Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—A complete model of a power-line communication technologies is involved in the realization of smart-grid infra-
(PLC) system on a medium-voltage (MV) network in the case structures: wire lines and fiber-optic cables, wireless commu-
of a line-shield configuration is presented in this paper. An MV nication (CDMA, GSM, GPRS, UMTS, WiMAX, HiperLAN,
cable model in a line-shield configuration is considered together
with the power transformers, the signal coupling networks, and etc.), radio communication, and wireless local-area networks
the receiving and transmitting line coupling interface of a ST7540 (WLAN, WiFi, ZigBee, etc.) and power-line communications
FSK power-line transceiver. Simulations of the complete model of [1], [2]. Each of these technologies has advantages and dis-
the system under consideration have been carried out for different advantages. The cable and the fiber-optic networks need a
line lengths, with and without power transformers and derivation dedicated network to be installed, but they are the most reliable
branches. The model is validated by experimental tests performed
in the laboratory. The measured results confirm the reliability of and fast solutions. The wireless and radio communications have
the model. the intrinsic costs of the communication plants and the service
costs of the communication provider. For example, Global
Index Terms—Communication system, medium-voltage (MV) System for Mobile Communications (GSM)/general-packet
cable, power-line communication, power system communication.
radio service (GPRS) technology is widely used in Italy by
electrical utilities in the case of MV networks, but it presents
some drawbacks due to the low reliability in the case of bad
I. INTRODUCTION
weather conditions and service costs. Power-line communi-
cations (PLC) is the only wire-line technology that has cost
comparable to wireless, since the lines are already present
Alternate Transients Program–Electromagnetic Transients Pro- obtained in the simulation of different cases for variable line
gram (ATP-EMTP). Both overhead line and underground cable length, with and without power transformers and derivation
were simulated and the presence of power transformers was branches. Finally, experimental results, carried out on a labora-
considered. However, the simulations did not include the cou- tory test bench, are presented.
pling system and the transceiver models, and no experimental
data were reported to validate the model performances. Another II. PLC SYSTEM MODEL
model was proposed in [11], where a multiconductor matrix
procedure was used to predict the medium frequency behavior The MV system under study is composed of three unipolar ca-
of the MV network. The model is very accurate but also quite bles, type RG7H1R with an aluminum core of 185 mm cross-
complex to be implemented. The accuracy of the method perfor- sections and copper shield. The transmission system is based
mance was demonstrated through systematic measurements on on line-shield configuration, in which the signal is injected be-
real networks. The authors found that the cable lines introduce tween the core of one cable and the shield connected to earth.
an attenuation of 1.5–4 dB/km. Moreover, they found an atten- Two power transformers have been considered. The signal is in-
uation of at least 20 dB for a complete transmission network, jected and received by two commercial coupling networks (CN),
where a coupling system was connected to the MV busbar of an each connected to the receiving and transmitting line coupling
HV/MV substation and another to an MV/LV substation. In re- interface of a ST7540 FSK power-line transceiver (TX/RX). A
gards to the power transformers, they stated that the transformer schematic representation of the PLC system is shown in Fig. 1.
impedance, seen from the MV terminals, was so high that the The complete model of the MV power-line communication
signal remains confined to the MV network. In [12], Xiaoxian system is carried out in the Simulink environment. The model of
et al. analyzed the 10-kV MV power-line channels using the each element of the system is described in detail in the following
transmission-line theory. They measured a path loss of 20 to 25 sections.
dB/km when the signal was transmitted in phase to ground con-
figuration. Moreover, the authors found that the electrical equip- A. Cable Model
ment between the transmitter and receiver, such as the branches The distributed parameters mathematical cable model is ex-
and the distribution transformers, affected the path loss the most. pressed by the time-dependent telegrapher’s equations, which
However, a simple model of the power transformers was used are the following [17]:
and no information were given about the coupling network. In
previous works, the authors proposed a model to simulate the (1)
signal transmission through MV cables in the line-shield and
line-line configurations [14]–[16]. (2)
In this paper, a complete model of an MV cable power system
for PLC communications is presented in the case of line-shield where and are the voltage and the current at the instant ,
configuration. The model takes the cables into account, the the variable indicates the longitudinal direction of the line,
coupling systems for the signal injection, the power-line trans- and , and are the per-unit length resistance ( /m),
ceivers, a ST7540 FSK being simulated, as well as the MV/LV conductance (S/m), inductance (H/m), and capacitance (F/m),
transformers. The advantage of the proposed model is that it respectively.
can be easily implemented in the Simulink environment, en- The voltage and current wave solutions of the telegrapher’s
abling one to perform the planning of an MV PLC transmission equations, for a lossless line , have the following
system. Finally, the model is validated by some experimental form:
tests performed in the laboratory.
In this paper, first, a description of the system under study (3)
and its model is reported. Second, the attenuation between the
received and transmitted voltage signals is reported, which was (4)
CATALIOTTI et al.: SIMULATION AND LABORATORY EXPERIMENTAL TESTS OF A POWER–LINE COMMUNICATION SYSTEM 2831
Fig. 2. Generic lossless line of origin m; end k, and length l. Fig. 3. Equivalent impedance network of a lossless line with the distributed
parameter according to Bergeron’s method.
(5) From (11) and (12), the equivalent circuit of the line, shown
in Fig. 3, can be obtained.
(6) So far, the line has been considered lossless. To take into ac-
count the losses in the line, the distributed series resistance
The Bergeron method is used to solve the telegrapher’s equa- is added in lump form. On the other end, the conductance is
tions in the time domain [18], [19]. This method, applied to neglected. The total resistance of the line can be calculated as
homogeneous lines, considers a unique observer moving at ve-
locity along the line. In this case, and are (15)
constant; therefore, the voltage and the current can be calculated
from the following expressions: In the present model, the total resistance is divided in three
lumped resistances: one is equal to inserted in the middle
(7) of the line model and two is equal to inserted at each end
(8) of the line model, (see Fig. 4).
In conclusion, the parameters needed for the model are the
where the values of the constants and can be determined per-unit length resistance inductance , and capacitance
by using known values of the voltage and current in a specific . Furthermore, the signal frequency range has to be known.
section of the line and at a specific time. For a generic lossless According to this, the mentioned parameters dependence from
line of origin end , and length as shown in Fig. 2, the the frequency was studied by experimental measurements in
wave propagation time from the origin to the end of the line can [14]. In regards to the per-unit length resistance the mea-
be calculated as . sured values in dependence of the frequency were fitted by the
According to Bergeron’s method, the expression following second-order polynomial function
seen by an observer leaving the origin at time and
moving at velocity remains constant when he arrives at the (16)
end at time . The same consideration can be applied to the On the other hand, in the frequency range of interest, the per-
expression seen by an observer who travels in the
unit length parameters and were found constant with the
backward direction. From the aforementioned remarks, the fol-
frequency [14].
lowing equations can be deduced:
In Table I, the coefficients and are re-
ported, which were measured in the case of a unipolar MV
(9)
shielded cable type RG7H1R of 185 mm cross section with
(10) aluminum core and copper shield.
that rearranged become B. Coupling Networks
The signal is injected and received in the MV cables through
(11)
two low-cost capacitive coupling devices (CN). The frequency
characterization of these devices has been carried out by a vector
(12) network analyzer (VNA). The coupling device has a passband
2832 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 26, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2011
Fig. 4. Equivalent two-port network for the line with lumped losses.
TABLE I
RL AND C COEFFICIENTS FOR 185 mm ALUMINUM CABLE
Fig. 7. Simulation results versus line length. The figure shows how the presence
of two power transformers—one in the transmission section and another in the
reception section—has a weak influence on the signal attenuation.
Fig. 9. Schematic representation of the MV power system in the case of two derivation branches.
All of these parameters were determined by the impedance in order to eliminate undesired interferences with external sig-
measurements at the terminals of the transformer in the fre- nals. The test bench is realized with a low-cost capacitive cou-
quency domain [21]. pling device and a power transformer connected to each end of
a 15-m-long MV unipolar cable-type RG7H1R, of a 185 mm
III. SIMULATION AND LABORATORY EXPERIMENTAL TESTS cross-section with aluminum core and copper shield.
The distributed parameter model of the cable in the core- Two ST7540 FSK power-line transceivers are directly con-
shield configuration was verified in [14]. To verify the complete nected to each coupling device. The ST7540 transceiver uses
MV power system model for PLC communications, the attenu- two frequency-shift keying (2FSK) modulation to perform
ation, defined as half-duplex communication on a power-line network [20].
Transmission and reception sessions as well as control register
attenuation (17) parameters, for example, carrier frequency, baud rate, and
deviation can be set by means of the EVALCOMMBOARD,
is evaluated for different line lengths. A power transformer of which is a general-purpose board which provides a reliable and
160 kVA with a resistive secondary load of 100 kW is connected flexible communication channel between a controlling PC and
at the cable ends in the transmission and in the reception sec- the EVALST7540-2 [23]. The coupling interface is designed
tion. In order to evaluate the transformer influence, the simula- to allow the ST7540 FSK transceiver to transmit and receive
tion results obtained with and without the power transformers on the low-voltage mains, by using a carrier frequency within
are shown in Fig. 7. The attenuation versus line length is evalu- the European CENELEC standard A-band [3]. A multimeter
ated for typical MV cable lengths between 0.75 and 4 km at the Agilent 34401A and a digital oscilloscope Tektronix TDS725B
frequency of 86 kHz. Attenuation values between 15 and 25 dB are used to measure the transmitted and received signal level.
have been found in both cases. The attenuation has a minimum The fast Fourier transform (FFT) of the acquired signal is also
value when the line length is equal to even multiples of the signal calculated with the digital oscilloscope. The tests are performed
quarter wavelength, and a maximum value when the line length by transmitting a signal correspondent to a sequence of bit 1 or
is equal to odd multiples of the signal quarter wavelength [10]. a sequence of bit 0. The ST7540 transceiver control registers
From Fig. 7, it can also be concluded that power transformers are set up to have a center frequency of 86 kHz,
have a weak influence on the signal attenuation. Similar results 2400 b/s and Deviation 1. The control register setting is
have been obtained by changing the type and rated value of the shown in Fig. 11. For the selected values, the FSK signal
LV loads. frequencies corresponding to bit 0 and 1 are, respectively, 87.2
The influence of derivation branches is also evaluated. A and 84.8 kHz. The transmitted and received acquired signals
three-phase branch is connected in the transmission section. and their FFT, in the case when a sequence of bit 1 has been
The branch has the same length of the main line, which connects transmitted, are shown, respectively, in Figs. 12 and 13. The
the transmission and reception sections. A power transformer measured amplitude and frequency of the transmitted signal are,
of 160 kVA, with a secondary load of 100 kW, is connected at respectively, 1.67 V and 84.66 kHz. The values measured at the
the branch end. The simulation results show a reduction of the receiving section are 130 mV and 84.68 kHz. The transmitted
received signal to about half of the value obtained without the signal is sinusoidal, while some disturbances are found in the
branch. A second branch is connected to the reception section received signal. Similar measurement results are obtained in the
(see Fig. 8). In this case, the received signal is one-third of the case when a sequence of bit 0 is transmitted. The attenuation
value measured without branches. In Fig. 9, the attenuation between the transmitted and received voltages is about 22 dB
versus line length is shown for the three cases. in both cases (see Table II). This value is compatible with
The proposed model has been experimentally verified in a the range obtained in simulation and shown in Fig. 7. The
laboratory test bench, shown in Fig. 10. The experiments are received signal amplitude in both cases is sufficiently high to be
carried out in an electromagnetically shielded anechoic chamber correctly received by the ST7540 transceiver, which is able to
2834 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 26, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2011
Fig. 10. (a) Schematic representation and (b) photo of the realized test bench.
TABLE III
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS OBTAINED IN THE LABORATORY
TESTS WITH A DERIVATION BRANCH
TABLE IV
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS OBTAINED IN THE LABORATORY
TESTS WITH TWO DERIVATION BRANCHES
Fig. 13. Acquired waveform and its FFT of the voltage V measured at the
input terminals of the receiving modem, in the case when a sequence of bit 1
was transmitted.
networks, and the receiving and transmitting line coupling inter-
face of a ST7540 FSK power-line transceiver. The parameters
TABLE II of the MV power system components were derived by measure-
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS OBTAINED IN THE LABORATORY
TESTS WITHOUT THE DERIVATION BRANCH ments in the frequency domain.
The performances of the complete PLC communication
system have been evaluated for different line lengths, with
and without power transformers and derivation branches. The
simulation results show that the cable length and the power
transformers give a little contribution to the signal attenuation.
On the other hand, a derivation branch causes a reduction to
half of the measured value. The model has been validated
by some experimental tests performed in the laboratory. The
measured results confirm the reliability of the model.
The proposed model takes all of the electrical components
into account, which can influence the signal transmission, and
it can be easily implemented in the Simulink environment, thus
allowing one to study and design new solutions for power-line
communication in MV networks.
The signal attenuation introduced by the power transformer,
although small, suggests a further investigation on the possi-
bility to transmit the signal across the transformer from the MV
to the LV network, and vice-versa.
REFERENCES
[1] A. Ipakchi and F. Albuyeh, “Grid of the future,” IEEE Power Energy
Mag., vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 52–62, Mar./Apr. 2009.
[2] P. P. Parikh, M. G. Kanabar, and T. S. Sidhu, “Opportunities and chal-
lenges of wireless communication technologies for smart grid applica-
Fig. 14. FFT of the voltage V measured at the input terminals of the re- tions,” in Proc. IEEE Power Energy Soc. Gen. Meeting, Minneapolis,
ceiving modem, in the case when a sequence of 24 bit 0 and 24 bit 1 were repet- MN, Jul. 25–29, 2010, pp. 1–7.
itively transmitted. Both tones of the FSK-modulated signal are visible in the [3] “Signalling on low-voltage electrical installations in the frequency
figure. range 3 to 148.5 kHz—Part 1: General requirements, frequency
bands and electromagnetic disturbances,” EN 50065-1:1991, Amend-
ment A1:1992 to EN 50065-1:1991; Amendment A2:1995 to EN
50065-1:1991; Amendment A3:1996 to EN 50065-1:1991.
at the line ends, a reduction to one-third of the value measured [4] E. Biglieri, S. Galli, Y.-W. Lee, H. Poor, and H. Vinck, “Power line
communications,” IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun., vol. 24, no. 7, pp.
without the branches is found (see Table IV and Fig. 9). 1261–1266, Jul. 2006.
[5] P. A. A. F. Wouters, P. C. J. M. van der Wielen, J. Veen, P. Wage-
naars, and E. F. Steennis, “Effect of cable load impedance on coupling
IV. CONCLUSION schemes for MV power line communication,” IEEE Trans. Power Del.,
vol. 20, no. 2, pt. 1, pp. 638–645, Apr. 2005.
An MV cable model in a line-shield configuration is consid- [6] Control Network Powerline (PL) Channel Specification, ANSI/CEA
ered together with the power transformers, the signal coupling 709.2-A-2000 (R2006).
2836 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 26, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2011
[7] M. Zimmermann and K. Dostert, “A multipath model for the power- [23] “UM0239 User Manual,” STMicroelectronics, Jul. 2006, ST7540
line channel,” IEEE Trans. Commun., vol. 50, no. 4, pp. 553–559, Apr. power line modem demokit graphical user interface (GUI).
2002.
[8] J. Anatory, N. Theethayi, R. Thottappillil, M. M. Kissaka, and N. H.
Mvungi, “The influence of load impedance, line length, and branches
on underground cable power-line communications (PLC) systems,” Antonio Cataliotti (M’01) received the M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in electrical
IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 180–187, Jan. 2008. engineering from the University of Palermo, Palermo, Italy, in 1992 and 1998,
[9] J. Anatory, N. Theethayi, M. M. Kissaka, N. H. Mvungi, and R. Thot- respectively.
tappillil, “The effects of load impedance, line length, and branches in In 2000, he was appointed Assistant Professor and since 2005, he has been As-
the BPLC—Transmission-lines analysis for medium-voltage channel,” sociate Professor in electrical and electronic measurements at the Dipartimento
IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 2156–2162, Oct. 2007. di Ingegneria Elettrica,. Elettronica e delle Telecomunicazioni, the University of
[10] T. A. Papadopoulos, B. D. Batalas, A. Radis, and G. K. Papagiannis, Palermo. His research interests include digital signal processing, power-quality
“Medium voltage network PLC modeling and signal propagation anal- measurements, as well as the detection of sources of disturbances in power sys-
ysis,” in Proc. ISPLC, Pisa, Italy, Mar. 26–28, 2007, pp. 284–289. tems and power-line communications.
[11] R. Benato and R. Caldon, “Distribution line carrier: Analysis procedure
and applications to DG,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 22, no. 1, pp.
575–583, Jan. 2007.
[12] Y. Xiaoxian, Z. Tao, Z. Baohui, N. H. Xu, L. Changxin, and T. Lixi, Valentina Cosentino received the M.Sc. and the Ph.D. degrees in electrical en-
“Investigation of transmission properties on 10-kV medium-voltage gineering from the University of Palermo, Palermo, Italy, in 2001 and 2005,
power lines—Part II: Path loss,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 23, no. respectively.
4, pp. 1886–1895, Oct. 2008. Since 2005, she has been with the Dipartimento di Ingegneria Elettrica, Elet-
[13] T. Tran-Anh, P. Auriol, and T. Tran-Quoc, “Distribution network tronica e delle Telecomunicazioni (DIEET), Università di Palermo, working on
modeling for power line communication applications,” in Proc. IEEE a research project concerning the development and characterization of instru-
ISPLC, Vancouver, BC, Canada, Apr. 6–8, 2005, pp. 361–365. mentation for power-quality measurements and for the detection of sources of
[14] A. Cataliotti, A. Daidone, and G. Tinè, “A medium voltage cable model disturbances in power systems.
for power line communication,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 24, no.
1, pp. 129–35, Jan. 2009.
[15] A. Cataliotti, A. Daidone, and G. Tinè, “Power line communications in
medium voltage system: Characterization of MV cables,” IEEE Trans.
Power Del., vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 1896–1902, Oct. 2008. Dario Di Cara received the M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering
[16] A. Cataliotti and G. Tinè, “On the model of MV power line communi- from the University of Palermo, Palermo, Italy, in 2005 and 2009, respectively.
cation system in the case of line to line transmission,” presented at the From 2009 to 2010, he was a Postdoctoral Researcher at the National Re-
19th IMEKO World Congr. Fundam. Appl. Metrol., Lisbon, Portugal, search Council—Institute of Intelligent System for Automation (CNR-ISSIA),
Sep. 6–11, 2009. Palermo. Currently, he is a Postdoctoral Student in the Dipartimento di Ingeg-
[17] S. Ramo, J. Whinnery, and T. Van Duzer, Field and Waves in Commu- neria Elettrica, Elettronica e delle Telecomunicazioni (DIEET), Università di
nication Electronics. New York: Wiley, 1982. Palermo. His research interests are power-quality measurements, characteriza-
[18] F. Tesche, M. Ianoz, and T. Karlsson, EMC Analysis Methods and tion of current transducers in nonsinusoidal conditions, harmonic power mea-
Computational Models. New York: Wiley, 1997. surements, and power-line communications.
[19] N. R. Watson and J. Arrilaga, The Institution of Electrical Engineers,
London, United Kingdom, “Transmission lines and cables,” Power
Syst. Electromagn. Transients Sim., pp. 124–126, 2003.
[20] STMicroelectronics AN2451, Appl. note ST7540 FSK powerline Giovanni Tinè (M’04) was born in Palermo, Italy, in 1961. He received the
transceiver. Ph.D. degree in electronics, computer science, and telecommunications engi-
[21] T. Tran-Anh, P. Auriol, and T. Tran-Quoc, “High frequency power neering from the University of Palermo, Palermo, in 1994.
transformer modeling for power line communication applications,” in Currently, he is a Researcher with the National Research Council—Institute
Proc. IEEE PSCE, Oct. 29–Nov. 1, 2006, pp. 1069–1074. of Intelligent System for Automation (CNR-ISSIA), Palermo. His research in-
[22] A. Cataliotti, D. Di Cara, and G. Tinè, “Model of line to shield power terests are electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) of power electrical drive sys-
line communication system on a medium voltage network,” in Proc. tems, EMC of dual voltage electric devices, and power-line communication in
IEEE I MTC, Austin, TX, May 4–6, 2010, pp. 1459–1462. MV systems.