WAVE EET AoW 59(2009.6) MES] SHO GS MES HS Asst Bae|eo] UFS so est ole ‘A Study on the Durabilities of High Volume Coal Ash Concrete by the Kinds of Coal Ash a Ae Choi Se~sin 2B the Kim Moo-Han Abstract, Coal ash is a by-product of the combustion of pulverized coal, and much of this is dumped in landfills, The disposal of coal ash is one of the major issues for environmental problems, In this paper, the effects of the kinds and replacement ratio of coal ash on the durabilities of concrete mixtures are investigated, Fine aggregate was replaced with coal ash (fly ash and bottom ash) in five different ratios, of 0%, 10%, 20%, 35%, and 50% by volume, Test results indicated that the compressive strength increased with the increase in fly ash percentage, The Joss of compressive strength of bottom ash concrete mixes after immersion in sulphuric acid solution was less than in the control mix (BAQ), In addition, the carbonation depth of fly ash concrete mixes was lower than the control mix (FAQ), ays: Agi], BeboloHAl, wieloHAl, ZEA, RAS, Sat Keywords : Coal ash, Fly ash, Bottom ash, Fine aggrepate, Compressive strength, Carbonation LAS Aeohs ABSA MESS LIBRA MPR Ws} fly ash, cinder ash, bottom ash OH HEI, 2 A829) S7bl wep IBS Yast Aisle) aby Fas] S7ista| DoLOWolts Yel oF GOOLE ols 2 28 PSL SIO, o1 S Seopa] Be AAMT BARES SAHRO} AWE Hele Foe BERS] ORES 7D OM, SHITE) APOE 7] HERO] a A] Aw Qo} BzaHss| elelol S1z goo} ols ASEH] seh aaah epela gous! © Betolobsol vial abt at alg AAG. wloitk AVA sah, Baz g BaRs Bwaiol Te Yael Baal BRO wef Akt MCE AIOHAD RW EER] AMBBLBO| 4 ABTS LOU, CHRAS AP MES SE ALA 22 Fae ofehgo] ool, Hewalal aoe AHI a -B-9 aei7P Al Gel Sarees abel Ae Hee wade] sobelt atch AASHIS] 2% HVFACKHiEh Volume Fly Ash Conerete) 2h OSE a8 AAA] * @ Eades AeaTe, Se, Gale se gudna ahaa Goins, van, ga 13 Aes Baelso] esl get ast Sts] ool en, sesh cabal cpiale Aah Be vichse yl Pew Ao we} Mash OES Melee] Bare} Eo] BS MAMAS SA 1 Boo] acho B+ get, a WOE UPOMIES S215 Wale ALB SH: THEO] APaS] of MERICHAIS] BAEAS] ABO] Hsp SIGUA WL AMAA] Ulvlsto} Ala} Aaleetel AKgshe Be wl ee Agel, 2 She TH SAB) AeiBIo 48. Heel Belo] FAIS} HRN] AighRol UKE Leve}e=2} Zlojwst, Syst, SHY Bl uitield & USS vat - AeROR A PANEA! ASO] SG SHS Feb Aes AalehaAy eet, 2. Ada 2 we 21 ee ne 2 SHO] ABA BL VIS Lofal Was wis} Zo] et ole) SHO ce AS cE ANA Baelee) UES ul BES] Hel] AelSo] SHS elololA| Label A193] BOR AAD, Z AGS] Gas AHA Blo}PRUAAITE LG AVE 52(2009.6) ‘Hotel 0, 10, 20, 35 3) 50% 7PAl THRE CAIs Ow At EA NME W Melsio shetze Boisich. Et Zt Ho] Srp MEH] gl eRe = $29} 60 B 180kg/mt Oe TAEHaKCh, iis 020 | 05 [105] vp0 | 05 | Foo] Lat ANE 627/ 205/59] 25] 21] - | 15 El dda 2 4 ‘S2}0l0HAl 12 | 661} 233/08] - | 42 | 24 ; wwani [v9 [ass [era [ool - [57 |aos 7 #] 1} Loss on ignition ~ BABE (Wen = apna 00 (amt, ae 7,25, ‘SHS AFH) (ey SEE Bom) (a) Beto}o4A] (b) SHORT #1 FA: Fly Ash, BA: Bottom Ash TS 1. AEs SEM BS 23 dese eae Atetole) Sool WH Sacto] PRIS aE] ssl SNe AH ARES HE Doh] Ste wht Zo} 4] EB APA Zeleis}o] BP KS PF 242A(contact gauge YY) SARIS, TAS WE 2.56, ZUR LOE oy ota} are, aaisteh. BMSzIOHS 100%100%400mm HeaHE YE 265, AOR 20mm] HOLE aol gulahS wale} ohn EAS Maat aaeatate Veit FEMI — oyaj gale &, 25 20420, AGE 6058, CORE Sum, US 1,979] vi AbGSIgIo0, Bet] ‘WE 2.13, Bas 3,6100i/g2) ABS AMBSHSICh, HE 3 2a 12 Alene, Belobo] ep eoh Ao] sis} gap Wao] SEM BS YEE Aloe eboloso] 29. 739] ofnele UBS He wel HOE ee] wg 2 Bebo] EAMES at + alot Bitelato} 12 NEMR| Bay By | 18 Bae Att BE: 3. 16a/c? BOE | 3285/0 APIA, GHAI Sr YE : 2650/0? - i@ (EM): 650 = BE: 2.0g/ot sem | B52 oel [AIRY sim. IE 1 BBglak uso Zen | zasuen (USE _ 510,269] Bassa ATION, 4ZE aud #KSF 259691 Sialo] ZJslzols Sgeisict, srdayo] Ay. 5% FSO BFS AMBS}O} G100%200mm SAE BANS Matelol WA SSIS DAF, WSO. +80H| AAA #1, 4, SFOS] SALE ISS, elah SSS Sasa. Gas a 5% NaCl 88S Ab Bal} 0100200mm SAE FAVE 28 HSA 417] B, NaCl $8040 472} Ballz) % BAP SHES Bel BARS(ARNO,) ASRS BP SIO} BNLSTS Bote} a ang ofgste} Sgetsict, BAIES] upypee B3F 1008 | Zal4) eld Ags} of ALE, aaa, 4 False] depas Ci $, Eo} ALMA, TASTES Felelol of Nz lS Nehs #8 SAWS AbBs sc}, aaa 3. Aaa BDF sat NGS] Sol HE 4g UwaIS Ue Zeleh, SHE “Heth Belo} 4aaa Mx es] ofecues | Be eB ce (4 anes nts 7 28 770 [35,1 288 278 6.97 [403] 38.4)26.3 6.58 [47 4|a4,2| 43.4) 44.9 100 098.0)6 0 65% [57.8/55.8|53.9| 5.600.098 0[97.0 6.28 [66,2| 63.1 6.2| 61.1 [00.098.5 7.4 7.18 [35.1]208|23., 16.0 00.08.2974) 3.75 {33.2128 5 | 26.6) 26.0 100.0,98,1] 97.4, 30,3] 28.0/25.8| 227 100,018.1'66.8 23.5) 27.8 24.6 [00,0198.197.3 347 73,91 29.4 5 56 na 7 2 6.5 f00.q08.21974] 9 35.5 [00.0 9e 11974 FAO) Fao F820 Fe Faso BAO Batol “Baz | 7.25 12635 | 7.60, 125.8) 28 Drying shrinkage (104) Age (weeks) . (a) Fly ash concrete “ease Drying shrinkage (104) ‘age (weeks) . (0) Bottom Ab} 2, Meta] SHol GE SARIS] oles 3.1 Boles BY WS FEA Ae 16th] vet Aes] SSE BL peal Is 2} OVS 3k 4 9b “Te 2 UEHRIEE ted ab AEE 5 3 OPHBol ne SAMI) opal YEN oe, Ie) Of] St Sh Hie} Go] AIS] Sr SE GBol heh cee ap Off Holst glom|, Atglalse algls}z] eke Bele eIES 19 8) 16S] ZolksoRs 7.13% 10", Sele] HRI OPIS BSE SaahisO) Zopetale= Zz} 6,28-G 97x10! 8 _ Neel SF ME eS 8 6.75-7.60%10 9] HBO Yet, AS] BF a, See ago] & shes, ole Set ae ae ons & l0ws AHR 4 Sale| veh eaten Zotesy Uy Ae BSeIES| UPS Be OF ye ope ae et 2 239. Belopil Belay} ches Al] UES Bake Mola IAS aed apo are Bebo] Wart BAIS] SS SAee alah S #0] PHAR ch Sols ANG gt alow AReICh, ube UNS ANSE BaeIES] Belts, AES] al alg EIS] GIARROIA) BelololA) A yEBen, MF ES A] SpA HE Lae G'S Modal gst Me, Compressive strength( MPa) Compressive strensth (Mpa) Compressive trength (MPs) oo | Flvash ehhh eaten percentage 14 3. Hela] Sew] WE SAA PAYS (28B) Elapsed time (days) @ Fy ash merce 0 See er = ao | = 5 -arenzo ~sHeass essa | ee Elapsed time (days) (©) Bottom ash cone 1H 4, HSO, 24 STING] WIE BazSO wi)__waagIEea BE AVE! 39(2000.6) 3.2 eA HE A Se HS, BHM BARS BAAS We AG 56 7] BAM] SYS WO} AAAS Szepsich, Ta 92 @ adele] Aes] Beal we ala UE 2] WIRE HENY Aloloh, 18) 4 5% H.SO, B44 BA}FS] 3 Ayal UE VAS] WSIS UHM dole, HERE 1 Ste ariadel te ages EAE Zole, Ads] SH gL oplgol ke Beles] yg 28 alo] Ard YAQES Yeh SE A Te OA we BS} Bol, SeolMIS HAE BF Seloloys) hake] Sree HS TETES welsh Glo, elol Saha] Save wpe alow Ge Ale, ots Beles Ba ae MAE Ae. Belt S79} Wal Shojo] Uy SARE. yo] Zs ble BAGG 48 W SEO Og oe 21 Va ol 7a Zl AREIEH, ole wal ulslolAle] AF Belo} opis} del lap} aw athe? 2 oslo ZavEU] F3S ables Sale Raby, ee AS} 22 IRS Hl Eo AR: BATS Wal oh | IIS WBE Ue} Ag dob} BE 9} ol, VE vided) aadage] Br} ‘el eh eget AaiaisL SASS a 4 Shek. ols Ha aed Sle Bares EelolAle] gaz} Bee) eget a2] ABO] SRS ole Wao] 7Hethslely] Woz Weel oP, Sebelhs aalet ae]=9] Ye able gale ge ASh 71G71B Bon Yoo}, VPS Ha BaAI=2] B $ SeoPIAS HN Ses (ALO) vleh AAPA a £ ASAeh NGI Bae B AOE YEE, oe 4] ISRO] OVO GARE BRC Selo |HIS GA AP SISA FROR BAAS Ro] wrt 4]21yy7] we Oe Amech EAL MNOS GARE B2]=9) wielo] Bal AeaeI=(BAO! Mal AEA} Galo Be Aes UenteM, oli Hala] dayhee MoS ale 2a 2S} Che: Sead Webshgloxt Ao] wild whe} Betofo A19} 2812490] HARE MOA Bae Sulels} Belolole] 2} Go] Ba USS Gori olzelal 22I0) ayeeyat wh 2. eel 24 5 ARE] $F LUPO iS Zael= Zale] ay WHS HEHE AOS, THOM ste vig} go} alxige] Srittol wet SE MLA Ae] AAs SS e+ SL EH, Olt 190, Safed ott Baal Bape] gah wy gel = Qa) GAM) weloZye AR wig] (091 $5} 5 HARBeH Ride] PHL Gaia HEH woIR ate 16 Weiehtratiops) Weight ratio) Chloride penetration depth) ) horde peter 7a Ome wed Flyash percentages (%) (@ Fy ash concrete 0 m7d OIE msed ‘hth battom ath percentares (©) Bottom ash concrete 2a 5 HSO, S91 ao HE Be Coatashpeicentages(%) ol G2 Sas Se zoo! wat an =-0317600271 aw s88e7 compressive strength M3) Ad 7 WRATH Gas Azole at3.3 UNS ARO] UE 2.5% NoOl +RAH0H 441 BALK] & Bates TALS] dee Vols Selec, Ha el 6k Ae] BF FRR) FE GAB A ole MSE HERA Zlelch. a Soles eat ae POR 8Ammee eh (PAO) Mle 42 GS MOLD gon}, Bet HUES ASE VEO Asia DES 4 Sch, oft Gasol Beast SASHA Hetolosy abet 2} BAPAUAS} Tetolaysjo] RAO} Stal alo} el 3} 51071 Wgo-2 Bee, Vigo Ol 214 2, BOE BETO 7-11. 2mm ELE MOPS a 3-7.8mm, 4h) BS SALSA] va YaaloR S As Mola. a AT, Ol UPOHAIS) olgALAgH eho} O18) offal 2] dae] easiest", chegel sgeWlo} Belais¥o] & FOV ABE AA vol alas 2} se2a) 7ielet lew Azetd al 72 AR] SH OE elevaSS} elsHe aes] BAS VERE Aloe, qaege7t S7Hiel oh alae ob ASL USL et + SC. G8) BerO|OHANS AE = AeE2] AP We Viriol 24 UTES AE BOL 4 ojo See ARMES UEMOSA BSE BOIS] 494 225. US S401 WEE + alg dow ae, oto} ANS aR ALAS TIS SH wet a SHE AoW} aisha gous ARLE et Bo] at 3.4 BYSz0] AER EM SAUL ATH SASS SMe 4 AH 8 9 oF Uehisie, 18) 8 ABS) Sah OblRed ake Ssh ole} SHS EMA Zee, Selo GARE # Bl}H) Page] BMS SSHeyE asa FHA, MS, Heyasgel eles Aeiolls 21 o| SAIL AP APES] BAS) BaeLSA| peepee: eb sasha Befolole 4h 2 BABLOWE Bethe Ak 29, mH oh Hoe YER oh ae A 8h 23 Uefiteh, HHOHA AR0| S7Hl wet S4eHIeV7 ee, oh wives] yg Abele aa 8] SHO] MS Yates} Syelzol2] WAS Ue Oe, Yate Wegloleh piste abede7t S7ebod Tet SYELOVE BABEL gor], Feojoy} E9] BF pares} SyA}olo| 4h ’ lat Qtek. ely MgO Gallet Hate=2} Gots eet F . i Be ? Coulash pereentages() ae 8 Meal ROL 881210194 Wa Fe yan | :. 2 i comprcrive strenatniaral Ae 9, HaAES} BYYOL! al THRE ARB BSL} BER B aS aoteiel cheat ach Sarel0| gowwlolst Rel Aa, Ae) S52 Uti} CH ROHR On|, ARISE: AWeH) Of AG T13%10"", Seo} BL ws) Howick: Zz} 6,28-6.97% 10 uebe aa seer dB] 7M 32 eh 20), SOAS AGRE 29. ST He aoh 7_RSVEAIBN EY GW 5212009.6) 4) GSE BERe|o} Ss sHVele] 4F, Selolols| GAS | S7HRE +S WEols} SYSeh= WABHgonl, SHSOMAIS AbGSE WAS] BP. Salelearel Eo} wpe ch & BRE Ae Uebieh 5) WHE ASB] BW Sesels} ease] YRS ‘Bebo lohs| Sae|ES] WH ee AHS BGLOL MH oH) B2elEe Aeohe Bebyel oF ee Bow y eR 6) 2 aras, JESS Zac S EY Ags] da 8% SAeEo| Beet URAL MIRE 2 SF US Roe webs, e2zeH# 1, WER OMB, AIAH, Bottom aah olgtt Athy AHA) sp rie, WaPIEstelA, 4250 ATS, pp, 699~E44, 2008 2 VSS, 2¥A, oles], GES, aaa ave, eeae, Bottom ash SAID ahs Btz1S9} Bao eet TA GE, A@aelSto] B AALEShS A, Aaa ALLS, pp.699~704, 2002 3, B, Berg, JA, Neal, Conerete masonry unit mix designs using ‘municipal solid waste bottom sash, ACI Materials Journal, Vol95 No.4, pp.470~479, 1998 4, KR. Hwang, T, Noguchi, F, Tomosawa, Bifocts of fine ‘aggregate replacement on the rheology, compressive strength and carbonation properties of fly ash and mortar, ACI Spee. Publ, SP-178, pp.401~410, 1998 5, KS F 4570, Boitom ash aguregate for the precast concrete product, 2007 6, KS F 4569, Bottom ash aggregate for road construction, 2007 M. Mbletudin, Al, Al-mana, MShamim HSericmen, Hiect of ‘snd replacement on the ealy-cge strength sin and long-term comsion-resting characteristics of ly ash concrete, ACT iter Jour, VoL85 No.1, pp.s8~4, 1968 8, Nader Ghafoori, Yuzheng Cai, Laboratory-Made Roller Compacted Goneretes, Containing Dry Bottom Ash, ACL ‘Material Journal, pp.224~251, 1998.5 8, N, Ghafoor, ¥.Cai, B, Ahmadi, Use of dry bottom ash 36 & fine aggregate in roller compected concrete, ACI Spec, Publ, SP-171, pp487~507, 1997 10, PK Mela and PJ, Mento, Oot, microstruc, rents, al sia, Sede MGeae-Hil, 106 11, RK, Dhir, MJ, MeCarthy and PAS, Title, Use of ‘conditioned PFA as a fine aggregate component. in ‘concrete, Materials and structures, Vol.93, Jan-Feb, pp.28~42, 2000 8 12, Rafat Siddique, Effect of fine aggregate replacement with Glass F fly ash on the abrasion resisianoe of concrete ‘Cement and concrete research, Vol, 33, pp.1877~1881, 2008 13, Rafat Siddique, Ritect of fine aggregate replacement. with, Class F fly ash on the mechanical propertis of concrete Cement and Conerete Research, Vol,33, pp.530~547, 2008, 14, VIM, Malhotra, M.-H, Zhang, PH, Read, J. Ryell, Long-term, mechanical properties and durility characterises of high-str/high-per, concrete incorporating, supplementary cementing materials under outdoor exposure onditions, ACL Materials Journal, Vol 97 No.S, pp.518~525, 000 15, HO RE 7 — RO ARTY SERIE, FOE EPRERIRRINME, pp.ABT~A54, 1909 16, GBR ED S794 7 9 > 2 ARIEL CHRRIL Pe YIN MBN SAVE OI~D), ARR APR Fk, pp77~80, 1997 11, SORE 2 794 Ty a CIM PhO AY FERAL REIL ARBOR «OAR 27 1) — ROR MR, Vol.20 No.2, pp. 709-744, 1908 18, AGRE Bb 7947 7 2 ORIEL REY LO E17) NCAR, Vol.21 No.2, pp.t09~114, 1999 (A+ 2009, 2. 23, 4144 2009, 3. 17, AASHH 2009, 3, 24)