltre’s affairs. What is known is that well as physical exercise every day. He devel-
Guarino moved from Venice because of oped great invulnerabilities to mental and
plague outbreaks, and married in 1418 physical demands, such as cold and heat. His
(Woodward, 1963, p. 23). meals were simple, but healthy and nutri-
In 1420 we find him as a teacher at his old tious. A healthy mind in a healthy body ap-
university in Padua. He had at this point be- pears to have been an important maxim for
come a highly respected lecturer and scholar him.
and received his students in his home. To Shortly after he received the chair as a
preside over a group of students (contu- professor, however, he abdicated his position
bernium) was considered a great privilege, (Woodward, 1963, p. 20). The reason may
only given to those teachers who had ac- have been dissatisfaction with the general
quired great prestige. The position was also tendency of students to take positions toward
regarded as very profitable and contributed the studies and morality that he was not able
to scholars becoming wealthy (similar to da to accept or influence to any significant de-
Feltre’s former teacher, Pelacani). gree (Woodward, 1963, p. 21). Guarino pre-
For da Feltre, the educational quality of viously resigned from a teaching position as
teaching came first, and he never took more well, due to students’ (some of them only 14
students than he could give personal, indi- years old) lack of discipline and undesirable
vidualized instruction to. He also took stu- attitude toward the studies (Woodward,
dents who were talented but poor into his 1963, p. 18).
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

In 1423, da Feltre was named principal of 22 years of his life. He died February 2,
a school for the sons of Venetian patrician 1447, at 68 years old.
families and had earned a reputation as the
best and most accomplished teacher of «new Pedagogic Praxis
time» knowledge (i.e. logic, mathematics,
rhetoric, classical Latin and Greek, etc.). The prince’s own children were the natural
This year he also received an offer that deci- starting point for da Feltre’s practice. At the
sively changed his life and made him famous time of his investiture, there were three chil-
in the contemporary period. dren, Ludovico, Carlo, and Gianlucido, aged
Gian Francesco Gonzaga (1395–1444), three to nine. Cecilia was born in 1425, an-
Mantua’s leading condottiere and enlightened other son, Alessandro, in 1427, and later an-
autocratic ruler, asked him to become his other daughter. Shortly after da Feltre began
children’s mentor and teacher. Gonzaga was his service, some children from other noble
a self-made man who needed to prove wor- families in Mantua came aboard. After one
thy to be included in the exclusive noble cir- year of experience, children of da Feltre’s
cle. During this time, one of the ways to friends were also accepted with school fees
identify as «cultivated enough» (which was a according to financial capacity.
sine qua non of being accepted into high so- During the years as a teacher for Gonzaga,
ciety) was to hire a significant academic or even very poor children with pronounced
scholar as a household famulus. da Feltre sub- skills were accepted, with no fees required
mitted to this prospect at the end of 1423. from the parents. These children received
162 Vittorino received the request as early as the exact same treatment as the noble chil-
1421, but declined on the grounds that he dren. Woodward writes that in some cases da
was well invested with the work of his school Feltre himself paid for these students’ ac-
in Venice and that a position for Gonzaga commodations, food, and school supplies, in
would certainly bring envy from his col- some incidents for more than ten years
leagues. In addition, he explained, he ab- (Woodward, 1963, p. 30)!
horred court life, which involved great su- Vittorino da Feltre’s school quickly be-
perficiality and useless formality. All he came famous for its excellent quality and
wanted was to peacefully complete useful many leading scholars and upper aristocrats
work. When he finally conceded, it was with of the early 1400s sent their children to
the insight that to educate the children of the Mantua. The school became known as Gin-
omnipotent merchant and war nobility was a nasio and the reputation of its quality spread
tremendous opportunity to influence the to France, Germany, and even to Greece.
personalities of future rulers. Actually, the Marquis Gonzaga’s school out-
Moreover, he thought it was possible to performed many European universities, es-
make the service resemble a monastic life, an sentially because da Feltre gave the children
opportunity that was very appealing to the more in-depth lessons and worldly tempta-
deeply and sincerely religious da Feltre. He tions were far fewer for young minds under
wrote to Gonzaga to accept service under the authoritative schoolmaster than in the
the conditions «that you [Gonzaga] do not dangerous freedom of large university cities.
wish anything of me that will require un- The school was in a house originally built
worthiness, either from me or you» (loosely as a casino (Woodward, 1963, p. 31), near
translated; Woodward, 1963, p. 24). Vittori- the princely corpes de logi, at an elevation in
no stayed at Gonzaga’s household for the last the Northeast corner of then Mantua. This
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

«Pleasure house,» as Woodward (1963, p. 31) a beloved and highly esteemed figure to his
calls it – La Gioiosa (due to its beautiful loca- students. These sentiments are testified in
tion and pleasant surroundings), da Feltre some of the surviving letters students wrote
appositely renamed La Giocosa – the house of after they became adults.13
play and learning.12 It was large with ample The instruction lasted between seven and
spaces, painted by famous artists with bright eight hours per day, beginning early in the
fresh colors, wall frescos depicting playing morning, and occasionally da Feltre woke a
children, and grand windows that let in an student earlier to help him review teaching
abundance of light. da Feltre believed the materials. The classroom teaching consisted
house should display the same spiritual dig- partly of text dictation, exercises, and trans-
nity and purity that he wished his students to lations, and partly of oral questioning. Dec-
possess, and that it should be devoted to lamations by him self, teaching assistants, and
sound intellectual work. The surroundings students interrupted the monotony of les-
were also designed in da Feltre’s humanistic sons. Individualization was used largely to
spirit. On three sides, the house was sur- support each student; even homework was
rounded by large meadows bisected by broad individualized and students were given spe-
avenues. In the meadows, children (i.e. boys) cial attention when needed (Woodward,
were trained in war arts and physical educa- 1963, p. 62 f.).
tion; however the meadows were also used The design of the school reflected the dis-
for playing different games. parity between da Feltre’s didactic methods
The school was structured so that all stu- and pedagogic views and other intellectual
dents lived together. Even the school master pedagogues of the time. The bright and 163
initially had his residence at the school. He friendly image matched his sympathetic and
was with his students in everything, play, helpful attitude, which, accompanied by his
work, studies, he even partly shared the lim- natural authority, resulted in rare use of dis-
ited leisure time given with them. He defi- ciplinary procedures.
nitely considered himself a father figure to da Feltre also showed a never-ending con-
his students, shared joys and sorrows with fidence and hopefulness that each student
them, and entered their personal spheres of had the opportunity to achieve greatly, as
interest. Although he at times was responsi- much as was possible within each individual’s
ble for between sixty and seventy students of constitutional framework. His faith was also
different ages, he almost never resorted to rock-solid in that teachers can affect and in-
corporal punishment, which to «all times» fluence their students’ life and character.
have been a common ingredient in school These were all new ideas, foreign to the me-
pedagogy (Woodward, 1963, p. 34). dieval monastic school, which was charac-
His unquestionable authority and bound- terized by dark and cheerless appearances,
less interest in and consideration for his stu- where each person was a sinner without
dents resulted in discipline never being a hope and no notice was taken of individual
problem (Woodward, 1963, p. 35). This qualities or age. Discipline and blind obedi-
contrasts the teaching of monastic schools ence were regarded as the highest traditional
and universities of the time, where chaotic virtues, it was believed that knowledge liter-
conditions could prevail. Respect for each ally had to be beaten into students.
individual’s value and integrity, as well as an The aim of the studies for da Feltre, as the
attitude implying attraction as better for true humanist and teacher he was, was to en-
learning than blind discipline, made da Feltre sure a consummate and harmonious devel-
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

opment of mind, body, and character, which guel, 1999). Older children took recitation
during later parts of the Renaissance was and declamation, i.e. rhetorical exercises be-
codified into concepts describing the ideal, came more important. At age 14 pupils were
complete citizen and member of society.14 able to recite entire speeches from Cicero or
However, during the young Renaissance, Demosthenes, in addition to being able to, as
this notion was completely new. For in- Woodward writes, with «accuracy and taste»
stance, for da Feltre’s friend and fellow hu- read entire books of Livius or Sallustus, as
manist, Guarino Guarini, the ideal citizen well as long excerpts of Homeros and Vergil-
was still a clever and well-versed scholar. da ius (Woodward, 1963, p. 39). Children stud-
Feltre desired to educate young men to be- ied both classical and Christian texts with
come good servants of church and state, re- the same requirements for proficiency in
gardless of the influential positions they re- both types of literature.
ceived. For Guarino, the ideal was mainly to Earlier on, students memorized short pas-
become a useful cog in the ecclesiastical bu- sages by, for example, Ovidius and Vergilius.
reaucracy. Some of the pupils by the age of ten could
recite longer Latin texts by heart. At a time
Didactic Methods when books were rare and very expensive, to
be able to recite prose and verse was a grand
da Feltre agreed with Quintilianus that chil- and popular asset. The art of memorization
dren should begin their studies as early as was thus also a subject of study for da Feltre’s
possible, they should come to school before students. Similar to Quintilianus, memoriza-
164 there was too much to unlearn (Gustafson, tion was for da Feltre and his contemporary
2004; Woodward, 1963, p. 38)! For the time a primun ingenii signum (both a sign of
youngest children (four to five years old) da and a precondition for learning) and its cul-
Feltre assigned word and letter games, com- tivation could lead to great results.
bined with simple oral exercises. He placed
great emphasis on correct, clear, and distinct Subjects Taught
pronunciation and also assigned speaking ex-
ercises similar to those of contemporary lan- Grammar, i.e. language learning, was a cor-
guage therapists and singing voice specialists. nerstone of da Feltre’s curriculum and was,
Intonation, accentuation, and stylistic train- with its various constituents, taught through
ing were also part of teaching, even for the four different categories of exercises. First,
youngest pupils. he taught a sufficiently large vocabulary
Literacy was promoted according to tradi- through dictation and included herein the
tional means of reading aloud, individually inflection of words. After, easy passages from
and in groups. In light of books being scarce, «poetic» authors were read, which were ex-
this was an effective method. During meals plained, translated, and used as tutorials.
there was total silence, save for one student Alongside this, introductions were given in
who read aloud to the others. As was the historical narratives with moral anecdotes
case in ancient times, da Feltre considered relating to the text. In addition, the compo-
reading aloud to be helpful in understanding sition and structure were studied along with
a text, as well as a test of whether the student how elements of the text could be used as el-
had understood the text properly. To most ements in disputative conversation. In that
people, reading silently to oneself has been way, language learning was not only a «tech-
uncommon up until «modern» times(Man- nical» study but was deposited in a literary
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

context and thus could provide students tragedies. Livius, in addition to Vergilius, was
with a «wider» meaning. one of da Feltre’s favorites.15 Quintilianus was
Such a flexible system of learning created obviously a favorite, as da Feltre acquired al-
space for da Feltre to show his great skills in most all of his rhetorical knowledge from
practical didactics. He used many tools and him. Plinius’ Naturalis Historia, and Cicero’s
different sides of his personality to give stu- speeches were also natural elements of the
dents the best of learning situations. curricula. Seneca was applied as a supportive
As mentioned, da Feltre did not follow text for da Feltre’s stoic inclination. Of the
the rigid medieval four-part system for text Christian writers, Augustinus was the prima-
interpretation (see above). His method to ry source. De musica and De Categoriis are
«read» a text followed different logic. At first mentioned by students. It appears that Vit-
he occupied himself with verba, the exact torino preferred, for stylistic reasons, classical
meaning of a word and its placement in a Latin authors. The Christian authors of late
given sentence, followed by an analysis of ge- antiquity and the Middle Ages seem to have
nus dicendi, i.e. the style of the text passage. been sacrificed on the altar of language, in
Here the author’s special individual rhythm, that they, in Vittorino’s eyes, were too lin-
selected word order, etc. are included. Then guistically corrupt and inaccurate. Therefore
the text is examined in relation to the it is presumed that da Feltre himself took care
«room» (the allusions that can be drawn from of Christian moral learning and theology.
the text), in which the storyline precedes, With the entry of humanism into Euro-
descripto locorum. Analyses of personal charac- pean thought, rhetoric, which had formerly
teristics (affectus personarum) are also per- appeared in the universities’ curricula, be- 165
formed. While all this takes place, the ana- came one of the most important subjects.
lyzed passage is illustrated by other passages During da Feltre’s time, rhetoric had not yet
from the same, or different, authors. reached the heights of prestige that would
As is often the case with talented peda- befall it during the High Renaissance and on
gogues, da Feltre had a great ability to illus- to the Baroque. Quintilianus naturally be-
trate his thesis and explain concepts to stu- came the central authority on the subject;
dents from different perspectives, always however, other scholars were used as refer-
with the intention that learning would be fa- ence points as well. One of them was Gaspa-
cilitated. It is said that he always utilized sim- rino Barzizza, who in De Compositione
ple and direct language in lessons. The ex- (1420) enumerated three rhetorical aspects:
planations were clear and adapted to the age composition, dignity, and beauty (elegantia),
and intellectual skills of the individual stu- which composed an agreeable basic canon.16
dent, while his voice was pleasant, varied, Vittorino’s opinion was that the style, either
and encouraged attention and dedica- as text or numbers, should be simple and
tion(Woodward, 1963, p. 46). clear without embellishment. In this too he
Each student wrote and made personal was paralleled with Quintilianus, who had a
understanding from what da Feltre discussed, great aversion to the time’s popular embel-
and they formed dictionaries with grammat- lishing and verbose style. According to
ical references and interpretations in their Quintilianus – and da Feltre – the rhetoric
own linguistic style. In this way, each student should have a practical purpose. Eloquence
created a personal collection of examples. was not an «art» in itself to be worshiped, but
Latin texts that were used include Vergil- a practical means of communication within a
ius, Aeneid; Horatius, Odes; and Seneca’s political and legal context.
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

In the teaching there was also emphasis on Music was in many ways a branch of math-
rhythm, various rhetorical topoi (arguments), ematics and had been since antiquity. In
and rhetorical figures. At the age of eleven to modern understanding of the concept, music
twelve, students began performing their own was not an especially popular subject for da
rhetorical writings. Students used formal Feltre. Surely there was music in the curric-
models, which were reproduced with great ulum, but then under careful supervision.
accuracy. They not only wrote in Latin but From da Feltre’s stance, music was subversive,
also translated Latin passages into Greek. da and could be corrupting his students’ good
Feltre himself put great effort into teaching morality. In addition, it fostered apathy – to
composition and rhetoric. Each student’s ex- only listen to music without participating
ercise was reviewed individually, corrected, was the same as an excuse not to do anything!
and, if necessary, rewritten by da Feltre him- Active pursuit of music could lead to a loss of
self so the student could see how it «should self-control (Woodward, 1963, p. 43). With-
look.» One testimonial that this diligent in this code of conduct, however, instrumen-
work bore fruits comes from the above- tal music, choral singing, and dancing were
mentioned Traversari, who asserted that ten- allowed. The latter probably as a concession
year-old Cecilia, Gonzaga’s oldest daughter, to the realities that dance was in fact an im-
surpassed his own adult students at the Uni- portant ingredient in the court life that the
versity of Florence. vast majority of students would later live.
The classically trained Renaissance person As described above, the surroundings of
should, in addition to linguistic disciplines, La Giocosa were largely meadows designated
166 possess philosophical and historical knowl- for physical exercise in the form of sports
edge. Homeros was considered a credible and play. da Feltre believed that not only the
historian. However, the more «real» histori- soul and the intellect needed to be cultivat-
ans, such as Herodotus and Thucydides, ed, but also the body. At this time, knowl-
were also in the curricula. Plutarchos was re- edge of different types of martial arts was a
garded as a foundation of moral and political sine qua non for the sons of the aristocracy.
wisdom. Philosophy was for da Feltre gener- Knowledge of war was quite essential for
ally synonymous with morality – ethics. Pla- young noblemen, even if in service for spir-
to, Aristotle, and the Stoics were taught to itual purposes. It was important to study tac-
provide arguments in the major project of tics and strategy, which could be found in
helping shape students into honorable states- ancient sources. To be able to command, to
men and citizens. be a leader of military operations, was also
da Feltre appreciated arithmetic as it necessary.
trained students’ mercantile skills and accu- However, for this to have any value, the
racy. He taught geometry, which likely was boys had to be trained to be physically and
associated with algebra, and trained students mentally able to handle weapons. da Feltre
to design and take measurements. Guest believed it was possible to learn how to sto-
speakers were engaged in natural philosophy ically endure pain and suffering, maintain
and Euclidean geometry. He ignored astrol- self-control, and discipline oneself. In this
ogy in favor of astronomy. To distinguish be- practical approach to physical education, he
tween these subjects was quite unique and leaned heavily toward the ancient Stoic phi-
was not fully recognized until the 1800s losophers.
(even a notable scientist like Newton often However, da Feltre also considered physi-
practiced astrology!). cal development of the body a moral matter.
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

As the Renaissance man he was, he respect- manism, in accordance with the classical ide-
ed that the whole person must be in harmo- als, were two inseparable factors, both indis-
ny – intellect, spiritual life, and body. Surely pensable for people to realize their full
the students had to learn at least one of the potential, and each contributed in creating
epigrams from Juvenalis’ Satires: a healthy the full and complete human being.
soul in a healthy body. Yes, da Feltre appre- Nothing indicates that da Feltre saw any
ciated sports and physical training to the ex- contradiction between Christianity and clas-
tent that in the hierarchy of subjects it was sical humanistic teachings. On the contrary,
only preceded by language studies! Never- Christian faith and morality were entirely
theless, the physical challenges were never complementary to, for example Stoic ideals
driven further than what was considered and platonic idealism. For him it was a unity,
sound and supportive for the body. He op- a whole that his students should experience
posed all types of physical excesses as much and incorporate into their characters, which
as laziness and apathy. was the motivation for all da Feltre’s teaching
Through first playing and gaming, and efforts.
then more regular training in weapon carry-
ing, with an «institutionalization» of an as- Conclusion
cetic life in terms of food and comfort (tem-
perature was never high at La Giocosa), the Several of the early Renaissance statesmen
boys were prepared for their coming com- and leading secular and ecclesiastical scholars
mission as generals and commanders. had studied under da Feltre in their youth.
Life outside of the school was carefully or- Niccola Perotti (1429–1480), who wrote 167
ganized. Regardless of weather, a daily dose one of the most widely used Latin grammar
of physical exercise was required. The exer- books, can be mentioned, along with Loren-
cises consisted of fencing, horse riding, run- zo Valla (1406–1457), who was perhaps the
ning, and various athletic arts. da Feltre had most important of all linguists after «cleans-
a special predilection for team play as he ing» Latin from all its medieval figments and
considered it an excellent arena for learning introducing a scientific source criticism in
consideration and team spirit. Now and the language study. The Duke of Urbino,
then, he and the older students went on ex- Frederigo de Montefeltre (1422–1482),
cursions into the mountains above Lake whose court the Renaissance historian Jacob
Garda, for several days at a time (Woodward, Burchardt described as «a work of art,» was
1963, p. 66). These excursions were organ- in adolescent years a pupil of da Feltre.17
ized not only to get exercise and fresh air, but At his death one of da Feltre’s «free» stu-
they also provided an opportunity to focus dents, Giovanni Andrea, bishop of Aleria,
on nature studies and to train students to en- wrote that his old schoolteacher had been
dure hardships and live a simple life. «the poor students’ father who everybody
The religious observances were not ne- looked up to as a beacon of goodness»
glected in any way. Quite the opposite, reli- (loosely translated) (Woodward 1963, s. 91).
gious reverence, faith, and pietism played a His colleague and friend, Ambrogio Traver-
crucial role in da Feltre’s private life. Human sari, leaves this epitaph: «Meliorem illo
value was unbreakably tied to God. All stu- virum, ausim dicere, nescio an unquam vi-
dents regularly witnessed mass and da Feltre derim» – loosely translated – «never ever has
himself was an example in religious rever- one seen or heard a better man». (Wood-
ence for his students. Christianity and hu- ward, 1963, s. 91) W.H. Woodward, da Fel-
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

tre’s modern biographer, describes him con- were required. As Syme asserts, an expecta-
clusively as «the first modern Schoolmaster». tion emerged in the imperial staff that there
Prendilacqua, da Feltre’s first biographer, should be an assembly of highly skilled man-
writes that he died so poor (due to his gen- agers with a substantial education who could
erosity) that the expenditures for the funeral competently administer diplomatic activities
had to be financed by others.18 His abstemi- and other important fields of «national
ousness and humility also made him hide, affairs» (Syme, 1958).
rather than display, his great knowledge and 5 The proper word here would be the Ger-
deep insight. Perhaps this is one reason why man «gebildet,» from the noun «Bildung.»
Vittorino da Feltre has been partly overseen Due to the impossibility of accurately trans-
in the history of pedagogy, despite his histor- lating «Bildung» and its grammatical deriva-
ically important role as a leading pioneer of tives, the following gives direction for defin-
humanistic pedagogy.19 ing this concept. The word implicates knowl-
edge of a broad range of topics – of culture,
Notes society, history, art, etc., as well as profound
human ethical understanding. The concept
1 Sources regarding da Feltre’s date of birth concerns erudition and broad cultural aware-
vary considerably. Woodward (1963), along ness and is not limited to «learning» in a nar-
with da Feltre’s biographer Francesco row academic sense, but considers the per-
Prendilacqua, purports the year to be 1378, sonal worldview an individual possesses. It is
Catholic Encyclopedia claims 1397, and sev- about stimulation (not only passive transmis-
168 eral other dates exist. In accordance with sion), development of character, and personal
Woodward and one of the dates Grendler capacities (not skills). «Bildung» is embedded
(1989, p. 129) suggests, I have chosen to in the interrelationship between an individ-
acknowledge 1378 as the year of birth. ual, other people, and the world, and leads to
There seems to be, however, relative consen- inner harmony between the different faculties
sus about the date of death as 1447. within man and outer harmony with others.
2 William Harrison Woodward’s work Vit- The «gebildet» person has strong self-esteem
torino da Feltre and other humanist educators rooted in understanding and real interest in
(first published in 1897, reprinted several people – not in mere need of aggravating
times) is still one of the foremost English oneself or in psychological defense mecha-
sources of knowledge about da Feltre and he nisms. The goal is a nuanced, non-egocentric
has even translated excerpts of Vergerio. self-government, in the deepest meaning of
This article builds to no small extent on the word, to enrich the individual and the
Woodward’s translations and interpretations. whole of humanity. When in the rest of this
3 Vergerio’s real birth year has been dis- paper the English words «educated» or «culti-
cussed. Here is chosen what Hans Baron vated» are used, most often they embody «Bil-
indicates in Speculum N° 52, 1977. dung»/»gebildet.» For definitions of «Bil-
4 This process can usefully be compared dung» see R. Spaemann (1994). Also see
with the similar bureaucratization process (of Brockhaus Enzyklopädie under «Bildung.» For
course without the material basis that capi- an English dissertation about erudition,
talism formed 1,200 years later) during the enlightenment and connoisseurship, all ingre-
first and second decade a.d. when the impe- dients in «Bildung», see Eisner (1991).
rial administration and diplomacy grew in 6 According to Oscar Kristeller (1961),
extent and more thoroughly trained officials one of the 1900s’ leading and most influen-
N O RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3 ———————————————— HU MA N IS TIC P E D AGO G Y IN IT ALY

tial researchers on Italian humanism, one can The logo on the diploma is often a more
not regard humanism as a philosophy, e.g. in important sign of quality than what grade
contradiction to scholasticism, but more as a the student is able to exhibit.
trend, a changed mentality, a movement in 12 In Venetian, there was a Cá Zoiosa. There
time. The Renaissance/humanism as a dis- is a striking word similarity to the Italian gio-
tinct philosophy was previously strongly cosa, which comes from jocosa (L. jocus is syn-
claimed by, amongst others, Jacob Burck- onymous with ludus – sport, competition).
hardt. Gioiosa comes from gioia (L. gaudia), which
7 The designation can be traced back to also was the appellation for elementary
Cicero, Pro Archaia, where the term studia school. Woodward quotes Paglia who says,
humanitatis ac litterarum occurs as classifica- that Casa Zoyosa was, loosely translated, «the
tion of the subjects that students must study house of playful studies (of «literature») and
in order to achieve their full human poten- caring of the spirit’s beauty and delight» (la
tial. All the seven «liberal arts» appear to be casa di ludi letterarie e di delizie spirituali) (p. 32).
included, which was relevant education for a 13 Out of the fragmented correspondence,
«free man.» This ideal of Cicero was contin- the letters from Sassulo da Prato and Franc-
ued by ancient authors such as Aulus Gellus esco Prendilacqua, are the more complete
whom in Attic Nights (Nocte Atticae) used that can testify to the students’ appreciation
the term for the educational program of the (see Woodward (1963) for explanation of the
ruling elite, not unlike the classical Greek full correspondence).
paideia, or the German/Swedish Bildung/ 14 Also for Quintilianus and his intellectual
allmänbildning. contemporary, the well-educated and inter- 169
8 Trivium – grammar, i.e. language skills in ested citizen was the ideal. See more in Gus-
Latin and Greek, rhetoric, and dialectics, i.e. tafson (2004).
logic. Quadrivium – arithmetic, geometry, 15 Authors who, for various reasons (often
music, i.e. in praxis mathematics, as well as moral), did not find favor with da Feltre
astronomy/astrology. were, of course, Ovidius and Juvenalis, but
9 These Renaissance boarding schools are also Plautus (some students with «strong
archetypes of e.g. the English famous board- morality» were, however, allowed to shortly
ing school, Rugby. One can also sense the get acquainted with him). Horatius’ satires
historical lines from the Renaissance were reserved for the last year of study
princely funded boarding schools to the (Woodward, 1963, p. 47).
North American Prep. Schools, the topmost 16 Barzizza was one of the first to receive a
aristocratic private colleges, as well as the Ivy transcript of Quintilianus’ Institutio from
League universities. Poggio after it was discovered (Kennedy,
10 Woodward indicates in one place, how- 1980).
ever, that Gonzaga in 1433, perhaps influ- 17 Frederigo’s library was one of the era’s
enced by da Feltre, applied and was granted most extensive, and contained copies of all
permission by emperor Sigismund to estab- works of well-known Greek and Latin
lish a «Studium Generale» based on the «Gym- authors, up to that contemporary time. It also
nasium Palatinum» that already existed. The contained a complete series of Italian poets,
grant, however, was never substantiated. essays on music, church history, works on
11 Compare this to the United States where theology, nature science, mathematics, med-
it is often more important at which univer- icine, law, military strategy and tactics, as well
sity a person has studied than their grades. as a number of books translated from
E R N I G U S T A F S O N ———————————————————————— NO RD I C S T U D I E S I N E D U C A T I O N 3 /2 0 1 3

Hebrew. Baldassare Castiglione (1478–1529), (The Johns Hopkins University Studies


author of Il Cortegiano («The Book of the in Historical and Political Science. Vol.
Courtier»), was also included in this very 107:1) Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Uni-
famous court of European cultural history. versity Press.
Frederigo’s person and court formed the Gustafson, E. (2004). Marcus Fabius Quintil-
model for what is described as «the basic ian: Retorisk Lærdom, Psykologisk Innsikt
grammar for courtly society up to the French Og Pedagogisk Visdom [Marcus Fabius
Revolution» and for «the ideal good govern- Quintilian: Rhetoric Learnedness, Psy-
ment» (Quondam, 1981, p. 37). We may well chological Insight and Pedagogical Wis-
assume that da Feltre’s upbringing of Freder- dom]. In K. Steinsholt & L. Løvlie (eds.):
igo was no small contribution to the creation Pedagogikkens mange ansikter [the Many-
of a court culture that uniquely characterized Faced Pedagogic].Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
the «household’s» collection of learned men Kennedy, G.A. (1980. Classical Rhetoric and
and women, of servants, but perhaps fore- Its Christian and Secular Tradition from An-
most the military chivalry of officers. This cient to Modern Times. Chapel Hill: Uni-
«household» was «governed less like a com- versity of North Carolina Press.
pany of soldiers than a strict religious com- Kristeller, P.O. (1961). Renaissance Thought:
munity,» and there was no «gaming nor The Classic, Scholastic, and Humanic
swearing, but men conversed with the Strains. New York: Harper & Row.
utmost sobriety» (Symonds, 1888, p. 21).] Manguel, A. (1999). En historia om läsning [a
18 A medal forged by Pisanello in da Feltre’s History of Reading]. Stockholm: Ordfront.
170 honor shows a pelican that gives birth to her Marrou, H-I. (1977). A History of Education
nestlings from a wound in the chest – a sym- in Antiquity. London: Sheed and Ward.
bol of the master’s great self-sacrifice, one Nauert, C.G. Humanism and the Culture of
can infer. Renaissance Europe. Cambridge: Cam-
19 Interestingly, however, in 1954 an bridge University Press, 2006.
inspired, well-documented novel Vittorino; Quondam, A. (1981). Introduzione a Il Libro
oder die Schleier der Welt was issued (not trans- Del Cortegiano Di Baldesar Castiglione. Mi-
lated to English or Scandinavian languages), lano: Garzanti.
by the German Otto Rombach. In this book Seigel, J.E. (1968). Rhetoric and Philosophy in
da Feltre’s great psychological and pedagog- Renaissance Humanism: The Union of Elo-
ical insights clearly emerge. quence and Wisdom, Petrarch to Valla. Prin-
ceton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
References Spaemann, R. (1994). Wer Ist Ein Gebilde-
ter Mensch. Scheidewege. Jahresschrift für
Brockhaus Enzyklopädie (1987). Mannheim: skeptisches Denken, 24. 34–37.
F.A. Brockhaus. Syme, R. (1958). Tacitus. Part II. Oxford:
Eisner, E. The Enlightened Eye: Qualitative In- Clarendon Press, 1958.
quiry and the Enhancement of Educational Symonds, J.A. (1888). Renaissance in Italy:
Practice. Italian Literature in Two Parts. New York:
Garin, E. (1965). Italian Humanism: Philoso- H. Holt and Company.
phy and Civic Life in the Renaissance. Ox- Woodward, W.H. (1963). Vittorino Da Feltre
ford: Basil Blackwell. and Other Humanist Educators. New York:
Grendler, P.F. (1989). Schooling in Renaissance Bureau of Publications, Teachers Col-
Italy: Literacy and Learning, 1300–1600. lege.

View publication stats

You might also like