Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(Studies in Continental Thought) Martin Heidegger - Plato's Sophist-Indiana University Press (2003)
(Studies in Continental Thought) Martin Heidegger - Plato's Sophist-Indiana University Press (2003)
by the anc"-'1115,
and ~ fourlb" lhe pttIpt"l" one. is lhen estot>hshed b" h'm. FiNllr. in LN
gt'IltlTffiofo<' rt CQl'rUpri.mc. ,\ris.otk· inqulI>:!S inlt) the GWl1tia. "'hich a",
theln5eh'l"! qui'" parlicuLor 6lll(l.l wilhin tIw tOOtl 6\'1:1l. And lh.>1 is !he
reason 6911\, ClInov, 'u,,1 oro'leiO\' a", OCI:""i"""ny id,""kal in """ning
for AnslOll", but only in a fonn;sl Sl'fISO!: laket1 strictly, they a", t.lo.....J fo'
parlieular reams 01 Bring, This conflttl"'lion "'ilh the ancil'11l! is, in all
Ih"", wa)'5 Aristotle carries il {JUI, dilft:renl from the Platonic one, ~ince
Aristotle already had a uni"OCll, ",,'rn jf nOI ,odical1y concrh'l'd, basis for
lhe onlOlogkal mode of questioning. "CCluil'\'d O<ll withoull!w plelimin:lry
"'ork nl P1~to him...lf.
Tht dt\-"lopMl;'1l1 0/ C~k ontology d<;Jel; no! p ~ 10 a coUe<:tion of
onlological re5UllS ,n \he senscof a !waring up of ,....,.,found catq;-ories.On
the contrary, its prope- "'o'k is CIll'l«'n!tated upon the el.tbot'3lion of lho.'
milieu in which (1l\loiogjcal re5earch can mO"e in l>"""tal,l-lere is I~ prop'"
cenler of Cl'Nk ~rch. Only if we Itam 10 understand mis. "',11 t!woe
t'XiSllho1 pKlSpl"ct of making our past producti,.., again. Pdrm....ides ~ins
lhe e1abnralion of lite mili..... from whidllh~quesli"" of tlw I:Ieingof bocings
can bt .... ~. This peeulia, loundahonol ~arch was nol, for t~ Gn.o<:b,
explici' 35 .lId>, but ;n fact .hci, ... ork ",,,,'«1 ius< much in 011,· Hdd cl
~ <IS in INI of 6\'.Spedfll"'all)", >.00:; is,lor Cn. ·k onlological """'arch,
the ,,'ar of;1otti'iS 10 lhe Sringofbt'lngs. Thisdoes not mean. oowc-'er, thai
Gn.""" ontology is depmdl'nt On "logic";' "''' would first ha".. lo""k "'hal
logic w'" for th.. Greeks. and ""~ mal' no! impure to Ihmt ,h. n>O\k'm
cCln<.'epl of logic. Plato', cril1qut of the pm'ious age has lhe inlefllion 01
carryinJI oul the onlologM:a1 owr and against th.. onlic, I.... ca"*,ri.ll,,,·
plicalion of l3ting o\'<'" and as"'n.st an onlk dl:':SCripliofl of beings, i...., of
making lhis ontological fllSe3rch ''isiblt f~ lhe lil'S! time In ilS buk p.uts.
Fo' II was Indeed an unheard of <IISC"","')' ", 5<'\' Ilelng 0"(.. oro "&lIASI
beings, rhougll. to be "'..... Parm""ides. ..'1>0 hims<:lf "'''S no! dea' "boul
It. took lhfo fir$! Slt'p in thi:!! direct'on ""h Ihe _n"ngly trivial prindpl<":
be,ng!! an'. This princ1pk' pla~ him jund,m('fl~~111' beyond beings in lhe
"""'" of a description.'
n,., hl.roriall consideration MalO p,di~,'!l '" h.,; P"'Jl<" d;;'lc<.k,,1 dis-
cu""i"" is meanllt)confmnl notl>ftll' all "'" pn,>\'ious philosoph;e" but lhe
one of his contemporaries as w~IL TIlt ronsiderdtion lheftby ""'lUlre> a
dear .rlieul.too.
I. The lfuruSliIOl'1 01 th~ Ancient Doctrif\CS of cW (2~2c-2~5c)
I. Tilltb&o<doo~(""r:104)
:. E.t...-l z........ Oir I'ldl.'''pl... "",~. ~ l.oQ E".", lIotn.,7. AWL. Lo,~!- ,m.
Pr· ,(ColO!;.
3. Enoln _ f'<Jo. , ~h • .oJ U""_~_l>p.t.-Ikr G""""". EtMt llo1flr. rift·
I>ufgL~. I!'l(\Z o: It.>Uor. F..O Il"''ii.1Ing Itl"I tn"",tI,'Ul.u,,,,,,,",..,...,,...,J ....._or
1-. ~ .... (1. 1IM<l<'lfL,,1> IhrOrr"""" (rP· jlO-llb).Nl ph""""Pt'f (1'1' t:V-I"<)
--,-[-
,3[.[i[ - - ' , 01- -'- ~"'-;l''"''''.''
~'!.O~~'loS!::::I:··~~~~'::::l~-~:&.~·lilfg~gt:;05' ~
2" Q. ,,!:. ~~. _ ii ::'.' ~"., '" ~ m iC ,"" "'" - •• 5' <;;: ~ ;;: 'C Co "
.~';'"
. .3 . .~ ::t~::e.aE!!!.~·~~~Q·o",rt";:{r~$
~. _$_" ,,1:_ :I,.>",'l"if~ 'I,~~~"", ll.~ e~
if· ..... '"- 0 tE .
lJ~
~ Q. :;I
f :;I
t .r J
• [ ....
~q §$ g. Ill'':!' 8II c.~~ill if- ~ ~,,-'';;;' -~ ~§: t, i- "~~ '""'[ ...~ ~c: l!~ !ro"_. l ;::i'~~ ~ ~ g ~ l"~!c: !-; p
ijt" '!r <I ~ g, 3 ::i: =-" [- ~ ~ = 5' ~ ~ a (> i ,.; ~.~ ;;: " " ai I' .. 8': "" ~ S" ~ ; ~~_:;;l
- .. "!l''''2'3
I I:il!lra,·.i~!I~I'I'~1111 •• [~!'i3•. li;",'
~ "5''''~·''''''0s- ~~"~:':'''i''' ~ ~l-
"" ':";"c~
a. ,/;
":J-:=l~~ l ~~<Z"'.!:oQ.~."
, ~. [~p , I .,~.'I:''C ,: l" [.,
r r. f ~ I "",..1!'f! .l,~ < i:;.",s.~"",<i'O _.J!; 'iI·' ,.-
:>- 3"J:ri, ~>l!i~g~
C.'l-'l-'5..,"
..... g:,;:>;,;<;;.
$_.,..-8" .. g"~::""""'>\'I'i"'fl'l'"
~ ... '2llo ll g··""",_
_::l._
-- :>
:::··a".·" <.-",
.:<' 3 ~"'a."1?'< '<!!l';;'~'''' .~ .. "~i.~~;.
fir\'! ;1.if t
,~5~~_~f~!f-fstffl~.4Iflf~:f~~~:fr~t:
~ g ., ... " 0
.H"·!-<' t'., ~ s,,q•• ......
p iI',;,: £1' .. _" 'Ili" 'f
, ..•. ~,...,l-,~-· ~-""'~. ~~~5.-[
;. 0",,-,,1 0'"
1"III~I-i!'l·ail: 11.:f'!'i.~i~I."ril.fli
-:rt'9"-'"~~O-''I~''''"U~~~''~''''' "'1;'::-5,:0:- 'f
~n~!
~
n",_
- ,,: •
"' •.. _i
'
~ ~ tj ~;, [i: ~l.~!'i i l~ ~- ~ "i ~.~ ~ l t1 ! ~: 5.~. *~ t;:;.~ t i::.
',~ "'i! 1,.,l'P ~ ~~ hi'![! ~,I" ~p F'J~; l:<d
·.ra3IK·'~·r.~I·I'.· ~'~I".I.~J ~~" 51: 1'- ~:
~5'l~~ ·~i.':!:~B::::;;;~·~~'8%;;:€' i.i",:;~.~Jl:,~!8~ ~.;~ - '4 n'<
~. ~. ~...a.
[~"""~~'''P'''[<;>~t l!
_'l~§.o3~.§fJ[Q't_""f"~;.,!i;;· 'f'!';:''''l~l'~~
~:1~itr; ..... -it~a".. !~t~
;~~,~§:l:-l{~'~~J i~!~i~ ;".. t"it~
W'O""Il~'-'I;I""'-'~ ;f' ~;r -
-e<~~~7~.~ji~'";,",f
,.,a ~:yl~-$i..
-111--'-'"' ,;a
cf;l. "oil"J!lii;r~5't' _,1.~
~ .. " "", GilS
..t~.lli.'l"r.
•. ~"" .:I!it_15
§651~~71
itself. In oIher wo<d.'l, Pl.lIQ .n.n,'s Ih<'J'cl>y Ih~l II...• aIlS"'''' m.c
rhm ta
IWvta d(ll'll not .01 aU k>uch Ihe qUlSl"lln <>f fleing, I ....id f .... l",dili"",,1
int"'Pl'I'1ali<)n.of Zelle•• Ilonil~.' ell:• .russes l/w> a<;lual m~lter al ~u ... II ~
nol al all fIl'«'SSlry tel analFA' the f\lS1 of 1M ~ubst.,nU,·e que!ltiOfl ""re. For
lhe proper tMne of Ih~ io'·elig.llion is made abuod""Uy clear al 2#<1.
"Ent&l '01,,,,, 1\llI'i~ 1\nop1\"flI'£". iJsld; «lid.< 1\l'i~ tjlto<:t,'li;tv i"m'W.;. tI
~on: jloUl.l:<:riIr "'lIl«ivt'W lltt6tIXY el\' ~ (a4ff.). uE!«:a..,.. we dQ nol
know any way OUI as rt"jpnls "'hal youa~ S")'ing h£o~. you rourscll ml.l51
u
c1.lrify for us ...hal you properly m"an "'hen you utter Ihis won:l6v. 1'1"'1
i~ Ill<' ",""'ndy ernl",1 Cl:'t1ctT1l cf 'his pI1;;;t1~ ~th1 of the w'ho:>k d;,,/ogJJt,
Tmay " ... ,,~t.- an "".""..hl.. ,...."m ttl met.• ""¥",;,,, anti <w'ltnlnm' R".
lhe '1ue;linn !'laIn "'ises here and poM'S by me.ms of I~ woole di.>loguc
has. in all hasl~. bftn forgolll'n. This for~ing of lhe ",.. in quesli(>u is"oUy
for US toda)'. For we (;In "pJ'f'a" cilher e>rplicill)' Or silmll)', tel two things:
1.) The ~ of IIdng i5 obvious e>'eryon,- U5o!S 'I roostanllr and
undE1'Wlnds ..hal I\e means b~' il
2.) The c<>r>l:epl 01 fleing Is I~ higtw.",t: therefore il cannl" al all b<>definN,
As 10 Ihe first we must ",,,,,uk IMI 'f'<'r1 from I.... question of whethe'
lhe supplJ!l<'d unj"er&ll ot",iouslX'S6 oflhe meaning of Ilo.>ing!nil)' or may
1>O.l>c id""'rifoed w;.h the <1"";11 of" p<>;Io:Iorhk..1 """",,,pt. in My c..sc it
is p~ly !his ob\'iousness. and nothIng ..L<e. tI>JI is I.... Ihe..... of .he
funWm....tal.<cimCll!.
As to lhe se<ond, "." must rema,k llul illwi nol 1>0..'\_'0 d~odde<! ",,,,-othe,
lhe CClnCt'pNai .. I.lbo",lion of lhe fundmm'Obl CON:>.'f'lS ""'~' be f"l'i"d
und.... lhe rules that d"'~rml"e ~ dl.'flnilion. "'hich il!;(:11 Presl.'Ots onl,. or\('
fonn of delennitU>lion.. Ilw .....' origj""~ng in a C('rf~ln propos.itonal and
a ~ 1 "logX.u The "log;"" of lhe determirolion of bt>ings ""'y!>01 ~
;n,'O;.oo ;t5 tho!- cnlerion fo< lhe ",plication of Ilcing. Tl>erd'on! Ihe us"aJ
lalk ~bc>u. lhe indefinabilily (l( IlI.'mg m~...ns IlOlhing. It merely man'fests
lhe common rnisund"rsllmding 01 "'hat is ~I issu"
\V'tth reg;>rd tel tho primal)' t.l$l< of any possible ClOloI<>g)', II mUSI be said
f'O'iti"dy thaI il resides f>""Cilo<'ly In the "",.."'lion, d' lIll' p"1"'r.ti"" of a
ground to iOSk aboul lhe "",ming of l:I.;ng in ~l. The quest...... of I"'"
meaning <i Ik-ing-"'h"t Beins "",a"" in ~~....l, io.he ...·n"" of l!w: pmpo-
slrion from P1a!O dtJl'd ..txn,,-,,, not ~ . lhe fi""l question ofOOloiogy,
md Ittis ~ cannol be ans"'em:! by a ,ummalion of onlOlogiCllI results.
On theronl""y. the qucstionof l~ me......g of Bo.'ing s\.ondsal the ~",ning,
bocause il mu.'Ol pro>'kIcguidanre .>slo the JX-Ible """,oing in any roncn>Ie
l£ol..atd lrkt. Ow Plod,..,.,.. '*' Gnt</Im z~.....,. "... &$If' ~!I- A...o, Lnp»g,
tm,
_ PI''''''''''''
_• .J_AuIL.foeI1u\,I8eO,rP- _ ....
1ol 1
E~~rri!~t~~ei&~~!!ftfi ~-"~~~pH~
~ * ~:ii"~"':';~'~J"'~~!!:'-~'~:l - - ?." ~.,.. .. " ;I
:l2.~_.3l"'aJ:YI··
,,3~ ~?1~~['
.... ~ 't
is' t. ~ g, • '" .... :;~) . . , ~
j~--"-~""~
~"'~"
-;. 0 ai' _ ~
.
, ;I 'f
t;;1~E'~!i,""""'&.~k
"' "I:-;l •.
i(ilfl-' lli3~fjil
2.~~ ~[li!~i~r.~~113~~~ ~. ~ .. ,i1 ~~·~~~f.f%""~~~
:r
!-.,.
. ,,;; - ... ..,
.~-
~~ ~ 21!!.~ "le.t&"'"
· ' r '" ~31<'-"
~"!f.:;;:' oil ~ , ,2.,:j, ",:~ ... gJ:l'
'''& ' I' hf ioo.:~~~" 2. g. ~ ;:~'"~! ~!~'
1~ d_~~~"~'
..-~jf"'l6">i: l~~-''''
ol~fl~-~~ -<;:." I
_. :Eu;SIii ~o i""1l l!0< ,PWih!!
~~:: ~iflii·l"~-::(f,",,~!1',,·~g."'f";· ;:0:; ~=z. ,,'3-'
::!"&. <r.1ii·~j(i:!,;;~··£...,;.,3~~t 1ii J, [!
~>i 3'i1'3~iJ'~1 $-~-2 :.l=m~
,p: a~il~~i.~ i
&.[?'
... "" [ tf 1ji''''5'~ij03? -
'" ~.. - t..... ..
:fl
~~;:. ",·~, .. ;r~i"'O~"':: ,;~,,~~~
I:Jjiflil;ti~!llli ..;-g i'::; ...~ "" ~~ ,;;,~·~jlg:~·~ t
~.~ I Jil.~:ii'""'~t?~~ g.~ *. ] ,."
?"
i §""
i" glii·:::r'.~;;. ~
:;.
;~~. (,~~~at~~;'<i!~J~'::~t~:l
"~:l.
I!"~ ~.
-S:~clii'
~.'
~'~"sa.f5l'~'S.·"g:
- :>:T~ ~
':O'~
\". ;;. l
" ~
~
~5'9..Si~;;r~·
,,~:.,,~ "3~
1 0- ~ ~ !!l,&~~31-~...
~. o~~~-a;'''!5'
3
!i~ ~~~~~ ~ ~~-~~
.~p~il·II! . ..,-
•• '1 1• ,,
, "
. ::I. ,,_ _~ ~ "
~";
::r~ .. '"
~g~H'f<-_d~" ~Q- 1l'C <SQ<-"t !. ~,t~~o~ is.~~
oIl! I'~ ~"'d .d,·~ , p . 5', ,~ ~ ", e- Ii ~ ..
~ g .,., ;o.S'~:s,;~ !l ,,"".01~'.;§~':'; , ,;. Fi':;fq'
'~~ 5l~'Jli ~~7~<:Lg:i~~e::~~ -'~~Il,~l.~l
... Iii'::I ':1!' 2'" If;;.
tj ,,0" -
'3'Q< ~ ~ ~
~ ~.
~~f
~ "~lf~~
.." .,::1-<"" _ I- ~~ J~-.l~
.",~=::;s. .,~ ~,~~-
,~
<i s3,<5''
.il- [~'" '"'
Al....ady in the Ov0J.lo. itsdf. which is bul or><' roml'O"enl 0/ ;.n,o.;. !he
lroubk- with Ihis posiliOJ1 is ,·isible. The 6"",a. precisely as uVOIla. :as
""preWOfl, is suppoo;o.-d 10 ~ .." ('~pn.'SSiOfl of something; lhe m'OJ.la Jigni.
fies somelhi"s. .."d indeed som~hing U... 1l"0J.l{l itsl.'lf is nol ... t'lTll'l'-'
Nl£[; U'; to"'wo. roillt¢l'lIll:m.;I~po"ljooAt'p:112+kl)f.); ho>nC\' .I.....uly
,,, Ii><:' 6voIJ.a of "",,"'hing. in .. significalion , ..... t means somelhing. they
are ....ying h.·o 6vm. II Ih~}' waMe<! In identify Ihe uVOIla and Ihe
Soli..o\ij.l""oV,th<' e~pm;sion and Wh.ll is meal'll in it made ,-;sible init. lilt'"
indccd 11>1." e~pre<lSion would"" "" expre>sion of nothing. Or d5<'. if lhe
6wjl1l1l; still suPP'*'<l 10 be- an (j,"OIlu two.;. an e"P~i"n of SOlnl."lhing.
yet wilhoull""nt>y ,,--kning 10 50mcthing <>tI>I."r tM" ilSt'lf.lhen ttl u"opu
6vq.uto<'; 6VOjlu laO"()\'. iiUuu lit o\.olir'\~ 0" (2+kl5f.). Hlhis 6''OJ.I(l rould
onl)' be an bv<>t<lItO<; m'OJ.lo bUI nol lhe 6vopa of sorn<'Ihlng ,,150:." Thus
lhe diffkulty of this posllion is ..1....adydNr in a fundamental componenl
of),Qyo<;; Itself. We need I., noUn> thaI MalO;" helt" cof\a'iving lhe 0"01111
in the....".. 0/ ,Is me.. ning 5Omcthing. To bo: sun:. he <k>e!; noll\"ll""l f"nher
on the sf"'Cific .trucltl .... of I""connection 0/ the word with wltdl il n"',"5.
He is salisfied w;lh Ihf s.imple for"",l·onlOlogicaJ fact IMI 10 the "'ON as
word ""longs Ihal which is m".."t.l-I" under.;I.ond. thi. fact pu....l}' ontkally
here: something is together wilh tomething. In an ""p.........,., "'SUCh,IM""
is Ihus already a OUj.Iv.o."1\.
''ou "'-'<'d In...., ,"'arty IMI Ihis ronsid"r"lion eannol "" laken a~ me",
snphistic.ll ""....ow·bo.i"l:\. On ...... contrary. ;t is a n,atle. of laking lhe
lhesis l'\' 6" Til mv ... rious1r. Plalo is '<>n<:efll.,d to !J>ow th:at in Ihi5
itx08l'Ol; the.... resid"" a moment "'hieh n.·xh6 b<.')'Ond its o ....n P"'P""
....-. Tn Undl'"!%lnd I'Lllo's e:cphcation here and panicular/y in lhe fol-
kWdng case. ....e must ~iH' thai he has nol yet e~,borilted an ""luaUy
precise cof>C\'PI of Being ,·""'u. beings. bu' lrol the whole cunsid"rahon
f\I,," its routS(' in an ind,~ bet....""'" the onlkal al'ld the OIllOlogkal.
And Ihis applies nol Oflly I""re bul ullimatt.-Iy 10 II\(' .....d of lho! d;"log~,
SO IMI this unclarity, present In P\.JIO hirnst'lf, 'onoliNI"" III£' prnp<'f diffi·
rulty in unders~ll,.jing th.: d,alog..... llw:: ""plic.,lions. 31 fif\>l "Iew, gin>
llul ;rnpn:ssi<m of b(oing simple imitalions of sophislic..1 argum... .,b. St'l....
on lr>p 01 the lat;><11""'" ddini"~ in the firsl part. 'ho.'Y occ.,si<mt..orl Ihe
,.........'. p<>pub...",Iil "<'I')' ~Uy, Ihal Ihis dialogue. loged",,' with some
olhl"f5, was apocryphal. But if we a.... clear about the inl."'lion .....iding in
I.... Idea 01 diale<:tie_§ Ihis becam" v;sibl" in """"'-"'lion with lhe PIoJv.
d",~"ly the intenlion tn go b~' war 01 mway<1IY'I to"'ard ,he l'\'. so
IMI on lhe basi. of the t., lhe further c"".~et rislics or beings become
inteUigibl.., tho>n "0(> will not find oursdves ,n Ih diffICUlt)' of "ndl'"lS~,nd·
Ing thesto "rgum""ts as purel)' onlical in th ... sophislk.. I .....' nSe.
The ~!I, i..... lho: renelu,",," of I....• ''''''lid.-mll"" or IhI, tv a. a d<'I<:1'-
'--·-'5'''-'1' ;/ _. - ' I . . . . . ' q"·'H'·'·
~J~f~tIJ~~~rs ~~~lf~~f~B~ai~=s~!~~3~~i
f ~:;.. ~;. ~"':' :T~j": 3'~[.g >i>~~ !{l;'}~;1 ~ ~ ~[[-::a § ~i~. a ~
• ~ ;',~,l;" ;:- I it 0
! <' _ ~ " " 0 - : •
It."",
oJ oj "''''iii'' "~!·-il~"'-Co"!l.;;;j;:j!"lCo"''':l-. ~
~ i ,. - ,- ,<<>.~ l·.
iii Q.
a", - li:: ." ~ .. ;; ~ if '" - o' 1.l' < -
~ <: - ~ ~ il ~?;;;. g ~ : ",' il ~
I ;1 &. r. f ~ ~ ~ .~ ;. ~ ~ i " ~ ;: ~; ~ t ~~. ~ r ~ i~ ~ ~ a~ ~. l i· X[ ~ ~
i [lrl!!II!~:!1 ~ll~~II!:I!t(III!~1111~1
i ",~. -""i3--~-!> ~~;;;i"g-i,g",";:I':i'~9'~' a~ "''''21~
," "! ;: '" it ~?;'1:r 1'
.... 2' [~. ~! g, ~ !'! ~~ Il 3]. ~~. ~~ ~ Co 3 It> ~ j:ii ::l"l ? it ill
l' >'i! "''''i'''' 1;,_ -f::j . ",,,-"':'<Q< "'!::i-:l: t'cai3
"" O'!;&.~o;:l:;;'~!-~' _.~~ i!~·!:ii:l-~li"<:"00~ a;;::!.;:j! ,.- .....
J~:[~~~~~~~J ~.gJ ~~ti'!~~~i~a~' j·~Jl~:·is.~ l
1 '.", < , - , •• , -j
! - .-
a 1;; '" So v; ,,' if ? i'! l.
q
-',,". -~_ . d -. " ".'< I
c ~ s i." 8 9. ;:j!" 6":T~ "'::: _
f ~=
11;'''0 a~3;l;i=;'::r-,
",,,,0<'3.;;;'''' c-
1- l! ~ . . 00"'~:T
-00<"11'<'" =-:.
;. ..·0-0 <3"i-l~_~_!"
..... :l:'" ",- f
.'i'~B;>,d'
~~.:[e..~~ ~""'e1t'
..
10'
,10 ;.~,-.~,.,«. "1,,, ,e
"pi! '~31 .. ]O~O 'i .... "'~~::,.. ~ ~
J ~~·~·l·~~~_~~.:i~if i ~~l!~~S6.il~~g. F1f.~~.~~]~-
~ lr;-~53r;l:"';~~:l ~Ji":l: ':;~"''' 0- "al"~~a."
~ ;:. . $ ~ :l'.
z,!f
"1;/ 'I ~ f~ ~ ;l~ s:it ~;~. ~ .. ~ ...~ 1r iii
~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ [~i if~ !·t 101 Q' '"
;; 8~ ..~ '"
~
i! ~Jj.
=. ~ !!j
, ''''''.I1"'i~.' !;···~U=-,j! ~~l~-'i'·
... :;1"..0:"
I !iii!!' 5
l!~ii~'I~f~J~
~; 9-~~':2"~
ig~.! ~~li~~'I!~1
~~~2.s~e::
~il~~I~i
--"H.d' I f . , • ,.'-,.~.l
afJ.!lPv;·p.2.:TV:·~~ s.. ... li,!f":!~r;.r.I·i5·='::;
•~ '",,,,'
." ;:.;Ij''''a.'I'~G;'~
bl The discussion of U-' .s ul.o\', Tlu diffc",,,~ b<:,wccn the
'"
tv as 6"",' and the tv aA'llM;. ConSN!uel\(fl for O,'.s 6Wv'
it> unlen.bility.
The i,."... loculoos "","' 1.1«> up _~"'" ' ......i. 01 Pa"""",idH. h·lw ro ft....••
(rom d diff<'f'ml point of "jc,,'. They do not ...mply consider that Ov is
;>ddrt.'55<.'d <os lv, bu' ;J\Stc.'>d I~' lake up the principle as a ,,'hole; t\'/h'
tV mv. WlLiI' this lhesi.~ duls ""th. pn>petly spe.tking. i5 0,- And this
«",hal,~ ptOOSt'ly 6\.', ill (orocein..:l in ilS ~h""," as rtirv; 0", ....·hkh is "'hal
is ~ken "bout, is under,ilnod from the n'''')' ouls<>l as t6 .{xv. And of this
« ..'hol.~ 6\', in this .no.... ~ "ro'. il15 s.,ld, lv. Thus , ..... fv is ,ho,
which i\ is
lIddres6l·.........
Thcql>e>tion r>oW is how ,,,'can b\o und,;>n;'ood.s I\UY. Tha, is. ~ncc lhe
e>.p""",ion t».o" nO"' appli.... \0 .av.the question is: in WMI liCfISt: isQv in
the th<-sOs O;l.cw? Th i. i"""-'d sup~ to"" Go ~6\'0\~ Hence it is """.
no longer. matter 01 fv and iW as 6,{pjl01Q bu. a nullet of elucid.l;ng.he
r:.:,'he one. ""iry. onelU.'56, since ir>d,~ the 6).0" is a rnndc of the lv. Ti lit;
16 Ow.., tttpov toil 0"'00; h'~ l'i tcrirt... ~ toUtll'; (d. 244dUf.l. "Is the liM'IV.
in which ..... is "",anl--<i,' which for ils pari i.add~ a5 fv-i.It"sli;..o",
.o.s a charnCl<':r of li~, !IOtT1e1hingother than the ..... b or the ... ~?" An.'~"Cr.
"H"", co.. ld they l\OI 5aY II is Ih.' 5amt'; the). c<'1'!.linly rkly &0 in the t....•..s'"
((>1). Ih.t whal sort of concl'J'l of li;..o" is \)ei"S US('(! h~re? In this regard,
n.'i~ is flOW "'ad~ 10 a fragmml of tt... didaclloC 1'0'-'''' of I'annffikles
himself:
nW.'ToWv EU,.,;..;..o1l ooalpn; tvU).l"...~ov (;yo."lf/,
llEooOOtv iOOltOli~ 1<6>'''!I' '0 y(jp 0(,,,, 111'ci~""
outt 11 1\a,6ttpov !tcl.b'Ql XP£<W Ion til f\ tfi j2.we)if.).
From this It isdear thill 0.' is understood in lhe..,nscofa o6oip<t. a sphere,
and il'ldeo.>d a weli'round<'<!~, comparable th"SlOa ...·ell·ru.. nd;>d "phen:',
a ...·hoIe (li'p."1fl h"'" meam Ihe same.os (;}.,pl, which I'lOO6Qr:v, "from the
m,ddIeOllt:~, "going Inll11 din."'llom." is <'<llMlly >Irons; "'I '" inda"<l
nol pCIIlSiblt' for it hl be in anr """"" swaler or slronger M'''' or there."
lO'oilt...... yr. 6~ /<>6). """"""hing hlu> th.~t," l~ the meaning of 6),ov in
Pannenides. A,a tOloUtO" 6;..0,· it has 3 fl1o<>~ and ~<T,(O:to: (etil. from lhe
middle OIll. in all di~Ii<>m;. up It) lhe outer limilS 01 lhe 5pho.>n>. 6" is
uniform, Now if1sofar as the 6Mn' has a "'iddle ""d "",,,,,,,illes,'t is SOlI.....
thing Ihal .... sl'ljl~ (en. "parts." Th..sil isa mall.,.,.of an mhrely ",.nkular
... ho~, a whok which has parts. and this wholffieS6 eM bo;> .. nderstood
35 "nity in a special sense, 'Aut. Ilfl~ T6'1t: l'lJ'CP."\'b"',' Jt6:9o.; IJh- tOU
0-0.; l'):E'" bI, tol<; I'tptQl !tO,ow o\>llt" <'vro..",...(,E~ 0;:(11 tau'TIli" ltlrv tf: 60,'
"cd {ww b- £1\..., (245.>lff.). Tlw- Ol..o,' is Ihllt' a 1U"1'EPICJllh'\IV, or, as AtislQlle
'"
",ill say 1.l1i'r, ~ &mpn6~.' "something that can boe taken .parl.~ What is
,".S""'I)' SC\'n in this noticm of ttw:- 6Mv ~5 IlfllfP10\ltVQV Aristotle L,\C,
ur>(/(orstood rlgo"",uslr in the mn<:epl 0/ ClV\'Q;t;,O St>dl. 61.0",,, olw" in
th<> ~ of thl' I'QIlPI~". can then>/"", lid,... ~dtIo<, toil t\"6.;. i..... ;1
can ha"e th<> det<.>nnin:>tene16 of the one; in suo:h" 61.ov as I'fI'£PUJI.ll''Ov
the lv is ill liOnlC S<.'nst> presellt. But tllis tv is <juile partirolar; il is. tv lh.ill
is und...rstood bri tOi~ I'IPl'OI "u.n". on the b.>sis of parts. w,lh "1}1rd 10
part" tv .... ""~ Tlw;,rdoro, the 6)Jw as lii..cw IS mdCl'd a tv, but this
tMov, which as {M.o,' is" pouticuln l\", " one (w.. do not ha,'" K!rm5 for
these disti",,"ons. i.e.. for ,..... S('r>5(' of the unit.,. of a whole composed of
parts)--this 0).0" or one is '~t.>inll' not tQ tv aim) (H5a5f.), "the one in
i~lf.· For (tlw.>ugh no! ""id ho!re. this IS .... h.' is mNntJ un;ly In the """'...
of who"'-'f\eS& is ;OS such 31"'")'11 still _r"u.g else. Iw..... I)· oroeness. II is
refened 10 a mo", original one. Prior 10 it then> is a",se of tv bJ' which
it i$ ilSelf determIned as unity. lhis tv. which is prior 10 !he tv 61..ov, is
.... (pt~ lW\'tl'~ (d. as). ~,lltog'1""r withoul parts·; it is the w,'l6ci>; l\'
(ibid.). ,,"h.~1 .. uU,,""t.'I}· discl<l6<.'d of lIS Cl.:lSoi. Thus if wc follo..' up th<'
~ of tv. we ultimdlelr find th~ tv Uji£ptc;. or, in Ari~otle, the
aliullpno\'. Hcn<t' the ~,.o.; can sa}" thai Ihis tv, the tv u rooovrov---hmcc
not the bI M'l9U>; but the tv as auvqt.;--to.: ~ II£poiJI' ov (bl), "is of
many pam." and exists only 011 !he b.JsiB of them and /or them. !.luI. iIS
~l.OCh. Olt <nlf'$oWl\ofl ~ ).Qyljl (blf.), "Ihis tv does not coincide wilh the
genu;,w J;('n5e of t>'-if I address it pmperlr" And 11'I this wa), " fll'6l
distinction arises within the coRCl'f'1 of tv: 1.) lhe rn cUfl8ci>,; and 2.) the tv
as ~ tlIllOl~ Ilfpcm: the one as unll)' of parIS
No..' lhe int>:rlo<:uto<s again ask.: in whal ~ is the 6v "'O:v or 6l..ov~
Either II Is "".ov In the..,...., of lIMo.; tou tro., tIov (d. ~), or cl"" il is 1'1'1
61..ov. As'iuming WI 6v is a tv in lhE- 5e\St' of" den"ed tv. as ..'h<>1"......-.s.
tv ""'" (d. b6). then the tv is a Itli9oJ.,;; rou "VT~ But if so, then ov or 6l..ov
is noIlhe Solme as I.... t.. in lhe proprr 5enS<! (ba). Aocordingty. lhe liAuv is
a tlI;l'O" over and .galnst ltv. iMofar .os Ihc latter is under.<tood in t.............
of lhe tv as tv w,ljllollo.:;, But If t ..... lil..ov is something oIher lhan 6v. lhe result
is ",;;.mvo. m wV'" ;"'o(,.;ld. baf.). there issom<.'lhlng mon' lhan this tv. the
l\' ",,"lied in th"I3t"'c;. if!h" llt<ru; Itself says: tv 6v 61..ov. But if. accordingly,
liv It~Jf-by h;wing the Kl'dIo<; ,oil ;""6<;,-is not Itsorlf the lJl.ov (elf.). and
lhe liAo.. ;s Ih~'refonc pther lhan 6v. lhen this 6~uv is somelhmg ltv as ltv is
no\. Const<l"""lly. the", is ,;omNhlng "'hick li,';" nol, which faUs outside
of li\'. but which r,,,.......m..J..... is, Th"",fo... <w is ;""Iid~ taurou (d. cli,). it
IS in ItseJll'Iftdful in ovIatlon 10 Itself: -''<.'In.lng is Jacl:.ing to it. something
Il\;l\"e "head) <.'1Tlph."tii200 1h.~1 if lheso! things a .... I\'ad unp....p..:-edl}' and
,,'ithout Ih" ,,,,reet ontologiclll ba.1s they Me cornpl<'l\'ly roniu!!oing. tn
anticipation I want 10 note bridly Ihallh....,. Ilr(' Ih"", <,:"""",,,I UlClaril~
in Ihls whole ronsid"ralion_und"ntics und.'O'SlO<>d nol In a crllical ",-""",
as llliSl3kes Plait) "'-"do.. but in lhe senseof difficulti... ""iding in tho.' maller
i\Sdf and in IIH1 tr.1dition.ol war of <:llf\('E'j\";ng these things:
1.1 The uocbrHy In !he <"Orl<:<.'pl of lhe """"N: if 0" "di§lInguW\ed I"""
1I.\.o\".lht-n to >a}' lhat Ihe 0 ........ is not <W is Ilt Ihe .. me l'llle 10 soy lhal "".
is noI .soml'thing; lhe'" is something "hieh is not included in 1Iv. This is
po!i8ibll' only on lhe bas;, of an <SS('tlli.1 uncL'rill' in lhe "nol."
2.) The unc... nty wllh regard 10 the <fu;lloction betw<'OII\ 1I".os Bel'\'l and
II" as bcin8'" This difflC\llty is e,,,,,,,mated in the C""rlIC of lhe subsl.1nlk"
1 Plato'
dlsCWis:i n m a mut p ak f: a) th in f
characie:rs
that
) must difftia
the ut'br
6 {461-4 -J 31
d, can
E,
ance
variou
inre
Plato i
!lefo'" l'l.>lo cnlkally ex.lmin('S tnQI';.' pteci!lel}' the ,wo o,h... posihons, he
gi,",'S ~ preview of the Oppon<-'I'IlS in lhe Y11OvtOj.lOZ(0 upl ni<; oOOfo..;
(246;J./f.). 1\0,,,, f3('liOl\!l d'" in opp<>5ilion. Oi jIt\' d~ Y'lV t~ oUpa\w 0:01 mil
UopGwu mvtu lAl«lUOl, loi; IEpoI\' utQ.\W; Jtttpo<; >:(1\ lIpi.:;
Ittpl~~VO,'a: ... too\, 10lI ta'oVi"", /:ooJIt6Il""" ,wVtuIV &'Dz"",rl";o'"lO'
tolita ~ivo:o 1l000v lll<llPhll "f"l<JIX>1..1\" "01 ErICl(Il\" 11\"0,. toirtllv mil\In
"aI oootav 6p'l";6slI;VO~ tliJy lrt 1i.lJ.<d\. d rt.; <n.> 41o\Ol'l Ill\ oWp.Q qo" rl'V:l,
"Q~voV1'u;,; to KapWrQV >:0:.1 OOOf>' t\ltwl"m; 6Mo a"OIil',,' (246..1fO,
"'The ones ~ ~ \V:I toU 60p6tou nUvICl &r<o\IOJ'. dr.og down ~i:;
Y'lv. It> earth, e>·~rythinll from hl':.:wen and "'\'('T}'lhing 'Ml CAnr\O' be.,......
with sensible eye. and dumsH~' grasp "'ilh ~ir hands for rocks and o.oks.~
They Ny: toUIO [;\'0" IlOvtw lll<Q/lQ<l "I"OOflo;,I\,' "01 blOO\lv. ~only lha'
is "'hid> olfel'll ;~I/. and ca" be en<:ounll'"n.'d, in such a "'ar lho' i'l"'nnl's
being pressed upol'l.1<pOO{k>;'1\. being ","",ulled like" cit>dd or ba,.,;e.,dEo.
or being lOUChed. t:nat".~ Only "'M' can be O'nC1lun'......-e! in It>is "'a}', CAn
be gr;>$fXd. and can. as il "'~. be assaulted and IOtlched. genuinely is. W"
could SIlyquile'briefly 'ha' rn, this posi,ion wha' is is wM'.nROUn<.l!!l,~1f
'hrough l'1."Sistam:e. TIwrefo~. according to "'" guiding hneof 'his"""'i't
of oliolo aOO Bring. ~o >;(II oOOIa'I' wUWv llj:Il~6\u:1'Ol' "They delimi'
body, """ ... ial 'hing. .nod g.." 'u;"" Being.. p"""l>C<', ui><riu. as ,he .... n,.,.·
OUolo.. pre;ence. """"unco'S ibi'lf. ""d ccrtifi..", ;~lf. fOt ,hem prill1.:lrily
dnd solely through bodily ...sisIanC\". Any'hing .... , cannni t>.. ..""",,,n'~n.'<I
by way of It>is n-sis.. ~ is not. l1\,l, is how we are 10 und""''''nd this
posi'ion. If we call U - f"'OPle ma ...·rialis!S thai could mean t~y.", like
Vog'.' M~hott.' and Buchner.' That, ho"·,'nr. has ",o'hing 10 do wilt> it
~S·""~:o.ST~<Tea;~;;·STii:· 'il3"'25!''C:T!'':!!::)~~·--·oQ.o:;.I:~g- ~.,:~o.$;l ~
" i i p . ~ , ~ ! l. 'c ~ , , , , • ~. } d' d ~
], .~ ;; j i •.
, Fq ~ "
~8 tor~J;,
" ~ 5- aill .... r :.-"1." ;j
~ ~t fJ~~'~ ~!J~~
!i: s.. ~
!'~~]~
~;;
~~ [;!
t f1.'0: :I. _.
1 ii ~~. ~ ~ ~ J! ~'i i.
f
Il:'~ ll""3 "'l:f ~ s' "~'!:O;'!:. 0
~~<TII~fl",~f'~rDII~,-
.. ''C 'C ... <:I
f'4iiJlr~~1~1~ft~}~I~R
0. ''''''00-.;\
if Ii' •
f~~~!
'~:>'..., "'I:: ,." [
1, 3..-1],'1"·}1'·"'-"
t f ~ Jl ,,' f ri' fa. = - is
,- j .~n"I;'~'J f,;i~i
f : ;" :! ~ : ~ 5. ~ _ e g ,., - 5" ~; ~ a- ~ ~. 9"~;' 3" §:
~~!111:illiri;ffl~fiJ~11I[!J~rf~';!J !!~~~ l
~!!II!IIII[I!II!lti)f!~;~~f~!{~lliil II~!I I
;is!"
f; hHi.H"I-·~:H'iH~~[;lj~H!!
""._=~- s.~'rJ.?_'~l<>~~~a.,,·~:!=,~ii I Hf!:1 ~il B 1~
~~·Sl9.S"· g3~Oil'
<
~~! ~[l~~~ s ~ a~.~~~ ~ ~'i; ;~_~ S'~ ~ !.~? r~~;§'r~~ ~ ~~:,~ _
... ;;-t ..
~"'<::I.9~.g>:f"'lal!f2"gl· iu;·tjla·"s.;;-~~ I: ll-!''I: ". •
i.~:~t~~f-,-"f !~~- r ~~,,~fc,r~a!~~Ja~f !~( ~
6 <i- "" - .. '<a, " . - ... ,. 3~~'"
-", """~'Ii"
... c:
. ",'1! ,Ii" 1~' ~'" hi.·!,l ~ .;:, I, " i''''i' "5:!'
1-3""~3,<1;;"!!5"S-~t~1"- rl!...,gQ.,'f:!-1fs·~t~~'<?
f" "l OJ
:rS.I<~ii
~~l~~,~!-;'" don ~'l,d""'[[j~"'~~i~· li,~"'"
,',-" '-, 1",0-' i" l"~"'·-,,·:·l' i ~;' ,.j
f'
of~'~'~;'~11i
_.
~~r~ !~'&:~ ~ r ,,-a~.,., ~s-~'j'~~'~ ~ ~ a~
:r~;:!i - 1:. a ai. c: 1Ji" ~ lf~. ¥: so' ". .. 3 ii" ~:I q" t ' 1"..., _ g '"
lfJJJf~
,- ,,~ '" "" g
~iJ~Jfs.'fl~a~·f~~'f:fi~~iJr[allrf~~'a ~~~1i
thi> is e.ther ui~:;. it(J..., touching, f""ling, sense pemoption. or ebe
"ociv, ,.e.• l.6ro<;. This question of the mod... of atte5Il III whal most properly
~ Being .. nOl ON: lhe CI'<'Cks lhemsch'''''' r~"" a> ~uch.llut. sit Jru;t1J.
they do r~ise i'. insofar as lhey ask what ...lse still belongs 10 ,he Ilcing of
""ings. whether, i....., ''0\0;; would ~lso belong In beings. This remarkable
qut'5lion. which ari;;es Liter,' n..... ns nothing ~ lI\dn Ihis if ~npa", that
which .Iwa~ 's. slHl,1Ie m....ning of Being .... p""""",an h~v.. kgililT\oKY
onl)' if ,he.... " something in attenda""... on ,hem. The rne.>ning of 1lo:ing is
lh"" dep;:n.ckn' on ,I>;, possibility ,hal beingscan be """"nte.w by a blS,,&
which ~ w n....thing lik.. !he p"""""l in g I. This dot'S not alall
me~n. hO<oo·.,..·..... 'Mt bcings ". beings "'ould in SOffi(' .... nse be d~t
on [)o"';n or on ron9Ci0usnes6 Or the like. This is t"AQugh /or an initial
o";""La';on. l..lt>1"r we will deal with the question in ~ more".....:ise w~)'"
We will requirt' bo,h opponents III answer tlwql.Ol:Stion: vlttp~; 1191:\"1UI
til; olio'ta.:; ('2~I. *what do they res.pern,·eJy posil as 6cing.?* The CJne5
who interpret oUo\u as tilin<; are rll.l£p(jiu:po, (<:9), "~~mer. more m..~
..bl....- i..... In(lrc rc~sonabl ... since they ~rc nlll weddallo an ""''''''''' p<>SI-
lion. lIS al"<' lhe OIhel"S, "'i,h whorn il is almost imp08Slble '0 dNL It Is hardly
ptlSSible 10 ha,·... any dealings with the ones who!;ly o\.o<riu ~ 0IiIpu. ben"",
tho:y den}' the elli$len<:'l' 01. ""'l'f)1hing not sensible and visible. and bee .....
for them lhen> i. basicall)" no ~ which inda'<llies in principle tq d
mel'\' 1lflOCJP<'>i..... and «t",. Thus it " ...... ""lIy impcoo;ible to 're.•1< with tho.'m
.., all. This is the thought implicitly lying at t..... foundn,ion ~. In order
thlY('fo", to be able 10 d"al with tht.-m at all. 10 lake them "";ousI)" as
opponents. PlIo,o approaches them as il tlK'y we... more l"<'a.iOr\olble and
kn.."W the "'MI'-"'" at i~ be{t..., thion they aetuillly do. He~cqull"C5 thereb)"
th~ ;>d,'anlage 01 now ha,'ing, in a ceruin _ . ~ mo", serious opponent
Th~t means a " ..~J 0f"!'0"""1--(he stn.>r>&cr h~ positi<ln. lhe bettl."l'-in ~
scientific di.<;n,t!;Sion can help one to get hold of lhe mane, and attain lruth.
for w,· ~'" not ronremed with t..... opponent hlms<'!f. Q)J.A tM'Iet:;
t'l'oilju;v (2016dSf.). but a ... concerned onl)" with th... mott"'r at i... uc; U",t ~
all we seek. And so w... a..,ume ,he :..tyQvtt~ oUoio. '" 0I1l\l(t hio\"... become
better th.>n they ",all)" "'" and. in a certain seM<'. fil to be de~lt with. I'k
...,..' want to asl< them and ha,'.. them tell u. how they ac1uaJly inkrprel
the "',,"ningol llein/;. Th,,~mall"'W'S Theaeletus 10 inronn him whal
is said ~bout <,«h: til l.£xllt.\" lWp' aUt"''' t't4otW"'vtllt (cl). 'EpJl'l~'"
me~n.. to inform in the """'.... of making int>1"lIig.bl.... mal<ing p<$ible an
S.2~o/I
"AH.Cf I'.., ",,..,,,,," ~_ Ed..."... .-e.. -"
w,.."*,, G"'_
(SOlt ..-..w.ln w~.GJl 8d "ll'l" 12J-I75tJ' llJ2.[f.nsfioh ..", loy I.........
~ ..Ii<... ""e-,"!_E,·........ _ u " '......m-"'-.t_.p. ..,.._T 1
1'1.>10', SopIrUlI~7\)_m I
what lhen will Ih~' 5.0)'1 N<>Ihing eI!Ie t.......: 16liu,...mv'\jl ~<lIK<'/l't'"(oec"
oro. t'nrI.ryryvro6o:u (d. "Sf.). n.ey lho.... will sa)'_nd ",e nl1l51 consider Ihis
""'1""'" wry ca",fuUr_'h>1 is det\.'fl11ir>ed by the "can,~ t6 bu,·at&\'. i...
lhe 5Cnie 01 ~Cljl(1yiyvrIl9';11 ~o:llixQ)'i)'VOO9n:~ in .he SoCn!il' of "bPing able
",t-Y.,n~ p""""', ....... ln "-,,_.,boenl." nv{(t<p). in ",!Ali"" .., ............hinij;
elw, ~ in ,",'''')' case s<>methillg or oth."." II i:; something or olher thruugh
lhe possibilily of its p~ in n-Ltlion l<l S()mcthing cl".. .hal is. Ileing
Ihus means he",: 10 be (dpable of pl"t'5O.'l'ln' with som~i,,& Whal i5 deter·
miMd by the ability to clH.'Xisl w,th SClrnE'lhlng. i.e., whol has this ability.
is. In .nticip.ltion.1ct lIS poinl out ~ I""'t thill ~I of Ilcing aht'ady
Include 1.) pn·scnce. oUo{o:, 2.) lhe "C\>'," OVI'.v.oICll. "",,·..,vla,. and 1.)
ability. ~'"
If lhcn'fo.., ~1«t,ooU"'l. ep6v<jcn;,. "nd tN! lik"• .md theM>Y also the
'l'v.tn i" "'hich they"'" p""""l-if "II ~ .....,." Eking. ho,,' "'ill they thm
speak about th<.'TT1? A", lhese beings6pa.'t/lY I<U'unOv n (d. 2~7bJ)r ~Can
they be """" with .he ...yes and be touched?» An: they acce5oSibk-' t o _
p""'eption? Or is all this in\'isibk-' bu. yl'l pR'SCnt? Whal lhen is the ca;l<'
conttming the p"""""e oIt ..... soul and of Ih... other things? !XdiOv oU6tv
"'"......' '11' 6pa.mv M). ·Sul\"l)· none ue "isibk> wilh lhe sensible e)'<5,.
ThlSletetus sal'S. Will the:-' It>m want to 5.Oy I'Wv ~6: n IOxt,., (el. b61.
that lhe5e Ihings ha"" a bod)'. bo."C,>usc they indeed are? n.e"",,",us answers
Ihat Ihey "'ill nPl an5wer /Ill the p,>rt.'I of Ihi1 question KIl'':' .trir<it
io%o0l'l''OVf(I, (bn, ·in lhe ... me way.» They will fighl shy of m wl.jlilv
(ell. "I..... risk.~ 01 eitl",. laking alllhese. I..... soul, t!l6"'l<llc;. and lhe lik<>.
as non·beings Or mainL~ining thai each i! C<Ilpo:. Bul iJ t.I\Iry' Iwsllale to
e~plajn all this ... non~ing on the basis of their theory. hesila~ to say. IOf
"""mple••hal if ,;onlelhing is, a body ml.l5t n~ril}' be co-p...,...,t with
ii, lhen they inlimale in doing !Ill lhal 'hel' are prudenl in ",&"rtf 10.he:Ie
gh'm.s; lho.')' "ill not risk a decision. Thi.~ n=slrainl aln.'ady makfS them
beiter. For 1""1 ill the prq>et rornpottmerol to ti'll' mattns. the proper respect
fill' th<m, ......... Iy not to intrude upon them p"""pitously with fi~ lhO'Orlcs
but 10 keep !ilcm if one cannot So'y anything about ~ In Ihis 5;1.....,., lhe
malll'r is in ""err case 3Ckno...·ll'dgOO llS il i! gh·en. """....·HI then t>o.
pnodent. bUI at lhe samc Ii"'" ther will not t>o. able to de'emunc anylhing
about the otho.'r m<><!<' of gi'·c,u,css. WII.>' ",...... ins ope" hell"-...·hid> ...·c
must take up--is lhe ~"gof 'f)6\'tlcn<;.and the like. In a rer1ain sen!W'the}'
cOflOl'<!<> vux'1; il is. BtH they cannol say anYlhing aboul the Ik'ing of
oP6'o"l"'';' That is irnport.onl, bec.use the discussion of the opposite la<:lion
wlUlal." ti'll'matize this phen<nnenon again.' This nlak", it dear lII.>t.he
I ~.:"",;,.Cf p.)JO,;
§o8un..4iJ/ 321
eith
b d t,ermjn lion of t
E1't ri
.er"i it I'
· . i
itself, i·
0'6 a,.u
I p. : "livin-
pllist45aff. Cf. p. ] .
of lhe laSI posilion. p,ocffds 10 Ihe decis",'e Sleps in the determiNoII'''' "f
0.', ~nd d0e5 so sp<'Cifia,.Uy try. n>tuming to ...hat he di!IC\Js.sed earlier, all
Ihe way to Ihe point ~I ,,'hkh hi' carri.'<! OIJI IhI' criliqu.. of th.. ~nci""'!li
He sa)"!!: ...e ",HI I\Ol simply repcm "'lmt we diSt'USSCd Ihen:-, bul ins"l~d
..... want to deal wilh II In such ~ "'ay Iva lijIg n "gI1ljlOt"'l'E" (l5Oa5f.j,
"thai we lhel'\'l>y taka Slep furward allh.. s-ame Ii""," This is nothing e1~
Ihan I"'" Votl'/Xlv tttp(lV. Unless we """ lhal dearl)', Ihe whole d,alog""
,,~II be a great <:onfl.l5i<m.
Now I"" ml,que p.>sses o"er 10 II>.: opposite side. I'a!' at~lion on'"
more to the results of lhecrit,,!ue of Ihe fiTS! f.<:I,on: tlx're is gi"en not emly
the op<:ltl'),· bul also lhe G6pwov ""d. priDf to buth of lhem, the
lQO\'(j.,;. ~nd lholt is inlerp~od as WvQjlI~.
""".ut;;
I Cf.p. .\."7
91. '-479) 1
Th
SChCJOI
up
Tl&!:: W YI)'\'liJa"l:IV 1\ til 'l'lY"<iJO>..o9o:1 oau: KO(l\Jlnll K6:tk!<; II a,.tOtrIl'OV;
" W ",tv K6:9r]I'.... W St fl(irrllO"; 1\ O(t\'tWrtwlV O~IlO" cOOftt'pov
roUfW" Illlt~Jl6;vl:lv; (d4ff.). "Willt~ So.1)' th.t YI'f\-MI"l:lV, boo"·'ng.
or 'l'lY''ti'loo:l:<rlkll. "",ng known.. is llOhll'<l or K~ O. th.>t the (IJl1' ~
ItQ{ll"'u .nd IbI' OIher ~?" Or ..·W tocy d",,)" th.1 lhe!;\' antologlcal
dt"tCtrninalioN, Ka'Eiv and JUiaxn\', appl}' 10 this 6\>, "fl1VOOo:l:l\',
0fllMl<n<;? Obviously dwy "'i11 dl'fl)" it n...y "'W dmy. in shott, thot 'f\'illm..
jl.(t~1lfM;1 bw<40{~ And lhl)' must da 50 if they .. ·."t to Jd..... w to
their fUillon and do not "'ant to spe.1k againsl themseh'15. If th"Y ron-
«'<led thalllllo ooo,vwvl(1 ofY'Y'~1\' Can be- i"t.,rpn.-t,..:t as W\',,,,,,;. the)"
wo"t<l .... uy.. g ,.... ,,(,l"""itP of ,,·h., ,two)' m.in'.;1W'<! 1'n....;"...I)· Why?
They i""-l .I>Oy: oiloia l<llp"; p-tO£...... .... h.1 ScnuIllcly ii halIl'OIh,ng 10
do with n'\()\'('\'I\(lt\\' is fM' of all clu"gi'_ If, 1I0>H,,·er. as lhey ind.....-d ron-
<"fdej .co.'\', 'l"'X" Y'Y"~" m:",{(1 "fl'f\'tiIo-I<£t(l.. otioio: is thcn..ofo....
"kno\o'n: Y'Y'....,,,~ (d. <'2),.s object, then th.It in'pli", 0\J<r((l. ~ de-
twmined.>s JUl:l'llwa; it is in some "'.y .affected by knowkdg<' ilse!f.l~u
.., oiloio. is known and Il\ereby.ffe<:«>d, il ilself <:onl.lins lhe ""'In\'1l1 of
~l\, "h"lm.,. But according to toorawn po!iilion. tl\"l is not po:tiible.
Something lik. lh.1t t:l\nnot be lll'pi ro fJpqloi", (Mf.). ·in the f>eld of what
~., r<'5t." Th.. ",1"'1'''''''' U«n'O ..."", ..... indiGot..... llhc end« 24&;'0
""""in <:onWU1tly in a d<1<.".,.,in.t., self..".mc.-.' fn.", of all chang<'. To
rono.<Ie th.It oimo. is known and knn".blc impl"'S il is coMl<'r:ni",-'" 1»'
lttifllll"land c"''"'''l"""U)' b" i5U'~'';' Sinn!, for them. d"'l<'l'; has no pLo""
in סOOI... I~ must n:'jcct thls posilion. Y"'II\", is 1\01 lC'r\o1blc! ",tt,,:r, this
has now --.. d<m1<Jr\§trat~ in principle.
)Th
, . Bd.
of /YoNo;jl,; originat<!d "'ith1'I~to. bulthe n:"'('fS(>: 1'I.,to alt~mpts 10 take il
,nlO account With Ihis aim. one cn,,1d ,",'l.'fI. as il; often d~.~pp"'llQ lhe
f"'l thol in the ontological d~'1ogu<: P~'mmiJ~, an Aristotle appea... asOOE'
of tho> rolloclJ~. aUI. as "'''$aid, ~a .... only surmises and dono!".,tIe
anything subslanti\"e1y. I only bring them "p h...... 10 clarify the b.1s.ic dif_
f~ In the ~ppUcation of tt1t' onlOlogic<ol conc.-pl of W\"~ll;"
) b
m
vi
allljl.o'" (d, 25O.l8f.), ~mOSI op~ lOON' ... 'other.~ "And yet)'OlJ 5'11"
cijlt6u:pa airto: ~al toro.npov ~ Ei,·!Xl (d. 2S00111.', ""both in them·
"",I ..." , and each for ,tself would be in lhe Oiln..- ....ay." Th<:rclore bodl, and
~ach IQl" illlelf,an: in tlw sa,me "'a)'_ Thi~agai" l\'\,l~ il dear thall'lalQdOl.'S
not mean Ihal th<><e tx>ing" which ~otmn~in an eminent .~""_ _~
from Ihl' slitndpoinl of lhe opponents. the dlirt-....oukl lhI'lI\5elvtS be
dct..-rmincd by d,'11o,~ lJl the SI'Me of l,re and '·ov;. i,e,. thai !he Ideas
Ihemsd,'''S would be ali,'" and knowing. butlhal d"'1c"" and o'do>.. e.>d>.
t ..ltttp<.>v, Q"". Ap(t ",,"tio9t:c. 'i.J:(ow cijlf6ttpa "..:rl b,ltttpov. 6tCIY dv(U
ovrx<09fi.;; (b21.'. llul if now both al\'. lhen aT(' not both in m<>tion' Or.
t<m:!:vu' o.uro. ...... f6u:pa ~;vo., (d. b5/.). if both ""'. ~a", then not both at
~t?~"""'" concl~ d ......n in rq;ard to ,,1,'l}O1.; .nd <'ltmn.; c;on be
Or, con,·ersely. 01lt<:n.; is, ><Ivllm.. ito, and lherclon> 'Hmn; is in motion.
'\/hal if. chal3cteri~tk of this kind of "'KummL~lion is thai il alwaY51ool<.s
.t "-tv",,,; and oTlttru; In s"ch a "'ay that Vv funclions in a certain s<:nse
only a;; lln au~,h,")' c ~ and IJ; not nl all d.,..1t w,thlhemol;o,lly,
TherclQre the que;tior\ ariSeli: Tplt""lipu t\ 1WPO- mim:r. ~ 6v tv q\ 'I'Vlll
till£{.. (1:>7). or "do you lhen posil in thi' md something liu a Ihird thing.
ne~t to 1ri""l<7'.; and "tlime,. ..... meIy 6vr This t\8£I; tv t1\ 'I'Vlll is only a
p.:>l3phra"'" lor l..tyt:"" in the _ I ha"e al",ady ",n"n>d to: Itw soul'.
CQIw....".tion "~th 11",lf abo", somcthlns.' Thus Ihe ~ is as.king: in tl\('
end, when you Sol)' o;jvl\m.; i. and (Tn'un.. is.- alT yo... add_ing thi' ~is'
a5 a thin;!. and specifically .... UK· tlCJ;lViW njv Tl: tmiolV >mi tilv dVllmv
I<l'Pl£XOj1tVI\v (bBI, "in such a wa)' thai tt'N"by IliVl}lll; and ot6cl... r\:
Mld"""""t "" ~-ncom~ in it: <ruUojlli>v llu\ OOtt1iocilv nutli>v IlpOo; n'lv
n'I.; oOOlo;; <t11,'W\'lnv, oiru»<;ri\'W. KpootiKU<; {qI06n:pa; (b9f.). In thl5 final
cia ....... Plalo pro\'id"" a short. y~1 f"l"Idament.lL analY5i5 of Itw TpiTIW
l.t'tfl\'; I.e.• he offe<l; her\: for the first lim" the P~ ~ic strucl"lT of
CJ\j~ and c,,~uentJyof lMuUyo:G6a•. Because 1'Ia"'·5 theme ~ AOW
specifically ontological, he can dcl('M\in,' more pn.'(i...ly the st.....cture of
WMI ",,,IIot,,. in the P/1MJ",., he could only char.>cleriZ<! with. gcn... ... 1
orien...tion.
I Cfp.:713.
§71lf95-496/
kno"'lt'<lh.... of the, 'SS<.'l1n'. Ph<'.",,,,,,,,oklgy toda}' Slill I~C\"S the h.>si, '"sk
0/ "aTifying the methodologjell moment 0/ eidctk koowle<:lj:\e, which ha..'<
nolhing wh.llsol.·'.cr to do with the e1detio: "typt'H in psydl<'logy TllIseidcti,
knowlof'dge ill ('fll'll'e<:ted h> the gencral problem 0/ tleins. to the que:sliUfl
of """,.....nwthinll in gen.,,,,1 un bl' prior 1(1 s<>m"'hing .. 15o> and wlul this
pe<'Ulia. Qrderof priority meAnS. The Groeks rod no tXClS'On h> relIt'd on
all this, "',,'''~ they lei t"" whole ('Ol"Ite>;t 0/ bein~ "nil lIeing play nut,
from the ' ....r ""1Sel. in the P~'l1t. And h<-'flCC il was noOIdifn.:ull lor I~"to
10 eIltTact, in !ii.'eing, I",m !he pregi'~ f",m o;l>.,,<J,,", and atWn;.. third
Ihing.. and 10 posil it .... 6Y for ,t:;clf.
To be ~U"', ,t .. nO! Ih., PI"',, ".,.. "1'1.''''''''' nf ,h~ <I'llk"lri... h.'no,
insl....d he ",,10.'<1: hnw an <Offi<"lhing Ix> whi(h is neil"'-..., nst nor in
"'It
motion. and "'" ne-.·crlt>ckss;'? This q"""tion is, fo. I'loln and It>c Gn:..oks,
" "CT)' ,,'t"lght)'01"'. if w.. ""liz.. that b..~n~s befn_~ ~riIy
",tI,er mo,'of'd o' at n.'Sl. And nOW tt"''''lSfiuppose<! 10 ~ somI'thing "'hick
residl':'l b<>yond bolh .",i yet i!I, and ind~ nOI onI)' i, bul ronstiMcsllein,.
i1\ the P"'f".'" sens<'. Thi. qU'-'5tioning. lIS il occurs he... in the Sof:hlSl. l.ltcr
bec.omc for the N,'Opl.to"ists a locus dl1.~ii'US_ Theydcri"!'d from il thdd....
0/ the tJ;t1Cl'.t'-'l.l, lJf what n.'S,d"li IIl'yond all roncrl"le beings: thI' idea of lho'
d. vi ~'" lv, d ~v. Th., Nevpl.lQnic rnmmcnla.;"".•b<>v" aU th< """" un
the PIl1ftll'fl"hs. LIke lhooiT orimLllion p",'Ci~dy from this pass;tge ,,, the
Sopl",'.
The fU$1 resull I'l tillS' It\o> tme1lLltion to,,-anl l.o>yt>; /ruI~ 01' ,,\!;Ible ~.
third thin,. booide ..-Iv"Ol'; Jnd alUm;. And aU~I'''''''' llJnMv M" to
be Iilkm posi~"e1y;os thl' mlJde lJr e~~tion in wh,eh, from whllt is p .....
IV"en, he-r-e from I".., presi""ns, ..-1"'10'-; and 01~ a tv, ""mr'ly ov, ..,.
eocomp.>ssing both, i.. ClfI... ct~ in an .~lraclin "",in,.. K,,'Ou'~Ii..;
lll.'1!lW<; Ipflov «~ol'«Vm~G\)Q' tI .0) ~, ~.ov "''''1(1\''
"..,<1 mdmv riv<U
)~ev (250d f.). "In this wily"·... ka ..... ,um... inlo the ,.;t....lio"''' Theae-I.:1,,'
Sill"', "of .. nnO\lncing B""'g as 5i>rO<'thing Ilk .• thin:! thing.~
'A~OI".vt£llIE:o&ol means In annuur>o:e "",,,ething as ",isling. 10 I." ....m...
thing bEo known. The ~'o.; ..,,1Wf.: a('(l)f<:lingly, it is nO! '$ 'imrle .. ,·OU
beliel'e<! belore (2~9d8). namel)' thai we would al~Jdy be alltw en<! 01 0'"
d,ff>('ulties simply by ~;ng that the o...-I'·"IOV and lho' \ll""''ll'h'OV
both.~. lSul pn.'cisely lhe~ ~ .... the d,fIlculty. bo.ornu"", IIll' Ik>'ng of
boIh of ~ p.-nl·"" to be • th,rd Ihing lind acoordingl)' is uln'iOU!'ly a
g"!" -
ff-'" !'I'!llrl ~'I'lllt!lrll!II'I'I'II-'?I&
l:"o " . " " "
. '<'a ilil-'-'o.'-~ -""" . " .. _1>
.,,~.a .. _ -!! <:I Ii'
ilP-! .,_O.!h'._'.
" 1,· ••• ·,,"·,-', l. ', .. ,.
.~ i::i" -"f~ 1L~i<~2_'''''i!i2:°~i:'.. t-'§~§'1;·~_", .. ~-g.-~
I. ~ ~~~r';i~f~ffJ;~i",~gr~I:~~~~fSI
. 2 <: :t" t - " ' "' .. <> _ !!i 3 0
11,1 , > q . ~ , , i' al! • ~1 ci• II •ir""" ~ h :r,.~ ,~o ~
did,~,
"f' ! S'
~ 5. i ~ ~ a§::i. -; ?':II ,. ~ ~ r ~ ~ ~ - i ~ ~ ~ Ii iU ~. ~ ~~ ~ j 0'
1ld Ci"l:Fa~l:g .. ~·.gI~·"':=12!.~ %~ili<Il~~3:"2f,,"i)\
,n i
I--[;,~":"':"
""i)\· ... :r_al;;lO"ili3~
,.~,,,,!~r~~!·',,,,~,,
~ }-1i·~li:·&.~",,1il:6 IlOS
q.
~ g
.! I I "",:o"';t"'-li. :._."
",,,,,,,, ,,],' ,.:-"
..
""""'1;:5<..°01;.:>
•. , '.""W'·it d i1~,,=g
11;ai.§=,3l'." j ~i.-_·g~ o·· .. )(o .. ::.;r,,'.oo2".
: 't; ~C
~".,.,.-
~f~ i
!
i. !
I;"'i ~~ ~~l:~!i~l!' [.~~~t~i[~.~~i.~~i~~~~isiii f
S,)€gi(i" ". Ii;
]~lt."~,;o:;:-1Il35'g~g,,.. Sl::3 "'=f.:~ ~
.., . 0;:
Q.~ ~ ~ !:. !~, ;: .' ;; 2.. 5' g ~ S~ ~ a' :>
~, 5' _ ~ 3; :2':r" ~ ~ ';"
nil
••e - 0 1::'
a;. '" l '" ;; '- [ ;; ~ ~ ;;: Ii ., ~ ~ =. 8. 5 ~ ~ ~ i l-~ - ~ j. !C. <i •
t ! '"
I' ,l if
i'I'~!i!j §~' ~~i~~i:!i t[:'i; ~~.~,~ [j fii; ~
'r'Hi. ~~~J~-lgl 11~lf~l!~§f~I!!~:li3~;il
+~ ~!~ijI191,-1 !~Il,!!fi!~!i!~,·~~!!ijj~l~~
fP: ""'"'\l:--'f''';''' /!;1iji{'
"'1f"' ..... ";>" 1i "'~ '11)0.,.;:1'
~ ~:~, !' [ ~ <ll a. g ;, a~ ,q: ; ~ ~] ;.. ~ ~ if'~ [~~ ~ ~ ~.'i g:
.:! ~'& .. _~!O =. "'"
i lz~:. ~ ~''';; 0 -, g,"'2. ii 1 ~ c _ 2 :5 <o:""'Z ~ ! 3 :;.
i f
I"d [,,~~~~'?'[6 ~~;·{a&.e.~.~g:~·d:'~~~~~~7~2.2.!;: ~
i!
•• "wlw···l····~··,···~···l.r
"''''lIiQ.5!
!l:!.'"'' 0l"'=-
, - I'i"
'II; ;."
•••
';>00!J.!il'-:l
:.:. <: 2 -
~ .. ",~
~. g'~ ~
'::r-!5~
Cl ~ if;;;.e'
it" :i.::.g-'!. ~~ 1!'!!l~I'IIl;~ ,,5·!-~::=.3:r ...
.~L·::-,p.!I,!t.,f5&~1. ~
;t ;- t;! !:; ;< :. 'Il ;,.
! Jll.nt,gf
::; ~, " 1. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.~ §
~ =.~:soot;s:iot' .?·::;:'1i'''\T!-c.'''''1,_Q;':::I5~"Gl_'' l
:l: ;; I: ::rS'!t._ ~~ .. 3 ;'--J::"'<:';;'~ a."" '",," .,!;';! ~
l J i. - 3 '" Jl'l; A> _ it ~.~ g ia l'i" ,,'--:. 2. til":l " :I 3 ~ So 10" f a.1r ~
~ ~ '~l g- t ~ g ~ =. ~'] g' :"l ~ 6. ~ f i ~ ~ ~ .3. '=:~. :;' ~ ~ ~'l J
•1
I
"l'
1; l ;iJll-1
;~5.=-":l~ k' ,18', !;l :;1,,1
2<1;~"-.-:::I{l5 .. 3
t;;··
"'~3Z 56.~ '" <!.-
, "[':l">l'~l~q",
'I >.·,.0,,:1,,1 ,
.< P
e~" ~ ~ g
'i'..a.. ...... !i. ~
'& Q &, .§ g:!! < £. ",<";0 =-;;" _.
;R ..,tjJ!:~lffliiif~ili~i!(ll~I~[!
~ ~ ~::r! Sl c <: if ~ ~ ~1i'
. ",;
'" "'=:=:~i" =,- ~ ;'<;'~_""I'i'
s .:;"1".-1'1 ", ... 1,,,,itiSi~:r
.;;""~"
:.:.... -tr""·~ S .. ';j'"
S:>.. "'·Q.::::a ~~ , i
~
~ :~.~.S3·.!~ ~S.;;·!:!:gll 9t~l;'~","';~i"~R~_
, -H'tj"
~.
•i '~!."d'·'·l'!·g<"'-·""ah!
~~~~;~6<~gl:~~~ftr~~~~I~~Q
~ ,~
f <~l'<g;"'j:' ;<~2-S'P'r.fl.~ ~~i3'~O·O!!.ag,",!:l
{ la .. ~i~asglf~~~£- r ~=·i~~t~I~O I, <
- '1:; ....
i~i-;" ':;!- g_. I': S .. g
'o"·'.'n.-_.~'_,"~ 0 _ ...• .. 3_
.! l
:i"ijiO:"~""?Q·.:c,Ill·:?~:i
c;.'~ll~IJf.ri!r!I!IIIIII!llf't .. :!l~liii1<"'5l_ f. •
0
E: ;,·ll a 3 i,
}03. ~'!IT P ., ~!i. ~ 1r:. a .!'r!, ~
?;...i:I.('~aa="g,~Ill·;:;;
l'~lll.I""~j-I-I---.r·l· 'j" a aif.-:!'ifij".:c~:l p~if>.
:!: l'1 ~ f' f n :r 0'
9- " 3",'" : or ,l:l n ;l ~ ~ ~ /;; :t 8' i"2 )0 ~
I~l l!~ ~i~[~cJ~<f~~~!:~~~~i
~ ,:,,5..; !9-~ ~2.~;:;i}i.:i,~~~g~~~~" .:::I~~
• ~1~~'~!~~;~!~=~~~I~~<'I&I=[!J"I
> ;;:
..
..- 5' ~• -
:0 ,
0; "§0
=O".'>!~"""
~"'0' "J".-lot :i:r. ~"-'~ 2.. '"< 9: ~ ,ji ~
<
i!l"' ·,., -,
~
{ ;;.]"".g~" ;f[~ '~~'<f~2.. 0
fl, a-i"Gl·::l,,:a.9 !! ~
" '" ~
"i"'f" -<il2 ~ '::.(> Q'-' - <:1.,< !ri';!...
OO~I ~"> !
=~ H -,,' " d !
.p. L.;'f, .~ 1 ' ,.,' -." •. P-, i!
j ;f#':r~::t~';l 3.~~S";=;~~g'::3 ... _:rg!?~~~~ ~~ a _
:.
" :1 ""i1'\,,"ioj" g
~": ~t' i : ;- ~t ~'
,,9 F' ~ :I:~ ~ ~ i $ ~ ""t:' ~
," i0:: <", '!It;:l;l'''::le: .~ iii!i.I
/[,_ e, i! ': '" >:0 g.t'~,
=. ,.,. ~ I" & _ ... :5 l;.
1:; ti i{ ~ .:::1.-£
B (i;'
~ g ~ i.'~ ~ 3ll ~ ;- ~ ~ 2 ~ 1 ~ f ~ ~ i ~ ~ "t ~,~ ~~ i '? i ~;> ;;if
§!§~-f2.:ri;~~:~~rl.r~~~;~i~i 00>
;'I!!.!!II~II'l~ •• ~tir.lfl.J' i j',f,. ~§
"':~9:~~'Il2."" ~cF.~'" &",~~i~'<~t'S > 1. 0.'
~
!5:·K.g.&..s:'~5g>: a··K=a-.~l~ ~g".• .:::Ioa.';., ~-
)0 ...
1 ~? a. ~ 1"" S ~ " 3 bl, -1 ~ a s: ~ ~. ~ 9 so ~ ..:! >
,< <;:! a. E: (i;' )0
:i i 7"" ~. ~ &. i" ~ ~ '~ .:::I ..::. ; [
... _
i .iis. ..~ g-~15"C8"]"· I ~<:I.;i..,!!l~O":l's..<;!-Q-.~
• 0
a g, ~ if - ~ ~ § ~. ~ § g. § ~ § ~ [ ~j t ~ ;; ~ a(,::
,;- <i.'iO
~ §- g- ii ~ ~ g, ~ :t ~l i!i '0 i! 'f
· ,
~"
S' ," )0 3 ;I ::I - i:'
l.! ~ sS. go~ "r ,=";;
.- - - '" ~ '" - n\ ~ ~ _.j! !:: •,
"" " Ill'
f~i'3ol .. a:o-:~ =2'" ,,!:!,~ os:
.i
,~~~.l-"'~'~~""'![~Ei~i~~~
~"-'''I$-' <:1.3""[ "'''"go''''liS: " m" "'"s-
8
r; ~ ~ 5 ~ ~. g i.l,~ i ~ ~ ~.~ ff ~ ~ -",~,~, ~~. ~ l
73 [ 04- 05J
all han
J i in the
J
'XPlre~;ed for
Pl to'
31506-50 J
b li ed ~l1eEV Ae-fR09at 1) rep oi. {ep }.J)yO), "n· thing can b addresSEQ
e t in the"A6y proper to it," i.. in th Myo * j e t forth 6p 1<Jl.l 0
E "'v (b), the on self-same thing p ited in reJati n to i If:
n 9pc.o1tO -d epro1t othing el can b .d at all-that' the trine
Antisth and th circl f hi f 11 \' e . Th nsequ c.e h
a
, a : J.111 al ~ ), "it' imp . ible to utt r a contracti ti n,"
in d m re eneralJ : ~llOE eu cram (b34), "thre' no decepti n \ hat-
er'" r A,6'r as A6yo , is tru ,This P ition' perfectl co . tent.
That . , if n "),oyo' pure am of a Ev' E 6 if th
P 'bili of a AeyElV lCa'ta nvo e,e "addr in of m thing m
thing," is· Iud d, then the ery 0 ibili of dec ption is undermined.
Thu au that Afyy ~ ruch is no becoming thematic in PIa '
opll' t, includ in' If the phenomenon f ~t1 0 , of 'l'eur) AOyO and
henc indud the qu lion f ho in J.i:'/El i elf ucha cruJ..l: '}, crl f ¥
and ~i't ov could be po ible, t the arne tim ther lur in the back r und
the till further qu tion .f hm A,oyoC; as A,oyo can and in a p . ibl
01 coia \' 'th th QV it is upp d to xhibit.
enid "A.6y in t w o c :
.) in far a there reside , in 'A6yo itself, a (JUJ.l1tA.otdl: in dd· in
omethin SOD'l thing is addressed as m thin. th ugh Plat did not
t ha an plidt co usn f the tructure of thi addr in· h .
till a\' are fa C iJllP 'ti n a <nJJ.urAOKrl, f A.oyo<; ut of () o~a and piill '
,
This distinction' th origin of an articuJation found in the later 10'c and
abo e all in grammar: n un and erb.
2 My is consider 'th ped t th fa t that a chr ·th tho
tructure resi ent in it, it till h a reJati n to th 0 the bin, ab ut hich
I
A final p.>sl'olgt' we shall ..."., from Atislotk-'. Mr!IIloIrysn:s. llook VIII, chapte.
3. 1Q..l3b2,j.-:!8, ",fers to lhe difficulty of the dOClri"" of Uryo.; in Antislhe1_
Aristolle points OUI lhat ltJe difficult)' u... M.,..ria"" Le" Anristhenes and
his 101"",'''''. found in l.lryu..;-Ih;ot there is no irvni.t}'t',v bu' only a tnC...
""mng by n~..-yet conlains something ~ignlfi(anl. ""'.... " .uopla,. "" 01
·A......o/lItvt'm Kol 01 o\r<0; flIIO:USt'vro, "ll6po...... q£t nm "«t,~v (bNff.):
w""lth<' follow.,.,. .. f Mlisthenesand others hi<t' I""m with t\tl idea about
!J(1t:'tKt: dealt ..'ith qt'" ","s. m'(z "ttlp6\', Thi. i. al first ,';ew a rt'ma"""bil!
USC of ~(I,pO.;! The o.:pl"CS'iion mt'''tlIl nothing ..be than what w.. t"day
would ""II ~doosh·e.· wmellting de<is;"e, sr>n"'1hing signlfKam. N~mely:
on 0"" ~Ot. 10 'If ton" 6plno:mktl (tOv yt)p 6pov l.6yov riva, l'a..p6~J,
a.ua ~o;ov 1'& t/ t"n" hatxr.ttI i5t~a" ~p 4fIl"'fXlv. 'If I'tv ttJ1W.
§7J fSOf-S1QI
Illl. I'm 5' olov omuln;po.; (d. b251LI, "that it ;s nol P'O"Sible 10 delimit,
<lplouo(lw. ... hat ~ml.'lhi~ is. t '-""""""" 01. thinK." I..... to<ll'l"""i",, il
in ~ l.tyuv,and 5pl.'CiIKaUy not 1x'C' Sl" thel'lpo.; "·Q..ld be. ~IIO:"~
a ''''''g ~ "i.... a ~6yo.:; compos<'<! of 5('""",1 words and th<.T<'fon> in a
~in """'" a16yo<; thai daims to ""1're!05 ""'"eral things .bollt one ..... tI'-'T.
Th;s delimiLitiOR i5 still imP'J!i05ibl... oKl;tX'ding to the- lhesis of Anlisthcnian5.
They""y: one cannot de«'rmin.. a rl (Otl in AJho:;; at most on.. can dl.'lt"t<
min<" a lIO;O\'. For cx:omple, it ;s nO! po66iblo.· to dl.'ll.>nnine silv... in it~
~. in i:s 'what; by mun~ of ~ one can only say: ~ looks like
lin. It;~ nmw"bblc that A'istoll" ..ml'hasizes ..... ~ U.., t the theoii of Anl~
t........... n'",hmv ItvnUyr"',allhnugb it in .....,,""" ~~lmpl)·a< c.lling
by name, still contains ~melhing decisl'·... Ati~t"'le '..... ns Anlist~ i5
pnxeeding ('Of'l~istentlr when he d'-'I\ies that lhel11 can be a <kfinilion. A
6po<, is pn.'risely suPf'05"d to eludd.'" a thing lMX1ln:ling to its 5Ubstantiw·
OOIllenl: L.... il is supp<ll5"'d to offer something substantively ~Ic-"nt, fIOm....
thing Re\'o, about t"" thing in question. On I....' oth.., hand. lhis l,.6yo<; as
6po<;..;OS dcl ninol\. must be iuch thai it does not c"p~ !,"methirlg arbi,
t...", abon! tl", bfing. e_g., how il is rel.lted '0 ot""," be;IlglI, but ins~.d
must l"<p.- determi""nons ""';ding in lhe being it!O.'l/. Ari5l.OIIe " ...... the-
Ii,." to """ lhi a problem of the edd..,.,InS 0' """",thinS M I,,,,,lf, ""'l·.,.,d
the mere po<iting of lis identity with itsclf....d he set II furth in his 1I1rlr>-
p/rJlSlcs, Boo~"~ -l. Hell' h.. m:.kes the flln,l3m"n.al dise',,''''Y lhal th~~ is
• U'rl'w as i.tyl:w tl -<0&' Qirr6. -an .ddf1'SSin& "' _tiling fu, "'/'1.11 il
it~lf ilI,- and spedfocolly such thaI tlus add~ing is nol simply an empty
t.ulology. as is the calling by name of Anli$then<'s, bul sum .Itd! Illisl.tyrw
n w&' <rirro allhe lI'IlR<' tin,e di1lClose!lthe Illing addl\'S5Cd for wlmt It is.
This disco""')' of I"" genui"'! ~ the original l..&yo<;. was possible onl)"
bea...... Ati5totle had P"l"'re<l his doctrine of l,.6yo<; tllrous!' a romspond·
log doct11nc of bFIngs and 1""1. f'O""lble detcTmll'lo,bUlty. for ,,"""I tills
~ whic.~ addl"eSSt'S suml.'lhinjl;;os thaI whktl It is. e"l">S"'!' .bolll .he
booing is it! ontologic.1 p""-"""RCl'. r.meI)" ttl.t wtlich already R5id." in
ii, what it it""lf in .......t.>in SCRS<';s. although this i. indee<! prior to,\ llself.
This theory of ),{ryoc;.. wtlich ,·<Tif..... in a posili'-e 5Cn5C pn.'Ci5eIy "'l\;It
An~ mainlain<"<! onl)" in a "-'lIlh "'"y. thOI-' p"-- . ...PP"S'" thtodi.......··
err of the ')'tvoc,. And this disc",,"), was i~lf made possible only by the
'act that a l'1a.o prt.«dl.'ll Aristulle, 11 is preci,;ely INs conne<:lion thal "'e
will v;plo", in lhe follow ins lee"' ...... The impot"t.om point-lhe """"'" I
refem'd 10 theso! passage. about Ami<th<.>nes-i< to....., how the lh<!ory of
},6yoi; cannot be sep.,... ted from Ihe GlIl.'StiOl'l of IX-ing
Plato hi""",l! cites Antislhenes "'""" m"", often. but I will nol no'"
.,"'borat.. I...... P"S""ges. since tl'lcy do not add anything f"'mculariy .... b-
stantial. ~ citAtions OCCllr in lhe OQ/ylus. ~:!9aff,: .h" ('dhy.kmW>. :!8Jc.
74. Tit' di CL ion 0 tJre ftmdan
wit/lin b in (
tvcmria.
1 s.r ""'0f'I""'l'"
§74/515-516/
him,;elf, ......... thotJgto throughout the whal., dialog"" he h..,; not partkuL>rly
3«ompli1;I,,'d ""I'}' much. He ",,)'s Uuutho.s lMsis would allow uS e.'en 10
take motion togetl1er with rest and =1 logeth..... with mohoo; 300 lhiot i1;
eerlainly quite imjlO!>'lible, for motion ~ indt~ in re!Jltu"" to re;., !too>
..,.....,W«n<W (d'. 2Sl.b71. llw fu.\ho.<. <>Pro-!. H~ .... ,he d ... ino:!i"" i. ck-ar
botIvern tl>t- e5SeflhaUv still onticaJ treatment 01 motion and "'5' in Plato
"eTSUS the <.>ntological tl\'alrnent in Aristotle. Altltough Plalo lal<'r says
(256b6ff.) that the", il; a certain "0"·..,\'1.... t>ctw""" I({vnlJl; aoo <JTUcw;-i.e.•
insofar as tht'ya",diffe"",I, de1<>rmmal by I"" hrpo~ cW<-s not ~-e'500
.he genuine connection, lhe poculiarsuktanth"<1""",,·cwlo.betwern motion
and ~l.ln order to understand thilt "U1'·w'·!u. ,,'" may not take motion.
as l'1IIlo dOl'S, putely onlicllly. Only il we ask alxlutth" !leinS 01 being-in·
motion and about the !leing of being-.ol·res! will we 1><- able 10 und.'I'6'and
it. If we .... y lhat what is at rest is nol what is in mol;"'" tlwn we can in facl
...y .hat wNt IS in motIOn is """Iuded from wha' is", .... t, and that, in a
pure sens<'. whill is at teSl is not what is in motion. On the other hand, m
the ije;ng of res', i.e_, in the onlQlogicaJ meaniog of "'5t. being-in·motion is
predsely ro-posiled, inwfar as onl)' §Ot1W'1.htnS that has the possibility of
motion can be a' "'Sl. That is to sa}". =1 ioI, as Aristotle disco,·ered. not an
oovrtov in ....Jalion to motion. some'hing opposed to motion" bul, on the
OOfllra'Y, plt'<isl'ly "'quires motion Rest OS nothlt'g ciS<' than a determina.e
Jim,t Ca'le 0/ motion. an emin"nt poss,bility 01 ",holt is in motion with regard
to Its possible !leing. But this anal)'sis 01 nlotion <:an be carriro out onl)' if
the !leing of motion i:5 S('O;'t'l and explicated. something fur which PL>to had
""';U",r the m""no nor the polcnti~l.
The idl"a of Ihis u'):V'l. the one that duddJtes the .vtVif",lo oI6vm. ,",'cell'''''
its /irst detomnination at2S3b8-<:J. Th<-ch",acteriZl'lion is ushcn.od in by an
exprell!iion we M ..... alrc<Mly met. at the ~lnning oi tilt' dialogue, and "'e
c.lIl'd ."...... lion to 1t al th,1I tim",' m yb.., (bBl. that lrum which belnlliS
origin:>le 'n t....' it lIeing. tl Is ,igniflcanl that this explic.>lion of the It):'''l
related to the I<QlV.llvi(IQf llvta begin. with the term to. ytv'l.
For thP moot part. <'5f"'dally in the o:-arlier dialogues, /'lato exdusi"cly
u!l<~ t"" cxpn:ssion dll'l. Now, how<"\·,,,. this term )'t\.., appealS. and il
<:lCI:\01'lI in PI.,o only In the Llte d",logu~: in the pa5S3g,.. just ITlt'I1tioned.
as ,,·cll •• in the Pll""""i4rs (IJ5bl. the Phl1</1u, (12cl, and .Iso in
and the Trm-s. l'ho" U5C of ytvo.; .trengtheJ>5 the ronjecIUI\' thaI Arisl<ltle
t"" Uno<
The idl"a of Ihis u'):V'l. the one that duddJtes the .vtVif",lo oI6vm. ,",'cell'''''
its /irst detomnination at2S3b8-<:J. Th<-ch",acteriZl'lion is ushcn.od in by an
exprell!iion we M ..... alrc<Mly met. at the ~lnning oi tilt' dialogue, and "'e
c.lIl'd ."...... lion to 1t al th,1I tim",' m yb.., (bBl. that lrum which belnlliS
origin:>le 'n t....' it lIeing. tl Is ,igniflcanl that this explic.>lion of the It):'''l
related to the I<QlV.llvi(IQf llvta begin. with the term to. ytv'l.
For thP moot part. <'5f"'dally in the o:-arlier dialogues, /'lato exdusi"cly
u!l<~ t"" cxpn:ssion dll'l. Now, how<"\·,,,. this term )'t\.., appealS. and il
<:lCI:\01'lI in PI.,o only In the Llte d",logu~: in the pa5S3g,.. just ITlt'I1tioned.
as ,,·cll •• in the Pll""""i4rs (IJ5bl. the Phl1</1u, (12cl, and .Iso in
and the Trm-s. l'ho" U5C of ytvo.; .trengtheJ>5 the ronjecIUI\' thaI Arisl<ltle
t"" Uno<
-d so Ii l:!.9:
hl<'.1td~.n·3p,~·,.~!i.~.ti·I,,!·?"7~·'~1
"!'ii!:!':i"-'o\!O~ ;;I~" ",,~.:>'<-3- S
·1' . "'''-'<!iir a ..
''f.-a.''~ ·!- ~ill~--o~' i9-
1r ~ f!~1'i[rf~~I.[~i~~; l~~~Jfi~flilijl':;~
,
,-~- 1'·\ . - - . ' 19l'·J·-"~"
gi[3~~,tlilf·>~~S..~§fll ~~< , ~[f ~ s~~.·I~ '~~i
3"." '" ,,"."~:> !:.~ It Q! . . . . ~ 5-·!l: ~ "''' = 1>'
~
.• I~if~~~f!i~~i~,ji~~I! &~[~jl~f ~ifftfi~;
l~[;!i·~·if~l~r."·~~;·~~§,ll~ ~~~§'::8Jar.~.tf~~~Q~·~ Q
! "'? "j"Q.
,'< <:
~ -_
~'"'"
,,,!,'",, ~ "oi'life
Ii ~~':li!- 5·:>3._
. 0_ _ .. :::,R i! ..:> , '.. ~"''' _ if~ _'" _<il. . q. l:i.~, 0;; ,
§i615U-5!S1
tual ront~'fl1 and, p"""""r "s.ruch, is rwt a s"ffic..mt basis for s"ining elM,ty
concerning 1he Being <n the Id"as t~rn!lel,·es. E;~ as a ronn-pt perla",ing
to th" gi"et\MSS ofbo>;ngs. basicall)' says nothing about the l3ei,,& '" these
bl>;ng:s,Ix-)-nnd e:q>ressing the On<' d,~ti"e tMt bl>;ngs a~ to b<> grasped
pnrnarilr in tl\eir out...ard look. i.e.. in their pre5CfICI', and spedlkAlly in
tl\ei, p ~ IQ a st,a,ghthm,'ard looking up"" thern.'Sinc>' it is preci!leJr
tltis cOfl<.'\"Pl <n d&o.; tMt gUldC'i l'l.,to·s on10logical q,,(~tioning.. at the
beginning and Mlullily throughoul its entire COUTSl::, he docs not riseabo...•
""",in diffICUlties In onlOlogicalres£'an."h,
Fmm the passage q..... tw. ",hich ...,..(Ie"" tho: usk "f dialectic in a "e<}'
CQmp~ ",ay, we can now ",,1rael ,·"OOu. moments of diak-ctic:
1.) What i§ fund.>m"""'l is th.lt o''ta-oong-.-.'''' gr.... p<"'! as /..l:'fOI.IC\"Cl.
I ...., a.s ~""""'nten!d in l,hyo.;;,'
!o) II "'e ",I:.) yt."T\ and ri6T] tog<:'ther as th~ determinations of beings
foilowinS from the war beings an! thematic in di3lectic, then w... h.>,.... 11)
Soly tho,1 dialectic grasps onC!---b<>inS-In l<'rm.'I of ...1\.,1 w3!l 01"''')11 al·
ready then.- in them, and this .ho".. itself only in pure p<'''"i'·;ng. In a
""",In Sft\S(', this is tied 10 the first dl'1C'tmination.lnsof.>r as'~ YOfiv.
and l.6yo.;. Uyr,v. an: of"'" id""tifit"d: l."I'Cl'I Aristotle 5Iill posits.-ill<>; ..
"""
3.) T"he,e beings, ""roun~'<l in l.6yoc; ,'nd now l\> Ix- grasped in tOOr
ytVl\, a~ inlem.>galed n'gdrdlf'llthcir m,l'Ol"~ .,olv(.wlu.;. rq;arding their
~:tcoecn a..,.<tul\'l!tv, I.e.. as ~watl.t <J\!ill'l(l''tI<l8ClL
4,) \\"thin this l<U,wov(a. th....., .", sorne. liuC!, a fe.... which an.' pn.'Sent
~O: lfQ.vt""'. e.....rywhere. np""'ading ""e<}"hing~; ther an! distu1gu~hed
b)' "ni,·""""J p~.
5.) n..... mod" of discJ""ing tho.- "-0"-.0-'(0 of beings 'ndud"" redllCing thl:-
multiplicltr of bo:ings '" one, mJ\·u'J'I''''. and also in<lud<'s. at the $0""" time.
the "pposite mO"ement, takIng them "p"rt, mOIll€Ol,>- ~IO(poot~ in a <:er't3;n
.~"'nse runs through lil<' history.>1 \he pro.·"",,1lC<" of" being forward. up lU
its ani"al at the p ~ nithE' roncn.'l<' Ix-Ing, out of whal is al",ady then-.
i,e.. out of tho.-~. f..'"" t.... gmo;pinS of tlu-' f,,11 COfl<.'"n.'Mn of a loelng.. as
Aristotle L>ter rnar.\t> .....plieitl}, thol'matic. is a matl<'r of a rn()(\e of enroun·
'~ng bo:ings ",I\jeh i. ,,'Ialk~ t.,~. The abiding qucst"'" i. t....,,-Io"""
ho'" is something p"""",ta. 'r.t6J.u;'-n"? In,;.,far as it is al"''')'5'' malter of
an enrounl.... '" ).£yt:lv, "'...., as "'Sard5 the concretion of th.. faclUdlly
..J<isnng thing hen! ond no",. the OOl'I<:,ete pl"CSt'nC<' L~ ,,1"'Ol'5 an (;/io.;; .nd
P""<'isoeJ)" this, 'n the full history of its pn:...."".nc>'. makes ;ntcllisibi>! t....
p ~ of the nthi. here,~ which is all that count•. That, hovo·...'er, is
• Atttn__._.wilh_b_lJ-..,.,..
5.M""'~
I'I.~,'. SophW ISl6-S!7]
o. th fall
d9), th dial-
n an ther. u
uhr:a tl
Pia' phi t f' 29- 0]
hat' 'aid, th
ed
Abo"" .11, .... e mUSI keep in mind, in the ensuinS dlale<:tical a"al)'sis, th..t.
along ....ith the ...bl;t.nnve ","ults of the indi"ldua) slepl', the ontologiaJ
2.Cf.p.J5IJ
another. 0-. th~ other lund, """·~·e,. '0 Ill! y£ 6Y Iln....uw 6il~v (dtO).
~Bei"8 IS mi....J in "'ith bolh 01 them,~ i.e.. Being is P""SO'TIt in both. Forbolh
indr..od art In St""" ... ay or other. And an ~a,lil'r anal)l3isclarified the Being
01 Neh of them by mo.>oUlS of tile phcnom''nl)I\of )'l't"O:1lQ:....... hich. insofar
as it is.incl..des "''''l(JI~''nd o~>Thus t~ 1't"'l are p~h'en fQ,.1he
di.ll<"Cticat discussion, and 5pt.'cilkalll' in a d<:tertninate ","",uS: "''''TjOI; and
0'6.01; In mutual ocJoWon. both. ho..-",·er. in 4550Cid.tion ...ith 6....
3Cfp.J.l7I
§17/$I1-$.l2/
ow:s....-:it
preosel..
c) of the htp .
11 1m f
thus we walll h) set in reli.ef. in Ihisdiall.'<:1ical5oef\5e. whal is said "in ~lalion
10 thes<' fin>. ar><! .p<'cifically in such d "'ay lhal we p('fC1el"<' c"""" of lho!
fi,-e singly lot lho!m;;('kes: All(>, t,,"'inl> established tht' Ih'" in lhdt dil.
f"rt:ntnes5. I"" gnal of lhe ensUing ronsideraMn is 10 d""""".I,al/: Itwo
pen'ash'" p~nce of It\<' tttpo,· in lhem.
«Q) roinl 0' d'1'a,lure: laking up "gain Ihe ...... Iion
1".1...~~ rl"'ltll;;-<JTUmc,--lw-tm'ro...
AI Ilrst I'lato wk<:s up something said ""li.e" Ilpli.lto~)iN rl'''la\\'. 0>;; fan
1W\'t~Q<l\\'turpov otWl£<oi; (255ellf.). K'\'Il<Jl~ "'as initIally distinguished
'""', and against atoo.;;; w" said, il th~ are tvo\'t\(lrmto. lho.'" rl'''l''''' is
N>t aTti<:I•.;. il i. lt1Wt'~no\\'hl"po~. fUr1ho.'m\OI'\'. " ... already dairnl'd: I:<JT\
Ilt yr.lio6. ro I'f-ttll"lV Too 6\'1<><; (256.11). rl"""", is. Thus. in thr firs! pl.>oc.
ur6:ol .. is 001 p.e;ent;n rl"'la,,;. bul on Ihecoot... ryOv is. We Sitid further:
Aibt~ rl"'l<JI~ftl"PO\- T,.';miI (d. il31. rl,"l~ is also dislioel from lo.(mk
This;s an nolh"'ll new; It is jU5t lhal W!\al !\ad all"l'l\dy been :;;lid is taken
togeth.,.. fo, the following considetalion. i'\k>t(, wdllh.lt whal is set in relkof
as n'&'rds ,i'-ll<J1;; ow' rind against <JT6<n;; is boI!'ing-diffetenl. "'~ and
againSlOvro-e><islenn'. and onrand againsl tairt6~ again being-diff<:renL
The mOi"l' pl'\.'cise eq>li<:alion bo>gins at l5607. and specifkaJly in the
'oIlowi,,& order. Plato In.'ilts 1.) rovt6v. 2.) "1601';' 3.lltte ttEpov. and ~.)
6>1. and does SO specifically wilh Itwo int''IlliOll 01 ~ing I.... t Itwo fu:pov
is p.-nt in Itw.m as w<il as is lCXU16v. Pbto ttw.reby adds on ..........,tial
supplemct1t towhal ,,-as p ..... ,iousl~· l>C'lui,....l n-gardingamm.... Ov. tt<irt6v.
He dernonstuI~: I.) 0"1" and again511he complete difl.......,.,.. ...f .... "l)OI~
in "'lalion to (lT6m;;.. that a «"lain tauT6v of rlv'1l7U; and <rr6<'n; IS in<Wed
possible. 2., Me, "nd against the ro-<.->:1steoce of Ov, thai 0:1""".; is" 1111
Ov. "nd 3.) o"","and againsr!he dille..,......, in n:gard to tmJfO,.·, that tnuft'"
is aloo co-prc5en1 in ,1,"l<JI:;' In the fifth and si~lh f.nn.",ds. Plotin.... la.I....
look up thIS f\O..... llealxlul tM fi...,.rtv'land seC it into a 8""1'...1mctaph)·.'1-
leal 'yoMm with lhe "id 01 Anst<»elian cal<gones
Illli first stage: -.1"'10\; and taVro~.'
7.TI.... ~on'~·._pI-
§i7 1~5Sl/ ~,
of tlw-ir <1OQ'gorial cootent. rl\" ~1,""IG'" (if) mirto'- t' tiw.n ~...I ~f) laUrov
6ll0AorrlTto" oru\ ou OOoxl:p(lVttov (.101.). "IV" m1l51 theTdon.-l'b.""jse "")'
and nol 1>0.- troubk...l about ii," i..,,, "'" musl simply.>m"pl il ... lhe: w"y!he
maner <I.lnd$: d''T\Ol'' 1(Il)IOv I' £;"(J.l orull1f) t(tlitUv, To be SU"', in speaking
lhl.l.'i: u\m')I' lOirtOv ",,,1111'1 m\rn;", out 0llolw.; £;P1\'"'IJC'o' (d, "nl.), "w"
are not sp<"Oking abotH d\'7llll<, in lhe So"'' 'l'I'$f"'d.' Hertel' lhe'" t!;, as was
a1reodr indic:alt'd, "'!larding I..... Wd)' :9Om1"lhing m<»' be :>ddn'SW in ,iyol',
the possibility of differing re;pt.'Ctl': J(lfl'O'1hing prq;r.""'.IS prt'St'll' can be
:>ddressed In 5f'<"'Ch as Ih.. or ttldt, i...., it c.>n be 1<110.•." in diHerenI ~f"1"IS,
In the biKl<ground >.pin ""'" is lhe /Kr.'«>l<':' I(\)II'l1lv\a.;; the difl'.'ml<'eS in
respul, ;md in 8....."'1 'IOfll<.'lhing Ilk a ""'f"'(1 dl all, a ..... b.lsed on lhe
W~'<' orol\1D\ill<;. on lhe possibllllr lhou lhe m..'Ojll<, 1<\>1\'\0110.; ~
SliMes the Ilcing 01 something and ill; pll'§l'llC\' in '!.Ctt'\'. (lll.' (lKUWV iiJ;\'
mUt6Y, lito 'rill.' 1Iffll:~", mUto\> Itpi),; roll'ril\, oiittll ~£v (aI210; if w..
say d"'lO'l<, wirtOv, "'('a"'Spol'aking .boull ~tIll:.;l<, miotoii K~tu1Jd)",
"i!li participation, u;/h rtgtlfJ 10 1I;;rl/, in So' I.'S6... Insof.r as il is 011'1)0'<'
with lhis utegorial CUrtIi:TlI, as 011"l<n.;. it is d('l~Jncd as I..... sa...... Out 'f
w.. say 1111 wUl6'; fb2), "molioo .. not SdIl"oCf'lCS6," we .. y this full ""'v
"(M''lIIYluv uu t::Iuttpou (b2), "in l'icw of its I<\>I"'Jl\'fu wilh I..... tttpo"": " ...
SOIy it ><pO; ht:pov. Min I'it'" "r Olr.m- • By !lIl" pl\.'SffiCe "f ot!'lernes8, i.e..
lit' II" w.o~,l;o\J.tI"l mirtoU yt'toI1:\' oil" h:e,,,o au' !1F.pol' (b2f,). b)' lhe
~ of the f;u:po" in dv'l'Jl~ in d certain S('fbt' d'~llll<, ..
<U<OJ.1llp,~0f'tvTI, "1'l'mOI'ed,~ from s.>menes6. SO thaI il is 1'- 0"'" tlOCil'O,
notlheSolme. not t<nit6\', but ftF.jlO~, And Ihus ",,,Cdn also qUI~ justifiably
add~ n''T]a!.; as ou 10"1(>,-_ Here in Tlwrov lhl"'" 'PP"'B as"in the
f"!C"liar dUllI ""'dnlng' ~"'mt:'fl<':"oS'" and -11M: !lOme." K("'I'Jl<, IS indeed lhe
sa"'" and hmce unJtQv. but aox"rding 10 its c.>1l'gOrial ('()fItet'll, 11 is ~
Sdrncr><.'M it5elf.nd the",fo'" i5 tttpo", diff""",t. from tu1Jrol', and thll5 1s
"" roUt6v. Hena: thisOrtl"")tvoc, is, ..';th "'S"rd to mUro". both «IDtUv .nd,
t:qllally, 1\01 tmit6,·. KiVlllll; is mUw' and 0.:. IcNl(\,',
The ..,,,"" «mslde:ralion, a§ Jus jusl ~ carril'd out ,,~th ...-go"d to I....
rdation betwl'<'rt d"TJ<ru; "nd tairtm', is no", I\.'l"'"tl'd wilh "'S"-rd 10
n"'la'<, and a.doI;
TYI Se<:und Sl.:Ige: d"'llll<; dnd all\o',,<,.'
Up to no,,' " .... h,,,,,, ~ "P"akinll 01 d'''lOl<,and OtOOl; a; t\·uvt"....ruw.
lwo ~ which stand opposl.'d 100..... nother in theIr substantil'" ron-
Iml. which exclude one anoth...... This WdY of spedking is justifil'd, PIOl;dl"d
....e limil ou!licl"cs to till" M)'Oo; ,\nli~lhrnne;Lll:IOOed 4S the onl)' possible
one: it is possibl<, '0 speak of soml:'thing only as rrgards;15 O...n sell.,;."ml'-
. - . Then ..-!'·'l'l1; is pM:i!;d~' ..-!"'lOl;' and "mo.; "wen<;.- Bul no... lhe
qu<:slion ~ri.<;e;, Qilo:ui>\' r(rv rlltll jl~f\!:Mv Cl'IittI 0;I,'Tl"'; Ol<'oo!'~
olitlb' U\" {fro"o\" ~,. oWOtjlOV «\rn'l" "po<1~t\" (b6f.). Mis il lhen SO
,,·Itollr ,nappropri,,\(' to addl"C:56 u,jtl\v. nam<'ly ..-!\"Tjen... a" n!St. as
atOOtjlov. as sianding ,till. in th.. sense of 1J,nu).(J~1I16.\'(,,"am.x~ thus
in the sense of IIt.c n>n<:epl oIlleing ..... a", no wring at the foundalion:
&\0\"«111; ~"Ot'·OJ\"Ia.;? Thm pcrItaP" xn. in some ar. 'H<i<no; is in<ke<! co-
presoenl with ~·h'Tlcn:;. And this Jlt'tl'l6j.lE'W,)\". this r.C1POooiu. Ih,s co-p.......
ence of (lt6.ot; in ..-!\"Tj<l'; would ju>tify saying Ihal o;IVI\Ot; and 0't6.a,; a...
not sh...... tyu\'tlo bul a.... in a CO'IUin _ t'mit<;v. Indeed. loa)" 1'1.110 ..
how.. p,,-,,'ioUJJy' al....ady faclu.,lly <:sIAblishN ill<; lon ~aw o\JGw ttWtyI
(256c2(.I. Mlhnl Ihe !kolng of 0.1\""",; is 01 itself Ilk IIt.'t: i.e" in il om.cn.;
is c:o-presenl. Th~ il ,,'as sho...n II\dI the onlologicoll ~ibility of lhe
COIl<'n.'«: ph~... o"",non of 'l'I'l'I'<OO"fl\" includes its bt'ing!nO' """"'I, and. as
'l'Iyvoil<fttt\' toi. ,",\"to.;. it is al th<> loa"'" lime mo,·"",,,,,t to"'ard the things
to II<- krt(n,.... T'I>e ¥UIl\ or the ~ IS d\"Tjou;a"d, "" ~1\"Jlo,;, in a cerlain
n...
5<.'fl.it' l<\\''llI'I; £1; ~l. s<>u1 is lhe beins in ...hkh ..... can see lhal in fael
01001:; OS e","present ... ilh mo"....... nt. llto> SOIJI is m",·.. menl in the ........ of
o}pt~l';' and. as !'bto sho...s in the 5ympos,um. till" sou, does not """"'y Ilol"..
deli", "" ~ among nuny oth£or lh'oo .-xperi<'nces. hul illSlCad the soul is
<h.'Sin: aIId nothing ........ TIte soul is , .... jlnn.;v. thc betwl""'- ... hich is
direcl.'d 10 lhe 0.£1, I•••.. 10 (ltoo.;. In lhe soul, as des...., lhe t'a:f i5 c:o-presenl.
Acrordingly, od\"Jl(ll; is related 10 ~ jusl as il is ... laled to tmh6v. II
is not ult....l)" distinct from OtOO1; but is itself Min ~ n-ruin .... nse:.m (bbl,
a«J<n;' Min a «!lain !i('nst"~--1~ ~ 0/ Ihls -cerlain ""~- is darif>t.'d
by lhe ~"O,Yll>VkL Onto~llyCO'preliCnt ... ,th "'hal is mo,.-ed. n~mely lhe
r""
'l">J:l\, is lho:'od. This remork.:lble ""d objecti"elygruunded demoostra·
lion of the _ ....)V(O: of o.1\"Tjot; and (lt6m; mu" nol bl' confu§<'<! will. lhe
AnslOI"'''n aMI}".... which loafS that ASI is ilSt.'lf motion. as t.... l;mil case
of molion. For Plalo is not al all concerned wlth making mot,on .os such
tltcmalic. On I..... ronlTilJ)'. he is spe.>klng of "'hal is in motion or. mo""
OOsicall~'. of lhe ""lallon bo.'Iw....... whal is in molion and whal is unmo"ed.
This m",,'oo being in its relation 10 tl'>c u""'O'o'ed OS he", simply grasped
diak.'dic.,IJ)·-6t!l'l;C:a!Jy ,n Ihc ~ of r.l:&!J, Thw; PIaIO is not hen'invesli·
galing 0.1''f\(Il<; "S dvljOt; but o;I"l\(Il; as ~"*,-o.;. u "" u\' among othNS.
".""",~ Answtledueidaleslhe l"'-"sis lhal re;t is motion from ,'''' ......aning
of motion itself. Plato doe; nol al all inqui"" into this "",aning .......,. Th\OS
(553-5 ' J
10
eide~elr'sman.· .pt.
_. r' man 'pt.
w.. h.>,·" from the '<nyoulset lh<'matically d..limil«llhi> "OtWlMlllhmugh-
ou' tht' Ii,·...n... ""eo 0;I''Tl<Rt;. ro.\it6v. <mi<n.;. fupov. and 6\", are lhel>asis
of the dlaJe.:ric;Il consideration....hich aims at !he hl:pov and ... ho8e goal
i~ Ilw l.'Iabo.... ti<)n of ils structure. These fi,'" ............. hibiled in adWIlC'l';IS
>;Q:<JJCl,ollt\"o:, i..... as a"tono""".. rl&]•• nd, .>5 thesf' ",.... they .....re
5101jl£16:, lak('n .part from 00(' .nother ,100 held fasl as 5IJ(h. Tim basi>;
.lion.. make possible the "",pl;ution "'hleh alms at delimiting ocl"TJ(Jl<; not
only ,n oppos,tion In ro.uro", In "Pf'O"ihon tn orom.;. "00 in opf>O§ition to
the hrpov, but ~...''''' in oppositiM to \'i\".
We must darifJ' Ih .. ,elation of o;I\ITlm.. to Ov, 'A&&; 6;>0: .
olo(ljlUX6\lfVQI ~'(dSf.), ~ ..... mU51 ,",,,,e struggle throush without
I".. 0' he5it.uion" 10 the proposition: n)v dV'l<RV fttpov EiVUI wit OVTOl;
(dS). "that motion IS also diff"""'t from Being." And h""" PlalO fol~ the
53me train of thought: motion is; ..." al",ady 53'" tho,t dVllOl., ..ettIE' in
6\' insol'a' as II ill al all." In this resp«t, it Is.wrov .. ~,h lw. The question
os no...... lwther it can alson be ttl<pm' tl)(>6~ In I""-'case of dvTio".. Plato
already demonstrak'<l the p ~ of the ftqXl\' in relation to """ thlft
ea,Ii<." yb'T]. Th~'r('lore i<lSOfJ' as marion in il5elf al",;>tiy has lhe hrpov
pre.;ent in it, and insofar;lS 6\' is for ils part co-p~1 as a fifth. lhereby
..ivl\(n" is als<> fttpo\" tOO 6\'t0t;. W.. must say here that motion, or, mOR'
Jl'TtlO:i!l<'ly, mo..."ner>'. is d'~1 from fleing. 0'. more .,,,,,,,,Iy. from 6eing-
"'-"'6 A.:ronlin~I>; 0:1,,'1"'-' is 6""~ 0.:." lw "'l)llw (d. d8f.), Oil 19. in its
mod" of fk>lng. not 0". and it is Ov."
1''
1ben'b1'''''' ha"('shewn: ro 0... tri n: .....""""... Ei\,{11 ,,!rll«tt«lt\'i\"t{l
to 'ltV'! (dllO. thai ,n ~ c.aSl" of d"IIm.;. TO 1'' 6v Eivu~ t1li1t in all
di_lions-,n l\'L>tioo 10 t;", fou' <>thers-ll1"'ltn.; IS "'" lhe om~,"" i.e.. it
h;u in reL>tion 10 "lIlh.. othe", the eh.>racl'" of ,he hcpov, insofar as lhe
fttpov is 510 ftl'l\'tlll\". Hen(\'" 00 the basis of 1""-' un;"er5a1 presomn> of lhe
fu:po". d''I}<n.;'' allhe ......... lime a 11110.... Bur th.,t ml"an'illfl Ov is presmt
if"! 0;I,'Tl0'-. \\"i'h fl'Ko'nllU ,he "ol\'!lWlu of d\lTl<R-' ...i,h ailihe others. This
<k!mnnslr,lIes, within in the c, ..... it of lhe (j,.... the ol'l<rfu I'll 6vro<;. the
presence of non-being. on Ihe Elt'ing of ..1,"l<JU;.. Notice lhal IhlS 's not •
""'t"" of" conclusion from the Ih"'" to th.. fourth bu.t ifl$ted<l is a demon·
stralioll wilhin ttHo fi".:' !ht.om,;ekes. with a lhemati(' on"""'lion toward
0.1"'\0'''' in which the pl\'!\"1'lCl: of the fu'pov was all\'ady made clur. Inl;Ofar
IS the ftl:pov is al....d)' f""'S""1 on dvTiOIt;. bul also insofar as Iht' IOO,VU/V[U
"I the fi,'" aln>.KI)' ""isis, d"'i"'-' is a. such diftnml from 6>1. ThUll this
ronsid""'tion h.>s not demonstrated 5Ofl'Iething about d\lTl"'-' bUI inotead
l.J.l.'I6o' Cf P 3lIO.
§77/5S6-5571
ha.dialeo:tic~lly sho""fllhe F"""as,,'~ p""""""
of the hrpov in lhe ..1 ,'ll0l;
toward all other tim,.
In.abr as Ihis consideralion is a fann.l·Llni'·".....1 """, ,n""far as lhe
htpo~ enjo)'S Ihis perwIsive pre5enC(', this n'Suh ;5 ,'alid "ith01.l' further
ado 1«lTU 1W;vtn.
14 Ct Sopb'21_1.s...p.lll6If.
mlllJ.a, "brTng the others: This Sl<Ite of affairs ",ith", beings muSl simply
1)0, 3S!SU t'd, tW><ql q ... I<Otw.Mcn' Oll"lo'~ II ~ "(f:\'~ ~ (a8l.).
sitl<:1" o.'T)' p...",.,. eonloml• ....·el)' ytV<JooO. as a f'Gcn", has a K(I'vlI,lV(o ",ilh
lheQth=l. He", it is'lu;l<!cIea.tn..1 ttl.. ~ing of non-brinl;!lcan bedarif.oo
only"" the b.>sls ollhe ICOtvtll'l'fu..
And SCl""<' h.>,'" gun<' Ihl\)ugh the fundamenl.ol di.>1«lkal('l)rlSjd;,rariun
in the S<>p/!rsl. "'him is """'II)" lak..... .os th.. P"'f'C'" m",,1 <>f the dl.log.....,
"'...."'.u; thor tn"'lmer>t of lho.' .'lOphisl himself is ~rrled as d'l<' !Ill'-Ql~
sI>cll. In this [undam<'ll",1 consideration, "'him .n.alY7J!5 the d"'l«tlcill
n>lalions of 0,·. <:ttW:n... oc!,"TlOl<;. lo'rirtlW••nd .." 0.... 01" tttpov. it is riVfl"'~
thaI gu~ the ronsiOOr.llion. 1 want 10 emph.lsiu optic'll)' """" mor..,
hDw"'·et", tNt w:h~ LS ootthe pri""'f}' and proper themo.'. Whal is prop-
erly supf'<ll"'d 10 be ~'n i' thaI lhe tttpov. being.()lhc•. is I~ In ....eh
of U", poseiblc ~11ifJ. th.t it c.n be p"""",t "'ith theln. i.e.. thai it ha' a
(ol ....)\"!a ""ilh them all J t .... phasi7'<c thaI ills r>Ot in prindpl<' ~I")' for
misdiltl«ticool ('t)(ISideration to b;,carrit'd QuI upon ri~ .I:tiicn", or (y".
Qr tairnlv. could just as ""1111 sen·e to guid<' I~ pruper <'OIUider.ltion. I.....
willlal<" __ why new,dll'Kss Ills precisely riV'l""; lhal is themalic: <lt1d
why lhe poee;ible pte!l<"l\Ce of the I;tq'H:>v i, dern""'tnIl~ pn'cisody in rela-
tion 10 ..1''tl<1\'"
J"'" as the presml di.>ledkal ronsid<'ritl1on aims al the miX'" in order
10 delimn it "'·C' and .gili"'1 lhe n-.xo."[{ov. SO the ne", pftenom«lOtl of the
tt:£po,. "'al<l.'!l "i,ible I~ di.l\et:Ik.J field <>f lhe fl£pov; in other words, it
ronctptu.llly eh,";wucs lhe structure 01 lhe ht:pov itself, l"ht> C<>nCt'f'I of 1"'\
0... Ih.... l:>fol:omes de!.....,..;n.blt,-.
'O!tOIOV ro II",,':;'" ~.• Ii>;. foIlC£\'. Q1j" 4vnvl'iov n~' m\i 6vtlJ,,;
W' fu:pov 1'000'·I2S7b3[.). "\'/ho.on ..... e 5"",,1< of II"" /Iv we a", not talking
.boul SClmrlhing 11k<- an t.·ro--tfov, th.~1 which. In ,ts
opposition 10 beings_
is si..... pl!' e>:I:lud~, b"t .athe. tttpov I'Omv; ....~ m""n by 1''1 0... only
something lIlh.....,.. This "01\1)'." f!£l>O"IIQ.VV, ",.."",tholl 6v """ai.... pre-
llet'o',.,j, Putting il wTJlI}", Ih.. Being Qf lhe "oot" (Ihe "Tl(In."). lh~ "". is
§i'8/S58-5S"I
Mlhing else than ,he ~'':; of the ltp6c; fl, lhe pl'l";el>Ce Qf lhe Ilo.'lng·in·
I'\.'latio:-HO. '~i3 Qrlly ~ mo.... pn..:i...." fQ""ubt'<K1 Kin'" to "". ;n"-"'P""
talion of the ide~ oI1«Il~O)vla. The Ileing oIlhe ~I>QI,~ lhe ,,1\ in I ..... ~n.'"
of the In:PQ~, is lhe W,'~,~ of 1M JIpO.; to. 1'("", d""" """ ""hi!>it Ihis ....
sum. bu, il .. implicit in Ihc idea of I<l,I;VfOVla.
Oio\,Qt(lv£blu¢' fl ,," "tyol. tUn: JlUJJ.Q~ tl 00' OOl\'6JldI'p: W ",,'''POW
" to ioo~ k1l.ai1\' ui> /1l\JlUfl; (b6f.). M" I-tra Ihus """ans not simp!)' ·sman
H
in the ~ oIlhe minimum of j.Itya, but inslead \l can mean ·nal bigg"r,"
·umc. And ~ ,t is cleor ag3,n llut 1'\.>10 d,d ind<.'<'d Mt ntt.;n per!,...:t
H
No,,· it is to bc shown Ihat, juot as the tu:pov is p""""'l ....... 'Y"'.......... ..,
al.9o IhMe is posited along with Ike Ileing of the one the Ilclng of the other,
Th.. np""",iOll avTl9£Ol~ emerges hen> In piaa' of tttpov. etm~ i5 10 be
under.;tood as positing. not in the sense of establishins or producin..&- but
in lhe sense tlut ~hlng alread}' there ;5 posited lIS there, thus in the
sense of "1ctting il prcsml IISclI ". there." This i. the Sol'Me of llt'm<; in lhl"
il'rm avriElEm<;. The qUl'S!k>n is Whl"t ....T the 4vflnlltll£vov for the .:a.\6v
is" ti, _thing, an clv, Or "'helh..... it l.o\'tM-'VI'OV. ~na"",I",,"'_hlch Is
here '-"lui'·.I""t 10 p<:lS'Ie5Sing no "ut>stanlh... ronte1t1 of its own and which
lhCnllorcaooqt' no tlW\'\ljlln.., ToiIr' oW~o.. tpo\lsll:\' fi tw' ~o..
tlll"""l'IU\'; -"ElO" (d9f,), "Does it h,,,·,, II possibk: ""me," i.e" does il
pM'lde of itsr:lf, on th" t'tiuisof i~ own sut't5t.rn!i,·e ronten~ a direction for
a I.In"·ocal naming of itself7 "Ind<.'C<l," 6 ~ II" .,nJ.6.. 0"" au.o-u n\..x;
tu:p6~ rot,." Ui~ tOO .,n).ou '100£11.\; (d. dlOf), Fat the Jl" mAO", the
Ct\'t,n9tl't:''O'' 10 Ihl" ~""""", is nothing else III.,n the lttpo~.uAoun,,~ il
§;8/5D4-5t>5/
'"
is of'PO"'-'d to .. n Dlher.' Thill ......ich is posill'd In t.... .n'1i9E<JI~ In Ille ~nol ~
is not urlder.;tood in tl>€' ~mpty field of nn arbllrary r>oth"'gness but r~ther
is thdttj'>Ol' 6.Uou two.;. tile ·not of an 01 ......... Thu,')"i,,/; "no:' the d""~1t
H
OUr lrust. 1\'(0 ha"e tr,lf\SCft\dl.'d lhe prohibit,oo not only by darins ,n S"neral
to 'n''eSl:'~k' ~" (w. "'hich l'arm'.... ldes ,~ prohibits. but Ell; to) ~.
1\'\ \'It'l\<KwtE,, ~&:(~"f"'V oimil (<91.), "we ha,'" gone furt"". and ha"e
<!emon:;l........ 'lQmelhing sub'ilanli".. ly n"'"abroul it~: w .. h,o,... m;xl.. ~"
0.. Itself ,·isible as an [ilSo<>-
Mil 6.. ItS lttpo.., .s ",ell ... Ihe f""'IIlbiHty of lhe ,·,change «r lhe lttpo,·
ilself inlO concret.. beings. firsl make posoiblc di.>lcclical "",ma. This oci-
en« is nol an idlo:' 8am~ bul 50m('lhing 7(aA.eIIIW 6110: ~Il:l "w.6v (259Nf.),
~difrO(\lJt yel at th~ same li~ beauliful" II is d,fiiroh because dial~ie is
nol!lw.' ,,"o.kof emply and blond e~I",,1 h.aiT"'Sphn'ng. On I~ conlra')'.
the 8enuine -'<-'1I5l' of fuallytoikl' is axoooh'M9a., lU lei be _." WNII is
properly "isible, 'hedii".ofbeings 'hernseh·f;'5. And 'hisl":."ience it; beaulit'ul
beca~ dialectu: as a.ulpt01,," as laking apan ber.ngs in ~ard 10 "'Nil is
mosl propt'rly "i~;bl" 'I' lhem, "xf'O""S lhe limilS of b<-ings 'I' Ih,~r Bein8
and lhu6 fi........ hibilS beings in lhei. p~. ,,"ordingl)',lhe fundamen·
lal lasl< and bask ""lui........... ' of theliuv.£I<n>."6.; is loi~ ).llOI'tVO';; oIm'
l' [i.·en ~a9' h0010V i1J:yxo"m hillCOW\lllf.i" (dlf.), "10 be capabk-,"
bo.'U/.ouQ[iv, of "pursu'ng.·· wk; ~';;' ""'''''1 is Silid,~ a"d spt'df·
icoll>, "."", is sai.d in ilS sapb.bly, ;'e~ pu.suing ,,·...It is ro-said, in ,",-ery
i..q6jlf:v<l\', aboul 0,,,,(1, i.e~ lhe dlloj, and t)J:rt.C1\', ~",poslllg publicly:
eJ<hibitillg.. Iett,ng be,....." I"" (iii" not ;n some arbilrary conn<'d;on but
N""!llffii ~O:l' t""i,·o (dl), in!lw.' presenl ""peel in ...·hkh lhey an:"f'I>ken
ar>d in ",lation 10 lhal lo..'ar<! "'hieh ,'''' .spect leads. Onl)' lhUll is lhis
,su;u.n'TIrli bnOTt\Il'l an v..-rx"" {t1'llllv~ (d. d51.). The genuine detrmni·
Mt.. idm of di.1lectic, aII;1 afists here, would hc~ fim be po:'i6ible through
th~ idea of I"" ~tl'pov and lhmugh ~ deI"""ina,;",, of the ta;pov '"
(wtI6ro,,> ""l.'1 and against Ihe h'Uvn<aOl;.
Plato had al",ad)', long befo"'lhe SarJuo!. po-m..ps from th.. ,·"')' ~nnin8
of hos g<mui....' philosr:>ph.U:ing. III.'('n lhoe distinction ""'....-en tnwri"",,;;.
..mpl), nt>gation. ~nd lh'n(lo;OI;;' III.- dioselo,;;"·" "nol. But he actuall)' mas-
N
lenod 'hi5 dislinction much Ia'er: i...., he aclually SolW 1M ronc"f'l of lhe
ht:Pll" ""'ry ].".." Tho,; distinction silo"''; itsl'11 ,,00.'.., aU in lhe absurditiei
implicil,n the claim lha' t:v~ is lhe one and ""Iy negalion and thaI
id""lifit"hon is the on,' and only w.tt6tno1;;. as Anlistho:nes held. n,..,
dishnCt;un is pl'\'cisel" meant 10 teak.. th"""" absunlilies. Th~ Plalo Soly",
...g, ill Bool< V of ,..... 1UpuNr("; 1\ 060'~ .w.o."poirv o:o:l ~OI''1TWV h'U''1'lo: (d.
454<:2(,), ~lhe t\iOI~ of the bald and the ""iry is diff.......L· On the b.>si' of
the ,he$is of Anlisthenian logic, namely tMl UrlO<; Can <mIl' ""press idro·
nlies. "',, could «rtain)y draw I"" roncluSlOn: t"",M,' OI.tw.o~'
tyo."t!av th'tll, tiN ~t.••(..:pol O...-utOTCI\100l", ,"'I til\' "OIlI1T«.;. U...·Ii· flU
l<OIlil'(U.I'f) t~\o;t'ttpo~(c3ff.). ~1flho;>\>.lld ~ Ihe tf):"'l of 6hoemak·
ing." If shocm.tking befits Ilwm, lhen "thusc- who hil\'c full Iwad; 01 hair"
canno! bo!ro"..,. ~ma""rs. PIaIO rhanNeri:res lhis p~u~ "5 10110"'"
mt' c::r:Ulo) to 6VOfl(l mm...,,,· roi:. J.qllb·Io.:; n)v t\'avti"",,,". tpllK, oil
/jow.tTmilllpQ.; wJN.ov<; XPWllI:,·Qt (a7ft.). ,I is saying lhe C'(lf'l~ary. i.e~
Mying ~not.." while iKlhering simply mutterances as such. to tho e~trin5ic
idenlity and ""i'lumess of the "'ords.by reason of a concern ".itJ, d;spu·
I.lIion alane,...:I nOI with" di!ICUssion of somc mlllt.... al issue. Thus PL,to
i!; Iw~ ~Ialing lhe ,s,w..r~.. 1<Q,;. 0' ,s,o..lJ-p:oQo,. 10 Ihe discussion of so......
mall..... al ...".\ llMI ......."'nL>y.offi.:;. ;P.. 'h"/I',nn.ro.;arwl /1"iJ'w.ln m ...
word·play. But one callnot objo«:t to Ihe dl"l';s above. so long AS <me ha. no!
mad" l..6yo.; tlBnsp.,......,t as sonwlh'ng otheT lhan a Uyf". 01 milO," Thos
ap,,"nmtl)' <mti",l}' formaJ logiOlllask ,,",s a ~aring Ihal firsl nukes pos.-
.ible dialectical science in general. Here for the fIrst Ii"", lhe p.,blem of
negation i!; J'O""'" and pUrslled ,n its first .teps.
l'hmommo1ogica1l}: thlSGln bedarifi<.d "ery briefly. E,..,'Y "not,' in",'CT)'
501}'ing of ~""'." ""h('lher e>cplicitl}' e>;ptl'SSed 0' implicit. h.ts. as a speaking
""oul somelhillg.. lhe eMrarler of exh.ibl~ort, E"en lhe t.'mplr ~not." the P1Cf\l
e>od..,...... of """""hln,o; ."..". ~nd Bl;<'Uul _thinS ...toil,~r)", "'-":>, bul i'
simply ""ow. that on wl>ich lhe rq;.otil" is fotlnded, Ihu~ whal, in "'ring
"no!: is de~mil~'d a"",I\5t the noth'ng. This empty neg.lion ~ dkccm·
....'t1l. U'to~ Md VOE'v, prim to lilt noIhins; it lets lhe nothing to.. ""-'" ....
founded by tho ""S"tro Thall!; lho:' m.'anmgofno:-g.1lion in P"-""C:'f1ld<"5, This
noegarion. plaCK! prior to lhe nolhing and pul'\'ly .".dusionary, has ~us been
Uflro\"<'n'd for the fin;1 hn,e ,n lhe histol)' of lhe ~'eJopm""1of our logic, in
.....r gr.>SP of ~ 1'h.~1 should not sed"", us into thmking lhat th.. neg~tion,
empt), exdus,m,;s the mosl immedi.ltE'one and the pnm.al)·one(';lrried ou,
tn ~".. On the ('QI'1''''l)'• •he I]IiglnaJ negatlon IS precise!}' .he llOC PlalO
e>:po.;es ,1' ro'lfllun~ and At+llolJe then. in a ""'laTk.lble l'C\'I-'f'SilJ of teTtM,
c-~Ib t\'(tvn(llO'.... The .""pO)' nl'gJtiort. at II dominated the un<JeTst,ndlng of
~". up 10 l'lato. did not spring from • p"mtlrdiaJ stud}' of '-Uyo.; but from
lhe ground of a particuLu at>d o,'...... !t.>sty (Ihis is nnt l'I'\eanl as" n."roao:h)
lllo.'Ory of Ilt~ns. namr.ly Ihe ram"",id~an tllco,)' 01 Bdng. ""'" un;"'etsal
characterorp~,ofd\'m, which l'am>midesw,,-su.., first lOsee, bt."",me
for hlm the ",,""!>Inti,... IWlm of beltlg! in geroernl. He Ihus i<!er.llfied lhe
ontulogicaf ......ning of Ileing will> Ihe""'i<:aJ lotality of beings. To th.~1 ",lent.
fot """<'T)' ""')'ing "no.~ t1lt're remained Wt ""C <>nIl" Iht- nothing.. si~ indcl'd
n is notIting cl;e lhan the t\' AS 6,·." This nu\:e; it de.lr lhat Itwo cL.rifirAltion
§i9/57J-574/
wro.;.. «U· oil (d7). Wi!h many bciRg!! ,,"6v will b<: Pr<'$COl. COn bo' f"""'lC"t.
bul ,,~Ih many n(lt. And.l.6y<>.; and ~(I belong to tN, I.U..., (d. d8). W..
1\.0.\", not mown. the sophist ... ill !<>y, that u.-,...;. as ~n 6", un posoibly
1uI\", a Tffi'''<lIVkt with ,," 6".nd th.,t there can thm:-f~ bt-son\l'thing like
a """""~; or a ttt''IJ in the ....,.,SO' of f(tVtOO't1lCl'i (d. d9). As long ..
lhat has 1\01 ~ ~wn, the poIlsilrility of the "xi5t'-""'" of I"" -IIOphist h..
not .>ctually b(>m P'O'·ro. Thus _ M,·C to undertake anew OUt assault on
the sophist,
In fact, If w... 1001< more clo5ely, "',, ...iII see IMt lhe fundamental dialec·
tical ronoideration ha. "",,·ro not in lhe field of """"" but ,,-ilhin the ftv.;:
rompletcly uni,'om<aI (61): <lv, o;l''lJolr;. otWn;. mVtOv, and tttpov. Bul
now, b«.1use the lh;:m" of tM d;"log.... is the sophist in "'ll"rd to his
uis~, "'" have tOe<hibil tit<' ~i1:>l" ('OIlju.-.cnon of ~ with ,," 6".
400
. c po ibl Th.·
th
th
.O.p.33 .
. . p.
o
if ~ili~II'~fiIJI~!l !llf[!~r·~~!~~:~~~li!
~p-~-c..~wl;;i;'clg~_ ..
It of9f~g I~~ ~~lf";~-~
ii;la2,I;;·~-"'~'~,,·c,~~--.:::a -':::"",Il
"'''' "<>',,,"':: ~rlirt'"
;;l". .;a.-c~32'&,,,,a~ "gll:::l ~-c~2:g?~~§jo;9-~5.r;~~ :>~.!;
iii ::i: -,~ ... !:.x.". .. ~-,--?g "'l~a:>::>-c,<~" '<~" Jr:>
~-~~_.a.:!J;.~'-<,'BIl:i6~~ ~ &. 15- g-s.,il;~~-~~~ga::l!'.1;Ic~
r< :~~~~:>ii""'~!W?=~~;l3 =.. i::"'l~l-J~f~-~l~~la
{ ~=lt~~:j~!§.i~~~1 i~p~~;'~~"J['!~ ~~~I
~~o<:l!J;.5·~if"~~~ . .f-;"a._~'1 ~--Z~~5~il;:;!.l 5-3'~.",::l~~a.
!~3~1~~~&i~1~~8t~ ~ff::>~lE~iJ'~~~~;il~
i ~~~.
a.~ sl~~~~s~stl-'"
_ it"'lIi- .~~... ~t!;%5Iii-c,~flE~I~Z;l.
o~~" ~ .. ~ _ !:::~
~ '<~li~~~~lli~e l~ ii~"~':l!i~~~~:!F~t
' I'Q. ,'I li·
0' 0' O'.:! '" O'~
1' "...."-,•.. ,
i5:S-
~",,~a~:::Ic1! g ~-2
,. ;-- .";: _,H.1' ,:;: •c ,..;".'i c'
_ S::>•. ~Pt ,'_." .",~.,, •- ..P,0:-. :l~
~~.
... -~, _., ::>_0-" ~::I"'-".
.~lll,=tl!tJ~.I~ ., •• I,I~.rl •• I,.f •• ~
t [ .(;-, 7]
t if r-
U.
12.
§ilO 1587-588/
q ,i J rai
~ J ~~ ¥ ~ ~ ~ IU! [~, i ~1'H! 1" 1: n~,!h ~ ,
a-~·g:'liig' a.1f.ig· .. ·-" iQ,ft~.~ ... i..l.~ 3i~; [; ~::= j
?~ <d ,... i. -l'i
" 0",_0, ~} .... ~!:
~ a~. ~ 1 ~ 2, ~ g:~ ~ ~go & a 3 lir
;""1:>"" -_:1-.;:.;0." 3:
[it i ~ ~ 5:!!:
~:>".~Q. i"-: ;; __
r;iag'B~~·[§.;;~~·~j'!:'J],~]i'li'i"~,l!('c ~--:~g,~~L~~
l!l. ~.< 0-"" 0- t Q. ... !: :> " _ III ~ _. i1: Ii " _ 2, -: ~ ...
'fl ~}~rli~iJI~~Jli2,fZ~i.jl~I~~!~t~it~ll~
~~ * ~ SJi if!l ~.]- g: if l~ i i f ~ 6:-0 Il: :t of ri' §~ ! ~ ~. ~ So ~. i. e;
H ~jrifrIil'Jtl~flllillillkl!~!~I;llli
'j"' ,.,. ,[/., ••.. ,,~,! •. ".~,.,.. ,. 1
I :r. ~ '1 a a~ l f if Q. [~ =- ~ if (0' S' S J' ; S' ~ if ~ 2. ,:"r;i G:'~.l :: ,I".,.
other: .~Ip: Ut~£,,~ ....~l,..... l&yov o\Kil'v •.. OIl[PyU~!"m'
'"
(262b5«.), ~ults It> roo ~ beGou~ lhlJ, 5e<lu~""edoes r>OI =""
"isil>l~
IN" Unll)' of a pR'Smt bcing. Just as littl.. a. dOl'S: lito" 1J:yrJt<ll "Uwv"
"~.. ·in~· .•• "om ''''';"1'- "'" t1'I,. crovt):£lQV 0Ii0Cl" ~((J G1J'WnJ
~ (b9ff.). H....... t<x>. with "'S"rd to this "",'ll:Un. no),{,yo;; actually
O<'<'U~. סOO<1I100.' OUtE ow>:; om" t""lnl>; "pi<;,v o;nj/i" ~l<.l" 0'Wt
oumen' uvtoe;~ I'll ""'to<; 611'-0, to O<I)'"t1lltvm. "pi" 0... nc; to.;; o.'6j.lam
tu lIoW-um ~pOan (d. (21f), Tlwessen,iaJ is that, in a ~ m ....."'l6tvt...
•"'" ullO'rar'l('l', rn., \<xulion. ~'-oi, "I'e\'NIs" (and this fonnubtKm is l<n·
portant for wh.1t will rom.. ldt""jo\lo1lo\·6\·to.; "ul 1'1)6V100;.·~~
nf beings oror 00tl-b6"gs.·" ,)'lMri!v th'Tero", l'l a marte.of p........,lify,ng
bei"&,, ()t n.on-bl.'ings. Such a b<l1.ol>v. ,uch a di"dos'"'' pl'l:'Sef\tifo<:atiorl,
does notoccur. howC"er, ""til lIph' /h·tl;; toi;;,h-6jJam mpl'\J.tom lOCpUan.
"6v<IjIUt(l and i»\ilam mi~ togelh£'r," Onl>' then is t.... ~ a ~ nlltl>t1nr\'.
This slate of affairs, the r>ro!S5''Y of a """,,:..000'\ of tWOI'll and pij,,(l. must
not be und,,"tood a, if A.6yo.; ~uhed ,n _11<."1\><" r..,m a summ~tion of
6vQjIu and j)ijl'''- 011 t~ cOI'Itra.)'. tho:' 6tll.oiw itself, the ",,"'aling. i!; the
prim.~ry pht..-nomeroon, prior to bod, of mew. Th.lt is why t~r ~'"
tlolUill'um. And ""Jy insofar IIli mey are such, is thoc oro"'",,·lo. possibl"
TheonJ,.,t oft..... de9Cription. in whi<h I'Jato hc'gi... with an iscllated Ih'Qjlo.
al\d j)ijJlll, is not idt'l'llirnl wilh t~ stru<1Un! ollhe ph......."""", in itJll'lf. II
is not the ",,5(' tn.1 words fir.;t flun". abotlt in isolalion ~nd thm a", t.1knl
tog..>t..... r. whence: meMtl.o\>,· ariSC'!. 011 theronlrnry. the futl.owis pri..... ..,..
II i!; lhe fundamenlal phmc>...." "'n. And only wim ",f""""" 10 it does lhere
enst the J'O"ibilily. as & d"'id<:nt mode. of isnl.ltcd. mt"1ely ,,-,<il('(l words
The 6T\l.ouv. which hari>or.; the possibility or discourse. Is • colIStllulh'"
dct\'fmin.ation of o"..,in it.. ..lf. ~ d"'.....minalion I ~m wont to d""ign.>t.......
Being.in-ttw._·o.1d Or !leing-in, P1~toSil}.. oothing aOOulm;". bul "'e muSt
a,<old misunderstanding it as a ..... lll::r of" caliunction of "-1''''''''''131\0<\5.
ThaI kIe~ of all extrinsic shm'ing tog"'~' still d()l'J\in:>t"" the ""tire ,,,,di.
liMa! callCgori.&J ma1<>rial of the grammar of the lnd~nic langual\';'S.
Thls matt-ri.lJ IS nol reducible to logic and is not anchored in it but in Cn",k
onlology. If "'e "'.nted \<) St'(' th<" urigi",~1 and p...."l\OmeMI «mn«tion
bo;otw"'!f1 'he ph""""""",n 01 IAngw8" and tIM: Bemg ur man, ..." ',;ould
h.we to ~ rid. allh£> "e<)' O\llSct. of I~ proposition as thoc point of d ..- par-
tu", lorourorientalion tOYo'ard langua~_ This d.."eloprncnt,as It has come
tobe today. "'~s pemaps ""tthe intention oftheCtwb. but" has for mem
• ju~tifiable se.-. si""" Myo.; and sf'NCh ....,'" for them giH'f\ initially io
this charKl......"
l'l.o",', Sopluu 1m-5951
.n tlw llCmt' of disroul"9l1': somdhing shows It:I<.'!'. t.... fi~ of so...... being
tx-ro""", presml. And only to lli..f:niu I(IVtO (db). Hthis inte"wining~ of
6~o and /liillo, (06c1~6IIdlo liryov (<16), "do ...... call Myo.;.·
The first "lag.' of the consid..... lion of l.6yo.; O<'ts out. as ....... "",'.. __,
from di!lCOUl$<' as sp<:>k ""pression. As SO p~,........ discourse shows itself
'niti.llly as a manifold of ·ords. Thecon5l<lcr.lti<.:.1, howl'...... from the """Y
oulSl'l does not simply allffilpt 1(1 mal«' understand.,bk this manifold of
words in ;!>Ielf. isolated. so tospo:~k, as .. manifold of 50"n,:I5;< but inste.:>d
the ~rd isdi~1I'd from the"er')' first lOWard ItI<' basicSlru<'lu .... oil.l'r£ov
in lhe scnseof &\1.olh·. From this phenomenon of IiftAOOv.lhciw6l1otu a...
th,,,, srasp«l as O'll.tilf.lom.~,on that basis.. the simullanrous o';""~lion
toward , .... pos6ible th<,om.-s "fdisd(Jtiu"" ""'uls a funda"",ntal distinction
.... ithin ilwlpa«l. Th .... tho- crilerion for the B.;ng of ....·ords in the unity 01
disroune is their dlSC""'i,·.. <""racter. And the obledi\'1' criterion for d;"-
tinguishing I""",,, &ll.tilf.la«l is the unity of the possible object of the d;"-
c1osul'\': "9Owa.KpO.;t;. I emphoslud lhal these terms al'\' t<> I;M, taken ~
in thor "idest SCf\!il'. We haw no rornospond'ng I'.p~. I'ither to cap-
ture the positi"e asl"-'ct of this discc,..cry or to ...press lhot .....h.,t is unrov-
..1'>'<1 hI'I>' is not al."ad~· rued appropriately by Ariuotle's late, ~ttempt to
do 50 In re["t~n to thor mtl'rion nf time. Ml.ou., it!lelf is no....·• Within ~
insofar as ~ is a "UI'!WJI<T\ of ll!Il.r!ll<Ofo. not the n'Sult of thri. com·
position, but. on thecootra')'. the ,:ol\'<.tWl"a of 6VO\l(t and /li\I'a is possible
at aU only because ),J;y€1" In itself isa Nll.oiw.On this ba..i9. whol s",m"""
calls Ihe utegotial p,,-,pnsition can be designated thl' 1<plirrc>; and
"",.:p6wtO<; ~ Thl'f'l"by Plato acquil'l'S. "e!'Sus lhc Cmty!1<i and The--
<>tt<'fus. ,hor possibility of dclimiting l.t'rn" posit;"el~' ow, and against the
6vw6:t£\\' 1'6''1)\' (d. .01· Naming.. til£' addl\':S6ing of b<.'inSS by way of
naming.. make! "!sible- nothing oIthl' brings the..-I,...,.. C..mng by name
can "",·e. dete,,,,i,,,,, what is named in its subs!.ntr.·e ront\"'t. Naming thus
does not ha"e the cha.acll;>' of di!lclosul'\'. Instead. If anything.' all il; visible
in namill,l;, it is~i.mpty the ....·ay the na.med obj«t is, lIS It Wert, S\WIlJ>OOed:
~,"'ll,ThI>~tioo"'~6"'.'-"_"'..Jo""II"C"""p""''<ll.6to<-~.
io"'" yo< tI'u~~( .. iiinl''rr<'g.''«I "'"""",,oill"Coriploilanli""S" Ihfr,/Mlpu. ~,......
l6.AH: \\1\01 10 II"C.........,. '"
--,1-.. fu>< ~1 ~I'I" 01
"'$ ...... in""T"tU_ ond. ""'k"'lI_'1 To
itIeoJ >lrU<nIJ'<of .... l""J""irian. Tl\o1 II tu<h Otlll
_IlQ do ......... WhoI .. ~_yJU$l,L"
l'a01.UISondlOl..... "'id... .kfic><>\I-.s.-...
.• on •toll< l _yill~
w
:7 TI.... -.J""~ r_ .....~"''''''OhAIJ .... oIl.&,o.;.p, oIOJ~
§8I'J IS!!!4/X)/
b)' the AAtnJn of the ~'1l.llll."nn. of lhe lwOJlu wilh lhe Pi!IIn.. n... ror>sll'
lution "I the t\ as STll.Q""£VQv, as ).q6I'£'VV,;' Ihus..,,<rn.u m 1M malo' of
~'''' Therefon.> lhe ~blc i.Fy6j.It,·ov, aa:ording to i~ ""'Y S<-'f\S<). is
pnogi"\'f\ p.mscly as so",,"'hing to be dcalt "·ilh. '""t pJ'Of"'fI)' m~.lRS
>tpiti;,;-ltpitnla. The dealing "';Ih solT\<'lhing is Ihus whal is pregi"en in
.....e1'). A.6'fO'; ""'OIding to its moo;t proper sense. l'\alo <ks'gn'"t'S Ihis by
l'I'Ieal'\S 0/ IhI' lenn ",pi 01. (U3.1~). Tht:'" belongs 10 ....."'Y ~ the Ittpl
0\1. 'The !.Uk is to u~~nd this lttj'l\ 0(, .,. a strudural momL",t of the
1~t\'OV and nOl lQ mj.und~"'nd it. k<l astray by Ih<· trad,tion. A~
as addl\'SSing something.. posst'SSCS, as preog;"en from lhe "elY fi~, the
unartil:ulal~ unilary being. The", bekmgs 10 ~ as a determinate mo-
menl, lho> c",akin" wagon on lhe .'rwl, for example. I do not I!<>ar noises
in an isolated way, as if I "'ere a .ubjKt in .In instilute of <'''f'''rimcnral
psychology. but J hear lhe wag"" on lhe Sl~. Th<> f,t''O<;'"'''' Th""..-k1us
.ilting before him Tht,~ctus. as" unitary p~i...m "'hole, is tl!<> n:tj'Ilo(,.
I-\'e can CoIll this the ~oboul which" of the sp'-"king. In lhoe dn:uit of wNt
is thus pnogiven, ~lV now ...1s ""mething in ....lief. W1",1 IS l('1 In n.'licf
is the6roUla~l, In It, lhcrclo"'.ln the p~i"en and .'~I unatticula~being.
I.trtov will .... something in relief. spKifkall)' SO a. to rnake the being
unden;loodil$liOmelhingand lherebrd~incit.Thus lho> "..oout which,"
lhe whole of wMt is pregiven, ".g. the c....aklng wagon. is Ih.cn grasp..'<I in
terms of lhe crealdng Itsclf: Ih,' w"8"n p.>j;Sjng by <m lhe st~ is now
e~pcrlc-nced and <k-tl'nnincd ~ cre.lking. ".., ""1"1 oil ,"""",,,,,, hJrI:x:t", a
double Slruc!u""
I.) It lMa,," the -about which,· as a wlook'.of ,'''' discoul"Sl' In general.
lhe whol<>. p""""', "'ill unal1lCUlJted lIi"~'" ""ing.
2.) Insobr as ttoesetling in ",I;"f is Olrr"od "ul llf"J" Ihis .(1"1 o\.. insofar
.... cn>,,~jng is "tlributed to it lIS" 5pecial dctermi""tion. the articulation of
the wagon itself p""'<!S 10 "" WhM is spokn about. The Kl'pl oil then means.
mme particularly, lhe tipecifoc ~of ...hich" of lhe dis-coul'lll'.
We therd.,,,, distinguish: I.) the "aboul which" of Ihe dL...:uurs<', i.e., tho1
unilrticulatoo wholor, and 2.)lhe "of "·hith." ,.... "'hat is thcmalic'aUy artie-
ulaeed aod sel in reliel: ",'''', grarn"",. ("[[5 the ~.ubje<1·01 the propos;lion.
Th>1S, clearly, 11>0 P"")"'" p"""""",,,.1 carrying oul 01 ., ...-llir>g in ",lief.
br ll'IloUvor iJ-ttl,., does not occur in su(h .. ""'r 1!\aII...O1'\'Pt15enl<llions
a", linkOO "'IIh one ...,other, bUI, inste"', oul of the p ~ of .." un-
attku"~ -.bout "'hich,• i.e.. a dCl''Tmi",'!e unill1iculaled Slat(> 01 affairs,"
il h"ppens, pre<:iscl)' th~ llw sc-tlinll in .-clief of the -"s-whil:h." of the
c",aking or Ihe ,ilting. IMt 3.t the some lime lhe"of which: lhe "'Agon m
~1. ~ ~ - !t po 1; ;I !T ... g" f~.t 0 IT ,- !T
t 'E;l -
f:l~!!l .1".;/
d:!., ~ ::r if ~ .t.
---0."-,. ,.. ,-'. ::> ~ 1;;"
~ p.. ~ i ~ ~ ",'!' it :~l
;;0" .§. ~ ;r'" a. '''I .
'» r;:~ ii'a §'a =:J ~ ~ ~. a: ,:a
~ ~ ~ a'; 2. : g. 0 ~ I;;"'~ - ~;;: .. '< 5 •
[i~ .. ~3''£l ~:j .;-" - ~:i ~ if <;. >; i 0< - ;;I• ., N''!!; ~ or " 'if - 9 ~.
, q' , , !:: il.lg'~""':7 .. .'Ii~1<~~"~"··Q"'~~ l'~
,n K :or :I. ':i !; a 1:
"lOll l~l.
~ !~~~~I~ljl~!~~it~t"'!:~~~lii
I, -'
.. ,. a "-
H £~ '3"'~if':'f<~[
1!f,-o~ ,~~Ii '0-,;"" '§' 2:;':1-I-';'~l
!'i i - ":T .. _. ;r"
ill i r = ~ cf..1i oN ::r ~ .: ~. :;. 2.
t1.~·;lqill""~
U .;31 ,j.j !T ~~~I?I~~~~i~>;~ a"~~:~'!{5'" ~
;,: ~~ \C .. 0 ~ --::r,~~ HI!.Q.!l ilE::! a8"".;:o9 0 ,,-~ '"
:,"."5\ <;.
"..
,,'
;<·ii!..,';',":;~::::5"
",~ j< ; _ . , , ' -<._. q - " i . 9~'llI:"'i_
~ •. ~.l:~ !-i
!
H! ~i:.~~!2. d~:" ",IPI~q~~~'t ~Bi~'~I,l- i
i . ~Ii:~ :g;ola_g.a3~i_q:, 5'~~'''''~ __. 1;Q"l "
~ "t .,;;
:t 0' ~l.p ... a 3';' 2, ~ 1 ~ ~ l~' _:l: §" ~ : ~ ~,. ~ -~
• t h·P'f
p - ... ( i ; " . ...
c .... 1;'!l:T
0l"""'",'7> i1' .-<
i! =: " '. P F.' S 5"
::.: _ o ., or" .. 2 n"", _. C;" -
~ ~ 3'. " ,"
'go':;l .•.
"!~"f: f'l'''''''·l~'
n '~H ~f' ~ • "'..Cl ". -
. I Co _. • ...
11::' it;; " :> <3 ;:l; /l;
'iI· ~ ~jII;I~ a.;l~ ~ G!tE ~!t>:::li &'<.*11: f.·".'I':,"O~.Q;'ia
e"'~2: :~ I" a,p·"·"~-'·.l"o'
J· I, !~ ~.~ J~j a ~ll i~J~{il~~~ f~~lg~ !;i~
• ~~ 'f h 1 ~~'f o2:;l1~1t~i=~ ~:"'a~~o=';3-<
~ ! ~~, ~, • I •• I;l.llil!I'~ 1:!I:li!I'~
::'~a 9'l"1'
"'"a .... · aij ;;t~·<..,Ilt)l"~"(l.-
'§=.~! ~-'" "'>",~ - 2.. ,
i • ,{ ~:;lb:·'!!i.3
]:I r;; __ _"" . "
~gg'9- _ S • "" ,, ,"!- , or
.. -II:'3"=-'-
". ,""'_
..
",,_ID _'''=:T.'l'''_,:;
:lc. . . . . . "jt; "_. ","l5
"''''' _ _ ''< .. ,. ""
Q. ..
::l
:or i. of' C>~ ".~
modification. !he &]l.oiw duo:s not somehow co",... to r>olhing, the l..qrlV
'"
10 a.l.J-rf;!v IlIl/ltv ' ....·hkh it cannot be. by ilS '-ery -.se), to a 100al lack 01
diKlo!iu .... but 00e.0w;e the Attn" tl,.os a COI\!itiluti,·~ ~INct""'. ill ~
,..rily f""lil'l'ved in ..... ~ modification 0/ '-6yo<;. Uryo.:; can be modifiM into
a JJOn-disdosure only in lhoe s<:ns<I of COfl<:l:aling,. dislortiog. obSlructlr>g. n(>I
letting be5f"ef\. Evt'f}' I.6"toc.. thus .....·en the 0"" modified in lhis way, lund
plt'Smts itsdf ;lS a l.tp:,v Tl. E".,.y ,,,,If..,xp'''5Sion. and "'""'Y speakinl,\
about 5Omelhing. is tak<.'n quite naturally al\ll primordially as a &11),,0\,\'.
Thus w~ have. as:suming thai the 61\).0"" can undergo a modifICation, the
following ~ructu~ \.) A 14'" preents irsoelf,and is the.... as a discl(ll5u,,",
of somethi"ll_ 2.} This Uyrw. how<!\"cr,can in itself be di51ortin~ it ,,on pasII
,;omeIhing off as 0111... than It is_ '"sofar as il p..".."..ts ;tself, and always
p~ts irsoelf, as l.t-p:w <I, but factually. in a p.1rl;ru!a, use,does 1\01 impart
the being. thil; U:ynv is a dl-ccption. Dton-ption is IhU'i pme;ib"'. and "n<t..r-
st.1ndabk in general, only in I..rmsof l.tl1W as l.t'r£'" 1'1. flecause il is ~
IW6<;.l.6yo.:; in ,!!;elf can be falS(>. JUl'1 .05 we speak of -f.Jlse roon.ey,n ,,'t!icl\
1"""sHu g...,,,ine mCll\e)' bul is not,.w lh<> l./:r£Iv tMt distorts Klfl'Il'Ihing
presmb il$elf~s what il is not: the I.£'tl"Y dislort!; 'I~lf, II is in itst'lf"fa~.n
E,''''Y l.6-,o.; is t""mol't', as Mr,o.;. a AtyE,v rt. But it nood not show that
a!>uul which It speaks; il ",n al!tO distort it. in sl>(h a ",ay. or routSf'. thot
this nf~be· judgment p tend' 10 be tru... n..ception. ~ Is thus
fOtlnded. a«<>rding to Its I). possibilit}~ in the intentional <:onstitution of
Uyf;ov. It ~ )1yI:,v lIS >..ty,:w ri thilt can be a dislortion.
ThUl; II is dear thilll'\'ery f..6yo.;. on the basis of this C'tlI'I'titutiQn, a1wal'5
and ~rily o<:'('Ul'! in a certain "mode." It dlS(loses m 5udl and Sl/(h Q
""'y' it is";!her disdo,,;'.., Of distortive; I.., .. ~'wry i..6yo.:; is aOl6<;. nOlo.. lit
yt n,'U tl;q.ic\' u''Uyl«liov llffiQtl;!\' (iv(u u;,y ~. (26:\.011 f.•. HWelOlY tMt
......ry Uryo.:; is ~rily 1lO'6<;. In one mode or anolher, n pnriseiy be<;aUS"
It is 1J:;tl\" ri. Like..·iso>. ~0l6v n,'a tei>tl')Y £;Ylln liEi (262e8), "II is nooessary
tMt I..6To<; a,lways be ~0'6<;.» In e.'t'<)' i1yl:,y. ttw1t'fo.... j"st iJlSOfat as it is,
a dl'<:ision I\as alwa}'ll aln:ady '-n mad.. n.-gan::hng ill; oS!J.I.m>v. 4lilivarov
I.6-,ov 6V1a IlI\OCvIlo.; £h'a, u.-,ov (d. 263clllf.): '11 is imf'O'Sible that ~ Al>yo.;
could at all be whot it is if It w",," ~ of nothing.· The r<-ible wa)'"
lot I.6yoc, 10 be ro'6.; 0"" none 0llw.>T dum I.(ryo.; 0Al\9t" lind 1.6yo.; ".,oolk.
Supplements
Z. (to p. oW)
3. (to p. +I)
But, insread. the ""'-SC' abo,"........ 1«-5;\ de.r: di>lclosun.' b)' way of affir-
mation And d;,cl~~ by way of dmial are bo,h ""v(I(~
Or. tvlltXflOI lit 00; &n{p(ow f(i.v,u aovm (~A~. r. 6. ~3Ob3f.). ~Affir.
""'lion and denial are li~ise to be inrerpreted as a taking ap.ort." Takif\ll
aporl is indet'd the ........-. pf corrymg QUI /""""$1111>", w<Xiv, i.e. d ka>ping
the f'I'. m.. who.... ,n .......... And taking.tparl;~ a P"""O";ng mod... oflctt,ng
the ....·holl> be"....... ;.('q ~iting I"" OIW' with the otlK'r.
!:uv8l:",~ and &'oip£<n';<:onMitutelhe full rn<J<k> oflheearrying out 01 vorl";
and this lotte< i~lr. insofar as the VQ(iv is that of ,"" Uryov 'IO\', ~ be a
I<Utaoum.; and (u:*"':;'
Cf.' Mtf. E.~. I027b2H.
to liIlCl " to 1"'P\<; VQfh__ mode of J".'m.'i'ing. er><'<lUnlering.•"JIo and
1000l<;--i'fl mtf(~"" (b2~)"not diK~ely ....... aflt'r thcOlhcr"-lho:- !!land-
ing roe>,1 to ("<lor" othl'r of llw \'01\1101(1, But instead; tv t\ Y(l''(o6(u (bUlls
th <I<risi ..... reah,... of this "",,-iv,
6jl 'uiY-t6 ovy>;r!l'£w" / 1"",1:; VO£i-w &J1pI1l'tvov. UJ:"'P'~
tv vot'v. lv vor,,,, as ""Yllfol.; al'd "" &;a{poo,,, 100. For £'\'.,., 6jlo vOOv
un be llnderstood lI5lMalpl:<Jlc,. CIIM,iMil'rly. in terms ri Intentional df'o
l(:rmi""tion,
o.ln(i~ lbJ..I) this mod,' of Being of beings-IO be WIC<lOl~"~ or 10 be
distorted In l.6YQ<;-il; n'I~ ko.vulo..; n ~ lbJ..II.). "_ beinll .. fl«ted III
the di~minll'~ Inso.l... a$ tM discernmenl enro""tcn SQm('Ihi~ W.... I is
<meounrer«l is Itself disclo.sed. tU'lllt.. .and ~ w" t~ 6'll..oVotv
oioo... n'"(loliow ro\IOvw.;tl02&2). n.<.>y6<> nnI p",,'ide _ df'!....mi ... ticm
",I the B<>;nll 01 bm>p which pM~irullo IhMn u being! in lhe1nseh'e bul
only imol... as tt-.r,· .. rt mcount...ro.
til tU"et.. bv-.~ to. tTl $o.(tV<)(q. (el. ,,1tI. K, II, 10f>5,021/f.). 11'>0 ''''.
etml'lfl1n1NSS ofbeings Is !lOmeming llul affeelS the d~nll di5closul\',*
IJiKI-.J p~"".
"Iv $o.ow!q. dueo not m....n: A p""""'"' of ttlought-filCtuill tXCUm.-o><:<', but
131""'" In be discemed-to be enrounle"-"<l. For: d"",loo;in' !'la"ing-Ihere.
Ilrinll_ JiK~ p~,.,.orld of .. li,'lng Ihin~
7. (In supplo.'rrn:nt6)
1l«"U5(' Bring .. p~Cl'. nOl validi!)' and the lil:l1. lU bt> uJ'IOO'-ered ..
gtJ"uint presence.
Or beca~ "trulh- ill u~<tWm'd1tt'SS of btm,v, w..T\Bl'.; belongs to I'l"-"di.o-
IMia,· '1ogk" in O"llIlogy.
TIv 1_ IS. Nut Ldeool;"tkally lind not ",,,l;s!io:a.lly but Greel<Jy. Ik>ing lind
truth. Truth and S...."i........."..
And ,,,,,mo...
lNp,ltltgNv. "T",Ilh"-tor ptm'f'OOn-is lin oj}iJi, of brr"g$
(!~llhous" tv lltuvol¢
7.(1 br""-1Il.I.Ulh21
14. (10 slIpplemenl 8)
"- ..,..
OA'lElt(,(,...-t",,'h: j.ltTo Uryou (&(i\"(It{I)---Ih-.:u I..6roll.
(U.'1\ll!Ut:,,~in
principle v«'..........o:imh1al<;. Mnu ...
l.O'to~-rll<'r
,icl-l..6yo;-ma.
ltJ.'1et;-m·~.QJJj9t"tu-llv ~ 6v I j~'{)v_
l..OyQ.;,-a5 the Immedl.1tt' form of <U'16l:tA:I\'-abo"" all, to ronce~l. to hold
<meself pl'Operly ;n ignoran<:e. A. rno<k of carrying out and mode of un-
CO\·ering. olfu~f~1 significan«" The "101101": that ....hi/:h iUCC'eS6ible
in spe«h and in spolo:en disroul'!le, constituting the Being of ....hatlS d~
sible;n this Wd~' and present 35 such.
&af..tyta9a1: int"'Pl'l'talion~rm~utical, Justification in Aristotle "'.
enrdi", 10 t..'o directions. EJcampk-: lit) .h t- 'fIlUl'Jo.;) .os 6-.>npn.>a-
ckntl'd-.--Lt'.. spuming ttll' ...,\loll pr.ttl....
0......, anJ Bring
...
should ~: the ~ of ~nm.w,;. WhM is, ,,'I\ot II is no' supposed to
2L tlo p. 134)
4).1\&'0 and tm, proper ch.racl<'r of flci"ll and ,\S flnnS "'/!rinK' oiofla-
f':-lU"l ~II'£VO\I,
The uncm·"';ng of beings is soml"lhing proper if it disclO!llt'S them in their
constitution i>5 OllX!\-ttl,o,; (proper p~Oi!).
apX!\-tt'Mo;_ char.cters of flcing-the """ning of J<tpcu;: wh"""" and
whereby beings in what they • ...-s bri"gs--a~ finished. No "as !i1:>mC'-
Ihlns,· Thertfore the chari><1cr of intend<'d·"""".md of unco"erPd·.-:
O&O:{~'-&IO~""""
I &!.",...••"I'Ploommt-
Z.~byl~"' ... ~';;'9(~"'p.tm.
{~lIy' "C"!IS," prm~"", of the ~nre, OnIQ~'cal'JI: ~ lilm' oPXr\'~
~-(l00(1l, oot Kala.
NO! for""'L nOlg.."'us (thi~ bltl" rx/""llly n-jtdeJ), but instl'.m: p,,~ly JI"<l
simply ·1/I1';WgIw." "F<:>"""lly," h<:m't'\'el", with an empkMis on 0",,1«:
IlpI'Ittpov 1\ 0\i(rIn. in tt.... temporali!)' 01 the pure p~c" of tlell.g:;.. ,h-
whal i."""""" of-lnto~"tlli£vo-notp<J5Ilnl. But IIlStNd: ...·hat i< already
t!>l'te In the di"",mlng discloslJl'l? .,.. Uyr",. He!\' lhe irruption ot.l.Oyo.; into
ontology. cr. "itt. Z.~.
.:.v-as u"""" ..rod-in a b"",rl,·, sen"": that which 15 spoken of.
al To what ""t<'Ot the ·al.....dr al lhe <l<Jtse!" in lhe ~'O,. In the
b..".d..... ~. oV<nll-sheer p"""",<:P-that whkh is lhen' at the '''''Y
OUlS<:t_in imm«tia.l~ ~"I'f)'day concerns. Thi<. how'-"'...... is i.(rro.;!
b) Of whal..,., is the "Iogkal"? Ihal which is "I",ad,· encounlered in
what is ~poken of as such. ro<onsritutlns pre;enre,
{(lnOl'minga): for Il>o::c C~ks vou.;-~ In speaking aooul-thl'
wQf"ld.-,omr.'\hing--l>elngr-thetP---inlti.lUy and for lhe rn<>sl pari.
This ·inltially and lor th~ mnst pari" isand ",mains In principle (.ItUt
~! u,yo.:;: tM boji<" "",.I, .fIkmS·'" llSroming III ~t.lMl ""hieh
pritno.rily is en('<,unlen'(! a~ already th~~ "",,'''dlll'''O'·. SpelIking re-
mains the p,ima,)' mode of 'a:ess and mod~ of appropriation of
beings. The bask mode 01 disclo"h'" Bemg·.... lth--<n" hfl!-"'ith bcin~.
Even the {ow-u l.6yol>-is 5O<'I\eIlting-is still Sl'en in It'rms of~:
bUllIc/ wilh the ":as..
"all' llirr6. But: by and In Uryo.;-",. a mode of aAl\lI£Uf:lv-<>lthc
"1IOl(:£1~'O\'
(...J
ConCt-'rRing b): The "Iogic.>l" Is as such ont.,.log.cal' l'r""i""ly not, thinking
and "-odInlque of thinking. But inst.-ad: lhlIl which ... ~ibl" in
5fW'1king (uncovering) and discou",.,. The Being of the beingsenroun·
lerW and !f'Ok<'n of In th;s .... al'. whallhus pt)S6ibl)' col1'\e!; to pre;mce.
al~ady ronstiluhng Its p~.
il5<1f. ,n whidl o..sein .I,,'~),,; at""""r Os. ~ mrounlen'd purely from them,
seh'l'S_ nw letting ~ enrountell.'d is b35l.'d, in ilS possibilities.. on lhelleing
of Dase;n. BulIN" !king of Oasein Is lernpoulity. And the pu,," k-tling I""
w.....1d ~ mrounll'nld ill a mak.ing p"'5"lll M sud!. il il; only lernpor.>lly
thai ;1 can express i'iitlfin I~ approprial<.' speaking aboul I~ ",..,rId, I~
l:leing of the ,,·.....Id "' p_.... ce. The domi"""", of Ihis nI)ti(In of Being rNIke
II d""r why Arislol~ inlO'rJ'rns lim~ itoclf on l~ l>a..io of I~ ~I, lho:"
"""""," Whal ill PI'\'5el'lI "' gmuine l:leing.. ar>d lhe Bt-ing .ID ionS" of lhe
past, as w~11 as 8elng r\ClI y<:l Qn ~ de\.....runl'd on tM b.uill of il.. "
8ul if o.."""n ilSielf must ~ inl~rp...'tI'd onlClk>gicaUy in ilS Being.. l.~..
...."e1 in ilS do."l<.'nn;nale non.g"",ui~ temporality of pl'e'ffilifying /nm.
mllS"""'~,lhen """,ponJily in iill genuin...- mUSt ~""pliwoo.
IlYllh.1t impli...: the beings which emersc in rn.:-onlOlogical int"'l'lt'IUion
of the Being of the ""otId c,,"rot determine tho> h~lk situation of
th~ ontologi<:'al re;eardl whkh", supposoed h) inlerp~ the ~1"5 of o-in
i~tf. Ral"""', il is pn><:ioo-Iy on In~ basis 01 this lMttht ~ of Being and
the origin of the forml'1" is f'O'!'ith'c1y clarifit'd ontologically. I.e.. ill gi'~ In
thechataet1't of 1lei"5'" ronct"i"l'<! ;n!flms of p~.-n", imrrwdi.l'"
mearung of Ileing.
Ileing-whal is alwa)'$ p""""'l 011 lis 0""11. 'J'h,.,re/o", "18" ~Iy the
"""hat"-"essenao"-;ond il lhe genuir"l' obit'ct of proper knowlO'd~.
Ill. Supplements 10 the Main Part
3-I.(lop. 19I l
Den;mon........ror
1l\I_
in t.... interpn>tation of the dofinitioro 01 the sophist, ....., We'" <'flIUtantly
f\.f('!n'd to l.6yoo;.. il sh".. ld ha,~ boot.-ro de.., from the ~k>ng wh~1
I. TIlt qll<"$loor! <Jf IN AAdIUS$ ~nd s.ryobil,ly <Jf Il~ Qv t! 1"'" If 111I OT]1'(llvtl~
<Jf6Y (244aSI.). t Qv oVlltv rU.op6mpov tlKti" roil ,," .... vro.; (d. 2*'a I).
Saidllm' genul disdosure of the meanIng!
The <JPIX':Sition make .isibk> lhe ~ui...... ot¥<:tiv;t}' of the neg.>1<!d. The
neg.tion in the Illl 01 tn.. tttpov is n(l'I only one bound in lhe ~i,""
p"",·.,nanr,e but II lite "'..... '".......... IJwI ,s r*Ji«'£r.rIy ahih,r",.~: It ""hibits
.........u.ing determinate.
1. 110 p.299)
r.=;::=..~.=.~~~,::=::};~;I:'~~':::'az
~.saY"~Ortc.I.~""" $:"-".Ortc. ::~.Do<.l.~."""
6:.w~Doe.&
.ts..p.lll._t
.\ s.. .......,nI ..... lt<lure..p 1.on<l.- t ...........·.U .. I' 13:2,'- t ~'hI<h(•• """"""
6.) II p.1g€5\pp. 9O-IUOoi tMpllolocopyl",ith ''''ofurther~labell'<!
~j and ~i; (pp. 90 and 92 ,,11M phl'llOt"Pyl .os well as mosU~' unl~beloo
shet'tS, addenda, and many ~nnoulions w,lh notes: .. ) on Ih.. Iruth
(QJ.l\~lO.l 01 J.6'ro.; ,n
Aristolk (MTCIn:li"g k) t:k IntrrprrlQ'~, c","pter 4,
t:k A~I"'" II. chapter 8: and Mf'lIlphJl"l" VI, ckolpten 2 ~nd 4). whim we...
.. ~nded In the le<-tu'" COU~. ,'nnr 10 the "tM""il;"n,~ ,n ron"""t;"n
"'ilh Niflmt,J(hM! (1It~ X, eIYple. 7," 1>ut ....·hich .hI<l roindd" w,th I"""
Silges from th.. "IT<lnsiti,,,,; and bl on th" questio" of the plMe of InIlh
(QJ.l\~I(l,) :>oo>rding to Mf'lQ/Ih!f>"cs VI. chdpler 4. and "Vtaph~kf.IX.dlap-
Ier 10. as well as on a critique of the ~ of \'kmeo- ]:oeget, ..... hlCh "'as
nol ,am..d out in Ih.. krtures."
Th" 5l.'<'Ond fil.. of 1M manlrSCripl consists of 170 ""g~ Of'golniloo .os
followS'
I.) 25 pages. w,th sheets 10<>Sely numbered X> I-X> 16. as ",,,lias addenda
and al\OOtalions.for t.... mosl pill'Ilabeled, with notes on I.... P1ak) p.11'1. up
k) I.... fifth dl."finLlion of th"l<lph"t, ind..,;i,·,,;"
2.) 14 p.1g'" (pp. 26-29 of lhe pkotoropyJ ~Iong with she.>ts Ioost'ly
numbe...-d 0:-'1. and p.1,d..llj' 1al>«led add""da ar>d annotaliolU ronlaining
no4,,", on I.... PMnlrw: ",",cunus.""
3.) 94 pages (Pl" 42-IlS of the pholoropy) along with sho."E'lS ~Jy
num~ Si.I 16-Sn 69 and partiallj' labell.'d addenda wilh nole'l on I""
inlt'rpl\"t.tion of the Sopht!;/, "I' 10 U... t:nd of the kct,,~"
4.,35 pagt"l (pp. 136-J70 of the photoc,,!,y) .'ong with a few disparale
shl.~ Iab<::led "So; ronlaining notes on I.... inlerpn't.>lion dIlle s.,m,."
as well asan .1>unclal\(\' of "nlabo-Ied ad<knda and anno~~lions wilh notes
~ially on the Plato part b"t also on t .... Aristotle part and on the qlll'Stion
01 tho! lectures as a whole.
Ill. The foU""'ing not"" ralu'n do"'" b)' Slud~nts "'1\0 attel1dNl tht.-Iec·
ru~
l.l a tYJ""'·rilt~."
1"lf\K';pl o. It>o. no''''' lah'l1 by lid...... \'kill, which
enrire !C<'lurecoun;e. Th"tran5(ript was pnxtu<WI by T~ and
tr3<'l! lh~
amounts to 497 P.lgcs.
Z-j a typ('Wrillen tunscrip! (-147 p.>&") of t~ s«'nOgr~phic ~ ofSimoTl
~ •. l1>ese begin only afle< I~ Christmas ho1id~ys and Ihus l>"I>der I~
Ifoctu"", fl'Ql'l'l IIw "!",osition· on.. Le., the Pt"to p;!rt. Hcideggt>r hi,"",lf
r(">'iscd this lranscrip!; 11<> ernployfd il as a working baili. supplied i! wilh
marginal ~arks, and authoriled it
).\ thr nott'S of Hans Jonas {6 nott'bool<s), which trare lhe enti.., rour.i<'
and on only one ocr....;on, the lw.... tr~ghlh s<ssion (Janu.ary 21. 1m),
display a h.lndwriling th.3t is not his OWl\, and, finally, tN- note. of Fritz
S<Nlk (5 notebooks), whid>, with lhe "arepti"n of the beginning of tJ1<,
ninlh ~ion (No'..,mb<-r 17, 192-1). liknoll,.. ro,"". tho ....1'... OOU"'"". n-
two _ 04 noteli progressh,,,ly rome to 1J\.>1d> OI\<"another "",il they r"",Uy
rotT<'SpOnd word for word.
Hrid"SS~r'J IectUnlS', both in his "'riling ;md in hi. oral dcli\'ery, p","""l,
in large .........su .... a mixtul't' of Greek cilillion ~nd (;('rman oommenl~'Y.
tl<'idegger quorro the Gn."('k tc:<t of P1.1!<> ~(:c....r ding to thl" first o.rord
E'.dilionof Plato's \Vorks,edited br l. Burnet'" and th<>G"",k t<>~tof Aristotle
acron:hng to the edition p"blished by Teubner in L£>ip~ig ,,~Ih ,·".-ious
editors." Tho.' te,t I h.we prt5l'rltro hert' lik"""I.'Ie 6!('S Mato 3(.'(onling to
Ilumt1 ""d Ari,u,tk> a"OOfding to Heid"U"r's jU51·namro cop)' When
l-kidegg<'1' fl'l't'ly "aned lhe GIt'cl< original for philosophical or pedagogical
rt'asons, I I'<.'t.lin"d Ills "'ay of quotiJ1g and pnmeed the oorrespond;ng
~Ie~" ""tl! • "0." Rather long ""i....... within the on81",,1 C"",k le><t
Wer\" markOO with sU5pCnsion points ( ••• ). Orl aero"nt of lhe Jlffe"",ce
in the ci=mstanres 01 the .t",lents' ootCS for the IWO parts 01 tJuo ro.m;e.
1 look ",,,'r tl".' Cr\'Oek ",tations in the firsl part. where Heidegger's oral
qoot.atlons (anlV)! be "'CQI"I!itructed. either from Heidegger·. manuscript or,
most olten. frum the noles taken by Weill, in wl!ich tJuo Crock te><ts were
int...-po!alo.'<I, 00\'1oos1y lat",., in mo6Il)' romplet<> !lcr\tenct'S. For th" ~OO1d
part, I n'tained Heideggcr'. oral quotarions, as fixed in tI>e transcript of
/>·fQSt'r's notes. in ord..... to 1'1'.,;......... the lecture '1)'1•. For the firsl pan, it
was rool dear which citalions H<>idegg..... had t... ""lated in ltiso 1deli,...!)',
and 50 1 included either !h. translation occa'lioNllty found in 'idcggt>,·s
manuscript or. In thoe case of diflicult Greek pa~ges. when there was
nelth.,.,. a lf3n51ation no, an "'terp"""th" paraphras<" in thoe manuscripl or
the trMl!ICriplS, my own transl.tion, employing Heidcggerian le,.,,,s, as l"ng
as it did not d;sturb the flo'" of the It',,. In the S«'OlId !",n. soch translations
rould bedlspensed with,slncealmost all of Heidegger'stranslations, para-
plu<>ses, and paraphrdSing interpretations arc pn.'SCI'It u\ M(>;<'r', Slt.'I'IO-
graphic notes and roukl be t,'ken from them. For I-kldcgger's translationi
the boundary bo.'tl'·«nliteraJ translahon and parapl!ra~ingcomrne1lLlry is
oiten fluid, I put In quotation markl; only lile'raJ mns"tio"" as well as
.,., ... pl!f35e5 Ih.ll Wft\., ....ady lranslations.
The 1ilcra~' ..yle of lho! tC:<t I am presenting mWI uRa.-oidably ,'al}'
bctw""", lhe first pari .... d the second, ~ince It ,,'as only MOIi<'I"" slc:n<>-
g...phic notes of the Ialler which permitted an apptOJrlrnate reproduction
of the Idilll;yno:ra!ic f<mnolations of Beidegget's oral deli\'~"Y'
I supplil'd the rontinu<>us texl of the INlu ....... for which no table 01
. ""......T"""".. . . _k"""''''''''_.£_.. . . . .
8 C.T-..rt.1911,
Wall;.. ~in...Jil>u>B.C.T...tmen.l"ll
S<fo<h<.,w.t.,~la>im ...."...
Appendl.
l) AJ'l""f"l<" "'W"","",,&--;'ll.
z,;,5o<!r lll.1IOOt1
17 r'-9!'>.r·'1MI'·
;)! ;..·tt..._uflh<.... tic>II.l...... oI ..... ""._·ontt....I'J'C""I,•. """"_v
~
3O.1.<ltit- IN
c...."'.._ r,. . . . *'"
Af'l't"d.... ~l>2S.V,23,Jl(.,..j~
1ld ~l,odi"'"
W_.
I>y Wol... _
MMbutgft " " " " " - w ~ 1<r'S-26.
h>nkfun._\t.. 1<m.. Eop<ri.oIIy pp. 16...... 1;~
Jl. A.,....... ~ny "'rrlo-mtnl>'" IN- ."......- .• - . ~ _ ~.
pari, which I kad al"'ady p"'f'<'n.'d. and lhey proved a ,'alual>l~ hdp for
my work on tIKo l'liolo P.~rI.
My N"'dwrilWfl "t'\'Slon of Ihe '''''1 of lhe Jt..ctu", (OUQe was typed by
the /l!i$I>t/mls d,p/6II<h wor1<.ing under"'" in !he philooophy <kp;Irlmcnl 01
lho- Unker.;ily QF .....USilnne. namdy Alel<and'" Schild. Mi",ille Ros.!ek>!.
up!. and Andtf )eanmrmod. WIth them. in a rornmon l'\'\Mling. my hand·
"'riting "'itS ~l«-d against lhei, lranscrlplinn. M",. Ro:>ssel....-Capt
lie. k Irlll'('S in C"""k. undenool< ('!;pe<:iolly the "erific>tion of tIK' C"",k
ciLlri'lI>S. V"~en Oeu .. ray. aw'~alll "ipsa",! in lhe philo&ophy dep.>rtment .
.... pplied the Gn",k lellts with atteniS. since the rompuU,. pointer (Quid nol
rorrectly ",pn:.oduee them. Guido All>ertelli. althal ti"'" working under me
as ar> lmislJltll JipllJml. prepan.'d lhe prinled man-npl and romple1~ the
bibliographic.ol data. FiMlly. Dr. TI<'tjen at'ld ~l.\rk Michalskl (I'h.O. candi·
da~. Uni\'<:1Sity of Fteiburgl .......·"'wed lhe printed manuocript wilh g....1
ca.....'enrol'<! lhe G"""k cital;on, in HPidogge,'scopyof the rexls, and added
the fmal bibliographical details In lK'COrd "'Ith lhe edllion!; a,'allable in
F,,·itnl'l;. They .11 desen-e my sino>e... lhanks for lheir efforts on the printed
manuscript. Ilhanl< Dr. Chrisloph Fmr. "on Wolzagen (Offfonbachl fur lhe
ronfil1't\alior> of the solulion of a q..eslion.able .bb""';"lion. and for sup-
plemenl>ry' bibliographical details. ~rdinll the .,,, ,.,."""iQ'" hul
1':alorp."
My .pecialth.U\ks an: duo.' to Or. TIl'¥n for lhe typewrilb:n tra..,;cript of
the not"" of Helene Wei8 as _lias for deciphering Heklegger's hat'ld""II.
len '''i"iMl m.>l\uscript. and. funher. 10 Prof. Friedrich·Wilht:lm ,'On
Herrmann fo' his friendly cou"""l. on<l.laslly. lO Dr. Henna,m H~,
8
for hI! pallen...... 0'...... my long-protracted editing of the ·Sophist.
IngWorg Schuille.
I.. USol""", Swll>:crland. August 19\1O