Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Background: Cotard’s syndrome (CS) is a neuropsychiatric condition marked by nihilistic delusional(s). Due to its
rarity, misdiagnosis of the syndrome often occurs. The current case study is of a Malaysian woman who was
misdiagnosed for several years by professionals due to the presence of hypochondriac symptoms before receiving
the correct diagnosis.
Case presentation: In this case presentation, we describe the case of L, a 42-year-old Malaysian lady who was first
misdiagnosed with depression. The diagnosis of schizophrenia and CS was confirmed after thorough clinical
examination, diagnostic investigations, and deliberation at a departmental forum. The patient improved after
receiving electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) along with antipsychotic medications.
Conclusions: This case study highlights the importance of early recognition of CS by professionals as it can save
time for both parties when setting up a treatment plan. Essentially, early recognition of CS in schizophrenia is
paramount in the process of rapid stabilization through ECT and promotion of patient recovery.
Keywords: Cotard’s syndrome, Depression, ECT, Hypochondriac, Schizophrenia
© The Author(s). 2021 Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if
changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons
licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons
licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain
permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Subhas et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:107 Page 2 of 6
disorder, and provide information of a treatment plan was given the diagnosis of schizophrenia and CS (Table
that was successfully implemented. To the best of our 1).
knowledge, there has not been a similar case of CS pub- After L was admitted, it became apparent that L was
lished in Malaysia. unable to make decisions. Therefore, her family was
called in. They were provided psychoeducation concern-
ing the disorder(s), how it is usually treated, and what
Case presentation types of treatments were available. After the session, the
L was a 42-year-old administrative assistant who pre- psychiatrist and the family came to an agreement that L
sented regularly to general practitioners with various should stay in the hospital for a while (1-2 weeks) and
non-specific health ailments (sneezing and vague ab- commence treatment with an atypical antipsychotic—
dominal pains) after the passing of her father in 2014. risperidone (2 mg, twice a day).
Four years later, her overall mental health had deteri- L showed poor response to risperidone and her nihilis-
orated. She had become withdrawn, anxious, preoccu- tic delusions remained while being treated at the hos-
pied, and unable to sleep due to buzzing noises pital. L insisted the nurses assist her to the ward counter
outside her ear. She was also worried that someone each time she walked. Her physical examination was un-
was trying to harm her. As a result of lethargy (due remarkable and her mental status examination (MSE)
to poor sleep) and issues with concentration, L quit showed blunted affect, poverty of speech, apathy, perse-
her job. She was diagnosed with major depressive dis- cutory delusion, and hallucinatory behavior. Her anti-
order by a private psychiatrist and was prescribed psychotic treatment was switched to amisulpride 200 mg
agomelatine 25 mg daily, and zolpidem 10 mg daily. nocte given the superiority over risperidone in effect size
An otorhinolaryngologist found no otorhinolaryngological and lesser weight gain [10].
abnormalities upon examination. L showed marginal improvement with regards to per-
L’s mental health and insomnia worsened despite 3 sonal hygiene and meals after 2 weeks although L started
weeks of treatment and she incessantly complained that to experience parkinsonism at the dose of 600 mg BD,
she “felt like a zombie;” attributing it to the antidepres- which were counteracted with 2 mg of trihexyphenidyl.
sants [9]. Also, she had become convinced that her or- There were still residual symptoms of psychosis upon
gans were decaying. She refused to eat and purged to her discharge.
prove that the food she ate was not being digested. This Unfortunately, L was readmitted a week later after sev-
behavior made her extremely weak and lethargic. Fur- eral unsuccessful suicidal attempts as she still had the
thermore, she was refusing to urinate and defecate as belief that she could not swallow, urinate, and open her
she believed her bowels and bladder were dysfunctional. bowel due perceived damage to her internal organs. The
Due to significant physical health deterioration, L was extrapyramidal side effects of amisulpride were also still
admitted to the public hospital in Klang Valley in Sep- present and she was experiencing amenorrhea due to
tember of 2018. By then, she was having third person hyperprolactinemia (316.2 mU/l). A departmental multi-
auditory hallucinations who were commenting on her disciplinary discussion was conducted and the conclu-
action(s) and she was becoming paranoid that imaginary sion was to provide a course of electroconvulsive
strangers were trying to harm her. No other Schneider- therapy (ECT) for acute stabilization of suicidal ideation
ian first-rank symptoms were noted. There were no de- and nihilistic beliefs [11]. Amisulpride was switched to
lusions of misidentification either. Both L and her family quetiapine immediate release (IR) 100 mg due to its fa-
did not notice any features of depression, mania, or vorable profile for hyperprolactinemia and extrapyram-
hypomania. There was an absence of psychiatric illnesses idal symptoms [12, 13]. Consent for treatment was
on either side of the family. L repeatedly pinned her anx- obtained in accordance to the Malaysian Mental Health
iety down to her belief that her organs were dying and li- Act 2001 [14]. L was to be given an acute course of
quefying inside her. The initial differential diagnosis bitemporal ECT consisting of 6 sessions over 2 weeks on
included major depressive disorder with psychotic fea- alternative days, using the Mecta SpECTrum 5000 MTM
tures, psychotic disorder due to another medical condi- machine (manufactured by Mecta Corporation, United
tion and schizophrenia. Extensive work-up was States of America) with a brief pulse width of 1.0 m/s
performed to rule out possible organic causes. Organic (33 Hz) (Table 2).
causes were ruled out by collecting a history of fever, After completion of all six sessions of the acute course
seizures, connective tissue disorders, illicit drug use, or of ECT, L showed significant improvement. She was dis-
any neurological deficits suggestive of migraine, stroke, charged after 3 weeks and was directed to take quetia-
or meningitis. L’s investigations showed all parameters pine IR 400 mg twice daily at home. Three months later,
were within normal limits. Given her first episode of her menstruation returned and her prolactin level nor-
psychosis with features of Cotard’s syndrome (CS), L malized. No extrapyramidal symptoms stayed. One-year
Subhas et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:107 Page 3 of 6
post ECT, she was concordant with the treatment plan with schizophrenia and CS presented with nihilistic-
and she was in full recovery, including regaining her hypochondriac delusions and a progressive loss of energy.
ability to perform instrumental activity of daily living. This means that the prevalence of schizophrenia and
CS together is less than 1% in the population [15].
Discussion As shown by Huarcaya-Victoria and colleagues’ [5]
Current knowledge of CS is based on case reports and study, the increased risk of self-aggression is
series and there are 328 cases documented worldwide [15, reflected by L’s second admission due to her self-
16]. Due to the rarity of CS, its nosology remains unclear harm as part of her CS that is associated with
and is not classified in the International Classification of schizophrenia. L is most likely suffering from
Diseases (ICD) or the DSM-5 [17]. The prevalence of CS Cotard’s syndrome type I. This is a form of CS that
in schizophrenia is rare. In fact, a study by Stompe and is delusional in origin rather than being secondary to
Schanda [18] found that only 0.87% of patients diagnosed and affective disorder [19].
Subhas et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:107 Page 4 of 6
CS represents a series of well-defined symptoms which brain (Hashimoto encephalopathy and anti-N-methyl-D-
can prevail on its own or comorbid with other psychi- aspartate receptors encephalitis), neuroleptic malignant
atric or neurological disorders [17]. The hypochondriasis syndrome, or drug intoxications [5, 17]. Due to the fact
that developed into nihilistic delusions led to a diagnosis that L did not show signs of any of the disorders above,
of CS. As discussed by Tomasetti and colleagues [17], all other differential diagnoses were ruled out. A thor-
these symptoms evolve into somatic concerns leading to ough history was taken along with relevant blood inves-
localized bodily sensations (rotting of organs) or global tigations and neuroimaging was completed to rule out
somatosensorial alterations (“I am dead”). neurological disorders.
Various papers have highlighted that CS can be re- The diagnosis of schizophrenia was made in lieu of
ported in neurological disorders (stroke, brain tumors, elementary auditory hallucinations followed by third per-
epilepsy, traumatic brain injury, migraine, subdural son running commentary and persecutory delusions in-
hemorrhage), psychiatric disorders (major depressive dependent of affective symptoms. Morgado and
disorder with psychotic or melancholic features, schizo- colleagues [6] postulated that the relationship between
phrenic spectrum, bipolar type I and II disorder, catato- CS and schizophrenia could be due to poor flow of in-
nia), demyelinating disorders (multiple sclerosis), formation from the sensory cortex of the brain to the
dementias, movement disorders (Parkinson’s disease), limbic system. Schizophrenia appears to effect the non-
autoimmune inflammations and infections affecting the dominant frontal, temporal, and parietal lobes as found
Subhas et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:107 Page 5 of 6
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations.