Professional Documents
Culture Documents
H O S T E D BY
Alexandria University
a
Architectural Engineering, Egypt
b
Department of Architectural Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Alexandria University, Egypt
KEYWORDS Abstract This research focuses on the problem of the design of contemporary glass buildings and
Glass facades; facades in a hot dry area such as Egypt, that is based on the ‘‘western” concept of the glass facade
Internal environment; design, without any attention to design according to the climate, or the use of glass in how, type and
Hot arid zone color to show the architectural identity and character of the country.
The result is that the energy needed to cool the internal environment of these buildings is very
high, leading to pressure on the total energy resources and the appearance of glass blocks that
do not respect the architectural identity of the country.
The importance of this study is to make designers and users aware of the application of appro-
priate glass types to ensure the comfort of users within buildings. Furthermore, it studies the effect
of the glass facades on the visual and thermal comfort of users, and proposes a suitable process
methodology for selecting the appropriate type of glass or color as well as effective shading systems
which respond to the solar radiation of that region. It also emphasizes on the glass design methods
that express architectural identity and culture of the country.
Ó 2019 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Faculty of Engineering, Alexandria
University. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/
licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Methodologies used include literature review to collect data interpretation, pleasant tones of light, and the absence of glare
concerning different aspects of glass types and glass facades, [5].
experimental methodology concerning simulation of different Visual discomfort/glare: Glare is visual noise that interferes
design strategies for the case study and finally, comparative with visual performance. Two main types of glare exist, direct
analysis of simulation outcome to assign the optimum design and indirect (reflected), and each can have very detrimental
strategy. effects on the ability to see [17]. Direct glare is caused by a light
source in the field of the view that is sufficiently bright to cause
2. Glass facade annoyance, discomfort, or loss in visual performance. Reflec-
tion of light sources on the glossy surface usually cause indirect
Glass Facade is an important element in buildings and the glare [5].
main function of it is to protect and distinct the internal from Visual comfort Vs human performance: Lighting quality is
the external environment conditions, so energy-efficient build- one of the determinants of human performance in the indoor
ing designers have started to develop their researches based on environment. Various studies have been conducted to compare
this matter. Today, energy usage in buildings have become an the effects of different lighting conditions on health, productiv-
important factor due to the limited energy sources, hence, ity, and well-being and alertness level. With regards to human
building construction materials such as glass and techniques perception, correlated color temperature (CCT) and illumi-
should be considered accordingly in the design period [19]. nance level are the two most important characteristics of light
to be considered [5].
2.1. Glass facade performance
c) Thermal comfort
There are four main Principles of glass façade performance as A suitable thermal comfort, in general, can be achieved by
shown in Fig. 2.1. A glass facade for building envelope sepa- the temperature being between 24 °C and 26 °C. Body facade
rates the interior environment from the exterior one. Differ- temperature, while in a sedentary activity, is 33 °C–34 °C
ences in the two environments generate environmental loads. and less; whereas internal temperatures increase with activity.
The most important of these environmental loads can be cate- A temperature of more than 45 °C can cause irreversible brain
gorized as: temperature, moisture, and air pressure. Tempera- damage and less than 18 °C can also lead to serious cardiac
ture load is generated by both exterior temperature factors arrhythmia and death. Therefore, careful controlling of body
[i.e., exterior air temperature, solar radiation, and wind], and temperature is crucial for comfort and health [6].
interior temperature factors [i.e., occupant activities, ventila-
tion, and heating equipment] [3]. 2.2. Thermal comfort problems in hot climates
a) Wind:
In hot arid zone, buildings normally face three main factors
Most Glass facade designs are based on average long-term concerning the thermal comfort principles:
wind pressure data; however, to justify short-duration random
wind gusts, gust factor can also be employed. Gust factor is the 1. Excessive heat gain in summer
ratio of maximum wind pressure to mean wind pressure, and is 2. Excessive heat loss in winter
most often used to estimate the accidental moisture gains due 3. High relative humidity level
to windblown rain [3].
In such climate zones, large amounts of energy are used in
b) Visual comfort: buildings, therefore, high cost is spent to provide thermal com-
fort for residents [22].
Visual comfort is a condition where human eyes receive a Natural ventilation works based on two issues: wind and
suitable amount of light without making an effort to visualize buoyancy. Along the building envelope, the difference in wind
some tasks, which strongly relate to the illumination levels pressure and also the difference between outdoor and indoor
inside the space either artificial or natural light sources [5]. temperatures generate natural air exchange between outdoor
Main parameters of visual comfort: The visual environment and indoor spaces. Also, Passive natural cooling generates
must allow people to see objects clairty, without strain, in energy by the usage of outside airflow, cooling it out and ven-
pleasantly toned surroundings. The parameters of visual com- tilating it to the building, without using fans or any other pow-
fort for which architects play a dominant role are: the level of ered mechanical systems. Passive cooling systems are typically
illumination of visual tasks, the harmonious distribution of used in designing the new buildings, but there are also some
light within a space, the ratios of illuminance within a building, cases where existing buildings can benefit from using the same
the absence of unwanted shadows, an exterior view, good color principles [7].
Fig. 2.1 The Fundamental Principles of Glass Facade Performance. Source: [3] (modified by the researcher).
Impact of glass facades on internal environment of buildings in hot arid zone 1065
d) Solar radiation
Table 2.2 Shading coefficient for typical win-
dows [18]. Source: [18].
Solar radiation influences Glass facade considerably. It
induces high surface temperatures, which cause high drying Glass type Shading coefficient
rates, and inward vapor flows, in Glass facade. Radiation trav- Single, clear 0.69–0.73
els in a straight line between two surfaces. This fact facilitates Bronze 0.53–0.62
the prediction of location, period, and intensity of solar radia- Green 0.50–0.61
tion based on sun path and building orientation [14]. Gray 0.48–0.60
Solar radiation that reaches the earth surface consists of reflective 0.17–0.28
two components. These are direct and diffuse solar radiation. Double, clear 0.60–0.70
Bronze 0.43–0.53
The earth is surrounded by an atmosphere which contains var-
Green 0.40–0.52
ious gaseous constituents, suspended dust and other solid and Gray 0.38–0.51
liquid particles. Due to this solar radiation is altered through HP green 0.33
absorption, reflection, refraction or diffraction [14]. Reflective 0.12–0.20
Double–low E, 0.32–0.60
2.3. Light and heat transmission through glass facade Clear Bronze 0.23–0.48
Green 0.27–0.47
Gray 0.21–0.46
Heat exchange through building material is quantified by the
HP green 0.25–0.39
thermal transmittance or U-value which is measured in W/
m2 K. U-value is the rate of loss of heat per square meter,
for a temperature difference of one Kelvin or degree centigrade
between the inner and outer environment separated by the gies aimed at maximizing the performance of glass in terms
glazing. Heat loss is also quantified in terms of thermal resis- of light transmission, heat blocking and safety issues [1].
tance or R-values. R = 1/U-value or R = m2 k/w. Table 2.1
shows the U&R value difference between Single, Double and 3.1. Glass types in terms of thermal performance
Double with low E coating glazing. [12]
The amount of solar radiation transmitted through the In terms of thermal performance and safety glass are classified
facade of a building is a function of the available radiation, as shown in Table 3.1:
area, orientation, and heat transmission characteristics of the
exposed facade. Solar gain through glazing can be as high as 3.2. Energy efficient and day lighting glazing
85% of the incident radiation [12]. The thermal performance
of a glass building is determined by its shading coefficient. The High-Performance Glass range of products, while being
The value indicates how the glass is thermally insulating (shad- relatively energy-intensive to produce, can, due to their
ing) the interior when there is direct sunlight on the panel or energy-saving properties ‘‘payback” that energy in a matter
window. It is a value ranging from 1.00 to 0.00. The lower rat- of a few months once they have been installed in a building.
ing, the less solar heat is transmitted through the glass, and the Solar and thermal characteristics have a large influence on
greater it’s shading ability, as shown in Table 2.2 and Fig. 2.3 the energetic performances of facades. Bioclimatic needs of a
[18]. facade are determined by three elements [12]:
3. Architectural glass 1- Heating: Heating needs depend on heat loss of the glaz-
ing (energy loss) which can partly be balanced by solar
It is a fact that glass is nowadays extensively present in the gain. The U-value is the key parameter to influence the
facade of modern buildings, thanks to its wide aesthetical pos- heat transfer through the glazing.
sibilities supporting the creativity of the architects. But glass is 2- Air conditioning: Cooling needs will be influenced by the
doing much more as it also plays a key role in the energy effi- solar factor. The lower the g value, the more efficient the
ciency of the building. Indeed, the last generations of glass glazing is at blocking the entry of solar energy and less
products for facade allow natural light to enter generously into air conditioning is required [12].
the building while drastically reducing the cooling and heating 3- Lighting: The higher the light transmission of used glaz-
needs, and providing to the occupants an improved comfort by ing is, the least artificial light is needed .The specification
cutting glare and noise [1]. Current researches, and technolo- for the solar factor (or Shading Coefficient), the light
transmittance and the U-value of the glazing has to be
made according to the building design and its localiza-
tion, the size and orientation of the glazing’s. Simulation
of the energy efficiency enables to determine the optimal
Table 2.1 U and R-value for 6 mm thick glass [12]. Source:
glazing while minimizing the sum of the three kinds of
[12].
energy consumption [12].
Type U–value, W/m2 k R–value, m2 k/w
Single 5.4–5.8 0.18–0.17 The specification for the solar factor (or Shading Coeffi-
Double 2.8–3.0 0.36–0.30 cient), the light transmittance and the U-value of the glazing
Double with low E coating 1.7–2.0 0.59–0.50 has to be made according to the building design and its local-
ization, the size and orientation of the glazing0 s. Simulation of
1066 Mohamed Ahmed Alaa El Din Ahmed Sayed, M.A. Fikry
Fig. 2.3 Heat loss through single and double glass. Source: [18].
A solar control glass is a glass with a special coating Self-cleaning glass is a dual-action self- cleaning glass man-
designed to reduce the amount of heat entering a building. It ufactured by depositing onto glass a transparent coating com-
reflects and absorbs heat as well as filtering light for reduced posed of photocatalytic mineral material, which have 2 actions
glare. Using a solar control glass can reduce the need for air- as shown in Fig. 3.3.
Impact of glass facades on internal environment of buildings in hot arid zone 1067
Glazing with high light transmission and Glazing with a lower light transmission and low solar
medium to high solar factor to help to warm the factors more adapted for warm climates. To clarify, there
are three glass categories in different strength.
building. These glazing are perfectly suitable for
cold and mixed climates or for glazing with low These are Annealed glass, heat- strengthened glass and
sun exposure. fully tempered glass. Of all the three, Annealed glass is
commonly used due to its good surface flatness and not
heat- treated. [12]
Fig. 3.1 General types of glazing (high and lower light transmission). Source: [12] (modified by the researcher).
4.1. Introduction
a) Thermal condition
b) Solar condition
After reviewing the literature that has been presented and Fig. 4.4 Dry blub- temperature. Source: [8].
obtaining basic building and weather data, this information
was used to simulate the energy performance of the building.
The simulation software used for this research was E-
QUEST, then use software CALUMEN. By clarifying and jus-
tifying many examples and appropriate strategies [4].
space 600mm
6 mm Gray tainted
glass Outer facade
Fig. 4.8 Strategy 1 wall sections and glass window. Source: the researcher, 2019.
W: The west facade individual, without the other facades. 4.3.1.2. Summary of strategy 1 output.
All: Applied to the four facades together. 1) In simulations, the first set (N) consists of the North
Facade only a double glass-faced either in the case of
the use of four facades consume a huge amount of
4.3.1.1. Strategy one analysis. The considered facade, consists energy for cooling. Energy cooling is reduced by approx-
of 6 mm gray taint glass (al. fixed) as an outer layer and imately 8% in this case as shown in Fig. 4.9.
6 mm clear glass as an inner layer and separated by an air 2) In the case of using a double glass facade in the four
space of 60 cm. Table 4.1 illustrates the main output achieved facades, the building will require to increase the cooling
to the building in New capital of Cairo. capacity by 60%, but when using the shading on the
1070 Mohamed Ahmed Alaa El Din Ahmed Sayed, M.A. Fikry
Table 4.1 The percentage of output achieved in strategy one. Source: The researcher, 2019.
Cooling energy Peak cooling Annual cooling Lighting
00 100% 100% 100% 100%
N 93% 96% 93% 39%
E 113% 110% 112% 41%
S 103% 101% 103% 38%
W 119% 122% 116% 42%
All 161% 159% 160% 43%
4.3.2. Strategy two description Fig. 4.10 Breakdown of energy consumption of strategy one.
The considered facade of strategy two, consists of a brick wall Source: The researcher, 2019.
facade with glazing area working as a double glass facade
Table 4.2 and Fig. 4.11 reducing the overall U-value of the
facade is the main objective of this facade. Hence reducing Table 4.2 Shows the basic output obtained by analyzing
the cooling loads by reduce the solar heat gain the facade Strategy two. Source: The researcher, 2019.
opens from the bottom in the summer to get hot air out of
the glass facades. However, In the winter, the facade is closed Cooling energy Peak cooling Annual cooling Lighting
to heat the air and maintain the internal temperature of the 100% 100% 100% 100%
building. The facade combines transparent and non- 85% 92% 86% 65%
transparent materials (spandrel glass facade) to achieve the 79% 86% 85% 23%
balance between daylighting and heat gain reduction. 72% 76% 75% 71%
Brick wall
a) The double glass facade layering effect Fig. 4.13 Breakdown of energy consumption of strategy strategy
two. Source: The researcher, 2019.
Although the use of two glass layers would reduce the U
value of the facade, it will also have a lot of radiation and con-
The introduction of shading devices for double glass facade
vection heat transfer across the glass which may fall into the
has the effect of decreasing the consumption of cooling energy
cavity trap. From the simulations, it can be seen that:
by 2–5% to become fully transparent by 100%. The double
glass facade in the north and the horizontal shading are more
i) Single glazing facade (The first strategy) Consuming a
efficient for the same facade without shading devices.
little less cooling energy (4–8%) than the traditional
As a result, it can be inferred that an appropriately shaded
individual facade so it is not considered the best solu-
double glass facade would lead to a limited energy consump-
tion. Replacing the four facades with double glazed
tion of the building. It also reflects the appropriate architec-
facades is a bad solution because the cooling capacity
tural identity of the country so Spandrel gray glass has
will increase by about 30% so it is recommended to
therefore been used to build the ministries with 6 mm HD
use it only on the north facade [2]. The second strategy
GREY tempered glass [15]. As Fig. 4.15 shows.
is the most efficient in energy consumption and trans-
parency in the hot arid zone, with a total cooling capac-
4.4. Case study analysis with the simulation software
ity of 13–28% less, which is a combination of
CALUMEN
transparent layers of glass and non-transparent brick
(spandrel glass facade). In terms of transparency, the
southern facade has the least transparency but the CALUMEN is the software that selects appropriate glass type,
northern facade has the maximum transparency. it is a calculation tool enabling you to produce performance
Although, the west and east facades having equal trans- reports for numerous combinations of Glass products in sin-
parency using half of the north facade is a good solu- gle, double or triple glazing. To evaluate the technical perfor-
tion. Fig. 4.14 shows the transparency of the facade mance of the glazing and reaching the building required
along the strategies [15]. technical values. By using filters as Summer Comfort, Daylight
b) Effect of the facade shading on the energy performance Comfort, Acoustic Comfort and safety to achieve the comfort-
able interior environment in the ministries building, Egypt.
From the CALUMEN simulation with the international stan-
dard ISO 9050 Saint-Gobain Glass, there are two Glazing
Configurations available for utilize in this building with classi-
fication like (Thermal transmission, Solar factors, Energy fac-
tors), Figs. 4.16 and 4.17 illustrate it [9].
Fig. 4.14 Transparency of the double glass facade by direction. Source: The researcher, 2019.
c) Building structure
Fig. 4.16 The two appropriate types of double glass from CALUMEN software. Source: [9] (modified by the researcher).
Type 01 Type 02
Fig. 4.17 The classification of the two selected types. Source: [9] (modified by the researcher).
users comfort inside buildings. In addition to, study the effect year and finding appropriate geometrical configuration for
of buildings glass facades on occupants0 visual and thermal the facade. Therefore, it is recommended that architects and
comfort, then propose a suitable methodology for the selection researchers be engaged in a comprehensive and holistic study
of appropriate glass material as well as effective shading sys- of their environment before major facade design decisions. Cli-
tems, which respond to the incident solar radiation. matic analysis and interpretation have to be integrated into the
The Internal Environment optimization is brought through design and fabrication process starting from the schematic
solar path study during those critical hours and days of the phase of the design. In addition, it is suggested that glass
1074 Mohamed Ahmed Alaa El Din Ahmed Sayed, M.A. Fikry
Fig. 5.20 Architectural Modern Egyptian theme, [6] (modified by the researcher).
Fig. 5.21 Building elevation structure (stone cladding and concrete skeletons), [21].
Impact of glass facades on internal environment of buildings in hot arid zone 1075
material importers have to study the performance of the mate- [10] Green Architecture, John Wiley, 2001.
rial in the local context and the architectural identity of the [12] Norbert Lechner, Heating, Cooling, Lighting: Sustainable
place, before supplying to the building industry. Design Methods for Architects, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2015.
It is suggested that future studies and experiments to be [13] J. Pejtersen et al, Indoor Climate, Psychosocial Work
Environment and Symptoms in Open-Plan Offices, Indoor Air
made on effective shading devices for existing radiation vulner-
16 (5) (2006) 392–401, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-
able buildings in the city. Type of glasses, shading devices and 0668.2006.00444.x.
effective angles for different orientations should be studied to [14] Permasteelisa Group, The control and recovery of solar energy,
produce a general municipal guideline which evaluates upcom- https://www.permasteelisagroup.com/.
ing facade designs in the city before construction permit. [15] Research - faculty of science – university of helsinki. Double
skin facades-structures and building physics, http://www.
References helsinki.fi/facultyofscience/research/mannila.html.
[16] Dirk Saelens et al, Energy performance assessment of multiple-
[1] Andrew, MOOR. Architectural Glass: a Guide for Design skin facades, HVAC&R Res. 9 (2) (2003) 167–185, https://doi.
Professionals. Mitchell Beazley, 1989. org/10.1080/10789669.2003.10391063.
[2] S.K. Chou et al, A Study on the Effects of Double Skin Façades [17] Tobias Schulze, Ursula Eicker, Controlled natural ventilation
on the Energy Management in Buildings, Energy Conver. for energy efficient buildings, Energy Build. 56 (2013) 221–232,
Manage. 50 (9) (2009) 2275–2281, https://doi.org/10.1016/j. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2012.07.044.
enconman.2009.05.003. [18] Solar Control & Shading Devices, Sol. Energy 2(1) (1958) 43,
[3] J.A. Clarke, C.M. Johnstone, Assessing and benchmarking the doi:10.1016/0038-092x(58)90020-3.
performance of advanced building façades, Mater. Energy [19] Sustainable Bioclimatic Second-Skin Façades Save Energy,
Efficiency Thermal Comfort Build. (2010) 484–502, https://doi. https://www.imoa.info/molybdenum-uses/molybdenum-grade-
org/10.1533/9781845699277.2.510. stainless-steels/architecture/bioclimatic-facades.php.
[4] Dania González Couret, Design Criteria for Warm Humid [20] Michael Wigginton, Jude Harris, Intelligent Skins, Elsevier,
Climates, World Renew. Energy Congress VI (2000) 534–540, 2006.
https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-008043865-8/50102-1. [21] Glass Structures Design and Construction of Self-Supporting
[5] M. David et al, Assessment of the thermal and visual efficiency Skins. Birkhäuser, 2007.
of solar shades, Build. Environ. 46 (7) (2011) 1489–1496, https:// [22] Z. Yılmaz, Evaluation of energy efficient design strategies for
doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2011.01.022. different climatic zones: comparison of thermal performance of
[6] P.O. Fanger, Thermal Comfort, McGraw-Hill, 1970. buildings in temperate-humid and hot-dry climate, Energy
[7] Hassan Fathy et al, Natural Energy and Vernacular Build. 39 (3) (2007) 306–316, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Architecture: Principles and Examples with Reference to Hot enbuild.2006.08.004.
Arid Climates, Published for the United Nations University by
the University of Chicago Press, 1995. Further reading
[8] ECG, and Dar El Handsa Consults, Final report governmental
district at new cairo, 2018. [11] Heinz W. Krewinkel, Buildings: Material, Structure and Detail,
[9] Gobain Glass Exprover, Saint, http://exprover.saint-gobain- Birkhaüser, 1998.
glass.com/.